Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutDOVER SHORES DREDGING*NEW FILE* DOVER SHORES DREDGING COUNCILMEN O ti� i ROLL CAL\ 9�top)� COY OF NEWPORT BEVH can+cmF.c. 1n 1070 MINUTES INDEX Jim Toledano, attorney for N.O.R.M.A., addressed the Council in opposition to either of the ordinances or the resolution. Motion x Ordinance No. 1821, being, AN ORDINANCE OF 0-1821 All Ayes THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH ADDING SECTION 12.57.027 OF THE NEWPORT BEACH MUNICIPAL CODE RELATING TO REGULATION OF ROLLER SKATING, was introduced and passed to second reading on October 1, 1979. CURRENT BUSINESS: 1. A report was presented from the City Arts City Arts ommission regarding a location in the City for the Corpsn sc 1pture of Dick Richard which is now located in (120F) the amber of Commerce offices. Don Port , Executive Director of the Newport Harbor Are Chamber of Commerce, addressed the Council and st ed that the Chamber concurred with the recommen ion that the sculpture remain at the Chamber unti another suitable place can be found in the City. Motion x The recommendation of e City Arts Commission All Ayes that the sculpture should re in at the Chamber of Commerce was confirmed in smuch as the City would appreciate having the s 1pture in a City building, but feels that it can b displayed with dignity at the Chamber of Commerce uilding. 2. A report was presented from the Traf ' Affairs Street Committee regarding the street lights on 00 and Lighting 2100 blocks of Bayside Drive. Bayside Dr (334� A letter received after the agenda was printed fro Charles S. Wheeler III, 2137 Bayside Drive, was presented indicating his willingness to fund his share for marbelite standards. Ruth Steen addressed the Council in favor of the marbelite standards. Motion x The staff was directed to install marbelite standards All Ayes providing the residents fund the cost. 3. A report was presented from the Marine Department North Star regarding core samples of the Dover Shores, Beach Channels. _ (596) The City Manager reported that the results of tests by Anaheim Test Lab on the core samples indicated that most of the material was not what could be considered beach sand. I i Volume 33 - Page 256 l*TY OF NEWPORT ACH COUNCILMEN� 1yG\` , �A ROLL CALL \ top) � September 10. 1979 MINUTES INDEX Motion x Resolution No. 9631 (alternate a), establishing the R-9631 All Ayes ad hoc Highway Action Team (HAT) and specifying the duties and responsibilities of the team, was adopted. Motion x Mayor Ryckoff's appointment of the following All Ayes members to the Highway Action Team was confirmed: Chuck Hirsch, Bud Schroeder, Dick Clucas, Bill Lusk, Judy Cooper, Bill Banning, Bob Shelton, Mike Johnson, Jean Watt and Bill Ficker. Motion x 2. Councilman McInnIs' appointment of William Dohr as Trans Plan All Ayes a member of the Transportation Plan Citizens CAC Advisory Committee to fill the unexpired term of (960F) R. H. Clucas ending December 31, 1979 was confirmed. Motion x Councilman Hummel's appointment of Richard Succa All Ayes as a member of the Transportation Plan Citizens Advisory Committee to fill the unexpired term of G. Edmund Siebel, Jr. ending December 31, 1979 was confirmed. Motion x 3. ouncIlman Hummel's appointment of Nan Plink as a Bicycle Trails All Ayes mber of the Bicycle Trails Citizens Advisory CAC Co mittee to fill the unexpired term of Dr. (205F) Sho off ending December 319 1979 was confirmed. 4. A rep dated August 13, 1979 was presented from Litter Control the C irman of the Litter Control Citizens CAC Advisory Committee regarding appointments to that (2046) Committe . Motion x Councilman art's appointment of Suzie Ficker as a All Ayes member of th Committee to £ill the unexpired term of Hal Pinch ending December 31, 1979 was confirmed. Motion x Councilman Humm I's appointment of a member to All Ayes fill the unexpired t rm of Helen Anderson ending December 31, 1979 as postponed to October 1, 1979. 5. A letter was presented om Joan S. Petty dated OrCo August 6, 1979 resigning as the City's representative Housing to the Advisory Committee of the Orange County Authority Housing Authority. (1272) Motion x Ms. Petty's resignation was ac epted with regret; All Ayes and Mayor Ryckoff's appointment f Willard Wade to serve as the City's reprosentativR on the Orange County Housing Authority Advisory Committee was confirmed. 6. A report was presented from the C y Attorney Rollerskating regarding roller skating regulations with ternatives Regulations of two ordinances (identical ordinances a cept that (2330) one would be as an emergency ordinanc } and a proposed resolution pursuant to Section 12.5f 025 of the Newport Beach Municipal Code prohibiting roller skating on public streets and sidewalks designated therein as hazardous to pedestrians, motorists and persons roller skating. j Volume 33 - Page 255 y COY OF NEWPORT EESCH COUNCILMEN MINUTES ROLL CALL �s s September 10 1979 INDEX Motion x Councilman Heather made a.motion to reaffirm the action of t e Council on .August 28 giving conceptual approval to the park. The following people addressed the Council in favor of the project: Jesse Curtis, Linda Taylor and Alan Reedy. _ Gary Lovell and Frank Robinson addressed the Council in opposition to the .project. Motion x Councilman McInnis made a motion to limit the Ayes x x x Council debate on the subject, which motion failed. Noes x x x Abstain x Councilman Hart stated for the record that she had listened to the public testimony'on the tape for the meeting of August 28 and, therefore, feels she can vote on the issue. She also stated for the record, since she intended to 'support the motion, that she was approving only 5,000 cubic yards of dredged material. Ayes x x x x A vote was taken on Councilman Heather's motion, Noes x x which motion carried. Abstain x H. CONSENT CALENDAR:, Motion x The following actions were taken as indicated except for All Ayes those items removed: 1. ORDINANCES FOR INTRODUCTION: For' introduction and set for public hearing October 1, 1979: (a) Proposed Ordinance No. 1822, b ng, AN Bldg Hgts ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF EWPORT Ocean Blvd BEACH ADDING SECTION 2 . 