The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutLIDO PENNISULA LAND DESIGNATIONLIDO PENNISULA LAND DESIGNATION GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT SESSION FOR FEBRUARY, 1975 Amendment to change land use designation for Lido Peninsula to provide for only residential use for all areas currently under residential use and to prohibit further commercial development. (Requested by the Lido Peninsula Community Association) NOTE: This amendment does not have a number because it was not set for public hearing by the Planning Commission January 16, 1975 - Planning Commission did not set this item for public hearing. January 27, 1975 - City Council upheld the Planning Commission's decision to not set this item for public hearing. COUNCILMEN MINUTES om\ °n xm9p�m�o ROLL CALL A ; q� N12 apm January 27, 1975 INDEX 3. A letter from Paul J. Gruber was presented resigning i I Bicentenni from the Bicentennial Citizens Advisory Committee. Citizens Adv Comte j The resignation of Paul J. Gruber (District 1) was Motion x accepted with regret; and Councilman Barrett's Ayes K x x x x (District 3) appointment of Pat Cleary as an alternate Absent x I on the Bicentennial Citizens Advisory Committee was confirmed. 4. Councilman Rogers (District 1) appointment of Margaret Envorommnt_ Stivers ass member of the Environmental Quality Qual Contr Control Citizens Advisory Committee to replace Ellis Citizens Motion x Glazier, who had resigned, was confirmed; and Council- Adv Comte Ayes K x x x x man Ryckoff's (District 5) appointment of Steven Absent x Donaldson as a member of the Environmental Quality Control Citizens Advisory Committee to replace Dr. Cotman, who had resigned, was confirmed. CURRENT BUSINESS: 1. A report was presented from the Community Development Annex 80 Department regarding request of Erwin de Mocskonyi, Valerie B. Avellar, et al., to annex forty-six acres generally bounded by Santa Isabel Avenue on the north, Tustin Avenue on the east, Twenty -Second Street on the south and Santa Ana Avenue on the west, zoned R-1 by County; designated Bay Knolls Annexation No. 80.. A letter from Pat and Robert Krone was presented in favor of the Bay Knolls Annexation. Erwin de Mocskonyi and Bob Carolan addressed the Council regarding the drainage problem Resolution No. 8422, consenting to the commencement R-8422 of annexation proceedings pursuant to the Inhabited Motion Territory Annexation Act of 1913 to be known as Ayes x x x Annexation No. 80 (Bay Knolls), was adopted; and the Noes x staff was instructed to report back to the Council at Absent x I the February 10 Study Session. 2. A report was presented from the Public Works Director Alley regarding alley paving in Block 3, East Newport (City Paving block bounded by Balboa Boulevard, Bay Avenue, 6th Street and Island Avenue). Motion The staff was directed to notify owners of property Ayes X x x x x in Block 3, East Newport, to construct a portland Absent x 7 cement concrete alley, using the procedure found in Chapter 27 of the Improvement Act of 1911. 3. A report was presented from the Community Development General Department regarding the Planning Commission's con- Plan sideration of setting public hearings for requested Amendments amendments to the Newport Beach General Plan. Motion x The Planning Commission's decision that a public Ayes x x x x Rearing is unwarranted on the proposed amendment rn . Absent x 31 the General Plan for the Lido Peninsula wag ,+nhe'el- Volume 29 - Page 20 •- r. COUNCILMEN C*y � m ROL rAL1. mNO 9f Nm5Z��to January OF NEWPORT BOTCH MINUTES 27. 1975 INDEX Motion x The Planning Commission was instructed to set General Ayes x x x Plan Amendment hearings on recommendations for improv- Noes K x ing the circulation on the Pdcific Coast Highway in Absent x accordance with the current circulation needs at .Specific Points 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 (Dover Drive to Newport Boulevard, Upper Bay Bridge to Dover Drive, Jamboree Road and the Upper Bay Bridge, MacArthur to Jamboree Road and MacArthur through Corona del Mar). 