Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutBAYFRONT RESTAURANTS REGULATIONSCity of Newport Beach City Council Minutes March 9, 1998 'Assistant City Manager Wood stated that the committee may not continue to meet the first Monday of the month, but may try to better coordinate with the timing of the City Council and Planning Commission meetings. 22. APPOINTMENTS�'BY THE CITY COUNCIL TO THE AVIATION COMMITTEE (appoir;Ced, by Council upon recommendation of each Council Member). Each of the council members stated thai`they will contact the City Cleric with their appointments. Council Member Glover announced that the next meetingwf the Aviation Committee is scheduled for April 6, 1998, with Supervisor Tom�Wil own as the scheduled speaker. CURRENT BUSINESS 23. BAYPRONT RESTAURANT REGULATIONS (Request of Council Member Hedges). Council Member Hedges stated that the staff report was fairly thorough and a good beginning to the project. Motion by Council Member Glover to refer the issue to the Environmental Quality Affairs Citizens Advisory Committee (EQAC) and the Economic Development Committee (EDC), with direction to look at the possibility of use permit conditions of approval that may be recommended for a majority of restaurants on the bayfront; and that staff be directed to retain a consultant to take noise measurements from existing bayfront restaurants and advise EQAC and EDC on techniques to control noise. Tom.Hyans, member of EQAC, agreed that this issue is a good opportunity for EQAC and EDC to establish a working relationship. Mayor Pro Tem O'Neil confirmed with City Attorney Burnham that the pending restaurant applications before the Planning Commission would continue to be processed. Council Member Noyes stated that he does not want Corona del Mar and the Balboa Island restaurants included in the motion. Council Member Glover confirmed that they were not. Without objection, the motion carried by acclamation. 24 -BOA PENINSULA REVITALIZATION PROGRAM STATUS REPORT. ----- __ Council Member Hedges, chairman of Prompte Revitalization of Our Peninsula (PROP), stated that the meetings of the committee, have been very productive, and some of the topics that have been discussed include -the INDEX No report BayfLont Restaurant Reg (68) Balboa Peninsula Revital PROP (24/68) Volume 51- Page 656 City of Newport Beach City Council Minutes March 9, 1998 Balboa Theatre, signage, adult business regulation, relocation of the Balboa Fire Station and the Balboa Branch Library, commercial property rezoning, design review, and tenant recruitment. Council Member Hedges recommended that a feasibility study be done by staff to look at the possibility and options of relocating the Balboa Fire Station and the Balboa Branch Library. Motiortby Council Member Noyes to direct staff to conduct a feasibility study regarding the relocation of the Balboa Fire Station and the Balboa Branch Library. `'� City Manager"*urphy stated that staff is in the process of looking at the GIS system and wligt the implications would be in moving the Balboa Fire Station. a Council Member Debby stated that she is encouraged by the participation of the local area residekp and businesses. She announced that the nest meeting of PROP would take place on Monday, April 13, 1998, at noon at Newport Landing. Tom Hyans suggested that the phone company building be looked at as a possible site for the relocations, being discussed. Assistant City Manager Wood noted the suggestion, t Council Member Glover asked about the cost of doing an in-house feasibility study. City Manager Murphy responded that the cost would be in pulling staff from other projects they would be working on. He stated that the Fire & Marine and GIS staff have already, begun looking at the possible relocation of the Balboa Fire Station, the implications and response time. City Manager Murphy stated that the next step might involve individuals in the community to look at the value of propertih, the acquisition of new sites and the sale of the existing sites. Virginia Herberts, member of EQAC, stated that she is concerned about the cost of moving the fire station and the library sucha short distance and about the $50,000 that was recently spent on the children's section of the Balboa Branch Library. \ Council Member Hedges directed staff to include in the study the cost of maintaining the current fire station. Louise Fundenberg, 808 West Balboa Blvd., stated that the City'.Council at its meeting of April 28, 1997, voted to eliminate the consideration of forming a redevelopment agency as part of its direction for BPPAC. She stated her opposition to the forming of a redevelopment agency on Balboa Peninsula, or any part of Newport Beach. Will Longyear, 215 Via San Remo, stated that he has not been receiving notification of the meetings involving the changes to the peninsula. He stated that he is concerned about the amount of money being spent on Volume 51-Page 657 E CITY OF NEw,,,*T BEACH Hearin te: March 9, 1998 p4p� COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT Agenda Item No.: yam. 6 PLANNING DEPARTMENT Staff Person: Patricia L. Temple 33 o NEWPORT BOULEVARD 644-3200 NEWPORT BEACH; CA 92656 (74) 644.3200, FAX (7 4) 644-3250 REPORT TO THE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL SUBJECT: Bayfront Restaurant Regulations PURPOSE: Review of options for additional regulation of restaurants in bayfront commercial districts. Included