The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About01/25/1960 - Regular MeetingCITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Page 137 - Volume 13 Minutes of REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL Date of Meeting: January 25, 1960 Time of Meeting: 7:30 P.M. Index pin,n of MGGtinO. rn..nnil rinnmlcra COUNCILMEN Z '6 o 00 G�2i o 7 m m N City uieril " - v Roll Call: Present Absent x x x x x x x Councilman Lorenz joined the meeting. The reading of the minutes of January 11, 1960, an January 18, 1960, was waived, the minutes were ap- Motion x proved as written and ordered filed. All Ayes HEARINGS: 1. (Agenda Item E -1) Mayor Stoddard opened a public hearing regarding Ordinance No. 908, being Public AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH ADDING hearing & SECTION 3295 TO THE NEWPORT BEACH MUNICIPAL COD 2nd rea ingRELATING TO REGULATION OF TRAFFIC, Ord. 90 re vehi relating to vehicular access and traffic control cular on Balboa Island. traffic • The City Clerk presented a Letter from John J. Swigart opposing the adoption of said ordinance, control and she read a letter from Harvey D. Pease sug- Balboa gesting a change in the wording of a subsection. Island 2nd rea ingAttorney John Penney spoke from the audience, waived representing the residents on Balboa Island in Ord. 903 favor of adoption of the ordinance, and stated adopted he understood the suggestion made by Mr. Pease CA -74 but did not agree that the change should be made, as it would defeat the purpose of the ordinance. The hearing was closed. Motion x All Ayes The second reading of said ordinance was waived Motion x and Ordinance No. 908 was adopted. Roll Cal : Ayes xx xxxxx Hearing 2, (Agenda Item E -2) The hearing regarding the r Notice Notice to Abate Nuisance (which had been served . R on Roger B. Van Pelt, property owner of build - at A ate ings located at 905 -907 East Bay Avenue and Nuisance 904 -906 East Balboa Boulevard, Newport Beach), Van Pelt having been continued from the Council meeting bldgs. held January 11, 1960, to January 18, 1960, for held over an inspection at subject premises by the Council, to 2-8-60- and continued to January 25, 1960, was further Motion x CA -81 continued to February 8, 1960, in accordance All Ayes with the request of Mr. Van Pelt. Public 3. (Agenda Item E -3) Ordinance No. 911, being hearing & 2nd rea ingAN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Ord. 91 AMENDING SECTIONS 8540, 8547, 8548 AND 8552 OF re signs THE NEWPORT BEACH MUNICIPAL CODE RELATING TO 2nd rea ing SIGNS, waived Ord. 91 regarding height and size of pole and roof adopted signs, et cetera, was presented for second CA -103 reading and public hearing. 4W Mayor Stoddard opened the hearing. No one desired to speak from he floor. T ing Motion x was closed. (l.11 Ayes ATTEST: Page 137 City uieril " - v CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COUNCILMEN Page 138 - Volume 13 ,r o 0o so Index (.Tnni.nr.. ?5 10(%O1 ti 1 V16 The second reading of said ordinance was waived and Ordinance No. 911 was adopted. Motion Roll Call x Ayes xxx xxxx PACIFIC ELECTRIC PROPERTY ACQUISITION: Mr. Hart's Councilman Hart, Chairman of the Pacific report Electric Property Acquisition Committee, reported on P,E. that in order to widen Newport Boulevard, to property cure some of the traffic problems, and to up- acquisi grade the area, acquisition of Pacific Electric tion. property is necessary, and that a 100 foot strip Subcmte between 26th Street and 30th Street, by reason authorized of recent P.E. appraisals, would cost approxi- to nego mately $183,619. He stated that.to acquire the tiate 24 foot strip of P.E. property, known as the for pur depot property, an additional amount of $45,925 chase. would be required, making a total of $228,544. CA -113 He further stated that the Committee believed this to be a fair price. • A subcommittee, consisting of Councilman Hart, the City Manager and the City Attorney, was authorized to negotiate for the purchase of Pacific Electric property consisting of the 100 foot strip between 26th and 30th Streets, and the 24 foot strip along Newport Boulevard be- tween 23d and 26th Streets; and the Council stated it intends to acquire both parcels by Motion x condemnation, if necessary. All Ayes Boy Mayor Stoddard greeted the Boy Scouts in the Scouts audience and announced that on February 8, 1960, to take the Boy Scouts