4. A report was presented from the Marine Department' Harbor regarding Harbor Permit Application #221-081 of Permit Delaney's Cannery Village (Mr.. James Schmitz) to revise existing slips and to construct a new bulkhead. Motion K The matter was continued to.February 10, 1975._ Ayes K x x x Abstain x' Absent x 5. A letter from The Bluffs Home Owners'Association was Private presented requesting Council's reconsideration to Streets authorize the enforcement of parking regulations on " the private streets in the Bluffs with existing conditions. Motion The matter was tabled. Ayes x x x -- Absent x " 6. A letter from The Irvine Company was presented solicit- Annex 81 ing the City's support at the Local'Agency Formation . Commission hearing on February 13 in connection with proposed Harbor View Hills Sector IV.(Phase 4).annexa- tion to the City of Newport Beach, proposed Annexation No. 81: Motion x The matter was referred to the Community Development Ayes It K x x x Department for inclusion in report to the Local Absent x Agency Formation Commission. 7.' A letter from Gene Atherton, Chairman of•"PARKS", was PARKS presented requesting to be heard before the Council regarding a higher local park standard. Dr. Gene Atherton addressed the Council. Motion x The matter was referred to the Parks, Beaches and Ayes K K x x x Recreation Commission. Absent x . CONSENT CALENDAR: Motion K The following items were approved by one motion affirming " Ayes K x x x the actions on the Consent Calendar: Absent x x 1.- The following ordinance was introduced and passed to , second reading on February 10, 1975: Proposed Ordinance No. 1599, being, AN ORDINANCE OF Unclaimed - THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH AMENDING CHAPTER 1.20 OF Property THE NEWPORT BEACH MUNICIPAL CODE DEALING WITH LOST 0-1599 AND UNCLAIMED PROPERTY, reducing the holding period from six months to three months." (A report from City Attorney was presented with copy of ordinance.) Volume 29 - Page 21 City Council Meeting January 27, 1975 Agenda Item No. G-3 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH January 22, 1975 TO: City Council FROM: Department of Community Development SUBJECT: Planning Commission"s Action Regarding Setting of General Plan Amendments for Public Hearing. At the January 16, 1975 Planning Commission meeting, the Commission received' requests for initiation of General Plan amendments for the next amendment session and decided to set six of the seven suggested amendments for public hearing at the February 20, 1975 Planning Commission meeting. The Planning Commission decided that consideration of the amendment suggested by the Lido Peninsula Community Association was unwarranted. This amendment would change the land use designation of Lido Peninsula to prohibit further commercial development. In making this decision, members -of the Planning Commission discussed the fact that the current designation for Lido Peninsula requires the development of an overall plan by the property owner which will be reviewed at public hearings before both the Planning Commission and City Council prior to any further development; this gives the City complete control over the type of development and gives the citizens ample opportunity for public input. Attached are copies of all letters requesting Planning Commission r. TO: City Council - 2 initiation of General Plan amendments, and a7ll letters relating to these requests. Following is a list of all of the suggested amendments considered by the Planning Commission: Element(s) ' 1. Land Use and Residential Growth 2. Land Use and Residential Growth 3. Land Use and Residential Growth 4. Land Use and Residential Growth 5. Land Use and Residential Growth Proposed Amendment Change land use designation of Pacific View property (50 acres, north of Pacific View Memorial Park) from "Governmental, Educational and Institutional" to "Low Density Residential". (Requested by Broadmoor Homes, Inc.) Change land use designation of lot at 809 East Bay Avenue (in Central Balboa) from "Retail and Service Commercial" to "Two -Family Residential". (Requested by Billie M. Hickok, property owner.) Change land use designation for the property on the north side of Coast Highway easterly of Jamboree Road from "Low -Density Residential" to "Administrative, Pro-fessional and Financial Commercial". (Requested by the Irvine Company, property owner.) Redefine "Low -Density Residential"; create new category: "Medium Density Residential"; apply redefined "Low -Density Residential" designation to Castaway, North Newporter, and a portion of Jamboree/Coast Highway. vacant sites; apply new "Medium Density Residential" designation to a portion of Jamboree/Coast Highway vacant site; change wording in Resi- dential Growth Element. (Requested by Paul Ryckoff.) i TO: City Council - 3 Element(s) Propos-ed Amendment 6. Land Use, Residential (Reset General Plan Amendment No. 16) Growth, and Recreation Add park area on the west side of and Open Space Marguerite Avenue at Harbor View Drive. (The Parks, Beaches and Recreation Commission is reviewing, as directed by City Council, and will submit recommendation prior to the February 20, 1975 public hearing.) 