Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout01/19/1956 (2)192 MINUTES. PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING. JANUARY 19, 1956, 70D P.M. ROLL CAUs , Commissiohers presents Smith, Rudd, Reed,.Longmoor, Lind, Hayton .Copelin Commissioners absents Briggs, Keene MINUTES: Minutes of the meeting on December 15, 1955 were approved on motion of Com. Rudd, seconded by Com. Copelin, and carried. WIT, GLENN P., 1401 W. Balboa Blvd., Newport Beach VARIANCES Lot.27, Blk. 14, Tr. 234, R -3 zone. The request is for a 1' 6" side yard; requirement is 31. #262 Applicant states a need for additional room on the interior of the new proposed construction. Denied Mr. Coit mentioned a hardship in designing the interior of new construction were he denied an exception from the 3' requirement. Com. Lind's report showed a bad side setback condition in this whole neighborhood, and if granted would encourage additional nonconformity. Com. Lind moved that the Commission Deny the variance. Com. Lind recommended a suitable design showing the new construction contigUdus with the old be submitted to the Building Department. Seconded by Com. Rudd, and carried by the following roll call vote, to -wits ALL AYES RAY, RICHARD B., 311 Amethyst, Balboa Island , #264 Lot 31, Blk. 17, Section 3, an R -2 zone The request is for a 1' 101" sideyard; requirement is 31. In Granted. addition an excessive frontyard of 54' is proposed. The applicant wishes to establish off - street parking, by raising the present nonconforming structure and installing a two car garage on the first story. No opposition present. Qom. Reed's report stated the proposed addition was in accord with Commission's desire to improve area. Com. Reed moved that the Commission Grant the variance' seconded by Com. Copelin, and carried by the following roll call vote, to wits ALL AYES SMITH, ,ZWRGPN:.W ', 928 W. Balboa Blvd., Newport Beach Lots 15, 16, Block 109, Section 'B', R -3 zone. #265 The request is for a 3' side yard, requirement is 41. The applicant expresses a need for additional area on the Approved interior of the new dwelling. Applicant stated agreement to Commission modification of request. Committee report showed a patio area in excess of 9' along one of the sideyards for more than 3/4 of the 100' depth. Com. Lind moved that this variance be Approved on condition that 3' sideyards be maintained .along the garage sides of the rear por- tion of the site on ;y; 4' shall be maintained along dwelling portion of lot. Motion seconded by Com. Hayton, and carried by the following roll call vote, to wits ALL AYES CARLSON, PHILLIP I., 4304 W. Seashore Drive, Newport Beach Lots 3 & 4, Blk. 43, River Section,,3rd Addition, R -2 zone. The request is for a 3' sideyard; requirement is 4'. The required sideyards on either side of this lot are only 31. The applicant feels he is entitled to the same setback. The proposed dwelling requires this additional area. Applicant stated a desire to improve area. Similar setbacks exist in the whole area. Com. Rudd moved that the application be Granted, seconded by Com. Copelin, and carried by the following roll call vote, to -wits ALL AYES MACCO CORP., 721 Patolita Drive, Newport Beach Lot 73., Tract #1700, Irvine Terrace, R -1 zone The request is for a detached garage on the front half of the building site. This would aid in keeping the architectural motif,.as established by the previous variances granted. No opposition from the floor or commission. Found to be in accord with planned development. Com. Reed moved that the application be granted, seconded by Com. Copelin, and carried by the following roll call vote, to wit: ALL AYES MACCO.COPR., 1530 Dolphin Terrace, Npt. Beach Lot 48, Tract #1701, Ifvine Terrace, R -2 zone. Request a detached garage on the front half of site. To keep architectual. motif established by previous variances. No opposition from the floor or commission.. In accord with planned development. Com. Reed moved that the application be granted, seconded.by Com. Copelin, and carried by the follow- ing roll call vote, to .wit: ALL AYES 1.93 #266 Granted #267 Granted LUTHERAN CHURCH, Newport Harbor, 2501 Cliff Drive. RESUBDIVISION Newport Beach. SPortion Lot A, Tr. 919, Book 29, Pages 31 to 34. Site 1,- Sally 1001± measured at right angles to the Sally line of the SEly 2401+ of the NEly 3621± of Lot A, Tract 919:. Site - that irregular parcel of land being the SEly 481+ of the NW1y.170' +.of the SWly 310.40' of Lot 'A', Tract #919. The church would like the privilege of selling off the above described SWly 100' to the owner of the site now occupied by the Malone Electric. The Malone Electric required additional land to the rear of their property for more efficient operation (storage & auto parking.) Access shall be off the Coast Highway. ' The Commission concurred with the applicant's views. Com. Lind moved that the application be granted, on con- dition that land above described shall be contiguous with and become an integral part of property adjacent to the Coast Highway, and described above as Site #2. Motion seconded by Com. Smith, and carried by the following roll call vote, to wit: ALL AYES #21 Granted 94 to 16, inclusive, Tract #2094. No opposition from floor or the Commission. The Commission desires larger building