Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout03 - MOU - Newport Beach Police Employees Associationf 3Zi . COUNCIL AGENDA N0.2_ CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH- ---COUNCIL ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES DEPARTMENT C ...:..:.. _' f::' MACH Resource Management Division ! F j SEP 81997 September 8, 1997 I TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE CIX FROM: Dennis Danner, Administrative Services Director 0.l0 SUBJECT: MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING - NEWPORT BEACH POLICE EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION C _ ao 5 (Q DISCUSSION: The current agreement with the Police Employees Association expired on December 31, 1995. The terms of the agreement were extended through the current date while negotiations were going on for a new agreement. It was the City's goal to provide a fair and competitive salary and benefit package to the Association members while reducing certain benefits that would achieve a long term significant cost savings to the City. The Association pre -ratified an agreement, announcing the results of their vote on August 1, • 1997. If approved by the City Council, the new agreement will cover the period from January 1, 1996 through December 31, 1998. Following are the significant conditions of this agreement: 1. Compensation Adjustment: A. Effective the first pay period of July, 1996 the City will pick up the full cost (1.75°!x) of the Safety Employer PERS rate increase for the 1996-97 fiscal year. B. Effective March 15, 1997 there will be a total compensation adjustment to achieve full formula (approximately 3.48%). C. Effective January 3, 1998, all unit salaries shall be increased by 1.6%. 2. Revised Flex Leave and Vacation/Sick Leave Accrual Schedule: A. Current employees will continue to accrue flex leave or vacation leave at the current rates. In lieu of a reduction in accrual rates of 8 hours in 1997 and 8 hours in 1998 (which all other associations agreed to), PEA Association members shall have their compensation adjustments scheduled for March 15, 1997 and January 3, 1998 (3.88% and 2.0% respectively) reduced by .4%, to 3.48% and 1.6% respectively. It is estimated that the monetary value of a leave day is .4%, thus the two compensation reductions of A% equate to the value of retaining 8 hours of leave in each of the two fiscal years. B. Employees hired after ratification of this contract will accrue flex leave at the following rates: Proposed Accrual Years of Service Rate (Days per Year 1 but less than 5 17 5 but less than 10 20 10 but less than 15 23 15 but less than 20 same as current employees 20 and over same as current employees In addition, these employees will not be eligible for flex leave spillover pay. C. There will be a corresponding proportional adjustment in the Vacation/Sick Leave accrual schedules. C. Effective January, 1998, current employees will be eligible for flex leave spillover pay only if they have used 80 hours of flex leave in the previous 12 calendar months. D. Employees actually working 2088 hours per year shall be credited with two hours of flex/vacation leave per quarter worked on the 12 hour schedule. E. All employees working an extra shift because of the added day on leap year shall be paid I'/2 pay for all hours worked on said shift. F. All unit employees entitled to compensation for previous additional work on 12 hour shifts shall be paid said compensation in cash to be included with retroactivity checks. 3. Salary Step Reduction: The entry level salary will be reduced by 10% by adding two lower 5% steps. The first three steps in the salary schedule will be identified as recruitment steps 1, 2, and 3. 4. Retiree Medical: Agree to achieve cost containment of retiree medical insurance through meetings of the Medical Advisory Committee. Cap at $400 per month contribution by City and active employees. 5. Tuition Reimbursement: Cap at $1,000 per year for non -sworn, 40% of $1,000 for sworn for newly hired employees. Current employees will retain the present tuition reimbursement program for the term of this agreement. 0 6. Bereavement Leave: Forty hours per incident. Bereavement would include death or terminal illness in immediate family. Immediate family means father, mother, brother, sister, wife, husband, child, father-in-law, mother-in-law and grandparents. 7. Non -Sworn Disability Coverage: The City and Association have agreed to reopen negotiations on this subject. 8. Medical Insurance: Any employee may opt out of the insurance plan offered by the City and receive $200 per month with proof of insurance and a signed hold harmless statement. Employee may re -enroll subject to plan rules. 9. 109% Pay Off for Accumulated Time: Upon separation through the duration of this contract. 10. 1959 Survivor Benefit: Amend contract with PERS to move to Level 3 and Level 4 1959 Survivor Benefit for Miscellaneous and Safety members respectively. 11. July 4"': The Police Department has the discretion to schedule any of its employees to work a regular work day on July 4s', regardless of the day of the week or job assignment. This may include modifying work schedules and/or days off according to deployment needs. Unit employees who actually work July 40' will be compensated at their regular hourly rate, plus premium pay equal to '/2 of the hours actually worked on that day. Employees will be provided their regular number of days off for the month of July (unless otherwise scheduled on an overtime basis), which will be selected/assigned according to the normal practices of their particular work unit. 12. PERS Increase: The City shall absorb the increase in the PERS rates effective July 1, 1997. 13. Release Time: Existing release time provision to be increased to Two Hundred (200) hours per year. Use of release time requires prior supervisory approval. 0 i 14. Modified Work Schedules: Substantive Work Schedule Modifications 0 The Newport Beach Police Department currently has available a variety of work schedules including 5/8 schedules, 3/12 schedules, 9/81 schedules, and 4/10 schedules. Except in the case of emergency, prior to moving any employee or group of employees from one work schedule to another (for example, from a 9/81 schedule to a 3/12 schedule), the Department shall notify, and upon request, meet and confer with the Association in advance of any schedule change. If an emergency prohibits meeting and conferring prior to the schedule change, the Department shall meet and confer with the Association as soon as is reasonably possible after the schedule change. Non -substantive Schedule Modifications In the event of any non -substantive change to an employee's work schedule (changes in starting times, days off, etc.), Management agrees to give as much advance notice of said change as possible and to give due regard to the needs of the employees to make adjustments to their personal schedules and commitments related to the change in work schedules. Transfers Transferring an employee to an assignment with a different work schedule shall not be considered a change to modified work schedules and shall not obligate Management to meet and confer over said change. 15. Seniority: The Department shall continue its practice of allowing employees to sign up for vacations, shifts and days off by seniority. The Department shall have the right to deviate from seniority in shift preference selection as necessary to meet training needs, train probationers, separate employees, meet specialized qualification needs, and/or to correct experience imbalances in accordance with existing practice. In the event Management wishes to propose substantive changes to the existing practice of sign-up for vacations, shifts and days off by seniority, it shall give notice to the Association and meet and confer to seek mutually agreeable solutions and/or remedies. In the event that a mutually agreeable solution or remedy is not found, Management may deviate from the prior seniority criteria to the extent necessary to meet operational or safety needs. ANALYSIS: As stated previously, in entering negotiations this year with the various employee organizations, it was the City's goal to provide a fair and competitive salary and benefit package to the association members while reducing certain benefits that would achieve a long term significant cost savings to the City. • L The approximate total costs of the proposed adjustments for the Police Employees Association are calculated as follows: 1996-97 1.75% PERS pick up (07-01-96) $190,000 3.48% Increase (3-15-97) 118,000 1.60% Increase (1-3-98) 0 Total Cost 308 000 1997-98 $190,000 386,000 89,000 665 000 $ 95,000 193,000 89.000 $3U—M The approximate total savings of the proposed adjustments for the Police Employees Association are calculated as follows - Flex -Leave Spillover Pay Savings Health insurance buyout Elimination of July 4th overtime Salary Step Reduction Retiree Medical Total Savings 1996-97 1997-98 1998-99 $ 0 $225,000 $150,000 0 48,000 24,000 0 0 25,000 0 30,000 15,000 0 0 0 � 0 $30.3,00 214 000 Thus the total net cost of this proposal, from July 1, 1996 through December 31, 1998 is estimated to be $833,000. RECOMMENDATION: It is recommended that the City Council approve the attached Memorandum of Understanding and Supplemental Memorandum of Understanding between the City and the Police Employees Association which cover the period from January 1, 1996 through December 31, 1998. C:IWINWORD\DENNISWP\STAFFREP.DOC 09/02/97 9AI AM William Avery & Associates V 408 399 4423 M915/97 03:46 PM ❑2/33 r MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING BETWEEN THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH AND NEWPORT BEACH POLICE EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION This MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING (hereinafter referred to as "MOU") is entered into with reference to the following: 1. The Newport Beach Police Employees Association ("NBPEA"), a recognized employee organization, and the City of Newport Beach ("City"), a municipal corporation and charter city, have been meeting and conferring, in good faith, with respect to wages, hours, fringe benefits and other terms and conditions of employment. 2. NBPEA representatives and City representatives have reached a tentative agreement as to wages, hours and other terms and conditions of employment for the period from January 1, 1996 to December 31, 1998 and this tentative agreement has been embodied in this MOU and the supplemental MOU which has been executed concurrently. 