7. Land Use Element Designate "Old -Newport Boulevard Area" for a Specific Area Plan by adding Specific Area Plan boundary designation on Land Use Plan (map). The Planning Commission's decisions were made pursuant to Council Policy Q-1 which provides that: "If the Planning Commission, after examination, is convinced that the proposed change is worthy of consideration, it may initiate amendment as set forth above. If not, the Commission shall forward the request to the City Council with its recommendation that consideration of amendment is unwarranted." Council Policy Q-1 further states that the: "City Council, after consideration of the •request and of the report from the Planning Commission, may either direct the Commission to initiate public hearings on the proposed amendment, or may return the request to the originator without further action." Recommended Action Pursuant to Council Policy Q-1, the City Council should either: 1) Uphold the Planning Commission decision against setting a public hearing on the requested General Plan amendment for / Lido Peninsula, and direct that the request be returned to l/ the originators without further action; or 2) Direct the Commission to initiate a public hearing on the / TO: City Council - 4 proposed amendment for Lido Peninsula. Respectfully submitted, COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT . V. Hog'". u-rrgc-cor RVH:TC:jmb Att. v COMMISSIONERS e m s s N m m � CITY OF NEWPORT #ACH (Motion Moti on 7 —.. 1. 9C 107G MINUTES ,rvvcn Item #3 Request to set public hearing for General Plan GENERAL Amendments. PLAN AMEND - Discussion was opened in connection with the MENTS various requests. SET FOR Larry Lizotte, Vice President of Broadmoor Homes, HEARING 17802 Irvine Boulevard, Tustin, appeared before the Commission to answer questions in connection with the request to amend the Land Use and Resi- dential Growth Elements by changing the land use designation of Pacific View property from Govern- mental, Educational and Institutional to Low Density Residential. He briefly reviewed the proposed project and requested that.the amendment be set for hearing. Planning Commission discussed what information was needed at this time to determine jus•ti.fication for setting the public hearing as well as the cost and time factors involved. Based on the potential problems of growing inten- sity in the area and feeling that this proposal X would contribute to these problems, motion was made that the request to change the land use designation of Pacific View property as requested by Broadmoor Homes not be set for hearing. Planning Commission discussed the procedures for determining which requests for General Plan Amend- ments should be set for hearing and there was some feeling that the gui.delines.were inadequate. X Commissioner Williams withdrew his motion and a new motion was made to set a public hearing for February 20, 1975 on all of the requested General Plan Amendments. Chairman Hazewinkel invited comment on any and all of the proposed requests to amend the General Plan and advised 'of his abstention on all matters involving The Irvine Company. Commissioner Heather chaired the meeting during the time Commissioner Hazewinkel was absent. Dave Neish, Manager, Planning Administration, The Irvine Company, appeared before the Commission and requested that the amendment to the Land Use and Residential Growth Elements of the General Plan as requested by Paul Ryckoff and listed as. Page 8. I- COMMISSIONERS m 10 m p Z n p N m • CITY OF NEWPORT JACK January 16, 1975 MINUTES INDEX ROLL GALL r Item 5 in the staff report not -be set for hearing for the reasons stated in a letter which he read into the record, signed by Thomas C. Wolff, Jr., Senior Vice President, Lan'ti Development, The Irvine Company, dated January 16, 1975. Robert Shelton, 500 Newport Center Drive, appeared before the Commission on behalf of Curci-Turner Company in order to determine that a letter dated January 14, 1975, signed by John L. Curci, opposin a request to change the land use designation for Lido Peninsula had been received and was made a . part