would be taking over the City Hall. over Mr. Keith Malcomson was presented to the audience City as the Boy Scout who had been chosen by the Scouts 2 -8 -60. to be the Mayor. COMMUNICATIONS: Fluori- 1. (Agenda Items F -1 (a), (b)) FLUORIDATION: dation. t (a) The City Clerk presented letters, cards, Jtement of petitions and two letters representing group Council opinion, which had been received subsequent to read by the January 11, 1960, Council meeting, bearing Mayor 128 signatures in favor of fluoridation and /or stating placing the matter on the ballot. Council should (b) The City Clerk presented letters, cards, take no petitions and one group letter, which had been action on received subsequent to the January 11, 1960, TIU=r1d - Council meeting, bearing 158 signatures op- tion. posing fluoridation and /or objecting to the CA -12 matter being placed on the ballot. (c) The City Clerk stated that, in addition, a few people had phoned to state that they were in favor of fluoridation and /or putting the matter on the ballot and wished to be official- ly recorded (Mrs. E. H. Krause, Mrs. Thomas Frees, Mrs. Marinus Contant). Said communications were ordered filed with Motion 11 Ayes x other correspondence o the subject. /( ATTEST:l Mayor City Uerkj Page 138 ti 1 V16 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Page 139 - Volume 13 Index !7.,.....,, -.. 9S 1OrA\ COUNCILMEN O O 2 0 / �YG \ \YpL LJ Mayor Stoddard stated that the Council had pre- pared the following statement, which he read: "Findings: "1. Professional medical opinion favors fluor- idation to control tooth decay. "2. A small sampling of lay opinion is divided but indicates an opposition trend. "3. Based on the natural fluoride content and the mean annual temperature of the area, MWD water contains up to 60% of the recommended minimum fluoride. "4. The propriety of a public vote on fluor- idation has been questioned. Arguments pre- sented are based on religious beliefs inimical to forced medication and a possible invasion of individual rights. These are legal questions. • It is also argued that there are moral questions of like nature. The former are matters for the courts to decide and the latter can be expressed at the polls. "Conclusion: "1. Without expressing an opinion as to any of the above points the Council should take no action on fluoridation." A motion was made, which carried unanimously, Motion x to adopt the statement read by Mayor Stoddard. All Ayes Or. Co. 2. (Agenda Item F -3) Payment of the statement of League f the Orange County League of Cities for dues of Cities luesthe City of Newport Beach, for the period of CA -42 January 1 through June 30, 1960, in the amount Motion x of $146.87, was approved. All Ayes Pet. re 3. (Agenda Item F -4) A petition was ordered filed Motion x T�772 with other communications on the subject, which All Ayes was signed by Virginia E. Ford, 318 Pirate Road, Assess. requesting that the Council take the necessary Dist. steps to form an Assessment District for im- CA-29 provements in Tract No. 772. Appli. 4. (Agenda Item F -5) A letter from Attorney Mark A. Newpt Bay Soden transmitting a copy of the Application of Inv. Co Newport Bay Investment Company, dba Balboa to exte d Pavilion Company, to extend service and to service establish rates, filed with the Public Utilities referred Commission on January 8, 1960, was presented. to Join Harbor Said communications were referred to the Joint Motion x Cmte CA 70 Harbor Committee for report back to the Council. All Ayes ''Opera- 5. (Agenda Item F -6) A letter was presented from tion Pace- print" Mrs. Isabell Wright, owner of the Yee Wee Beastie Shoppe, requesting permission to request denied commence a project which she calls "Operation Paw Print, "to have people imprint the paw print of their favorite pet in a new sidewalk in front of her store, charging fee which w d e (� ATTEST: Mayor t`�} City e M4 Page 139 / CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Page 140 - Volume 13 Index ( January 25. 1960) COUNCILMEN "payable to the Business and Professional Women's Club" for its Z A 7i U` N Gl O "payable to the Business and Professional Women's Club" for its worthy charities. After discussion, the request was denied. Motion x All Ayes 6. (Agenda Item F -7) The following communications Motion x were ordered filed; All Ayes Costa Mesa Two excerpts from the minutes of the Boundary Annexa- Commission placing the City on.notice that Cost tions Mesa proposes to annex a territory called CA -108 "Harbor No. 1" and "Adams Annexation No. 1," which are areas in the vicinity of the Fairview State Hospital and Harbor Boulevard. 