HomeMy WebLinkAboutS2025-0049 - Alternative Material & MethodsCITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
BUILDING DIVISION
100 Civic Center Drive I P.O. Box 1768 1 Newport Beach, CA 92658-8915
www.newi)ortbeachca.gov 1 (949) 644-3200
CASE NO.:
❑ REQUEST FOR MODIFICATION TO PROVISIONS
OF TITLE 9 (FIRE CODE) OR TITLE 15 (BUILDING CODE)
OF THE NEWPORT BEACH MUNICIPAL CODE
(See Reverse for Basis for Approval) (Fee $291)
❑X REQUEST FOR ALTERNATE MATERIAL
OR METHOD OF CONSTRUCTION A31 b
(See Reverse for Basis for Approval) (Fee )
For above requests, complete Sections 1, 2 & 3
below by printing in ink or typing.
JOB ADDRESS:
SITE ADDRESS: 1534 Santiago Drive
Owner Lori Gray
Address 1534 Santiago Drive
Newport Beach zip 92660
Daytime Phone (949 ) 500-0111
ovE M� , Y
a'ME/yT
'KAR
2 6 20?5
.Q cirYOF
O � Nf w�Rre�acy
FOR STAFF USE ONLY
Plan Check# 1t01C85-0a1O # of Stories a
Occupancy Classification R3
Use of Building 5FR # of Units l
ProjectStatus 1?C-"2.cs-ZS-- d2 1®
Construction Type 8
Verified by 'D(Zfk
No. of Items 1
Fee due $31(0
DISTRIBUTION:
Owner 9PIan Check Z 7
Petitioner ❑ Inspector
❑ Fire ❑ Other
PETITIONER:
Petitioner David L. Bailg Architect, Inc.
FPetitloner to be architect or W91mer)
Address 23183 La Cadena Drive, Suite 101
Laguna Hills CA zip 92653
Daytime Phone ( 949 ) 573-1050
Email: david@dlbarch.com
2 REQUEST: Submit plans if necessary to illustrate request. Additional sheets or data may be attached.
o allow the use of the alarms stem "CamerE e Edge" in lieu of door and window alarms where the
a r� t .. I ..,� sen>e as Harr of the nnnl /sna harrier. and to allow the use of the "CamerEye Edge"
OF
CODE SECTIONS: NBMC 15.09,
CBC 3109.2
IF safrty system of cameras. hubs. and sirens fall in the "Other equal or greater means or II
Position Architect
Petitioners Signature adacG CA Professional Lie. # C27404
Date: 3/19/2025
V
FOR STAFF USE ONLY
DEPARTMENT ACTION: In accordance with: *BC 104.11/CFC 104.9
❑ CBC 104.10/CFC 104.8
(Alternate materials & methods)
(CBC Modification)
❑ Concurrence from Fire Code Official is required. ❑ Approved ❑ Disapproved
❑ Written Comments Attached
By: Date
[Request (DOENB�ssen any fire protection requirements.
(Request (DOES OES NQlPessen the structural integrity
The Request is: Granted ❑ Denied (See reverse for appeal information)
❑ Granted (Ratification required)
Conditions of Approval:
Signature -- PositionCHIEF BUILDNQ QFFICIAI
Date (4 ZcE?L
Print Name Lcm.ff F li-AT
APPEAL OF DIVISION ACTION TO THE BUILDING BOARD OF APPEALS (See Reverse)
(Signature, statement of owner or applicant, statement of reasons for appeal and filing fees are required.)
CASHIER RECEIPT NUMBER: RE G — 0033C 1 - 7-02-5 Forms\modif 07/01/21
CamerEye Edge Background, Code & Permitting Considerations
Drowning as a Public Health & Safety Risk in the United St,
Drownings and near-drownings in pools and spas continue to pose a significant public health and safety risk to our nation's children,
and drowning remains the leading cause of unintentional death for children ages 1-4.
According to the Consumer Product Safety Commission, more than 400 children a year die from unintentional but preventable
drownings. The vast majority of those deaths happen at residential/home pools or spas.
