HomeMy WebLinkAboutXC2022-1994 - Alternative Material & Methods�6QOaa -- Iggq
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
BUILDING DIVISION
100 Civic Center Drive I P.O. Box 1768 1 Newport Beach, CA 92658
www.newportbeachca.gov 1 (949) 644-3200
DOCUMENTATION OF UNREASONABLE HARDSHIP — $357.00
FINDING OF UNREASONABLE HARDSHIP FOR PROJECTS UNDER
$186,172* CBC 11B-202.4 — EXCEPTION: 8 (FILL OUT PAGES 1 & 2)
❑ FINDING OF UNREASONABLE HARDSHIP FOR PROJECTS ;OVER
$186,172* CBC 11B-202.4 — EXCEPTION. 8 (FILL OUT PAGES 1 & 2)
MUST BE ACCOMPANIED WITH RATIFICATION APPLICATION **
❑ FINDING OF TECHNICAL INFEASIBILITY FOR PROJECTS PER
CBC 11B-202.3 - EXCEPTION: 2 (FILL OUT PAGES1, 2 & 3)
A. JOB ADDRESS: J(( b Z N W Pa RT gLV D ,
SUITE NO.
B. PROPERTY OWNER. TOM STANSP�UCZ�
Address: J bb 4LI) t 1E_W f bZr pjLV D City OEW FIoIZT
State: CA Zip: ")21n l03 Phone No. 944) tp42. (272.
CASE NO.:
H 2O22-
PROJECT INFORMATION:
P/C. #: 1 C?Crl.-2 — W 9 v
Permit#:
Use: re6rrA( L
Stories:
Verified by:
Receipt #: REC-003g0q
JE" DISTRIBUTION:
W Owner
C. APPLICANT: LAUKeL- hYEgg/ jTAMAy'+5 `� 5TA'tA1?5 2f petitioner
Position/Relationship: AC-tWT' ❑ P/CEng
Address:
FAI Rv I E. W AJE City H [ A�A(6-1� ❑ Inspector
State: CA Zip °} 103 D Phone No.: 213 32-1 930e) ❑ Other
Email' LAUREL _h eP-5>& YAHOO. Cott
An unreasonable hardship exists where the cost of providing an accessible entrance, path of travel, sanitary
facilities, public phones, drinking fountains, etc. exceeds 20% of the cost of project without these features.
The actual work of the project must comply with current code and an additional amount equal to at least 20%
of the cost of the project must be spent to improve required accessibility features that are not in compliance
with current code.
In choosing which accessible elements to provide, priority should be given to those elements that will provide
the greatest access, in the following order: 1) An accessible primary entrance; 2) An accessible route to the
altered area; 3) At least one accessible restroom for each sex; 4) Accessible public telephones (when
provided); 5) Accessible drinking fountains (when provided); 6) When possible, additional accessible
elements such as additional parking, storage and alarms.
To request an unreasonable hardship, complete the attached worksheet, and prepare a site and floor
plan of the existing and proposed accessibility improvements. This information must be submitted to
the Building Division in duplicate, prior to processing a permit application. One copy of the approval or denial
will be returned to the applicant.
For projects exceeding the valuation threshold of $186,172, a hardship approval can only be obtained
through a ratification application and hardship application.
* The $186,172 is based on $50,000 in 1981 dollars as of January 1, 2022.
"Ratification form can be obtained at. https://www.newi)ortbeachca.clovlratificationform
Forms\Hardship 06/08/2022
Address: _4 � (� L-b 1J E=W pp R T LJ b P/C #:
## Roof REPAIR/
1. Total Cost of Construction contemplated (not including disabled access work) $ 24 �5( W-W ELU-MICAL
Identify the accessibility features, which will NOT be brought into compliance if the request is granted.
Provide an estimate of the cost of compliance for each item.
60
❑ Path of travel to entrance (ramps, walks) ............................................ $ 32, (PW
❑ Path of travel to s4w;e4 wea(.a)........................................ $ 24, 7FA 01
❑ Sanitary facilities (restrooms)................................................................. $ 2$, 49 Z'°
❑ Parking.................................................................................................... $ 3 41 too o°
❑ Drinking fountain(s)................................................................................ $
❑ Accessible phone(s)............................................................................... $
❑ Accessible signage................................................................................. $ 1 vIODD°
❑ Other....................................................................................................... $
Total cost of providing compliance:..... $ 121_t f)5(pq
Identify the accessibility features and equivalent facilities, which will be provided or brought into
compliance as required by Code. Provide an estimate of the cost of each item.
a. RERACEnEIT aF (F) i;-ARACjE P 095 W JTi NEW PAI t2. DF $ 5 t
b. A C&E531 g 1, E D OD (ZS $
C. $
d. $
e. $
f. $
Total: $ 51 50"
2. Technically infeasibility — if applicable complete Page 3 of this application
3. Fill out this section if the path of travel from the disabled parking spaces to the tenant space
is not accessible. List projects (tenant improvements, additions, remodels, etc.) performed within
previous three years where no disabled access improvement was performed in conjunction with the
project. State description, date, and cost.
vi,5 l5 vE wtL Poo ECG Wtv(N -rR 6, IA T 3 iEAgS, PATH of TRmEL FRoh 6o .