is a discussion of the establishment of a committee to review operational characteristics and design criteria related to bayfront restaurants, and a discussion of options for the allocation of additional resources for code enforcement activities for restaurants in the evening and on weekends. ACTION: Direct staff to prepare a draft Resolution for the consideration of the City Council to establish a Committee to review and make recommendations on restaurant operational characteristics and design criteria, and to retain a consultant to assist with noise issues. Background In response to a request of Councilmember John Hedges, and as directed in the action taken by the City Council on the Windows on the Bay Use Permit, staff has prepared this report to outline potential options to add regulations in the Newport Beach Municipal Code to address operational characteristics and design criteria for restaurants located in bayfront commercial areas. Discussion Regulations for eating and drinking establishments are contained in Chapter 20.82 of the Municipal Code (attached). This chapter establishes physical development standards (such as parking, landscaping and fencing), but does not include any operational standards for restaurants generally. It relies on the Use Permit process to establish appropriate operational limitations. Only the specific provisions for Limited Take Out Service and Accessory Outdoor Dining have operational standards (such as hours of operation; alcoholic beverage service, live entertainment and dancing). Because the City relies on the Use Permit process to establish the specific operational characteristics for each restaurant on a case -by -case basis, each business is subject to individual consideration of conditions of approval. This process creates an inconsistent application of 11 0 requirements from business to business. It would be more equitable and would simplify the process of approval to incorporate operational limitations and design criteria into the Municipal Code. Without conducting an exhaustive analysis of the implications of each, staff has developed the following list of items which could be considered for incorporationinto the Municipal Code. For the internal operations of restaurants: • Hours of operation • Cessation of meal service • Alcoholic beverage service • Live entertainment • Dancing • Use of sound amplification (both pre-recorded and live) For outdoor dining areas: • Hours of operation • Ancillary alcohol service facilities • Live entertainment • Dancing • Use of amplified sound • Amount of outdoor dining area • Outdoor games (such as video tables, arcade games, etc.) • Outdoor paging systems • Special events For all bars and nightclubs: • Security plan approved by Police Department • Hours of operation • Outdoor activities • Live entertainment • Amplified sound • Dancing • 'Special events Restaurant design criteria: • Non-openable windows if live entertainment or amplified sound is permitted • Interior sound absorbing materials usage • Location of entertainment and dancing • Sound control features for outdoor dining • Design and location of trash enclosures Eayfiont Restaurant Regulations Page 2 Review Process As part of the motion on the Windows on the Bay Use Permit, Councilmember Glover included a suggestion that the City Council consider the establishment of a committee, including Council members, residents and business owners, to assess noise issues generated by bayfront business. Staff is of the opinion that this Committee, if established by the Council, could be used to evaluate the restaurant operational and design criteria listed above, since they are largely related to the noise and compatibility issues raised by restaurants. This committee could include geographic representation from the potentially affected restaurant areas on the Balboa Peninsula and Mariners' Mile, as well as potentially affected residential areas in and around Lower Newport Bay. Staff would suggest that this committee be composed of two City Council members, two Planning Commissioners, and one restaurant representative and one resident representative from each of the following areas: Mariners' Mile, Lido Village/Cannery, Linda Isle, and the Balboa Peninsula. If so directed by the City Council, staff will prepare the appropriate Resolution, for City Council consideration, to establish Committee. As part of this review process, it is suggested that a noise consultant be retained by the City to assist the committee in its deliberations. The consultant would be asked to take noise measurements near bayfront restaurants and in affected residential areas, as well as advise the committee on design techniques which can be used to assure that restaurant related noise is retained on the restaurant site. Depending on the number of sound measurements required, staff estimates that this work can be done for approximately$5,000. Code Enforcement Resources The Planning Department currently has one full time Code Enforcement Supervisor and one half time Code Enforcement Officer who staff the City's code enforcement function. This function is in addition,to the Senior Code Enforcement Officer in the Building Departmentwhich performs 100% of the RBR inspection activity. The half time Code Enforcement Officer is funded with CDBG funds, and is limited to enforcement activities on the Balboa Peninsula. Prior to the staff reductions which resulted from budgetary