HomeMy WebLinkAbout19 - Intent to Override Finding of Inconsistency for Housing Element Implementation, Noise-Related Amendments (PA2022-0201) - CorrespondenceReceived After Agenda Printed
September 12, 2023
Agenda Item No. 19
From: Jim Auster <jimauster@hotmail.com>
Sent: September 10, 2023 9:58 AM
To: Neil Treffers <ntreffers@ptats.com>; Dept - City Council<CityCouncil@newportbeachca.gov>
Cc: M. Smith <mws.aspenroyal@gmail.com>; Linda Giedt <Iclemensgiedt@gmail.com>; Brian Barson
<brianbarson@gmail.com>; Caroline Dobbins <carolinedobbins@icloud.com>;
smeadows2412@gmail.com; josh@liquidgraphics.ty; schleige@yahoo.com;
kurt_kawczynski@yahoo.com; cityroofing1357@gmail.com; bspackard@gmail.com;
kh@sureboard.com; crncable@gmail.com; cope2003@sbcgloba1.net; bjsihilling@gmail.com;
lowerynewport@yahoo.com; 2jeffroberts@gmail.com; nbvineyards@gmail.com;
buckjohns@aol.com; buckjohns@inlandenergy.com; carreramullinax@gmail.com;
cylekspr@gmail.com; ematthias@sbcglobal.net; wagoring@aol.com; ktrobar@gmail.com;
robar4@sbcgloba1.net; treb@glasshouseballoon.com; troygrover@gmail.com;
louisemgrimm@yahoo.com; californiakane@yahoo.com; andrewsadvisory@gmail.com;
rmeadows@morrow-meadows.com; vincesdo@gmail.com; shane.d.bradley@gmail.com;
colepcannon@gmail.com; craigima@yahoo.com; greylikesweddings@gmail.com;
jill@jabulaniyoga.com; roberts4forme@gmail.com; ejohns3287@aol.com; anneima@yahoo.com;
christina_larkins@hotmail.com; lscottp@gmail.com; ronmariano@earthlink.net; kymartin@uci.edu;
dunnwriter@yahoo.com; brad.larkins@outlook.com; rominrad@gmail.com;
kdugan@dslextreme.com; dniccole@gmail.com; proud858@hotmail.com;
donnamcmeikan@gmail.com; ksimpson@moffattnichol.com; mickeysteinmeyer@gmail.com;
merrileebliss@gmail.com; janburns@msn.com; jcable@gmail.com; blueporsche3@yahoo.com;
sleech@nmusd.us; jim.glidewell@glidewelldental.com; angievazirian@gmail.com;
meleahmail@gmail.com; kadycarson@yahoo.com; Iberggren23@gmail.com;
marlenehester@cox.net; cspence@roadrunner.com; dcmcreynolds@yahoo.com;
curtism@pcwservices.com; pdelgadol5@gmail.com; dianerinker@me.com;
peggykerr22@hotmail.com; bdarling001@roadrunner.com; ddoyle@avcity.org;
apronkdunn@yahoo.com; john.chapman@wpwm.com; kersteph@aol.com; hproud949@gmail.com;
taylorfelix90@gmail.com; tedfarry@gmail.com; troy@troyjohnsonstudios.com;
juliecook838@yahoo.com; raykangl0@gmail.com; pbfowler@yahoo.com;
kimberlycabo09@gmail.com; toddmwca@aol.com; mjlclark@roadrunner.com;
jackieland@sbcglobal.net; brettmullinax3@gmail.com; mgonzales@geometricre.com;
drewmcallisterl9@gmail.com; nkerr22@hotmail.com; caputogirls@yahoo.com; mo@gsainfo.com;
jpanetta24@gmail.com; Allisonpanettal7@gmail.com; nestlerode.matt@gmail.com;
joepennino@gmail.com; mollyjmagnuson@gmail.com; Iegitsound@yahoo.com; jacable@gmail.com;
brad@ matchgradeinsurance.com; j.travers.design@gmail.com; bpoundersl9@gmail.com;
Iucianicolai@me.com; k9carrie@yahoo.com; devonwortmann@yahoo.com;
jmiller2411@gmail.com; jordanpaigefelix@gmail.com; nm.gallogly@gmail.com;
brynnedunn@gmail.com; mboltjones@gmail.com; robert@onetrustlegacy.com; jghall@fea.net;
