Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout02/24/1953 - Regular Meeting199 February 24th, 1953 The City Council of the City of Newport Beach met in • regular session in the council chambers in the City Hall at 7:30 p.m. The roll was called, the following members being present: Finch, Roll Call ' Isbell, Bennett, and Miller. Councilman Smith was absent. On motion of Councilman Finch, seconded by Councilman Regular Order of Isbell and carried, the regular order of business was waived. Business Uaived Trophies awarded for excellence in Christmas decoration Trophies awarded for were presented to the City of Newport Beach and to the City Employees Christmas decorations. Association by Herb Kenny, representing the Associated Chambers of Commerce of Orange County. A third trophy was presented to residents of the Cliff Haven area by Mr. Kenny. Councilman Smith arrived and took his seat at 7:35 p.m. C. Smith arrives Mayor Miller announced that this was the time and place Opening of bids for set for the opening of bids for the extension of the Balboa Parking Balboa Parking Lot Lot, and the following bids were opened and read: Sully- Miller Contracting Company . . 0138599.00 M. E. Horst Company . o 13,848.20 John J. Swigart Company . 13P599-00 R. J. Noble Company . . . . ... . . . 130237.10 On motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Referred to C. Engr. Bennett and carried, the bids were referred to the City Engineer for checking. for checking. Mayor Miller announced that this was the time and place Opening of bids for set for the opening of bids for the dredging of the Grand Canal. Dredging Grand Canal The following bid was opened and read: Trautwein Bros. . . . . . . . . . . . $ 58535.00 On motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Referred. to C. Eng. Bennett and carried, the bid was referred to the City Engineer for for checking. checking. The regular order of business was resumed on motion of Regular Order of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett, and carried. Business Resumed The reading of the minutes of the previous meeting was Minutes approved as waived, and they were declared approved as written on motion of written Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried. Certain demands, having been approved by the Finance Demands approved. Committee, were presented for payment. On motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett, the demands were ordered paid by the following roll call vote, to -wit: AYES, COUNCILMEN. Smith, Finch, Isbell, Bennett, Miller. NOES, COUNCILMEN: none ABSENT COUNCILMEN: none C014MUNICATICNS: The Traffic Committee recommended the designation of Traffic Committee rec- ' certain streets on Lido Isle as one -way streets, and that parking ommends 1 -way streets be prohibited in certain areas. On motion of Councilman Finch, on Lido Isle. seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried, the recommendation was approved and the report referred to the City Attorney for draft of an amendment to the Municipal Code establishing the one -way streets requested. • The Chamber of Commerce reported that arrangements have Chamber of Commerce been completed for the third annual western Sprint Championship asked permission to Rowing Regatta to be held May 23rd, 1953, and asked that permission wnstruct shelter for be given for the erection of a canvas cover for the shells at the rowing shells. Balboa Bay Club, and the cooperation of City Departments in pre- paring for the event. On motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Finch and carried, tie request was granted. E. L. Brumley, 901 North Bay Front, Balboa Island, E. L. Brumley requests asked that the curb be repaired at that address and that a tree curb be repaired. be removed because of flood water hazards. On motion of Council- man Finch, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried, the request was referred to the City Manager. The Chamber of Commerce requested an appropriation of Chamber of Commerce re- $1500 to cover expenses in connection with the coming Boy Scout quest $1500 for Boy National Jamboree for which the council has been designated Scout Jamboree. Director of Physical Arrangements. On motion of Councilman Finch, seconded by Councilman Bennett, the appropriation was approved by the following roll call vote, to -wit: AYES, COUNCILMEN: Finch, Isbell, Bennett, do Miller. NOES, COUNCILMEN: Smith ABSENT COUNCILMEN: None ME Chamber of Commerce The Chamber of Commerce reported that it had been requests housing ar- designated Coordinating Agent for the arrangement of housing for ran gements for Jam- adults attending the Jamboree and asked that the Council cooperate boree. in making rooms in private homes available. On motion of Council- man Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried, the request was referred to the City Attorney. • Request for 'Heliport' A request that a black top area approximately 100 or ' at 15th St. beach. 