7. (Agenda Item F -8) A letter was presented from CdM State G. Mark Engelke, Chairman of the Parks, Beaches & City and Recreation Commission, stating that the Beach Park Commission approved the final plans and speci- Pub Ser fications for Public Service Area No. 1 and the Aiea No. 1 revised Master Plan for Corona del Mar State Pla s and City Beach Park, and recommended that the & Specs City Council adopt the same. appr Clerk tD Said revised Master Plan of Land Use was Motion x adverti e approved. All Ayes for bid CA -49 A notice of approval of said land use by the Motion x State was ordered filed. All Ayes The plans and specifications for said public improvement, construction of buildings, were approved and the City Clerk was authorized to advertise for bids to be received on February Motion x 18, 1960. All Ayes Ltr/ P 18. (Agenda Item F -9) A letter was ordered filed Motion x Palmer from P. A. Palmer, President of the Newport All Ayes express ng Balboa Savings and Loan Association, expressing apprec. appreciation for the time and effort expended CA -83 by the Council and the Planning Commission in efforts to work out a feasible plan for off - • site parking. Sully- 9. (Agenda Item F -10) A letter from Sully- Miller Miller Contracting Company requesting renewal of its Ise ren wallease agreement for the removal of bare materi- ref to al from City of Newport Beach property, "as per City Mg Paragraph No. 12, your resolution No. 4627, C -461 dated May 13, 1957," was referred to the City Motion x Manager for report. All Ayes Small 10.(Agenda Item F -11) A notice of meetings of the Craft Small Craft Harbors Commission to be held Harbors January 22, February 15 and February 16, 1960, Motion x Cmsn Mt was ordered filed. All Ayes CA -70 ll.(Agenda Item F -12) A copy of Application for ABC Alcoholic Beverage License, Clarence R. and License Virginia B. Rustenbach, for new off -sale beer CA -63 and wine at the Newport Market, 2000 West Balboa Boulevard, Newpo Beach, was rd d Motion x filed. A Ayes ATTEST: Mayor ciry e MS Page 140 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Page 141 - Volume 13 Index iJanuar 25 1960) COUNCILMEN ➢ jO m N N G� D m 12.(Agenda Item F -13) A letter was presented from • the Southern Counties Gas Company of California transmitting a copy of an Application for General Appli Increase in Gas Rates before the Public Utilities for Commission. Genera Incr ir The letter was ordered filed, and the City Motion x Gas Rates Manager was requested to contact other cities i All Ayes CA -36 the area and invite their representatives to meet for discussion of the matter. Claim 13.The claim for damages, in the amount of $5000 for for unlawful arrest and imprisonment on DecemLe Damages 3, 1959, of George Dawson, was presented. CA -84 Said claim was denied and the City Clerk's action in referring the matter to the insurance carri- Motion x ers, was confirmed. All Ayes LICENSES: (Agenda Items G -1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8) The follow Motion x • ing Applications for License were approved: All Ayes Licens sl and 2. Exempt, Elder Marion W. Heaps, and Exempt, CA -63 Elder Ferrin James Rex, 363 East 20th Street, Costa Mesa, missionary work, calling door to door for the purpose of acquainting the resi- dents, if they so desire, with the doctrine of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints; headquarters 1591 East Temple Way, Los Angeles. 3. Exempt, R. P. Ray, 344 Donney Brook Street, Orange, soliciting and direct selling of suits, slacks and sport coats for future delivery from out of the State, representing the Interstate Garment Corporation, 1056 West Van Buren, Chicago, Illinois. 4. Exempt, Frances B. Sterling, 20691 Canyon Acres Drive, Laguna Beach, house to house soliciting, sale of encyclopedias, World Book and Childcraf , • representing Field Enterprises Educational Corporation, Merchandise Mart Plaza, Chicago, Illinois; regional officer J. A. 0. Stub, 635 West Avenue, Fullerton. 