Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutM2012-0044inn+Form:. Worksheet for Building Combo Permit Application j Comm I F Residential City of Newport Beach - Building Division i NOTE: PLAN CHECK FEE DUE AT TIME OF SUBMITTAL (-Building (' Grading F -Drainage F_ Elec F Mech (- Plum Cu Yd Cut r Cu Yd Filly ^ Project Address (Not mailing address) Floor Suite o I I� i I . �A�I A� �N l�� F - F - Description of Work Use �5"Vt -tel Axl moor, - l dor Kiri1� t ,, „ eq' ^� (O Gj V !!/i ) V Y/1 ' Qom, � 1 #Stories #Units (ii' Res)r_ Valuation $ Material/Labor N'ew/AddSFr_ Remodel SFl--- Garage/New/Add OWNER'S NAME Last I r✓Y Voles `j �� First' Owner's Address Owner's E-mail Address Jacquelyn. chung@sbcglobal.net City Newport Beach r State California Zip 2 BTele hone9�49.631:312-1 i APPLICANT'S NAME Last f Swift First Pete Applicant's Address Applicant's E-mail Address 2027 Placentia AvenueJacquelyn.chung@sbcglobal.net City Costa Mesa State California Zip 92627 Telephone i949.631.3121 ARCHITECT/DESIGNER'S NAME Last First Lic, No. Architect/Designer's Address Architect/Designer's E-mail Address I city State Zip Telephone i i l ENGINEER'S NAME Last Bazley First Tim Lic. No. 5001 q Engineer's Address Engineer's E-mail Address i 2500 Via Cabrillo Marina Unit 200 Jacquelyn.chung@sbcglobal.net City Fan Pedro State California Zip 90731 Telephone 949.631.3121 CONTRACTOR'S NAME/COMPANY Swift Slip Dock and Pier Builders Lic. No. 797052 Class,�A � I � Contractors Address Contractor's E-mail Address 2027 Placentia Avenue Jac uel n.chun q y g@sbcglobal.net City Fosta Mesa state California Zip 92627 Telephone 949.631.3121 ENERGY PIC FEE $ FIRE P/C FEE $ PERMIT NO. j GRADING P/C FEE $ PLANNING P/C FEE $ PLAN CHECK NO. c;231 I�r —I ELEC/PLUM/MECH P/C FEE $ PLAN CHECK FEE $ DEVELOPMENT # TOTAL FEES PAID $ ClT OF NEWPORT SERCH CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH I WEST UPPERi— N PPORT Ex>,t ic•� V) VICINITY MRP Aoar PROFILE a1w M'. w•vam JETTY SOUNDINGS ARE EXPRESSED IN FEET AND DENOTE ELEVATIONS BASED ON MEAN LOWER LOW WATER. so _ _ -_ pontoons' b. SCpQEp �oRKextistingf\oaena Reoo\je 306 (e9 tgoC \ Is 52e Sh IRPPLICRNT'S NRME Kl ••Yj'K,WV\J� IJOB ADDRESS r1l� ,Gi , QjM A4i IDATE I2 -'IS, 2I 1011F City of Newport Beach - Building Departm Please print 3 copies WmR f Building F_.. Grading J—Drainage 1. Project Address (Not mailing address) JWI.M13 Tenant Narne(if Applicable) F! Elec F. Extg Gar sf F77 Demo Garage sf Add/Reconstruct Garage sf F—I New F_. 3. Owner's Name TOTAL BLDG SF TOTAL GARAGE SF # Units (if Residential) = Use Valuation $ Pwi # Stories 171 Cu Yd Cu Yd Fill Last First ........ ......... ....I... .. 11.1 .................. Owner's Address City F State F �W Owner's E-mail Address . .. ..... ....... . Zip Telephone F_. 4. Architect/Designer's Name Last F First Arch itect/Designer's Address City State Zip Telephone F Lic. No. 5. Engineer's Name Last First Lic. No. Engineer's Address ........... . City et State Engineer's E-mail Address .. . ..... .. ... .. .... ..... ...... .. . ... ........... ................. ........... Zip Telephone 1—,,'6. Contractor's Name Lastl. First ......... ... ....... ... ..... .... ...... Contractor's Address `07 7 / 0 - Pecs ....... ..... ..... ............ . City I State F ......................................................... 1 ............................ . ..... OFFICE USE ONLY ENERGY P/C FEE $ GRADING P/C FEE $ FIRE P/C FEE $ Lic. No. ffi;�'- Class 17W] Contractor's E-mail Address Zip TelephoneFPT� =M 9 We] PLAN CHECK NO. 2d) ID 0^., 1 He 1AM PI I=r.1hAr('.I41PI I IRA P/r PPI= S P1 AN (.HP:(.K FFP: R I , Zye) d :-i 1 oj �/ L o •rwaenwt JCA. ..-, rf n.b Pf^eo'-..._..._....._ n....P.. ........ ...._,_. � nc Tia .- _._....._.... ' �:,•t3 „Sire. U �.., , Newroar E°iAY CALIWCa Nl.q drp/hs ue/nw Mcn:o Ln,nrer Lpw Wn/c/;.,r;,r„+�. . rcrrt of >'i de apP rn Kr.no/a/y f . arrc/eslob//Shed /rr /lo:s src fron oF.ti4 �..•�- U. ----- --- ----._..__.._. rel (�i�il II i�� u � ,;�... _.I 1 - `�' U•S. rrl-'L:.rt'-t�. I .(ince i I, I 1 •� r t ..,, �. ,.,'; II' � ��r�^.F` ^move" »r✓ I � r �, � l..-.. _ %7' �.i� iC. •rFi`�CYfi r,`)C>r.;'.✓ n'l/�/.'<��i .S7 ,QcY�//,?0a .c'/Vc CITY Of NEWPORT REACH PE9M15SIOrd.r:7;'Sy _.t e.NalNTAIN .*[:... -• t: :: TFtUCT AND AT T11E e. t`. . .. .. ..ii ANN 15, Ile 1}1A y/.' G J IN ACC;C ua yit.E E 2 as "c :y...U, fl. tCiJn. CITY FIA^ Ita„OR CO(+�as' 1K-ATi OR (D - ¢/3 PERMIT NO. DATE .SPI M. t:hc dpi.n."a s: I'C'rpzc i.,-M�.-„c,nfi..9 P@5tifit %Q- cra!;�lo cci'u➢`!*y ESC;s: iit —7¢�/ aY CITY COUNCIL 1 JL s.1 `ti.lIT t DATE ..... .. SEE ATTACHED SHEET 4414— t ...._.i6 1- -14 el r ~` J A T�. b aata mnq `i � M � {.n 4 6 y'' � 7 f a✓ � � d Ae i'"9 ... nvixr .Jdt'PY' !j C.es.• `• �,x) Nxiasaea nr E"rnY C,nt iGefgwrfa �. y., j, .� �> lrrrr i SOvn,eY°nn5 aru expr�s,s tc! t» {crf w-pcd cs'Mp ,'hs. �iq/ow �N'r_rsr! Lad w'gr C. a+w Wn dxrr. +1�<rxr.+v.!/.n eo",7r& o/ t"&d r7pf�r^vxt racy qdy' '<%✓.r¢�•y( f✓nr8r>r 4;11 3 are ee�i✓ohle'yh�a y;, �h s;saYr.�ron of',Uew�,a�rf rry: A fIb C 148 exA: e t rJ e. tk 1/61 ^7 .I a I .) R.. ts�r�,hP•.1c 4414— t ...._.i6 1- -14 el r ~` J A T�. b aata mnq `i � M � {.n 4 6 y'' � 7 f a✓ � � d Ae i'"9 ... nvixr .Jdt'PY' !j C.es.• `• �,x) Nxiasaea nr E"rnY C,nt iGefgwrfa �. y., j, .� �> lrrrr i SOvn,eY°nn5 aru expr�s,s tc! t» {crf w-pcd cs'Mp ,'hs. �iq/ow �N'r_rsr! Lad w'gr C. a+w Wn dxrr. +1�<rxr.+v.!/.n eo",7r& o/ t"&d r7pf�r^vxt racy qdy' '<%✓.r¢�•y( f✓nr8r>r 4;11 3 are ee�i✓ohle'yh�a y;, �h s;saYr.�ron of',Uew�,a�rf rry: A fIb C 148 exA: e t rJ e. tk 1/61 ^7 .I a or CITY ®F NEWP®R'r BEAC1# HARBOR PERMIT PERMISSION IS HEREBY CRANTED TO CONSTRUCT ANA MAINTAIN THE FACILITY SIi U`NN ()IN THE REVERSE mEREOP. AT THE SITE INDICATIED, SUB.iu.; .— i"O Tli Pi2CVIS1Of45 07 AN.E HARBOR PER191T POLICIES CF' 4E`W;'O T REACH AN7: SP4 T TRANL CON9ITIGH£..OM. THIS PEE: R7c.. S IdOT TP2AN5 FSRABd.€•: §Y". +; 4TUY"i'Ff: k;'r;Yg: F,l CONSENT O- .HE CITY P7ARROt E;!?.'d' i3O:L:^JI} CnUNCiL. 'rit ',IGtITS GIVEN UNDEC? 1'I.7IS d''E Ta; i'1" .}e. la r•nh 1I)NCILS'VE ONL', •!dD 7H1a 7'EF.!l9 iZ ItStiY BE REVO74ED i3Y THE CITY COUNCIL IN AGCOPi6iY L�7CE � d"V's T7 lI S7 fF YHE MUNICIPAL CODE. Y '3 -7 SPECIAL CONDITION,.;: COrtss cif Enrineers Permit OrJ7age County P�rm►t Other St t*1 ?,L e S -1-7 -S PERMIT ISSUED SUBJECT TO DREDGE MATERIAL BEING HAULED TO SEA. r PLACED ON AGI, IA -121943 A121943 ^` P T Igo t..