HomeMy WebLinkAbout20191218_Coastal Hazards AnalysisPMA CONSULTING, INC.
CONSUL TING STRUCTURAL ENGINEERS
28161 Casitas Ct. PH. (714) 717-7542
Laguna Niguel, CA 92677
December 09, 2019
Craig S. Hampton, Inc.
5500 E. Quartersawn Street
Boise, Idaho 83 716
e-mail: p.petrov@pma-bg.com
RE: COASTAL HAZARDS ANALYSIS REPORT FOR COASTAL
DEVELOPMENT PERMIT
5009 Seashore, LLC; Applicant
5009 Seashore Drive
City of Newport Beach, County of Orange
PMA Job #32519
Dear Mr. Hampton,
PMA Consulting, Inc. is pleased to provide this report regarding Coastal Hazards Analysis for
the proposed development at the subject site. The site is adjacent to Pacific Ocean; thus, it may be
subject to Coastal Hazards such as, flooding, wave runup, and erosion. This study investigates the
potential for the aforementioned hazards to impact the proposed development on the site over the next
75 years and addresses compliance with Coastal Hazards Analysis Report requirements and standards
ofNBMC Section 21.30.15.E.2.
STATEMENT OF THE PREPARER'S QUALIFICATIONS
Plamen Petrov, P.E., the preparer of the Coastal Hazards Analysis Report on this project,
holds a Master of Science in Structural Engineering from University of Architecture, Structural
Engineering & Geodesy of Sofia, Bulgaria, and is a Licensed Civil Engineer by the State of
California Certificate No. C66947. For the last 20 years of his professional career he has been
actively involved in the design and entitlement of many Waterfront Developments such as custom
homes, seawalls, piers, platforms, floating docks and marinas. A great number of Coastal Hazards
Analysis Reports prepared by him have been reviewed and accepted/approved by California Coastal
Commission.
All the above being said, Plamen Petrov, P.E. shall be considered a qualified preparer for the
Coastal Hazards Analysis Report on this project.
Requirements in Appendix A for Step 1:
Establish the project sea level rise range for the proposed project's planning horizon
(life of project) using the current best available science.
The State of California Sea-Level Rise Guidance 2018 update developed by the Ocean
Protection Council in close coordination with Policy Advisory Committee with representation
from California Natural Resources Agency, the Governor's Office of Planning and Research, and the
California Energy Commission provides a bold, science-based methodology for state and local
PA2019-264
governments to analyze and assess the risks associated with sea-level rise , and to incorporate Sea-
Level Rise into their planning, permitting, and investment decisions, and it is considered the
current best available science.
As reflected in the clouded area of the enclosed Table 28, based upon direct interpolation
of the data for High emissions 2090 & 2100 and Medium-High Risk Aversion, over the project's
planning horizon of 75 years, the estimated Sea-Level Rise (SLR) for year 2094 shall be
approximately 6.00', which is the Sea-Level Rise for the proposed project. Based on the highest
high tide of +7.90'MLLW (Mean Lower Low Water)== 7.72'NAVD88 (North American Vertical
Datum 1988) recorded in the project area, the above established Sea-Level Rise will account for
bay water level of +13.90'MLLW.
Requirements in Appendix A for Step 2:
Determine how physical impacts from sea level rise may constrain the project site,
including erosion, structural and geologic stability, flooding, and inundation.
According to the enclosed Exterior Elevations Sheet 6, the lowest habitable Finished
Floor Elevation of the proposed structure is at+ 15.08' NA VD88==+ 15.26'MLL W which is above
the Base Flood Elevation established for the area. The highest high tide reached in Newport
Beach of +7.90' MLLW is approximately 7.36' below the lowest habitable Finished Floor
Elevation of the proposed structure and will remain below it until after year of 2094.
INTRODUCTION
The subject site is currently separated from the shoreline by an approximately 300 feet wide
relatively flat sandy beach, as reflected on the following Photo.
PA2019-264
FLOODING HAZARD
The primary hazard due to flooding from the ocean waters for this site, like majority of the sites
located adjacent to Pacific Ocean, would be due to long term Sea-Level Rise. The current water levels
in Newport Bay are reflected on the enclosed Datums for Newport Bay Entrance.
According to the enclosed Topographic Survey, the lowest Finished Grade at the subject
site facing the beach is+ 14.84' NAVD88.