5. Exempt, Robert L. Williams, Executive Director, Orange County Society for Crippled Children and Adults, Inc., 12612 South Tustin Avenue, Orange soliciting funds selling paper lapel Easter lilies on the streets of Newport Beach on April 8 and 9, 1960, as part of the 1960 Easter Seal Campaign; approximately 25 solicitors of the age sixteen and over. 6. Anthony Sigalos, dba Orange County Food Service Inc., 7951 Whittaker Avenue, Buena Park, porta- ble food stand, adding the following location to existing approved locations: Construction job (Tract No. 772) at the intersection of Lancaster and Prospect. Letter received from • Frank H. Ayres & Son, dev lopers, re tin subject service. ATTEST: Mayor City CiLerk MS Page 141 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COUNCILMEN Page 142 - .Volume 13 y' o y p 3 N O y Index (Januar 25 1960 ) p < a m o 7. Phil Hanson, dba Santa Ana Auction Service, 325 • East 17th Street, Santa Ana, auction at 547 San Bernardino Avenue, Newport Beach, household goods, furniture at private residence of J. Douglas Dunsmore to be auctioned on February 6, 1960. 8. Woody Matthews, dba Automatic Games Company, 237 Orange Avenue, Costa Mesa, four skill games at Anchor Cove, 2805 West Coast Highway, 1 pool table; Vaux Restaurant, 810 East Balboa Boulevard, Balboa, 1 electric gun; Patio Restaurant, 113 - 22d Street, Newport Beach, 1 bowler game and 1 pool table; being a transfer of ownership; formerly owned by Golden West Amusement Co. ADDITIONAL BUSINESS: Ord 910 1. (Agenda Item H -1) Ordinance No. 910, being adding Sec 8103 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH ADDING to SECTION 8103 TO THE NEWPORT BEACH MUNICIPAL CODE • RELATING TO CHEMICAL TOILETS FOR CONSTRUCTION Municip 1 PROJECTS, Code 2d rdg was presented for second reading. waived Ord 910 The second reading of said ordinance was waived Motion x adopted and Ordinance No. 910 was adopted. Roll Call CA -57 Ayes x x x x x x x PB &R re B, (Agenda Item H -2) A letter from G. Mark Engelke, for prop Chairman of the Parks, Beaches and Recreation not to on- Commission, was presented, regarding recommen- cession iredations which had been submitted to the City & conce sioAttorney for the proposed notice to prospective agrmt C M concessionaires and concession agreement for the State & Corona del Mar State and City Beach. City Beach CA -49 Said letter was ordered filed. Motion x All Aye • 3. (Agenda Item H -3) Resolution No. 5151, being a resolution of the City Council of the City of R 5151 Newport Beach announcing a General Municipal re Election to be held on the 12th day of April, General 1960, setting forth the offices to be filled, Municip 1 ordering the submission of two proposed amend- Electioi ments to the Charter of the City of Newport Beac 4 -12 -60 to be submitted to the electors of said City at adopted said General Municipal Election, appointing CA -76 election officers and establishing their compen- sation, designating polling places and providing for the opening and closing of the polls for said General Municipal Election, and approving the limited consolidation with School District Elections, was presented. Mr. Edward Healy spoke from the audience opposing the proposed Charter Amendment which if adopted would permit the sale of the City -owned property now leased to the South Coast Company. • Resolution No. 5151 was adapted. Motion x oll Call Ayes xxx xxx x ATTEST: Mayor Page 142 `ity er M5 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COUNCILMEN Page 143 - Volume 13 1,i1 � 95 _1QL,nl Resolution No. 5152, authorizing the Mayor and • City Clerk to execute a Lease Agreement between R 5152 the City of Newport Beach and the Newport Beach auth Ice School District for the land fronting on the agrmt v/ Elementary School grounds, between 13th Street NB School and 14th Street on Balboa Boulevard, was adopted. Motion x Dist (Lease is subject to approval of the majority Roll Call adoptec vote of. electors of the City on April 12, 1960.) Ayes x x x x x x x Imprs 4. (Agenda Item H -4(a)) The recommendations of the accept Ed City Manager and Public Works Director that the TR 197 improvements be accepted and the surety bond be CA -23 released for Tract No. 1973 (vicinity of Mariners Drive and Dover Drive), South Coast Constructio Company, subdivider, were accepted and author- Motion x ized. All Ayes Imprs 5. (Agenda Item H -4(b)) The recommendations of the accepted City Manager and Public Works Director that the TR 3357 improvements be accepted and the surety bond be CA -23 released for Tract No. 3357 (Cameo Shores), Cameo Shores Development Co., subdivider, were