2.050(F) TO 0-1822 THE NEWPORT BEACH M ICIPAL CODE (3348) TO REDUCE HEIGHT IMITS AND TO ESTABLISH BUILD G HEIGHTS IN RELATION TO C B HEIGHT ON THE SIDE OCEAN BOULEVARD EEN C NATION AVENUE AND AV UE, CORONA DEL MAR, ng ommissiot: Amendment No. 537, a initiated by the City of Newport (A report from the Community pment Department) IE ed Ordinance No. 1823, being, AN Water Rates ANCE OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT 0-1823 AMENDING SECTION 14.12.090 OF (250) EWPORT BEACH MUNICIPAL CODE ROVIDE FOR ADEQUATE WATER RATE ADJUSTMENT FROM AND AFTER JANUARY 219 1980. (A report from the i Utilities Director) i i Volume 33 - Page 257 WY OF NEWPORT 810CH y' COUNCILMEN MINUTES GTyF �' i� ROLL CALL �s'� INDEX 2. RESOLUTIONS FOR ADOPTION: (a) Resolution No. 9632 concerning charitable Payroll payroll deductions. (Letter with attachments Deductions from United Way of Orange County) R-9632 (3349) (b) Removed from the Consent Calendar. (c) Resolution No. 9633, authorizing the Mayor OrCo and City Clerk to execute an agreement Airport between the City of Newport Beach and (195F) McDonough, Holland, Schwartz h Allen in R-9633 connection with legal and consulting services ting to Orange County Airport. ached) oved from the Consent Calendar. olution No. 9634 opposing AB 1274. (A Pending Legis rt from the Acting City Attorney) R-9634 (1243F) lution No. 9635 supporting SB 823 to \(h)Resoluti Pending Legis ude stock cooperatives within the R-9633 ivision Map Act. (A report from the (1243F)' ng CIty Attorney) ution No. 9636 opposing AB 1611. (A Pending Legis r from the Acting City Attorney) R-9636 (1243F) luti No. 9637 authorizing the Mayor Vacation Allay/ City Jerk to execute a quitclaim deed to Lafayette do the Bank Newport for a portion of the 31st St alley adjace t to the Bank of Newport, (A R-9637 report from t blic Works Department) (2230) (1) Resolution No. 38 designating as one-way One-way Alley the alley betweensAdams and Palm Streets. Adams/Palm (A report from`` the Traffic Affairs R 9638 Committee) (3350) (j) Resolution No. 9639%a�rding a contract to Traffic Signal William R. Hahn regardingthe installation of do Pushbutton traffic signal and safetylighting at BIrch Installations Street and Von Karman Aue and bicycle buttons f/bicycles push at 14 signalized Intersections R-9639 (C-2101). (A report from the Public Works (3333 do 205F) Department) \\ (k) Resolution No. 9640 authorizing he Mayor Traffic Signal and City Clerk to execute a sup�f)emental PCHwy do agreement between the City and CAL RANS Irvine Ter for the Installation of the traffic si al at R-9640 Coast Highway and Irvine Terrace. (A r rt (2$84) from the Public Works Department) (1) Resolution No. 9641 approving the parcel ma Resub 631 for Resubdivision No. 631) and acceptIng the dedication pA R-9641 offer of of easements. report (3320) from the Public Works Department) I Volume 33 - Page 238 i . It 0 • 11 • CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH MARINE DEPARTMENT September 10, 1979 ITEM NO: G-3 TO: MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL FROM: Marine Department SUBJECT: DOVER SHORES CHANNELS; CORE SAMPLES Action: If desired, (a) affirm the action of August 28, or (b) modify, or (c) rescind the action of August 28. Background: The City Council at an adjourned City Council meeting on August 28, 1979, passed a motion concerning the development of North Star Beach. The minutes read, "Mayor Ryckoff made a substitute motion to adopt Resolution No. 9630 as recommended by the Parks, Beaches, and Recreation Commission regarding desirable improvements for the public recreational use and enjoyment of North Star Beach, subject to: the City's obtaining three additional samples from the short finger, and five additional samples from the long finger; these samples to be analyzed by an independent, qualified laboratory; these granular samples be compared with the EPA Dredge Material Disposal Criteria; that this constitutes conceptual approval of a 5,000 cubic yard operation; and the Dover Shores Association contribute $12,000 for the development of North Star Beach Park, which motion carried." The Marine Department staff, as directed by the motion, collected eight core samples from the Dover Shores Channels during the morning of August 31. (Exhibit A - Collection Locations) The samples were collected by a Marine Safety Officer in scuba equipment using a 2" diameter steel pipe 42" in length. The collection tube was pushed into the bottom material by the diver approximately 15" to 26" in depth dependent on sample location. The core samples were then placed in a plastic bag and delivered by Mr. Welden to the Anaheim Test Lab for analysis. The above sampling method was discussed with Mr. Vais of the EPA in San Francisco prior to the collection of the samples. He verified that the collection technique utilized was the correct method of sample collection for this type of project. Sample Comparisons: Mr. Welden, in a telephone discussion with Mr. Vais of the EPA, requested that the EPA send to the Marine Department their latest Dredge ti- 0 -P.Mayor and City Council -2- September 10, 1979 Material Disposal Criteria. • Mr. Vais informed the Marine Department that there is no granular criteria for contained upland disposal, and that the disposal zone pro- posed by the Dover Shores Association is out of the EPA jurisdiction because it is above the elevation line of tidal influence. Mr. Vais emphasized