HomeMy WebLinkAbout00 - Public Comments - Non-AgendaReplace the Memorial Bench to the Same Location
at Buena Vista & Edgewater
YqPAG CoMMOkS
The donated memorial bench that had been located in the public space at the corner of Buena Vista Blvd. and
Edgewater Ave. has been stolen after 13 years at that location. In early August, the city staff was ready to replace
the bench in its original location. However, the City manager, Dave Kiff, has placed a hold on this action. He is
possibly considering another location for the replacement bench such as Marina Park. We, the undersigned, enjoy
having the bench in our neighborhood and would like to keep the replacement bench at its same location.
_ 0/'13IJ�
Print Name
Address
email
Si2nature
G'► 6{ � / J
�J Z tv. . 8
s ► w�3� `� z
ti
n
,-- n-
s
cnS ►�
.3 2�
_
X� A
-
q,. -c
3 NAS
7L -We \k51ck'-�S1 i"
ca �
'1A
"Q, AV,�e,��
J .
-,-✓�
09/01/2016
Replace the Memorial Bench to the Same Location
at Buena Vista & Edgewater
The donated memorial bench that had been located in the public space at the corner of Buena Vista Blvd. and
Edgewater Ave. has been stolen after 13 years at that location. In early August, the city staff was ready to replace
the bench in its original location. However, the City manager, Dave Kiff, has placed a hold on this action. He is
possibly considering another location for the replacement bench such as Marina Park. We, the undersigned, enjoy
having the bench in our neighborhood and would like to keep the replacement bench at its same location.
09/01/2016 V 0
Signature
ra 0161KINMI
NO,
us
11 ElVA
JIM
..
Wi LIMA EN
09/01/2016 V 0
i
Replace the Memorial Bench to the Same Location
at Buena Vista & Edgewater
The donated memorial bench that had been located in the public space at the corner of Buena Vista Blvd. and
Edgewater Ave. has been stolen after 13 years at that location. In early August, the city staff was ready to replace
the bench in its original location. However, the City manager, Dave Kiff, has placed a hold on this action. He is
possibly considering another location for the replacement bench such as Marina Park. We, the undersigned, enjoy
having the bench in our neighborhood and would like to keep the replacement bench at its same location.
Print Name
Address
email
Signature
2-
_ t
11)
. I
09/01/2016 J,
It
w
x
Replace the Memorial Bench to the Same Location
at Buena Vista & Edgewater
The donated memorial bench that had been located in the public space at the corner of Buena Vista Blvd. and
Edgewater Ave. has been stolen after 13 years at that location. In early August, the city staff was ready to replace
the bench in its original location. However, the City manager, Dave Kiff, has placed a hold on this action. He is
possibly considering another location for the replacement bench such as Marina Park. We, the undersigned, enjoy
having the bench in our neighborhood and would like to keep the replacement bench at its same location.
Print Name
Address
email Si2nature
"')AWo C /
CYC Cz .
�
t4 lf
A,
Fr a -ek (a A d o V —
/ v
g `
Y' 7�
Y .T-51a��d At o
r ft r�- a -s-& a sGccto 64" f1i evr4o��-"L'z AOU
On
.cow
YZI
,ERRy L b&)
::36 N 0 �`
L a X k YOUV WO
09/01/2016 ( � /
Replace the Memorial Bench to the Same Location
at Buena Vista & Edgewater
The donated memorial bench that had been located in the public space at the corner of Buena Vista Blvd. and
Edgewater Ave. has been stolen after 13 years at that location. In early August, the city staff was ready to replace
the bench in its original location. However, the City manager, Dave Kiff, has placed a hold on this action. He is
possibly considering another location for the replacement bench such as Marina Park. We, the undersigned, enjoy
having the bench in our neighborhood and would like to keep the replacement bench at its same location.
Print Name
Address
email
Signature
15 "O 6) f✓r-:F�I�
fie' . / fiL . 1,f /V
ICON
09/01/2016
s
sel
Replace the Memorial Bench to the Same Location
at Buena Vista & Edgewater
The donated memorial bench that had been located in the public space at the corner of Buena Vista Blvd. and
Edgewater Ave. has been stolen after 13 years at that location. In early August, the city staff was ready to replace
the bench in its original location. However, the City manager, Dave Kiff, has placed a hold on this action. He is
possibly considering another location for the replacement bench such as Marina Park. We, the undersigned, enjoy
having the bench in our neighborhood and would like to keep the replacement bench at its same location.
Print Name
Address
email
Signature
I U , Gadd
�rlAn
Z5
A,:� G
r
�1
/�
3 r 1. `t� 1q i
09/01/2016
Replace the Memorial Bench to the Same Location
at Buena Vista & Edgewater
The donated memorial bench that had been located in the public space at the corner of Buena Vista Blvd. and
Edgewater Ave. has been stolen after 13 years at that location. In early August, the city staff was ready to replace
the bench in its original location. However, the City manager, Dave Kiff, has placed a hold on this action. He is
possibly considering another location for the replacement bench such as Marina Park. We, the undersigned, enjoy
having the bench in our neighborhood and would like to keep the replacement bench at its same location.
Print Name
Address
email
ature
alei
L4'), ' C'
0L.i, e Ck^e ✓'6 3�
.,
09/01/2016
•
J•
3
Replace the Memorial Bench to the Same Location
at Buena Vista & Edgewater
The donated memorial bench that had been located in the public space at the corner of Buena Vista Blvd. and
Edgewater Ave. has been stolen after 13 years at that location. In early August, the city staff was ready to replace
the bench in its original location. However, the City manager, Dave Kiff, has placed a hold on this action. He is
possibly considering another location for the replacement bench such as Marina Park. We, the undersigned, enjoy
having the bench in our neighborhood and would like to keep the replacement bench at its same location.
Print Name
Address
email
Signature
4yS m
YIlG!
CJI ✓ ! r
r
09/01/2016
f
I'm speaking on behalf of my wife and her family regarding the replacement of a
memorial bench. I know the mayor and city manager are well aware of this issue.
