HomeMy WebLinkAbout20 - Appointments by the City CouncilJanuary 23, 2001
Agenda Item No. 20
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
FROM: LaVonne M. Harkless, City Clerk
SUBJECT: APPOINTMENTS BY THE CITY COUNCIL TO CITIZENS ADVISORY
COMMITTEES, THE AVIATION COMMITTEE AND THE MAYOR'S
APPOINTMENTS TO THE HARBOR COMMITTEE.
Pursuant to Council Policy A -9, the Citizens Advisory Committees are comprised solely of
citizens with perhaps City Council or staff liaison. The Aviation Committee has the same basic
composition with the addition of the president or designee of the Airport Working Group. The
enabling resolutions for the Environmental Quality Affairs Citizen Advisory Committee, the
Harbor Quality Citizens Advisory Committee and the Aviation Committee provide that
appointees represent each of the Councilmanic districts in which case appointments shall be
made by individual Council members for their respective districts subject to confirmation by the
full City Council.
In preparation for these annual appointments phone calls were made to all of the current
members to determine their continued interest in serving or being considered for appointment. A
"Notice of Vacancies" was also published in The Daily Pilot on December 16 and 23d soliciting
new applicants for the Harbor Quality Citizens Advisory Committee. The deadline for applicants
to apply was Thursday, December 28, 2000.
As of January 5, 2001, we have received the following responses from the current members of
the Aviation Committee and the Harbor Quality Citizens Advisory Committee. All members of
these two committees have responded indicating that they are interested in continuing to serve in
their present capacity.
Also listed below are the current members serving on EQAC. EQAC appointed a Membership
Subcommittee, which polled the current committee members regarding their interest in
continuing to serve and those that indicated an interest are designated. In cases where there is
more than one interested person for a District, the other persons are likely to qualify for the
positions to be nominated by EQAC.
• Environmental Quality Affairs Citizens Advisory Committee
Citizens District)
Tom Hyans (1) At large [Interested]
Louis Von Dyl (1) [Interested]
Elaine Linhoff (1) [Interested]
Christopher Welsh (2) At large
Pete Tarr (2)
Marge Pantzar (2) [Interested]
Brent Jacobsen (3)
Gale Demmer (3) [Interested]
Vacant (3) At large
Jennifer Winn (4) [Interested]
Barry Eaton (4) [Interested]
Richard Rivett (4) At large
Phillip Lugar (5) At large [Interested]
Jack Callahan, Jr. (5)
Jean Watt (5)
Barry Allen (6) At large [Interested]
Laura Dietz (6) [Interested]
Jim Wayne (6)
Ernie Bain
Vacant
Vacant
(7)
(7)
(7) At large
In addition to the current members that have indicated an interest in serving, attached are copies of
the applications currently on file for EQAC (Gordon Kilmer and Nancy Raney).
• Harbor Quality Citizens Advisory Committee
Citizens District)
Nancy Gardner
Alan Silcock
(2)
George Drayton
(3)
Bud Frenzel
(4)
Tom Houston
(5)
Lee Sutherland (6)
James Martinez (7)
In addition to the current members that have indicated an interest in serving, attached are copies of
the applications currently on file for the Harbor Quality Citizens Advisory Committee (Mark
Kurian and John Cunningham).
• Aviation Committee
Citizens (District)
Robert Shepherd (1)
Pete Drummond (1) Alt.
Dan Gilliland (2)
Timothy Brown (2) Alt.
Sue Hogan (3)
Tom Anderson (3) Alt.
Richard Taylor (4)
Mike Bigi (4) Alt.
Nancy Raney (5)
Vacant (5) Alt.
Bill Lusk (6)
Bonnie O'Neil (6) Alt.
Chuck Colesworthy (7)
Vacant (7) Alt.
In addition to the current members that have indicated an interest in serving, attached are copies of
the applications currently on file for the Aviation Committee (John Cunningham).
