Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout02/13/1968 - Regular MeetingCITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Volume 21 - Page 197 Minutes of REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL Date of Meeting: February 13, 1968 Time of Meeting: 7:30 P.M. Index Place of Meeting: Council Chambers COUNCILMEN 112 Nrmx =+ X x X x N Roll Call: Present x x x x Absent x The reading of the Minutes of the Regular Meeting of January 22 and of the Adjourned Meetings of January 15 Motion x and 23, 1968 was waived and said Minutes were approved Ayes x x x x. as written and ordered filed. Absent x HEARINGS: 1. Vice Mayor Marshall. opened the public hearing 15F pursuant to Section 21107. 5 of the California Vehicle Tract Code to determine whether the provisions of the 6015 California Vehicle Code should be made applicable to (Newport 100 foot long portions of the three private roads in nter) Newport Center which are on extensions of Newport Center Drive, Santa Rosa Drive and Santa Cruz Drive public street alignments. A letter dated February 6, 1968 from The Irvine Company requesting that traffic regulations contained in the California Vehicle Code apply to the subject roads and waiving the 10 -day notice requirement was presented with a memorandum from the Public Works Department dated February 13 regarding application of Vehicle Code to certain private roads in Newport Center. No one from the audience desired to be heard. The hearing was closed. Motion Ayes x x x x Absent x Resolution No. 6696 finding and declaring that certain A =6696 private roads open for public use in the Newport Center area of the City shall be subject to the traffic Motion regulations contained in the California Vehicle Code, Roll Call: was adopted after the reading of the resolution was Ayes x x x x waived by unanimous consent of the Council. Absent x 53 2. Vice Mayor Marshall opened the public hearing Iverson, regarding the appeal of The Irvine Company, as Chick property owners, from the decision of the Planning VW dealei Commission granting Use Permit No. 1327 with Irvine Cc conditions, and requesting that Condition No. 7, which Appeal stipulates that there shall be no access to Bayside Drive with the exception of fire access,be deleted. Applicant for Use Permit No. 1327 is Chick Iverson Page 197 X x X x N CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COUNCILMEN Volume 21 - Page 198 s m oya' apc,a Index 1r PhrlinrAr 11 1 qAR Volkswagen, Inc., 445 East Coast Highway, requesting an automobile sales and service facility in an un- classified district, portion of Blocks 54 and 94, Irvine's Subdivision, Zone "U ". The appeal letter dated January 25 from The Irvine Company was presented with the findings of the Planning Commission dated February 13, 1968. Planning Director Ernest Mayer, Jr. reported on the findings of the Planning Commission. Richard Reese of The Irvine Company spoke from the audience on behalf of the applicant. The hearing was closed: Motion x Ayes x x x x x • Absent x The action of the Planning Commission imposing Condition No. 7 on Use Permit No. 1327 was over- ruled and Condition No. 3 of the Public Works Depart -. ment that access rights to Bayside Drive be dedicated, except for a maximum of one drive approach to be Motion x located as approved by the Public Works Department, Ayes x x x x x x was approved. Absent x 3. Vice Mayor Marshall opened the public hearing 54 regarding the appeal of Raymond B. and Emma Torian, as joint tenants, from the decision of the Planning 'orian, Ray Commission granting Use Permit No. 1331 subject to & two conditions, and requesting that Condition No, 1, huna - appe which stipulates that all new additions conform to the 1P 1331 required setbacks, be deleted. Application for Use Permit No. 1331 requests approval of a second floor addition to an existing nonconforming building at 1701 • E. Balboa Boulevard, Lot 27, Block L, Tract 518, Zone R- 1. The appeal letter dated January 26 from Mr, and Mrs. Raymond Torian was presented with the findings of the Planning Commission dated February 13, 1968. Planning Director Ernest Mayer, Jr. reported on the findings of the Planning Commission. Mr. Raymond Torian spoke from the audience. The hearing was closed. Motion x Ayes x x xx__= Absent x Page 198 Index 1, February 13, 1968 Th Co wit rej 4. Vil —1243 col W1 Wi M2 oro Or CONTI 48 1. Th American Po Legion wh