sites whenever possible. Com. Hayto.n moved that the application be approved on the Tentative Map, seconded by Com. Rudd, and carried. Com. Hayton moved that the application be Approved on the Final Map, seconded by Com. Rudd, and carried by the following roll call vote, to wit: ALL AYES MASTERS; C. W. 140 Fernleaf Ave., Corona del Mar Lots 1, 3, and '/ Lot 5, Block #335, CDM Tract #28 Site # - All of Lot 1 and the Sally 12' of Lot 3. Site - NEly'181 of Ebt 3 and the Sally % of Lot 5. The request is for the legal establishment of two Granted building sites as described above. ' Wishes to improve the building area by adding square footage. - No opposition from the floor or Commission. Mr. Threlkeld, representing Mr. Masters mentioned the creation of larger building sites, to the advantage of the City. The Commission concurred. Com. Reed moved that the application be granted, seconded by Com. Copelin, and carried by the following roll call vote, to wit: . ALL AYES PETERS, GEORGE, F. NE corner of ;;Irvine and Clay. USE PERMITS Lot 22, Tr'. 1220, R -3 zone Posted 1 -9/56. 2nd hearing A Use Permit under Sec. 9103.32(a) - 8 units. To supply more adequate accomodations. #207 Findings on which Planning Commission inased its decision to deny this application. Denied 1. This lot #23,1Tr. #1220 is located in R -3 residen- tial zone in which number of residential family units is limited to three per building site. Under the code a property owner may apply to the Planning Commission for a Use Permit to buildInesidential family units in excess of three per building site. ' This application is for such a Use Permit. -The action of the Planning Commission on this applica- tion is based on Section 9106.23 (.A) of the City Code. IRVINE CO., Box 37:, Tustin, Calif. (old) Lots 12 to 16 incl. Tract #2094, and (new) Lots Ito 4 incl..Tract #2984, as recorded in RES[)BpIVI- Book 57, Page 50, Miscellaneous Maps of Orange County. SIONS ' TheaIrvine Co' wishes to increase the size of these building sites. #27 Economically unwise to increase the size of these building sites. Economically unwise to develop these -lots as they now exist. (Note: This application concerns the submission Approved by the Irvine Co., for apprmval of a Tentative and Final Map of Tract #2984, which is a resubdivision of Lots 12 to 16, inclusive, Tract #2094. No opposition from floor or the Commission. The Commission desires larger building sites whenever possible. Com. Hayto.n moved that the application be approved on the Tentative Map, seconded by Com. Rudd, and carried. Com. Hayton moved that the application be Approved on the Final Map, seconded by Com. Rudd, and carried by the following roll call vote, to wit: ALL AYES MASTERS; C. W. 140 Fernleaf Ave., Corona del Mar Lots 1, 3, and '/ Lot 5, Block #335, CDM Tract #28 Site # - All of Lot 1 and the Sally 12' of Lot 3. Site - NEly'181 of Ebt 3 and the Sally % of Lot 5. The request is for the legal establishment of two Granted building sites as described above. ' Wishes to improve the building area by adding square footage. - No opposition from the floor or Commission. Mr. Threlkeld, representing Mr. Masters mentioned the creation of larger building sites, to the advantage of the City. The Commission concurred. Com. Reed moved that the application be granted, seconded by Com. Copelin, and carried by the following roll call vote, to wit: . ALL AYES PETERS, GEORGE, F. NE corner of ;;Irvine and Clay. USE PERMITS Lot 22, Tr'. 1220, R -3 zone Posted 1 -9/56. 2nd hearing A Use Permit under Sec. 9103.32(a) - 8 units. To supply more adequate accomodations. #207 Findings on which Planning Commission inased its decision to deny this application. Denied 1. This lot #23,1Tr. #1220 is located in R -3 residen- tial zone in which number of residential family units is limited to three per building site. Under the code a property owner may apply to the Planning Commission for a Use Permit to buildInesidential family units in excess of three per building site. ' This application is for such a Use Permit. -The action of the Planning Commission on this applica- tion is based on Section 9106.23 (.A) of the City Code. 1.95 2. This lot contains approximately 9157 square feet of ground area within its property lines. It is located at northeast corner of Iririrae and ' Clay Streets. 3. Lots 2 to 30 inclusive and lots 36 to 46 inclusive of Tract 1220 in this area after annexation to the City of .Newport Beach were zoned R -3. Mr. Earl W. Stanley applied to the Planning Commission by letter under date of October 13th, 1953 requesting that the above lots of Tract, 1220 be zoned R -3. 4., The.buildings so far constructed on these lots have not been inexcdss of three family units per building site and are all one story in height. 5. A plea was made in behalf of the applicant to the effect thtt before annexation to the City of Newport Beach, this tract was in the County under the juris- diction of the County Zoning Ordinance and zoned R -2 thereunder. 'Also this tract was planned for develop- ments under the permissive provisions of the County Ordinance and that the City of Newport Beach should permit them to carry out this plan. Uses permitted under the County Ordinance areas follows: - Section 11 R -2 "Group Dwellings - District Regulations. ' A. Uses Permitted