Harbor Committee
The Harbor Committee, as established by resolution, consists of thirteen (13) private citizens,
nominated by the Mayor and confirmed by the City Council. The terms are for one year (January
1" to December 31 s). The following is a list of the current members as appointed on 1/25/99:
Mike Whitehead
Darryl Lundrum
John Corrough
Lee Sutherland
Gary Hill
Tim Collins
Clive Towndrow
Seymour Beek
Tom Houston
Mark Sites
Dave New
Bill Mountford
Ralph Rodheim
LaVonne M. Harkless, City Clerk
APPLIC�-..ION FOR APPOINTIVE r'OSITION
filled out completely so that the City Council may fully evaluate your qualifications. Applications will be kept on file for two
years. If you are not selected for appointment during that period of time, it will be necessary for you to re- submit an
application if you are still interested in being considered. NOTICE: Section 702 of the City Charter requires that members
of Boards or Commissions appointed by the City Council shall be from the qualified electors of the City.
NAME OF BOARD, COMMISSION, OR COMMITTEE: EIVUIKcr/mk rw- .-"r%Q
Name: K,0Lv
(Last)
Residence Address: I E
How long have you lived in Newport Beach?
Business Address: 19 Qov£
(First)
Home Phone _
Business Phone
Soc. Sec. No.
(Middle)
Have you ever been convicted of any crime or violation of any law or statute other than minor traffic violations?
Yes No !�_ (If yes, explain on reverse side)
Name and Location of Colleges/Universities Attended
Major
Degree
Last Year
Attended
PAST LLC- E o,trR MW
,61ili41- a
A. 19.
19 b 2-
L1F kSS 1- A Late )gcH
oL Ti&4L &6ruKa
1
51 fo
l.iF. ST4TR �b
Atl +rvu7�z�tl�on
—
196 S
(yam. -EC40V of DtaZd 61
1490— A&!$Nl
ENViitry MaN w- Q mLi' liF'FdIvu 9�Irissnu APwi -& I Co At m .
619"A901 o1' 04*24NO,
1991 — A91
Prior or Current Civic Experience (Include membership in
professional, charity or community organizations)
Office Held
if an
Dates of
Membership
w cr aCA or c ^
--
ruorr
14 ?0 —1190
Nrzw at 4ARGcot G Q of t^ow%oEvzcfz
1410 —t4�s
01*4 u ` tP ^ .c, . Pomo ¢tlte C w PO NA
Ct+ "E
'1 (0 -iCoe
Nrcw fbvtr µ'Lt.s
PRes1 *0ari1'+).R
14'11 —FA se4i
C_ii61 -. e4e S ilwli SSpervf l'tcnl
(yam. -EC40V of DtaZd 61
1490— A&!$Nl
ENViitry MaN w- Q mLi' liF'FdIvu 9�Irissnu APwi -& I Co At m .
619"A901 o1' 04*24NO,
1991 — A91
(OVER)
Occupational History. Begin with your ..resent or most recent position. List all , ;itions separately held for the last five
year9.
Firm or Organization
Type of Business
Title
Dates of
Employment
/
KIL EZA E ?Tc2 Rl?ds
Fooio SeRvir—a
nn
i'2>:tr EM-
1970 -
References (include names of at least two residents of Newport Beach who are not officially connected with the City).
Name Address Telephone No.
1. IN -L'635 PoyOrr mQGQL , Q C4. 92640 '7S9 -403
2. Fj9Eb ttucI W$S 3o RouAG. ST GEo,eiE (y. 11 09.gL6(A0 �IN9)G'f�-o616
In the space provided below, summarize briefly why you wish to serve the City of Newport Beach on a Board or Commission.
Include any special qualifications you have which are particularly appropriate to the position for which you are applying:
(THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT SECTION AND MUST BE COMPLETED FOR YOUR APPLICATION TO BE
GIVEN CONSIDERATION. IF MORE SPACE IS REQUIRED, PLEASE ATTACH A SEPARATE SHEET).