150 square feet on the beach, seaward of 15th Street at Newport, be established for a heliport for the Los Angeles Airways, Inc., was made by the Chamber of Commerce. After some discussion of alternate sides, it was moved by Councilman Finch, seconded by ouncilman Isbell and carried, that the request be taken under con- sideration and the city help in locating a new landing field. Women's Civic League The Women's Civic League of Newport Harbor asked that requests appropria- an appropriation be made for garden supplies to be used In the beau - tion for garden sup- tification of the Boy Scout Jamboree Headquarters and that arrange - plies for Jamboree. ments.be made to care for the landscaping for the next five months*' On motion of Councilman Finch, seconded by Councilman Smith and �arried, the request was referred to the Park, Beach, and Recreation ommission. P.B. &R. recommends The Park, Beach, & Recreation Commission recommended city purchase soil the city purchase soil for the planting at the Lido Isle entrance for Lido Isle plant- at the expense of $300. On motion of Councilman Finch, seconded ing. by Councilman Isbell and carried, the request was referred to the City Manager and City Engineer._ P.B.&R. recommends The Park, Beach, & Recreation Commission recommended $2100 allocation to that the sum of $2100 previously allocated to the development of preserve bluff view Bayside Drive, Corona del Mar, be used for the acquisition of in CDM. Corona del Mar bluff property known as 'Inspiration Point''. The Corona del Mar Civic Association submitted a supporting letter urging that the request be granted. On motion of Councilman Finch, seconded by Councilman Smith, the appropriation was authorized by ' the following roll call vote, to -wit* AYES, COUNCILMEM Smith, Finch, Bennett, & Miller. NOES, COUNCILMEN* Isbell ABSENT COUNCILMEN: None P.B.&R. recommends A letter from Mrs. Helene Ceenar, Secretary of the Park, city allow no more Beach, and Recreation Commission, urging that no lease be made of leasing to private waterfront property to a private organization, was read and on clubs of bay front motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Finch and property. carried, was ordered filed. Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried. The League of California Cities asked that the city be Miller named to at- represented at a state wide meeting on county and city sales taxes tend state wide meet to be held in Sacramento on March 12th. On motion of Councilman reo sales tax. Isbell, seconded by Councilman Finch and carried, Mayor Miller was lunch. GRANTED designated to represent the city without dompensation, Mayor Miller voting 'No'. of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried. The Planning Commission referred to the Council a request Plan. Com. referred from Mrs. Gladys Sessell, proprietor of the Anchor Cafe, for parking Gladys Sessell requestapace provision in front of the cafe. On motion of Councilman for parking infront oilsbell, seconded by Councilman Finch and carried, the request was Cafe. referred to the Traffic Committee. LICENSES* Kaminski, Marvin Marvin J. Kaminski applied for a license to operate Mac's Cafe 113 Maim Street, Balboa, The application, having ' Lie. appin, cafe. at GRANTED been approved by the ealth Department, was granted on motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried. Christensen, Bryant H. The application of Bryant H. Christensen for a license Lic. appin, fountain to operate the Fountain Lunch at 619 Coast Hiway, Corona del Mar, lunch. GRANTED having been approved by the Health Officer, was granted on motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried. Cefis, Syvilla, The application of Syvilla Cefis for a license to appl'n License. operate the fountain lunch at Vicent's Lido Drug, Newport Beach, fountain lunch having been approved by the health officer, was granted on motion GRANTED of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried. Lake, Mable The application of Mable Lake for a license to operate Lie. appl'r, to the lunch stand and miniature golf course at 700 East Ocean Front, operate lunch stand. Balboa, suhject to thb approval of the Health Department, was GRANTED. granted on motion of