that the EPA had reviewed the original Army Corp of Engineer's Public Notice No. 77-160 regarding dredge disposal on North Star Beach. The EPA had stated by letter dated September 16, 1977, to the district Corp of Engineer that, "we have reviewed the following Corp of Engineer's Public Notices and do not object to your issuance of these permits." The letter was signed by William H. Pierce, Chief, Permits Branch. In addition, Mr. Vais related that the EPA, during 1976, issued iterim criteria for Beach Replenishment. However, that criteria is no longer in effect and the EPA now reviews each application for Beach Replenishment on a case by case basis, because sand material varies con- siderably from bay zone to oceanfront zone and also area to area. Beach Replenishment is considered material ,that is placed on the surface of a beach that is normally subject to tidal action. • The following report (Exhibit B) from the Anaheim Test Lab is the granular analysis of the core samples taken from the Dover Shores Channels. In the report from the Anaheim Test Laboratory, the sub -headings ("Retained @50, Retained @100, Retained @200, Passing @200") refer to a mesh screen size. These numbers, to the right of the word "Retained", i.e. 50, 100, and 200, mean the number of square holes per square inch in the screen. The numbers below the sub -headings refer to the percentage of dried material that was retained or passed through the particular screen size. In order to give council some basis to relate these different samples with, the EPA interim criteria for "Beach Replenishment" required that 91 percent or more of the material be retained on a 200 mesh screen. In sample #8 from the Anaheim Test Lab, 32.1 percent was retained on a 200 mesh screen. The other samples showed less retention. The Dover Shores project is not considered a "Beach Replenishment" type of project by the EPA. The project is an upland disposal type of project for which the EPA does not have granular size requirements. To staff knowledge, • the EPA is the prime agency responsible for establishing Dredge Disposal Criteria by Federal law. Conclusion: If Council desires, and because there is no EPA criteria re- garding granular samples for upland disposal, the granular analysis could be submitted to the Regional C.C. with a request that they review the test results and determine the suitability of placing this material in upland Mayor and City Council -3- September 10, 1979 containment basins and covering them over with native material as pro- posed by the Dover Shores Association. David Harshbarger Marine Director DH:mw Attachments UPPER NOTE: ... �... ; NEWYORT BAY APPROXIMATELY 5000 \ C.Y. OF GRANULAR _ SIN .,,A.,`' ,,,v.LLW. ow � MATERIAL TO BE � im °1 "' DREDGED BY HYDRAULIC \ DREDGING AND DEPOSITED AT DISPOSAL SITE. fflftoo N 9M91:L 4 y- ���g`f` -- +9,e EX s"M &AAW &W 3rar'se•s�_; Newro" NCH :1 ro PRO] LOCK I e4r MciFic � ooE,u, • a:: _ A 0 a PROPOSED DREDGING AND DISPOSAL PURPOSE: MAINTENANCE OF BERTHING AREA IN NEWPORT BAY a �AT NEWPORT BEACH, CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF ORANGE APPLICATION BY DOVER SHORES COMMUNITY ASSOC. SHEET I OF 1 5/13/77 �k�18/7' Iq —., ANAHEIM TEST LABORATORY 3004 S. ORANGE AVENUE •SANTA ANA, CALIFORNIA 92707 PHONE (714) 549.7267 To.. Dover Shores Retained@50 n7W PARTICULATE ANALYSIS Retained@100 1.4 0.8 1.1. 0.7 2.1 8.4 27-3 DATE: 9-5-79 P.O. No. Verbal Lab. No. K 3447-1-8 Material: Dredge material Retained@200 2.0 1.8 4.5 1.1 14.2 i 32.1 07 �;Jj r S et ') Passing@200 96.6 9?•4 9. �4 98.2 94.2 977.4 4o.6 ANATJEBI TEST 1.A130RATO13y James A. alias, Chit 4 CALIFORNIA STATE POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY, POMONA Plant•and Soil Science Department LABORATORY EXERCISE j PHYSICAL PROURTIE$ OF SOILS •General 3. SS 231 - Basic Soil �Sciencer,pBrady,�dChad�ters 3 and r10. G. ..3 NAME KEr/n/ertl ei-�A/ LAB SECTION DATE 16/17 TNcrc: I. Introduction The physical properties of soils affect many other soil properties, e.g., soil, moisture relations, nutrient capacity and availability, chemical properties/ erosion and biological properties. Topics often reviewed as soil physical properties include soil texture, bulk density, particle density, porosity and soil color. Soil structure, soil temperature, soil swelling capacity, soil compactability, and soil permeability are also important but will not be considered in this exercise. II. Soil Texture • A. Principles Soil texture refers to the relative proportion of sand, silt and clay in the soil. Specifically, the textural classification is based on the amount of particles less than 2 millimeters in size. If particles greater than 2 millimeters are present in significant amounts, an appropriate adjective such as gravelly or stony is added to the textural name. The size fractions (sand, silt and clay) are called separates. A soil separate is a group of mineral particles ranging in size between definite limits. The names and sizes of separates recognized by the United States Department of Agriculture are: very coarse sand (2.0-1.0 mm); coarse sand (1.0-0.5 mm); medium sand (.5-.25 mm); fine sand (0.25-0.10 mm); very fine sand (0.10-0.05 mm); silt (0.05-0.002 mm); and clay (<0.002 mm). Sand size particles feel gritty when the soil is rubbed between the fingers. They are not plastic or sticky when wet. Silt particles feel smooth and powdery when rubbed between the fingers. They are not plastic or sticky when wet. Clay particles feel smooth, sticky and plastic when wet. They form very hard clods or peds when dry. • Texture is an extremely important characteristic of the soil. It affects the chemical, physical and biological properties of the soil. Broadly, soils can be divided into three general textural classes of coarse-, medium- and fine -textured soils. S;-ecifically, soils