Signature
Mis_l \Users \Clk \Shared\ Boards, Commissions, Committees \Miscellaneous\Application
I L ^) o"g3
Date
APPLICATION FOR APPOINTIVE POSITION
Applications will be Jept on file for two years. If you are not selected for appointment during that period of
time, it will be necessary for you to re- submit an application if you are still interested in being considered.
NOTICE: Section 702 of the City Charter requires that members of Boards or Commissions appointed by
the City Council shall be from the qualified electors of the City.
NAME OF BOARD, COMMISSION, OR COMMITTEE: &,Wt( ZA4Wirf ( EZIkkG)
Name: 94*- 46111 NA0\J6&7 E3.12A SE77f'-
(Last) (First) (Middle)
Residence Address: _96 Gtt.*J % CoWlft p PAL-&A I f L4A /17 Cri- c( "(e 2,
How long have you lived in Newport Beach? II vT rS Home Phone +K £-73-03.210
Business Address: 301 6 IWP 40W* L- Business Phone /144 (.77- 072.1.
a*+ 4OA- WL#WD e-+ g21.62- Soc. Sec. No. 1Z0— 72 - 7S$6
Have you ever been convicted of any crime or violation of any law or statute other than minor traffic
violations?
Yes No W-' (If yes, explain on reverse side)
Name and Location of Colleges/
Universities Attended
Major
Degree
Last Year
Attended
SIA'IrC UH ✓rs
h �'W ied
RA-
M)o
le" LA-W
JD
K63
fib.,,, j O C"
Prior or Current Civic Experience (Include membership
in professional, charity or community organizations)
Office Held
if an
Dates of
Membership
i�! lG hin Kw/ tV r cil.
AA.0 4e e-
12 -;1 {f
Kzu/ r-+- 8n1lic . G GlKb
Pre r(
Jalo 4q9`?
fib.,,, j O C"
(OVER)
rw-f,r-fi
y I1+5
t4"
1594
Occupational History. Begin with your present or most recent position. List all positions separately held for
the last five vears.
Firm or Organization
Type of
Business
Title
Dates of
Employment
F' Cagy
I C'147 — r
IdnvN u
rc4 I9<iy 144
IZoL�Pn<w�� I.f�sbw�...+..
r I�t41- Ikq
s t (a�tr�4
UG 4
References (include names of at least two residents of Newport Beach who are not officially connected with
the City).
R
Q
Name Address Telephone No.
In the space provided below, summarize briefly why you wish to serve the City of Newport Beach on a Board
or Commission. Include any special qualifications you have which are particularly appropriate to the
position for which you are applying: (THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT SECTION AND MUST BE
COMPLETED FOR YOUR APPLICATION TO BE GIVEN CONSIDERATION. IF MORE SPACE IS
REQUIRED, PLEASE ATTACH A SEPARATE SHEET).
Plu+fc- sec-
Signature
Mis_1 \Users \C1k \3hered\ Boards, Commissions, Commi ttees\MismUaneous\Application
/ —Z —O/
Date
?. r'
1yj)
Application for Appointive Position — Nancy E. Raney (EQACAC)
I wish to serve the City of Newport Beach on the Environmental Quality Affairs Citizens
Advisory Committee because I truly care about the City of Newport Beach and its most
precious resources: its beaches, harbor, air quality and the use of its land. Because of my
experiences and ability to serve, I will be a valuable, contributing member of the
Committee.
I am currently a member of the Aviation Committee and enjoy serving on that committee
as the representative of District 5. The issues involving the extension of the Settlement
Agreement involving John Wayne Airport and a potential airport at the former El Toro
Marine Corps Air Station are probably the most significant issues impacting the quality
of life for Newport Beach residents.
Among the circumstances in which I have been involved with improving the immediate
environment was the process that ultimately culminated in the dredging of the Grand
Canal. By late 1998, it had become apparent that the Grand Canal had seriously
deteriorated. The sand level was decreasing, threatening the integrity of the bulkhead, and
the appearance of the Canal was dreadful. I attended a meeting of the Coastal
Commission in San Diego County at which the dredging was approved.