bha11949@gmail.com; annchat@sbcgloba1.net; hstevenson@mindspring.com;
mauicat40@gmail.com; rpabramson@gmail.com; pdunn5000@aol.com; timstoaks@sbcgloba1.net,
cello1933@gmail.com; I.escalera@columbiasinks.com; heleyak@gmail.com;
spdemille@roadrunner.com; selmersax55@gmail.com; sbkim213@gmail.com; heimalrl@gmail.com,
jsalvo2105@aol.com; anu_sona@hotmail.com; laurie@silverliningrealty.com;
savannahoehn@yahoo.com; cakenpie@mac.com; ejgoodl@hotmail.com;
blueberriekids@gmail.com; khybs@hotmail.com; analong.nb@gmail.com; Jeff Stuckhardt
<bayfarmbz@road run ner.com>; mzmegan02@yahoo.com; Maxwell <maxsandquist@gmail.com>;
cyja@mac.com; Julie Davis Dill <julie2668@att.net>; tdwinc@att.net; sarateag@hotmail.com
Subject: Re: Update: Airport Land Use Commission meeting 8/17/23.
[EXTERNAL EMAIL] DO NOT CLICK links or attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the
content is safe.
Newport Beach City Council
If you revise the JW noise contour map to allow for housing development directly under the flight
path there is a long list of negative, even disastrous, consequences to Newport Beach while doing
absolutely nothing to affect the local housing supply and demand equation, the hopelessly flawed
assumption behind the Housing Element mandate. There is no limit to demand for housing in NB and
coastal California and also no limit to problems from increased congestion, demands on highways,
infrastructure, public services, water, schools, environment, quality of life, etc from increased
population that are completely ignored in the Element mandate and the statewide elimination of
single family zoning.
Hopefully the absurdity of this plan is obvious to voters and every elected official who supports it will
soon be replaced but we will all have to live long term with their mistakes.
Jim Auster and Merrilee Bliss
20401 Bayview Ave
On Sep 8, 2023, at 5:00 PM, Neil Treffers <ntreffers(@ptats.com> wrote:
Mike,
Last I was told / heard was this item was being discussed or voted by city council in the "first
meeting in September" Everyone needs (that can) should show up to the meeting.
Neil Treffers
On Sep 8, 2023, at 3:23 PM, M. Smith <mws.aspenroyalPgmail.com> wrote:
Neil & Group,
Does anyone know if this item will be addressed by the NB City Council on 9/12/23,
next week?
Thank you.
Mike Smith
20342 Bayview Ave.
Michael W. Smith, Broker. CA BRIE #01040263
Direct: 949.246.3686
Email: mws.asoenroval(aDamail.com
ASPEN Royal, a California Corporation
Real Estate, CA BRIE #01522580.
2549 Eastbluff Dr. #413, Newport Beach, CA 92660
www.ASPENRoyal.com
PLEASE NOTE: This message contains information which may be confidential and privileged. Unless you are the
intended addressee (or authorized to receive for the addressee), any distribution, copying or disclosure of the message
or any information contained in the message is strictly prohibited. If you have received the message in error, please
advise the sender by reply e-mail and delete the message. All rights reserved.
On Mon, Aug 21, 2023 at 11:23 AM Neil Treffers <ntreffers@ptats.com> wrote:
Agreed! Thank you, Mike.
