HomeMy WebLinkAbout21 - Superior Avenue Pedestrian/Bicycle Bridge and Parking Lot Project - PowerPointa
•.�TiTi/!
=•�- - - meati _ . + - �. '�Rw a
Pow
a t
4ft -Ilk
le
AIL
dw
41
../: •-may .y �� � r _ •w... y ' �' . •_ J : '�
it r `w..�• �I - 1 � � .f .� -. . � - �•�� ^
•� , dye R • �
Backaround
➢ Located at NE corner
of Superior Ave and
WCH intersection
➢ Existing parking lot with
64 parking spaces
➢ Area between the existing parking lot and Sunset View Park is
undeveloped
➢ Sunset Ridge Park completed in
Dec 2014 without an on-site parking
➢ Improve safety and access to SRP
➢ Increase parking availability
0
Project Ur)date
➢ Began conceptual ideas with PB&R Comm
2017 (Commission meeting)
fission on April 4,
➢ Worked with City Council working group and PB&R Ad Hoc
committee review conceptual design alternatives
➢ Coordinating with Caltrans and CCC to complete federal
environmental review (NEPA) and CDP Amendment
➢ Presented Conceptual Design to adjacent residents
(5 community outreach meetings)
➢ Presented Conceptual Design to PB&R
Commission on August 6, 2019
Proposed Improvements
New Pedestrian and � NEWPORT
SUNSET RIDGE PARK
� `REsti
Bicycle Bridge �
connecting parking lot . � 44�`
to Sunset Ridge Park "°°'T'°""`
PUBLIC PARKING
Larger parking lot with
128 parking spaces
New recreation area
(Dog Park or passive
area)
➢ Drop-off area, bike
node, and drinking
water fountain
SU!PAR
SET VI -
RECREATIONAL
'rAREX
rCOftr
VILLAGE H' 0PPING,� � ``��. ' •
0p CENTER
JACK IN F
4 THF RnY / ��-`-
oei irtjqq Kri-rinp- itp-nrism-ri-ne
CJC•��;� •� .�7k-�_ ;� � � ��'��I -+-L�
tip! { y+ • i k t` �t •l�
•l i r� �w
I" EA� Adilk
D 0 0 LZA
F,7
�,'1 irvw4
0 I=qj I 12 1*
3w
- "AL i,.
jpw
7jof •
IF
Aor
a
4'.'Alft11IIII1[•11[•
I
i
t
AWW
1
+¢ _ '. _ -� • u � ' , _� _ - �� _ _ " -fir
� - �� •'w—� p - ` � -��� .f , � i''� .. f; _ � ` j" � +ISA .
� .... /f% �`• ��� y �* E�
;�� �
Jiff. O
�P� I •� ,J ��, �'� � i v�.4 � � � /s '.{� IJJ -. YaY �.i f�.•�- �r�• _S
�s T YY_ ,. ._�;`. `t .� ��� � � �'1.� 1 � .: ? -K � vir 1, � � ?/i '. � f _' . � ' �.�-,.�'.... "�f ='�. tr_Y� • - �. , fil Li.� atiJ�Y .. .� �►� .i
{ R tel'.
(.; t
w11"
�
f
� I
fIF
t
tl '/
x
�
�Zf �•
�� •
t ti �--
�JIPAt. J._
AIM-
." � -1 - -'r, . - -i. . . - -.fR
SAW
e
w� 'wig � •
TL
y. v
Md
Al
y
1 _
ti
�� �. � � v ! rte' i 1 � 1. • w ±� `1
View Simulations (Cont.
Steel Truss Bridge - View form Superior Ave sidewalk looking south towards ocean
F, I
E
0
E
View Simulations (Cont.
Steel Truss Bridge - View from Coast Hwy sidewalk looking north towards Newport Crest
View Simulations (Cont.
,
Concrete Bridge - View from Coast Hwy sidewalk looking north towards Newport Crest
Park*na Lot (Existin
SOW
r ^�MAI
.. ' • [ -' lot'
+tri
r<E
t
Parkin
Lot (Pro
osed
ii.I I'.�`�'r+w�,� „ � j �•i'i,. r w• ww fir. .� ��t - .w •�-. _ r - � �. '• \. _.
+� �� .�f ' . �• yam. � � art-,;�., � �► _ , !.
- • � !' : .:. �``^�4 � I� ' _ �. 1 � "+. - _ yet
Public Outreach and Feedback
➢ Presented conceptual design to the following residential communities:
• Newport Crest Association (5/9/19)
• Villa Balboa Association (5/21/19 and 10/15/19)
• West Newport Association (5/29/19)
• Lido Sands Association (6/8/19)
➢ Bridge and parking lot were both well received.
➢ Community and PB&R prefer concrete bridge over steel bridge
N
➢ Concerns from Villa Balboa residents regarding the dog park (potential
noise, odor and added traffic)
➢ Received support for dog park from residents outside of Villa Balboa
Recreation Area
➢ Provide
for more s
ifficult i
inset Vie\.A
peration <
inter Doa
➢ Currently d
➢ March 2015
Lower S�
➢ Similar o
Civic Ce
ports programming at Sunset Ridge Park
access and shortage of parking
PB&R Dog Park Ad Hoc Committee identified
✓ Park as the #I priority for a dog park
]S
Park
➢ Heard concerns from
Villa Balboa residents
➢ Developed alternatives
for recreation area
PROPOSED IMPROVEMENTS
RECREATION AREA
SUNSET RIDGE PARK
;h #
A , $ NEWPORT
CREW
J
ADDITIONAL
:''` = •.`'`�;-M PUBLIC PARKING `` VILLA
BALBQ
At
Ae
/—Z--
C! SUNSET Vl -� --- --
.z
t r
PAR
r., '�, .;`. RECREATIONAL
04 'AREA
�SrCO�` HOAG HOSPITAL
qST/�;°_ LOWER CAMPUk
VILLAGE SOPPING.