Through speaking with City representatives, I was aware that the City had put the
dredging project out to bid to many contractors, but only one had submitted a bid, which
was seriously over budget. In January 1999 the agenda of the City Council reflected that
the issue of the dredging of the Canal was to be put on hold indefinitely. In speaking with
then City Councilman John Noyes, it became apparent that the next step was to make the
City Council aware of how dire was the condition on the Grand Canal and how strongly
the neighbors felt about it. On a Sunday afternoon, I, along with another neighbor, went
door -to -door and collected almost forty signatures on a petition to urge the City Council
to approve the only existing bid and proceed with the dredging.
We were very grateful when, after receiving our petition, the City Council changed its
mind and unanimously voted to approve the dredging project. The Grand Canal is much
improved and is enjoyed by beachgoers and those who visit the ducks on the Grand Canal
after getting their coffee and frozen bananas.
As a member and President of the Newport Balboa Rotary Club, for the last seven years I
have been involved with many of the City's programs that are sponsored by the Club. I
worked with members of the Newport Beach Parks and Recreation Staff and participated
in events such as the All City Track Meet, the City's Halloween Carnival at Grant
Howald Park, the Special Olympics and the Sister City Program, through Newport
Balboa Rotary Club's Sister City relationship with Okazaki, Japan.
I have also completed the Community Emergency Response Training (CERT) Course
offered by the Fire and Marine Department, having attended the second session of CERT
classes offered. This year I also assisted with Public Safety Day at the Fire Station
Application for Appointive Position — Nancy E. Raney (EQACAC) — page 2
I have lived on Balboa Island since September 1989. I vacationed on Balboa Island every
August from the time I was six months old unti11983, when I took the California Bar
Exam, twenty -five years later.
I have always had a very strong connection and love for Balboa Island and Newport
Beach. Among my fondest childhood memories are playing in the sand in front of the
house, riding on the Showboat, walking down Marine Avenue in pursuit of a frozen
banana, sailing and paddle boarding in the harbor, and taking in the sights and sounds
around Balboa Island and the Pavilion during evening walks.
I actually always dreamed of living on Balboa Island, and that dream became possible
when I had the opportunity to transfer from the Los Angeles office of Cummins and
White to the firm's Newport Beach office. I took that opportunity and moved onto
Balboa Island in September 1989.
When I applied to Stanford, applicants were asked to write an essay on the following
question: "If you were to write a book, what would it be about?" My topic was Balboa
Island. The Admissions officers must have liked my topic; they admitted me to the Class
of 1980.
In short, I can make a significant contribution as a member of the Environmental Quality
Affairs Citizens Advisory Committee. I have demonstrated an ability to assist in
accomplishing that which needs to be done to bring about improvement. I have developed
this sense of responsibility over years of visiting and living in Newport Beach. Through
my community service I have also shown a deep caring for the City. I have the time and
ability to serve the needs of the City on EQACAC and would welcome the opportunity to
do so.
I appreciate your considering me for a position on the Committee.
2
APPLICA-rION FOR APPOINTIVE t-OSITION
tilled out completely so that the City Council may fully evaluate your qualifications. Applications will be kept on file for two
years. If you are not selected for appointment during that period of time, it will be necessary for you to re- submit an
application if you are still interested in being considered. NOTICE: Section 702 of the City Charter requires that members
of Boards or Commissions appointed by the City Council shall be from the qualified electors of the City.
NAME OF BOARD, COMMISSION, OR COMMITTEE:
Name:
(First)
Residence Address:
How long have you lived _iin�Newport Beach ? / r3 t�_
Business Address: 4 / Gt r' ,
K& te ��
Home Phrne _
Business Phone
Soc. Sec. No. 1
(Middle)
�n.1 -7 --F�
Have you ever been convicted of any crime or violation of any law or statute other than minor traffic violations?