3. This MOU, upon approval by NBPEA and the Newport Beach City Council, represents the total and complete understanding and agreement between the parties regarding all matters within the scope of representation; subject to the provisions of the SMOU. In accordance with the provisions of the Charter of the City of Newport Beach, the Meyers Milias Brown Act of the State of California and the provisions of the Employer's/Employee Labor Relations Resolution No. 7173, the City acknowledges that NBPEA is the majority representative for the purpose of meeting and conferring regarding wages, hours and other terms and conditions of employment for all employees in those classifications specified in Exhibit "A" or as appropriately modified in accordance with the Employer/Employee Resolution. All other classifications and positions not specifically included within Exhibit "A" are excluded from representation by NBPEA. B. Duration of Memorandum. 1. Except as specifically provided otherwise, any William Avery&Associates V 4083994423 M9/5197 03:47PM D3/33 ordinance, resolution or action of the City Council . necessary to implement this MOU shall be considered effective as of January 1, 1996. This MOU shall remain in full force and effect until December 31, 1998, and the provisions of this MOU shall continue after the date of expiration of this MOU in the event the parties are meeting and conferring on a successor MOU. C. 2. The terms and conditions of this MOU shall prevail over conflicting provisions of the Newport Beach City Charter, the ordinances, resolutions and policies of the City of Newport Beach, and federal and state statutes, rules and regulations which either specifically provide that agreements such as this prevail, confer rights which may be waived by any collective bargaining agreement, or are, pursuant to decisional or statutory law, superseded by the provisions of an agreement similar to this MOU. 1. All present written rules and current established practices and employees' rights, privileges and benefits that are within the scope of representation shall remain in full force and effect during the term of this MOU unless specifically amended by the provisions of this MOU. 2. Pursuant to this MOU, the City reserves and retains all of its inherent exclusive and non—exclusive managerial rights, powers, functions and authorities ("Management Rights") as set forth in Resolution No. 7173. Management Rights include, but are not limited to, the following: (a) the determination of the purposes and functions of the Police Department; (b) the establishment of standards of service; (c) to assign work to employees as deemed appropriate; (d) the direction and supervision of its employees; (e) the discipline of employees; . (f) the power to relieve employees from duty for lack of work or other legitimate reasons; William Avery&Associates V 408 399 4423 M915/97 03:47PM ❑4133 • • (g) to maintain the efficiency of operations; • (h) to determine the methods, means and personnel by which Police Department operations are to be conducted; (i) the right to take all necessary actions to fulfill the Department's responsibilities in the event of an emergency; (j) the exercise of complete control and discretion over the manner of organization, and the appropriate technology, best suited to the performance of departmental functions. The practical consequences of a Management Rights decision on wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment shall be subject to the grievance procedures. 1. NBPEA members shall be allowed to participate in the following activities and receive full pay ("Release Time"): (a) attendance at meetings, conferences, seminars or workshops related to matters within the scope of representation; (b) to prepare for, travel to, and attend scheduled meetings between the City and NBPEA during the meet and confer process. (c) representation of NBPEA or any member with respect to a grievance or minor disciplinary proceeding. 2. NBPEA shall designate certain members as those members entitled to release time. In no event shall any one designate be entitled to use more than 100 hours of Release Time (exclusive of actual time spent meeting with City representatives on matters relating to the scope of representation), within any calendar year. Designates must give reasonable advance notice to, and obtain permission from, their supervisor prior to use of release time. Requests for release time shall be granted by the supervisor unless there are specific circumstances that require the designate to William Avery & Associates ('4003994423 (&9/5197 03:46PM 05/33 remain on duty. Designates shall, to the maximum extent feasible, receive shift assignments compatible with participation in the meet and confer process. 3. City grants NBPEA members the right to engage in the activities described in subsection 1(b) at any time without any reduction to City—provided Release Time or to any Release Time bank created pursuant to subsection D(5). 4. City Grants NBPEA 200 hours of Release Time per calendar year to engage in the activities described in subsection (1)(a) and (1)(c). (City—provided Release Time.) NBPEA may accumulate up to 300 hours of City—provided Release Time. 5. In addition to City—provided Release Time and Release Time provided pursuant to subparagraph (3), NBPEA members may contribute up to two hours of earned compensatory time off ("CTO°) to an NBPEA Release Time Bank. Members may contribute earned CTO only during the period from July 1 through August 15th during any calendar year. However, members shall not have the right to contribute CTO to the NBPEA Release Time bank if NBPEA has accumulated more than 600 hours of total Release Time. Any NBPEA member who contributes CTO to the Release Time Bank gives up any right to usage of, or payment for, the contributed CTO. Contributions may be made only in hourly increments. Contributions shall be on forms prepared by the City which shall then be submitted to the appropriate department employee. City shall advise NBPEA as to the balance of hours in the Release Time Bank upon request. For purposes of this subparagraph only, the term "compensatory time off or CTO" includes accrued flex leave, accrued vacation leave, and accrued holiday time. Space shall be provided on bulletin boards within the Police Department at their present location for the posting of notices and bulletins relating to NBPEA business, meetings, or events. All materials posted on bulletins boards shall indicate. the name of the organization responsible. Material posted shall not contain personal attacks on any City official or 4 William Avery & Associates 'N4083994423 1U9/5/97 03:49PM p6/33 employee, any material which constitutes harassment, discrimination or retaliation on the basis of race, gender, ethnicity, religion or other statutorily or constitutionally impermissible basis, or any pornographic or obscene material. F. No Strike. The parties recognize their mutual responsibility to provide the citizens of Newport Beach with uninterrupted municipal services and, therefore, for the term of this MOU, the parties agree not to conduct concerted strike, work slowdown, sickout, withholding of services, or lockout activities. G. Conclusiveness. Except as provided in this agreement and the SMOU,this MOU contains all of the covenants, stipulations, and provisions agreed upon by the parties. Therefore, for the life of this MOU, neither party shall be compelled, and each party expressly waives its rights to request the other to meet and confer concerning any issue within the scope of representation except as expressly provided herein or by mutual agreement of the parties. No representative of either party has the authority to make, and none of the parties shall be bound by, any statement, representation or agreement which is not embodied in this MOU or the SMOU. y�� •1_ Any agreement, alteration, understanding, variation, or waiver or modification of any of the terms or provisions of this MOU shall not be binding upon the parties unless contained in a written document executed by authorized representatives of the parties. I. Savings. Should any part of this MOU be rendered or declared Illegal or invalid by legislation, decree of court of competent jurisdiction or other established governmental administrative tribunal, such invalidation shall not affect the remaining portions of this MOU. J. Impasse. In the event of an impasse (the failure to agree on a new MOU after the express term of the existing MOU has expired), the parties may agree on mediation pursuant to the procedure outlined in Section 10 of Resolution No. William Avery & Associates rI L It 408 399 4423 7173 or a successor resolution. offZ-274-� M915197 9 03:50PM ❑7/33 Effective March 15, 1997, there shall be established internal salary relationships among the various classifications covered by this Agreement, as well as the salary relationship between each Pay Step in the classifications of Police Officer. Those salary relationships are described in the Matrix attached hereto as Exhibit "B" in the column entitled Percentage. Thus, for example, the salary of an employee in the classification of Police Officer, at Step 1, shall be 71.118 of that paid to an employee in the Benchmark Position (i.e., a Police Officer at Step 8), the salary of an employee in the classification of Video Technician at Step 8 shall be 95.608 of that paid to the Benchmark Position and the salary of an employee in the classification of CPTR. SUPT. MGR at Step 6 shall be 119.398 of that paid to the Benchmark Position. 