Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout3.1_Matls recd after packet deliveryMaterial(s) received after the Planning Commission packets were distributed, or received at the meeting. These material(s) were distributed to staff, Commissioners and made available to the public. RESTAURANT / BAft 440 Heliotrope Avenue, Corona del Mar, CA 92625 Tel: (949) 723 -9685 Fax: (949) 723 -9687 Web: www.partcdm.com Wednesday, August 19, 2009 Aun: Commissioners Newport Beach Planning Commission City of Newport Beach Dear Commissioners, Thanks to those of you that have taken the time to meet me or be in correspondence with me over the past couple of days and I am looking forward to meet the rest of you in person. Pursuant to my earlier conversations with some of you gentlemen in regards to short nature of the time that materials have been provided publicly and without any notice to me that they are available on city's website and due to some inaccuracies and lack of objectivity for the upcoming hearing in regards to Port Restaurant application and needed time to gather evidence to refute the picture being portrayed of the Port. I would like this letter to serve an official request for a continuance of the application in order for me to perform additional discovery. I would like our modified application to be heard on your second meeting in month of September that is scheduled for 9/17/2009. I strongly believe that if this hearing is conducted on 8/20/2009, it will not turn out to be a fair hearing due to lack of adequate notice and opportunity to challenge associate planner recommendations of denial of the application by requesting a new staff report based on all the past documentation and future ones that will be provided based on our discovery that would be inclusive of all memorandum by various departments. The provided documents for the hearing do not include any of our my prior correspondence to the planning department explaining the nature of our application and high degree of importance for future vitality of this business by lack of consideration to the given economical arguments as well as Port's employment of 25+ loyal employees and its contribution to the local tax base. Port Restaurant & Bar has thrived to be a great asset to Corona del Mar and the surroundings area by continuously providing first class experience to the Public for their special events such as birthdays and wedding dinners as well as sponsoring community events with CDM and Newport Chamber of commerce, schools and charitable organizations over the past few years and wants to further provide benefits to the area and enhance and improve the character of the area. From Jazz performances in Trees and loud piano playing in Mistral to DJ Music of Svelte, the location of 440 Heliotrope has always had entertainment as part of the venue and it should have be noted in documents provided to public and I have been advised by many residents and experts that Ports current use permit should be subject to being grandfathered in for approval as to hours of operation and live music just like other similar venues in Corona del Mar and Newport Beach in general. Port Restaurant & Bar is a social venue that intends to provide eclectic entertainment in form of acoustic performances and artistic DJ's that's safe and not loud and strives to uphold its image and it does not tolerate any misbehavior. The dancing has never been a part of the business plan and we were advised by planners to include it in the application. However, that inclusion has hurt us in the eyes of many people as we want to become a nightclub venue. As I mentioned in person to you all and to Mr. Murillo in many occasion that has never even crossed my mind and I want the opportunity to clarify that matter further to all involved parties including the law enforcement agencies proposing conditions that we never want to become a night club and dancing and using club promoters were never part of our wish list contrary to the provided memorandums. I have managed this project personally and owned its real estate property from its inception and have been very consciousness of its unique position in center of the village and its place in people's hearts. The best interest of the community has always been a main focus of Port and it has been a true pleasure to restore its image. My vision is for Port to continue on as a quality establishment to enrich the experiences from residents as well as becoming a tourist attraction and a dining destination for visitors of the great Village of Corona del Mar, but discriminatory treatment given when compared to other restaurants that are allowed to have live entertainment music and stay open until 2:00 a.m. This document should also serve as a written correspondence my grounds to challenge the matters on the agenda in the event that continuance of the public hearing is not granted pursuant to the last paragraph of the Agenda. Lastly, I would like also for you gentlemen to review attached letters of support by both Corona del Mar Chamber of Commerce as well as Corona del Mar BID. Thank you all for your time and fair consideration on this matter. Best Regards, Ali H. Z addde®eh Sri= /' • �r�/ Port Restaurant and Bar 440 Heliotrope Ave. Corona del Mar, CA 92625 ai s BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT • DISTRICT GA sl, v DATE: August 19, 2009 ATTN: Newport Beach Planning Commission SUBJECT: Port Restaurant Hearing on Thursday. Aug 20th, 6:30PM Dear Commissioners, On behalf of the Advisory Board of the Corona del Mar Business Improvement District, we are in support of the Port Restaurant's application to extend hours of operation with added security, induction of lunch hours and obtaining the required entertainment license. The Business Improvement District Board of Directors voted to support this application to assist in retaining this valuable asset, the Port Restaurant, as a longstanding community establishment. There are many businesses in Corona del Mar that are closing their doors due to these difficult times, and the Board feels that it is necessary to support the Port Restaurant due to its positive contribution to city revenues, employment, and the local dining interest it provides. Thank you for considering this endorsement. Sincerely, Bernie Svalstad Chairman CORONA DEL MAR BUSINESS IMPROVEMENT DISTRICT 2855 E. Coast Hwy, Suite 101 / Corona del Mar, CA 92625 / (949) 673 -4050 Qtaj\ DEL 41 MBER COMMER � �EIA OE DATE: August 19, 2009 ATTN: Newport Beach Planning Commission SUB]ECT: Port Restaurant Hearing on Thursday. Aug 20th 6:30PM Dear Commissioners, On behalf of the Board of Director's of the Corona del Mar Chamber of Commerce, we are in support of the Port Restaurant's application to extend hours of operation with added security, induction of lunch hours and obtaining the required entertainment license. Mr. Ali Zadeh, Owner and Operator of the Port Restaurant, has been an active part of the local community and serves on the Corona del Mar Business Improvement District's Advisory Board as well as the Chamber of Commerce. The Chamber's Board of Directors supports the Port Restaurant as a longstanding local establishment with a positive impact to both city revenues and employment for approximately 30 employees. The restaurant has been a part of the Corona del Mar Community and provides cuisine and friendly service to our local neighborhood. Thank you for considering this endorsement. Sincerely, Linda Leonhard President CORONA DEL MAR CHAMBER OF COMMERCE (949) 673 -4050 2855 E. Coast Hwy, Suite 100 • Corona del Mar, CA 92625 • PH (949) 673 -4050 - Fax (949) 873 -3940• InfOCai!cdmchamber.COm www.cdmchamber.com August 19, 2009 Newport Beach Planning Department CITY HALL 3300 Newport Blvd. Newport Beach, CA 92658 -8915 Re: Port Restaurant & Bar / Project File No.: PA2009 -080 Dear Planning Commissioners and Planning Staff: As the owners of the commercial building located at 436 Heliotrope Avenue in Corona Del Mar, which happens to be immediately adjacent to the Port Restaurant & Bar, we wish to comment on this application for extended hours and activities by the restaurant. For anyone not intimately familiar with the Port Restaurant property, we would strongly suggest a close review of the satellite photo of the site, complete with overlaid property lines, that is contained in the Newport