Yes No _�_ (If yes, explain on reverse side)
Name and Location of Colleges/Universities Attended
Major
Degree
Last Year
Attended
{ 9 . q-)L4., G
Prior or Current Civic Experience (Include membership in
professional, charity or community organizations)
Office Held
if an)
Dates of
Membership
(OVER)
Occupational History. Begin with your present or most recent position. List all positions separately held for the last five
ears.
Firm or ftrganization
WIFE, 00 4
,
References (include names of at least two residents of Newport Beach who are not officially connected with the City).
.�l
In the space provided below, summarizVbriefly why you wish to serve the City of N6vport Beach on a Board or Commission.
Include any special qualifications you have which are particularly appropriate to the position for which you are applying:
(THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT SECTION AND MUST BE COMPLETED FOR YOUR APPLICATION TO BE
GIVEN CONSIDERATION. IF MORE SPACE IS REQUIRED, PLEASE ATTACH A SEPARATE SHEET).
540
Date
Commissions,
APPLICATION FOR APPOINTIVE POSITION
a n r
'99 10 -9 P3 :41
0�r1;; = 0 of +'ITY CLi:RK
C ;T; .,,ilTaEacli
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
3300 Newport Boulevard
Newport Beach, CA 92663
City Clerk (949) 644 -3005
Fax (949) 644 -3039
DIRECTIONS: A separate application is required for each appointive position for which you apply. Applications should be
filled out completely so that the City Council may fully evaluate your qualifications. Applications will be kept on file for two
years. If you are not selected for appointment during that period of time, it will be necessary for you to re- submit an
application if you are still interested in being considered. NOTICE: Section 702 of the City Charter requires that members
of Boards or Commissions appointed by the City Council shall be from the qualified electors of the City.
NAITC OF BOARD, COMMISSION, OR COMMITTEE: J-1AL 'r �/
Name: CUNN /N/ NAM JoH,� I�avL
(Last) (First) (Middle)
Residence Address: I X S' E ore r 13 A V Z2o 14T /y FX.2 a- r- A c w CA 4 -z- e- & z.
How long have you lived in Newport Beach?
Business Address:
Home Phone 9 Ll q- G-7 s 9 4/009
Business Phone
Soc. Sec. No. 5Sa - S/o - z 1 73
Have you ever been convicted of any crime or violation of any law or statute other than minor traffic violations?
Yes No ✓ (If yes, explain on reverse side)
Name and Location of Colleges/Universities Attended
Major
Degree
Last Year
Attended
- CL /4, G4
8 qo
1953
Prior or Current Civic Experience (Include membership in
professional, charity or community organizations)
Office Held
if an
Dates of
Membership
0
8 qo
(OVER)
Occupational History. Begin with your present or most recent position. List all positions separately held for the last five
vears.
Firm or Organization
Type of Business
Title
Dates of
Employment
TI f
NA 14L., IzA CT 0 21N
1 C., c
S
References (include names of at least two residents of Newport Beach who are not officially connected with the City).
Name
Address
Telephone No.
1. SAN STfZIN66ZZ 70o SourN L�ie�FQaNT 9�/9- 673 -3L/D3
2. SE%/rv�rcE RFrE1,' 5-28 L:7>A.L1 'r Qq9 -G75 -98x7.
In the space provided below, summarize briefly why you wish to serve the City of Newport Beach on a Board or Commission.
Include any special qualifications you have which are particularly appropriate to the position for which you are applying:
(THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT SECTION AND MUST BE COMPLETED FOR YOUR APPLICATION TO BE
GIVEN CONSIDERATION. IF MORE SPACE IS REQUIRED, PLEASE ATTACH A SEPARATE SHEET).
SFr ATra @D
Mis_1 \Users \C1k\ Shored \Boards, Commissions, Committees \Miorellaneous\Appliration
/ /.g- 99
Date
I am in the process of retiring from a 40 year career in management at International
Aluminum Corporation, a publicly owned nationwide manufacturer of glass and aluminum
building products. I will be fully retired on December 31.
