Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout5.0_AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal_PA2019-115_1_Staff PresentationAT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal Public right-of-way on the north side of Bayside Drive, approximately 900 feet northwest of El Paseo Drive Planning Commission Public Hearing October 22, 2020 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) Community Development Department -Planning Division Project Background and Appeal •City’s review limited by federal law •Aesthetics •Land use •Environmental impacts •February 12, 2019, CC authorized MLA with New Cingular Wireless, LLC for use of City-owned streetlights •April 16, 2020, ZA approves Resolution No. ZA2020- 031 •Call for review attempted by the PC after appeal period expired and UP2019-034 became effective. 2 of 17 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) Community Development Department -Planning Division •Later determined CDP required •On August 27, 2020, the ZA conducted a public hearing and approved CD2020-118 •On September 9, 2020, Mr. Mosher filed appeal citing inadequate consideration of alternative locations and collocation 3 of 17 Project Background and Appeal Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) Community Development Department -Planning Division 4 SLC4653 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) •Remove SLC4653 •Replace in same location •Install support equipment •Same luminaire height (light source) •Height increase from 21’-1” to 27’-5” •Antennas enclosed in shroud •Equipment below grade and inside pole Community Development Department -Planning Division Request 5 of 17 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) Community Development Department -Planning Division Design 6 of 17 6’-4” height increase Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) Community Development Department -Planning Division Rendering EXISTING 7 of 17 PROPOSED Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) Community Development Department -Planning Division Coverage EXISTING 8 of 17 PROPOSED Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) Community Development Department -Planning Division Alternative Sites SLC4653 Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 9 of 17 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) Community Development Department -Planning Division Alternative Site No 1 SLC4651 10 of 17 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) Community Development Department -Planning Division Alternative Site No 2 SLC4652 11 of 17 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) Community Development Department -Planning Division Alternative Site No 3 SLC4654 12 of 17 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) Community Development Department -Planning Division Alternative Site No 4 SLC4655 13 of 17 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) Community Development Department -Planning Division Traveling northbound on Bayside Drive 14 of 17 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) Consistent with LCP City-owned streetlight replacement Not impeding access Not impacting public view Not within sensitive area Consistent with ZC and GP MUP obtained Visual compatibility Blends with streetscape Large parkway area Complies with NBMC 21.49 standards <35 feet tall Concealed within pole and underground Alternative sites considered Community Development Department -Planning Division Findings 15 of 17 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) •Conduct de novo public hearing •Find project exempt from CEQA •Adopt the Resolution to uphold ZA’s decision and approve the CDP •Correction to draft resolution Community Development Department -Planning Division Recommendation 16 of 17 Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115) Contact Questions? Joselyn Perez 949-644-3312 jperez@newportbeachca.gov www.newportbeachca.gov Community Development Department -Planning Division Planning Commission - October 22, 2020 Item No. 5d Additional Materials Presented at Meeting by Staff AT&T Small Cell SLC4653 Appeal (PA2019-115)