Beach City computer system. From this satellite photo it quickly becomes apparent that the restaurant property has absolutely no off -street parking! In fact, the site is so constrained that, according to City records and staff, the restaurant's chain link trash enclosure, trash dumpster, waste grease trap, etc., are actually located on an adjacent property owner's parking lot and vehicular access to this enclosure can only be achieved by driving across this neighboring property. If the nature of that property were to substantially change, the restaurant could lose that access and their ability to have a trash dumpster. Also, it should be pointed out that immediately adjacent to the northerly side of the restaurant is the Port Theater, which is currently undergoing renovation. Like the restaurant, the Port Theater also has no on -site parking! When the Port Theater eventually re -opens for business, parking in the neighborhood will become even more of a challenge than it is presently. Neither of these businesses would likely be allowed to establish themselves now as "new usages" in this neighborhood due to the non- conforming nature of their respective properties and the negative impacts they have on neighboring businesses and particularly the many residents of the immediate neighborhood. We, as owners of the commercial building adjacent the Port Restaurant, have to provide on -site parking for our building. We are baffled as to why this adjacent business, the Port Restaurant, is allowed to operate with absolutely no on -site parking whatsoever, especially in a neighborhood known for vehicular congestion. Furthermore, given that the current operators of the Port Restaurant have a history of ignoring city codes and regulations when it suits them - according to city employees and based upon our experience as well - and have shown a complete lack of regard for the negative impacts their operations have on their neighbors, we have to ask why anyone would think their behavior would suddenly change for the better if they are allowed to expand their activities and hours of operation? Additionally, some of our tenants meet clients on an appointment only basis, in the evening hours. Thus, the allowance of live music and the attendant noise likely to be generated from the Atrium area of the Port Restaurant could have a severe negative impact on some of our tenants and also on our ability to use our building and property to its fullest extent. Therefore, we strenuously object to live music and dancing being allowed at the Port Restaurant! While we recognize the rights of the operators of the Port Restaurant to operate their business and applaud their apparent success in attracting clientele, we feel that their success dictates that they move to a site more suitable to their needs. Their success should not come at the expense of their neighbors, particularly the local residents! Sincerely, Geoffrey Haddad (via email, for Haddad Properties) Page 1 of 1 Robert Weber From: "Robert Weber' <r2weber@sbcglobal.net> To: <Theresa Selga >; "Matt Cosylion" < mcosylion @city.newport-beach.ca.us >; "Jaime Murillo" <jmuriilo @newport- beach.ce. us> Cc: <Matt Cosylion >; < Tselaga @city.newport- beach.ca.us >; < moosylion @city.newport- beach.ca.us Therisa Selaga >; < Planning Department>; <Office Assistant>; <Code Enforcement> Sent: Monday, August 17, 2009 9:39 PM Subject: Planning Commission Meeting, Thursday 8 -20 -09 to hear Ammendment to Permit No. 15661 I wll be unable to attend the subject meeting. Please see that my comments are represented to the Planning Commission. Thank you. The Port RetauranVBar currently provides a commendable service as just that, a restaurant/bar. It presently operates on the margin of a residental neighborhood and as such is conditionaly acceptable. What is being proposed is the extention of that permit to make it into a night club with all the attendant negative features and no positive contribution to the neighborhood. Corona del Mar is a village. We can do without bud music, intoxicated carousing, and other noisey disturbances into the middle of the night. I recommend the Planning Commission deny the subject amendment. 8/19/2009 197/. si..f ea .w .sa.r•t' wl+�t 7X.o.e rs..s:.P'1� 6�✓ i�''''C .ti.. -..� d+✓. 7sao•«�•'�'r .tr��'�• t 4LttI .ac. -,.L o�c+.+�- /.,f++ o�w.. -�..� a..i- h.ws�f �•t�"'"d �+✓ a✓ �s4.La •�.�s. -y, d�.+•.� Yom-- �W....� C"""+�' . • �� esfes *atr�.�•+ -.,, �ww �+dM�6�s+»n, ew.c:�. 11= 204 s .-0 4 — amt - *'I • sJs August 11, 2009 Newport Beach Planning Department City Hall 3300 Newport Blvd. Newport Beach, CA 92658 Subject: Public Hearing Notice Port Restaurant & Bar 440 Heliotrope Ave Project File No.: PA2009-080 To whom it may concern: PLANNING DEPARTMENT AUG 18 2009 CITY OF NEWPORTBBACH I am writing in response to the above referenced Public Hearing notice received on August 10, 2009. Unfortunately, I will be unable to attend the scheduled hearing and I would like to express my concerns with the application for amendment to Use Permit No. 1566. I currently reside at 430 1/2 Heliotrope Ave which is located within walking distance to the Port Restaurant & Bar. Please be advised that I strongly oppose the expansion of their existing business hours. Currently, the business produces a great deal of traffic and noise to the area. This is understandable and has been tolerated because it occurs during normal business hours but I feel the expansion of their existing business hours would be an inconvenience. I feel it would certainly lead to unnecessary traffic and noise during all hours of the night. This would not only be an Inconvenience to me, but surety to other neighbors. I feel that their business hours should remain the same and the application for expansion should be denied. I would like to thank you for the opportunity to express my concerns and ask that they be taken into consideration during your process of deciding whether or not to grant the amendment requested. If I may be of further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, ` S n J. Sm-4 SJS/sm v#** STEVEN J. SMITH *40+40* 430'/ Heliotrope Avenue Corona Del Mar, CA 92625 (949) 701 -9484 Murillo, Jaime From: Rita Berdelis [ritaberdelis @gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, August 20, 2009 12:05 PM To: Murillo, Jaime; info @portodm.com Subject: Re: Port Restaurant Dear Jaime, Port Restaurant & Bar is very well known in Corona del Mar and is one of our favorite local places to eat. They have been such a wonderful addition to our local community. My husband and I hope that the city grants this fine establishment this permit, so they are able to improve on an already great thing. Rita Berdelis CDM Resident 562- 233 -5200 Murillo, Jaime From: Dave Stone [stonebeachhouse@yahoo.com] Sent: Thursday, August 20, 2009 12:27 PM To: Murillo, Jaime Subject: Port restaurant app for amended license Dear Jaime, This is Dave and Dawn Stone. We have owned the property at 439 and 4391/2 for the last 20 years. Our building is directly across the street from the Port restaurant and the business parking lot they use. We strongly object to this amended license proposal! Because we are the closest residence to the restaurant in the neighborhood, we know from 20 years of experience how bad the situation is already. All during the evening and especially at closing time, the patrons come out of the restaurant and talk, argue, smoke, drink, rev their engines, etc... until they finally decide to leave. Many times the police have been called because they just wont be quiet and they won't go home. So if the license was extended to 1 AM the noise could continue until 2 AM and our tenants have to get up for work early. These people have urinated on our lawns and bushes, thrown their cigarette butts and beer bottles on our lawn, keyed cars, and even side swiped parked cars while driving away. We as landlords have to put it in the lease with any new tenant about the noise from the restaurant because it is so bad. It causes lower rental rates and is surely a detriment to the value of our property. We have a wonderful little residential area and we as property tax payers feel we deserve some respect! We want peace and quiet! We want safety for our property and families! Please do not approve this amended license application! Thankyou, Dave and Dawn Stone 714- 329 -5617 Murillo, Jaime