constraints, the Planning Department had 4 code enforcement personnel. One of these positions was dedicated to Use Permit compliance activities. This position was eliminated in FY 93-94. Use Permit compliance has been done on a complaint basis since that time. Use Permit condition enforcement is a complex activity which requires the ability to understand the intent of conditions and, especially in the case of restaurant compliance, requires a high amount of evening and weekend work. Most code enforcement activity of this nature is done by the Code Enforcement. Supervisor as overtime hours. Recognizing the increased interest in restaurant condition compliance, the Planning and Police Departments have been working together to devise strategies to improve performance in this area. We have determined that a review of all Use Permits for existing restaurants could be conducted, Bayfront Restaurant Regulations Page 3 with the most important operational limitations identified and provided to the Police Department, particularly those officers who visit restaurants to review compliance with ABC licensing conditions. This could assist the Planning Department in identifying earlier those business which are operating outside the limits of their Use Permits. The completion of this task has been delayed, however, due to the high workload currently being experienced in the Planning Department. The Planning Department is also currently preparing its budget for FY 98-99. Due the departure of an Associate Planner, the Department has some options to consider in terms of staffing levels. We currently plan to fill the vacant counter position at the lower level of Planning Technician. The salary saving realized from this reduction could be used to make the part time Code Enforcement Officer a full time position, and to fund half of that position with General Fund dollars. This would enable that Code Enforcement Officer to allocate half of his time to non -Peninsula problems. Should the City Council authorize through the budget review the establishment of this position as full time, the additional hours could be targeted to Use Permit condition compliance. Additionally, the work schedule could be designed to allow for the necessary number of night and weekend hours. Potential for Broader Application of New Code Requirements As staff prepared this report, we discussed the fact that many of the issues which have been raised related to noise and community compatibility by the bayfront Use Permit applications also apply to restaurant activities in other commercial areas, like Corona del Mar and on Balboa Island, where there are residential uses in close proximity to restaurants. Therefore, the City Council way wish to consider expanding the scope of this study to include those commercial areas. Should the City Council determine to broaden the scope of potential code additions to Corona del Mar and Balboa Island, staff would also suggest that the composition of the committee discussed earlier in this report be expanded to include representation from restaurants and residents in those areas. Submittedby: . SHARONZ. WOOD Assistant City Manager Attachment Prepared by: PATRICIA L. TEMPLE Planning Director Bayfront Restaurant Regulations Page 4 . Page 1 Eating and Drinking Establishments Sections: 20.82.010 20.82.020 20.82.030 20.82.040 20.82.050 20.82.060 20.82.070 20.82.080 20.82.010 Purpose CHAPTER 20.82 EATING AND DRINKING-ESTABLIsHm ENTs Purpose Use Permit Required Application Contents Design and Development Standards Accessory Outdoor Dining Changes in Operational Characteristics Nonconforming Structures and Uses Rights of Appeal and Review Eating and Drinking Establishments range from large destination restaurants to small neighborhood ice cream stores. Full -service establishments -are likely to generate more traffic, parking demand, noise and trash than small businesses with limited menus. Conditions and restrictions on the operation of large establishments may be unnecessary in the case of small, limited item food serving businesses. However, particular small-scale establishments may, because of location, method of operation or other factors, be expected to cause, or actually cause, impacts equivalent to a full service establishment and, in such event, additional controls should be imposed or the use prohibited. 20.82.020 Use Permit Required A. Unless otherwise prescribed in the individual chapters of this code, Eating and Drinking Establishments shall require the following permits: Use Classification Permit Required Full -Service, High Turnover Use permit Full -Service, Low Turnover Use permit Full -Service, Small -Scale Use permit issued by the Planning Director. Take -Out Service Use permit Take -Out Service, Limited Use permit issued by the Planning Director. Accessory Permitted by right. Bars and Cocktail Lounges Use permit BrAont Restautant Regulations Page 5 • • Page r2 Eating and Drinking Establishments B. Required Findings for Bars and Cocktail Lounges. In order to approve a use permit for the establishment of any bar or cocktail lounge, the Planning Commission shall make the following findings: 1. The proposed use is consistent with the purpose and intent of this section. 