PARYK tJ 6 -M W) M AIN EI`1Mv2 pE5 5 N0T AC.CE 610L.E. PAR4e-1 M61 15 DU A SLDP E
Aa trNTVANCEP) AAVE STEIRS. WE P{ P05O , TD ADD A 13e-W NR-0F
ACrESSIPjLE Da7RS AT P{&R W► F-i2 WORK WAS 9DNE,-
The applicant understands that although the City may approve this request of unreasonable hardship
irf and the proposed equivalent access, the City reserves the right to require additional access
compliance upon receiving a complaint of inadequate access at this location.
(A licants Nam or Autuonzer epresentative) (Date)
(Aprfiz,anis Signa e) (Date
_ --EOR CITYdJSF-ONLY
,Approved ❑ Denied By: zr?"LZ
(Chef B Wing Otficia/J _ (Date)
Forms\Hardship 06/08/2022 2
103rOid
100-`d
3 VOS
31VO
V1
H
m
eo
D
z
y
i
P
�,
i hNrlavil-
tuaoa-l(iaLd IIpNJ dp4a ��f J I�tl111�OJd;1'i
E hNrn�dva
r
G
y
I
I
��z
od _2 CVVI'7dv+O�—nor/
'S3XO1V31 A11113ISSKOV 3AONd]NI 01 O3IVMRON SV - eOM
30V3NV IV SNOOO SS3JJV L14V17dWOJ VOVd0 MVd M1 HAM 1N31N3JV".ONV NOW 9'IA1S
3DVNV O 9MISIX3 40 "IVAONHWONIO"IIf13 NV3X 1V 13NVd 1VOIX10313 A13N ONV Sulvd3N 30011
-Y olt d0 UODS
I S31XO1S 30 N33lNINl
9t6I 1'11f19 HV3A
10HS S3nOld.lv`V/7V'ION94VlNOJ 3SfllAJNVdnJJO '1VS3N3033Id30—OOIDNIf10Z
'd'S EZZ'5:iNod3N 33JHVd HJV39,Lwo A%3N dO AID N3d 39V10Od 3XVf1bS.LO1
51d18 )119 LZ N1 N NOI1MOS30'1V031
LZ HVd SM A1MOJ E8Z'9Z6 �H33NnN'17J OSS355V XVl
ONVA3'InOe 1NOdM3N O']O 99t:SS3NOOV
SdOa1LNv AHn3SNV15 WOLAHn3SNViS woi :H3NA10
-d0es_53.gtl.Y_
-sS �ai'� xyw �21r„ 7�nY711 „do
no011a'?v10 r/19d015 :Plvw $
Jwlil\hJ(I_'YJ Im 10 LdVli;-,
"NTJA >tfln my"
I'Sti fJa?iy�}?% 2i-'
l
S�lYh pal a/ I'-
515Nd
U
» W yeyaxarela rqX
pe Ap peleoroaa9ps]'aefilueNsegex MNNea4op We,aNeeNna eie awmowplww 911
fiwea,arye vle0namp aylp VWV+ Vaulgl,{u!NW mlleys xneVna e¢aVlul aµlellaquan»IelwzlrW d
W�➢"=Ira apP4xM aNm»eym ylrswoe anrylleya AVearyen W,rrsvawpurro,BnwaBNlu9
gylp(ww pSZlvayaup{w,ypnwveMv aleB W=Pop Bu!dymg'aa>eYnv aWbpuv,poO plL ppY611
me Wepno ���w :a:°°aa
pryla,pxa>um,eNu neaOuagPw qq rrlq Pw=, plpvl^W, aan, "aV'ro'11olArytl , yl
w,waewavan spucuas:wmppa0wy,n,als3 I
cal
ve ay lleW alaB,o,xpuwaa G>rlµ0,o fiuws,vf nl»,ol ml»,a Buluaepeleb Wa,oppfi[a0P644
„0.,1..+ti-3,vas �[`<nd '�lIG_SNoI1raNUJ I
wPee�J.Sg7!