From: scott hendel [scotthendel @hotmail.com] Sent: Thursday, August 20, 2009 3:26 PM To: Murillo, Jaime Subject: Port Restaurant Hi, i am emailing you to give my support for the proposed changes for Port Restaurant. I own a home nearby for many years and we have dinner at Port very often. There has never been a problem outside Port and we are in favor of the proposed changes and additions. I don't see any reason not to support this plan. With many for lease signs around Corona del Mar as there are now and will continue to be for the foreseeable future, we should fully support this local business. This plan will provide more money for city revenue and employment. Thank You Scott Hendel 310 - 967 -9888 Windows Live: Make it easier for your friends to see what you're up to on Facebook. Find out more. Murillo, Jaime From: Lyle, Lee V. [Ivlyle @firstam.com] Sent: Thursday, August 20, 2009 3:53 PM To: Murillo, Jaime, Cosylion, Matt; Selga, Theresa Cc: Bill Lyle Subject: Project File No. PA2009 -080 Location 440 Heliotrope Ave, CDM Permit amendment Dear Madam /Sir, This letter serves as our objection to the application for a night club license at property address at 440 Heliotrope Avenue. We have been residents at 428 Heliotrope for over 6 years and intend to stay at our current resident for the many years to come. Over the past several years, we have seen a slight change in the neighborhood as a result of having a restaurant 4 doors from our home. Some of the nuisances we encounter are trash thrown on our front yard, such as red cups and cigarette buds. Corona del Mar prides itself by being a clean, upscale and safe neighborhood. By allowing Port to be licensed as a nightclub in a neighborhood street will jeopardize the quality of the neighborhood. We strongly urge you to protect our neighborhood by opposing the night club at 440 Heliotrope Avenue. Sincerely, Bill & Lee Lyle This message may contain confidential or proprietary information intended only for the use of the addressee(s) named above or may contain information that is legally privileged. If you are not the intended addressee, or the person responsible for delivering it to the intended addressee, you are hereby notified that reading, disseminating, distributing or copying this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this message by mistake, please immediately notify us by replying to the message and delete the original message and any copies immediately thereafter. Thank you. FACLD To Whom It May Concern, During the 1980's and 1990's, I was the Restaurant Critic and Op Ed columnist for the Daily Pilot, as well as the host of K -OCEAN 103.1 FM's "Dining With Judy." Professionally and personally, I was a regular diner at Trees, one of the most innovative culinary establishments of its day. The food was lovely, the atmosphere chic and relaxing and the dining experience was further enhanced by the restaurant's policy of having live music nightly. The entertainment in those days was often provided by local performers like Donnie Singer, and a fellow named "Caesar." When the restaurant became Mistral, I was one of the artists who entertained there myself with my jazz combo. Because of its excellent food and dedication to service and relaxing atmosphere enhanced by live music, Trees established itself as a fine dining destination that attracted a loyal clientele. It was not uncommon to find visitors from San Diego, New York, San Francisco and other parts of the country enjoying leisurely evenings of multi- course dinners prepared by the award - winning Trees. And listening to live music. As a member of the Southern California Restaurant Writers Association, I can attest to the fact that Port Restaurant is dedicated to renewing and restoring the cultural imprint that Trees was known for in its heyday. Fine art, sculpture, comfortable seating, a diverse and interesting, well -priced menu and gracious environment are alive and well in Corona del Mar because of the Port. It's not easy to trying to operate a business that is geared toward the culturally- minded these days! Despite the trend toward attracting a mostly -bar business, I am confident that it is not the Port Restaurant's objective to be anything but a high -end establishment that will continue to make the kind of outstanding contribution to the legendary lineage of Newport Beach's acclaimed dining destinations that was pioneered by Trees so many years ago, in the years to come. Sincerely, Judy Chamberlain Judychamberlain.com 714- 319 -9242 PEOPLE SUPPORT OF PORT PROJECT 1) SOURCE: h=:// www. oetitiononlino .com/gortcdm2420ition 898 Signatures To: City of Newport Beach In order to better serve our guests and community, Port Restaurant & Bar has started working with the city of Newport Beach to make building improvements and amend its current use permit that is dated back in 1977. We welcome your valued input and comments and please sign if you are in favor of these improvements: 1) Create a better flow so the entire restaurant interior could be used throughout its operation and to avoid having any potential noisy lines in the front of the premises. 2) To add additional sound control measures with the professional recommendation of environmental engineers to provide Live Entertainment in a very modest and reserved fashion. 3) To start a valet/security service in our leased lot for added security. 4) To extend its closing time to 1:00 AM so guests are not all rushed out of our premises at once and create a noise and disturbance issues in our neighborhood. Sincerely, The Undersigned 2) We have also more than 2,000 we signature supporting the project gathered from clients and retail locations like Bank of America, Verizon Store, Images Salon, Gallo's Deli, Bare Tan, Curves among other retail locations. 3) Port Corona del Mar — 536 Friends Port Restaurant and Bar — 419 Friends Support Port Project —130 Members ORANGE COUNTY BUSINESS JOURNAL Port Restaurant and Bar is Chic and Satisfying Port's Presence Port Restaurant and Bar in Corona del Mar is a fine place to repack your culinary suitcase and have a fetching dining experience. Tucked a few feet from the ocean on Heliotrope Avenue, this space was a casual local hangout called Pirate's Inn for a long run. Then, a chef took ownership and called the place Trees for a relatively short span before it disintegrated. Alas, we loved and lost Mistral, the next incarnation that took its name from the unruly winds that scour the Provence region of France in certain seasons. It too was eventually sold to yet another owner who had a very short run with his Svelte name and idea. DINING Fifi Chao Then, two and a half years ago, along came Ali Zadeh — businessman, lover of fine food and good wine, bon vivant and, most certainly, an intent host - who gave the restaurant an intensive and inviting makeover. It's now quite chic while being ultra friendly. The rooms are punctuated with a lot of good art, custom architectural details and a cool adjoining bar. Patrick and I merrily trekked through some of the menu with this paper's publisher, Richard Reisman, his charming girlfriend, Anita Modha, our executive editor Rick Reiff and his wife, Mary Ann Brown. Makes it easier to try several things with a table of six or so. For appetizers, don't miss the crispy gnocchi with spinach and morel mushrooms. Crab cakes sit atop fennel salad and are dappled with chipotle sauce, classic coconut shrimp have a jaunty sweet chile sauce, ahi tartar is a good textural counterpoint to the crunch of lotus root and spicy shrimp or a bowl of clams and mussels keeps the interest flowing. Entrees on our plates included salmon with a white wine and shrimp sauce, seared sea bass with a tad bit of brown butter sauce and nice garden vegetables, a swell plate of seafood pasta, tender braised short ribs and a couple of selections from the steak, chops and lamb entrees. All were quite satisfying. Someone obviously paid a lot of attention in putting together the eclectic and international wine list. A few that would add pizzazz to any meal without emptying the wallet: Trimbach Reserve pinot grigio, Saint Supery sauvignon blanc, Dutton Goldfield pinot noir, BV Tapestry red wine, Lancaster or Whitehall Lane cabernets, Ridge "California Mountain" zinfandel -syrah blend or Chateau Taillefer from the Pomerol region of Bordeaux. To go along with some