of the record. Mr. John Kingsley, Acting President of the Lido Peninsula Community Association appeared before the Commission and requested that the requested amendment to the Land Use and Residential Growth Elements of the General Plan relative to the Lido Peninsula be set for hearing. Jean Watt, #4 Harbor Island, appeared before the Commission on behalf of S.P.O.N. and requested that the amendment to the Land Use and Residential Growth Elements of the General Plan as proposed by Paul Ryckoff and listed as Item 5 in the staff report be set for hearing in order to preserve the environment and control density. Bobbie Riddle,resident of Lido Peninsula appeared before the Commission in favor'of setting the public hearing to amend the Land Use and Residen- tial Growth Elements of the General Plan in connection with the Lido Peninsula. Commissioner Seely requested withdrawal of the motion setting all the items for public hearing in order that each matter could be considered individually. Following discussion of the request, the motion was withdrawn. ' Action was then taken on the requests involving The Irvine Company in order that Commissioner Hazewinkel could return to the dais and partici- pate in the other requests. Motion X Motion was made to set'for hearing on February 20, Ayes X X X X X X 1975, the request to amend the Land Use and p Absent X Residential Growth Elements of the General Plan by changing the .land use designation for the property on the north side of Coast Highway east- erly of Jamboree Road from Low Density Residential to Administrative, Professional and Financial Page 9. '- ' COMMISSIONERS v�My m v m£ n m ,% mom QnII rA11 T CITY OF N EVWPORT 9ACN January 16, 1975 MINUTES tt\YG/. Commercial.(Requested by The Irvine Company, property owner.) Motion X Motion was made to set -for hearing on February 20, Ayes X x K x 1975, the request to -amend the Land•Use and Resi- Noes X X dential Growth - Elements of the General Plan in Absent X order to redefine Low Density Residential; create a new category known as Medium Density Residential apply the redefined Low -Density Residential desig- nation to Castaway, North Newporter, and a portion of Jamboree/Coast Highway vacant sites; apply new Medium Density Residential designation to a por- tion of Jamboree/Coast Highway vacant site; change wording in Residential Growth Element. (Requested by Paul Ryckoff.) Commissioner Hazewinkel returned'to the dais. Motion X Motion was made to set for hearing on February 20, 1975, the request to amend the Land Use and Residential Growth Elements of the General Plan changing the land use designation on Pacific View property (80 acres, north of Pacific View Memorial Park) from Governmental, Educational and: Institu- tional to Low Density Residential. (Requested by Broadmoor Homes, Inc.) Discussion indicated there was some feeling that this request was a "cart before the horse" situa- tion and that there were procedural problems involved which needed further review. The questio was raised as to how much preliminary information would be necessary in order to make a decision at the General Plan level and it was felt this also needed further study. Ayes X X X X X Following discussion, the motion was voted on and Noes > carried. (Motion X Motion was made to set for hearing -on February 20, All Ayes 1975, an amendment to the Land Use and Residential Growth Elements of the General Plan to change the land use designation of the lot at 809 East Bay. Avenue (in Central Balboa) from Retail and Service Commercial to Two -Family Residential. (Requested by Billie M. Hickok, property owner.) Motion X Motion was made to set for hearing on February 20, 1975, an amendment to the Land Use and Residential Growth Elements of the General Plan to change the land use designation for Lido Peninsula to provide for only residential use for all areas currently under residential use and to prohibit further Page 10. COMMISSIONERS CITY OF NEWPORT WCH LL it+.ve s (Noes Motion Ayes Abstain Motion All Ayes MINUTES lnnnAry 1A_ 1975 commercial development. (Requested by the Lido Peninsula Community Association.) Discussion 'of the motion included the fact that consideration was recently given to this matter, that the area was appropriate for a specific area plan to be developed within the General Plan designation as presently established, that the major landowner indicated a time factor of approx- ,p imately 10 years before redevelopment and any