Neil Treffers
From: Linda Giedt <Iclemensgiedt(@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, August 18, 2023 6:26 PM
To: M. Smith <mws.aspenroyal na gmail.com>
Cc: Neil Treffers <ntreffers(c2tats.com>; Brian Barson <brianbarson(@gmail.com>;
Caroline Dobbins <carolinedobbins(@icloud.com>; smeadows2412(@gmail.com;
ioshPliquidgraphics.ty; schleige(@yahoo.com; kurt_kawczynskicftahoo.com;
cit)troofing13576Dgmail.com; bspackard(@gmail.com; kh(@sureboard.com;
crncable(@gmail.com; cope2003(@sbcglobal.net; bisihilling(@gmail.com;
lowerynewport(@yahoo.com; 20effroberts(@gmail.com; nbvineyards(@gmail.com;
buckiohns(@aol.com; buckiohns(@inlandenergy.com; carreramullinax(@gmail.com;
cvlekspr(@gmail.com; ematthias(@sbcglobal.net; wagoring(@aol.com;
ktrobar(@gmail.com; robar4C@sbcglobal.net; treb(@glasshouseballoon.com;
troygrover(@gmail.com; louisemgrimm(@yahoo.com; californiakane(@yahoo.com;
andrewsadvisory(@gmail.com; rmeadows(@morrow-meadows.com;
vincesdo(@gmail.com; shane.d.bradley(@gmail.com; colepcannon(@gmail.com;
craigima(@)Iahoo.com; greylikesweddingsPgmail.com; iill(a�iabulaniyo a.com;
roberts4forme(@gmail.com; eiohns3287(@aol.com; anneima(@)�ahoo.com;
christina_larkinsPhotmail.com; lscotti)@Email.com; ronmariano(@earthlink.net;
kvmartin(@uci.edu; dunnwriterCfftahoo.com; brad.larkins(@outlook.com;
rominrad(@gmail.com; kdugan(@dslextreme.com; dniccole(@g_mail.com;
proud858(@hotmail.com; donnamcmeikan(@gmail.com;
ksimpson(@moffattnichol.com; iimausterPhotmail.com;
mickeysteinmeyer(@gmail.com; merrileebliss(@gmail.com; ianburns(@msn.com;
icable(@gmail.com; blueporsche3Pyahoo.com; sleech(@nmusd.us;
iim.glidewell(@glidewelldental.com; angievazirian(@gmail.com;
meleahmail(@gmaiLcom; kadycarson(@yahoo.com; Iberggren23C@gmail.com;
marlenehester(@cox.net; cspence(@road run ner.com; dcmcreynolds(@yahoo.com;
curtism(@12cwservices.com; pdelgado15Pgmail.com; dianerinker(@me.com;
peggvkerr22(@hotmail.com; bdarling001(@road run ner.com; ddoyle(@avcity.org;
apron kdunn(@yahoo.com; iohn.chapmanPwpwm.com; kerstephPaol.com;
hproud949(@gmail.com; taylorfelix90(@gmail.com; tedfarry(@gmail.com;
troy(@troyjohnsonstudios.com; iuliecook838Pahoo.com; raykangl0(@gmail.com;
pbfowler(@yahoo.com; kimberlycaboo9(@gmail.com; toddmwca(@aol.com;
milclarkProadrunner.com; iackielandPsbcglobal.net; brettmullinax3(@gmail.com;
mgonzales(@geometricre.com; drewmcallisterl9(@gmail.com;
nkerr22(@hotmail.com; caputogirlslcDyahoo.com; mo(cDgsainfo.com;
ipanetta24(@gmail.com; All isonpanettal7(@gmail.com; nestlerode.matt(@gmail.com;
ioepenninoPgmail.com; mollyjmagnusonPgmail.com; legitsound(@)Iahoo.com;
iacable(@gmail.com; brad(@matchgradeinsurance.com; i.travers.design(@gmail.com;
bpoundersl9(@gmail.com; Iucianicolai(@Me.com; k9carrie(@yahoo.com;
devonwortmann(@yahoo.com; imiller2411(@gmail.com;
iordanpaigefelixPgmail.com; nm.gallogly(@gmail.com; brynnedunn(@gmail.com;
mboltiones(@gmail.com; robert(@onetrustlegacy.com; ighallCc�fea.net;
bha11949CcDgmail.com; annchat(@sbcglobal.net; hstevenson(@mindspring.com;
mauicat40(@gmail.com; rpabramson(@gmail.com; pdunn5000(@aol.com,-
timstoaksPsbcglobal.net; cello1933(@gmail.com; I.escalera(@columbiasinks.com;
heleyak(@gmail.com; spdemille(@roadrunner.com; selmersax55(@gmail.com;
sbkim213(@gmail.com; heimalrl(@gmail.com; isalvo21o5(@aol.com;