are divided into 12 textural classes; these will be reviewed later. Fine -textured (predominance of clay) soils have a greater amount of surface area than coarse -textured (predominance of sand) soils. A single gram of loam soil exposes from 75 to 195 square meters of surface area. Calculations show that a single gram of clay loam soil would contain 5 to 6 acres of surface area. -2- 0 0 • The texture of the soil, then, largely determines the amount of surface area that is available for adsorption of water and nutrients. Thus, fine -textured soils are usually more fertile (contain more nutrients and organic matter) than the sandier, coarse -textured soils. In addition, texture affects the total amount and size of the individual pores which, for the most part, determine the rate and amount of air and water movement through soils. Coarse -textured soils often are more porous and permit more rapid water intake or infiltration. However, fine -textured soils have a greater water -holding capacity than sandy soils due to their greater surface area. Clayey soils have a larger percentage of total pore space than sandy soil. This difference is due to the larger number of micro pores which function in water retention. Coarse -textured soils have more macro pores which function in air and water movement. Loamy soils or medium textured soils are intermediate between the clayey and the sandy soils in all of these relationships. Mechanical Analysis (eouyoucos Method) A. Principles The determination of the percent sand, silt, and clay is called a mechanical analysis. Particles suspended in water settle differentially, depending on the amount of surface per unit volume (specific surface) or particler size. Clay particles have a high amount of surface area per unit volume mrapery lanand ettle particleslsettlele silt rapidlypbecausesettle of theirloworevidlydsand specific surface or large size. After the soil aggregates have been dispersed, this procedure can be used to effect a separation of the sand, silt, and clay particles, The rate at which particles settle can be calculated using Stokes Law. In the eouyoucos Method, the amount of particles in suspension is determined using a hydrometer to measure the densthere arefathe largesamountnof suspendeddensity particlessuspension suspensiowhen n. Dispersion is accomplished by two treatments; one chemical and the other physical. Calgon (sodium hexametaphosphate) is added to supply sodium ions which replace calcium ions on the surface of the clay. The calcium precipitates as a metaphosphate. The presence of the Targe sodium cation on the negativeurface chargeoofthe theclay clayrwhichsthe causesetheeof particlesltoation of dispersetby net repelling each other. Aggregates are further broken down by physically stirring the suspension. The hydrometer is calibrated so that the corrected reading gives the grams,of soil material in suspension. The sand settles to the bottom of the cylinder within 40 seconds, therefore, the 40 second hydrometer reading actually gives the amount of silt and clay in suspension. Silt settles in two hours. B. Procedure 1. Weigh sieve soil out 50.0 grams of OD* soil that has been sieved through a 2 mm and place it in the special mixing Cup. (Use 100 gm if the is over 90% sand.) FW Li *oven -dry C CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH OFFICE OF THE CITY MANAGER August 29, 1979 TO: MARINE DIRECTOR FROM: City Manager SUBJECT: DOVER SHORES DREDGING The City Council, on August 28th, adopted the resolution re- garding improvements to North Star Beach as recommended by the Parks, Beaches and Recreation Commission, with two conditions. -- 1. That the Homeowners' Association contribute a sum"of" $12,000 for the improvements to the North Star Beach. 2. That eight additional granular tests be taken at the Homeowners' expense. The City staff is authorized to take the tests and have them delivered to a testing lab by.a member of the City staff, with the costs being paid by the Homeowners' Association. The staff will take three samples from the short waterway and five samples from the long waterway. As indicated above, the tests are to examine the granual quantity and quality of the material. No metal tests are required. The testing laboratory is to compare the quality of material with EPA standards for beach replacement sand. This subject may be further clarified when the City Clerk prepares the exact language of the motion adopted. The action taken by the City Council o conceptual approval and I believe, therefore, th mitted either by the City and/or the Homeowners' Coastal Commission for processing. RLW:mm CC: arks, Beaches & Recreation Director Community Development Director n e August 28th is considered material can be sub - Association to the ROBERT L. YW NN AY OF NEWPORT BACH COUNCILMEN \\�i �•` y SJ' �C, Gy � Ciy� i g��� i9�0 y9s22i November 13, 1978 MINUTES INDEX Bayside Drive Park Construction, Contract No. Bayside Dr 1910. (A report from the Public Works Park Department) (1971) 11. The lowin Harbor Permit A� licat�ions were Harbor approve Permits (304F) (a) Removed from Consent Calendar. (b) Application #109-1907 0 11 Ware for maintenance dredging at 1907 Bay Avenue - approval of application, subject the conditions of approval listed in the ge al permit issued to the City by the Corps of Engineers. (A report from the Marine Department) (c) A request by Dover Shores Community Associa- tion to amend a previously approved dredging permit-fo'aTjow d"isposal of dredged material at sea - approval of the; amendment. (A report from the Marine Department���F'� 12. The following budget amendments were approved: BA's BA-019, $12,486.00 increase in Budget Appropria- tions for interest payments for 1977-78 and 1978- 79 on three lots purchased at $165,000 from the State which was