Post 291 wa RESOL R -6697 1. Re Pl; es 12 pro Ulection the es1 33 Tr uisgi. Map ME No. 51 Motion Th Amendment Jai W1 Wi M2 oro Or CONTI 48 1. Th American Po Legion wh Post 291 wa RESOL R -6697 1. Re es 12 PIE Ulection the Municipal to 1968 re co I� CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COUNCILMEN Volume 21 - Page 199 s � y C mo N o m N N� A F a Z B action of the Planning Commission imposing adition No. 1 regarding setbacks was overruled, Motion x h Condition No. 2 of the Planning Commission to Ayes x x x x x x nain in the restrictions. Absent x :e Mayor Marshall opened the public hearing in inection with Ordinance No. 1243, being, AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH ESTABLISHING SETBACK LINES AND AMENDING DISTRICT MAP NO. 51, inning Commission Amendment No. 238, which )poses to amend Districting Map No. 51 in order to ablish front yard setbacks on Lots 1 through 91, act 6425, located north of 5th Avenue, easterly of rguerite Avenue in Corona del Mar. a findings of the Planning Commission dated wary 22, 1968 were presented. e hearing was closed. Motion x ; Ayes x x x x x x Absent x th the unanimous consent of the Council, Vice yor Marshall stated that the further reading of the finance was waived. dinance No. 1243 was adopted. Motion x Roll Call: Ayes xxx xx x Absent x QUED BUSINESS: e request of the Newport Harbor American Legion st 291 for extension of its lease at 215 15th Street Motion x ich had been.diaried on January 8 t February 13, Ayes x x x x x x s rediaried to February 26, 1968. Absent x UTIONS FOR ADOPTION: solution No. 6697, appointing election officers and ablishing their compensation, designating polling .ces, and providing for the opening and closing of polls for the Regular General Municipal Election Motion x be held on April 9, 1968, was adopted after the Roll Call: Wing of the resolution was waived by unanimous Ayes x x x x x x isent of the Council. Absent x Page 199 i _Lndex -7' R -669£ li Electi Munici if :0 • R -6699 1 PI PCtl Muni ni 196 R -6700 55 Villa Conval Hospit CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Volume 21 - Page 200 February 13, 1968 COUNCILMEN \;10�\00-01 A W x x x x x x X x x x x �;4 2. Resolution No. 6698, ordering the submission of proposed amendments to the Charter of the City of Newport Beach to the qualified electors of said City at the regular General Municipal Election to be held on pal on April 9, 1968, was presented. 68 Proposed Charter Amendment Number One was approved to be placed on the ballot as follows: Shall Section 401 of the Charter, requiring that to be eligible to hold office as a member of the City Council a person shall have been a qualified elector of the district from which he is nominated or appointed for Motion at least one year immediately preceding his nomination Ayes x x x or appointment, be amended to change the one -year Noes requirement to ninety days? Absent Proposed Charter Amendment Number Two was approved to be placed on the ballot as follows: Shall Section 705 of the Charter be amended to authorize the City Council to provide by ordinance for payment of an allowance of not to exceed Fifty Dollars Motion in any month to members of City boards or com- Ayes x N x missions established by the Charter to defray out -of- Noes pocket costs? Absent Proposed Charter Amendment Number Three was Motion x approved to be placed on the ballot. Ayes x x x Noes Absent Proposed Charter Amendment Number Four was Motion approved to be placed on the ballot. Ayes x x x Noes Absent x Resolution. No. 6698 was adopted after the reading of Motion x the resolution was waived by unanimous consent of Roll Call: the Council. Ayes x x x Noes Abstain Absent x 3. Resolution No. 6699, authorizing all of the Council 2 members to file written arguments for and against Motion on City measures, was adopted after the reading of the Roll Call: pal resolution was waived by unanimous consent of the Ayes x x x 8 Council. Absent x 4. Resolution.No. 6700, authorizing the execution of an agreement regarding off -site parking, between the Kont rey City, Factory Development Corporation and Villa esc Monterey for off - street parking for the Villa Monterey Motion x Convalescent Hospital under Use Permit No. 1285, Roll Call: was adopted after the reading of the resolution was Ayes x x x waived by unanimous consent of the Council. Absent Page 200 W x x x x x x X x x x x �;4 