The highest percentage of these deaths (57%) were attributed to a gap in the adult supervision where an adult lost contact or
knowledge of the whereabouts of the child, and during that period, the child managed to access the pool/spa.
Drowning is Preventable Through "Layers of Protection"
Drownings happen quickly and quietly so no single prevention strategy is enough. Home pool owners should use "layers of
protection" to provide a system of increased security to prevent unauthorized access to bodies of water, especially important for
children. This means that multiple strategies or devices are used constantly and simultaneously.
The layers include various types of strategies and physical barriers, including alarms that detect motion on the water's surface and
can notify a parent or caregiver when an electronic perimeter is crossed close to a pool or spa. The alarm should sound both at the
pool and in the home when the surface of the water is breached or the perimeter is crossed.
CamerEye supports and is a completely consistent element of the universally accepted drowning prevention strategy calling for
layers of protection. CamerEye uses cutting -edge Artificial Intelligence, integrated with high-performance cameras that among other
things, alerts parents, caregivers or pool home owners via a mobile app creating a 24/7 safe aquatic environment.
CAMEREYE
• Is designed and lab tested & certified to detect human entry in and around a pool/spa. For example, if a child were to fall into a pool,
CamerEye immediately sends an alert to the homeowner, parent or caregiver so that they can take quick action.
• Alerts immediately when a child approaches a pool or spa allowing for quick adult response to prevent water entry In the first place.
• Rings an audible alarm at the pool/spa, In the home and on a designated mobile phone to help ensure that an adult is aware of a
potential safety issue at the pool.
CafTlerEye Ccma�,3liance with City and State Code
PRODUCT FEATURE COMPLIANCE
LISTED IN ACCORDANCE TO AND COMPLIANT WITH ASTM F2208 - TYPE B (SUB -SURFACE OR IN -POOL ALARM) AND TYPE C (PERIMETER OR ENTRY ALARM)
CamerEye is the first Artificial Intelligence system to meet ASTM F2208-08 standard for pool alarms in two (2) product classification
categories. First, it is the only pool alarm to be listed as a Type C perimeter alarm, underASTM, that detects an unauthorized entry
into the pool/spa before entry into the water byway of a permanently structure mounted system visa visa camera. Our A.I: based
pool alarm systems uses visual artificial intelligence to detect when someone has entered the pool area and act as a virtual pool
fence. The Type C product feature can then send an audible alarm on the camera and an indoor siren in addition to the phone or
tablet, so pool owners can take action right away. This is accepted by many states such as California, New York, North Carolina,
Maryland etc..
` CAMEREYE"
Additionally, our pool/spa alarm meets the requirements of the widely used Type B classification that monitors subsurface incidents
and alarms consistent with the Standard when a water entry scenario is detected. The Type B product feature is designed to monitor
for signs of water entry and send an audible alarm on the camera and an indoor siren in addition to the phone or tablet, so pool
owners can take action right away. These devices use a variety of infrared signals emanated from the camera device that go below the
surface of the water to detect when someone has entered the water, including how long they've been submerged, and whether or not
they are moving. Additionally to the code requirements, if the device detects that someone has been submerged for too long or is not
moving, it will send an audible alarm (with a different sound) on the camera and an indoor siren in addition to the phone or tablet, so
pool owners can take action right away. This is required in a few states especially Florida.
LISTED IN ACCORDANCE TO AND COMPLIANT WITH UL 2017 (DOOR AND WINDOW ENTRYALARMS)
Conforms to UL 2017— CamerEye fully conforms and is listed in accordance to Underwriters Laboratories 2017 standard which helps
ensure that alarms sound effectively if an unlawful entry is detected by the form of door or window sensors that communicate the
entrance to the camera as well as an indoor siren. When a door or window above a certain height requirement is opened, an audible
alarm sounds on the door sensor, and an indoor siren in addition to the phone or tablet, so pool owners can take action right away.
Each of the CamerEye alarm features (Type B subsurface alarm, Type C perimeter alarm and door/window entry alarms) sound at a
level that meets or exceeds the ASTM and UL auditory decibel requirements which is 85 dB at 10 feet.