1. Salary/Total Lary/Total Compere a ion Adjustments. The salaries specified in Exhibit "B", or total compensation, as appropriate, shall be subject to the following guaranteed adjustments: (a) The parties have agreed on internal relationships among the various classifications represented by NBPEA, as well as the relationship between each step in those classifications and the Benchmark position. The term Benchmark Position shall mean the top step non -specialty police officer of any municipal police department in Orange County and top step Patrol Deputy for the County of Orange without consideration of special pay or benefit categories or designations such as Master Officer or Senior Officer which are based on a combination of experience, training or education. These internal relationships have been computed in terms of numbers which, when multiplied by the Criteria Salary, (the salary that must be paid to the Benchmark Position in Newport Beach to achieve the appropriate level of Total Compensation or Modified Total Compensation and not the salary actually paid to the Benchmark Position in • Newport Beach which is beyond the control of the parties) represent the salary to be paid to the classifications represented by NBPEA. William Avery&Associates 9:4083994423 Q99/5/97 03:51 PM D8/33 The multipliers for each step of each classification represented by NBPEA are shown . on the matrix attached as Exhibit B. The matrix shall be effective March 15, 1997. The salaries of classifications represented by NBPEA shall be subject to the following mandatory adjustments calculated and implemented in accordance with the foregoing: (i) Effective March 15, 1997, the Total Compensation as defined below,for all classifications represented by NBPEA shall be increased by the difference, as of July 1, 1996, between the monthly Total Compensation of the Benchmark Position in the City of Newport Beach as defined in paragraph A above, and the average monthly Total Compensation of the five (5) Benchmark Positions among other law enforcement agencies in the County of Orange, as defined below, less 0.48. Benchmark Positions among other law enforcement agencies in the County of Orange shall be defined to mean the "top step non -specialty Police Officer of any municipal Police Department in Orange County and the top step Patrol Deputy for the County of Orange Sheriff's Department, without consideration of special pay or benefit categories or designations such as Master Officer or Senior Officer which are based on a combination of experience, training or education. The Benchmark Positions among other law enforcement agencies in the County of Orange with the highest Total monthly Compensation as of July 1, 1996 shall be calculated on the basis of the survey conducted by the Orange County Division of the League of California Cities (League Survey) as verified and/or augmented by telephonic or written communication by the City and/or NBPEA, the results of which shall be made available to the other party. Any dispute among the parties as to the actual Total Compensation paid in any Benchmark Position in another law enforcement agency within the County of Orange shall be resolved by reference to William Avery & Associates V 408 399 4423 90119!5197 O3:52PM D 913 the governing collective bargaining agreement and/or enactment of the applicable public agency. The term Total Compensation shall represent the total of (a) base salary, (b) the value of employer retirement contributions, (c) the value of employee retirement contributions paid by the employer and (d) health insurance contributions, which shall be calculated based on the maximum contribution made by the employer on behalf of an employee with two or more dependents who is enrolled in the health plan having the largest number of employee participants. This adjustment shall be implemented through a salary increase to the benchmark position of 3.93%.with corresponding increases to other NBPEA positions pursuant to the matrix . (ii) Effective the first pay period in January, 1998, the City shall increase salaries for all classifications represented by NBPEA by 1.6%. In addition, NBPEA shall be entitled to reopen negotiations solely on the issue of appropriate salary increase as of the first pay period in January, 1998, in the event the Consumer Price Index (Los Angeles/Long Beach, all urban consumers) for the twelve month period ending October 1, 1997, exceeds five (5%) percent. (iii)Effective the first pay period in July, 1998, the City shall increase compensation of employees covered by this agreement to the extent necessary to maintain a level of Modified Total Compensation which is defined as (Total Compensation as defined above in subparagraph Bl,less the value of employer retirement contributions, for the Benchmark Position that is at least equal .8 percent below t h e average monthly Modified Total Compensation of the five Benchmark Positions in other law enforcement agencies within the County of William Avery & Associates If4083994423 169/5/97 O3:52PM D10/33 Orange with the highest modified monthly Total Compensation at that time, based upon the League Survey as supplemented or augmented in the manner described above in subparagraph B1. Unless the parties agree otherwise, this increase shall appear in the form of a salary increase to all represented classes that causes the monthly Modified Total Compensation to be increased in the manner described above. For example, assume that (a) the difference between the monthly Modified Total Compensation in the Benchmark Position and .8% below the average monthly Modified Total Compensation of the five Benchmark Positions in other law enforcement agencies within the County of Orange is $218.00, (b) the value of the City's payment of the required employee retirement contribution for the Benchmark Position is 98 of base salary, (c) there was no change in the maximum health insurance contribution paid by the City with respect to the Benchmark Position, and (d) the monthly base salary of the Benchmark Position that was used to calculate its monthly Modified Total Compensation was $5,000.00. Under these circumstances, the salary increase would be $200.00 (218 divided by 1.09) and the monthly base salary of all employees represented by NBPEA would thereby be increased by 4% ($200 divided by 5000). (iv)"Pick-up" or payment of employee retirement contributions) of NBPEA members that is at least equal to the average Modified Total Compensation of the five (5) Benchmark Positions (exclusive of the Benchmark Position in Newport Beach) with the highest Modified Total Compensation. Any increase in July, 1998 shall be based on a comparison of Modified Total Compensation paid to the Benchmark Position (exclusive of the Benchmark Position in Newport Beach) using the League Survey published on or about January, 1998, subject to verification of accuracy by the City E William Avery & Associates :4083994423 W19/5/97 O3:53PM D11/33 and/or NBPEA, with information relative to accuracy shared by the parties. (v) Retroactive pay shall be made to employees within 30 days of the execution of this agreement. (i) Effective July 1, 1996, the City shall assnma t.ha navmant_ of the fall PmnlnvPr retirement contribution increase for safety employees approximately (1.76$) without any corresponding reduction in the salary or Total Compensation of any NBPEA member. (ii) Effective July 1, 1997, the City shall assume the payment of the full employer retirement contribution increase for safety employees (approximately 3.28) without any corresponding reduction, or increase, in the salary or Modified Total Compensation of any NBPEA member. 3. Additional Step. Effective September 1, 1997 two additional steps ( designated 1 and 2 with existing first step designated 3 with the remaining steps designated 4 through 8 (steps 1 through 3 shall be considered recruit steps) shall be added to the compensation schedule for each classification represented by NBPEA. The first salary step (1) shall specify a salary for the classification that is ten (108) percent lower that the current first step in the salary range. The second additional step (2) shall specify a salary that is five (58) percent lower that the current salary for the first step in the salary range. Existing rules relative to the time of step increases and advancement shall be applicable to the two new additional steps. (a) The City shall pay each member's required PERS retirement contribution (98 of salary for sworn employees and 78 for non—sworn employees). City payments pursuant to this Section shall be deemed to be member contributions under the Public Employees Retirement System and recoverable by the 10 William Avery & Associates V 408 399 4423 M9/5/97 03:54PM p12133 0 i member as such in accordance with the rules and regulations promulgated by PERS. These amounts will be reported to PERS as special compensation for retirement purposes. The City has amended its contract with PERS to move to Level 3 and Level 4 1959 Survivor Benefit for Miscellaneous and Safety members respectively. -w D - The City and NBPEA have agreed to eliminate entitlement to compensation for duty incentive time and Code Seven time based upon implementation of the 9/80 work schedule and a Settlement Agreement between the City and NBPEA. NBPEA and its members agree that the provisions and rules relative to entitlement to compensation for duty incentive time or Code Seven time survive the termination of this MOU, that the provisions of the settlement agreement are in full force and effect and that no request for compensation for duty incentive time or Code Seven time at variance with the provisions of existing rules or the settlement agreement shall be made at any time in the future by NBPEA or any of its members. 6. Overtime (i) Employees shall be entitled to overtime compensation at the rate of time and one half for hours worked in excess of their regularly scheduled shift. Paid time off shall be considered time worked for overtime calculation_ purposes. (ii) Overtime compensation shall be in the form of compensatory time off or pay at the election the employee. Maximum compensatory time accrual shall be 91 hours. All overtime worked for employees at the CTO maximum shall be paid. (iii)The Police Department has the discretion to schedule any of its employees to work a regular work day on July 4th, regardless of the day of the week or job assignment. This may include modifying work schedules and/or days off according to deployment needs. Unit 11 William Avery & Associates 544083994423 449/5197 03:55PM [)13133 0 employees who actually work July 4th will be compensated at their regular hourly rate, plus premium pay equal to 1/2 of the hours actually worked on that day. Employees will be provided their regular number of days off for the month of July (unless otherwise scheduled on an overtime basis), which will be selected/assigned according to the normal practices of their particular work unit. (iv) All unit employees entitled to compensation for previous additional work on 12 hour shifts (2088 hours), and for working extra time during the previous leap year (1996), shall be paid compensation, at the appropriate rate of pay, in cash to be included with retroactivity checks pursuant to this MOU. (v) Should the employees work an additional shift and subsequently leap years compensation shall be paid at the appropriate rate of pay pursuant to this section. 