While Sea-Levels have been Rising for decades, higher rates of raise are forecast for the
coming century because of climate change -see enclosed table 28. Increases can be attributed to
warmer temperatures, which cause water to expand, as well more liquid mass caused by melting of
ice caps. Current estimates of future SLR generally fall in the range of 4.5-6.7 ft for the year 2100.
Global warming may impact flooding in other ways as well. Warmer water could intensify North
Pacific storms, bringing greater wind and wave energy to shoreline in winter and higher intensity
precipitation.
The Newport Beach Peninsula portion of the Pacific Institute California Flood Risk Map is
shown herein as OE S Quadrangle. The dark blue colored areas show the areas where a 100-year Sea-
Level Rise of 55 inches is added to the existing FEMA coastal flood elevation shown in light blue.
Obviously, the entire Newport Bay area will be affected if sea level rises 55 inches by the year 2100.
If the sea level rises in the next several decades as currently estimated, regional measures
to mitigate the potential flooding hazard shall be taken. As determined in Step 2 above, lowest
habitable Finished Floor Elevation of the proposed structure will remain below High Tide sea
level until after year of 2094.
Thus, the proposed development shall not be a subject to Flooding over the economic life
of the structure.
WAVERUNUP
Wave runup is the uprush of water from wave action on a shore barrier intercepting Stillwater
level. On steeply sloped shorelines, the rush of water up the surface of the natural beach, including
dunes and bluffs, or the surface of a manmade structure, such as revetment or vertical
wall can result in flood elevations higher than those of the crest of wind-driven waves. See wave
Runup Sketch below.
/ Umlt of Wave Runup
-~ .. r •... ~_' ... , .......
. '
Stillwate,
Elevation
Hypotheliall Slope
Wave Runup Sketch
PA2019-264
During a storm, the sea level rises along the shoreline and allows for waves to break closer to the
shoreline and runup on the beach. As acknowledged in Step 1 above, the historical highest water
elevation in Newport Beach is 7.90 feet above MLLW (approximately 7.72 feet above NAVD88).
Sea-Level Rise for the proposed project is 6.00'. The wave that generates the greatest runup is the
wave that hasn't broken yet when it reaches the toe of the beach.
According to the Coastal Construction manual FEMA 55, for a coastal flood hazard area where the
ground is gently sloping, as it slopes at the subject site, Wave Crest=Base Flood Elevation (BFE)
shall be equal to Erno+0.55d100, where Erno= 100-year Stillwater elevation in feet above datum; d100=
100-year Stillwater depth. In our case, Erno= 7.90'+6.00'=13.90 feet; d100=13.90'-14.84'= -0.94 feet,
say 0.00 feet. Thus, BFE=13.90'+0.00'=13.90' which will be below the lowest Finished Floor
Elevation of +15.26' MLLW.
It is unlikely that overtopping waters over the next 75 years will reach the subject site,
even under extreme weather conditions. Due to the sand profile in front of the site, even if some
waters reach the site, they will not cause erosion and/or damage, because of their relatively low
velocity.
EROSION HAZARD
Erosion refers to the wearing or washing away of coastal lands. Beach erosion is a chronic
problem along many open ocean shores of the United States. To meet the needs for comprehensive
analysis of shoreline movement, the United States Geological Survey has conducted analysis of
historical shoreline changes along open ocean sandy shores of the conterminous United States and
has produced an Open-File Report 2006-1219 entitled "National Assessment of Shoreline Change
Part 3: Historical Shoreline Change and Associated Coastal land Loss Along Sandy Shorelines of the
California Coast". The report looks at survey data of the following periods: 1800s, 1920s-1930s, and
1950s-1970s, whereas the lidar shoreline is from 1998-2002. The report looks at both long-term and
short-term changes. According to the report, the average rate of long-term shoreline change for the
State of California was 0.2±0.1 m/yr., and accretional trend. The average rate of short-term shoreline
change for the state was erosional; with an average rate of -0.2±0.4 m/yr. The beach footprint of this
site is stabilized and not subject to significant long-term erosion. Review and analysis of historical
aerial photographs and field measurements for seawall repairs in the area show no change in the
position of the shoreline over the last several decades. The future shoreline changes over the next 75
years are assumed to be the same as in the previous several decades. However, there is a rapid rate
of Sea-Level Rise predicted in the next 75 years. If that prediction holds true, the rapid Sea-
Level Rise may accelerate shoreline erosion, but it shall not impact the structure on the subject
lot over its economic life.