Councilman Isbell,, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried. Bowden, Mildred M. The application of Mildred M. Bowden to operate a ham - Lic. appl'n. ham- burger stand at 510 South Say Front, Balboa Island, subject to the burger stand. approval of the Health Officer, was granted on motion of Councilman GRANTED Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried. Jac's Studio Lic. The application of Jac's Studios, Hollywood, for a application to soli- solicitor's license for home portraiture, having been submitted to ' cit photography. the Police Department, for investigation and report was reported DENIED. upon negatively and on motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried, the application was denied. 9®1 The application of R. J. Hallmark for an exempt license Hallmar, R. J. under interstate commerce to sell Fuller Brushes house to house, Fuller Brushes having been recommended by the City Attorney, was granted on motion To C. Atty. of Cousaoilman Bennett, seconded by Councilman Isbell and carried. The application of Carrol L. Ford for an exempt license Ford, Ca.rrol L. under interstate commerce to sell encyclopedias house to house, having Encyclopedias been recommended by the City Attorney, was granted on motion of To C. Atty. ' Councilman Finch, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried. The application of Sybil Baker Rogers for a]icense to sell Rogers, Sybil Baker encyclopedias house to house under interstate commerce, haling encyclopedias. been approved by the City Attorney, was granted on motion of Councils To C. Atty. Isbell, sbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried. ' The application of Charles F. Schultz for a license to Schultz, Chas. F. operate a tool and die machine shop at 422 31st Street, Newport, Machine Shop. subject to the approval of the Fir Department, was granted on motion GRANTED of Councilman Isbell, seconded by ouncilman Bennett and carried. Chief of Police, R. R. Hodgkinson presented a report of Chief of Police's the events which caused the suspension of six members of the Police report on Department. ' Department and the filing of criminal charges against 5 of the mem- bers. Letters commending the Chief and the department were read Prom the following: Mark Healy, Dean C. Bradford, Ed Allen, Mrs. Billie Robert- Letters supporting son, Nelson Sta6ford, 0. B. Reed; the executive committee of the the Chief. Newport Harbor hamber of Commerce comprising Lonnie Vincnet, Ch&Ir- man, John T. Boyd, Jr., T. M. Hambrook, John T. Keeler, Harvey Sommers, A. E. Stockton and Roland A. Wright; Mrs. W. B. Scott, W. 0. Buck, the Newport Beach City Employees' Association. ' Letters urging a Grand Jury Investigation of the Depart- Letters urging Grand ment were read from: Dr. Wm. 0. Haldy, and R. A. Guthridge. Jury be called in. Letters urging the removal of the Chief of Police were Letters urging re- read from: E. H. Skinner, E. Ralph Sehisler, Fern & Norman Frahm, moval of Chief. Elmer J. Wiles, Dick Park, Ray R. Reeves, Florence M. Bischoff, I. M. Box, Wm. Glassell, and Harry W. White. Letters urging investigation of the department were Letters urging in- read from: John F. Lieb, Herb R. Bland, & Mrs. Lucy P. Bowles. vestigation of Dept. The Lions Club recommended that the base pay of starting Lions Club recommend-. police officers be raised and that all members of the delvrtment pay be raised. be granted increases. The Kiwanis Club expressed confidence in kiwanis Club express the department and urged that an investigation be made of working confidence. conditions. Additional letters commending the Chief of Police and the Department, recieved too late to be read were from: Donald D. Harwood, George M. Holstein and Thomas E. Heffernan. Petitions expressing the highest confidence in the Chief of Police and the department as a whole and urging that full and active support be given them by all citizens, were presented bear- ing a total of 546 signatures. After some discussion, Councilman Finch moved that the Council go on record as expressing confidence in the Chief of Police and the Department. The motion was seconded by Councilman Isbell and carried by the following roll call vote, to -wit: ' AYES, COUNCILMEN: Finch, Isbell, & Bennett NOES, COUNCILMEN: Smith, & Miller ABSENT COUNCILMEN: None 546 signatures on petitions expressing confidence in the Chief & department. Council goes on reco� expressing eonfiden__ in Chief & Dept. Motion by C.Smith to call in Grand Jury. Trost on R.C. vote. C. Smith presented 21 points of criti- cism & rumors of the city. Recess Meeting resumed Councilman