12 7. Master Police Officer Recognition Program. The City and NBPEA agreed to institute a Master Officer Recognition Program ("MORP") on July 4, 1987. The intent of the MORP is to encourage NBPEA members to remain with the Newport Beach Police Department by compensating employees who have acquired special skills, training and ability through years of service. The parties agree that, after completing a specialty assignment, an officer shall return to Patrol for at least six months before receiving another specialty assignment. The MORP is comprised of three levels with progressively higher compensation paid as years of service increase. MORP pay is calculated on the basis of MORP earnings during the previous calendar year, but eligibility for MORP pay is determined based on the member's assignment as of November 30th of the previous calendar year. MORD pay shall be calculated solely on the basis of the member's salary, payment for overtime and Scholastic Achievement pay (collectively referred to as "MORP Earnings"). MORP Earnings shall not include any other form of compensation. In October, 1996, the City and NBPEA agreed to allow members eligible for Master Officer Pay the choice of receiving their pay in one lump sum in the first pay period in February of the following 12 William Avery & Associates '4083994423 1489/5197 (D3:56PM 614133 0 49 year or bi-weekly. This change took effect the first pay period in 1997. Each year (prior to • November) all members will be surveyed to determine their choice of the above two options for the following year's MORP pay. If an officer becomes eligible for Master Officer I prior to November and chooses to collect the pay bi-weekly, he/she must notify the Chief's Secretary at the time of eligibility. If no notification is received, then the employee will receive their MORP pay in a lump sum the following February. NOTE: This is the only circumstance where an officer may make a change to their MORP pay status other than at the time of the annual survey. The requirements and compensation of the three levels of MORP are summarized as follows: MASTER OFFICER I 1) Minimum service of five (5) years as a Newport Beach Police Officer. 2) Must have obtained an intermediate POST Certificate, or the educational equivalent. 3) Must have successfully completed one year in a specialty assignment. 4) Must receive and maintain at least a competent rating on their most recent performance evaluation. 5) Must be active (includes industrial disability or other paid leave) and on payroll as of November 30th of each year. 6) Must have returned from specialty assignment to Patrol prior to Master Officer II status. Compensation:5% of the member's MORP Earnings during the previous calendar year. MASTER OFFICER II Requirements: 1) Minimum service of eight (8) years as a sworn Newport Beach Police Officer. 13 William Avery & Associates V 408 399 4423 ag/5197 03:56 PM D15133 2) One full year at the Master I level. 3) Must have obtained an advanced POST Certificate, or the educational equivalent. 4) Must have successfully completed a full year in a second (separate) specialty assignment. 5) Must receive and maintain at least a competent rating on their most recent performance evaluation. 6) Must be active (includes industrial disability or other paid leave) and on the payroll as of November 30th of each year. 7) Must have returned from the specialty assignment to Patrol prior to Master Officer III status. Compensation: 10% of the member's MORP Earnings during the previous calendar year. MASTER OFFICER III 1) Minimum service of ten (10) years as a sworn Newport Beach Police Officer. 2) One full year at the Master II level. 3) Must successfully complete a full year in a third (separate) specialty assignment. 4) Must receive and maintain at least a competent .rating on their most recent performance evaluation. 5) Must be active (includes industrial disability or other paid leave) and on payroll as November 30th of each year. 6) For purposes of the Master Officer III level only, seven years of uninterrupted service on the NBPD SWAT Team will be considered a specialty position. Compensation:15% of the member's MORP Earnings during the previous calendar year if assigned to uniformed Patrol or a uniformed Traffic 14 William Avery & Associates 8 400 399 4423 GM915197 03:57 PM p16/33 • field assignment. Uniformed Traffic field assignments are Motorcycle Enforcement Officer and Accident Investigation Officer. 12.5% of the member's MORD Earnings during the previous calendar year if not assigned to uniformed Patrol or a uniformed Traffic field assignment. 15% of the member's MORP Earnings during the previous calendar year after 15 years service with the Newport Beach Police Department regardless of assignment. NBPEA members who have served as sworn Newport Beach Police Officers for more than 15 years and who elect to retire prior to November 30th in any calendar year shall have the right to receive, upon retirement, a pro rata share of their annual MORP compensation. The retiring officer's pro rata share shall be calculated by multiplying the annual MORP benefits by a percentage derived from dividing, by 12, the number of full months worked by the retiring officer since he or she last received MORP compensation. B. Pay or Time Not worked. 1. Flex Leave. (a) Subject to the provisions Of subsection (b) NBPEA members shall accrue flex leave as follows: Years Adjusted Accrual of Con't. Svc.: Per Pay Period: 1 but less than 5 6.85 5 but less than 9 7.46 9 but less than 12 8.08 12 but less than 16 8.70 16 but less than 20 9.31 20 but less than 25 9.92 25 and over 10.54 (b) NBPEA members hired, or rehired, by the City of Newport Beach on or after September 1, 1997 shall accrue flex leave at the following rates: 15 William Avery & Associates 0 0 It 408 399 4423 C� J M915197 03:58 PM ❑ 17133 • Accrual Rate Per Pay Period 1 but less than 5 5.23 5 but less than 10 6.15 10 but less than 16 7.07 16 but less than 20 9.31 20 but less than 25 9.92 25 and over 10.54 (c) During the meeting and conferring for the 1999 MOU, NBPEA may opt to increase unit employees salaries in exchange for a reduction of up to two (2) days (16 hours) of paid leave accrual. Said exchange shall be at the same rate (0.4%) per eight (8) hours of leave accrual as is used in this MOU. Nothing herein is intended to limit or restrict NBPEA's ability to meet and confer over future paid leave accrual rates and levels as well as salary levels pursuant to the modified formula and/or the meet and confer process in general. (d) The Flex leave program shall be administered as follows: (i) NBPEA members shall not accrue flex leave until continuously employed by the Newport Beach Police Department for a period of six (6) months provided, however, if a member on the flex leave program becomes sick during the first six months of employment, the City will advance up to thirteen (13) pay periods of paid leave time for use by the member to recover from illness. In the event the City advances paid leave time and the employee is terminated or resigns before completing six months of continuous employment, the member's final check shall be reduced by an amount equal to the number of flex leave hours advanced multiplied by the member's hourly rate of pay. (ii) NBPEA members shall accrue thirteen pay periods of flex leave immediately upon completion of six (6) months continuous . employment with the Newport Beach Police Department, provided however, this amount 16 William Avery & Associates IT 408 399 4423 EN915l97 03:59 PM ❑18/33 shall be reduced by any flex leave time advanced during the first six months of employment. (iii)Members employed by the City prior to initiation of the flex leave program have had then current accrued vacation time converted to flex leave on an hour for hour basis with then current sick leave placed in a bank to be used as provided in Section 703 et seq. of the Personnel Resolution. Members entitled to use sick leave pursuant to Section 703.1 of the Personnel Resolution must notify appropriate department personnel of their intention to access the sick leave bank and, in the absence of notification, absences will be charged to the member's flex leave account. Members who wish to convert an absence from flex leave to sick leave must submit a written request to the Chief of Police within twenty (20) days after the absence (20 days from the last absence in the event the member was continuously absent for more than one day) specifying the nature of the illness and the person notified of the intent to use sick leave, or the reasons for the failure to notify appropriate department personnel. The Chief of Police shall grant the request for conversion if the member submits a written statement signed by his or her attending physician confirming the illness and the Police Chief determines that the member's failure to notify appropriate departmental personnel was reasonable under the circumstances. (iv) NBPEA members shall be entitled to accrue flex leave up to seventy (70) times the members bi-weekly flex leave accrual rate (Flex Leave Accrual Threshold). NBPEA members first hired by the City prior to September 1, 1997, shall be paid for all flex leave that accrues in excess of the flex leave accrual threshold (Flex Leave Spillover Pay). Flex Leave Spillover Pay will be paid at the member's regular hourly rate of pay. Effective during the first pay period of January, 1998, NBPEA members who have not utilized at least 80 AN William Avery & Associates V 408 399 4423 1211915197 03:59 PM D19/33 hours of flex leave during the prior calendar year shall not accrue flex leave in excess of the Flex Leave Accrual Threshold and shall not be entitled to Flex Leave Spillover Pay. NBPEA members first hired, or rehired by the City subsequent to September 1, 1997, shall not be eligible for Flex Leave Spillover Pay and shall not be entitled to accrue flex leave in excess of the Flex Leave Accrual Threshold. (v) All requests for scheduled flex leave shall be submitted to appropriate department personnel. Flex leave may be granted on an hourly basis. In no event shall a member take or request flex leave in excess of the amount accrued. (vi) Members shall be paid for all accrued flex leave at their then current hourly rate of pay upon termination of the employment relationship. (vii)Should approved leave be canceled due to the needs of the City, a reasonable extension of time (up to 90 days) will be granted for employees to reschedule the leave without the loss of spillover or leave accrual. This provision shall also apply to those hired after the ratification of this MOU. (viii)Employees actually working 2088 hours per year shall be credited with two hours flex/vacation leave per quarter worked on the 12 hour schedule. Bereavement Leave shall be defined as the necessary absence from duty by employee having regular or probationary appointment because of the death or terminal illness in his/her immediate family. NBPEA members shall be entitled to forty (40) hours of bereavement leave per incident (terminal illness followed by death is considered one incident). Immediate family shall mean father, mother, brother, sister, wife, husband, child, father-in- law, mother-in-law, and grandparents. 