GROUNDWATER AND SLR
As mentioned previously in this report, the project site is about 300 feet from the ocean. Being
that far from the ocean, the groundwater elevation is lower than the tides. Thus, ifthere is about 6.00'
of SLR in the next 75 years, the future maximum groundwater elevation on this site will be the
typical groundwater elevation plus approximately 5.00', which added to the historical highest water
elevation in Newport Beach ocean waters of 7 .90 feet above MLL W (7. 72 feet above NA VD88) will
still be below the lowest habitable Finished Floor Elevation of+ 15.26' MLLW. Our conclusion is
that rise in the future groundwater elevation due to SLR shall not adversely impact the
structure on the lot over its economic life.
PA2019-264
CONCLUSION
In conclusion, flooding, wave runup and erosion will not significantly impact this
property over the proposed life of the development. Thus, need for a shoreline protective devise
is not anticipated over the economic life of the proposed development to protect it from flooding,
wave runup or erosion.
The above conclusion was prepared based on the existing conditions, proposed drawings,
current projection of future Sea-Level Rise, and within the inherent limitations of this study, in
accordance with generally acceptable engineering principles and practices. We make no further
warranty, either expressed or implied.
PMA Consulting, Inc. appreciates the opportunity to work with you towards the successful
completion of your project. Should you have any questions regarding this report, please give us a call.
Respectfully submitted,
Plamen Petrov, P.E.
Principal
Enclosures:
Location Map
Aerial View
Topographic Survey
Architectural Exterior Elevations Sheet 6
Table 28: Projected Sea-Level Rise (in feet) for Los Angeles 2094
Datums for Newport Bay Entrance
Newport Beach OE S Quadrangle
PA2019-264
PMA Consulting!! In~.
Consulting Structural Engineers
28161 Casitas Ct., Laguna Niguel, CA 92677
Phone: (714) 717-7542
E-Mail : P .Petrov®PMA-BG.com
PROJECT
SITE
5009 SEAS HORE DRIVE
NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92663
l
~ ,
l l . ,'3:
i
• ➔
JOB . 325 19
SHT.
DE S. PBP
DATE 12/09 /19
. J-:19'ag .·~~rn1;Qri ·~1
H;ospi_fal Pres ·yterian
· e·as hore.:Drive: · .. . .. . .
LOCATION MAP
PA2019-264
I ' .
PMA Consulting~ Inc.
Consulting Structural Engineers
28161 Casitas Ct., Laguna Niguel, CA 92677
Phone: (7 14) 717-7542
E-Mail : P .Petrov@PMA-BG.com
5009 SEASHORE DRIVE
NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92663
AERIAL VIEW
JOB. 325 19
SHT.
DES . PBP
DATE 12 /09/19
PA2019-264
t---------i--_/ ----1----f----✓ ____ _L -----! -----/ _________________________________ t ! · I • I . · I SE~SHDRE .DRIV·E1 • • i I d i i J&i" • • 1' LEGEND DESCRIPTION '123.45) MEAS. ELEVATIONS < ) REC. BRG. g. DIST, = DECK # BRICK \JALL ---------BUILDING _,. _____ PROPERTY LINE ------,<--I FENCE S BENCH MARK N,G. NATURAL GRADE P.P. P□VER POLE \JM 'w'ATER METER f".F. FINISH F'LO□R G.F'. GARAGE F'LOOR C □NC. CONCRETE F'.S. F'INISH SURF"ACE H.H, MAN-HOLE P PLANTER A.C. ASPHALT T.G. TOP-GRATE Rc!M SURVEYING INC. RON MIEDEMA LS. 4653 23016 LAKE F'□REST DR. 1t409 LAGUNA HILLS, CA 92653 (949) 858-2924 OFFICE (949) 858-3438 F'AX RDMSURVEYING@C□X.NE T I ~ : ~ : I .J I ' ' ' ·-----~-• • I ! r-r---.,k;_---, -~~--;.-~-:r-----I---------------{---------------; i ' ;,,,.-,/Pc.,;.---=,~-1".--i;-/.