inadvertently omitted from the budget, from Unappropriated Surplus, Building Excise Tax Fund. BA-020, $8,000.00 increase in Budget App pria- tions for Street Lighting Energy Conse ation Program, from Unappropriated Surplus General Fund. BA-021, $37,960.00 transfer o udget Appropria- tions for completion of fun ng for City share of Cooperative Beach Erosion ontrol Project, from Repair Ocean Piers to B ach Erosion Control Project, General Fun OVED FR THE CONSENT CALENDAR: Motion x win items removed from the Consent All Ayes re postponed to November 27, 1978: oposed ordinance, being, AN ORDINANCE OF Bluff CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH ADDING SECTION Atha Development 1.080 TO THE NEWPORT BEACH MUNICIPAL CODE Regulations TLED "DEVELOPMENT OF BLUFF SITES" (RELAT- (3061) TO PLANNED COMMUNITIES), Planning ission Amendment No. 515, initiated by City of Newport Beach with a report from the Community Development Department. (H-la) % (b) A letter from Kent S. Moore suggesting Animal �+ stiffer penalties for dog owners who do not Control clean up after their pets with a proposed (862) r` sign. (H-3b) Volume 32 - Page 292 Y OF NEWPORT EACH !LLF' UNCILMEN MINUTES S'AROLL �v'� s November 13, 1978 INDEX (c) A letter from Ralph D. Anderson, M.D. and a Height & petition bearing six signatures requesting a Density moratorium on building permits for remodeling Regulations of houses on Kings Road that would change the (1279) height of the existing structure. (H-3d) (d) A letter from the Newport Harbor Area Chamber Elections of Commerce requesting that a public hearing (12F) be set to change the local election to coincide with the statewide elections. (H-3k) (e) A letter from Herman Kimmel & Associates, Traffic Inc. stating that they are making every Model effort to meet the December, 1978 schedule (673) for the Traffic'Model. (H-4h) (f) The following General Plan Amendments (H-9): General Plan (A) General Plan Amendment No. 78-2, a (673) request to consider the following proposed amendments to the Land Use and Residential Growth Elements to include: 1. Proposed change of use or reduction in allowable intensity of develop- ment on the major commercial/ industrial undeveloped sites, including, but not limited to, the following: a) Newport Center b) Castaways Commercial Site Bayview Landing Site d San Diego Creek Sites e) MacArthur/jamboree Site 2. Prop ed reduction in the number of dwells g units allowable on the major r sidential undeveloped sites, i luding, but not limited to, the f lowing: a) Westba Site b) Newporte North c) Freeway R ervation East d) Fifth Aven Parcels e) CALTRANS We f) Beeco Propert g) Roger's Garden and Vacant Residential Par el to the South h) Castaways Residen ial Site i) Bastbluff Remnant j) Big Canyon k) Newport Center Condos 1) Baywood Expansion (A report from the Community Development Department) Volume 32 - Page 293 MARINE DEPARTMENT • November 13, 1978 ITEM NO.: H-11 (c) TO: MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL FROM:' Marine Department SUBJECT: REQUEST BY DOVER SHORES COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION TO AMEND A PREVIOUSLY APPROVED DREDGING PERMIT TO ALLOW DISPOSAL OF DREDGED MATERIAL AT SEA INSTEAD OF ON NORTH STAR BEACH Recommendation If desired, approve the request subject to the approval of the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers. Discussion On April 11, 1977, the Council approved a harbor permit to allow dredging of the Dover Shores Channels and deposit the dredged material on North Star Beach adja- • cent to the project site. Subsequent to the City Council approval, the applicant has been attempting to obtain the necessary State and Federal agencies approval. All of these were obtained except the State Coastal Commission. The applicant was unable to resolve the Coastal Commission objections and therefore has decided to request an amendment to their City permit to allow disposal at the EPA designated site four miles at sea. DAVID HARSHBARGER, DIRECTOR MARINE EPARTMENT G n E. Welden Tidelands Administrator GEW:11 Attachments 0 I* � 9 IN 1 DISPOSAL SITE �t UPPER NOTE: NEWPORT APPROXIMATELY 5000 \BAY C.Y. OF GRANULAR �\ PIP. n°iu0— MATERIAL TO BE \ ""`'w' DREDGED BY HYDRAULI DREDGING AND SITED AT ""'\NiJI 0\ DEPO \\ DISPOSAL SITE. TILL a M.M (I I \ um" I -- +9'6" -- EXIST/ND 8MMEAD I MOPE 3 0 100 200 3001"t PURPOSE: MAINTENANCE OF BERTHING AREA NEWPOK BEACH rPROJECT II LOCATION p,a eµeOA D sl VICINITY MAP RI o .e PROPOSED DREDGING AND DISPOSAL IN NEWPORT BAY AT NEWPORT BEACH, CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF ORANGE APPLICATION BY DOVER SHORES .COMMUNITY ASSOC. SHEET I OF 1 I 3 DOVER W SHORES C O M M U N I T Y • A S S O C I A T I O N t rovember 6, 1978 Iqr. Olen Welden Marine Department 3300 Newport Beach Blvd. Newport Beach, Ca. 92663 Dear Vr. welden: On April 11, 1977 the mayor and city council approved a permit allowing us to maintenance dredge our channels, and to deposit the mat- erial on North Star Beach. Because of our • inability to secure a permit from one govern- ment agency, we request an amendment to our permit allowing us to dispose of the dredged material at sea. Thank you for your past help. 5 cerely, Owen McLean Member of the Board. of Directors 404 Eveninli Star Lane Newport Beach, Ca. 92660 r association manager , devine properties, p.o. box 667, corona del mar, ca 92625 CRY OF NEWPORT BEICH COUNCILMEN 'A� * 9 O�iPy� �G\i c`��N'�„A CALL 9 °^Tyy yys LL P % April 11, 1977 MINUTES lotion x The following resolutions were adopted: kyes ioes Ix, x x x x x Resolution No. 9051 authorizing the Mayor and R-9051 City Clerk to execute a Cooperative Agreement between the County of Orange and the City of Newport Beach for construction of roadway improvements in unincorporated county area at the southwesterly corner