18 William Avery & Associates 5 408 399 4423 W915197 04!OOPM [)20/33 • • NBPEA members shall accrue holiday time at the rate i of 96 hours per fiscal year (July 1 through June 30th), and at the rate of 3.7 hours per pay period. NBPEA members may (a) use holiday time as paid time off work, (b) convert holiday time to flex leave or vacation leave, or (c) receive pay for holiday time as specified in this Section. NBPEA members who have not used all holiday time accrued during any fiscal year shall, during the month of July, elect either to convert unused holiday time to flex leave or vacation leave if the member is in the vacation leave/sick leave program) or to be paid for unused holiday time at the same "regular rate of pay" that the employees would receive had they utilized the holiday benefit to receive a leave of absence with full compensation, provided, however, NBPEA members shall not be entitled to convert holiday time to flex leave to the extent that the conversion would cause the amount of flex leave accrued to exceed the flex leave accrual threshold. In the absence of an election during July, the members shall receive pay for unused holiday time at the same "regular rate of pay" that the employees would receive had they utilized the holiday benefit to receive a leave of absence with full compensation. NBPEA members who elect to receive pay for unused holiday time shall receive compensation in their paycheck for the last pay period in August. In no event shall any NBPEA member be entitled to receive holiday pay until serving at least thirty (30) consecutive calendar days in active paid status. • q For the term of this agreement, NBPEA members shall receive payment for any accrued leave upon termination at the rate of 1098 of their base hourly rate. (a) Sworn Members. Any NBPEA member who is a sworn peace officer and incapacitated by reason of any injury or illness which has been determined to have arisen out of or in the course of his or her employment shall receive compensation in accordance with the provisions of Section 4850 19 William Avery&Associates '5 408 399 4423 Q915l97 04:01 PM D21/33 et. seq, of the Labor Code of the State of California. (b) Non -sworn Members. Any employee incapacitated by reason of any injury or illness which has been determined to have arisen out of or in the course of his or her employment shall receive, in addition to temporary disability compensation pursuant to the laws of the State of California, an additional sum which, when added to temporary disability payments, provides the injured employee with regular compensation. Regular compensation is defined as the salary for the position and step occupied by the employee on the date of the job-related illness or injury. Payment shall commence with the first day of approved absence and end with the termination of temporary disability, or the expiration of six (6) months, whichever occurs first. Except as expressly provided in this MOU, the payments which supplement temporary disability compensation shall be made as provided in the Personnel Resolution. The City shall make available to all NBPEA members, their spouses and dependents. the PERS health insurance programs and a second health care plan. City shall pay the health and dental premium for each NBPEA member, up to a maximum of $400 per month. The City will obtain a quotation for the addition of orthodontia to the dental plan. Subject to the agreement of other City Employee Associations, the benefit may be added to the dental program, however, the total contribution by the City to employee health will remain at $400.00. 3. Information Committee. City has established a Medical/Dental Information Committee composed of one representative from each 20 William Avery&Associates It 408 399 4423 [U915/97 04:02PM D22/33 • • employee group and up to three City representatives. The Medical/Dental Information Committee has been established to allow the City to present data regarding carrier and coverage options, the cost of those options, appropriate coverage levels and other health care issues. The purpose of this Committee is to provide each employee group with information about health care issues and to receive timely input from associations regarding preferred coverage options and levels of coverage. City shall provide information to the Committee in December, February and April of each year during the term of this MOU. Effective upon the ratification of this agreement, NBPEA members who do not want to enroll in any health care plan offered by the City, provide evidence of health care insurance coverage, other carriers, and execute an agreement releasing the City from any responsibility or liability to provide health care insurance coverage, shall receive in lieu of the $400 contribution towards the premium for coverage offered by City sponsored health care providers in lieu health coverage payment of $200 per month. Employees may re -enroll in any of the City's available health plans per the rules of those plans. The parties agree that during the term of this agreement, the maximum combined contribution by the City and active employees for retiree medical insurance shall not exceed $400.00 per month. (City contribution limited to two-thirds (2/3) of the $400.00 with the active employees paying one- third (1/3). Further, the City and Association agree to work, through a City-wide committee, on a variety of issues involving retiree medical insurance in an attempt to achieve cost containment and equity amongst the City's retiree medical programs. 0 21 William Avery & Associates It 408 399 4423 M9/5197 04:03PM D23/33 The City currently administers a short term disability plan funded through a combination of employee and employer contributions. A NBPEA member shall pay the full cost of any short term disability premium until he or she has accrued at least 160 hours of flex leave and/or sick leave. A NBPEA member shall pay fifty percent (50%) of any short term disability premium when he or she has accrued between 160 hours and 319 hours of flex leave and/or sick leave. City shall pay all of any member's short term disability premium when he or she has accrued 320 or more hours of flex leave and/or sick leave. The plan provides up to two-thirds of a member's salary for a period of up to six months post -disability provided the employee has used available sick leave and a portion of accrued paid leave. City shall have the right to re -open this MOU to meet and confer regarding the transfer of the responsibility for administration, and the manner of funding, of the short term disability plan. The City shall continue to self-administer the short term disability plan until the parties reach agreement regarding appropriate amendments. 2. Lonc The City currently provides long term disability protection through an insurance company. This plan is funded through a combination of employee and employer contributions. A NBPEA member shall pay the full cost of any long term disability premium until he or she has accrued at least 160 hours of flex leave and/or sick leave. A NBPEA member shall pay fifty percent (50%) of any long term disability premium when he or she has accrued between 160 hours and 319 hours of flex leave and/or sick leave. City shall pay all of any member's long term disability premium when he or she has accrued 320 or more hours of flex leave and/or sick leave. The City shall have the right to re -open this MOU to meet and confer relative to the provision of long term disability coverage. In the absence of any agreement to the contrary, the City will use its best efforts to continue to provide long term disability coverage through qualified insurance carriers or companies. 22 William Avery & Associates 4 408 399 4423 W915/97 04:03 PM D24133 3. The ceiling on insured income under the short term and long term disability plans will be $7,500 per month for non -industrial claims. The maximum benefit shall be $5,000 per month. The maximum benefit for industrial injuries shall be $1,750.00 per month. The City will pay one-third (1/3) of the cost of a member's health, dental and life insurance premiums when the member has at least five (5) years of continuous service with the City and is on approved disability leave of absence. The City will pay two-thirds (2/3) of the cost of health, dental and life insurance premiums for an employee with ten (10) years of continuous service who is on approved disability and the City will pay the entire cost of those premiums for an employee with fifteen (15) or more years of continuous service not to exceed the amount paid for active employees. NBPEA members hired prior to September 1, 1997 attending accredited community colleges, colleges, trade schools or universities may apply for reimbursement of one hundred percent (1008) of the actual cost of tuition, books, fees or other student expenses for approved job-related courses. Maximum tuition reimbursement for sworn personnel shall be $885.00 per year for the term of this agreement. Maximum tuition reimbursement for non -sworn members shall be $2,213.00 per year for the term of this agreement. Sworn employees hired subsequent to September 1, 1997 shall have a maximum tuition reimbursement of $400 per fiscal year. Maximum tuition reimbursement for non -sworn employees hired after September 1, 1997 shall be $1000 per fiscal year. Reimbursement is contingent upon the successful completion of the course. Successful completion means a grade of "C" or better for undergraduate courses and a grade of "B" or better for graduate courses. All claims for tuition reimbursement require the approval of the Chief of Police and the Administrative Services Dircctor. Section 125 of the Internal Revenue Code authorizes an employee to reduce taxable income by City payment of allowable expenses such as child care and medical expenses. City shall, maintain a "reimbursable 23 0 0 William Avery & Associates If4083994423 CW915197 O4:04PM p25133 • account program" in accordance with the provisions of Section 125 of the Internal Revenue Code, pursuant to which an NBPEA member may request that medical, child care and other eligible expenses be paid or reimbursed by the City out of the employee's account, with the base salary of the employee reduced by the amount designated by the employee to be placed into that account. The City's obligation to establish a reimbursable account program is contingent upon the City incurring no cost or potential liability relative to the plan or its administration. City shall cooperate to the fullest extent of the law provided, however, City may require the plan to contain provisions that authorize the administrator to pay allowable expenses only upon submittal of a demand from the City. Any "reduction" in salary pursuant to this Section and/or the Section 125 