I feel that I am now at a stage in my life where I want to devote some of my attention and
skills to certain charitable and civic betterment efforts. I would be delighted to serve the
community as either a member of the Newport Beach Aviation Committee or the Harbor
Quality Advisory Committee.
My interest in our aviation related problems goes back many years as is evidenced by the
attached copy of a letter which I wrote to the Times back in the mid to late eighties - I'm
not sure exactly which year. For the record, George Rebella did come to our home one
morning at 7:03 for a meeting with a fairly large contingent of our local friends and
neighbors and about all he had to say was "anyone who bought a house on Balboa Island
after 1968 had rocks in his head ".
As far as harbor water quality is concerned, my wife and I now live on the Little Island
bay front, we are boaters and we have seven grandchildren who love to come to our home
and play on the beach and swim in the water. Need I say more?
The Airport Noise - Abatement Issue
George A. Rebeila's letter response (May
14) to William Monroe's letter regarding:
airport noise is tilled with the same political[
and bureaucratic nonsense that constantly
surrounds this whole subject. For anyone
to take the position that the number,
altitude and noise level of flights passing.
directly over our home on Balboa Island is
somehow acceptable indicates a total lack.
of knowledge of the true situation.
I would like to invite Rebella and any
officials he would like to bring along to
have coffee with us on our patio on Ruby
Avenue any morning at 7:03. Then, and.
apparently only then, will he perhaps;
realize the intolerable conditions for the
residents of our island created by the
routing of 100% of John Wayne's commer-
cial flights directly over our heads. A
spreading of the misery by the adoption of
perhaps three or four additional takeoff
vectors would at least allow for a fair'
exposure by other neighborhoods of New-
port Beach to the burden now borne by
those of us directly under the present flight
path.
The official position that BAe -146 air-
craft do not make enough noise to be
objectionable and therefore somehow do
not count in the daily tally indicates either
plugged ears or fuzzy thinking on some-
body's part. With the upcoming increased
capacity of the passenger terminal and the
already authorized further increase in the
number of flights, it is absolutely ridiculous
to exclude any multi- engine commercial jet
aircraft from noise control restrictions.
Admittedly, the 737s and certainly the
MD -80s are louder than the BAe -146s.
However, to term the latter quiet and
unobjectionable is absurd.
It is time for our airport and elected
officials to stop talking in riddles and start
doing something. I am hoping for a re-
sponse to my invitation.
JOHN P. CUNNINGHAM
Balboa Island
APPLICATION FOR APPOINTIVE POSITION
P D"CE;'d;_D
'99 10V -9 P 3 :41
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
3300 Newport Boulevard
Newport Beach, CA 92663
City Clerk (949) 644 -3005
0 i F nE "iE G ITY CI_EIRh 'uFOaN' Fax (949) 644 -3039
C.c.i I' u'".IRT BEACH
DIRECTIONS: A separate application is required for each appointive position for which you apply. Applications should be
Filled out completely so that the City Council may fully evaluate your qualifications. Applications will be kept on file for two
years. If you are not selected for appointment during that period of time, it will be necessary for you to re- submit an
application if you are still interested in being considered. NOTICE: Section 702 of the City Charter requires that members
of Boards or Commissions appointed by the City Council shall be from the qualified electors of the City.
NAME OF BOARD, COMMISSION, OR COMMITTEE: gyygr C e m ,.,
r
Name: CUNN /N! NAM ..1 OHNI I -AUL
(Last) (First) (Middle)
Residence Address: l Z S' G As T 3 A ,Z ZfLo NT /yEUPo rt- 3 r- A r- N CA q -I- e- a z
How long have you lived in Newport Beach? / G �/e�y cc Home Phone 9 q 4 - f- T 5 _ y y A
Business Address:
Business Phone
Soc. Sec. No. 5So - s/o - z 1 7
Have you ever been convicted of any crime or violation of any law or statute other than minor traffic violations?