Motion x • accepted and authorized. All Ayes Clerk 6. (Agenda Item H -4(c)) Specifications were ap- to advt proved and the City Clerk was authorized to for bids advertise for bids for the painting of the ex- for paint- terior of the City Hall and existing Police ing City Building, and the painting of the interior of Motion x Hall CA -38 the Council Chambers (and the Mayor's office). All Ayes R 5153 7, (Agenda Item H -4(d)) Resolution No. 5153, ac- Gr of E se- cepting a Grant of Easement from Earl S. Cook ment for and Pauline M. Cook for sewer main; authorizing sewer m in the City Clerk to execute and attach a Certificate Motion x adopted of Acceptance and Consent to Recording, was Roll Call Deeds adopted. Ayes x x x x x x x R 5154 8, (Agenda Item H -4(e)) A memorandum containing auth recommendations from the City Manager and Public contracL Works Director regarding the receipt and opening for traf of bids by the City Clerk on January 20, 1960, 1 for the construction of a traffic signal system •sign 32nd at the intersection of 32d Street and Newport & Newport Boulevard, was presented. w /Stein & Mitch al Resolution No. 5154, authorizing the Mayor and adopted City Clerk to execute a contract for the con - CA-19 struction of said traffic signal system with the Motion x low bidder, Steiny and Mitchel, Inc., at the Roll Call contract price of $9,563, was adopted. Ayes x x x x x x x R 5155 9. (Agenda Item H -4(f)) A memorandum containing auth comtr recommendations from the City Manager and Public w /Milti ioreWorks Director regarding the receipt and opening Inc for of bids by the City Clerk on January 21, 1960, constr of for the design and construction of Type IV Metal Corp Yard Buildings at the City Corporation Yard, was pre - bldgs sented. adopted CA -38 Resolution No. 5155, authorizing the Mayor and City Clerk to execute a contract with the low Motion x bidder, Miltimore, Inc., at the contract price Roll Call of $10,321, was adopte. Ayes x x x x x x x ATTEST. i Mayor City Olerl M5 Page 143 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COUNCILMEN Page 144 - Volume 13 �3, a � o 0 Index (January 2S_ 1()60) p r < 2 m o 10.(Agenda Item H -5(a)) Discussion of an ordinance creating a new C -0 District which will permit Discussion limited commercial and residential uses and will of ord create a new off - street parking formula to be re plan in *nown as "Z" factor, was held over for present- & zoning ment on February 8, 1960. h/o for present'- Attorney Rod Lippold spoke from the audience. tion on 2 -8 -60 Mr. J. W. Reckman of Boatswain's Locker spoke CA -10 from the audience stating that the adoption of the ordinance would put him out of business. The Mayor stated the Council will study the ordinance before introducing it. Mrs V ll.(Agenda Item H -5(b)) The findings of the Weber Planning Commission.regarding the Application of withdra s Mrs. V. Weber to rezone property located at 405 req for Columbus Circle, Corona del Mar, from R -2 -B to rezonin R -3 -B District, recommending denial of the pop ert Application, were presented. CA -10 The City Clerk stated a letter had been received, written on behalf of Mrs. Weber, withdrawing her request for subject rezoning. The findings of the Planning Commission were Motion x sustained. All Ayes 12.(Agenda Item H -5(c)) Ordinance No. 912, being Ord 912 re zoni g AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH introduced ESTABLISHING SETBACK LINES, REZONING PROPERTY, Passed -o AND AMENDING DISTRICT MAP NO. 32, 2nd rea ing Set for establishing staggered front yard setbacks and P/H the rezoning of Lots 1 through 15 in Tract No. 2 -8 -60 3542, located easterly of MacArthur in the CA -10 vicinity of Harbor View Drive and Goldenrod, from an Unclassified to an R -1 -B District, was introduced. • The first reading of said ordinance was waived and Ordinance No. 912 was passed to second Motion x reading and set for public hearing on February Roll Call 8, 1960. Ayes xxxxxx Tent 13.(Agenda Item H -5(d)) The Tentative Map for Tract Map No. 3201, bounded by Acacia and Birch Streets, Tr 3201 Palisades Road and MacArthur Boulevard, being Motion x appr approximately 72 acres, was approved. All Ayes CA -23 14.