But I just want to bring you all up to speed with some background information and
recent developments. My wife's sister, Cora Van Loon, who was a resident of
Island Avenue lost her battle with cancer in 2001. In 2003, her family paid for a
memorial bench placed on a waterfront public space around the corner from her
house. This space, at Buena Vista and Edgewater was very special to Cora where
she enjoyed the view, meditated, and did her yoga. Last November, the nearest
resident to the bench brought a request to the Parks, Beach, and Recreation
Commission to move the bench to a different location. The request was
unanimously denied for a number of reasons. Six months later the bench was
stolen.
Park Maintenance Supervisor, Paul Ramirez, has been working diligently with my
wife to replace the bench although we were told we had to pay for a new memorial
plaque, which we did. The replacement bench was ready to be re -installed over a
month ago when my wife received a call from City Manager, Dave Kiff. He
wanted to discuss the possibility of installing the bench at another location such as
Marina Park. The resident whose request to move the bench had already been
denied, and a clearly defined appeal process was not followed, now seems to be
influencing Mr. Kiff to try again through informal means.
Now, although this should not have been necessary, over Labor Day weekend, my
wife and I decided to walk the surrounding neighborhood with a petition to see
how the neighbors felt. Although, knocking on doors was something I was
dreading, it actually turned out to be an extremely heartwarming experience. The
response was positively overwhelming. This is a close-knit neighborhood who are
passionate about keeping the bench right where it is. We met people who knew
Cora and welcomed us with open arms. Many people were wondering what had
happened to the bench and were shocked when told it was stolen. One young
woman who at first didn't answer her door, then ran out to catch us and sign the
petition because her boyfriend had proposed to her on that bench. There were
many other wonderful stories and when we were done we had received 62
signatures in favor of keeping the bench right where it has been for the past 13
years. This does not include our own family and friends who enjoy the bench and
a visit with Cora, but just the immediate neighbors, which I believe is most
significant. There was only one gentleman on Buena Vista who did not want to
sign because he didn't think that area should be a public space. Even the neighbors
to either side of the complaining resident were happy to sign. So we are all asking
you to do the right thing and return the bench to its rightful place without further
delay. Thank you.
i
g g 131
@3 OC Hu man R
Building community by fostering respect, resolving conflict and pursuing equality
Annual Report 2014-15
Weare OC Human Relations
2014-2015
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Leticia Mata, President
Assistant Vice -President,
Orange County's Credit Union
Jim McQueen, Vice President
Attorney, McQueen & Ashman LLP
Sean Thomas, Treasurer
President, TLIS
Frank Marmolejo, Secretary
Historian
Rusty Kennedy, CEO
OC Human Relations
Gurpreet Singh Ahuja, M.D.
Surgeon, Children's Hospital
Orange County
Julio Badin
General Manager, Park
Operations & Guest Relations,
Disneyland Park
Adam Birozy
Attorney At Law
Becky Esparza
Community Leader
Lin Fujitsubo
Development Consultant,
Community Enhancement
Services
Judy lannaccone
Director, Public Affairs &
Publications, Rancho Santiago
Community College District
Kenneth K. Inouye
Partner, Inouye, Shively
& Klatt, LLP
Christian Lopez
Student
Minzah Malik
Manager, Community Benefit,
Hoag Memorial Hospital
Presbyterian
Fran Rahimi
Principal, Restructure Group
Susan Reese
Business Owner, Susan Reese
Design
Rev. Karen Stoyanoff
Minister, Unitarian Universalist
Church
Carol Turpen
Senior Manager
Communications, Ingram Micro
Bill Wood
Retired, PacifiCare Health System
V
A Message from Our President
At OC Human Relations we are united by the
belief that ALL people should live free from
discrimination and violence. For more than four
decades people like you have worked with us
to create safe, respectful and inclusive schools,
workplaces and communities in Orange County.
We are grateful to you for your support.
The vision we share is clear: only by working
together can we create an Orange County that
promotes respect, empowers diverse communities,
resolves conflict respectfully and advocates equal justice. Can you picture it?
This year, while engaging our staff, nonprofit Board, and members of the OC
Human Relations Commission in our annual strategic planning, we reflected on
three traits that we feel best define the value we have to offer to you and our
community:
We're passionate about making Orange County a better place for ALL people
to live, work, go to school and do business. Our unique team aims to foster
respect and mutual understanding, address bias and prejudice, resolve conflict,
empower voices that are not heard and develop diverse leaders. That's a heavy
load! This often difficult charge results in priceless outcomes we see in schools,
neighborhoods, courtrooms and classrooms each day.
We've built incredible, long-standing, trusted partnerships in Orange County.
We're in the business of building bridges of respect between diverse people,
especially in times of conflict. Since being established in 1971, relationships have
been key in our success to bring people together to solve many of the hot topic
human relations issues each era has presented. We want to keep building these
relationships, especially with you.
We have the expertise to foster respect and understanding between institutions,
systems and people that are divided by bias or division. Whether working
with students, educators, parents, grassroots leaders, disputing residents,
volunteers, the police or public officials, we are skilled at addressing prejudice,
discrimination and conflict through time -tested collaborative and inclusive
processes. We're a resource to help guide, support, train and empower
leaders of all ages from schools, neighborhoods, businesses, government, law
enforcement, educational institutions and community groups.
Thank you for caring about Orange County. We sure do! Please continue to
utilize our expertise. Partner with us. Share our passion.