Yes
No ✓ (If yes, explain on reverse side)
Name and Location of Colleges/Universities Attended
Major
Degree
Last Year
Attended
- CL /i e CA
8 40
1953
Prior or Current Civic Experience (Include membership in
professional, charity or community organizations)
Office Held
if an
Dates of
Membership
ffLff-S
8 40
(OVER)
Occupational History. Begin with your present or most recent position. List all positions separately held for the last five
Years.
Firm or Organization
Type of Business
Title
Dates of
Employment
t
N I
V1 E
S 99q
References (include names of at least two residents of Newport Beach who are not officially connected with the City).
Name
I
Address
Telephone No.
2. -S Et/ra.,RF -r�F_Et1 SZS <nt,TU l3 %✓ IZ2nuT 9r19 — W7s -98ZZ
In the space provided below, summarize briefly why you wish to serve the City of Newport Beach on a Board or Commission.
Include any special qualifications you have which are particularly appropriate to the position for which you are applying:
(THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT SECTION AND MUST BE COMPLETED FOR YOUR APPLICATION TO BE
GIVEN CONSIDERATION. IF MORE SPACE IS REQUIRED, PLEASE ATTACH A SEPARATE SHEET).
SE E A7 -rA ay
// -8 — 99
Date
,Mia_1 \Users \C1lr\ Shared \Boards, Commissions, Committees \Miswllanwus\Application
I am in the process of retiring from a 40 year career in management at International
Aluminum Corporation, a publicly owned nationwide manufacturer of glass and aluminum
building products. I will be fully retired on December 31.
I feel that I am now at a stage in my life where I want to devote some of my attention and
skills to certain charitable and civic betterment efforts. I would be delighted to serve the
community as either a member of the Newport Beach Aviation Committee or the Harbor
Quality Advisory Committee.
My interest in our aviation related problems goes back many years as is evidenced by the
attached copy of a letter which I wrote to the Times back in the mid to late eighties - I'm
not sure exactly which year. For the record, George Rebella did come to our home one
morning at 7:03 for a meeting with a fairly large contingent of our local friends and
neighbors and about all he had to say was "anyone who bought a house on Balboa Island
after 1968 had rocks in his head ".
As far as harbor water quality is concerned, my wife and I now live on the Little Island
bay front, we are boaters and we have seven grandchildren who love to come to our home
and play on the beach and swim in the water. Need I say more?
The Airport Noise - Abatement Issue
George A. Rebella's letter response (May
14) to William Monroe's letter regarding
airport noise is tilled with the same politicall
and bureaucratic nonsense that constantly
surrounds this whole subject. For anyone
to take the position that the number,
altitude and noise level of flights passing
directly over our home on Balboa Island i5
somehow acceptable indicates a total lack:
of knowledge of the true situation.
1 would like to invite Rebella and any'
officials he would like to bring along to
have coffee with us on our patio on Ruby
Avenue any morning at 7:03. Then. and.
apparently only then. will he perhaps'
realize the intolerable conditions for the
residents of our island created by the -
routing of 100;6 of John Wayne's commer-
cial flights directly over our heads. A
spreading of the misery by the adoption or
perhaps three or four additional takeoff
vectors would at least allow for a fair'
exposure by other neighborhoods of New-
port Beach to the burden now borne by
those of us directly under the present flight
path.
The official position that BAe -146 air-
craft do not make enough noise to be
objectionable and therefore somehow do
not count in the daily tally indicates either
plugged ears or fuzzy thinking on some-
body's part. With the upcoming increased
capacity of the passenger terminal and the
already authorized further increase in the
number of flights. it is absolutely ridiculous
to exclude any multi - engine commercialjet
aircraft from noise control restrictions.
Admittedly. the 737s and certainly the
MD -80s are louder than the BAe -146s.
However. to term the latter quiet and
unobjectionable is absurd.
It is time for our airport and elected
officials to stop talking in riddles and start
doing something. 1 am hoping for a re-
sponse to my invitation.
JOHN P. CUNNINGHAM
Balboa Island