HomeMy WebLinkAbout10 - AB 1196 (Harper) and Contract with Don Schmitz and Associates - Attachment APort Master Plan, Public Works Plan, Master CDP Comparison (revised 4-24-2018)
Projects w/Level 2
Projects w/Level 1
CDP (always req
What's Always Appealable
Type of Plan
Coastal Act Section
Purpose
Requirements of
Projects exempt
CDP (non-
public hearing; can
(PRC §30600 et seq)
Plan
from CDP
appealable, no
be appealable or
public hearing)
non -appealable)
To allow ports to plan
Port Master
Chapter 8 (Ports) of
and permit projects
Land and Water
Maint dredging of
Minor grading,
Major structures for
Storage, transmission of
Plan (PMP)
the CA Coastal Act
within their boundaries
uses; Port
existing channels
paving, lighting,
recreational
LNG and crude oil.
(we used the
(§30700 et seq)
without separate CDPs
Facilities;
fencing
purposes
Port of LA's
issued by the Coastal
PMP for these
Commission
examples).
PMPs are specifically
Environmental
Repair/Maint that
Installation of
Marine terminals,
Wastewater treatment
called out in the Coastal
inventory, impact
does not add or
modular
creation of upland or
facilities
Act.
analysis,
expand
structures,
coastal water fills,
mitigation
storage, floating
measures.
docks, guard
houses
Listing of
Utility connections
Demolition of
Major dredging of
Roads or highways not
appealable
wharves, buildings,
water areas
intended for internal
projects
tanks.
circulation.
Provisions for
Things destroyed
Removal of
Crane additions or
Office and residential
public hearings
by disaster.
pipelines.
replacements
buildings.
and public
participation
Major building
Oil refineries and
renovations
petrochemical production
plants.
"Under the PWP, Ventura
Public Works
§30605 of the Coastal
An entitlement for
Goal (of the
Likely to be only
See Appealable
See Appealable notes
County issues all permits ...
Plan (PWP)
Act "plans for public
Public Works projects
Channel Islands
maintenance and
notes
for ... development
(we used the
works ... may be
that is an alternative to
PWP): "to ...
repair.
authorized under the PWP.
County of
submitted ... in the
project -by -project
provide policies
County notifies the
Ventura's
same manner (as LCPs)
review by the Coastal
which provide,
Commission ... of the
Channel Islands
Commission.
protect, and
development and ...
Harbor PWP for
maintain access to
show(s) that it is consistent
this example)
PWPs are a more
and use of the
with the PWP. Review ...
vaguely identified in the
recreational
by Commission ... limited
Coastal Act than PMPs
waters ... protect
to imposing reasonable
and maintain
terms and conditions to
commercial fishing
ensure that (it) ... conforms
facilities"
with the PWP and ...
Coastal Act."
Public Works
PRC §30605 and 30606
Applicant issues a Notice of
Plan (PWP)
of the Coastal Act and
In this case, addresses
Addresses public
Likely to be only
See Appealable
See Appealable notes
Impending Development
(we used State
§13357(a)(5), 13359,
parking, restrooms, and
access, visual
maintenance and
notes
associated with the PWP.
Parks' Malibu
and 13353-54 of the
public access trails and
resources,
repair.
Commission ED determines
State Beaches
CA Code of
stairways at three CA
biological
if the proposed
PWP for this
Regulations govern the
State Parks beaches.
resources and
development is consistent
example)
Coastal Commission's
water quality,
with the certified PWP — if
review of subsequent
geologic stability,
not, it comes to the
development where
and CEQA.
Commission for review.
there is a certified
PWP.
Master CDP
CA Coastal Act does
To allow the Coastal
Full review and
None. Is a Master
N/A
N/A
Once the Master CDP is
(example
not define Master
Commission and public
hearings before
CDP, covers all
approved by the
includes the
CDP. But this term has
agencies to agree on
the Coastal
aspect of a large
Commission, no need for
Newport Coast
been used for other
blanket CDPs for a
Commission.
and
appeal process. All
"Master" CDP)
large-scale
specific area, like the
comprehensive
projects must be
coastal projects
Newport Coast.
effort/project.
constructed in accordance
covering land and
Addresses items
with the Master CDP. If
water, including the
including public and
projects or uses change,
Newport Coast. First
private infrastructure
the Master CDP would
CDP in NC
(like private docks), site
have to be amended by
was referred to as
plans, and more.
Coastal Commission.
"Master Coastal
Development."