The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About11/16/1967CITY .OF NEWPORT BEACH Minutes of: Regular Meeting of Planning Commission Date: November 16, 1967 Time: 8:00 P.M. Aft D7 COMMISSIONERS 4" ROLL CALL Commissioners Present MEMBERS Present: Ernest Mayer; Jr., Planning Director x x xx x xx EX-OFFI.CIQ Thomas L. Woodruff, Asst. City Atty, Benjamin B. Nolan, City Engineer STAFF MEMBERS Present: Thomas F. Nelson i Helen Herrmann MINUTES The minutes of the meeting.of November 2, 1967 were approved on the motion of Commissioner Clemence,.seconded by Commissioner Jakosky and carried. VARIANCES V188 SMALLWOOD, Dr. K. J. 3729 Ocean Blvd., CdM Portion of Block A Corona del Mar Tract CONTINUED Zone R -1 N IT)�L Applicant requests approval of a front yard D€T-77 building setback encroachment in connection with building remodelling. A 10 ft..encroach- ment.into a-10 ft. required yard setback is .requested.. The application was continued until December 7" Motion x 1967 due to the absence of the applicant. Second x All Ayes USE PERMITS BALBOA BAY CLUB, INC. 1221 West Coast Hwy. ii UP -1311 Metes & Bounds Description Lrvine's Sub. DENIED Zone R -4 Applicant requests approval to operate an ex- cursion boat serving alcoholic beverages. Richard S. Stevens was present representing th Balboa Bay Club. • The application was denied because the Commis- sion determined that.the use would be Motion Second. x x proposed detrimental to the health, safety, peace, Ayes x x x x morals, comfort and general welfare of persons Noes x x x residing and working, in the neighborhood of such proposed use and would be detrimental or Page 1. .. 1 01 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH a .. ml. ,� ,,,s, COMMISSIONERS WE0 03\ I, ovem a IV 17V/ injurious to property and improvements in the neighborhood and to the general welfare of the City. UP -1314 AMERICAN LEGION AUXILIARY., 4323 E. Coast Hwy. Metes & Bounds Description Zone C -O -H DENIED Applicant requests approval to operate a service men's club within 200 ft. of a 'residen- tial district. The following people spoke in favor of the application: John Salyer, representing the American Legion; Mrs. Roy Owens, President of the Auxiliary; Mr. George Pusateri with the Legion Post; Mrs. Mary Stevens of the American Legion Auxiliary, Theodore Kimmell, Commander of'Post 291; Jim Shirley, not a resident of the area but a past Commander of the 29th District representing all of Orange County; Donald Hart, not a member of the Legion but a resident of West Newport; Clara B. Kecker. • The following people protested the granting of the application: Bill Rankin, President of the West Newport.Improvement Association representing approximately 400 residents of the Newport area; George D. Roberts, attorney, representing the Balboa Coves Community Asso- ciation; Glen Ferguson, who lives in Balboa Coves within a stone's throw of the facility; Cliff Rignall of.Balboa Coves. The application was denied because the Commis - Motion x sion determined that the proposed use would Second x be detrimental to the.health, safety, peace,. All Ayes morals; comfort and general welfare of persons residing and working in the neighborhood of such proposed use and would be detrimental or injurious to property and improvements in the neighborhood. MASTER PLAN AMENDMENTS Master Plan Amendment No. 14 which proposes to NO. 14 include Fifth Avenue on the City of Newport CONTINUED Beach Master Street and Highway Plan and to UN T request the California Highway Commission to DW 7 approve grade separations and interchanges at the connections of Newport Center Drive and Fifth Avenue with the proposed Route 1 Freeway alignment was held over until December 7, 1,967 Motion x for the.purpose of further study. Second x All Ayes Page 2. 0 II CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Alk November 16. 1967 COMMISSIONERS � � o The Commission directed that proposed Amend-, ments No. 15 and No..16 to.the Master Street and Highway. Plan be set for public hearing before the Commission on December 7, 1967 at 8:00 P:M. and that public notices of said Motion x hearing be'published as required by law. Second x All Aye AMENDMENT EASTBLUFF- NEWPORT, INC. Tract 6228 A -236 Lots 9 thru 12; 15,.27 Zone A-1-13 APPROVED and 30 thru 38 Applicant requests approval of a change in front yard setbacks as follows: Lot No. Existing Setback Proposed 9 10 ft. 6 ft. 10 10 ft. 6 ft. 11 10 ft. 6 ft. 12 10 ft. 6 ft. 15 15 ft. 10 ft. . 27 10 ft. 6 ft. 30 10 ft: 6 ft. 31 10 ft. 6 ft. 32 10 ft. 6 ft. 33 10 ft. 6 ft. 34 10 ft'. 6 ft. 35 10 ft. 6 ft. 36 15 ft. 10 ft. 37 15 ft. 10 ft. 38 20 ft. 10 ft'. Mr. William D. Lusk,-Vice President of Eastbluff- Newport, Inc., represented the applicant.. The application was recommended to the City Motion x Council for approval. Second x All Ayes VARIANCES ADAMS, H. R. and Jane 1412 East Ocean Front V -915 Por. Lot 9 Block A Tract 518 Zone R -1 APPROVED Applicant requests approval of the establish- ment of the fallowing setbacks:. 