anu_sona(@hotmail.com; laurie(@silverliningrealty.com; savannahoehnpyahoo.com;
cakenpie(@mac.com; eigoodl(@hotmail.com; blueberriekids(@gmail.com;
khybs(@hotmail.com; analong.nb(@gmail.com; Jeff Stuckhardt
<ba)zfarmbzProad run ner.com>; mzmegan02(@yahoo.com; Maxwell
<maxsandquist(@gmail.com>; cyia(aDmac.com; Julie Davis Dill <iulie2668(@att.net>;
tdwinc(@att.net; sarateag(@hotmail.com
Subject: Re: Update: Airport Land Use Commission meeting 8/17/23.
If NB City Council revises the JW noise contour map to allow for housing development directly under
the flight path there is a long list of negative, even disastrous, consequences to Newport Beach while
doing absolutely nothing to affect the local housing supply and demand equation, the hopelessly
flawed assumption behind the Housing Element mandate. There is no limit to demand for housing in
NB and coastal California and also no limit to problems from increased congestion, demands on
highways, infrastructure, public services, water, schools, environment, quality of life, etc from
increased population that are completely ignored in the Element mandate and the statewide
elimination of single family zoning.
Hopefully the absurdity of this plan is obvious to voters and every elected official who supports it will
soon be replaced but we will all have to live long term with their mistakes.
Jim Auster and Merrilee Bliss
20401 Bayview Ave
Thanks Mike for going to the meeting and letting all of us know what happened and
what we need to do as a group to voice our objections to dumping a lot of the
burden of the Housing Element in and around our neighborhood.
Don't forget neighbors, if the noise contour is changed, this could also open up the
flood gates to changes at JWA with more noise, no curfew or even expansion of the
airport in the future.
Please email and show up at the 9/12 City Council meeting. Mark it on your
calendar!
citycouncil@newportbeachca.gov
Linda
On Fri, Aug 18, 2023 at 5:22 PM M. Smith <mws.aspenroyalCc)gmail.com> wrote:
Dear Friends and Neighbors,
On 8/17/2023 a neighbor and I attended the Airport Land Use Commission
meeting. At this meeting and as expected, the Commission Members voted to
approve the Airport Land Use Commission's Staff recommendation to KEEP the
current Existing JWA Noise Contours and New Housing Sites map, see
ATTACHEMENT 1. By doing so, they REJECTED the City of Newport Beach's
request to alter the Proposed JWA Noise Contours and Housing Sites map, see
ATTACHMENT 3. Mr. James Campbell, Deputy Community Development Director
of the City of Newport Beach, was present and was representing the City of NB
and spoke in support of the City's request as shown in ATTACHMENT 3. 1 did
address the Commission and Mr. Campbell and stated very clearly that I and a
large number of my fellow Neighbors do NOT support the City's request/map as
noted in their ATTACHMENT 3.
The good news here is that the ALUC Commission rejected the City's request and
is on record as doing so. The bad news is the City Staff is Planning to recommend
to the NB City Council to, "Override" the ALUC Commissions decision at a future
City Council meeting, see attached Notice from the City of NB. Mr. Campbell
informed the audience that this issue was being pulled from the City Council
Agenda for 8/22/2023 and would instead be added to the 911212023, City
Council Agenda.