Sincerely,
Leticia Mata
Board President, 2014-2016
LA
HAB A
FULLERTON
BUENA
PARK
PALMAR
CYPRESS
STANTON
ALAMITOS
GARDEN
GROVE
SEAL
BEACH
TMINSTER -
HUNTINBEACH (�j •
FOUNTAIN
VALLEY
COSTA ' `\
BREA
MESA
Dispute Resolution
O
NEWPORT
MISSION
PLACENTIA
ti
WOODS
YORBA
LINDA
Walk In My Shoes Symposium
• Parent Leadership Institute
l
ORestorative Justice
LAGUNA
BRIDGES Safe and Respectful Schools Program
%MEN'
Civil Rights Exhibit
LAGUNN
JUAN
ANAHEIM
f
VILLA PARK
AN
AN
ORANGE
TMINSTER -
HUNTINBEACH (�j •
FOUNTAIN
VALLEY
COSTA ' `\
MESA
Dispute Resolution
O
NEWPORT
MISSION
Police f Community Relations BEACH
Community Building
WOODS
Youth Leadership Camp and Internship
Walk In My Shoes Symposium
• Parent Leadership Institute
Skills for Success
ORestorative Justice
LAGUNA
BRIDGES Safe and Respectful Schools Program
%MEN'
Civil Rights Exhibit
LAGUNN
ANA
r--TUSTIN
LAKE
FOREST
&Wh64A'q"
OC
Human
Relations
At OC Human
Relations we believe
that all people
should live free
from discrimination
and violence. We
have a mission
to foster mutual
understanding
among residents and
eliminate prejudice,
intolerance and
discrimination
in order to make
Orange County
a better place for ALL
people to live, work,
go to school and do
business.
During 2014-15,
we impacted the
lives of over
50,000 students,
families, educators
and residents
across Orange
County.
3
MISSION
VIEJO
LAGUNA
%MEN'
NIGUEL
LAGUNN
JUAN
BEAISTRANO
AN
AN
During 2014-15,
we impacted the
lives of over
50,000 students,
families, educators
and residents
across Orange
County.
3
BRIDGES Safe & Respectful Schools
A Year in the Life of BRIDGES Schools:
Loara High School
In 2014-15 the Loara BRIDGES Program
launched an anti -violence campaign to
build empathy, provide resources, and
offer alternatives to violence. Activities
included the Not in Our School anti -
bullying campaign which reached more
than 21000 students through movie
screenings, classroom presentations, an
"upstander" pledge wall, art contest,
lunch time activities and a homegrown
play by Loara Thespians seen by more
than 1,000 students. In addition,
students led the You are Not Alone
depression awareness campaign to
support Suicide Prevention by showing
PSA's produced by the Loara Thespians
in all classes, creating a "Send Silence
Packing" backpack exhibition that
students visited during lunch, and
distributing yellow ribbons and life-
line cards for all students. In addition,
students will participate in Peer
Mediation and Community Circles to
equip students in peer mediation skills to
resolve conflict, with the aim of violence
prevention. Students will be trained by
OC Human Relations to mediate peer-
to-peer conflict and community building
circles on campus.
Garden Grove High School
The BRIDGES Safe & Respectful Schools
team at Garden Grove High School
unified their campus during the 2014-15
school year around civil rights history,
school safety and issues of respect. This
group focused on civil rights history by
hosting OC Human Relations' Civil Rights
History Exhibit on campus. Students
also visited the Mexican American
History Museum, hosted a forum around
the Mendez v. Westminster case that
desegregated Orange County schools,
and participated in a local Cesar Chavez
Day march. Students also focused on
Safe and Respectful Classroom activities,
including student -led trainings for 120
teachers on Creating Safe Classrooms,
the recognition of 30 teachers who
create safe classrooms, a collaboration
with the Gay Straight Alliance to host
the National Day of Silence, plus "Love
Doesn't Have to Hurt" training for 150
students, three all -day human relations
retreats that integrated English Language
Learners, and a Unity Fest with live
music, cultural performances, a resource
fair, food, and college and career
information for over 300 students and
parents.
'1 learned how to communicate, to make new friends and
1 learned to respect others so others can respect me."
Josue, BRIDGES Skills for Success Student
Newport Harbor High School
Newport Harbor High School BRIDGES
students focused their school year on
teacher appreciation and engagement,
peer mediation and breaking down
cultural divides on campus. Activities
included teacher engagement and
appreciation. Students recruited teachers
and parents to advise BRIDGES efforts
and engaged adults through a kick-off
event, trainings and presentations on
school data. These allies integrated and
promoted BRIDGES activities in their
classrooms and campus organizations.
In addition, two teachers, one counselor
and one administrator were recognized
for creating safe classrooms and spaces
and combating bullying at an after-school
reception in their honor. To show the
power of positivity, students distributed
over 500 compliments across campus
during BRIDGES Compliment Day. Peer
Mediation was also a focus, as a cohort
of 30+ students were trained in peer
mediation and continued the school's
commitment to offering mediation as an
alternative to discipline. For more than 15
years, this effort has been supported by
the administration and has been useful
in peer-to-peer conflicts. Finally, students
looked at Bridging Cultural Divides.
During the spring, BRIDGES students
began to raise questions about why the
social interaction at lunch seemed to
be largely segregated by race/ethnicity.
They are currently planning a campaign
to encourage students to "break down
the walls" that divide them by inviting all
students to eat lunch together.
0
� OC Human,R�elatior
Our Partner 22,543
Students
Schools 504
Anaheim Community Parents
Day School
Fountain Valley
High School
Garden Grove
High School
Huntington Beach
High School
Loara High School
Magnolia High School
Newport Harbor
High School
Savanna High School
Servite High School
South Jr. High
Spring View
Middle School
Sycamore Jr. High
Valley High School
Westminster
High School
194
Administrators
1,277
Teachers
304
School Staff
155
Community Members
We Create Safe,
Inclusive and
Respectful Schools
This year, with your support, our
BRIDGES Safe & Respectful Schools
Program team:
• Engaged 24,977 Students,
Educators, Families and
Community Members in over
600 intergenerational school
Task Force meetings, retreats,
trainings, programs, circles,
presentations and school -wide
events at 14 local BRIDGES
schools.
• United 650 diverse Orange
County students and educators
from 26 Orange Countyjunior
and high schools, including
two private schools, at our
annual Walk In My Shoes Youth
Conference.
• Facilitated 109 Staff
development sessions, parent
presentations and classroom
presentations.
• Led 102 Restorative Justice
Community Circles with
students, educators and families
in school settings.
• Graduated 56 Spanish -Speaking
Parents from our 7 -week
Parent Leadership Institute at
three local schools: Loara High,
Savanna High and Bernice Ayer
Middle Schools.