full- flavored sweets at the end of your meal, there's a fine selection of dessert wines. Port should be added to your dining list since the great tastes are complemented by sensible prices and superb atmosphere. Dinner appetizers are $8 to $16, entrees $26 to $38. Murillo, Jaime From: Jason Rockwood Dasonrockwood @hotmail.comj Sent: Tuesday, August 18, 2009 7:06 PM To: Murillo, Jaime Cc: ali @portcdm.com; Wood, Sharon Subject: Port Restaurant Mr. Murillo, I am writing in support of Port Restaurant in Corona del Mar. We have lived just down the street from the restaurant for over 7 years and have witnessed the changes in the establishment as well as it's management. During the time that Port Restaurant has been in business, we have never had a problem with any sound or nuisance issues resulting from the restaurant. In fact, it has been a positive experience to have a close location we can frequent with such a friendly staff, great food and enjoyable ambiance. Jason and Sandi Rockwood 438 Goldenrod 949 - 929 -9445 Murillo, Jaime From: Tracey McCarter [tacey @jtmccarter.com] Sent: Tuesday, August 18, 2009 4:13 PM To: Murillo, Jaime Cc: info @portcdm.com Subject: Support Port Restaurant Hello Ms. Murillo, I have enjoyed the restaurants that have occupied the space at 440 Heliotrope for many years, and Port is by far the best of them. The new ownership has definitely changed the venue for the better, with amazing dining, wonderful staff and excellent service. It is no longer a bar /restaurant... but a restaurant with a nice bar /lounge. I live in CDM and go to Port for family dinner in the earlier hours (we have 2 small children), date night with my husband and Girls Night Out with my fellow mom friends when we get a "hall pass' to stay out late. Port is a great restaurant and the entertainment is always nice, never too loud or annoying, which I can't stand when you are trying to speak with others! In fact, I believe Port is now the only place to go in CDM to enjoy fantastic cuisine in a hip, airy (and clean) atmosphere with fun music (I am past the age of enjoying clubs). When we have friends, family or business customers visiting from out of town, we always recommend Port. I also care to share with you that the owner, Ali, is a very kind and generous man who assisted our local Harbor View public elementary school with it's fundraising endeavors. Ali generously hosted our Underwriting party at Port and supplied all the specialty drinks at our annual event at the Fairmont Hotel last November, helping our Parent Faculty Organization raise $110,000. No other shop or store has, in the two years I co- chaired our events, assisted us as much as Port did this past year, a time of great need as the CA school budget funding continues to decrease. I sincerely hope you assist Port restaurant with their plans to improve upon their successful business. I would especially like to be able to go there for lunch! Like the Lido Diner next to the Lido theater, Port can offer a place to dine before and after shows. More importantly, Port can become a CDM landmark along with the rejuvenated Port theater, a real town jewel where neighbors of all ages can enjoy fine yet casual dining and entertainment, and visitors can get a real feel for the life and friendship that CDM residents enjoy. Please support and approve Port's requests for improvements, as they have proven to show consideration and respect to our neighborhood in their successful business strategies, Tracey McCarter CDM resident since 1996 949.300.5855 ,aoA4 •►, PC '61 t9ladc 7 Murillo, Jaime From: edie @edienoesser.com Sent: Tuesday, August 18, 2009 2:11 PM To: Murillo, Jaime Subject: PA 2009 -080 OP 2009 -003 440 Heliotrope Avenue Mr. Murillo: I am an owner's representative for properties affected by the Port Restaurant & Bar. Included in these properties would be residences at 500, 500 1/2, 502 and 502 1/2 Goldenrod Avenue. The transition of the former Pirates Inn /Trees Restaurant, as a former neighborhood establishment patronized by locals, to the Svelte /Port operation has brought a different, seemingly non -local clientele that is noisy and disruptive to the quiet residential area. Patron's stretch limos and taxi cabs were never seen prior to this transition. The bar operator has been unable to control exiting customers in the late evening hours who typically congregate in the subject parking lot. History suggests that proposed monitors /security officers will be an unenforceable measure that will not be sustained. Bar hoppers are known to leave their car at the Port lot and return later after drinking at other establishments. This pattern adversely affects the safety of the neighborhood while the numerous calls to police divert them from other responsibilities due to potential drunk driving problems. Cars have been sideswiped by hit and run late nighters. For the good of the nearby property owners, I believe that rather than extend operating hours, that they should be shortened and operating /use permits should be revoked if the problem gets worse. On the matter of off site parking, please be advised of the following; Public records show that the fee interest in the building and parking lot at 2865 East Coast Highway is owned by Shirley Price Piantanida. The owner /operator of the building improvements and parking lot area is on a ground lease from said owner. The ground lease is currently in litigation over the valuation of a proposed purchase of the fee interest in subject property. Unless and until adjudication of this matter results in a transfer of ownership of the land, the "lessor "; Legacy Property Management indicated in the PC12 exhibits, would not seem to be able to legally bind the future use of the parking lot, 30 Day Notice notwithstanding. Edie Noesser Murillo, Jaime fez) From: david mok [dmosuda @yahoo.com] Sent: Tuesday, August 18, 2009 12:16 PM To: Murillo, Jaime; Cosylion, Matt; Selga, Theresa Subject: 440 Heliotrope Ave- Permit amendment Dear Madam /Sir,We have been searching for an ideal property for our retirement for the past year. When we came upon Corona Del Mar, we fall in love with the community immediately. We found our dream house at 428.5 Heliotrope Ave.As we are preparing to move into our dream house, we received a disturbing news from our neighbor. We found out that the restaurant located just a couple houses from ours is applying for a permit to operate a night club at the premises. Needless to say, we are extremely upset at the prospect of having our on street parking spaces taken, loud music through late hours of the nights and possibly rowdy crowd around the area. Corona Del Mar is an upscale, peaceful and safe community, having a night club right in the middle of the residential area will most definitely ruin the integrity of our neighborhood.We have no objection to having a night club in Corona Del Mar provided it is operated away from the residential areas. As elected officials for the residents in Corona Del Mar, we urge you to protect the image and the serenity of the community, respect the voice and the interest of the residents in Corona Del Mar and reject the application for the amendment to Use Permit No. 1566 and Off -Site parking Agreement No. OP 2009- 003.We strongly and Vehemently oppose to granting a permit to operate a night club at 440 Heliotrope Ave. Sincerely, Suzanne and David Mok428.5 Heliotrope Ave-Corona Del Mar, CA 6 Murillo, Jaime From: Donald Okada fencore7 @sbcglobal.net] Sent: Tuesday, August 18, 2009 9:01 AM To: Murillo, Jaime Subject: Port Restaurant Jaime Murrillo, As a homeowner at 431 Iris, CdM, I wish to extend my support for Port Restaurant and their application to be heard on August 20th. Port is a lovely local establishment that furthers the experience of living in Corona del Mar. I fully support the application for a Entertainment Permit and increased operating hours. Anne Whitehead 431 Iris Notice to recipient: This e-mail and any attached files may contain confidential information or a communication privileged by law and is intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are addressed. If you received this e-mail in error, you are hereby notified that any disclosure, copying, dissemination, distribution, or use of any of the information contained in or attached to this transmission is STRICTLY PROHIBITED. If you have received this email in error please notify us immediately of the error by return e-mail and please destroy the original transmission and its attachments without reading or saving them in any manner. Thank you in advance for your cooperation. an, A, frjt9 �as6q M A K A August 16, 2009 To whom it may concern, I have been a resident of Corona Del Mar for several years. I recently built a home in the area just three doors down from Port Restaurant. My home is located at 430 Heliotrope in CUM. I can't say enough about this reslourant and Ali. They are top notch with their service and their cuisine. They are so professional with all aspects of their, business including any weekend and nightly activities. The location of Port makes it nice for locals to walk to which keeps the area safe and because it is so convenient, they are keeping the community within the city limits and that keeps the revenues in our area. I am a business owner and Port has always exemplified the type of service I would expect from my hotels and restaurants. Regards, Paul Makarechian CEO Makar Properties LLC ,..