�3Ha1ra �
00
T
khlpd
'a7\RL41C
ahv dais/�dolrc=)atn!iex"I '
-rIVM YNJ
\„ 3�c1-vL*ISF�^-ZLBis€3''>JtitN)
x NW wpyaleea^ pwepam+.a W Ireya woaw,eyfippe,aars uprvx^e=aevepm
a PaMi 4N a Vnu��awee wawaeww I n unWpw
1 1 L y v e^a W m aep'Inpcall sa. Ne !rya e
P+aropP w aw aea N 'em'x.uw!an^a xgWav +aeaaway {Bp plzrao-eu
un2uuiewl VG!V wwZ92,1 V"pl!>N aVW V� sAewamq�eWWpMI!p'xPl Vxro�ewWuspNVu,N Wxrcd
rLL'vp eyvugy 5'Z'ieP9/{
ww Z51 aVa•,!B WY 9
sxap,WaYamIp�MW
ryueyele
rxlww zoo:»Wn pw .
w>ap!VPma.e T
wppwae,e mlq Wa w.^IWlwwsai::w�mepw x
"papa wttrYl IpPo ',
1 OIB) W
.(uw,B1111 sarµ101
tl
p5,rw d
1 pBI Y+�Z
(ww YZ511 s>V^u109
tl
MY a
1 6551 R
,(ww91111 saV>uIIY
nd
B' Bw y
1 61 9Z�Iwdp29115ww
BBird
M V
I 1
Iww6,ZllxaV'=u B1
arrtl
3
x(ww ZSYlvalru el
I IwwrasllxWrvl OP
vrd
myuo,a�
Aum
'�M1O0ia
ams>uwp,prs]
•olnanp y>eo,aer
AvvpeO pl lal etl
alpu d
a a 6u,annaue I] wnwIIW u
I IV
av paG
B) L
»e ue uop OU Gu enm esaaunea fiu auraue vZPoY911 aIVe1 Ipp p I Va51 WI I] V W4"'
{'Pt'rorel� ewel vrw G+{nNumanue,eer
6vyamamwaeayl!eya aeee pue eeM 6u!EunS' 6pueuwp BulBUImS 4'YTIOP6/I
,am WeAwmpaW lowpun irvo =LI
p A/.uw peya agxBpue ump,e aeauereap0wu.v.'lauewunww!ry'aauee ezl'aVBUVauIPo� W pZMP91t
�IuwwZGll vx7+. pwa>•a,u, ava puc,B»,aym:wl=av a,walwwzLo2lxayw o¢ We Iwwwel
"pZ uaa.WW NpM6ulu�ereq^aweu �p=pyi- wOromGVs.=Y aN anyelwwp9Blsaq'I
aL=aw,a.nyp,+Bw"w alxn awm,uN`ipwprlxpe°,;a"OpuW:opwel'w"w=w lww IBlac
=a pae=war.eouw ¢ ww me I o'saa,bp ae=ap
pp wP pua xwpewloex,eNuaaraeVparnxeaw»PeyxeimphnBuyv ylw.Mevwplo ebuurdo
N'ieal] ",/iwlu!w (ww LlB) saVZIZL pywM,eare aplwGBryssOpuaep,mp NPI,AIeal] tZ'YWpll
' 'VL'Mtall We [ L'PoPall ew�WS NWAIdwm IlWs
xaas IpW yuru.wmpl=xaaea wme •alp.w Waq lr+a¢o ppe wpppmaltyy^^pa'epPeu
z roPell pW»s wme!ewmuaee avea.eawmrol Wpmlw.
saleGle^yew We Ger.wap Wes,mplenueyl"sale0lenuewpl,e'sAwoop'sloop lenueWZPOp911
camas aWNewo+eexauw q¢azewer,e of Bare rev efiwa'va..rmp amp lwaoam lormi
va,ebpue sRem,00p amp
rpren
VI{«AWwm Ye,p Wewgs se,Qs We w,I aIVWaW eVsxmeynx l,—, Wx,mW ,eaaup l2'D B44
I,aa»Y •e,W UWxmgm Widen
,c YCR xxmaW 4L1 ueVlua»la W,wlleyxxmeyn e&Pi!MlvnNa]m' 6up=rvapl aaa15 Z.LpY911
20[914'aPsa541W Nuwm Ileys sweyne pum0pm,l -»eyns punwB,o,00b S[OP911
[pP9lleq,sa9 NMAleuw lleVsaNe,gFssaxa uelo ueu¢ae leaa+eWs6uryeM'lenua]{'LOP911
x»eons BuWleMmP911
cars plo
�xaryx pawya�ii pub. Lrva'vuw'e, p' �jjeWwe,�Me�.vmpuew,aawVa pa'WOIS WuwyepV e"avaaeµx
i VOware slug u!n .Al aNlo ,owuawlo,s su ieyvxapm, awxxmtl gyauetlwp]Z'ZOP611
IiOi Yi A911f 3A1 LJ3.dJ3.LN34V99,IdIlS 300J DK1a19111� VINOIOd19tlJ b10Z
S31nOH 3931SS3JJV t NOISIAIU :S1dH3JX3 9000 gjyw7 V01'1ddV