2. Establishment, maintenance or operation of the use will not, under the circumstances of the particular case, be detrimental to the health, safety, peace, comfort and general welfare of persons residing or working in the neighborhood or injurious to property or improvements in the area. In making findings required by this section, the Planning Commission shall consider the following: Whether the use serves public convenience and necessity. 2. The crime rate in the area as compared to other areas in the City. 3. The number of alcohol licenses per capita as compared to the county -wide average. C. Required Findings for Take -Out Service, Limited. In addition to the findings established in Chapter 20.82, the following additional findings shall be made in order to approve a Take -Out Service, Limited establishment: That the use will not contribute to a disproportionate number of take-out establishments in the area nor contribute to a land use mix that is inconsistent with the specific purposes of the zoning district in which it is proposed. 2. That the site and structure are of sufficient size and design to accommodate the use and will not cause customer service queues, storage areas, or waste to encroach onto adjacent properties or public rights -of -way. 3. That a condition of approval of the use permit includes a practical program for controlling litter, spills, and stains resulting from the use on the site and adjacent areas. 20.82.030 Application Contents In addition to the application requirements of Chapter 20.82, an application for a use permit or an amendment to a use permit, the following materials shall be required, provided that the Planning Director may waive submission of items deemed unnecessary: Bayrront Restaurant Regulations Page 6 • • Page Eating anddDrinking kinging Establishments A. A statement specifying the nature of the establishment, the proposed hours of operation, whether the applicant intends to provide live entertainment and/or dancing, and other pertinent information regarding the operational characteristics of the proposed Eating and Drinking Establishment. B. A plot plan of the property drawn to scale showing the location of all buildings, storage facilities, planting areas, signs, outside eating areas, walls, parking areas, and curb cuts. C. A floor plan of any building delineating all interior floor space and indicating its proposed use. D. A parking layout and traffic plan showing all parking spaces, aisles, access points and directional signs and markings. E. A grading plan indicating how the property is to be graded and drained. F. Elevations including all building and sign faces and materials. G. Such other plans, drawings and information as the Planning Director may reasonably require. 20.82.040 Design and Development Standards A. Full ServiceKi fh Turnover Full -Service Low Turnover.• Full -Service, Small -Scale, Take -Out Service Establishments and Bars and Cocktail Lounges. Site. The site shall be of sufficient size and configuration to satisfy all requirements for off-street parking, setbacks, curb cuts, walls, landscaping and refuse storage as provided in this chapter. 2. Setbacks. The Planning Commission or the Planning Director may establish setbacks more restrictive than those required by the regulations for the zoning district in which the proposed use would be located if it determines they are necessary or desirable for the protection of the public health, safety and welfare or to insure compatibility with uses on contiguous properties. 3. Off -Street Parkin . Off-street parking shall be as specified in Chapter 20.66: Off -Street Parking and Loading. 4. Circulation. Parking areas and driveways shall be arranged so that a free flow of vehicular traffic and adequate site clearances are permitted at all times. If the Traffic Engineer determines that there is a need to accommodate vehicles Bayfront Restaurant Regulations Page 7 • • Page20.82-4 Eating and Drinking Establishments waiting for service, a reservoir parking area for standing vehicles shall be provided in additional to the other required parking and driveways area, 5. Walls. A solid masonry wall 6 feet inleight shall be erected on.all interior lot lines, said wall to be reduced to 3 feet in height within any required front yard setback area or within 15 feet of the corner of any intersecting street or alley right-of-way. Walls 3 feet in height shall be erected between on -site parking areas and public rights -of -way. 6. Landscaping. Not less than 10 percent of the total site area shall be devoted to landscaped planting area, including: a. A planting area with a width of 3 or more feet between street side property lines and walls screening parking facilities. b. A planting area with a width of 3 or more feet adjacent to interior property lines. C. All such planting areas shall be separated from vehicular or pedestrian paved areas by 6-inch-high concrete curbing. The bumper stops shall be installed and located in such a manner as to preclude parked vehicles from overhanging such planting areas. All planting areas shall be provided with a permanent sprinkler irrigation system and hose bibs for supplemental watering. Li htin . All parking areas shall be illuminated by lighting with minimum intensity in any location of 2 foot-candles and an average intensity of 5 foot- candles. The lighting system shall be designed to minimize the reflection of light to streets and properties adjoining the site. No lighting standard shall exceed a height of 10 feet from the finished grade of the site. 8. 'Utilities. All utility services on the site shall be installed underground. 