•• yrs 'i ,l'. .i.h r(: I'.:�I � ,':�Yic:i .. Yl ril cl,l•k_'.L�iu.'. Murillo, Jaime From: Denise Beaufort [dbeaufort@roadrunner.com] Sent: Friday, August 14, 2009 8:28 PM To: Murillo, Jaime Subject: Re:Port Restaurant & Bar Use Permit No. 1566 I am writing this letter in regards to the amendment to Use Permit No. 1566 for the Port Restaurant & Bar. I am a resident in the 400 block of Heliotrope Ave and have some concerns about the Port Restaurant & Grill extending the closing time to 1:00am as well as the introduction of live entertainment and dancing. Many of their patrons park along our street and their voices can be heard as they walk back to their cars. Some are laughing, while others are having conversations. We hear them as they start their cars and drive off. We as homeowners on this street hear this and tolerate it for the most part. Closing the restaurant at 1:00 is just too late for all of this to be going on. This restaurant opens to Heliotrope Ave. which is unique from the other restaurants in CdM. Most of them front Pacific Coast Hwy. My concern is the noise level that will come from live entertainment and dancing. The restaurant is located too close to the homes to have music emanating from it. I am also concerned about the lines that will form along the street as people are waiting to get in to dance and listen to the live entertainment.. These lines can get long and the noise level increases as people congregate. This is not the type of business that belongs along a neighborhood street. Thank you Sincerely, Chris and Denise Beaufort (My email provider is changing my email address from "dbeaufort0ladelohia.net" to "dbeaufort(Droadrunner.com ") QkAAJ A% �0 ''<ta�aeo°i Murillo, Jaime From: Frank Ultimo [frank @teamultimo.com] Sent: Sunday, August 16, 2009 11:20 AM To: Murillo, Jaime Cc: info @portcdm.com Subject: Port Restaurant Hi Jaime, I am a locally resident in CDM and I wanted to show my support for the Port Restaurant in regards to extend the closing hours and obtain the live entertainment permit as well as additional lunch hours. I visit Port frequently and believe the restaurant is an asset to the community for all of us residents and visitors. I think that they are a quality establishment and wish to support there business to assure that they will be around for years to come. The combination of there excellent food, entertainment as well as friendly service is definitely noted at Port. I believe the management will demonstrate what ever is reasonably necessary to satisfy the city, neighbors and objectors of this application. Please consider my opinion. Thank You, Frank Ultimo 708.5 Marigold Ave. Corona Del Mar, CA 9262 &2411 Call; 949 - 689.5293 The information contained in this message may be privileged and confidential and protected from disclosure. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, or an employee or agent responsible for delivering this message to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by replying to the message and deleting it from your computer. Murillo, Jaime From: Avi Bagherpour [avibagherpour @gmail.com] Sent: Friday, August 14, 2009 1:15 PM To: Murillo, Jaime Subject: From Avi Bagherpour (I LOVE PORTIM) Hi there. I hope Port gets to stay open late night and keep their entertainment. Their music is so awesome there and many people would be let down as Port is everyone's favorite place to go! Their food is amazing and a lot of people wouldn't have a place to go to eat for lunch, since everyone in the area loves their lunch menu! So many residents and visitors go there .... I always have friends from abroad visiting and everytime they come back they say, "we wana go to Port!" Also a lot of people work there as employees, wouldn't it hurt for more jobs to be lost in this difficult economic time if the restaurant is doing well and doesn't NEED to let go of employees? Please keep Port going strong and long by extending the hours of business and keeping entertainment there ... that's part of why Port is so great. Without their exquisite cuisine and amazing entertainment ... Port wouldn't stand out the way that it does. Thanks, Avi Bagherpour 949 - 293 -3433 auibaeherpournn email.com ,Hoed- A� V Is it4.(a66C Murillo, Jaime From: Dino Katsiametis [dino @caccastalloans.com] Sent: Friday, August 14, 2009 12:18 PM To: Murillo, Jaime Subject: port restaurant in CDM Hi my name is Dino Katsiametis and I live in Corona Del Mar. I'm writing this letter to show my support in allowing Port Restaurant to do a small remodel. As a resident of Corona Del Mar I like to support my local businesses. Although, we have many options for dinner we don't have very many options for dinner and entertainment. It would be nice to have a place within walking distance to enjoy dinner and music with friends and neighbors. Port is a gem of a place and I would really like to see it succeed. It has the disadvantage of being tucked away from the main traffic so only locals know of the place, which is probably why it has changed ownership as many times as it has. The owner is a reputable man and deserves a fair chance to succeed. urge you to allow for improvements and allow for light music entertainment. Respect, u� _R: t: Dino Katsiametis CFO 19700 Faireh ld Rd. Suite #150 Imine, CA 92612 IA (949) 720 -1616 ext.22 f" (949) 266 -5718 Don't forgot to ask me about our nevi divislon... :_I ac^ftt5i -c ltt 4e;ttent f:3[ =portunitics 1'61 FXelasive Clie€xts' Search the jVILS http: / /idx.diversesolutions.com /search /2843/4 aenaE -10 PC 4jto1a�69 Murillo, Jaime From: Sara harold [saraharold @hotmail.com] Sent: Friday, August 14, 2009 11:23 AM To: Murillo, Jaime Subject: FW: Port Restaurant & Bar To whom it may concern, I am writing this letter on behalf of Port Restaurant & Bar located in the city of Corona Del Mar (CDM) at 440 Heliotrope Ave. This is a great location for all of the CDM residents to go and enjoy them self with lounge style music. I have never walked in from the outside and heard any noise, but when I go in I can hear the great music. Everytime I am sitting enjoying myself with friends the bar closes and we are all forced to go home or walk to another bar. The type of people that go to this establishment are working adults that just need great food and a great atmosphere, and it's a great place to relax after a week of work. This establishment is not chaotic. I see no reason in not keeping Port open until the other local bars in the city close. Thank you for your time and I appreciate your consideration in this matter Sincerely, Sara Harold Local Resident of CDM dQA4'%PC H)l9laoa9 Murillo, Jaime From: Scott Wellwood [swellwood @dentalxchange.comj Sent: Friday, August 14, 2009 10:53 AM To: Murillo, Jaime Subject: Port Restaurant and Bar Mr. Murillo, I am writing to you today to ask for your support for Port Restaurant and Bar in Corona Del Mar. For the past two years I have enjoyed the food and atmosphere at this establishment and my company has hosted many business events there (large and intimate). It has become our "go to" place when we want to make a favorable impression with both local and out of town guests and business associates. I have reviewed their proposed project and am convinced that they have put a great deal of thought and effort into expanding their establishment