-l "' II:. "' • -~ ;DIC. --I I I -1 ~ I -.: I ' ,:? I I I 1 I I -l_'j' I -I I I I I I ' I I I I 1--✓ -, I ~ I I I I I I 1-I ---~ I -.dl['.., I I I I 1' I j ! I I : : -=-I J#' I ax. y i1~1 I I t I I I I I J-•-1 ul t I I CARPORT I I I I • f-I ..... ,_ 1-' _J I •-5r 11 • I I I I I-I • W 1-, " 'i 'I :t::r-. I·' I I I I W I w 2 STORY ..J 11!1 ---=-.JI ~-,... I I I w 1' 1 ~ RESIDENCE tffi_#i~ lf/"{oc.1coc.l : : I ~ I f-2 STORY ~~j-1 I iii I I I f-' v? RESIDENCE ___ ... __ 1.):I I la,c.l~: : I 11 (/) I 1 IBLl"ll I I~ 2 STORY I I I I-I ~-I 2 STORY I_ :R:l,,i: RESIDENCE I I t I ti 1 (/) ~ I ~ l RESIDENCE ~81 I I I I-I .--i II!) I I ! I O I If) 1,~-: ~~ I I I I l0 I ' :•~, I /i~ fi;:11----l,'lf~---: : I , !I : ,.. : :~11 :I( :1'."'i :-:~~ : : l ! i I =----;,----7.Z-J :-V-__________ J:-~ ___ F__ I : i I ! i i I .,.z ' ;f' 1 I I I = = ' --,JP'-• ,(I'--I I I I L_t _________ '.'.'.° __ '!:' • -L.-_ • -,i' -_ = = -I f------------_J I f------------_J I i :_~3":"' :iooF::· .,.... / :_:-.;;,-_,:._-~---d.,;~ -_ l l__ ____________ l_L_-:_"':.': _________ J / \ / '""" ~-16' l SCALE, 1'=8' NOTE, RECORD EASEMENTS ARE N□T PLOTTED IF' ANY, SURVEYOR OR ENGINEER SHALL PERMANENTLY MONUMENT PROPERTY CORNERS DR □f"'F'SETS BEFORE ST AR TING GRADING. TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY JOB• 76-1 DATE, 4/17/19 / / / OWNER• BRIAN AND DANA FLOOD LEGAL DESCRIPTION• LDT 5 OF BLOCK 50 OF TRACT NO. 3813 BENCH MARK, COUNTY OF □RANGE BENCH MARK NB2-7-77, ELVATI□N = 8.56 NAVO 88 DATUM ADDRESS OF PROJECT, 5009 SEASHORE NE\IPORT BEACH. CA s,m 11 Of 11 SI-EETS PA2019-264
ii
Ii
<I "I
,f r..rr illiij i ii .~ , " IJ I II :~
I]
DIii
I
' i~
ji
I II
I I I: :ij
I I ' I 111~ I' 1ti:e
I I ·w I , ...
"" I I "" I
""' U·Z:
C S009SEA51{,:ulJRJ\'E,N!iWPORTBliACH,CALIFORNIA
J Q_1,rroM RESIDENCE FOR
5009.SE>.SHORE..LLC
:: I CORPORATEPu.z.A,SUm! 110 ~ NEWPORr Be..\CH, CA 9"-62S {949)81J.S058
1• ,§
!~
I
~
m
In
S;i
::l
0 z
Ul . ~
: --1 ,; m r-m
S;i
'-I
6 z
<I • i· ii I~ .,,. I '• ' -"' I~ la ol ••,
' . '
~I
~!
ii!
C=::Jll
C=::Jll
C=::JII
C=::JIII
C=::Jllil
C=::JII
C=::Jllil
C=::Jll
,~
•C !li:
EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS
COASTAL SUBMITTAL PACKAGE
f
f
I
i
f
f
I
I
T§" I I "" I I I I
I I
.,,.
lt---""----iij
i ! ~~
' I "ll ! I 1r
I
C~~~L; ~; !'f_A,~l,"l;ON
DU.U.l;it<,;; QUAUfY \!lln'l.)ll HOMES IINCt 1~79
5'oor Q~u•~;)~-•o"<.1-'•'-<> 071&
-~~i--...,. ..... ,..~"""'~
1· .~ I~ ·• I
I
..
!~ !~
I PA2019-264
Hi gh emi ss ions 20 30
2040
20 50
Lo w em issions 2060
Hi gh emi ss ions 206 0
Lo w em iss ions 207 0
High emi ssions 2070
Lo w emi ssio ns 20 80
High emission s 20 80
Low emis sion s 20 90
High emis sion s 20 90
Lo w emi ss ion s 2100
Hi gh emissions 2100
Lo w em iss ion s 2110 ·
High em issi ons 2110 '
Lo w emi ss ions 2120
Hi gh emi ss ion s 2120
Lo w em iss ions 2130
Hi gh em is sion s 2130
Low emi ss ions 21 40
High emi ss ions 2140
Low emi ssions mo
Hi gh emiss ions mo
ST ATE Of CALIF ORNI A SEA -LEVEL RIS E GUID AN CE
TABLE 28: Projected Sea -Leve l Rise (in feet) for Los Angeles
Probabilistic projections f or the height of sea-level rise shown below, al ong with the
H++ scenario (depicted in blue in the far right column), as seen in the Rising Seas
Report. The H++ projection is a singl e scenario and does not have an associated
l ikelihood of occurrence as do the probabilistic projections. Probabilistic projections
are with respect to a baseline of the year 2000, or more specifica lly the average
relative sea level over 1991 -2009. High em issions represents RCP 8. 5; low emissions
represents R CP 2.6. Recommended projections for use in low, medium -high and
extreme risk aversion decisions are outlined in blue boxes below.