of Jamboree Road and Bristol Street. Resolution No. 9052 authorizing the Mayor and R-9052 ty Clerk to execute a right-of-way certifi- cat n for Jamboree Road widening from Eastb f Drive (North) to MacArthur Boule- bard. 6. A report was presen d from the Marine Department Boat regarding a request fr the Imua and Newport Storage Outrigger Clubs to store �a d launch canoes from the public bay beach streeds at loth and 19th and West Bay respectively. lotion x Councilman Ryckof£ made a motion to a rove the permit, subject to the conditions of ap oval recommended by the staff. Craig Leeper, representing both outrigger clubs, addressed the Council and stated he was present to answer questions. Ayes x x x x x x x A vote was taken on Councilman Ryckoff's motion, which motion carried. _ 7. A report was presented from the Marine Department Harbor regarding Harbor Permit Application #0111-100 by Permit Dover Shores Community ssociation to ma ntenance dredge and to place the dredged material on North Star Beach. Marine Director David Harshbarger gave a brief staff report. Motion x The application was approved, subject to the conditions of appro`vaT"'reriommen3eH-'liy staff. Ayes x x x x x x x — — — — — — CONSENT CALENDAR: Motion x The following items were approved by one motion affirm - Ayes x x x x x x x ing the actions on the Consent Calendar. 1. The following ordinance was introd a and passed to second reading on April 25 1 77: (a) Removed fromConsent Calendar. �t�he 2. The following resolutions were adopted: �(a) RResolution No. 9053'recognizing the First of May as Law Day. (Attached) Law Day R-9053 l (b) Resolution No. 9054 approving the destruction Juvenile of Juvenile Arrest Records ordered sealed by Arrest the Court. (Attached) (Report from the City Records Attorney attached) R-9054 i Volume 31 - Page 96 CITY OF NEWPORT BEALH MINUTES Motion Ayes 11, 1977 2. The appointment of a member to replace William R. Holmes as a member on the Environmental Quality Control Citizens Advisory Committee x x x was postponed to April 25. Motion Ixlxlxlxlxlxlx Ayes Motion Ayes Motion Ayes x x x 13 Motion Ayesxxxxxx Abstain lllxlll,l CURRENT BUSINESS: 1. A letter from Duane C. Black was presented advisin, that he and his wife have moved to Long Beach, and that he will no longer be able to serve on the Bicycle Trails Citizens Advisory Committee. Duane Black's resignation from the Bicycle Trails Citizens Advisory Committee and Pat Black's resignation from the Board of Library Trustees were accepted with regret; the City Clerk was directed to prepare Certificates of Appreciation; he appointment of a replacement member for Duane ack on the Bicycle Trails Citizens Advisory Co ittee was postponed to April 25; and the app ntment o£ a member to the Board of Library True es to fill the unexpired term of Pat Black endin June 30, 1977 was referred to the Council Annoint ents Committee. CEQCAC Bicycle Trails CAC/ Board of Library Trustees 2. The Mayor as directed to send a letter to the Solid General Se ices Agency of Orange County requesting Waste the County t reconsider an amendment to the County Solid ste Management Plan to provide for an additional ansfer station facility in the vicinity of the range County Airport. 3. Letters from the H bor Towing Co. and Coast Police Tow Truck Towing Service requ ting an increase in rates for towing and storage w e referred to staff for Service report back on April 4. A report was presented f m the Public Works Encroach - ment/ Director regarding the re eat of Stewart Woodard to construct an automobile ridge with with 3601 Ocean railings to serve as a garag approach at 3601 CdM Ocean Boulevard, Corona del Mayor Pro Tem Barrett stepped do from the Council table due to a possible c flict of interest. Stewart Woodard, applicant, addresse the Council. Lars de Jounge, President of the Friend of Inspiration Point, addressed the Council nd asked that action be deferred pending a court de ision on the adjacent lot. The application of Stewart Woodard was approv , subject to the applicant's signing a hold-harml as agreement. , Mayor Pro Tom Battett resumed his seat at the Council table. 5. A report was presented from the Public Works Director regarding Jamboree Road widening from Eastbluff Drive (North) to MacArthur Boulevard. Volume 31 - Page 95 Jamboree Road Widening 0 MARINE DEPARTMENT April 11, 1977 ITEM NO.: G-7 TO: MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL FROM: Marine Department SUBJECT: HARBOR PERMIT APPLICATION BY DOVER SHORES COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION TO MAINTENANCE DREDGE APPROXIMATELY 5,000 CUBIC YARDS RECOMMENDATION If desired, approve the project subject to the following conditions: 1. The approval of the U. S. Array Corps of Engineers. 2. Dredging depths shall not exceed the original design depths for the channels. (Minus 8 feet MLLW, with 3 to 1 side slopes to minus 3 feet at the bulkheads.) 3. The "alternate" basin layout shall be used, with 3 basins which do not utilize the existing drainage course. 4. An encroachment permit shall be obtained from the Public Works Department for the discharge pipes located in the public streets. 5. During the course of the work dredging rates shall be adjusted as necessary so that the discharge water returning to the Bay from the final settling basin does not contain excessive silt. 6. Dredging rates shall also be adjusted as necessary so as to preclude over filling of the settling basins and possible breaching of the dikes. 7. The disposal site shall be graded and restored at the conclusion of the work. Unsuitable material shall be buried under at least one foot of material which is suitable for beach use. 8. The work to be done shall be set forth in plans and specifications which are sufficiently complete to accurately delineate the work and the applicable requirements. For ease of preparation, the specifications may be in the form of notes on the plan if desired. 