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COUNCILMEN Volume 21 - Page 201 01.4 x 5. A memorandum was presented from the Public Works 56 Director dated February 13, 1968 regarding relinquish ,esub 241 ment of access rights to the westerly side of East bluff Drive northerly of Vista del Sol (Resubdivision No. 241). -6701 Resolution No. 6701, accepting a Relinquishment of Motion x Access Rights, was adopted after the reading of the Roll Call: telinq. resolution was waived by unanimous consent of the Ayes x x x x x Council. Absent x iccess rgts 6. A memorandum was presented from the Public Works i7 Director dated February 13, 1968 regarding archi- ;dm tectural services for proposed addition to Corona del ,ibrary Mar Library. 2.02 Resolution No. 6702, authorizing the execution of an Motion x agreement for architectural services with William P. Roll Call: Ficker, Ficker, was adopted after the reading of the reso- Ayes x x x x x lution was waived by unanimous consent of the Council. Absent x 7. A memorandum was presented from the City Manager 58 dated February 1, 1968 regarding parking fees at the �dM State Corona del Mar State and City Beach Park. 's City 3each Par 6703 Resolution No. 6703, amending Resolution No. 6171 to increase the parking fees to be charged for vehicles Lncr prkg other than buses on weekdays from $. 75 to $1. 00 at Motion Fees the Corona del Mar State and City Beach Park, was Roll Call: adopted after the reading of the resolution was waived Ayes x x x x x by unanimous consent of the Council. Absent x 8. A memorandum from the Planning Director dated ?5F February 13, 1968 regarding proposed Upper Harbor a ticy View Hills Annexation was presented with a letter W dated January 30, 1968 from the Local Agency Jpper Ha or Formation Commission regarding public hearing on View Hill February 14 on the proposed annexation to the City vo. 61 of Newport Beach designated as the Upper Harbor View Hills Annexation. R -6704 Resolution No. 6704, declaring Council's favorable consideration of and signifying its preliminary consent to the principle of annexation of territory known as Motion Upper Harbor View Hills, was adopted after the Roll Call: reading of the resolution was waived by unanimous Ayes x x x x x consent of the Council. Absent x • Page 201 i x Index February 13, 1968 1 12 Elect: Muni c-- 191 59 Curb i Rodef 60 Co Marka 61 Climb Strom D 15 Curb Newpc Tr 60 • CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Volume 21 - Page 202 COUNCILMEN CURRENT BUSINESS: 1. The arguments in connection with proposed Charter .on Amendments to be submitted to the qualified electors of the City at the regular General Municipal Election Motion x ;� to be held on April 9, 1968 were diaried to February Ayes x x x x x x 26, 1968. - Absent x )it 2. A memorandum was presented from the Public Works .'er Director dated February 13, 1968 regarding the request of Mr. and Mrs. E. O. Rodeffer for a curb cut at 2227 Pacific Drive. The request for the curb cut was granted. Motion x Ayes xxx xx x Absent x .lxt 3. A memorandum was presented from the Public Works Director dated February 13, 1968 regarding the request of Mr. and Mrs. William Markas to construct a 25 foot wide curb cut on First Avenue at 420 Carnation Avenue. The request for the curb cut was granted. Motion x Ayes x x x x x x Absent x �t 4. A memorandum was presented from the Public Works Director dated February 13, 1968 regarding request of John Strom for a curb cut at 418 East Ocean Front, Balboa. William Martin, representing Mr. Strom, spoke from the audience. The request for curb cut was approved as applied for Motion x with the condition that applicant pay for relocating Ayes x x x x x x the existing fire hydrant. Absent x 5. A memorandum was presented from the Public Works F Director dated February 13, 1968 regarding request :uts from The Irvine Company for curb cut permits in rt Ce 15 riter Newport Center. The Public Works Director was authorized to approve Motion x driveway design in the Newport Center area having Ayes x x x x x x widths greater than the present standard, and utilizing Absent x curb return type approaches with a maximum curb radius of 25 feet. Page 202 . i Index February 13, 1968 62 Upper Bay Water Main 0.1079 Chng Order 63 Alley Tmp btn 15th & Balboa • 64 Mariners Library Safe 65 Seal's Ambulance Service r1 lJ 29 Master Strs & Hwys 49 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COUNCILMEN Volume 21 - Page 203 6. A memorandum was presented from the Public Works Director dated February 13, 1968 regarding acceptan of 16 -inch Upper Bay Water Main in Tustin Avenue (C- 1079). Change Order Number 1 in the amount of $1, 084. 