The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About4.0_AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal_PA2019-113_1_Staff PresentationAT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal Public right-of-way at the northwestern corner of 38th Street and Lake Avenue Planning Commission Public Hearing October 22, 2020 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Project Background •City’s review limited by federal law •Aesthetics •Land use •Environmental impacts •February 12, 2019, CC authorized MLA with New Cingular Wireless, LLC for use of City-owned streetlights •May 28, 2020, Zoning Administrator approves UP2019-032 for installation on SLC0902 •Later determined CDP is required for small cell •August 27, 2020, ZA approves CD2020-119 •September 9, 2020, Mr. Mosher files appeal 2 of 21 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division SLC0902 Newport Island Park 38th Street Park Lake Street Park Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division R-2 PR R-1 SLC0902 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division R-2 PR R-1 SLC0902 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Applicant’s Request •Remove SLC0902 •Replace in same location •Same luminaire height (light source) •Height increase from 21’-0” to 27’-6” •Antennas enclosed in screen •Support equipment vaulted below grade •Requires MUP for Class 3 Install (approved) •Also requires CDP (appealed) 6 of 21 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Design 7 of 21 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Rendering EXISTING 8 of 21 PROPOSED Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Alternative Sites SLC0902 Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 9 of 21 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Alternative Site # 1 10 of 21 SLC0903 –Opposite corner at 38th St and River Ave Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Alternative Site # 1 11 of 21 SLC0903 <3’ Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Alternative Site # 2 12 of 21 SLC0901 –Corner of 37th St and Lake Ave Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Alternative Site # 2 13 of 21 SLC0901 –Corner of 37th St and Lake Ave Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Alternative Site # 3 14 of 21 SLC0904 –Corner of 39th St and River Ave Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Alternative Site # 3 15 of 21 SLC0901 –Corner of 37th St and Lake Ave <3’ Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Visual Analysis 16 of 21 “Public view” means a vista of features seen from a public vantage point as identified in CLUP Map 4-3,including bodies of water, beaches,coastline, islands, ridges,bluffs, canyons,geologic features,and landmarks.The term “view”does not mean an unobstructed panorama of these features. “Public view”means a vista of features seen from a public vantage point as identified in CLUP Map 4-3,including bodies of water,beaches,coastline,islands,ridges,bluffs,canyons,geologic features,and landmarks.The term “view”does not mean an unobstructed panorama of these features. Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Visual Analysis 17 of 21 “Public view”means a vista of features seen from a public vantage point as identified in CLUP Map 4-3,including bodies of water,beaches,coastline,islands,ridges,bluffs,canyons,geologic features,and landmarks.The term “view”does not mean an unobstructed panorama of these features. Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Coverage EXISTING 18 of 21 PROPOSED Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Findings 19 of 21 Consistent with LCP City-owned streetlight replacement Not impeding access Not impacting public view Not within sensitive area Consistent with ZC and GP MUP reviewed and approved May 28, 2020 Visual compatibility Blends with streetscape Large parkway area Complies with NBMC 21.49 standards <35 feet tall Concealed within pole and underground Alternative sites considered Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Conditions •COA#1 –Substantial conformance •COA#3 –Comply with local, state and federal laws •COA#5 –Replacement pole location •COA#6 –Replacement pole design •COA#7 –All equipment concealed •COA#8 –All wiring concealed •COA#11 –Height certification required •COA#13 –Maintenance required •COA#26 –Planning inspection required 20 of 21 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Community Development Department -Planning Division Recommendation •Conduct de novo public hearing •Find project exempt from CEQA •Adopt the Resolution to approve the CDP and to uphold ZA’s decision COA#35 –(STRICKEN) COA#38 –(ADDED) BMPs to protect canal during construction 21 of 21 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113) Contact Questions?Benjamin M. Zdeba 949-644-3253 bzdeba@newportbeachca.gov www.newportbeachca.gov Community Development Department -Planning Division Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 4d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC0902 Appeal (PA2019-113)