• Supported 37 Academically
Challenged Students in our
Skills for Success Program at one
school.
• Trained 20 Youth Leaders from
ten cities at our annual BRIDGES
Summer Leadership Camp from
ten cities.
• Facilitated 20 Day -Long
BRIDGES retreats.
• Mentored 19 High School
BRIDGES Youth Leaders in our
BRIDGES year-long OC Youth
Organizers (OCYO) Internship
Program, from nine schools.
• Coordinated 8 School -Based
mediation trainings.
5
Community Building
Community Building Initiative in Anaheim
• Target Neighborhood: "ABC
neighborhood" (Alameda,
Brownwood, and Catalina streets)
in Anaheim, an under -resourced
neighborhood where we have
begun groundwork for a long-term
capacity building and leadership
development project.
• Funding Source: St. Joseph Health
Community Partnership Fund
• Partnerships: Established new
partnerships during our first
phase of development, including:
City of Anaheim -Community
Services Division, Anaheim Police
Department and the Anaheim
Union High School District.
We have all heard the saying "it takes
a village." We want our children to grow
up in a safe and healthy environment,
free of violence. But how do we really
accomplish that in a neighborhood
riddled with problems of violence, drugs,
gang activity, lack of safe outdoor spaces
for children to play, and high crime rates?
OC Human Relations is working
to build neighborhood leaders in a
community in Anaheim that is facing
When Hate Comes to Town
these challenges head-on. Together,
we are working to develop grassroots
leaders to collaboratively and strategically
plan and map out a detailed blueprint,
which will be implemented over three
years. During this timeframe, results will
be carefully measured and tracked in
order to guarantee positive changes are
occurring and improvement measures
are working. Even though this community
improvement project is in its early phases,
positive outcomes are already starting
to emerge and volunteer residents
are seeing that when a community is
empowered, their assets come alive and
the transformation begins.
Thanks to funding from the St. Joseph
Health Community Partnership Fund, we
have been engaging community residents
and partners to lay out the foundation of
this community building initiative.
Over the next three years, OC Human
Relations is excited to see how this
community grows. Some key areas our
project aims to target are low-level
crimes, youth engagement, safety,
green space, parental involvement, and
community appearance. Though it will
take time to collect data and see our
vision unfold, unexpected outcomes are
already starting to surprise us!
So far, our Community Building team has successfully:
• Hired and trained one new employee to join the OC Human Relations staff and
to lead the initiative
• Facilitated 30 Core Team Meetings with engaged residents
• Led 5 Community Forums for residents
• Collected feedback from 240 households via door-to-door community input
survey distribution
• Engaged the core team of neighborhood residents in over 600 hours of volun-
teer service
• Graduated one neighborhood leader from our Basic Mediation Certification
Training
What happens when an Orange County school is targeted by hate? How do we
respond when our students feel targeted and confused? The answer is: with great
love and great force.
Last April the City of Anaheim and Anaheim High School were notified that
a nationally recognized hate group planned to hold a protest on the public
property adjacent to the school, with the intent of spewing anti -gay slurs and
sentiments. OC Human Relations was called on as a resource to support the
school community with information, strategy development and people power.
Our BRIDGES team was on campus in the days leading up to the protest and
the day of the incident to provide safe spaces for students and staff to come
together.
On the day of the protest our staff, Board members and Commissioners
joined local education leaders, law enforcement, residents, alumni, students
and supportive organizations from across the county to take a stand against
hate. In its finality, the protest went unnoticed in comparison to our
counter message of support and acceptance for all people.
11 Y6 2,, s
Rusty n
� 9 Human RelaoEG
san as
Ana. CA 97 )OS'n9 a
Oear Rusty,
ashe Anahe.
[he OC Nun,an� n Hi
' Rerapo s`nPPloso-,ctaPa
enacura9eme t r boars
c eam�n9 me wes , rot yP. 'n of �„stees a
Yo��r r 9rearr rba pbA of ss! ndflS
3P�toan Y aPPren ro tla Churc m `� ` sincar! m ensu
to lrvP, `, sfer,mu, Pr,or to an n P otes tl suPPer 1 r thank You, as
a wPrka°`scr: `af-n+ _ aaunn tour Haa0
10
20"" PT'?'rhen9 You� oru bus�ss� � L°�� no n oan`C �nevCenf �ahe APr�I Zp eceve ?owre��p inn
tlents, n
an Refarrons. r9anr;yr�o^ f(,Y[ommuY PLr info dctfone C untY d jef >"nafe Q� e
S'nce ry sranns for antl eve our t?eAnahelm Hl e�a/ca r�udce,
rYthrnq you nn rrrc[ srn9e e vna o!"A[G e PA=
"' Y✓t4 We com n OC
Mrchaaf e n
sncarn a' nrats„aa �`�-..
tenses[
AAnneO,ma'e Raf Trustees
Ka na L a AnC�erkreJo, P,-esitlent
Brran G'ry I �Yr`Sm:th
Ar labb ear, nrembenssrstant clerk
r• Member
=lnahefn�pniun
It is a proud day in Orange County when we come together to express Hi ghs,,,ep,O,SUPER
t .Sot V. CmscV7"S pI.FI(:g
to our youth and community that hate will never prevail when good people
get involved and take a stand together.
' YI999.,J.io2
6 Sze,/! tleo of the event at facebook,cornfochumanrejations
ALLPEOPIL
ARF Fri F _---
Community Empowerment. One Woman's Story
A key community volunteer is a mother named Debbie, who despite
struggling financially and personally, has made it a top priority to be an
integral part of the neighborhood organizing project in Anaheim. In fact,
the project has empowered Debbie so much that she has been motivated
to go back to school to attain an administrative certificate and has
completed the required hours of training to perform mediation sessions
in order to help her community further. It is our hope that as this
community project unfolds, we will see other residents follow Debbie's
lead to rise up, engage deeply and take their community back!