Low Medium -High Extreme Risk
Avers ion Risk Aversion Risk Aversion
0.3 0.2 0.5 0.6 0.7 1.0
0.5 0.4 0 .7 0.9 1.2 1.7
0 .7 0 .5 1.0 1.2 1.8 2.6
0 .8 0 .5 1.1 1.4 2.2
1.0 0 .7 1.3 1.7 2.5 3 .7
0 .9 0.6 1.3 1.8 2.9
1.2 0 .8 1.7 2 .2 3 .3 5 .0
1.0 0 .6 1.6 2 .1 3 .6
1.5 1.0 2.2 2.8 6.4
1.2 0.7 1.8 2.5
1.8 1.2 2 .7 3.4 8 .0
1.3 0 .7 2.1 3 .0
2 .2 1.3 3.2 4 .1
1.4 0 .9 2 .2 3 .1
2.3 1.6 3 .3 4.3 7.1 11
1.5 0 .9 2 .5 3 .6 7.1 SAY 6.0 FOR
2.7 1.8 3 .8 5 .0 8 .3 YEAR 2094
1.7 0 .9 2 .8 4.0 8 .1
3.0 2 .0 4 .3 5 .7 9.7 16.1
1.8 0 .9 3.0 4.5 9 .2
3.3 2.2 4 .9 6.5 11 .1 18 .7
1.9 0 .9 3 .3 5 .1 10.6
3 .7 2 .4 5.4 7.3 12.7 21.5
'Most of the available c limate model experiments do not extend beyond 2700. The resulting
reduction in model availability causes a small dip in projec tions between 2700 and 2170 , as well as
a shift in uncertainty estimates (see Kopp et al. 2074). Use of 2770 projections should be don e with
caution and with acknowledgement of in c reased uncertainty around these projections.
APPENDIX l : SEA-LEVEL RI SE PROJE CTION S FOR ALL 12 TIDE GAU GES I 72
PA2019-264
9410580 NEWPORT BEACH, NEWPORT BAY ENTRANCE, CA
Home(/) / Products (products.html)/ Datums (stations.html?type=Datums) /
9410580 NEWPORT BEACH, NEWPORT BAY ENTRANCE, CA Favorite Stations...,.
Station Info,., Tides/Water Levels,., Meteorological Obs. Phys. Oceanography
Datums for 9410580, NEWPORT BEACH, NEWPORT BAY
ENTRANCE CA
NOTICE: All data values are relative to the MLLW.
Elevations on Mean Lower Low Water
Station: 9410580, NEWPORT BEACH, NEWPORT BAY ENTRANCE, CA
Status: Accepted (Apr 17 2003)
Units: Feet
T.M.: 120
Epoch: (/datum_options.html#NTDE) 1983-2001
Datum: MLLW
Datum
MHHW (/datum_options.html#MHHW)
MHW (/datum_options.html#MHW)
MTL (/datum_options.html#MTL)
MSL (/datum_options.html#MSL)
DTL (/datum_options.html#DTL)
MLW (/datum_options.html#MLW)
MLLW (/datum_options.html#MLLW)
NAVD88 (/datum_options.html)
STND (/datum_options.html#STND)
GT (/datum_options.html#GT)
MN (/datum_options.html#MN)
DHQ (/datum_options.html#DHQ)
Value
5.41
4.68
2.80
2.78
2.71
0.92
0.00
0.18
-3.33
5.41
3.76
0.74
Description
Mean Higher-High Water
Mean High Water
Mean Tide Level
Mean Sea Level
Mean Diurnal Tide Level
Mean Low Water
Mean Lower-Low Water
North American Vertical Datum of 1988
Station Datum
Great Diurnal Range
Mean Range of Tide
Mean Diurnal High Water Inequality
PA2019-264
Datum Value Description
DLQ (/datum_options.html#DLQ) 0.92 Mean Diurnal Low Water Inequality
HWI (/datum_options.html#HWI) 5.08 Greenwich High Water Interval (in hours)
LWI (/datum_options.html#LWI) 11.15 Greenwich Low Water Interval (in hours)