Smith then moved that the recent failures in duty or delinquency of certain members of the Police Department be made a matter of investiation by the Grand Jury. The motion was seconded by Mayor Miller andlost by the following roll call vote, to -wit: AYES, COUNCILMEN: Smith, & Miller. NOES, COUNCILMEN: Finch, Isbell, & Bennett. ABSENT COUNCILMEN: none In the course of the discussion, Councilman Smith pre- sented a summary containing 21 points of criticism of the city and its government. He explained that he had been unable to find any foundation for smme of the criticisms, that they wore not made as charges, but submitted as a compilation of rumors. He moved that they be submitted to the Grand Jury or to a committee appointed by the Council with power to subpoena. The motion died for lack of ' a second. At 9:20 p.m. Mayor Miller declared a recess At'9:30 p.m. the council meeting resumed. 546 signatures on petitions expressing confidence in the Chief & department. Council goes on reco� expressing eonfiden__ in Chief & Dept. Motion by C.Smith to call in Grand Jury. Trost on R.C. vote. C. Smith presented 21 points of criti- cism & rumors of the city. Recess Meeting resumed 202 Planning Commission report The report of the Planning Commission recommending the recommending annexation annexation to the city of the property described as lying between of 15 -16th St. property. Irvine Avenue and Santa Ana Avenue, 15th Street and 16th Street, was presented together with notification that there had been filed with the City Clerk an-affidavit of publication and a copy of the notice of intention to circulate petition in the matter of annexation. Res. No.4039, approving Resolution No.40, being a resolution acknowledging circulation of petition redelpt of notice of intention to circulate petition for annexa- for annexation adopted. tion, and approving the circulation of said petition was adopted on motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried by the following roll call vote, to -wit: AYES, COUNCILMEN: Smith, Finch, Isbell, Bennett, & Miller. NOES, COUNCILMEN: None ABSENT COUNCILMEN: None Res. No. 4039, giving Resolution No. 4039, being a resolution ratifying the consent to proceed with previous consent of the City Council of the City of Newport Beach proposed annexation. to proceeding with the proposed annexation was adopted on motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried by the following roll call vote, to -wit: AYES, COUNCILMEN: Smith, Finch, Isbell, Bennett, & Miller. NOES, COUNCILMEN: None ABSENT COUNCILMEN: None Communications relating On motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman to annexation ordered Smith and carried, the communications relating to the annexation filed. were ordered filed. Hearing on "City Disposal Mayor Miller ordered the hearing on the proposed annexation Area continued. of property known as "City Disposal Area" continued until March 9th In order that three annexation areas might be conducted simultane- ously. NEW BUSINESS: Cliff Haven petition A petition bearing signatures representative of 39 parcels for annexation. in the area known as Cliff Haven, asking that it be annexed to the Referred to Plan. Comm. City of Newport Beach and requesting that permission be granted for the circulation of an annexation petition in the territory was read. On motion of Councilman-Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett, the petition was referred to the Planning Commission. Tract 27 petition fo A petition of the owners of Lots 1 - 12 inc., Block 12, as°mt dist. for sanitary Tract 27, for the formation of an assessment district to pay for sewers. Referred to the cost of a sanitary sewer line in said block, was presented. C. Eng. On motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Smith and carried, the petition was referred to the City Engineer for the preparation cff plans and specifications. Plans & Spes. approved All of the owners of property along the easterly side of on sewer, Old County Rd, Old County Road between Beacon Street and the first alley south- & Beacon St. westerly thereof, having deposited $2,070 with the City Treasurer for the installation of sanitary sewer, the City Engineer presented plans and specifications for the improvement. On motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried, the plans and specifications were approved. City Clk instructed to On motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman call for bids on same. Bennett and carried, the City Clerk was instructed to call for bids to be opened on March 9th. Plans & Specifications A