and services in a manner that will not only improve their business, but will do so with the utmost consideration for the surrounding neighborhood. In such a tough economy where many businesses are floundering, it is important that we all do everything possible to support local establishments such as Port as they add not only revenue, but character and charm to our communities that is sorely lacking. I sincerely hope that we all will be able to reap the benefits of the Port improvements in the near future Best regards, Sean Scott Wellwood President EDI Health Group, Inc. - DentalXChange 17701 Cowan Suite 250 Irvine, CA 92614 Visit us online at w vQentalxchanoe.com. w .EHGFund.oro Tel., 877.932.2567 Ext. 220 Fax. 877.334.4545 swellwood(Ddentalxchange. cam "Enhanced Connectivity Solutions" EDI Health Group, Inc. is focused on the specific challenges faced by the dental EDI industry. Our mission is to create technology and transaction solutions that dental providers can easily understand and to respond effectively to the complex system integration needs of providers, vendors and payers. We exceed client expectations through our expertise and dedication to service excellence. CONFIDENTIALITYSTATEMENT. The information in this e-mail is confidential and maybe legally pri leged It is Intended for the use only of the addreme(s). Thank Yom Murillo, Jaime From: Jessica Anne Cahill Qessica @jwilliamsstaffing.com] Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2009 12:00 PM To: Murillo, Jaime Subject: Port in CDM.... Jaime, PORT is a wonderful local establishment that provides wonderful food and atmosphere in an area where there is not mnay alternatives .... a late night venue would be a wonderful addition to the CDM scene, and would provide additional revenue to the City of NB by increasing sales and promoting additional out of town visitors that will spend $$$$$ : -D live very nearby, and have for several years, and am in complete support!! Jessica Anne Cahill, CSP Vice President, Southern California New Home Sales Division JWilliamsStaffing, Inc. i Tuesday, August 18, 2009 To whom it may concern: I want to give my full support as a local resident to the Port Restaurant in Corona del Mar. I have lived within 100 yards of the Port at 432 1/2 Goldenrod Ave. for two years and I have to admit that there has never been a need to complain about any noise generated from restaurant's operation from their Music or their clients. My only wish is if they could be open later so our experience does not end abruptly and we don't have to go to other places that are not as good as Port afterwards. My Neighbors and I try to go to Port every once in a while to enjoy their great appetizers and dinner menu as well as listening to local musicians and DJ's that are playing at very respectful levels. I was very disappointed to see that they had to stop the Music a couple months ago because of their upcoming application to the city. We can definitely use a place around here to provide Music in a tasteful manner. Port is a "gem" in the heart of Corona Del Mar. It is well -run place with excellent food and welcoming staff as you have heard by other neighbors and local residents and it's a perfect place to meet clients for business meetings. It would be quite an addition to the community if they were to open for lunch. Please feel free to contact me at the numbers listed below if you have any questions Kindly, Justin Kautz 949 - 748 -5143 efax 559 - 679 -5730 cell 949 - 612 -7386 direct Mr. Murillo, I am writing in support of Port Restaurant in Corona del Mar. We have lived just down the street from the restaurant for over 7 years and have witnessed the changes in the establishment as well as it's management. During the time that Port Restaurant has been in business, we have never had a problem with any sound or nuisance issues resulting from the restaurant. In fact, it has been a positive experience to have a close location we can frequent with such a friendly staff, great food and enjoyable ambiance. Jason and Sandi Rockwood 438 Goldenrod 949 - 929 -9445 H i, I am emailing you to give my support for the proposed changes for Port Restaurant. I own a home nearby for many years and we have dinner at Port very often. There has never been a problem outside Port and we are in favor of the proposed changes and additions. I don't see any reason not to support this plan. With many for lease signs around Corona del Mar as there are now and will continue to be for the foreseeable future, we should fully support this local business. This plan will provide more money for city revenue and employment. Thank You Scott Hendel 310 - 967 -9888 Hello Ms. Murillo, I have enjoyed the restaurants that have occupied the space at 440 Heliotrope for many years, and Port is by far the best of them. The new ownership has definitely changed the venue for the better, with amazing dining, wonderful staff and excellent service. It is no longer a bar /restaurant... but a restaurant with a nice bar /lounge. 1 live in CDM and go to Port for family dinner in the earlier hours (we have 2 small children), date night with my husband and Girls Night Out with my fellow mom friends when we get a "hall pass" to stay out late. Port is a great restaurant and the entertainment is always nice, never too loud or annoying, which I can't stand when you are trying to speak with others! In fact, I believe Port is now the only place to go in CDM to enjoy fantastic cuisine in a hip, airy (and clean) atmosphere with fun music (I am past the age of enjoying clubs). When we have friends, family or business customers visiting from out of town, we always recommend Port. I also care to share with you that the owner, Ali, is a very kind and generous man who assisted our local Harbor View public elementary school with it's fundraising endeavors. Ali generously hosted our Underwriting party at Port and supplied all the specialty drinks at our annual event at the Fairmont Hotel last November, helping our Parent Faculty Organization raise $110,000. No other shop or store has, in the two years I co- chaired our events, assisted us as much as Port did this past year, a time of great need as the CA school budget funding continues to decrease. I sincerely hope you assist Port restaurant with their plans to improve upon their successful business. I would especially like to be able to go there for lunch 1 Like the Lido Diner next to the Lido theater, Port can offer a place to dine before and after shows. More importantly, Port can become a CDM landmark along with the rejuvenated Port theater, a real town jewel where neighbors of all ages can enjoy fine yet casual dining and entertainment, and visitors can get a real feel for the life and friendship that CDM residents enjoy. Please support and approve Port's requests for improvements, as they have proven to show consideration and respect to our neighborhood in their successful business strategies, Tracey McCarter CDM resident since 1996 949.300.5855 Hi Jaime, I am a locally resident in CDM and I wanted to show my support for the Port Restaurant in regards to extend the closing hours and obtain the live entertainment permit as well as additional lunch hours. I visit Port frequently and believe the restaurant is an asset to the community for all of us residents and visitors. I think that they are a quality establishment and wish to support there business to assure that they will be around for years to come. The combination of there excellent food, entertainment as well as friendly service is definitely noted at Port. I believe the management will demonstrate what ever is reasonably necessary to satisfy the city, neighbors and objectors of this application. Please consider my opinion. Thank You, Frank Ultimo 708.5 Marigold Ave. Corona Del Mar, CA 92625 -2411 Call; 949 - 689 -5293 Hi my name is Dino Katsiametis and I live in Corona Del Mar. I'm writing this letter to show my support in allowing Port Restaurant to do a small remodel. As a resident of Corona Del Mar I like to support my local businesses. Although, we have many options for dinner we don't have very many options for dinner and entertainment. It would be nice to have a place within walking distance to enjoy dinner and music with friends and neighbors. Port is a gem of a place and I would really like to see it succeed. It has the disadvantage of