Plan established by the City, shall not affect any other provision of this MOU. 24 City shall provide an Employee Assistance Program through a properly licensed provider. NBPEA members and their family members may access the Employee Assistance Program at no cost subject to provider guidelines. F. Scholastic Achievement pay. Sworn NBPEA members are entitled to additional compensation contingent upon scholastic achievement ("Scholastic Achievement Pay"). Sworn NBPEA members may apply for increases pursuant to this Section when eligible and scholastic achievement pay shall be included in the member's paycheck for the pay period immediately after approval by the Chief of Police. It is the responsibility of the NBPEA member to apply for Scholastic Achievement Pay. Approval of the member's application shall not be unreasonably withheld or delayed, and the member shall not be entitled to receive scholastic achievement pay prior to the date the application is approved even though the member may have been eligible prior to approval. Scholastic achievement pay is contingent upon years of service and the number of units and/or degrees received by the employee. The Plan consists of five levels which reflect multipliers of the base scholastic achievement pay of $46.00 per month. Qualifying units and/or degrees must be awarded by accredited community colleges, state colleges or universities. The following is a schedule of monthly . payments pursuant to the Scholastic Achievement Program: 24 William Avery & Associates 9'4083994423 V&9/5/97 04:05PM 026/33 Years of puiV.L:E.': Su units: Qy un1LS: Yu units: bA1bb:MA/MbJ_": 2 $48/mo. $48 $48 $48 $48 3 $48/mo. $96 $144 $192 $192 4 $48/mo. $96 $144 $192 $240 MGM135if The night shift differential pay for non—sworn personnel shall be $1.00 per hour between the hours of 6 p.m. and 6 a.m. Nothing contained herein is intended to abridge management's right to schedule work to meet the Police Department's needs of providing services in an efficient and safe manner. Management recognizes its obligations under the Meyers- Milias-Brown Act to meet and confer before making any substantive changes to work schedules that impact an employee's conditions of employment. Newport Beach Police Department currently has available a variety of work schedules including 5/8, 3/12, 9/81 and 4/10 schedules. Except in the case of emergency, prior to moving any employee or group of employees from one work schedule to another (for example from a 9/81 to a 3/12 schedule), the Department shall notify, and upon request, meet and confer with the Association in advance of any schedule change. If an emergency prohibits meeting and conferring prior to the schedule change, the Department shall meet and confer with the Association as soon as is reasonably possible after the schedule change. In the event of any non -substantive change to an employee's work schedule (changes in starting times, days off, etc), Management agrees to give as much advance notice of said change as possible and to give due regard to the needs of the employees to make adjustments to their personal schedules and commitments related to the change in work schedules. 25 William Avery&Associates It 408 399 4423 U9915197 04:06PM 027/33 3. Transfers Transferring an employee to an assignment with a different work schedule shall not be considered a change to modified work schedules and shall not obligate Management to meet and confer over said change. B. Seniority Nothing contained herein is intended to abridge management's right to schedule employees to work or deny leave requests that management feels will interfere with the efficient running of the Police Department or present a safety hazard to employees or the community. The Department shall continue its practice of allowing employees to sign up for vacations, shifts and days off by seniority. The Department shall have the right to deviate from seniority in shift preference selection as necessary to meet training needs, train probationers, separate employees, meet specialized qualification needs, and/or to correct experience imbalances in accordance with existing practice. In the event Management wishes to propose substantive changes to the existing practice of sign-up for vacations, shifts and days off by seniority, it shall give notice to the Association and meet and confer to seek mutually agreeable solutions and/or remedies. In the event that a mutually agreeable solution or remedy is not found, Management may aeviate Lrom the prior seniority criteria to the extent necessary to meet operational or safety needs. The provisions of this section shall apply when the City Manager determines that a reduction in the work force is warranted because of actual or anticipated reductions in revenue, reorganization of the work force, a reduction in municipal services, a reduction in the demand for service or other reasons unrelated to the performance of duties by any specific employee. Reductions in force are to be accomplished, to the extent feasible, on the basis of seniority within a particular Classification or Series and this Section should be interpreted accordingly. 1. Definitions. (a) "Layoffs" or "Laid off" shall mean the non—disciplinary termination of employment. (b) "Seniority" shall mean the time an employee has worked in a Classification or Series calculated from the date on which the employee was first 26 William Avery&Associates V 408 399 4423 1&9/5197 (94:07 PM [J 28/33 granted permanent status in their current Classification or any Classification within the Series, subject to the following: (i) Credit shall be given only for continuous service subsequent to the most recent appointment to permanent status in the Classification or Series; (ii) Seniority shall include time spent on industrial leave, military leave and leave of absence with pay, but shall not include time spent on any other authorized or unauthorized leave of absence. (c) "Classification" shall mean one or more full time Positions identical or similar in duties and embraced by a single job title authorized in the City budget and shall not include part—time, seasonal or temporary positions. Classifications within a Series shall be ranked according to pay (lowest ranking, lowest pay). (d) "Series" shall mean two or more Classifications within a Department which require the performance of similar duties with the higher ranking Classification(s) characterized by the need for less supervision by superiors, more difficult assignments, more supervisory responsibilities for subordinates. The City Manager shall determine those Classifications which constitute a Series. (e) "Bumping Rights", "Bumping" or "bump" shall mean the right of an employee, based upon seniority within a series, to displace a less senior employee in a lower Classification within the Series. No employee shall have the right to Bump into a Classification for which the employee does not possess the minimum qualifications such as specialized education, training or experience. 2. Procedures. In the event the City Manager determines to reduce the number of employees within a Classification, the following procedures are applicable: (a) Temporary and probationary employees within any Classification shall, in that order, be laid off before permanent employees. (b) Employees within a Classification shall be laid off 27 William Avery & Associates It 408 399 4423 M9/5197 04:08PM 029/33 in inverse order of seniority; (c) An employee subject to layoff in one Classification shall have the right to Bump a less senior employee in a lower ranking Classification within a Series. An employee who has Bumping Rights shall notify the Department Director within three (3) working days after notice of layoff of his/her intention to exercise Bumping Rights. (d) In the event two or more employees in the same Classification are subject to layoff and have the same seniority, the employees shall be laid off in inverse order of their position on the eligibility list or lists from which they were appointed. In the event at least one of the employees was not appointed from an eligibility list, the Department Director shall determine the employee(s) to be laid off. 3. Notice. Employees subject to lay—off shall be given at least thirty (30) days advance notice of the layoff or thirty (30) days pay in lieu of notice. In addition, employees laid off will be paid for all accumulated paid leave, holiday leave (if any), and accumulated sick leave to the extent permitted by the Personnel Resolution. � ' - � Il i ii ' I Permanent and probationary employees who are laid off shall be placed on a Department reemployment list in reverse order of layoff. The re—employment list shall remain in effect until exhausted by removal of all names on the list. In the event a vacant position occurs in the Classification which the employee occupied at the time of layoff, or a lower ranking Classification within a Series, the employee at the top of the Department re—employment list shall have the right to appointment to the position, provided, he or she reports to work within seven (7) days of written notice of appointment. Notice shall be deemed given when personally delivered to the employee or deposited in the U.S. Mail, certified, return receipt requested, and addressed to the employee at his or her last known address. Any employee shall have the right to refuse to be placed on the re—employment list or the right to remove his or her name from the re—employment list by sending written confirmation to the Personnel Director. 28 William Avery & Associates :408 399 4423 0 5. Severance Pay. Permanent employees who are laid date of lay—off, receive one week year of continuous service with Beach. 1. Definition. M0915197 ®4:09PM D 30133 off shall, as of the severance pay for each the City of Newport The term "grievance" means a dispute between NBPEA or any member and the City regarding the interpretation or application of rules or regulations governing the terms and conditions of employment, any provision of the Personnel Resolution, any provision of Resolution No. 71-73, or this MOU. 2. Guidelines. Any NBPEA member may file a grievance without fear of retaliation or any adverse impact on any term or condition of employment. (a) A grievance shall not be filed to establish new rules or regulations, change prevailing ordinances or resolutions, nor circumvent existing avenues of relief where appeal procedures have been prescribed. (b) An employee may be self—represented or represented by one other person. (c) An employee and any representative shall be given notice of the time and place of any grievance proceeding, the opportunity to be present at such proceedings, a copy of any written decision or communication to the employee concerning the proceedings, and any document directly relevant to the proceedings. (d) All parties shall engage in good faith efforts to promptly resolve the grievance in an amicable manner. The time limit specified may be extended upon mutual agreement expressed in writing. (e) The procedures in this MOU represent the sole and exclusive method of resolving grievances. 