ANNUAL AWARDS 44 GALA CELEBRATED JUSTICE,
DIVERSITY AND THE HUMAN SPIRIT
Our 2015 AWARDS Dinner and Fundraiser, sponsored by SoCalGas,
celebrated local unsung heroes in our diverse OC communities, schools
and businesses who engage in human relations issues in powerful and
moving ways.
AWARDS 44 continues on page 12
We Build
Community
This year, with your support, our
Community Building team:
• Worked with more than 1,500
people through advocacy
and support at community
meetings, public forums, city
council meetings and Board of
Supervisor meetings to address
homelessness issues in Orange
Co u nty.
• Delivered 28 presentations to
brief Elected Officials and Police
Chiefs on local hate crime trends
and concerns.
• Documented 40 Hate Crimes in
our annual Hate Crime Report.
• Responded to 12 Victims of
Hate Crime in Orange County.
• Delivered 5 Police Academy
Trainings to 192 police recruits
in Orange County.
• Gathered 1,000 People at 11
showings of our traveling OC
Civil Rights History exhibit in
Santa Ana, Irvine, Huntington
Beach, Garden Grove and
Orange.
• Hosted 3 Listening Sessions to
learn about the issues related
to discrimination faced by
the Jewish Community, the
Transgender community and the
Chinese American community.
• Facilitated 30 Core Team
Meetings and 5 Community
Forums for residents from a
targeted, under -resourced
Anaheim neighborhood to begin
groundwork for a long-term
capacity building and leadership
development project.
• Engaged 400 Parents and
Residents in 17 presentations
about hate crimes and
immigration.
• Attended 12 Diverse,
Collaborative Community
Events, including marches,
rallies and vigils for peace,
equality and justice.
i;
<
N
Dispute Resolution Program
Fostering Police/Community
Relationships
OC Human Relations has a long
history of partnering with law
enforcement and the community to
promote community -oriented policing
strategies. Our award-winning Police/
Community Reconciliation Program
offers residents assistance with
understanding and navigating the OC
Sheriff's complaint process. It also gives
community members and police an
opportunity to effectively and peacefully
resolve complaints with the help of a
neutral mediator.
Most recently, as relationships
between law enforcement agencies
and residents have been stretched to
their limits, we have been leading local
efforts to address tension and challenges
between the community and the police.
Over the past few months, we have
facilitated a series of community circles
to engage residents and officers in
dialogue to improve relationships and
learn from each other how we can work
more effectively at keeping our families,
friends and neighbors safe and free from
violence and discrimination.
This year, through our development
of multiple on-going Police/Community
Dialogues, we have been engaging
diverse community groups such as
the Transgender population, Latino
neighborhood leaders, African American
youth, and other groups with police
officers. In these dialogues, we bring law
enforcement and community members
together to build understanding and
trust, as well as dispel stereotypes
that add to tension and could possibly
escalate to confrontation or violence.
We believe in the power of relationships
to create change and will continue to
work to create effective ways to bring
these groups together in the interest
of the safety and well-being of our
communities.
2014-2015 Family Mediation
Program Grows
For the 5th year in a row, the OC
Human Relations Family Mediation
Program grew to better -provide high
quality mediation services to low income
and/or self -represented litigants in family
court cases.
Staff and volunteers mediated 36%
more cases than in the previous year,
opening 445 new cases and performed
an additional 69 mediation sessions
on existing cases. In over two-thirds of
these cases, parties were empowered
to create their own agreements rather
than relying on a judge to make critical
personal decisions for them. The efforts
of the OC Human Relations volunteers
are greatly appreciated by the judges
who refer cases to the program as noted
in the comments of one judge, "They are
miracle workers and the parties seem
to feel really good about accomplishing
something together. I am so glad we
have this "tool" at our disposal."
Another focus of the Family Mediation
Program has been to expand its
comprehensive training program and
reach out to professionals who engage
with divorcing families, such as private
mediators, attorneys, psychologists and
divorce financial analysts. When these
professionals incorporate mediation skills
into their practice or consider referring
parties to mediation, even more families
in need are impacted in a positive way.
"1 believe that mediation can be a powerful process for change
it has the potential to transform difficult situations into improved
outcomes for families. The Divorce Mediation Training is compre-
hensive and was a great opportunity to add to my skill set."
Training Participant, Licensed Clinical Social Worker
"Working with OC Human Relations' mediation program is a special honor.
1 get to work with a variety of clients on all sorts of challenging matters and
in most cases, facilitate a settlement that solves some immediate problems
and often resolves some longer-term issues. It's a pleasure to work with my
fellow mediatorspeople who bring expertise and wisdom from their
careers and who foster a collaborative atmosphere."
—Ross Conner, Volunteer Mediator
8 See volunteer profiles at ochumanrelations.org/volunteer
Volunteer Mediator Profile:
Sean Thomas, OC Human Relations Board Treasurer
Sean Thomas not only serves as treasurer for OC Human Relations'
Board of Directors, but he also devotes much of his time to volunteering,
mediating, fundraising and participating in events for the organization.
As a boy living in both Puerto Rico and Central New York with his Puerto
Rican mother and Irish and Polish father, he learned from a very young
age that even though we may have different words and ethnicities "we
can live together in peace."
When Sean and his partner of 43 years,
Dan, moved to their home in Brea, they were
warned: "[their] kind were not welcome in
the neighborhood." Residents even started
a petition in an attempt to force Sean and
Dan out of the neighborhood. However, the
couple stood their ground.
Sean has spent his whole life standing
up for the oppressed. He has been a voice, a
I
eader, a helper and a tireless fighter for human I IgIlLb.
OC Superior Court Partnership
OC Human Relations mediates conflict in the community, as well as in
courts. Our team coordinates services and support at three local courts:
Central Justice Center and North Justice Center (civil and small claims courts)
and Lamoreaux Justice Center (family court). In an expression of our valued
partnership, the OC Superior Court, judges and administrators honored our
entire Dispute Resolution Program staff and volunteer mediators at their
spring DRPA Civil Mediation Volunteer Appreciation Reception.