petition and waiver for the paving and construction of Sewers & alley Tract 444 sanitary sewers in the alley adjoining Lots 40 to 59 inc., Tract 444 to C. Engr. for prepar- was read, and on motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Council - a.tion. man Bennett and carried, was referred to the City Engineer for the preparation of plans and specifications. Pier Permit A -230 trans- The transfer f pier permit No. A -230 from B. H. Finley ferred from Finley to to W. F. and Frances Mark having been approved by the City Engineer Stark was approved on motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Finch and carried. Pier Permit A -21 trans- The transfer of pier permit No. A -21 from Robt. E. Campbell ferred from Campbell to to Charles and Marie Palmer, having been recommended by the City Palmer. Engineer, was approved on motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Finch and carried. Argabright, H. A. Variance The Planning Commission reported that it had considered Denial upheld by council-the request of the Council for re -study of the application of Mr. H. A. Argabright for a certain Variance previously denied by the Commission, and recommended its denial be upheld. On motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Finch and carried, the council concurred with the C ommission in the denial. Plan. Comm. Res. No. 551 Planning commission Resolution No. 551 being a resolution Kelso -Sloan Variance granting the application of Kelso -Sloan for a rear -yard Variance GRANTED from 10' to 4' at Via Centro and Graziana was presented, and on motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by 6ouncilman Finch and carried, the Council concurred with the Commission in granting the Variance. • 1 1 0 r 1 0 9ot3 Planning Commission Resolution No. 552 being a resolution Plan. Comm. Res. 552 granting the application of Thompson Webb for the reduction of the Thompson Webb . front setback to 18 on the garage. portion of his proms ty at 312 Variance, GRANTED Hazel Drive, Corona del Mar, was presented and on motion of Council- man Finch, seconded by Councilman Isbell, and carrie(Y, the Council concurred with the commission in granting the Variance. ' Planning Commission Resolution No. 5538 being a resolution Plan. Comm. Res. 553 denying the application of Martha L. Smith for a 51 rear yard set -- Martha Smith Vari back instead of the required 100 at 121 Agate Avenue, Balboa Island, ante re- referred to was presented. Reconsideration having been requested, the Resolu- Plan. Comm. tion was referred back to the Commission on motion of Councilman Finch, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried. Planning Commission Resolution No. 554 being a resolution Plan. Com. Res. 554 granting the application of Karl Davis for a 21 overhang on a garage Karl Davis Variance apartment at 221 Sapphire Avenue, Balboa Island, was presented, GRANTED and on motion of Councilman Finch, seconded by Councilman Isbell, and carried, Council concurred with the Commission in granting the Variance. The City Engineer reported that the bid of the R. J. Noble Company in the amount of $13,237.10 was the low bid for the exten- Res. No. 4043 sion of the Balboa Parking Lt. On motion of Councilman Isbell, awarding Balboa seconded by Councilman Finch, Resolution No. 4043, being a Resolu- Perking Lot Contract tion awarding the contract to the R. J. Noble Company and authorizingto R. J. Noble Co. the Mayor and City Clerk to execute the contract was adopted by the following roll call vote, to -wit: . AYES, COUNCILMEN: Smith, Finch, Isbell, Bennet -t, & Miller. NOES, COUNCILMEN: None ABSENT COUNCILMEN: None r 7 0 The City Engineer reported that the single bid of Trautwein Trautwein bid for Bros., for the dredging of the Grand Canal was almost twice his dredging Grant Canal estimate. On motion of Councilman Finch, seconded by Councilman REJECTED Isbell, the bid was rejected by the following roll call vote, to -wit: AYES, COUNCILMEN: Smith, Finch, Isbell, Bennett, & Miller. NOES, COUNCILMEN: None ABSENT COUNCILMEN: None The City Attorney read a letter from General Counsel for the League of California Cities pointing out that the employment of the Letter from General City Clerk for duties other than those specified in the government Counsel of League of code was authorized and that the council had discression to set Cities re: City Clk whatever salary it saw fit for these additional duties. duties & pay. C.K. ORDINANCE NO. 650, being AN ORDINANCE ADDING SECTION 10155.1 TO THE MUNICIPAL C1 OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH, PROHIBITING CERTAIN