9. The plans and specifications shall be reviewed and approved by a properly qualified licensed civil engineer. An estimated of quantities shall also be prepared, and reviewed by the engineer. 10. A faithful performance bond in the amount of $3,000 shall be provided by the permittee or by the contractor to ensure that the work is properly completed. 11. The final plans and specifications shall be reviewed and approved by the City's Grading Engineer; and the completed work shall be subject to the approval of the Grading Engineer. 12. The settling basins shall be enclosed with fencing in accordance with Community Development Department requirements. DISCUSSION The Dover Shores Community Association has applied to the Marine Department for a permit to dredge approximately 5,000 cubic yards of material from the Dover Shores channels and place the dredged material on North Star Beach adjacent to the project site. 0 0 PAGE TWO DOVER SHORES MAINTENANCE DREDGING PROJECT The Dover Shores Community Association wishes to dredge because of a build up of silt in the channels which is causing damage to vessels and docks. Preliminary plans submitted by the applicant have been reviewed by the City Engineer resulting in the above reocmmended conditions of approval. During the course of obtaining necessary County, State, and federal Agencies approvals, additional conditions and restrictions will undoubtedly be placed on the project. Upon completion of the dredging and dredge spoil placement, the North Star Beach area will be restored to original or better condition. Several existing holes on the beach will be filled and the ground leveled. Based on the City Engineer's recommendations and preliminary contacts with other permit agencies, staff is of the opinion that placement of dredge spoils on North Star Beach will not degrade the area and the completed project may enhance the area by eliminating existing holes. D. HARSHBARGER, DIRECTOR MARINE DEPARTMENT G1 gel Tidelands Administrator GEW:II Attachments DOVER: TTTMM� SHORES C O M M U N I T Y ASSOCIATION SUBJECT: REASONS FOR DREDGING DOVER SHORES' CHANNELS With silted condition in the channels it is creating tremen- dous problems for the residents who have boats in this area. Most of the boats moored in this area are resting in the mud at low tide each day. This causes damage to the propellors, the shafts, and rudders; and also can cause sever damage to the bottom of the boat itself which could show up later when running at sea. Add- itionally, it is very damaging to the engines' cooling systems which is caused by sucking up silt and it results in costly re- pair bills. The cost of a haul -out for a 25 to 50 foot boat is from $150 to $560, and the cost of physical damage to the boat would be in excess of these prices. It is necessary for boat owners to go to sea and return at low tide because of the height of the Pacific Coast Highway Bridge. There is also damage to the docks which are primarily designed for floating. There is a severe strain when part of the dock is resting on the silt and the remainder is floating. The pilings are uprotted and structural damage to the docks are incurred. association manager, devine properties, p.o. box 687, corona del mar, ca 92625 DOVER.. W SHORES C O M M U N I T Y ASSOCIATION EMERGENCY MAINTENANCE DREDGING DOVER SHORES COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION Project Description: In this area storm drains discharge into the channels. We also get a great deal of silt and debris from storm run-offs from the back bay. The purpose of the dredging is to restore the channels to safe navigable water depths. The dredge material at this location is silt and not virgin material. The estimated quantity to be dredged is 5000 C.Y. Hydraulic. means will be used. The dredged material will be piped across our beaches and down the east gutters of Polaris and across North Star Lane into the entrance of White Cliff. The dredged material will flow into the first holding basin of the three basins shown on the map. It will be necessary to build small ramps over the pipes at the.entrance of Evening Star Lane and North Star Lane to take care of traffic. The basins have been created by utilizing the existing holes on the property. (See photographs) The first basin is the largest and will be'equipped with a pipe near the top so the water can run into the second basin when the first is near full, and so on into the third.basin. The heavy material in the water will settle to the bottom of the first basin and possibly some into the second. The water running from the second to the third basin should be completely devoid of sand and debris. By the time the water is returned to the bay from the third basin it should be clean. These association manager, devine properties, p.o. box 687, corona del mar, ca 92625 i Page 2 • holding basins are sand that was dredged from these channels originally, so a portion of the water will be filtered through the sand as it goes back into the bay. This procedure was re- cently used at Sunset Beach with'great success. These channels are privately owned by,the Dover Shore residents, and the cost of the dredging will be paid for by the Dover Shores Community Association --not by -the tax payer. In order to avert this deteriorating condition, any effort to expedite the processing and approval of this project by the government agencies involved would be greatly appreciated by the Dover Shores Homeowners'. ,�{ }r.-. • �' - „�y;" •-. :. `•., =: _ " .-:.,-r '• -yam*-^m-"_c+ir.).•^""w `• '-. '1�.Aw�l *�' ;.t: g._t•4�. •-•.-..�.y..r j11, .)••', S`\. .,,• _ � •:,5.::" ;,mac- -' Y*:. _.-..'�''�.,„...•»•-,.-_ ... � � ty» _ � "p.:,.. • `F. j-.