Orange County Mediation Conference
As co-sponsor of the annual OC Mediation Conference, we brought
together 150 mediators at the UCI University Club. The program featured OC
Board resolutions celebrating Mediation Week, shared by the Orange County
Community Investment Division, presentations by an UCI Ombudsman, and
OC Superior Court updates by commissioners and judges.
We Bring People
Together To
Mediate Conflict
This year, with your support, our
Dispute Resolution Program team:
• Handled 30 Police Complaints
brought to the Commission for
help and reconciliation.
• Investigated 8 Conflicts referred
by law enforcement for
resolution.
• Delivered 61 Presentations
to the public and police
about the Police/ Community
Reconciliation program.
• Helped 4,551 People in conflict
with mediation services.
• Conducted 2,106 Mediations,
and resolved 66% successfully.
• Provided 499 Family
Mediations.
• Certified 146 People who
attended eight Basic Mediation
Certification Trainings and
two Basic Divorce Mediation
Trainings (more than doubling
last year's attendance).
• Elevated 1,126 Mediators and
their skill level via 29 Advanced
Mediation Workshops.
• Brought together 150 Local
Mediators at our annual
OC Mediation Conference.
• Educated -16,071 Residents at
502 Dispute Resolution Program
Presentations and 119 people in
17 Educational Workshops.
• Utilized 78 Volunteer Mediators
in our Dispute Resolution
Program, representing Chapman
University, CSU Dominguez Hills,
CSU Fullerton Pepperdine Law
School, Trinity Law School, UCI,
University of San Diego, Wellesley
College, and Westwood College.
• Engaged Volunteers in 10,200
Hours of Service via courtroom
and office walk-in mediation
support.
"This was the most meaningful
and relevant internship 1 have
ever had. l learned a lot from
the staff, fellow interns, and
volunteer mediators."
—Dispute Resolution Program Intern
9
OC Human Relations Commission
Today, the County of Orange utilizes
our nonprofit, OC Human Relations, as
contracted staff support to the Commis-
sion. Naturally, our nonprofit programs
directly relate to the Commission's public
charge, as the Commission is the root of
our nonprofit's existence.
Advocating for a Multi -
Service Homeless Shelter and
Permanent Supportive Housing
The Commission led the City of
Fullerton's Task Force on the Mentally III
and Homeless, created in the aftermath
of the death of Kelly Thomas in 2011.
From that focused study on how we
can do a better job protecting the
vulnerable members of our community,
emerged two top recommendations
consistent with the OC Ten Year Plan
to End Homelessness. First: create
multi -service homeless shelters around
the county to consolidate the system
of care for the homeless; and second:
promote Permanent Supportive Housing
developments to serve mentally ill
people experiencing homelessness.
This year the Commission
collaborated with faith communities,
non-profit providers, housing advocates,
public agencies, business leaders, and
local leaders to support several multi-
service homeless shelters, bringing this
critical need very close to becoming
a reality with the first such shelter in
Anaheim. Additionally, the Commission
successfully advocated the development
of A Community of Friends Permanent
Supportive housing project in Fullerton
which will integrate housing units to
support people with mental illness.
Facilitating Police/Community
Dialogues
A critical need to facilitate dialogue
between police and diverse youth and
adults was identified by the Commission
as a priority response to growing tension,
hostility and fear across the nation and in
Orange County. The Commission worked
to help ease animosity and suggest a
path forward when residents concerned
about police abuse of Latino and other
diverse communities responded with
anger. Police/Community dialogues
with Latinos in English and Spanish, and
the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender
(LGBT) community were the initial
elements of this strategy.
Leading Listening Sessions with
Diverse Communities
To gain insight into Orange County's
diverse communities, the Commission
conducted Listening Sessions, going
out to venues where people gather and
engaging them in conversation. This year
the Commission learned two challenges
facing the Transgender community:
issues related to feeling respected on the
streets and feeling safe when interacting
with law enforcement. Another Listening
Session at Congregation Shir Ha Ma'alot
gave insight into concerns about the
international Jewish community as well
as concerns here in Orange County.
The session at the South Coast Chinese
Cultural Center was a lesson in the
different historical experiences and
current issues of the Taiwanese, Hong
Kong, and Mainland Chinese Americans.
Handling Police Complaints and
Reconciliation
Seven years ago the Board of
Supervisors asked the Commission
to take responsibility for handling
police complaints by adding a Police/
Community Reconciliation process to the
tools available to residents. In 2014-
15 our staff fulfilled the Commission's
charge by handling 38 police/community
cases with face-to-face reconciliation
sessions, assistance in navigation of
complaints, and mediation.
Documenting Hate Crime: 2014
Since 1991, the Commission has supported hate crime victims, educated the public
and police on hate crime issues, and published an annual report on reported hate
crime and the targets of that bigotry. A ten-year downward trend continued in
2014 when 40 hate crimes were reported, about half of those reported ten years
ago. Race/ethnicity continues to be the most frequent motivation, followed by
perceived sexual orientation and then religion.
Overall Hate Crime Numbers Fell While the New Trend
of Violence Against People Remained in 2014
15
10
■ 8
6
5;..
■ 3
0
49 40
2013 2014
Hate Crime
Targets:
African
American
LGBT
Jewish
Arab/Middle
Eastern
(including Muslim)
i Latino
Asian/Pacific
Islander
Christian
1! Buddhist
10 View annual hate crjn-ie reports a1 o.chumanrej.at ons,org/ala°fecrirne
• One-third of reported hate crimes in
2014 were violent crimes, up from
historical local trends.
• Continuing a 20+ year trend, African
Americans remain the most frequently
targeted group in Orange County.
While making up close to 2% of
the county's population, African
Americans were targeted in 28% of
reported hate crimes.
• The number of reported hate
crimes targeting the gay and lesbian
community and those perceived to be
gay or lesbian rose slightly from 7 in
2013 to 8
in 2014.
• There were 6 hate crimes targeting the
Jewish community, up one from 5 in
2013.