In my opinion, the City of NB is trying to adjust the current JWA Noise and
Contours and Housing Sites as you can see from ATTACHMENT 3. Their goal is to
add more housing in their new 60 dB CNEL zone, and they want the authorization
to add more housing in their new 65 db CNEL zone. If you look at ATTACHMENT 3,
that the City Staff wants, you will see a major impact to our Neighborhood and the
immediate surrounding areas. This includes the golf course area, Mesa, Birch,
Bristol, Orchard, Orchid, Zenith, etc.
What's next: We must push the NB City Council to vote against this issue. We
need to send emails in advance of the meeting to the City Council asking them to
not move forward with this. We MUST attend the NB City Council Meeting in
force to show that our Neighborhood is against this. This is not a time to think
that someone else will carry the ball. Again, please, we MUST show up in person,
in force and speak up on this issue with the NB City Council.
We all love our Neighborhood, it's worth all of us showing up in person for a
couple of hours at a NB City Council Meeting.
We believe this issue will be on the N13 City Council Agenda on 911212023. If
anyone can confirm this, please update this group.
Thank you all,
Mike Smith
20342 Bayview Ave.
Michael W. Smith, Broker. CA BRE #01040263
Direct: 949.246.3686
Email: mws.asoenrovalaamail.com
ASPEN Royal, a California Corporation
Real Estate, CA BRE #01522580.
2549 Eastbluff Dr. #413, Newport Beach, CA 92660
www.ASPENRoval.com
PLEASE NOTE: This message contains information which may be confidential and privileged. Unless you are
the intended addressee (or authorized to receive for the addressee), any distribution, copying or disclosure of
the message or any information contained in the message is strictly prohibited. If you have received the
message in error, please advise the sender by reply e-mail and delete the message. All rights reserved.
On Tue, Aug 15, 2023 at 7:45 PM M. Smith <mws.aspenroya1Pgmail.com> wrote:
Neil,
Thank you for this information. Much appreciated!
MEETING: Thursday, 8/17/2023 @ 4:00 pm
AIRPORT LAND USE COMMISSION
PLACE: John Wayne Airport, 3160 Airway Avenue Costa Mesa, CA 92626
Airport Commission Hearing Room
Thank you all,
Mike Smith
20342 Bayview Ave.
Michael W. Smith, Broker. CA BRE #01040263
Direct: 949.246.3686
Email: mws.aspenroyal(a).amail.com
ASPEN Royal, a California Corporation
Real Estate, CA BRE #01522580.
2549 Eastbluff Dr. #413, Newport Beach, CA 92660
www.ASPENRoyal.com
PLEASE NOTE: This message contains information which may be confidential and privileged. Unless you
are the intended addressee (or authorized to receive for the addressee), any distribution, copying or
disclosure of the message or any information contained in the message is strictly prohibited. If you have
received the message in error, please advise the sender by reply e-mail and delete the message. All rights
reserved.
On Tue, Aug 15, 2023 at 12:40 PM Neil Treffers <ntreffers(@ptats.com> wrote:
An update to kee)jou all apprised:
There is one other group meeting to discuss the proposed update to the
airport noise contour matter this Thursday, 08/17/23, before it gets to our
City Council next week on 8/22/23. This next meeting is with a group called
the "Airport Land Use Commission" to whom the City of Newport Beach is
presenting their request to have this Commission approve their new
proposed contours.
Per the Commission's current Agenda, the Commission is not recommending
approval of the proposal. Unfortunately, the Clty Council can still override
this on 08/22/23, but the Staff Report for this Item gives a really good
background and overview of this topic to date, if anyone is interested and
wants to better understand this issue.
Unfortunately, I think the only way you can submit
comments/questions/concerns is to actually appear at 4:00 PM at the
Thursday meeting in person. See the Agenda for the location.
For those of you who have contact with city council members, I would think
now is a good time to reach out to them requesting they do not approve any
changes to the airport noise contour maps.