(Agenda Item H -5(e)) The Tentative Map for Tract Tent No. 3660, located north of Fifth Avenue and east Map of MacArthur Boulevard, Corona del Mar, being Tr 3660 approximately 29.8 acres, was approved, con- Motion x appr w/ ditioned that a temporary cul -de -sac at the end All Ayes conditi ns of Harbor View Drive be constructed with a paved CA -23 diameter of 80' and that the cul -de -sac at the end of Setting Sun Drive be enlarged to have a 80' diameter paved, and that a walkway and steps be provided between Ebb d6 Drive and Pebble Drive. (� ATTEST: �'WY> (dJ1 Mayor c City tC.LeLl< MS page 144 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Page 145 - Volume 13 Index (January 25- 1960) COUNCILMEN N N< y m 0 The Public Works Director was requested to re- port back at the next meeting as to fencing of the small reservoir in the Tract. R 5156 15.(Agenda Item H -6) Resolution No. 5156, amending amendi g the sections of Resolution No. 4895 relating to Secs oJ R 4895 special compensation provisions and leaves of Motion x adoptec absence, pertaining to the accumulation of over -1 Roll Cal.: CA -46 time, was adopted. Ayes x x x x x x Lifegd 16.(Agenda Item H -7) The City Manager presented a accum report regarding accumulated overtime for life- overtime guards. The City Manager was authorized to CA -61 settle the claims of the lifeguards for accumu- Motion x lated overtime at a cost of $1,273.52. All Ayes Add'l 17.(Agenda Item H -8) The City Manager requested Police authorization to increase the Police Department Dept. personnel, effective February 1, 1960, for the personnel addition of two Patrolmen and two Police CA -45 Dispatchers. • The amendment of the Police Department Budget to include the additional positions,as requested Motion x by the City Manager, was approved. All Ayes R 5157 18.(Agenda Item H -9) Resolution No. 5157, amending re Class- Schedule "A," adopted by Resolution No. 5034, ificat'on and amended by Resolution No. 5058, relating to & Comp ns.Classification and Compensation, by deleting th adopted class of Associate Engineer and Street Superin- Motion x CA -45 tendent, and adding the class of City Engineer Roll Call and Street Superintendent, was adopted. I Ayes x x x x x x 19.(Agenda Items H -10 (a), (b)) The following Motion x Budget Amendments were approved: All Ayes Budget Amend- (a) No. C -55, being a Transfer from Unappropriated ments Surplus, Water, to Unappropriated Surplus, appr General, in the amount of $31,547.61, being an CA -102 amount equivalent to the total expended for sewer improvements during the first half of the • 1959 -60 fiscal year. (b) No. C -56, in the amount of $600, being an Increase in Budget Appropriations from Unap- propriated Surplus, General, to Sewers, Land Improvements; for extension of sewer main in 15th Street, easterly of Irvine Avenue; owner has deposited $1200 to cover estimated cost of labor and materials. (c) No. C -57, in the amount of $2500, being an Increase in Budget Appropriations from Unap- propriated Surplus, General, to Police Structures; for remodeling the existing Police Wing, in- cluding electrical, plumbing, sheet metal, plastering, cabinet work and brick work. Channel 20.The Public Works Director was authorized to Motion x ization employ Boyle Engineering to prepare plans and All Ayes Aeronut oni §pecifications and to do field engineering for CA -104 the channelization at the intersection of the Aeronutronic parking lot and Jamboree Road. RECESS The Mayor declared a five m ute- recess. ^ ATTEST: Page 145 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COUNCILMEN Page 146 - Volume 13 0 ➢ p m � N C Index (_Tanvary 2';- 1 QAn) Z < Z m o The Council reconvened with all members present. 21.Mayor Stoddard read again the statement re- garding fluoridation, adopted earlier in the General. meeting by the Council and set forth above in discus ionthe minutes. He then asked if any one in the Fluori a- audience desired to be heard. tion CA A-1 12 Mrs. George Kelley ommented on the dirt which water was found in the when she recently filled her swimming pool in Corona Highlands. The following people participated in the dis- cussion in favor of fluoridation: Charles Winfield, Mrs. Maclyn Somers, Hans Bowman, Mrs. Robert B. Bernard, Dr. Robert E. Washbon (who read a letter which he delivered to the Council just prior to the Council meeting). The following people spoke from the audience opposing fluoridation: Stanley R. Brown, Miss • Harriet Gould, Hans Dickman, Mrs. Margaret Ellen Gilliland, Elmer Poirer. Mrs. Barbara Stabler commented. The meeting was adjourned. Motion x All Ayes ATTEST: yor City C er Page 146