3. Procedure for NBPEA Members. Step 1 — The employee shall orally present the grievance 29 William Avery & Associates 9;4083994423 t$1915l97 04:10PM D3V33 to his or immediate supervisor within ten (10) working days after the member knew, or in the exercise of reasonable diligence should have known, the act or events upon which the grievance is based. The immediate supervisor shall conduct any appropriate investigation and meet with the employee no more than ten (10) working days after presentation of the grievance. The employee shall be given at least 24 hours notice of the meeting. The meeting shall be informal, and the employee may have a representative present. Any employee not satisfied with the decision of his or her immediate supervisor may proceed to Step 2. Step 2 — If an employee is dissatisfied with the decision of his or her immediate supervisor, the employee may proceed to Step 2 by submitting a written grievance to the supervising captain. Any employee dissatisfied with the decision of his or her immediate supervisor may submit a written grievance to the supervising Captain. The written grievance shall be filed within five (5) days following receipt of the immediate supervisor's decision. The written grievance must contain a complete statement of the matters at issue, the facts upon which the grievance is based, and the remedy requested by the employee. The supervising Captain shall meet with the employee and any representative in an effort to resolve the grievance. The meeting shall be scheduled no more than ten (10) days following receipt of the appeal unless deferred by the consent of both parties. The Captain shall provide the employee with a written decision on the appeal within ten (10) working days after the meeting. Step 3 — Appeal to Chief of Poli Any employee dissatisfied with the decision of the supervising captain may proceed to Step 3 by submitting a written appeal to the Chief of Police. The written appeal must be filed with the Chief of Police within five (5) days following receipt of the supervising captain's decision. The written appeal must contain a complete statement of the matters at issue, the facts upon which a grievance is based, and the remedy requested by the employee. The Chief of Police shall meet with the employee and any representative in an effort to resolve the grievance. The meeting shall be informal and the discussion should focus on the issues raised by the grievance. The meeting shall be scheduled no more than ten (10) days following receipt of the appeal unless deferred by the consent of both parties. The Chief of Police shall provide the employee with a written decision on the appeal within ten (10) working days after the meeting. 30 William Avery & Associates 19 408 399 4423 W915l97 04:10PM 632133 Step 4 — Appeal to City Manager_. In the event the employee is dissatisfied with the decision of the Chief of Police, the employee may proceed to Step 4 by submitting a written appeal of the decision to the City Manager. The written appeal must be filed within five (5) days following receipt of the Police Chief's decision. The written appeal shall contain a complete statement of the matters at issue, the facts upon which the grievance is based, the decisions of the supervising captain and Chief of Police, and the remedy requested by the employee. The City Manager shall meet with the employee and his or her representative in an effort to resolve the grievance and to receive any additional information the employee or department may have relative to the matter. The meeting shall be scheduled no more than ten (10) days following receipt of the appeal unless deferred by the consent of both parties. The City Manager shall provide the employee with a written decision within ten (10) working days after the meeting. The decision of the City Manager shall be final. HNNErer-TTIr-MW111147-TITME A general grievance affecting more than one NBPEA member may be filed by NBPEA on behalf of the affected employees with the Chief of Police. The grievance shall contain a complete statement of the matters at issue, the facts upon which the grievance is based, and the remedy requested by NBPEA. The Chief of Police shall meet with NBPEA representatives within ten (10) days following receipt of the grievance and provide a written decision on the grievance within ten (10) working days after the meeting. In the event NBPEA is dissatisfied with the decision of the Chief of Police, it may appeal to the City Manager by following the procedures outlined in Step 4 of the procedure applicable to employees. In the event NBPEA is dissatisfied with the decision of the City Manager, it may appeal the decision to the Civil Service Board by filing a written notice of appeal within fifteen (15) days after receipt of the decision. 1. The City and Association agree to reopen negotiations on the issue of bilingual pay by September 1, 1997. Subject to justification to and approval by the City Council, the intent of the parties is to develop a bilingual pay program for implementation by January 1, 1998 (paying at least the average of Orange County Polices agencies - $75.00). 31 0 0 0 9 0 William Avery & Associates Ir4083994423 Q19/5197 04:11 PM D33/33 0 2. Disability Insurance The City and Association agree to participate in a City- wide committee to restructure the existing disability insurance -leave program during the term of this agreement. Executed this day of 1997: NEWPORT BEACH POLICE EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION By: Steve Martinez By: John Adams CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH By: Jan Debay Mayor ATTEST: By: LaVonne Harkless City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: Robert H. Burnham, City Attorney 32 11 EXHIBIT A NEWPORT BEACH POLICE EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION , REPRESENTED CLASSIFICATIONS Police Officer Senior Dispatcher Dispatcher Senior Custody Officer Custody Officer Computer Support Manager Civilian Supervisor Senior Animal Control Officer Animal Control Officer Senior Community Services Officer Community Services Officer Photo ID Technician Station Officer Range Master Electronic Specialist Fiscal Services Manager Crime Scene Investigator Computer Technician Computer Applications Coordinator Senior Crime Analyst Crime Prevention Specialist Video Technician 0 Pea31597 8:48 AM 9/5/97 . EXHIBIT B POLICE MATRIX (March 15, 1997) - TO BE USED FOR PEA MEMBERS New Position Salary Pers Health Total Percentage Hourly Rate safety 19.7460% Non -Safety 11.7350% COMPUTER TECH 1 $3,161 $371 $400 $3,932 65.91% 2137 2204 2 $3,319 $389 $400 $4,109 68.88% 3 $3,486 $409 $400 $4,295 72.00% 4 $3,646 $428 $400 $4,474 75.00% 5 $3,859 $453 $400 $4,712 79.00% 6 $4,019 $472 $400 $4,891 82.00% 7 $4,233 $497 $400 $5,130 86.00% 8 $4,447 $522 $400 $5,369 90.00% CPTR APPS CORD 1 $4,107 $482 $400 $4,989 83.63% 2 $4,312 $506 $400 $5,218 87.480/6 3 $4,528 $531 $400 $5,459 91.520/6 4 $4,754 $558 $400 $5,712 95.76% 5 $4,992 $586 $400 $5,978 100.22% 6 $5,242 $615 $400 $6,257 104.900/6 7 $5,504 $646 $400 $6,550 109.800/0 8 $5,779 $678 $400 $6,857 114.95°/6 SR CRIME ANALYST 1 $3,018 $354 $400 $3,772 63.24°/6 2 $3,168 $372 $400 $3,940 66.06% 3 $3,328 $391 $400 $4,118 69.040/6 4 $3,492 $410 $400 $4,302 72.12°% 5 $3,667 $430 $400 $4,497 75.39°% 6 $3,849 $452 $400 $4,701 78.81°% 7 $4,042 $474 $400 $4,916 82.41% 8 $4,243 $498 $400 $5,141 86.19% CRIME PREV SPEC 1 $2,861 $336 $400 $3,597 60.30% 2 $3,004 $353 $400 $3,757 62.98°% 3 $3,154 $370 $400 $3,924 65.78°% 4 $3,312 $389 $400 $4,101 68.75°% 5 $3,478 $408 $400 $4,286 71.86% 6 $3,652 $429 $400 $4,481 75.12% 7 $3,835 $450 $400 $4,685 78.54°% 8 $4,027 $473 $400 $4,900 82.15% VIDEO TECHNICIAN 1 $3,373 $396 $400 $4,169 69.89% 2 $3,542 $416 $400 $4,358 73.06°A 3 $3,719 $436 $400 $4,555 76.36% 4 $3,905 $458 $400 $4,763 79.85% 5 $4,100 $481 $400 $4,981 83.50°A 6 $4,305 $505 $400 $5,210 87.35% 7 $4,520 $530 $400 $5,450 91.37% 8 $4,746 $557 $400 $5,703 95.60°A 18.23654 19.14808 20.11154 21.03462 22.26346 23.18654 24.42115 25.65577 23.69423 24.87692 26.12308 27.42692 28:80000 30.24231 31.75385 33.34038 17.41154 18.27692 19.20000 20.14615 21.15577 22.20577 23.31923 24.47885 16.50577 17.33077 18.19615 19.10769 20.06538 21.06923 22.12500 23.23269 19.45962 20.43462 21.45577 22.52885 23.65385 24.83664 26.07692 27.38077 Pea31597 8-.48AM 915197 • • EXHIBIT B POLICE MATRIX (March 15, 1997) - TO BE USED FOR PEA MEMBERS New Position Salary Pers Health Total Percentage Hourly Rat Safety 19.7460% Non -Safety 11.7350% Police Officer 1 $3,304 $652 $400 $4,356 71.1 2030 2015 2 $3,470 $685 $400 $4,555 74.6 3 $3,643 $719 $400 $4,762 78.4 4 $3,824 $755 $400 $4,979 82.3 5 $4,015 $793 $400 $5,208 86.4 6 $4,215 $832 $400 $5,447 90.7 7 $4,426 $874 $400 $5,700 95.2 8 $4,647 $918 $400 $5,965 100.0 9 S4,879 $963 $400 $6,242 105.0 10 S5,112 $1,009 $400 $6,521 110.0 11 $5,228 $1,032 $400 $6,660 112.5 12 $5,344 $1,055 $400 $6,799 115.0 Sz'rge t 1 $4,460 $881 $400 $5,741 64.44% ° 2 $4,683 $925 $400 $4,016 100.77% 3 $4,917 $971 $400 $6,288 105.81% 4 $ $10 $400 $6,582 111.11% 5 $5,42 $1, $400 $6,891 116.66% 6 692 $1,124 $400 $7,216 122.49% 7 $5,977 $1,180 $400 1 128.61% 8 $6,279 $1,240 $400 $7,919 13% Lie 1 $5,244 $1,035 $400 $6,679 64.44% ° 2 $5,506 $1,087 $400 $4,016 118.48% 3 5 781 $1,142 $400 $7,323 124.40% 4 $6,0 $1 $400 $7,669 130.62% 5 $6,39 $1, $400 $8,057 137.60% 6 6,693 $1,322 $400 $8,415 144.02% 7 57,027 $1,388 $400 1 151.22% 8 $7,379 $1,457 $400 $9,236 ° Cap 1 $6,161 $1,217 $398 $7,776 64.44% /° 2 $6,469 $1,277 $399 $4,016 139.21% 3 793 $1,341 $400 $8,534 146.17% 4 $7,13 1 $400 $8,940 153.48% 5 $7,48 $1, $400 $9,368 161.16% 6 1864 $1,553 $400 $9,817 169.22% 7 $8,257 $1,630 $400 1 177.68% 8 $8,669 S1,712 $400 $10,781 ° SR DISPATCHER 1 $3,082 $362 $400 $3,844 64.44% 2210 2200 2 $3,236 $380 $400 $4,016 67.33% 3 $3,397 $399 $400 $4,196 70.35% 4 $3,566 $418 $400 $4,385 73.51% 5 $3,743 $439 $400 $4,582 76.82% 6 $3,928 $461 $400 $4,789 80.29% 7 $4,122 $484 $400 $5,006 83.93% 8 $4,327 $508 $400 $5,235 7P/.Jl 19.06154 20.01923 21.01731 22.06154 23.16346 24.31731 25.53462 26.80962 28.14808 29.49231 30.16154 30.83077 25.73077 27.01731 28.36731 29.78654 31.27500 32.83846 34.48269 36.22500- 30.25385 31.76538 33.35192 35.01923 36.88846 38.61346 40.54038 42.57115 35.54423 37.32115 39.19038 41.14615 43.20577 45.36923 47.63654 50.01346 17.78077 18.66923 19.59808 20.57308 21.59423 22.66154 23.7807 24.96346 0 . Pea31597 8:48 AM 815187 EXHIBIT B POLICE MATRIX (March 15, 1997) - TO BE USED FOR PEA MEMBERS New Position Sala Pers Health Total Percentage Hourly Rate Safety 19.7460% Non -Safety 11.7350% DISPATCHER 1 $2,667 $313 $400 $3,380 56.66% 2200 2170 2 $2,800 $329 $400 $3,529 59.16% 3 $2,941 $345 $400 $3,686 61.80% 4 $3,085 $362 $400 $3,847 64.50% 5 $3,238 $380 $400 $4,018 67.36% 6 $3,397 $399 $400 $4,196 70.36% 7 $3,566 $418 $400 $4,385 73.51% 8 $3,743 $439 $400 $4,582 76.82% SR CUSTODY 1 $3,038 $357 $400 $3,795 63.62% 2150 2195 2 $3,191 $374 $400 $3,966 66.48% 3 $3,351 $393 $400 $4,144 69.47% 4 $3,516 $413 $400 $4,329 72.57% 5 $3,690 $433 $400 $4,523 75.82% 6 $3,871 $454 $400 $4,725 79.22% 7 $4,064 $477 $400 $4,941 82.84% 8 $4,265 $500 $400 $5,166 86.61% CUSTODY 1 $2,629 $309 $400 $3,337 55.95% 2140 2155 2 $2,760 $324 $400 $3,484 58.41% 3 $2,899 $340 $400 $3,639 61.01% 4 $3,042 $357 $400 $3,799 63.69% 5 $3,191 $374 $400 $3,966 66.49% 6 $3,351 $393 $400 $4,144 69.47% 7 $3,516 $413 $400 $4,329 72.57% 8 $3,691 $433 $400 $4,524 75.84% 2225 2 $4,952 $581 $400 $5,933 3 $5,201 $610 $400 $6,211 1 4 $5,460 $641 $400 $6,501 1 5 $5,731 $673 $400 $6,804 1 6 $6,016 $706 $400 $7,122 1 7 $6,313 $741 $400 $7,454 1 8 $6.628 $778 $400 $7.806 1 80 2215 2 $3,682 $432 $400 $4,514 75. 