Thank you.
Neil Treffers
From: Linda Giedt <Iclemensgiedt(@gmail.com>
Sent: Friday, August 11, 2023 2:08 PM
To: Brian Barson <brianbarson(@gmail.com>
Cc: Caroline Dobbins <carolinedobbinsPicloud.com>; Neil Treffers
<ntreffers(@ptats.com>; smeadows2412(@gmail.com; josh(@liquidgraphics.ty;
schleigeC@)yahoo.com; kurt_kawczynski(aDyahoo.com;
cityroofing1357(@gmail.com; bspackard(@gmail.com; kh(@sureboard.com;
crncable(aDgmail.com; cope2003(cDsbcglobal.net; bisihilling(cDgmail.com;
lowerynewport(@)yahoo.com; 2jeffroberts(@gmail.com;
nbvine)zards(@gmail.com; buckiohns6Daol.com;
buckjohns(@inlandenergy.com, carreramullinax(@gmail.com;
mws.aspenro)jaI6Dgmail.com; cyleksprPgmail.com,
ematthias@sbcglobal.net; wagoring@aol.com; ktrobar@gmail.com;
robar4CcDsbcglobal.net; treb(@glasshouseballoon.com;
troygrover(@gmail.com; louisemgrimm(aDyahoo.com;
californiakane(@)Iahoo.com; andrewsadvisor)z(@gmail.com;
rmeadows(@morrow-meadows.com; vincesdo(@gmail.com;
shane.d.bradley(@gmail.com; colepcannon(@gmail.com;
craigima(@yahoo.com; greylikesweddings(@gmail.com;
iill(cD'abulaniyoga.com; roberts4forme(cDgmail.com; ejohns3287(cDaol.com;
anneima(@)�ahoo.com; christina_larkins(@hotmail.com; lscottp(@gmail.com;
ronmariano(@earthlink.net; kymartinPuci.edu; dunnwriter(@)Iahoo.com;
brad.larkins(@outlook.com; rominrad(@gmail.com; kdugan(@dslextreme.com;
dniccole(@gmail.com; proud858(@hotmail.com;
donnamcmeikan(@gmail.com; ksimpson(@moffattnichol.com;
iimauster(@hotmail.com; mickeysteinmeyer(@gmail.com;
merrileeblissPgmail.com; ianburnsPmsn.com; icable@2mail.com;
blueporsche3Pa ahoo.com; sleech(@nmusd.us;
iim.glidewell(@glidewelldental.com; angievazirian(@gmail.com;
meleahmail(@gmail.com; kadycarson(@)Iahoo.com; Iberggren23Pgmail.com;
marlenehester(@cox.net; cspence(@road runner.com;
dcmcreynolds(@ahoo.com; curtism(cDpcwservices.com;
pdelgadol5(@gmail.com; dianerinker(@me.com; 1)e22vkerr22(@hotmail.com;
bdarling001(@roadrunner.com; ddoyle(@avcity.org;
apronkdunn(@yahoo.com; iohn.chapman(@wpwm.com; kersteph(@aol.com;
hproud949(@gmail.com; taylorfelix90(@gmail.com; tedfarry(@gmail.com;
troy(@troyjohnsonstudios.com; iuliecook838(@yahoo.com;
ra)zkangl0(@gmail.com; pbfowler(cDyahoo.com; kimberlycabo09(@gmail.com;
toddmwca(@aol.com; milclark(@road run ner.com; iackieland(@sbcglobal.net;
brettmullinax3(@gmail.com; mgonzales(@geometricre.com;
drewmcallisterl9(@gmail.com; nkerr22(@hotmail.com;
caputogirls(@yahoo.com; mo(@gsainfo.com; ipanetta24Pgmail.com;
Allisonpanettal7(@gmail.com; nestlerode.matt(@gmaiI.com;
0oepenninoPgmail.com; mollyjmagnuson(@gmail.com;
legitsound(@yahoo.com; iacable(a�gmail.com;
brad(@ matchgradeinsurance.com; i.travers.design(@gmail.com;
bpoundersl9(@gmail.com; lucianicolai(@me.com; k9carrie(@yahoo.com;
devonwortmann(@yahoo.com; imiller2411(@gmail.com;
iordanpaigefelix(@gmail.com; nm.gallogly(@gmail.com;
brynnedunn(@gmail.com; mboltiones(@gmail.com;
robert(@onetrustlegacy.com; ighall(@fea.net; bha11949(@gmail.com;
a nnchat(@sbcgloba1.net; hstevenson(cDmindspring.com;
mauicat40(@gmail.com; rpabramson(@gmail.com; pdunn5000(@aol.coml-