9. Sup in SS� torque. All facilities for storage of supplies shall be located within a building. 10. Refuse Storage. Any refuse storage area located outside of a completely enclosed building shall be surrounded by a solid masonry wall 6 feet in height with self-locking gates. B. Take -Out Service. Limited. Take -Out Service, Limited establishments shall be operated in conformance with the following standards: Bayfront Restaurant Regulations Page 8 • • Page 20.82-5 Eating and Drinking Establishments 1. Hours of Operation. Opens for business no earlier than 7:00 a.m. and closes no later than 12:00 a.m., daily, provided, however, this provision shall not apply if the business, measured from the property lines, is, in all directions, more than 250 feet from the boundaries of any residential district or any mixed commercial/residential district; 2. No alcoholic beverages shall be served or consumed on the premises; No live entertainment or dancing shall be provided; 4. The facility contains receptacles sufficient in size to accommodate all trash deposited by customers; 5. Trash generated by the business is stored ou-site in an area screened from view except when placed for pick-up; 6. Smoke and odor are controlled by kitchen exhaust fans, or other means, to the satisfaction of the Building Director; 7. A wash -out area for refuse containers and kitchen equipment is provided and the area drains directly into the sewer system unless the Building Director and Public Works Director approve alternative drainage; 8. Off -Street Parking. Off-street parking shall be as specified in Chapter 20.66: Off -Street Parking and Loading. C. Additional Requirements. The Planning Director or the Planning Commission, as the case may be, shall have the right to add additional conditions of approval in order to insure compatibility of the development with the surrounding area and the goals and objectives of ' the General Plan of the City. In addition, the Planning Director or the Planning Commission, as the case may be, shall retain jurisdiction to impose additional conditions after. approval if necessary or appropriate to ensure that operation of the establishment is consistent with the findings made at the time of approval. D. Modification or Waiver of Regulations. tions. The Planning Director or the Planning Commission, as the case may be, may modify or waive any of the design and development standards contained in this chapter if strict compliance with the standards is not necessary to achieve the purpose and intent of the standard. 20.82.050 Accessory Outdoor Dining A. General Provisions. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this chapter, Chapter 20.62, Chapter 20.63, Chapter 20.64, Chapter 20.91, and Chapter 15.38 of the C.. Bayrront Restaurant Regulations Page 9 • • Page 20.82.E Eating and Drinking Establishmcnts Municipal Code, the Planning Director may approve an application to add or expand t outdoor dining to an existing Eating and Drinking Establishment provided the area devoted to outdoor dining does not exceed 25 percent of the existing interior net public area of the establishment, or 1000 square feet, whichever is less, and is accessory to any indoor dining. B. Required Findinsts. Before approving an application, the Planning Director shall make the following findings: 1. That the proposed outdoor dining is accessory to the Eating and Drinking Establishment. 2. The establishment, maintenance or operation of the accessory outdoor dining will not, under the circumstances of the particular case, be detrimental to the health, safety, peace, comfort and general welfare of persons residing or working in the neighborhood or injurious to property or improvements in the area. 3. That the proposed accessory outdoor dining will not be located so as to result in reduction of existing parking spaces. C. Required Conditions. The Planning Director's approval of an application to add or expand outdoor accessory dining shall be conditioned upon the following: That the outdoor dining shall be subject to all the existing hours of operation, operational characteristics and conditions of any use permit applicable to the establishment. 2. No amplified music or entertainment is permitted outdoors. 3. All doors and windows leading to the outdoor dining shall remain closed while any approved indoor amplified music is being played. 4. Roof coverings shall not have the effect of creating a permanent enclosure. 5. Fences, walls or similar barriers shall serve only to define the dining area and not constitute a permanent all weather enclosure. 6. Such additional conditions the Planning Director deems necessary or appropriate to ensure operation of the outdoor dining is consistent with the findings made at the time of approval. aayfront Restaurant Regulations Page 10 0.82-7 • • Page ra Eating and Drinking ng Establishments D. Required Notice. At least 10 days prior to the administrative decision, notice shall be mailed to the applicant and all owners of property within 300 feet of the boundaries of the site, as shown on the last equalized assessment roll or, alternatively, from such other records as contain more recent addresses. It shall be the responsibility of the applicant to obtain and provide to the City the names and addresses of owners as required by this section. Exception Notice is not required for applications on properties which are not located within 300 feet of a residential district. 