Product Use Compliance
Authorized by the ISPSC - With the ILL 2017 listing, CamerEye is authorized by the International Swimming Pool and Spa Code to
meet the additional safety layer needed if a perimeterfence is used around the pool/spa where a wall of a dwelling serves as part of
the barrier and doors and windows provide direct access to the pool/spa. With our ASTM F2208 listing, we believe that the CamerEye
system and each of its product features ALSO fall into the "catch all" provision of ISPSC section 305.4, Subsection 6 as adopted by
many States, Cities, Municipalities and Townships. The drafters of the Code considered (and rightfully so) that over time there would
be new and better technology and products that would support the "layers of protection" scheme of Section 305.4. Accordingly,
Subsection 6 (in the 2021 version of the Code and Subsection 3 in the 2018 & 2015 version of the Code) anticipates that the code,
when it comes to safety, should keep up with the changing marketplace so long as the technology is as good as other listed options
AND is approved. CamerEye meets both of these ISPSC requirements. The product provides the same degree of protection and, in
fact, exceeds the safety of traditional door/window alarms and the product is approved by listed N RTL labs - IAPMO test lab (ASTM
F2208-8) and CSA (UL 2017). I will note that the ISPSC defines "approved" as either a code official himself/herself approving
the feature or if an "approved agency' approves including"an established and recognized agency who is regularly engaged in
conducting tests or furnishing product certifications". Code officials around the nation are approving CamerEye as an acceptable,
additional "layerof protection" underthe ISPSC.
At least 16 States have adopted the ISPSC for all newly constructed orsubstantially remodeled/repaired pool/spa. Additionally, at least 19 States have
authorized optional adoption which has resulted in hundreds and hundreds of municipalities around the country to adapt the ISPSC. Please contactyour
CamerEye representative if you have questions about the requirements of particularjurisdiction.
Stand Alone Alarm Use Laws
Many states and cities have their own stand-alone drowning prevention or pool alarm requirement laws (i.e., Florida, California,
Tennessee, just to name a few). Installation of the CamerEye system can often meet these state and locality requirements for an
acceptable "layerof protection".
Please contact your CamerEye sales representative if you have questions about the requirements of a particularjurisdiction or also by
reaching out at programs@camereye.ai or calling us at our support line number 1-800-906-2810.
CAMEREYE"
Power Requirements
The camera system requires a 12V/5A (60W)
power supply and the siren requires a
5W1A (5W) input.
Product Disclaimer
The provision of the alarm equipment may be
affected by any number of external factors that
are not in CamerEye's control, including without
limitation, environmental conditions, interruption
and interference by persons in the pool, loss of
signal, interruption of feedback and
communication problems etc. Any one of such
factors may create false -positives or false -
negatives in the detection of alarms and the
general quality and performance of the
monitoring services and equipment. We assume
no liability or responsibility for damage or injury
to persons or property arising from any use of
the monitoring services and equipment.
Furthermore, the product is based on artificial
intelligence, computer vision and camera
technology and as such there may always be
alarms that it may miss due to the inherent
nature of the technology that is affected by many
factors such as weather, light, water clarity,
distance, shades, obstructions such as water
features, body position, and more. The product is
mainly designed to detect people above and in
the water and as such may not always detect
people if they do not pass the human detection
model. If a user sets the area of alerting
(sometimes referred to as ai smart fence), they
acknowledge that the alerts/alarms are excluded
outside the area drawn by the user on the app.
Similarly, app notifications disabled or silenced or
bypassed by the user can lead to inaccessibility of
the information by the user.
Recommended distance from
transmitter to receiver
We recommend that the camera is installed
between 10 and 60 ft from an edge of the pool
to ensure reliable operations. Occlusions and
conditions may affect alarm performance.
Guidelines for Camera Placement
Install cameras 6-12 feet from the ground.
This height is low enough to capture fine details
but high enough to cover more area of the
pool.
Install cameras to fully cover the pool area.
Ensure there are no blind spots in the entire
pool regardless of the water depth. Consider
installing multiple cameras if one camera
cannot fully cover the entire pool.
Don't point cameras directly at the sun.