Max Tide (/datum_options.html#MAXTIDE) 7.67 Highest Observed Tide
Max Tide Date & Time (/datum_options.html#MAXTIDEDT) 01/28/1983 08:06 Highest Observed Tide Date & Time
Min Tide (/datum_options.html#MINTIDE) -2.35 Lowest Observed Tide
Min Tide Date & Time (/datum_options.html#MINTIDEDT) 01/20/1988 16:30 Lowest Observed Tide Date & Time
HAT (/datum_options.html#HAT) 7.18 Highest Astronomical Tide
HAT Date & Time 12/02/1990 16:06 HAT Date and Time
LAT (/datum_options.html#LAT) -1.92 Lowest Astronomical Tide
LAT Date & Time 01/01/1987 00:00 LAT Date and Time
Tidal Datum Analysis Periods
01/01/1980 -12/31/1993
To refer water level heights to NAVD88 (North American Vertical Datum of 1988), apply the values located at National Geodetic
Survey (http://www.ngs.noaa.gov/Tidal_Elevation/diagram.jsp?PID=DX1968&EPOCH=1983-2001 ).
5
Datums for 9410580, NEWPORT BEACH, NEWPORT BAY ENTRAN
All figures in feet relative to MLLW
DHQ: 0.74
♦-------t-MHW: 4.68
PA2019-264
PAC I F I C
I NST I TUTE
California Flood Risk: Sea Level Rise
Newport Beach OE S Quadrangle
-~~-.
-ustiig!wiay 0
-Sl•1e~ Q -c..,,,,.,,,.., []
Clll!et11Coa.i.lBM1Flood
(epe,rorlmr .. IOO~tar llood 1x:.1nt)
se ■UlvelRiqSQtnarlo
Colltu1BIHFIOad•UrNle:s(55 1n,;JVi•)
U,,ct,."W llrnil ol
Erolionffilll'!HaurdZ01111'12100
,/'V Co1ullot>t,llourvwy
Thil lni«malion ii bel!'lg made awbtila fo, in!Dm1atlooal purposes only. U&tn d ltl■ lnl~n
~oebytnelruu 10 hold blameleM th,State o/Ca!lomla.11f'd b rl!lpectiYe ~,.,,~yen,
agenta, eor.tr;,clon,, ar,d IUOCOftr.lCl>t1 for any liat;'lity assoelated win its UM in any tonn. This \II01;
lhdl nolbe uwdto _,actual COHlal hazatda, lnaurance 1«11Wemerill, ot property Yaues
8l',d apedlb!ly !Jha/1 not be vtedlnlieuofflood lmi.nn1;e Sludie,.w;ifiood klsuraneeRal:e MapJ
lssuedbylhe f edenl!Emergency"'-1~fT\81lllvjef\C/{FEl,I.A).
0.25 0.5
Miles
0.5
KHometeni
Cteale<I by the Peck lnstit.Jte. Oakl.JOd. Callb'Tlia, 2009.
Pro;&ct funded by th!! Califomia Energy Canniuion's
Public ll'lletHt El\e!VY Research Program, Cal:Ttatlt,
ard tie Qiibmle Oc.1111 Protection Council
1.5
GridCOO(dna!e$;
UTM Zone 11N meler-1
NAD!IJGCSJ,:go:eo,
"~--2: Nev,por10each
J: Tultin
•= nolpfin/sd
5: LaguriaBeach
6: nolprin/efl
7: nolprinlrtd
B: natprintrtd
OIIIIIS.....:•·USG~s.-y.o,,,..._,io,~fOOCf.~o!-O;Mrk•r<l---1c
M-00(>¥».J,.}Ma,;,,.,O...,,s.nt.{NOS}Co,,,._~,_(CSC),S-.,poll't<!.,_
d~a;<'IJ,l'l,lip _ _,~,.__.,__lni;.(l'W"}VSO.~~ol~-•l!JSOA).
c.#crrioConUICotTll!il..,.._,,.,Nak>Ntit,.,o,-...,,;,_..,..,Sple9M!IW\antbo (W.S,,) ~lfo,,ES!I.Jan<IKJ.t>M
,. -Map eldel'lts mald'I USGS 7.5 mute 110pOgr.1phlc map,
PA2019-264