planning by the staff prior to that time would be premature. X Following discussion, motion was voted on and X X Y X X X failed. Motion was•made to set for hearing on February 20, X X Y X X 1975, an amendment to the Land Use, Residential X Growth and Recreation and Open Space Elements of the General Plan changing the land use designation of the vacant parcel at the corner of Harbor View Drive and Marguerite Avenue from Low Density Residential to Open Space. Motion was made to set for hearing on February 20, 1975, an amendment to the Land Use Element of the General Plan in order to designate the Old Newport Boulevard area for a Specific Area Plan, by adding a Specific Area Plan designation on the Land Use Plan (map). RESOLUTION O. 905 * * * * * * * Planning Commission Resolution No. 905 setting a SUMMARY OF ITEMS SET public hearing for February.20, 1975 to consider FOR PUBLIC Amendments to the Newport Beach General Plan HEARING included the following items as reflected by the above actions: FEB. 20 1. Land Use and Residential Growth Elements - Change land use designation of Pacific View property (50 acres, north of Pacific View Memorial Park) from "Governmental, Educational and Institutional" to "Low Density Residential".' (Requested by Broadmoor Homes, Inc.) 2. Land Use and Residential Growth Elements - Change land use designation of lot at 809 East Bay Avenue (in Central Balboa) from "Retail and Service Commercial" to "Two -Family Residential." (Requested by Billie M. Hickok, property owner.) Page 11. Planning Commission Meeting January 16, 1975 Agenda Item No. CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH January 8,. 1975 TO: Planning Commission FROM: Department of Community Development SUBJECT: Proposed Amendments to the General Plan The next General Plan amendment session, according to Council Policy Q-1, will commence with Planning Commission public hearings in February. Following is a list of all General Plan amendments requested by citizens and property owners (all letters are attached): Element(s) 1. Land Use and Residential Growth 2. Land Use and Residential Growth 3. Land Use and Residential Growth 4. Land Use and Residential Growth 5. Land Use and Residential Growth Proposed Amendment Change land use designation of Pacific View property (50 acres, north of Pacific View Memorial Park) from "Governmental, Educational and Institutional" to "Low Density Residential". (Requested by Broadmoor Homes, Inc.) Change land use designation of lot at 809 East Bay, Avenue (in Central Balboa) from "Retail and Service Commercial" to "Two -Family Residential". (Requested by Billie M. Hickok, property owner.) Change land use designation for the property on the north side of Coast Highway easterly of Jamboree Road from "Low Density Residential" to "Administrative, Professional and Financial Commercial". (Requested by the Irvine Company, property owner.) Redefine "Low Density Residential"; create new category: "Medium Density Residential"; apply redefined "Low -Density Residential" 0 0 TO: Planning Commission - 2 Element(s) (Continued) Proposed Amendment (Continued) designation to Castaway, North Newporter, and a portion of,Jamboree/Coast Highway vacant sites; apply new "Medium Density Residential" designation to a portion of Jamboree/Coast Highway vacant site; change wording in Residential Growth Element. (Requested by Paul Ryckoff.) Also, staff suggests that General Plan Amendment No. 16, regarding proposed park area at the corner of Marguerite Avenue and Harbor View Drive, be set for re -hearing. This amendment was referred to the Parks, Beaches and Recreation Commission for - review and comment; their recommendation is expected prior to the February public hearing's. In addition, staff would suggest that the Planning Commission initiate an amendment to the Land Use Element to designate the "Old Newport Boulevard" area for a Specific Area Plan. (The preparation of a Specific Area Plan for this area was called for by the Planning Commission at the October 18, 1973 public hearings, when the proposed zone change from C-1 to A-P, initiated by the City, was withdrawn.) Recommended Action Staff recommends that the Planning Commission set all of the requested General Plan Amendments for public hearing at the February 20, 1975 Planning Commission meeting. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT R. V. Hogan, Director Director l By q ;. i Cowell Advance Planning Administrator TC:j Attachments