Bright light causes glare and high contrast and
can increase false detections or miss a true
detection and hence reduce efficacy and
reliability of the system. Consider the
movement of the sun and angle your cameras
for indirect light. Always prefer facing cameras
South/North compared to East/West.
Is the Wi-Fi signal strong enough?
If your Wi-Fi is weak or the stream is lagging,
consider adding a Wi-Fi extender to the system.
You can find our recommended Wi-Fi extenders
on our website at the time of cart checkout.
Terms of Service Trouble Shooting
Appendix 1 Appendix 2
S2,025-VNq
(5-*f 6wrrAezv c)
SITE PLAN NOTES:
I. M EPA LOCATION
2. IW EPA EW5IPMENT LCLATION
S."b'-O' TN.L, NOKtLIM&aELE 11 EXTEft10W POOL SAFELY CNLLOYRE
4. N 6b' TA PAIN OF %' WIOE NON-LLINHPELE IfROM EKIERIDw CAM WN
FOOL SAtTTY ENLL05.RP GATES, LCRT I"ED TO Asi 2]Eb-O5. 5ELF LI m
AtA 59.E LATLHINS PER STA` YARD NOTE&, ENCCT S.
S.
w 6'b' TALL. cm, NOK- LRBABLE (PROM E Im WAIL
6. 0 6b' TALL R INS ORN Y &ATE, NONEUMBAPJ.E gaeoM E%TH M
r. (E) 6'O' TALL. WOOD F@LE. NON- U BA6EE (YFOM ElT I1
b. 0 b'O' TALL WOOD FENCE, NWIGLIM&AELE IFPOM FXEER1Gw
9, P
T (.M>stAEYE POW- PLApM SIRBI TO 6E P051TIOISD IN 91TRYWAY SO P9
TO EE VEAROT1F OA-TT1£fbNff.
10. RU EPA ALARM BY Prot EUASiO, MODEL Ib. ED TO. SF/AMEO NN ASTM
F]208-20Ob FOR PERFORMANCE AND RD NOIED TO N5F1. StIUOARD 50
FOR MAT9tIAL5 AND TE Llx STANDARD I .SHEET 9.
12 (NI A.I. ED AIN PROIELTE2 OOORS AND WYAO . .
15. THE
A.I. WMDOI4'i, lYJ ACCESS TO REAR YARD.
IS. TIE A.I. SYSTEM E SIDE N Tiff i@AR YARD AREA,O,q C, Tie Nome, ANY
MOTILN IED A TE 91DE AID FffAR T 6INi AND WIIA TlE OF THE ,
14. PROPOSED A.I. CAMERA POI-E.
AT b F9?t AroVE 1HE 6O A
Gl W mTN TO A 9TE6 THE. CAMERAS ARE 5"TED IMO A
LIRGIRTNAT ISPARE OFTIEO FOEIE WIV THE
ll THE
HLI4E AM' 1551E5 ARE SENT ro DEJILES IN TIE AFP. T11s Tc gcE
IS TO BE USED IN PLACE OF COOK AND WINOOW ALARM.
I5. (NI LUIDOJR 61KK U DLR LOVHtED PATIO,
16. (NI 6'O. TALL, 6- Cm 5C MEN1 W AS PER Llx STANDARD
SITE PLAT
SCALE: 118161LO
SHEET M)EX'
T-I WO SNEET / SITE PLAN / 6EIBW. INFLRMATION
F-I POOL RAN5
P-2 NEVPORT 6ErVM POLL RHd11RElBi19
P-5 STM[] mARIEYBGRT 6EALN CRAIw ft+W
ILO 5TANOARD FOOL 5TRUL NAILS
6a0 EPA GETNIZ
PROJECT PARTICIPANTS
OWNIR Lai brq
1594 fwRbga p'Ive
11 yZ -011i LLllfoml0 926C0
[9M] SOOblll ph
ARO jl[(j OaI L. EGllq A2M1IbeGt, Iw.
Deelgn PnM1eelonol L' Ib! Ln caEGm Or., 5ulb l01
In Rwparolble LaN Mlb, GA 9]659
LMrge for Me [94915TY1050 PM1
Llcerme VL21404
CONTRACTOR 6M. N-1 Im
Boab1 wn�y wy Law
Trdvr LLa N;Fon LA 9] 11
(V9 J 5893499 - f949) sb9-2121
ATTN. Bay Neel
9NIGIN)RM Peo1 EegroxLg 1w.