29 was approved; subject work was accepted; and the City Clerk was authorized to file a Notice of Comple- tion and to release the bonds 35 days after Notice of Completion has been filed, or upon receipt of accept- ance by the County Road Department, whichever date is later. 7. A memorandum was presented from the Public Works Director dated February 13, 1968 regarding paving of the alley west of 15th Street between Balboa Boulevard and bayfront. Contribution by the City was authorized up to a maxi- mum of $2, 000 for its share of the alley improvements with the stipulation that the adjoining property owners- deposit funds for their share of the improvement with the City before any construction work is authorized. 8. A memorandum was presented from the City Manager dated February 13, 1968 regarding purchase of floor safe for Mariners Library. The purchase and installation of a floor safe at Mariners Library was authorized at a cost not to exceed $170. 9. A letter was presented from G. Larry Seal, Seal's Surgical Supplies, dated February 6, 1968 requesting permission to substitute a 1968 Superior Pontiac Ambulance for a 1962 Superior Cadillac Ambulance. Permission to substitute vehicles was granted as requested, subject to vehicle inspection by the Police Department. 10. A memorandum was presented from the Planning Commission dated February 13, 1968 regarding Master Plan Amendments No. 14, 15 and 16, recom- mending that the following be included in the Master Plan of Streets and Highways: Fifth Avenue in Corona del Mar; MacArthur Boulevard between East Coast Highway and San Joaquin Hills Road be classified a primary road; and Hospital Road and Placentia Avenue between Superior Avenue and Newport Boulevard be - classified a secondary road. The matter was set for public hearing on March 11, 1968. Page 203 Motion Ayes Absent Motion Ayes Absent Motion Aye s Absent Motion Ayes Absent Motion Ayes Absent x x x x Ixi lxlxlx x CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COUNCILMEN Volume 21 - Page 204 s q 9 x 66 11. A memorandum was presented from the City Manager Wrks dated February 13, 1968 regarding Public Works Management Seminar, Management Seminar. The attendance of the Public Works Director at the Motion Management Seminar to be held in Solvang, California Ayes X x x was approved with no additional money to be budgeted. Absent x 67 12. A report from the Tidelands Revenue Committee Tidelands dated February 13, 1968 regarding tidelands and sub- & Submerge merged lands use recommendations was presented lands use with letters from the Balboa Peninsula Point Associa- tion dated February 9 and from the Corona del Mar Chamber of Commerce dated February 13, 1968 requesting that action be deferred and that information al material be made available to these and other group .. The matter was diaried to February 26, and the staff Motion was instructed to make the information available to Ayes X x x these organizations and any others. Absent x Applic. APPLICATIONS - HARBOR PERMITS: Harb. Pern 1. A memorandum was presented from the Public Works 68 Director dated February 13, 1968 regarding Harbor Villa Nov Permit Application No. A- 688 -R -1 of Allan Dale Restauran (Villa Nova Restaurant) to add additional first and second story rooms over the water behind the U. S. Bulkhead Line at 3131 W. Coast Highway. 69 Harbor Permit Application No. A- 688 -R -1 was Irvine Co approved subject to the issuance of a building permit 337 Baysi a from the Building Department, and subject to condi'_ Motion tions imposed by the Building Department and the Ayes X x x Public Works Department. Absent • 2. A memorandum was presented from the Public Works Director dated February 13, 1968 regarding Harbor Permit Application No. A -1512 of The Irvine Company to construct a two -story building at 337 Bayside Drive with the second floor and roof extending beyond the bulkhead. - Harbor Permit Application No. A -1512 was approved, Motion subject to the securing of a building permit from the Ayes 31 N x Building Department. Absent x • Page 204 x Index 70 Mariner's Mile Marina Bus. Lic. Lindley 49 35th St. drainage 52 36th St & Short 72 