2. Contents ofNotice. The notice of the decision of the Planning Director shall contain: a. A description of the location of the project site and the purpose of the application; b. A statement of the purpose of the administrative decision; C. A reference to application materials on file for detailed information; Cd. A statement rights of appeal. C E. Calls for Review. The decision of the Planning Director to approve or deny an application is final, subject to the call up for review -by the Planning Commission or call up for review by the City Council for referral to the Planning Commission within 14 days. F. Revocation. An application to add outdoor dining may be denied or approval of an application may be revoked or modified by the Planning Director upon a finding of the failure to comply with the conditions in this section and all other applicable conditions and regulations. G. Encroachments Permits. In the event that the proposed outdoor dining area is located on a public sidewalk, the application shall not become effective until the applicant has obtained a valid Sidewalk Cafe License Encroachment Permit pursuant to Chapter 13.18 of the Municipal Code. ,aayfront Restaurant Regulations Page 11 • • Page20.82-8 Eating and Drinking Establishments 20.82.060 Changes in Operational Characteristics A. Major Changes A use permit or an amendment to a use permit shall be required for any major change in the. operational characteristics of any Eating and Drinking Establishment requiring a use permit under the provisions of Section 20.82.020. For purposes of this chapter, a major change in operational characteristics shall include, without limitation, any of the following: 1. Any increase in the hours of operation; 2. The introduction of live entertainment consisting of 3 or more individuals or live entertainment performing with amplified sound or dancing, or a significant change in the character of the live entertainment; a.. The introduction of the sale of alcoholic beverages; 4. An increase in the gross floor area, net public area or in the size of the area principally devoted to the sale of alcoholic beverages in excess of 250 square feet; 5. The increase in the number of seats of a bar or cocktail lounge by more than 15% (for purposes of this section, each 18 linear inches of a bar, counter, or ( . similar serving area, shall be considered to constitute a seat); 6. A loss of on -site or off -site parking spaces for a period of 90 days or more, which would reduce available parking below the number than required by the provisions of this code or the use permit applicable to the establishment; 7. The introduction of valet, tandem, or compact parking spaces; 8. The addition of 3 or more pool tables. 9. Any change that would affect a condition of approval. B. Mnor Chances. The Planning Director may approve minor changes in the operational characteristics of any Eating and Drinking Establishment provided the use permit for the establishment has -not been approved or amended within the past 90 days. For purposes of this chapter, a minor change in operational characteristics shall be any change which does not constitute, either individually or cumulatively, a major change in operational characteristics as defined in Section 20.82.060 (A), and shall include, without limitation, any of the following: Bayfront Restaurant Regulations Page 12 0.82-9 • • Page ri Eating and Drinking Establishtnents ;j The introduction of live entertainment consisting of no more than 2 individuals, provided the live entertainment is performed without amplified sound; 2. An increase in the gross floor area or net public area of up to 250 square feet; 3. A loss of on -site or off -site parking spaces for a period of less than 90 days which would reduce available parking below the number than required by the provisions of this code or the use permit applicable to the establishment; 4. The addition of up to 2 pool tables. 5. The increase in the number of seats of a bar or cocktail lounge by not more than 15% (for purposes of this section, each 18 linear inches of a bar, counter, or similar serving area, shall be considered to constitute a seat). C. Other Required Permits. The applicant shall obtain all required City permits prior to implementing any approved major or minor change in operational characteristics involving entertainment, dancing, pool tables.. or amusement devices (Section 20.60.085: Uses Requiring City Manager). 20.82.070 Nonconforming Structures and Uses A. Except as provided in Section 20.82.060, the provisions of Chapter 20.62 shall be applicable to all Eating and Drinking Establishments. In the event of any conflict between the provisions of this chapter and the provisions of Chapter 20.62, the provisions of this chapter shall control. B. Maintenance, repairs, and structural alterations can be made as provided in Chapter 20.62. 20.82.080 Rights of Appeal and Review A. Appeals. Decisions of the Planning Director may be appealed by any interestedparty to the Planning Commission. Decisions of the Planning Commission may be appealed by any interested party to the City Council. B. Calls for Review. The Planning Commission may review any decision of the Planning Director. The City Council may review any decision of the Planning Commission. C. Procedures. Procedures for appeals and calls for review shall be as prescribed by Chapter 20.95: Appeals and Calls For Review. Bayfront Restaurant Regulations Page 13