VESSELS FROM CERTAIN AREAS OF NEWPORT HARBOR was introduced and reading of the ordinance was waived motion of Councilman Finch, seconded by Councilman Isbell and carried by the following roll call vote, to -wit: )DE ORDINANi USING closing Channel vessels upon Reading AYES, COUNCILMEN: Smith, Finch, Isbell, Bennett, & Miller. NOES, CDUNCILMEN: None ABSENT COUNCILMEN: None )E No. 65o Bay Island to certaih introduced, waived Ordinance No. 650 was passed to second reading on motion of Ord. No. 650 passed Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Finch and carried by the to second reading. following roll call vote, to -wit: AYES, COUNCILMEN: Smith, Finch, Isbell, Bennett, & Miller NOES, COUNCILMEN: None ABSENT COUNCILMEN: None The City Attorney reported that in connection with the con- State °s offer of demnation proceedings instituted by the State in connection with $9300 for property the Freeway adjoining the corporation yard, he had secured an adjoining Corp. yd appraisal from the firm of Goode and Goode in the amount of $9,675. accented. He stated that the State now offered to withdraw its condemnation proceedings and pay $9,300 for the property. This sum is $3000 greater than-the original offer of the State for the property and its acceptance was recommended by the City Attorney. On motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Finch, the State's offer was accepted by the following roll call vote, to -wit: AYES, COUNCILMEN: Smith, Finch, Isbell, Bennett, & Miller. NOES, COUNCILMEN: None ABSENT COUNCILMEN: None The City Attorney stated that certain amendments had been made by mutual agreement to the cityes contract with Sully- Miller Company for the removal of the proposed granite from the dump site. On motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried, Resolution No. 4031 approving the original contract was rescinded. On motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Finch, Resolution No. 4040, being the resolution authorizing the execution of the amended contract with Sully - Miller Company was adopted by the following roll call vote, to -wit: AYES, COUNCILMEN: Smith, Finch, Isbell, Bennett, & Miller. NOES, COUNCILMEN: Nora ABSENT COUNCILMEN: None Amendments to Sully - Miller Contract. Res. No. 4031 res- cinded. Res. No. 4040 autho5 izing amended con- tract adopted. 204 C. Engr. instructed to The City Engineer reported that a Use Permit had been draw plans & spcs. for issued by the.Planning Commission for the proposed Newport Beach Ocean Front parking lot parking lot on the Ocean Front. On motion of Councilman Isbell, Ift Newport. seconded by Councilman Bennett and carried, the City Engineer was instructed to draft plans and specifications for the lot. C. Mgr. authorized to The City Manager stated that a salary and wage survey employ Kroeger Assoc. had not been made for some time and asked authority to employ to make salary survey. Kroeger and Associates to make the survey at a cost of approximately $800. On motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Finch, authorization for the survey was granted by the following roll call vote, to -wit: AYES, COUNCILMEN: Smith, Finch, Isbell, Bennett, & Miller. NOES, COUNCILMEN: None ABSENT COUNCILMEN: None C. Mgr. authorized to The City Manager stated that f call for informal bids lated some 30,000 miles a piece and that for 4 police cars. policy, it was now time to replace them. Isbell, seconded by Councilman Finch and was authorized to call for informal bids the four cars. Dur police cars had accumu- in accordance with On motion of Councilman carried, City Manager for the replacement of C. Mgr, authorized to The City Manager stated that the ,jeep used for lifeguard purchase Ford pickup work on the beach should be replaced and recommended the purchase for Lifeguard service. of a Ford one -half ton pickup especially equipped with 4 wheel drive and over -sized tires from the Crook Company of Los Angeles the sole distributor of these vehicles for the total amount of $3,364.91. On motion of Councilman Finch, seconded by Councilman Isbell, the purchase was authorized by the following roll call vote, to -wit: AYES, COUNCILMEN: Smiith, Finch, Isbell, Bennett, & Miller. NOES, COUNCILMEN: None ABSENT COUNCILMENt None C. Isbell granted per- Councilman Isbell requested permission to ]wave the state. mission to leave the Permission was granted on motion of Councilman Finch, seconded by state. Councilman Bennett and carried. On motion of Councilman Isbell, seconded by Councilman Adjournment. Bennett and carried, the meeting was adjourned, sine die. Or / , c City Clerk 0 n 0 1 41