Alley 28th/ 73 Alley I 63to6 L] CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Volume 21 - Page 205 February 13, 1968 3. A- memorandum was presented from the Public Works Director dated February 13, 1968 regarding Harbor Permit Application No. A- 1337 -R -2 of Mariners Mile Marina (Louis Syracusa), 2607 W. Coast Highway to construct 7 slip floats for a commercial marina, and project roof overhang of restaurant building 30 inches over existing bulkhead to the U. S. Bulkhead Line. John Waddell of B. H. Miller Construction Co., representing the owner, spoke from the audience Harbor Permit No. A- 1337 -R -2 was approved, subject to the installation of equipment on the docks in accord- ance with the fire ordinance and subject to the recom- mendations of the Public Works Director. APPLICATIONS FOR BUSINESS LICENSE: 1. The application of John H. Lindley for Orco Trash Container Service, Inc. , 2283 Fairview, Suite 9, for trash bin disposal service, was approved. COMMUNICATIONS - REFERRALS: 1, The following communications were referred to staff: (a) A letter dated January 30, 1968 addressed to Councilman Forgit from Harold P. Allan re- garding a tide and drainage problem on 35th Street between Marcus Avenue and the canal. (b) A letter dated January 30 from Catherine A. and Fred J. Kriete calling attention to the "worn out and dangerous condition" of the wooden bulkhead on the canal at Short and 36th Streets were referred to the staff, 2. A letter dated January 30, 1968 from Pete Fenton >vrnntsnclosing a petition signed by property owners of ten of fourteen lots involved on 28th and 29th Streets, and asking that the area be declared an assessment district and the rest of the alley paved at the earliest possible date, was referred to staff. 3. A letter dated January 25, 1968 from Margaret E. Strs Hall, 6604 W. Ocean Front, regarding a petition presented to Council February 24, 1967 which was signed by over 51% of property owners requesting the paving of their alley was referred to staff for reply. Page 205 Motion Ayes Absent Motion Ayes Absent COUNCILMEN IM x x x Motion x Ayes x x x x x x Absent x Motion x Ayes xxx x x Absent x Motion Ayes Absent x x Index 29 Master Goals & 74 Palm Tr on Ocean F r1 �J 75 30th & Balboa alignmE Claims: 71 SpigarE 80 Clegerr • 81 Moore 77 SouthwE Capital Corp seawall requesi C, J CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Volume 21 - Page 206 FPhrrnary 13. 1969 COUNCILMEN s c 4. A letter dated January 30, 1968 from C H A R T '1 (Citizens Harbor Area Research Team) complimenting Ob j Council for implementing the Goals and Objectives Study, stating that by unanimous action the Board of Governors had deactivated C H A R T for the period during which the city's Goals and Objectives Study will take place, and enclosing a list of ninety names of persons who have been active or shown interest in participating in the C H A R T program was ordered Motion x filed, and the Mayor was authorized to write a letter_ Ayes x x x x x of thanks. Absent x 5. A letter dated January 25, 1968 from West Newport ees Improvement Association recommending street end planting on the ocean front of a cluster of palm trees, ror t preferably 30 feet from residences, on a voluntary basis, as opposed to the plan for planting palm trees Motion x on every lot, was referred to the Parks, Beaches and Ayes x x x x x Recreation Commission. Absent x 6. A letter dated February 3, 1968 from Mr. Bliss Motion x Trimboli regarding the alignment of the street at 30th Ayes x X x x x Street and Balboa Boulevard, was referred to staff. Absent x nt 7. The City Clerk's referral of the following,matters to Motion x the insurance carrier was confirmed: Ayes x x x XX Absent x (a) Claim of Alice M. Spigarelli for personal injuries sustained on or about January 5, 1968 11' when she allegedly fell because of a faulty street condition. (b) Claim of James Hughes Clegern for damage to his car on January 22, 1968, allegedly by a City . vehicle. (c) Summons and Complaint of Thomas J. Moore, a minor, by Alvin J. Moore, his guardian ad litem, Case No. 152310 in the Superior Court. 