3 $3,866 $454 $400 $4,720 79. 4 $4,058 $476 $400 $4,934 82. 5 $4,259 $500 $400 $5,159 86. 6 $4,470 $525 $400 $5,394 90. 7 $4,691 $550 $400 $5,642 94. 8 $4.923 $578 $400 $5.901 98. 15.38654 16.15385 16.96731 17.79808 18.68077 19.59808 20.57308 21.59423 17.52692 18.40962 19.33269 20.28462 21.28846 22.33269 23.44615 24.60577 15.16731 15.92308 16.72500 17.55000 18.40962 19.33269 20.28462 21.29423 27.21346 28.56923 30.00577 31.50000 33.06346 34.70769 36.42115 38.23846 20.23269 21.24231 22.30385 23.41154 24.57115 25.78846 27.06346 28.40192 Pea31597 8:48 AM 9/5/97 . POLICE MATRIX (March 15, 9997) - TO BE USED FOR PEA MEMBERS New Position Salary Pers Health Total Percentage Safety 19.7460% Non -Safety 11.7350% EXHIBIT B SR ACO 1 $3,021 $355 $400 $3,776 63.30% 2120 2190 2 $3,173 $372 $400 $3,945 66.14% 3 $3,331 $391 $400 $4,122 69.10% 4 $3,496 $410 $400 $4,306 72.18% 5 $3,669 $431 $400 $4,499 75.42% 6 $3,850 $452 $400 $4,702 78.83°% 7 $4,041 $474 $400 $4,915 82.40% 11 8 $4,241 $498 $400 $5,139 86.1 F/ ACO 1 $2,614 $307 $400 $3,321 55.67% 2110 2150 2 $2,744 $322 $400 $3,466 58.11% 3 $2,882 $338 $400 $3,620 60.691/6 4 $3,024 $355 $400 $3,779 63.35°% 5 $3,174 $372 $400 $3,946 66.16% 6 $3,331 $391 $400 $4,122 69.10% 7 $3,496 $410 $400 $4,306 72.18% 8 $3,669 $431 $400 $4,499 74.42°% SR CSO 1 $2,577 $302 $400 $3,279 64.97% 2195 2140 2 $2,758 $324 $400 $3,482 58.37°% 3 $2,841 $333 $400 $3,574 59.92% 4 $2,979 $350 $400 $3,729 62.52°% 5 $3,128 $367 $400 $3,895 65.29°% 6 $3,283 $385 $400 $4,068 68.19°% 7 $3,444 $404 $400 $4,248 71.22% 11 8 $3,615 $424 $400 $4,439 74.42°% CSO 1 $2,025 $238 $400 $2,663 44.65% 2190 2105 2 $2,127 $250 $400 $2,777 46.55°% 3 $2,233 $262 $400 $2,895 48.54°% 4 $2,344 $275 $400 $3,019 50.61°% 5 $2,459 $289 $400 $3,148 52.77% 6 $2,579 $303 $400 $3,282 55.02°% 7 $2,708 $318 $400 $3,426 57.43°% 8 $2,841 $333 $400 $3,574 59.92% 9 $2,981 $350 $400 $3,731 62.54°% 10 $3,128 $367 $400 $3,895 2185 2 $3,048 $358 $400 $3,806 3 $3,200 $376 $400 $3,976 4 $3,361 $394 $400 $4,155 5 $3,526 $414 $400 $4,340 6 $3,701 $434 $400 $4,535 7 $3,884 $456 $400 $4,740 8 $4,077 $478 $400 $4,955 Hourly Rate 17.42885 18.30577 19.21731 20.16923 21.16731 22.21154 23.31346 24.46731 15.08077 15.83077 16.62692 17.44615 18.31154 19.21731 20.16923 21.16731 14.86731 15.91154 16.39038 17.18654 18.04615 18.94038 19.86923 20.85577 11.68269 12.27115 12.88269 13.52308 14.18654 14.87885 15.62308 16.39038 17.19808 18.04615 16.74231 17.58462 18.46154 19.39038 20.34231 21.35192 22.40769 23.521150 0 0 ,Pea31597 8:48 AM 915197 . EXHIBIT B POLICE MATRIX (March 15, 1997) - TO BE USED FOR PEA MEMBERS New Position Salary Pers Health Total Percentage Hourly Rate Safety 19.7460% Non -Safety 11.7350% STA OFCR 1 $2,614 $307 $400 $3,321 55.67% 2300 2150 2 $2,744 $322 $400 $3,466 58.11% 3 $2,882 $338 $400 $3,620 60.69% 4 $3,024 $355 $400 $3,779 63.35% 5 $3,174 $372 $400 $3,946 66.16% 6 $3,331 $391 $400 $4,122 69.10% 7 $3,496 $410 $400 $4,306 72.18% 8 $3,669 $431 $400 $4,499 75.42% RANGE MSTR 1 $2,613 $307 $400 $3,320 55.65% 2270 2145 2 $2,743 $322 $400 $3,465 68.09% 3 $2,880 $338 $400 $3,618 60.66% 4 $3,022 $355 $400 $3,777 63.32% 5 $3,171 $372 $400 $3,943 66.11% 6 $3,328 $391 $400 $4,118 69.04% 7 $3,493 $410 $400 $4,303 72.13% 8 $3,665 $430 $400 $4,495 75.36% ELECTRONIC SPEC 1 $3,377 $396 $400 $4,173 69.950/0 2160 2205 2 $3,645 $416 $400 $4,361 73.11% 3 $3,719 $436 $400 $4,555 76.36% 4 $3,903 $458 $400 $4,761 79.81% 5 $4,096 $481 $400 $4,977 83.43% 6 $4,299 $504 $400 $5,204 87.24% 7 $4,512 $529 $400 $5,442 91.23% 8 $41736 $556 $400 $5,692 95.42% FISCAL SVC MGR 1 $3,937 $462 $400 $4,799 80.46% 2170 2203 2 $4,135 $485 $400 $5,020 84.15% 3 $4,342 $510 $400 $5,251 88.03% 4 $4,576 $537 $400 $5,513 92.43% 6 $4,823 $566 $400 $5,789 97.06% 6 $5,082 $596 $400 $6,078 101.900/0 7 $5,364 $628 $400 $6,382 106.99% 8 $5,639 $662 $400 $6,701 112.34% CRIME SCENE INV 1 $2,604 $306 $400 $3,310 55.49% 2132 2143 2 $2,735 $321 $400 $3,466 67.93% 3 $2,871 $337 $400 $3,608 60.48% 4 $3,012 $353 $400 $3,766 63.140/6 5 $3,163 $371 $400 $3,934 65.95°h 6 $3,320 $390 $400 $4,110 68.90% 7 $3,485 $409 $400 $4,294 71.98% 8 $3,660 $430 $400 $4,489 75.250/6 15.08077 15.83077 16.62692 17.44615 18.31154 19.21731 20.16923 21.16731 15.07500 15.82500 16.61538 17.43462 18.29423 19.20000 20.15192 21.14423 19.48269 20.45192 21.45577 22.51731 23.63077 24.80192 26.03077 27.32308 22.71346 23.85577 25.05000 26.40000 27.82500 29.31923 30.88846 32.53269 15.02308 15.77885 16.56346 17.37692 18.24808 19.16385 20.10677 21.11538 0 0 SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING • This Supplemental Memorandum of Understanding (SMOU) between the City of Newport Beach (City) and the Newport Beach Police Employees Association (NBPEA) is dated the day of 1997, for purposes of identification and is based on the following: A. City and NBPEA have entered into a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) regarding matters within the scope of representation and which is to be executed contemporaneously with this SMOU. B. The term of the MOU expires December 31, 1998 and this SMOU implements elements of the agreement of the Parties which are to take effect on or after July 1, 1998. C. This SMOU and the MOU collectively achieve the objectives of the Parties as described in the Recitals to the MOU. D. The SMOU is intended, among other things, to establish general guidelines for meeting and conferring regarding matters within the scope of representation while providing for periodic and mandatory adjustments necessary to ensure that Modified Total Compensation for NBPEA members is, on specified dates during the term, at least equal to the average of the Modified Total Compensation paid to the five (5) Benchmark Positions with the highest Modified Total Compensation. NOW THEREFORE, THE PARTIES AGREE AS FOLLOWS: 1. Definitions For purposes of this SMOU, the terms Total Compensation, Benchmark Position, League Survey and Criteria Salary shall be defined/calculated as specified in the MOU. 2. Term/Effective Date The term of this SMOU shall commence on July 1, 1998, and expire on July 1, 2001. This SMOU shall be effective: (a) when signed by authorized representatives of the Parties; and (b) upon execution of the SMOU by authorized representatives of the Parties. 3. General Criteria for Negotiations The Parties shall, commencing in July of 1998, and July of 1999, and July 2000, if required due to the expiration of an MOU approved subsequent to the current MOU, meet and confer on all matters within the scope of representation with the intent to reach agreement on an MOU to be effective the first pay period the following January. The Parties shall consider in good faith all relevant information and data presented to each other during the meeting and conferring. 4. Leave Accrual NBPEA members shall have the option, beginning with any negotiations regarding salary which occur on or after October, 1998, to elect to increase their salary by .4% or .8% by agreeing to reduce their annual flex or vacation leave accrual by one (1) or two (2) days respectively. The option to exchange leave accrual for salary shall not limit or restrict the right of NBPEA to meet and confer regarding leave accrual rates and/or salaries or modify City's obligation to modify salaries if otherwise required by this SMOU or other agreement of the Parties. 5. Supplemental Adjustments Effective the first pay period in July, 1998, 1999, 2000, and 2001, the City shall, if necessary, increase Modified Total Compensation (Total Compensation less employer retirement contributions but including employer "pickup" or payment of employee retirement contributions) paid to NBPEA members to a level at least equal to .8% below the average Modified Total Compensation paid to the five (5) Benchmark Positions with the highest Modified Total Compensation. (If the Association exercises its option to increase salaries pursuant to Section 4 above; the adjustment will be to .4% below the average, or to the average, respectively.) The comparison of Modified Total Compensation shall be based on the League Survey published in the proceeding January, subject to verification of accuracy by the City and/or NBPEA with the results of verification to be shared by the Parties. Any dispute among the parties as to the actual total compensation paid in any benchmark position in another law enforcement agency within the County of Orange shall be resolved by reference to the governing collective bargaining agreement and/or enactment of the applicable public agency. 6. Adjustment Procedures Once the appropriate increase in Modified Total Compensation has been agreed to (subsequent to meet and confer) or calculated (in the case of increases in the first pay period in July that may be necessary to comply with Section 4), City shall calculate the corresponding increase in the Criteria Salary for the Benchmark Position in Newport Beach necessary to achieve the appropriate level of Modified Total Compensation and increase salaries for all classifications represented by NBPEA in accordance with the revised multipliers in the Matrix. 0 ATTEST: LE Executed this day of 1997: NEWPORT BEACH POLICE EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION Un LE Steve Martinez John Adams CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH wl Jan Debay Mayor LaVonne Harkless, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: Robert H. Burnham, City Attorney 0 0 0