CENTER
:±•,
r� JA
d THE BOX
PROPOSED PROPOSED DOG PARK
PARKING LOT AT LOWER SUNSET
VIEW PARK
EXI Sll NG EARTHEN MOUND
PROBED MAX 15'
TALL 'SHADE ST1U CT11NE
F5YNTH ETIC TURF--,, t EL 7's' .
4
f EL � 1' FS
SIJNSET
NEW PA
% O ❑
HOAG HOSPITAL
PR0POISED EXI 5 -fl N G VILLA BAL3()A
LANIDECAPE ! lUN SET VIEW PARK - - (PRIVATE PROPERT
EXISTIN G
_ f 6{ A ECESS FOA —11
X11 100
EXISTING GRAS'S w 11
�lI
Zil
cil -90
EXISTING WALL —"\�11
nil
mil
Zig
t EL 791.,X11
1 Wii -
1 0
EXI STI � '.33 SUNSET VIEW PARK WALKWAY
f EL 74'
PROPOSED DOC- PARK FENCING
PROPOSED RETAINING WALL
-1150
-.50
- 40
— 30
�1
n
r.
SUNSET,
VIEW PARK
HOAG HOSPITAL
PROPOSED
PARKING LOT
PROPOSED PASSIVE
RECREATION AREA
AT LOWER SUNSET
VIEW PARK
(OPEN SPACE)
EXISTING EARTHEN MOUND
f
EL 75'
PROPOSED GRASS - - -
--- f EL 50'
Wiwi Wi
t EL 41' FS 495Ehmm. bI I NIN lblb lblbl blb lblb l
PROPOSED EXISTING
LANDSCAPE SUNSET VIEW PARK
EXISTING GRASS -n,
PROPOSED RETAINING WALL
EX15TING SUNSET VIEW PARK WALKWAY
t
EL 74'
- 40
- 30
Alternative No. 3
Passive Area (Ur)r)er SVP
PROPOSED
F5 hC3 C'ILXr- M r Yt C3 r A Tl^K i A I Anr-K
SUPERIOR AVENUE
.�SL NSE -
1 VEW PARK
PASSIVE RECREATION AREA EXTENSION
0 UPPER SUNSET VIEW PAP,Ks
0.1 ACRES ;�
OP�7 SPACEi � ti
0 89 9PA
_ 70
51
9fD �
FEOAG HOSPITAL
87
�59
B0
-110
-100
- 90
80
- 60
- 50
- 40
- 30
Environmental Review
Draft Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) circulated
for public comment September 23 to October 23
➢ Environmental Factors:
• Aesthetics
• Agriculture and Forestry Resources
• Air Quality
• Biological Resources
• Cultural Resources
• Energy
• G eology and Soils
• Greenhouse Gas Emissions
• HazarrIr- ani Hazardous Materials
• Hydrology and Water Quality
• Land Use and Planning
• Mineral Resources
• Noise
• Population and Housing
• Public Services
• Recreation
• Transportation
• Tribal Cultural Resources
• Utilities and Sewer Services
• Wildfire
Environmental Review -Public Comments
➢ Received 27 comment letters
➢ Provided written responses to each comment
➢ No comments affecting or altering the conclusions within
the IS/MND were raised
�,;:9
9%,
Notice of Availability and Intent to Adopt a Mitigafec! Negative Declaration for the
Superior Avenge Pedestrian and Bicycle Bridge and Parking Lot Project
(PA2019-014)
Exemptions from Zonina Code
➢ Retaining wall height: 8 -foot limitation
• Proposed walls up to 25 feet
➢ Bridge height: 26 -foot limitation
• Proposed bridge 36 to 38.2 feet high
➢ Minor use Permit for parks and parking facilities
r
Local Coastal Proaram Compliance
➢Coastal Development Permits required
➢ City Jurisdiction: CDP for parking lot, bridge and
recreation area - appealable to Coastal Commission
➢ Coastal Commission Jurisdiction: Amendment to Sunset
Ridge Park CDP for bridge abutment
A L I F 0 R N I
COASTAL
0 M M I S 5 1 0
Prelimina
Cost Estimate and Schedule
Planning and Final Design Phases
Construction Phase
Construction Contingency, Testi
Construction Management
ng & Inspection (15%)
Total Project Cost
Current Adopted Budget
(Includes $2,349,600 Federal Grant)
Additional Budget Needed (FY 2020-21)
Complete Final Design - Spring 2021
Start Construction - Summer 2021
Complete Construction - Fall 2022 (16 month duration)
$1,081,000
$6,000,000
$900,000
840.-000
$8,821,000
$5, 600, 000
$3, 22 1, 000
Recommendations
➢ Conduct public hearing
➢ Adopt Mitigated Negative Declaration
➢ Exempt project from Title 20 (Zoning Code) development
and use standards
➢ Select preferred alternative for the recreation area and
approve conceptual design
➢ Approve Agreement with Dokken Engineering (start final
design phase)
F4(
OA7
Q�
LL�FORNI
Comments and Questions
Public Works Department
A Well -Engineered Machine
Protecting and Providing Quality
Public Improvements and Services