being tucked away from the main traffic so only locals know of the place, which is probably why it has changed ownership as many times as it has. The owner is a reputable man and deserves a fair chance to succeed. I urge you to allow for improvements and allow for light music entertainment. Respect, Dino Katsiametis CEO 19700 Fairchild Rd. Suite #150 Irvine, CA 92612 teL (949) 720 -1616 ext22 fax (949) 266 -5718 Don't forget to ask me about our new division... E=.aclusive Investment Opportunities fbr Exclusive Clients To whom it may concern, I am writing this letter on behalf of Port Restaurant & Bar located in the city of Corona Del Mar (CDM) at 440 Heliotrope Ave. This is a great location for all of the CDM residents to go and enjoy them self with lounge style music. I have never walked in from the outside and heard any noise, but when I go in I can hear the great music. Everytime I am sitting enjoying myself with friends the bar closes and we are all forced to go home or walk to another ba r. The type of people that go to this establishment are working adults that just need great food and a great atmosphere, and it's a great place to relax after a week of work. This establishment is not chaotic. I see no reason in not keeping Port open until the other local bars in the city close. Thank you for your time and I appreciate your consideration in this matter. Sincerely, Sara Harold Local Resident of CDM The Port is a breathe of fresh air. The staff and the fine setting is serine and relaxing. The entertainment is a must! !! This restaurant is everything positive to the entire community. Please keep the Port open later, keep the entertainment let Corona Del Mar and surrounding cities enjoy The Port to get away and enjoy fine food, fine atmosphere and fine spirits!! Thank you!!! Stacy Gens Dear Mr. Murillo, I understand there is a hearing for the Port Restaurant, and I really felt that I had to give my input on the matter. I am a resident in Corona Del Mar, and I have been going to The Port since its opening, as I had gone to the other restaurants before it. However Port has something special about it! I go there with my mom to wind down after work, and be around quality people. The Port really caters to any age with its ambiance of music, and the great architecture and ambiance. The food is great -I go there for Brunch and dinner, and repeatedly I have asked the owner if they could open for lunch. Corona del Mar is a great place for nice restaurants, and i think the PORT really brings in quality people from CDM, as well as our neighbors in Laguna beach and Newport Beach. Its presence in many magazines and all of its positive advertising bring a large crowd to Corona Del Mar. A friend of mine is a very close neighbor of the PORT and she says that she never is interrupted by its crowd because of its secluded location. The music is never too loud, and really gives the restaurant a good vibe. I think Corona del Mar would be missing a lot if it didn't have The Port!! Thank you for your time, - Shadan Shamloo 2500 Lighthouse Lane Corona Del Mar, CA 92625 9)735 -9067 Dear Mr. Jaime Murillo, I've reviewed the Port Restaurant Project Details http: / /portcdm.com/project.html and signed their On -Line Petition http:// www. 12etitiononline .com/pgrtcdm2 /petition.html. This email is to show you my support for all Port Restaurant initiatives. Mr. Murillo, for over one year I've enjoyed Corona Del Mar's finest 4- Star Restaurant, Port www.PortCDM.com. I've always been welcomed by all Port staff, including the owner himself. I believe Port Restaurant is an asset to Corona Del Mar, so anything that improves Port will ultimately prove to be Win - Win -Win for the people of CDM, the City and Port. Sincerely, Richard Hart Corona Del Mar, CA 92625 9)735 -9067 To Whom it may concern, I was given your email address from a friend/ the owner of Port Restaurant. I am a 31 year old, single and professional Freelance Graphic Designer who has 5 friends that live on Heliotrope. I live at 435 1/2 Heliotrope, which is across the street and three houses down from Port. In my opinion, and speaking on behalf of my friends, Port is a place we absolutely love to go. Its a welcoming atmosphere, where people from the community, younger and older, can come after work and on weekend nights to wind down from work, meet new people, network, etc. When I heard that Port was having trouble with the city and had to use noise contraints /close early because of complaints, I was shocked. I work from home and lead a busy and professional life and I never hear ANY noice or any kind of disturbances coming from there ... if anything, I occasionally hear my neighbors yelling, or someone's tv is turned up loud, but never hear anything from Port besides some fun laughs, in which actually make me want to go over and join in the fun. This place is very unique to the other bars and restaurants in the area because of its MUSIC and ecclectic style. Whether its a guy on a guitar singing, or the talented djs that they have play, we all enjoy it the way it is! It only adds to the experience that they have such a personable staff, great hidden location, and great food! In my experience, this is a place where I've met new great friends, talked business, celebrated birthdays, and hope to have many more experiences at Port. Thank you in advance for taking this letter into consideration. Carrie Trimm 949 -500 -2077 435 1/2 Heliotrope Ave, Corona Del Mar, CA 92625 I am a local 29 year resident of Newport Beach and live @ 71 Linda Isle. I have been a regular customer since the current owners took over and have frequented this establishment under at least 3 previous owners. I have found the Port to be a great place to meet ,mingle ,and enjoy great food with friends. The ownership is first class and almost always on premises. With rare exceptions even as a 60 yr old ,I find the cliental to be a fun loving but well behaved group, and a comfortable atmosphere. It is a nice addition to the area and a pleasent place to visit. I hope what they are requesting is approved and the can continue to grow and prosper. Bill Piercey As a resident of Corona Del Mar I am requesting that the City of Newport Beach approve any plans to expand and improve their facility. The Port has become an important location that many local residents enjoy and feel comfortable spending time. The restaurant is very supportive of the community. Dan Tarulli CEO Tarulli Tire Inc mobile: 714 883 5722 email: Dan @TarulliTire.com website: www.tarullitire.com Hello Jaime: My name is Sara and I am a weekly Port customer. Sometimes I'll visit more than once a week. The place is cozy and friendly oriented. The food is great and all his employees, owner included and very professional and friendly. I love to go there and network with other professionals and entrepreneurs like me. The entertainment is fun, variable and very desent. It is funny that a lot of time when I am at the front, I think the place is close, because is so quiet. It is not until I get into the place that I realize that is busy and the entertainment is on. So don't really know what it is all this about. I love to go there and have a good and healthy time. I don't live in Corona Del Mar, I live in Irvine, but Port is one of the few places that I feel safe and confortable to go and have a good time. Hope this helps, please look at the facts. Thanks for your attention. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me. Sara Chevere 714 -651 -2153 www.tkeniisecrel.com Dear Jamie, I have been going to Port Restaurant 2 -3 times a week since it opened a couple of years ago. In fact, these days, Port is the place where my friends and I go to relax, eat good food, have a laugh and enjoy the music. For what I need and want in a restaurant & bar, Port has everything. I feel safe and secure at Port, it has a cool ambience and friendly staff. It is truly unique in Orange County. Port is well liked by everyone who has ever been there. The only draw -back is how early it closes. If Port is allowed to stay open a bit longer, it would bring more enjoyment to the customers while helping the owner with higher revenues, and thus, higher tax revenues for Corona Del Mar -- a win - win -win for all involved. I strongly urge you to approve Port's application. regards, Alan Hi Mr. Murillo My name is Babak Khorashadi and I am a regular at Port. Its a place where locals get togather and have a good time. We just wish it can stay open for us till 2:00am like other clubs around port such as Landmarke, quite women, The place, and etc.. Babak Khorashadi Jamie Murrillo, I am writing in regards to Port Restaurant's application to extend the closing time by one hour and obtaining the now required live entertainment permit. I am a resident of Corona Del Mar and live one block South of Heliotrope on Iris. I consider Port Restaurant my 1 st choice for fine dining and entertainment. I have been frequenting Port Restaurant since it opened in 2007 due to it's award winning cuisine and extremely friendly service. Port has a very reserved fashion of live entertainment which is good for our neighborhood. This can be backed by the results of the sound study. During these times, granting of this permit can only benefit our city by it's positive impact to increase city revenue and provide employment for 25 employees. Port management has maintained a consciousness nature up to this date, and I am convinced that they will continue to do so in the future with additional security personnel to insure an orderly exit of the clients. Thank you for your consideration in this matter. Dave Ball Jaime Murrillo, As a homeowner at 431 Iris, CdM, I wish to extend my support for Port Restaurant and their application to be heard on August 20th. Port is a lovely local establishment that furthers the experience of living in Corona del Mar. I fully support the application for a Entertainment Permit and increased operating hours. Anne Whitehead 431 Iris Jamie Murrillo, I wish to express my support to Ali and Port Restaurant for their upcoming hearing on August 20`". As a local resident and homeowner at 316 Iris, I fully support the application for increased hours and the Entertainment Application. I have been a patron of Port for a number of years including its days as Mistrial. Ali has brought the same consciousness and experience to Port while updating its appeal. I also own a triplex at 227, 229, 231 Carnation. I have seen my tenants at Port on numerous occasions and they have expressed to me their support as well. Regards, Donald Okada 316 IRIS Corona del Mar, CA Thursday, July 26, 2007 Restaurant not just any Port in a storm Review: A new Newport Beach restaurant offers a fresh and tasty refuge in a sea of sameness. By ELIZABETH EVANS SPECIAL TO THE ORANGE COUNTY REGISTER Comments t I Recommend 0 1 have a theory about the song 'We May Never Pass This Way Again." That is, the guys who wrote it never reviewed restaurants in Orange County. For if Jimmy Seals and Dash Croft had, they would have been aware of a certain dejA vu when it comes to the dining scene here. Its not just that restaurants copy one another and that themes get replayed — Northern Italian, anyone? Its also that with the high turnover of restaurants and the limited spaces for them, new places tend to turn up where old restaurants once stood. There are few places where that is more true than in one small stand -alone building on Heliotrope Avenue in Corona del Mar. This problematic space with no parking lot and a tiny dining area has housed at least four different eateries in the decade -plus that I've been covering local eateries. Trees, Mistral and Svelte have all come and gone, and five months ago Port Restaurant/Bar opened. And while I've never been a fan of the cramped dining room, I do have a fondness for what comes out of the kitchen. And my opinion of the newly remodeled space hasn't changed much. On this visit we're seated at a window with a view to the atrium space that houses the outdoor section of the bar. There's a singer -guitarist on the other side of the window — note: I like that there's live music this early in the work week. However, when he starts to play his muffled songs compete with the soft jazz playing in the dining room and a broadcast soccer game apparently coming from the kitchen. In addition one of the patio's bright heat lamps shines directly in my eyes. I feel as if I should invoke the Geneva Conventions. The good news is the wait staff here is responsive to our pleas, and the Muzak is turned off along with the light. Then we can concentrate on the food and a glass of Veuve Clicquot ($18 a glass), which we've ordered as an aperitif. The French Champagne is a nice accompaniment to the starters we've chosen. Appetizers include Springtime Asparagus Soup ($11), which ... wait for it ... tastes of asparagus. The buttery grass flavor of the delicate vegetable is so prevalent that one wonders how anything that's been creamed and cooked to such a smooth potage could maintain its taste integrity. After a few bites other flavors break through, and I detect the warming touch of nutmeg and woody morel mushrooms that have been added to the blend. Chef to add and layer flavors and ingredients. Even the House Salad ($12) is a lovely mountain of mixed greens dressed in a heady sherry-based vinaigrette topped with roasted candy cane beets and glossy candied almonds. Clams and Mussels ($14) are also well prepared. All of the meaty bivalves arrive at the table open in their shells. They are served in a fragrant white wine sauce imbued with a mix of herbs and spices reminiscent of Morocco. But I think my favorite starter is the House Gnocchi ($14). Rather than big soft pillows of mashed potato dumplings, these are pebble size and pan saut6ed. They're served in a pile with crisp browned exteriors tossed with caramelized cipollini onions, juicy roasted tomatoes and morel mushrooms in a light cream sauce over a bed of spinach. If I wasn't working I could have easily stopped there, but that would mean I would have missed the Spiced Lamb Chops ($38). Three big meaty chops cooked to order, which for me is medium -rare. It's a difficult preparation to get right; in other restaurants my meat has arrived either overdone or underdone. Here it looks as if it might be the latter, however, the crisp outside is dark brown and sizzling and the interior is warm, pink and just right to the tooth. The mildly grassy meat is served in a pool of savory roasted tomato and shallot sauce and over a lemon zest, almond, and dried cherry- studded couscous. Striped Sea Bass ($26) is served with a sweet corn relish and lightly cooked English peas. Its an elegant way to present this delicate and under -used fish. Maine Diver Scallops ($36) are another winner. These bivalves, about the size of a silver dollar, are crisp on the outside and just past the point of quivering inside. They are lined up on a rectangular plate on a bed of fennel and mushrooms. I have a soft spot for homey food, and Braised Short Ribs ($26) rank high on that list. Port's version is like something straight from grandma's slow cooker. They are deeply cooked and have a meaty taste and silken texture that seems to melt into the soft polenta on which it comes. Completing this cozy dish are sweet carrots, caramelized onions and earthy baby turnips. Amazingly, the Taz Pinot Noir Fiddlestix Vineyard ($60) is a fine partner for each of the dishes we've ordered tonight. The Santa Barbara County red is a full- bodied Pinot Noir that is still gentle enough for the lighter dishes. Desserts include some fine chocolate choices including a very well - prepared Chocolate Souffle Cake ($10), a ramekin - shaped dessert that has the kitchen's signature crisp -on- the - outside, wicked -on- the - inside texture. There's also a dense Chocolate Tart ($10) made with dark chocolate and served with seasonal fruit and chocolate ice cream. Its a very decadent sweet. The menu says the Mixed Berry Crumble ($10) is served piping hot, and it is — this not - too -sweet mix of blueberries, strawberries amd blackberries in a balsamic glaze is too warm to eat when it first arrives, so we melt the vanilla ice cream it's served with over the top to cool things down. But the dessert that offers the biggest surprise might be the Mandarin Panna Cotta ($10). The egg -free custard comes from the kitchen looking like just another nursery sweet dolled up on an oversized dish, but instead it is a blend of ginger and citrus, fragrant with vanilla and full of flavor. I am going to have to rethink my seen -one- panna- cotta - seen - them -all stance. All I can say is that if I do have to pass this way again, I hope it's because I'm returning to Port.