timstoaks(cDsbcglobal.net; cello1933(@gmail.com;
I.escalera(@columbiasinks.com; heleyak(@gmail.com;
spdemille(@road run ner.com; selmersax55(@gmail.com;
sbkim213(@gmail.com; heimalrl(@gmail.com; isalvo2105(@aol.com;
anu_sona(@hotmail.com, laurie(@silverliningrealty.com;
savannahoehn(@ahoo.com; cakenpiePmac.com; eogoodl(@hotmail.com;
blueberriekids(@gmail.com; khybs(@hotmail.com, analong.nb(@gmail.com;
Jeff Stuckhardt <bayfarmbz(@roadrunner.com>; mzmeEan02Pyahoo.com;
Maxwell <maxsandquist(@gmail.com>; cvjaPmac.com; Julie Davis Dill
<iulie2668(@att.net>; tdwinc(@att.net; sarateag(@hotmail.com
Subject: Re: Airport Noise Contour vote by NB City Counsel set for 8/22/23
Carrera let me know that the Planning Commission voted YES
on 8/3 by a vote of 4 ayes and 3 recused, and recommended
that the City Council approve the Amendments so the Housing
Element can go forward.
Now it goes to the NB City Council for a vote on 8/22/23.
Attached is the Agenda with all the information. Also,
attached is the Planning Commission's staff report listing their
BS reasons to change the noise contour to allow for housing at
the golf course on Mesa right under the flight path along with
the noise contour maps.
To send an email to ALL the members of the City Council
about changing the noise contour ---
citycouncilCcDnewportbeachca.gov
Please email your concerns and objections to changing the
noise contour.
Our neighbourhood should be very concerned about changing
the noise contour. Change it once, it can be changed again
and again. Expansion of the airport, curfews, you name it
could be in play in the future by changing the noise contour.
Also, other residents in the surrounding neighborhoods can
also email the NB City Counsel to object so pass it along to
your friends and family.
On Fri, Aug 11, 2023 at 12:57 PM Linda Giedt <Iclemensgiedt(@gmail.com>
wrote:
Does anyone know the outcome of the vote on 8/3 by the Planning
Commission re the noise contour?
On Tue, Aug 1, 2023 at 2:51 PM Brian Barson <brianbarson(.gmail.com>
wrote:
Writing an email now - thanks to all for sending along the
commissioner's emails. Does the city recognize our neighborhood as
Santa Ana Heights or Bay View Heights, just so I can ensure they
understand exactly which area I'm talking about?
Thanks,
Brian Barson
On Tue, Aug 1, 2023 at 2:35 PM Caroline Dobbins
<carolinedobbins(@icloud.com> wrote:
Hello Neighbors!
The e-mail address below will send a message to all commissioners. It
would be great if everyone on this list could send them an e-mail.
Pass it on! Thanks Carrera!
Planningcommissioners(@newportbeachca.gov
Caroline
On Jul 31, 2023, at 1:00 PM, Neil Treffers
<ntreffersPptats.com> wrote:
M
Apologies it's been a while since sending out a report
from NPBD crime watch updates. It's been busy on my
end and trying to get back into it.
1. Please read a message and see attachment from
one of our neighbors that I have been asked to
pass along regarding some information with the
city of Newport Beach that will have a direct
effect on our neighborhood.