0 Front Yard - 10 ft. Side Yard - 3 ft. on each side. Rear Yard 3 ft. Page 3. CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH AMN6 Nnvemhcw 1F. 1Qr7 COMMIIASIONERS o� Mr. Howard Brief represented the applicant and asked that the Minutes show that an extension would be requested at the expiration of 18 months. The application was approved as requested. Motion x Second x All Ayes V -916 ROUSSELOT, Thomas T: 218= 2O =22 -24 - 61st St, and WILLIAMS, Neal D: DENIED Lots 1,20 & 4 B1. 260 Tract 772 Zone R -3 Applicant requests approval of the construction of a 6 unit apartment complex in the R -1 District. Mr. William P. Ficker represented the applicant. The application was denied because the Commis- Motion x sion determined that under the circumstances of Second x the particular.case the granting of the vari - Ayes x x x x x ance would be materially detrimental to the Noes x x public welfare and injurious to property and • improvements in the neighborhood. V -917 R. B. SMITH, INC. 2601 Salt Air Circle. Lot A Tract 6385 Zone R -3 -.6 APPROVED, Applicant requests approval of the installation of swimming pool equipment to encroach 5 ft. into the required 5 ft. side yard setback Mr. Scott Biddle, Vice President of Richard B. Smith, Inc.; represented the applicant. The application was approved subject to the Motion, x following condition: Second x All Ayes That the swimming pool equipment be completely screened on all 4 sides with a 6 ft. masonry wall with a gate for access to the equipment. V -918 KELSO, A. P.. 207 Na..:Bay Front. Lot 4 B1: 4 Sec. 1 Balboa Island Resub CONTINUED Zone R -2 Applicant requests approval of an attic obser- UNTIL D 7 vation room undler the 35.ft. height "limit and to permit a 3 ft. open safety rail in connec -. tion with a 3 ft. raised patio to encroach into,the front -yard setback in the R -2 Page 4. .i CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Aft November 16. 1967 COMMISSIONERS District. Said patio will encroach to 0 ft. from the front property line. Mr. Frank Spangler represented the applicant and the.applicant Mr..A. P. Kelso also spoke. The application was continued until December 7 Motion x 1967 to give the applicant an opportunity to Second x amend his application. All Ayes USE PERMITS RAMOS,.J. A. 305 Palm Balboa UP -1316 Lot 12 Block 3 Balboa Bayside Tract APPROVED Zone C -1 Applicant requests approval of the establish- ment of an upholstery shop in the C -1 District. A use permit is required for said use under Section 20.24.030 of the Newport Beach Municipal Code. Mr. J. A. Ramos was present at the meeting. • The application was approved, subject to the Motion x .following conditions:, Second x All Ayes 1. That all signs be in keeping with the Newport Beach Sign Code. 2. That all physical changes to the build- ing meet the Newport Beach Building Code and that the proper permits be taken out by the,applicant. 3. The building shall meet the standards of the Newport Beach Fire Code. 4. Review of all remodelling of:the ex- terior of the structure to be approved by the Planning Director prior to the issuance of building permits. Commissioner Jakosky left the dais. RESUBDIVI IONS THE IRVINE COMPANY 2701 -2707 Blue Water Dr. R -246 A VED Lots 42 and 43 Tract 6385 Zo.ne R-3-13 Applicant requests..approval of the realignment of property lines.. Mr. Scott Biddle represented the applicant. Page 5.. Oi •i 01 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH COMMISSIONERS filk Nnvomhor 1F_ 19(,7 k•C'.. ��11, The application was approved as requested. Motion x Second x All Ayes. Commissioner Jakosky returned to the dais. COMMUNICA IONS Request dated November 7; 1967 signed by Don 1. Rypinski, Supervisor, Graphics Department, Planning Department of the Irvine Company re- questing a 45 day extension of Use Permit No. 1305 which permits 2 temporary identification signs in the median at the entrance to Newport. Center from the Coast Highway was granted for Motion x a period of 30 days. Second x- All Ayes ADDITIONA BUSINESS Resolution No. 701, being. 1. A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH DECLARING ITS INTENTION TO CONSIDER CERTAIN AMEND- • MENTS TO TITLE 20 OF THE NEWPORT BEACH MUNICIPAL CODE BY .THE ADOPTION OF A P.C: "PLANNED COMMUNITY" DISTRICT ORDINANCE was adopted and set for public hearing on Motion x December 7, 1967 at 8:00 P.M. in the City. Second x Council Chambers. All Ayes 2e The Commission adopted a Minute Order to amend Motion x Variance application No. 911 granted on Second x November 2, 1967 to permit the development of All Ayes an 11 story building with a maximum height of 109 feet with no less than 7 floors of parking and with the same setbacks as shown on the approved plot plan. 3. Commissioner Dosh requested permission to be absent from the next two Planning Commission meetings and Commissioner Clark asked to be absent on December 7, 1967. On motion of Commissioner Jakosky, seconded by • Commissioner Clemence, and carried, the meeting was adjourned until December 7, 1967 at 8:00 P.M: in the City Council Chambers. Ray, Y". 4opelin,.Secretary Planning Commission