8. A letter dated February 7, 1968 from Southwestern str Capital Corporation regarding construction of a sea -. wall in connection with Harbor Permit No. A -1486 and asking that the City lower its water line to facilitate Motion x this construction was referred to staff to contact for Ayes x x x x x renegotiation and report back to Council. Absent x Page 206 i �dex 2E Unif' Schoc Dist] 7£ Salar SUrVE 1� BuggE A=c R. 20 i CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Volume 21 - Page 207 February 13, 1968 COUNCILMEN s q Y O T C �2 [jx x ADDITIONAL BUSINESS: M ed 1. Vice Mayor Marshall nominated Councilmen Rogers 1 and Shelton to serve as members of the School Pict Liaison Committee. The nominations of Vice Mayor Marshall were Motion x approved. Ayes x x x x Absent x M 2. The firm of Griffenhagen - Kroeger was authorized and Motion x y instructed to proceed with the second phase of a City Ayes x x x X3 Y employees salary survey as outlined in the contract Absent x 68 between the City and Griffenhagen - Kroeger dated November 13, 1967. BUDGET AMENDMENTS: t mentE 1. The following Budget Amendments were approved with Motion the understanding that the money is in there on C -50: Ayes x x x X3 P Absent x C -49, $3, 000 increase in Budget Appropriations and a decrease in Unappropriated Surplus to provide architectural services for addition to Corona del Mar Branch Library. C -50, $700 increase in Budget Appropriations and a decrease in Unappropriated Surplus for funds for Via Lido Traffic Island Landscaping. C -51, $130 increase in Budget Appropriations and Revenue Estimates and an increase in Unappropriated Surplus for purchase of floor safe and reimbursement from insurance carrier to cover losses due to burgla- ries at Mariners Library. COMMUNICATIONS - ADVISORY: 1. The following communications were ordered filed: Motion x Ayes x x x x x (a) A letter dated January 25, 1968 from the Local Absent x Agency Formation Commission regarding public hearing on February 14 on the proposed annex- ation to the Costa Mesa County Water District designated as Annexation No. 26. (b) A letter dated January 19, 1968 from Gene Ashmore, private investigator, commending the Police Department for their courtesy and assist- ance. Page 207 �2 [jx x CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Volume 21 - Page 208 Index February 13, 1968 (c) A letter dated January 22, 1968 from Old Town Newport Association thanking Council for its 20 decision to turn off the business meters on the ocean front. 20 (d) A letter dated January 18, 1968 from Edmund Burns protesting the ordinance "requiring a person who rents three or more units in this city to pay a license of $25. 00. " (e) A letter from Mrs. Lois Hines asking Council to 20 vote against any billboards or signs proposed in Newport. (f) A letter dated January 15, 1968 from League of 83 California Cities attaching a list of annual appoint League ments to League committees, including the follow Calf Cites ing from Newport Beach: Committee on Library COnuaittee Services - William Coleman, Board of Library Trustees; Committee on Revenue and Taxation - Councilman Doreen Marshall; Committee on Tide- lands - City Manager Harvey Hurlburt; Committee on Water Quality Control and Solid Waste Manage- ment - Mayor Paul J. Gruber. (g) Resolution of the Board of Supervisors dated 17F December 12, 1968 commending persons and organizations for their participation in the "limited peril" beach erosion operation at New- port Beach. (h) Agenda of the Board of Supervisors meetings held 20 January 23, 24, 30, 31 and February 6, 7, 1968. 20 (i) A letter dated February 8, 1968 from the Newport • Harbor High School Social Studies Department thanking City Manager Hurlburt, Assistant City Manager DeChaine and Finance Director Pappas for their presentations to the students regarding the role of City government. (j) Notice from the City Planning Commission, City 20 of Huntington Beach, regarding public hearing to be held February 20, 1968 to consider petition for a Conditional Exception to regulations of District- ing Ordinance. 2. A letter dated February 3, 1968 from Farel Walker 20 attaching a copy of a letter to the License Supervisor Motion and protesting manner in which citations had been Ayes issued in her office was referred to the City Manager. Absent • Page 208 . COUNCILMEN Index February 13. 1968 _lk 1W .0 • • CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COUNCILMEN Volume 21 - Page 209 T p y m O A P y O O Vice Mayor Marshall stated that the regularly scheduled Study Session for February 19, 1968 would not be held. The meeting was adjourned at 10:15 P.M. Motion x Ayes xxx X Absent x yor ATTEST: City Clerk / i Page 209 i