One of our council members and I had a nice chat today
and he thought our neighborhood should be informed
about a matter coming to Planning Commission next
week on August 3rd. The item concerns shrinking the
size of a noise contour around the airport, that would
effectively allow housing (for dense, affordable units to
meet RHNA numbers) on the golf course parcel south of
Mesa. See the attached staff report to read more
about this. There is an argument that where a contour
bisects a parcel, that parcel should not be deemed
eligible for building.
It is prudent that our neighborhood pay attention to
the matter now at planning commission level and
write to the planning commission with our concerns if
we want to preserve the golf course as is. If approved
by planning commission, it will go to the City Council
next for their review and approval, but it's better to let
our concerns be known sooner rather than later so that
there is more time for revision and discussion.
<Staff Report. pdf><J u ne 2023.pdf><ReportDistrict and
Area Map.pdf>
Received After Agenda Printed
September 12, 2023
Agenda Item No. 19
From: Jeff Stuckhardt <jstuckhardt@gmail.com>
Sent: September 10, 2023 10:31 AM
To: Dept - City Council <CityCouncil@newportbeachca.gov>
Cc: Linda Giedt <Iclemensgiedt@gmail.com>
Subject: Existing JWA Noise Contours
Dear City Council Members,
I implore you to accept the Airport Land Use Commission's Staff recommendation to KEEP the current Existing JWA
Noise Contours and New Housing Sites map. Do note vote to overturn their recommendation.
Sincerely,
Jeffery L. Stuckhardt
2402 Bay Farm Place
Newport Beach 92660
Received After Agenda Printed
September 12, 2023
Agenda Item No. 19
-----Original Message -----
From: Beth Darling <bethdarling61 @gmail.com>
Sent: September 10, 2023 10:41 AM
To: Dept - City Council<CityCouncil@newportbeachca.gov>
Subject: Revision of SNA noise contour map
[EXTERNAL EMAIL] DO NOT CLICK links or attachments unless you recognize the sender and know
the content is safe.
Dear Newport Beach City Council,
My family and I have been long time, voting, residents of Newport Beach.
We have seen many changes, good and bad to our city. Very few of the changes regarding John
Wayne airport have been good for NB residents and the city itself.
Changing the noise contour and adding more housing under the flight path is a terrible idea.
Unless the plan is to make N.B. into Inglewood, where the air traffic is the most notable feature of the
city, we must stop letting SNA rule our city and lives. It's OUR city, not SNAs and should remain so.
I, and my extended family living here in Newport Beach, are strongly opposed to changing the
existing JWA Noise Contours plan, and strongly opposed to building housing under the flight path.
Sincerely,
Beth Darling
Received After Agenda Printed
September 12, 2023
Agenda Item No. 19
From: M J Clark <mjclark@roadrunner.com>
Sent: September 10, 2023 2:12 PM
To: Dept - City Council<CityCouncil@newportbeachca.gov>
Subject: JWA noise contour adjustments
I am writing to voice my opposition to altering the noise contours for JWA making it possible to build housing of any type
within those existing contours. It is unacceptable to alter those contours for any reason. The city fought long and hard
to bring this area into its sphere of influence to uphold the quality of life in our city and limit any future expansion of the
airport. To reverse course on this now seems very suspect in my opinion. Who on the council will directly or indirectly
benefit from the altering of these noise contours?
There is also the issue of the city trying to satisfy its responsibility to meet the affordable housing mandate by dumping
additional housing at a higher density disproportionately into our neighborhood.
There will be many environmental impacts as well as increased traffic congestion if the city goes ahead with its proposal.
This will also affect the quality of our area which is both an environmental and recreational jewel for the citizens of both
our city and the surrounding areas to enjoy .
These solutions in fairness must be spread throughout the city so that no one area bares an unfair share of the burden.
Sincerely,
Matt Clark
20111 Bayview Ave.
Newport Beach