The Human Face of Hate
• In August a lesbian couple
was shopping at a local
store. A man approached
them and asked if they
were lesbians. When
they confirmed, he
assaulted both of
them, leaving the
women in need of
emergency room
treatment. When
the police 20,14Hate Crim
and interviewed • _ ,
witnesses, they.
originally classified
the crime as a
robbery. After the OC Human
Relations Commission and The Center OC
contacted law enforcement, police authorities determined
that the crime would be charged as a hate crime and presented to
the District Attorney for prosecution.
While a senior Vietnamese American woman traveled on her daily
trip to a convalescent hospital where her husband lived on life
support, she was targeted by a man upon getting off her bus. The
man shouted racial slurs at her, kicked her in the chest and knocked
her to the ground. When people from the bus came to her aid,
the perpetrator fled and was not caught. OC Human Relations was
contacted for support. A Commissioner and our CEO visited the
woman to provide emotional support and resources.
O�LjFOg���
We Stand Behind
the Orange County
Human Relations
Commission
For decades, a critical
element of our nonprofit
work has been to
support the efforts
of Orange County's
Human Relations
Commission. In 1971,
when the OC Human
Relations Commission
was created by the
Board of Supervisors,
in collaboration with
the League of Cities,
we were assigned the
responsibility to build
mutual understanding
among Orange County
residents and eliminate
prejudice, intolerance
and discrimination.
OC HUMAN RELATIONS
COMMISSION
Kenneth Inouye, Chair
Becky Esparza, Vice -Chair
Nadia Saad Bettendorf
Bekele Demiss[e
Timothy Kowa[
Chief Dave Maggard
Bang Van Pham
Rev. David Rader
Rabbi Richard Steinberg
CarolTurpen
C. William Wood
Doug Wooley
11
{
�Human
Relations ,-
1 i• L `•Yj j .9
Celebrating Justice, Diversity and the Human Spirit
OC Human Relations annual Awards celebration brings together over 500 local, diverse
community and business leaders to celebrate unsung heroes who have made exemplary
contributions to human relations in schools, cities, businesses and police departments in Orange
County. Supporters of this event send an important message to the community that they are
committed to creating and Orange County where ALL people are valued and respected.
Sponsored by
SoCalGas
A Sempra Energy utiiity
12 earn more at ochumanrelationsawards,org
2015 Awards
Honorees:
Community Policing
Officer Jenny Lindsey,
Irvine Police
Department
Diverse
Community Leaders
Farrah N. Khan
The Bravo Family
Nicholas
Academic Centers
Distinguished School
Savanna High School
Distinguished
Businesses,
Embracing Diversity
and Inclusion
Program Support
Complete Audit
The private, nonprofit 501(c)(3) OC Human Relations Council's independent
audit was conducted by the firm Paul Shishima & Company, CPAs. The
auditors issued an unqualified opinion for the year ending June 30, 2015
concluding that OC Human Relations'
finances were in compliance with
standard accounting principles.
OC Human Relations' Fiscal Year
2014-15 total cash expenses
were $1,545,321 and income was
$1,482,400. In-kind contributions
were valued at $84,893. The audit repor
Assets of $1,822,881 with Liabilities of
$465,669, Equity of $1,357,212, for year
Total Liabilities and Equity of $1,822,881
Staffing
Full time permanent staff increased to 10 U 11b
year, augmented by 10,200 hours from volunteers who serve as mediators,
Board members, Commissioners, Community Partners, and interns, as well as
individuals who donated their professional services.
oC
Human
Relations
Where the Money
Comes From
• Generous donations from
individuals, businesses and
foundations totaling about
$661,368 were facilitated by
the investment of time, energy
and resources by our Staff,
Community Partners, and
nonprofit Board of Directors.
• California Court filing fees
funded a $300,000 Dispute
Resolution Program grant.
• The County of Orange provided
$252,000 for our nonprofit staff
to support the public OC Human
Relations Commission.
• Fees for services brought in
$166,230 of income.
• 20 cities paid $93,089 in dues.
• Interest accounted for $9,635 of
income.
• These funds supported
the nonprofit charitable
programming expenses of
$1,482,400 in FY 2014-15.
Our Staff
Jim Armendaris
Sara N. Babadi-Sharif
Seema Bhakta
Alfonso Clarke
Nabil Dajani
Alison Edwards
Peko Gomis
Don Han
Barbara Hunt
Jennifer Jones
Rusty Kennedy
Norma Lopez
Adriana Cortes Luna
Edgar Medina
Melisa Montano -Ochoa
Melissa Morgan
Joyce Sanchez
Kathy Shimizu
Kristian Vallee
Sheri Wingate
13
ThankYou for Caring About Orange Cc
It's Good for the Community,
It's Good for Business.
Our community partners are successful business and
community leaders who support and promote respect
and understanding in Orange County's increasingly
diverse communities.The philosophy we share:
greater community harmony creates an environment
conducive to building an equipped and viable
workforce for our future, making Orange County a
better place to live, work and do business.
Thank You for Caring About Orange County
We are grateful to these incredible supporters whose
investments are making a difference in our community.
Community Partners Advisory Board
Jack Toan, President
Vice -President, Wells Fargo
Neena Master, Vice -President
Director of Community Relations,
SoCalGas, A Sempra Energy Utility
Ralph Bauer
Retired Mayor,
Huntington Beach
Rhonda Bolton
Corporate Diversity,
Kia Motors America
Kay Carpenter
Retired, ConAgra
Carol Chaney
School and Community Relations,
SchoolsFirst Federal Credit Union
Donnie Crevier
CEO, Crevier Classic Cars
Lynn Daucher
Former Director, California
Department of Aging
Gary Dunn
Executive Vice President,
Banc of California
Rossina Gallegos
Director, Union Bank
George Gibbs
Manager, Community Affairs,
UPS
Dr. Jerry Hunter
Retired Chancellor,
North Orange County
Community College District
Kenneth K. Inouye
Partner,
Inouye, Shively & Klatt, LLP
Jim Lehmann
Consultant, Partners Advantage
Dr. Greg McQuater
Retired Executive,
Taco Bell Corp.