�i� ��, IY{ -- - ^ice'-;:1�'wGa �4 •,a 1n •rt''':.' 3.:-S,v:�•-•<i- \ � f F" - <✓_ '�. _ _ c:4Y •e_ �•�r--:.a�•'_A,n'�'%•�`{.':•�: \ I �.i1.:r. ems•.% •s. .. / -•a..-: c�=� 1.. �'Ly:a'irJ �:• •c - _ � �•/�-:Fa-.y'.�t 3:=y::G��r^..'f'.'.'�:}'^�•• � �. -..,: rr^�,R`.Ji � /.•- - '� � �_=--.''�:.+'.'•'.._i..��`"t. �. � .:- a�l`c.GaS�;i".v w�.a-yY.>.-->:J;a).,"�ti •.' � 'rt •r• .v:.:%� .% F+]•` "F. a{ '_' t.y. .tiik::c,l �• .t^ Y'a �.,:: .ni4oyPy:�r*,;:. ir.r^n� •`^{•3'>r^,.`a 7,' 'k-{ ��r %`�' .6,-]� i•`,-., ��,i:-if?:Si,arY..^�T �'.',nu 'y�p'�.,�. ti�„`�. ."�.i�'al": {r: 4 ly1- �i-a_�L_'.1' ..0: � Y, 1�''%'If IJfU l" - r� :+f':'"_-� r ) "�,'_7: ��i-�^a rs.� .:...at>n_ L.r- n,s ,4oi: fw� ijaf•rt. i` r;':,.. �-.�,,. _a 7 ��I(]}i*i�_1 " ,...r_ rlat �i .f�Vy "�..: _.• �••_fr-.' � y z�+�:: (�r '� „•3»_ '�� }jJ u�\{. ^ .� ' "ci'.... . � �. � arc- �' T• ,c✓..:.. ...tom Lid;(-- �o'• (�,, r, l�'. _ :N41A, �I �4 '��.-� `Q"-^3� i'•`�•`I�'•'�D �� �.r•l�'S•`'i'• .... '.Ym-riy t.,, c*:�rAti:r�'-`ti^ w , : � .- � --•�G del .:�.-i f.. k- .� .r � r e1, 'L,.�-...�✓ -, + - . • ti' i x.�yyr• ts,�, .`yr, itF `=}'�'�x =- _-4'?�i`�. _ y�`� , •:•....:....,�o...•,.-. ., a :. v'y,. "� ::4. :"•'".••S rTF'_F" 'l•., l\' -_1,i _ �! � I `, • / ,L`Y. •�� _ \�� // r�ty�'srS `-' �, '�,jqa �3 !. -`�-„i�:.:i�_��"-- .t _ !r/ .mot:: s.'.. ;:� � •�, r �•��.' f"'"�.�G:.`.°2�'Av '�' `�.yn�' 1, _ t .. � \� • - i9' � is - ,4 , � ^li._.�'.•-c. _ 1 ..i -- ' - Ni :1i � - f:^y„i+.x 1i1 J. �•tiZ �' � Jr J• - \ t `\ :„z,,, 'A-t - •i' �+'ey` is�,�1�%�'k.:•S:a±\r'• ^S'. r.i•:�? 1�'i;-1C�' ___ ,,•,1 ���\„+\, ^'• fir. CAI t,.:. _ •.•..�,y• ` .ra.k {:';.::.`.`-'±�. >4 fr- i,h �,: "", y{.\y 'rx %�'•`� ����';`-�..`�-t:,-.r:.. ni'fit r1-,hl'., `_�:�. T:�~;,�ert`•.':u3��~"Si•:i:�'S*„^b:c• . sH 4;: '�e. - 54 Y,•, -��' x.r.-•'�•�,\ 'rC> _ � `� Y .a: •.G.,2r• -� ,6_�e "S✓-:�f r..r:. v =F:-re r� s- :. "?, \• y � � •'-!>♦ '���'�' '<•pr"T :^•r',� ..7; vy`i.-'::i:. :.i���� .tt�%..�'d r-'L"..�•�,'r...Zl '�,-'I 'a�`^.: - : r i,e...`��\. , rI :•, � ��'iy � ':ri,-r, ••r- �i'•, w, A33 :: - trlm- .x'.�.C,y"�y "*rt�`.}'�''1,` "'',,,r-,'.�•. �:5'{ • O•: `T .i-,-•-n. __ __ __ _- � E` .� -v"' :.:. t\�;j lre„' `t _. __ - \ ��.�1 w; :a.z 'ty: `;,'p ^1c,.t{.'.^:,V:.... - ^`': ,�F• •:1 _Yu _ _ 'w,. �,�"�;A'•t' "' ON r 't a • •'7.-'!i:`yy}).,��_�� a, rx-.t.r_'+y.. ": i.�.•}:,t4',rs_� s..-.„', v - \.- `--' ''•,;.1,1^, �"',' ' •IJ. V=A .:: �: n, .13.3'•.i. .... .,•n, ,w,iw V � i� la�.tit y.'i�. •�.. �A ' "" 1-_ _�r�:Ni-.^N �rt� i... = '.3�\ �l..l, i��°�' -• ' ', �jY rvA 43 ,Y 4�`- s i h ' �-,",, .�` `'STAR''..• ._'l'__..__ ,- ,dtX_', i t' y ' :.. � :n:'� 0:'-'' _ N — �.:,•"i �'?:: rim` .war r • t �� l �`�a.� s, ` •'�-i .♦� . { _ Wit'-^t' 3#.,'-. 2'eir `i3�`' `y+} .... II � , i �, ���"r'y. - 1 � • �-'', • ..._ ��^r :-.y `.:,-�__,. ec}i.-';;�ik?;n�:ti_ari+,F. •. '7�.,. :»��;�+..t ; r V�\�''yt;,F )) 'Y_ y ';4 •`') `<" � rw'�'-S:'-'�`eti, xS+:a�L� ik:.>-.ems..+•t'+aJ i Yeti'?'-:`:tiL:.i:�:.. f�;��,,} 1 wb�t,"'a-,- «,'h: �s'7t3 --`c 3•`••-• � ••,jF•«A , y..,...,.,,. r Ii J'y'- ��!!-!,��,yy.�•,i.a':iQ+�rw':3'"-4�.•s�,`�a�`�:..,s.:yY��'"i�,"rr mil.' i:g��°, x��Fl.'�;.t ;.) `•+',u ;� r:••''`. iGtj' 1i..• iy'aw 4,•e•_1,'✓:• �, 1 tt: ,-•i.Yyn�\�\ •', �}' ts:.. • �}, -' =- 'i+Yi+Ll': K• i �• , L., y",r:Fat_�if'�?;�L:�n".•>5,,. �M," \•••t^-,..• ,t. t � _�'•i .uaR�•'.1.'F••^�"Mi.:,Y`'``( ,'s"..m``''Y Yt��^�'?�^r?., ^' r Qi :Nix>R�rsi'P'. y 2-+'"-' !4. > ,. c .r'» '4-.,,���...rrr .•.,. "•. " i � 5' €.. `;,-r" i st'.�• � rr ,�.,`_�`-�'�+,•Y.�r+t,`.?cn",a:;���{'.iwn�,; i'g; �'r?:'.i:;'--n.`., ��.� _`4w". •• _4.1 !_ �F'L`••-': ;. '.sue ttP. :r'+-_., r� '��.^ roe-», a. �.:' :�''�:; ,f-' y .1 '•,•:. , /,�f,�C:�rl.^'�-S'.:y"����lY',L�f ,.'.'%_a '.j%-'�'�.?K sff.'i.": ��L f !•:.4 T� 1. •-' ,. ,Y- y. _ , _- `]"'a`c• r•;•^j{r Sw:,�•ds .-s.�„mow->�. . �• 'R.:y :,; a- t�', - Y,, .•� 'CC '6y`STaAn�y a-'�•••-.,t •.::,.::. .. � 2.3'.�'`-•=•Y y`!«+�'9r� � � ll ` ` _� l-'i •� '•. •. a� ,c: i,<,_,,,y�-U•»;}=.✓;1y''._,_. „•+ O T"`:'-r' {," c'' a, LZ, 'Ar '\\tl �'S `y At•i• -•ye' ..>y.^','*"w:.: "'%• � !'�.l !. -M1 %.A:•r-sa' wrCh�'et \3 `:• // „rih.t 4+' C" 9'0% 't.'Yi'�':r.� a• ��:� i : x;,;�✓:•L .ss�s• rns.-'r," (�f,�M' kl , �� 9 ^t.c� P't. v i `l :c`i _ r?Y_• 3,4_,FT?A' •`A `i,'�, •`�4��: ,t -ter\�, .� ,�.ti•��}y {, _j•- airy \i-��,�1::;�r.;_..<-!'',7:'3'M`''�'4�}\�-sy', Y,, .yl\�- ,- ./ •^ .' t,^ .•}��':?r�f �,-i•Y�0 .! l� � l ``�\\{�+'•� 1t:, �r,.t�y Y.� �C;'.;'Y. ,I,n'i�•��yy' y/�j' .' ; ii c5'-•.; �� � `�la.;f,_ +-°�.G 0� �.:, • i -..t' •t,<'y':3.... \'�,;.:s v:C"t.'�°.1�rr`�-�`= <C #� ' \ `:./ -,.. j� '+''a :, •- 'i.o i Y4•,'', y" <. or w5r♦y o"� ny, i�.t.-nl ." 3„r / ::1 4`)I il. "j, :."`-j �J:4 •Gr,`t�".4�`Yfr}"'i'F +.rJ"F .� ,��..� .,s':.irt�-�.='•' � .G� '., i1�t`•�' Y' :,..' �?L•"t:-n.�T"t`±Fl:;S[ i_ I /` �r - �� f: :'.-,;�;t�' ra � (�`�('�'K•1I �i'•/�j%,ry` '/.ha, r.,/' /. =i-`' Watt. \- �:`'}l�/-:;::'•'' r �}:;i � e, l�'' w I', � / I' }; •'t, .,.' !��//: '•',+i,, '� -w,% .M7�'M. '�.--i ':+)t -!Y it �� v-:'+°u-,r.'ni :_' `�.�-`\--`ii�", rjrA-`.� ,/y��I •� <A' 'Gi _ '.Y%��,S:�t: v" I / r:t ,� u:^e ". a �,,rA.i'• .., �i r' c. ?.. ry: A ,�.: I.! - yIt _ bna.�,?'+"-.'>Hc.^ qvt.->r.��'y�•,_ ` .-�...�'- l J �F"� ",•f�WrtS:,Yy',✓.y`� _ .'ia'"' C-T,,;z�rA SR a...�'.!:w4i``»tih:-F _•. \ ., f.�.,�'•-` 'an •'- �^i-•- i ,pry��. `�`:�-h r"'•l:"`•, `- - _ ��_ -'f` a+tt^ �_-: d, l:_r-`:-..c:i'.: ;, �."--`a Olal :4-..,--:.v,�s q I a 3 � S fL 5 4 P 3 DOVOR 'SlAoRES Souwptucs FRor O.00 M.l.l.N. ALL .50IwNDIN6b MINKS Rv4C SS 'OTHERWISE INDICATED By Sb4.E11 MR1tER, INC. 1 DREDGING PROJECT TO RESTORE WATER AREAIS AROONO DOVER SHOREb TO ITS ORIGINAL NAVIGABLE CONDITION, 1°°nr"T'e. .Ix,•awr,nr) V110 Aln n y 1 -NORTH STAR _ 1 4 I . 'J S Y FILL eDRA//J� CAPnCITY y LA'S/N • /R Dpp Crr yqM. CPP9uTY ` + y,� J��•, 1 IItl��Il�lii `II .I ALTERNATE BA51N LAYOUT R