IXJI 'IUeLN Ave.
(l4) 69
P14) 6I;0l11
LA 92E01
4
ATTN. ROM[N Lepe
OLLWANLY. R5N 51I461-E FAMILY PUMAGEP
TYPE OF LONST TON. V-B
'vPRINKLERE. iq'ff E%IETI115.IOM1E PROP05E6
NIMEER OF STORIE5. TVO
GOVERNING BODY: c1x of IEYPORT BEACH, CAL1FORNlA
APPLICABLE CODES:
2022L IPOfWIA REEICEMFIAL COVE
M22 LALIFORNIA ME toA- COOS
XR2 LPLIFLRVIA PL IN& CODE
=CD LAUFORFIRLODE VIA E
'Of GAUFORNIA 9 MC, WOE
'ODD CALIF IA T-24 EIiR&Y L0NEEIWATJON REWLATIONS
ALL LOCAL LW6, AMENDN ' AND LIx OROINAN 15
2022 LALIFORNIA EKAL IN6 COVE
2'i22 LALIFORNIA Et✓BtfiY CODE
2022 LALIFORIIA EREEN WILOIN& 5TAIDAROS CODE
PROECT SCOPE
II TYO STOW 51NE,I.E FAMILY RESDENCE
I. ISYI SPA IN THE REAR YARD, WITH SPA EMIP ..
2. LAIDECAFE, HARO9LAPE P 'EO BY OBIERS AND NOT A
PART OF THIS SCOPE OF YORIC
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
AYE EAR FA Et. mp 9 Ilrhll-21
T T P&I, LOT 4
LOT SIZE AND COVERAGE RATIO
10f 50MfET90fA6E lom swA,E f@T
M MEMO
BaLDAaE . 41* sF - T'
TOTAL N LOJBLf£ • 445E 5F Ar T 5
ibtk ra covaaeE. abr, eF Am
r nEas
• L'.. L. L.o I .
L DETNL TFE B01G1E 69D OR o119t MEPN4OF EYMDIH6 FOR
N1 WµK S,RM FIN WMA 3 A- aF TE •PA
RfSAP0.£ES W FINIOH MATFA R]IFOROIYa, 1A16ff.I£T3J.
� AID BY ANrt.+lS1] PAV I PIN&IAVC !RlI BE
UNDdtLATED BY AN AAFW®B'.ADIIK 6RIV sY51EN
tLF{bm26 IkMTA
2 NL Fl.rvBJ Tk PARTS WTXIu s ff£T Lf TIE SPA 9 BE
li?DID INGIDNK. BR IOf & mme, I AL Amml R
LMl!S PID NIT& Do. T£Tk RRIYa, IYfk AYI:IIYfl, IErk
(UE ND 14Tk DCCR PN) WILtlW iRM£5
(CFL6W2g13111.
VICINTY MAP
NOT TO SCALE
A
David L.Bailey ,
A ncnitec T. lrvl.
zme]Lo Caa.ne0nan.3u,ie Al
_
U.une Hill, CA 92553
1B0:1.11573'10Se
E-N[N: tleNtl®ElbertR[om
mmaN°° a.tl'"�'ml. ,npo°'ro.v' n�16
..ennm.,mree a Ne.� m'tl m .ro
\ N
WN' Ivvluret u ARCHITECT.
O �e BAILEY ARCHITEO�. INC.
%
REVISION
DATE
EM OTYT. MMAL
5/20M '
Q
1
O �CNA!
L e
CPfM
flFM 1-]i-D
��jP CF
CPbtfN 3/20fS
W
U
C
a)Zoro�
m �
Q
��
E
s] 0
Z 0' 0
L Q 3
f? N 3,
asm Try
J TITLE SHEET
NEW SPA
C
i
nma b 24o2T
V DAN N1acM1 20, 2025
E[VJa AS REPERENL®
j
d
Z
V
T-1
D