James McQueen
Partner,
McQueen & Ashman LLP
Susan Reese
Business Owner,
Susan Reese Design
Keith Swayne
Founder, Keith and Judy Swayne
Family Foundation
Bill Witte
President, Related California
14 Learn more at ochumanrelations.org/communitypartners.
Champions
$25,000 and
above
Crevier Family Fund
Hoag Memorial
Hospital
Presbyterian
Kia Motors America
Orange County
Community
Foundation
SoCalGas, A Sempra
Energy Utility
St. Joseph Health
Community
Partnership Fund
Weingart Foundation
Wells Fargo
Foundation
Sponsors
$10,000-$24,999
Annenberg
Foundation
Banc of California
Disneyland Resort
Keith Swayne
Keith and Judy
Swayne Family
Foundation
Related California
Sisters of St. Joseph
Healthcare
Foundation
Steinmetz Family
Foundation
Supporters
$51000-$9,999
Anita Varela & Rusty
Kennedy
Chevron Products
Company
Clearinghouse CDFI
Edison International
Employees
Community Fund of
Boeing
Francisco Marmolejo
Gurpreet Singh Ahuja,
MD
Susan & John Reese
Tarsadia Foundation
Union Bank
University of
California, Irvine
UPS
William Gillespie
Foundation
Advocates
$2,500-$4,999
Ana C. Orellana
California State
University,
Fullerton
The California
Endowment
California Sikh Council
City of Anaheim
Gregory McQuater
Henry T. Nicholas III
Ingram Micro
James & Simone Kozel
Kay M. Carpenter
Ken Inouye
Leticia Mata
McQueen & Ashman
LLP
North Orange County
Community College
District
Orange County
Department of
Education
Orange County's
Credit Union
The PIMCO
Foundation
Ralph & Charlene
Bauer
The Resnick Family
Foundation
Satinder Vir Singh
SchoolsFirst Federal
Credit Union
U.S. Bank
Community
Partners
$1,000-$2,499
Adam Birozy
Amy & Craig Nickoloff
Bang Van Pham
Bichlien Nguyen
Bill Wood
Church of Jesus Christ
of LDS Foundation
Clem C. Glass
Foundation
Congregation Shir
Ha -Ma'alot
Frederick C. Balzer
Jeff Lyall
Jeffrey & Margaret
Sotzing
Jerome Hunter
Judith A. lannaccone
Julio Badin
Karen Stoyanoff
Lilia & Adrian
Tanakeyowma
Lin Fujitsubo
Lynn M. Daucher
Margaret & Bartley
Harloe
Margaret M. Gates
Nicholas Academic
Centers
Pacific Western Bank
Parking Concepts
Peter G. Welsh
Rebecca Esparza
Rosa Diaz
Sean Thomas &
Thomas Long
St. Jude Medical
Center
Vivian Perez
Friends
$250-$999
Alan Sorkin
Alison & Chris Edwards
Brian Mann
Dolly S. Kaplan
Douglas Bystry
Evelyn Miller
Fran Rahimi
Gregory Chatterton
Imran Qureshi
Jim Lehmann
Julianne Holt
Kellogg Supply Inc.
Kristine Long
Lisa Bartlett
Mai V. An
Maria K. Khani
Marie Otto
Nabil Dajani
Neena Master
Nguoi Viet News, Inc.
Nydia F. Hernandez
Ora Ben -Barak
Patricia Mai & Son Thu
Bui
Pepperdine University
Riley & Rebecca
Newman
Rita A. Lehmann
Sharon Preston
Southern California
Mediation
Association
T & T Gas & Auto
Service
Thomas D. Long
To Quang Pham, MD
Tustin Police
Department
Victoria Stephenson
Vinh N. Hoang
Vivian Clecak
Walt Disney Company
Foundation
Please contact us if there is an oversight in listing your contribution. Every effort
was made to ensure the accuracy of our donor list for the period covering this annual
report: July 1, 2014 -lune 20, 2015. For a full list of Donors, including $120 level
Annual Members, visit ochumanrelations.org/partners.
INVEST IN GOOD. Contact Melissa Morgan, Director of
Partnerships at 714-480-6582 or melissa@ochumanrelations.org
to learn how your partnership can change lives.
oc
AC40.6kHuman
Relations
We need partners
like you.
Join us in building
respect and cooperation
within our schools,
neighborhoods,
institutions and
workplaces. We're looking
for Orange County
leaders who share our
vision of the future.
Together, we can make
Orange County a better
place to live, work, go to
school and do business.
OC BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
Todd Spitzer, Chair, Third District
Lisa Bartlett, Vice -Chair, Fifth District
Andrew Do, First District
Michelle Steel, Second District
Shawn Nelson, Fourth District
Frank Kim, County Executive Officer
Steve Franks, OC Community
Resources Director
CITY PARTNERS
Aliso Viejo
Anaheim
Brea
Buena Park
Cypress
Dana Point
Fullerton
Garden Grove
Huntington Beach
Irvine
Laguna Beach
Laguna Niguel
La Habra
Lake Forest
La Palma
Los Alamitos
Mission Viejo
Newport Beach
San Clemente
Santa Ana
Tustin
ljwl�i.o,chu ai-irelatjuns.org/ akeadi 'erence. 15
Make a Difference in Orange County.
STAND WITH US. Since 1971 we have worked hard to address issues of prejudice and discrimination
in Orange County. We provide quality programs and services in schools, communities and courtrooms
to build safe and strong schools, empower active and engaged residents, find innovative ways
to resolve conflict and take a stand against hate and discrimination.
Utilize our expertise. Partner with us. Share our passion.
OC Human Relations
,tci> .46 Building community by fostering respect, resolving conflict and pursuing equality
1300 S. Grand Avenue, Bldg. B, Santa Ana, CA 92705 — (714) 480-6570
OC Human Relations is a 501(c)(3) charitable organization that can thrive with the help of supporters like you! Tax ID #33-0438086
Join our a -list by textirlg EQUALITYMATTERS to 22828 or vjz3 r
ochumanrelations,orc 0001�"