✓�9 %Z /'2 tl a i DREDGING APPLICATION i Project Location:,1� k_ �AlhnA nya Cubic Yards to be Dredged: 475 Method of Dredging: g 9: A,ycirAvl 1 c_ Svr.ti nn Nature of Dredged Material: Sand/4iu Disposition of Dredged Material: Pippli,nP tr,AnAnnrt to beach reclaimation Method of Material Disposition: pipeline transport Turbiditv Control Methods aad1 Ce a�harp�"p "P'1nnit'7'/tUrhi iy�n Effect of dredging on contiguous bulkheading and beaches Reinforce/protect bulkhead -restore sand to depleted beach I, Mark Sites hereby state that I have read the U. S. Arn1y (print name) Corps of. Engineers permit for maintenance dredging in Newport Harbor, the City of Newport Beach and orange County Harbors,Beaches and Parks District (if applicable) permit for maintenance dredging and that I accept all the provisions therein. Additionally I guarantee that the proposed dredging will not occur because of any altering of existing use of the affected zone. Brookes (Applicant -type name PA/" i (Date) Tntronnnqtnl T)r ging-_ name) — — Signed: Contractor s Representative U. S. Corps Post Office Los Angeles, Attention: Subject: Dear Sir: C of Engineers Box 2711 California 90053 Waterways Control Section Harbor Permit Application No. I hereby request a U. S. Corps of Engineers' Permit for the construction and installation of a wood seawall. and appurtenances thereto, to be locate-a—i New p'or*essay; bayward-of Lot No. 7 , Block No. N&23, Tract Eastside Addition , Newport Beach, Ca'ri£ornia. I am tzeowner of.ire afc�remention-e—%--property, and I have made application for a Harbor Kermit to the City of Newport Beach. The adjoining property owners are: Lot 6 Block N&23" Tract _Eastside Addition C.L. Peck Date _ 17�LZ3 Enc. Plans dated 11/16/73 3 Sepia 7 copies Lot e , Block N&23 Tract Eaatside.Addit on Robert McLain 1415 E. BA1boa Blvd. Newport Beach. C lifornia Respectfully submitted, .R.J. Brookes 0413_ E.Balboa BB1va— ___Newport Beach California CI'T'Y OF NEWPORT BEACH APPROVAL The Harbor and Tidelands Administrator of the City of Newport Beach has reviewed Harbor Permit application by _/C 3.fir /5 _ and subject to the approval of the U. S. Corps of Engineers, will i'issssue Harbor Permit No. Al -)y U. larrshbarger, Captain Date r-' 7- �� Marine Safety Department ec ; CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH HARBOR APPLICATION NO. i 'L/ /-? 60" Ne L✓ wall j X /a?" r�s 8 10ROF/,L E NO S",CE I I I I I ✓06 Siff c� 9v VICINITY SKETCH wisT JfTtr i N,,,o Rr BAY CALIFORNIAJef'r -f3�%L1^Yi�/L E S Souno'rn95 ore eX11,c55ed "n Pee/ and lona le o'ep/hs be/ow peon Cower Low Woi<r. Mor/mum rouge of i0 f<e>: Norbor /qe5 are es dob:"Shed Jn /hrs 5ecf.on Orlvcw"", Bor. �/.-5. P -P AID .Clue � I r � I ri woo I c%rr � r i P I I I i i y E. Ba//Joa Blvd. ('I�GCd7�B0/% I Ie. L7 L Broo.�c 3 I I I L—1 iq/ E. Ba/60cr &/vd. 41010,0E -9s 6o'si,F1W& N ,r ej 7 � ge t- 4 � O A 7Yau�wain �^os. B 0/4) G7.7-/740 //-/G-7.? ✓06 Siff c� 9v VICINITY SKETCH wisT JfTtr i N,,,o Rr BAY CALIFORNIAJef'r -f3�%L1^Yi�/L E S Souno'rn95 ore eX11,c55ed "n Pee/ and lona le o'ep/hs be/ow peon Cower Low Woi<r. Mor/mum rouge of i0 f<e>: Norbor /qe5 are es dob:"Shed Jn /hrs 5ecf.on Orlvcw"", Bor. �/.-5. P -P AID .Clue � I r � I ri woo I c%rr � r i P I I I i i y E. Ba//Joa Blvd. ('I�GCd7�B0/% I Ie. L7 L Broo.�c 3 I I I L—1 iq/ E. Ba/60cr &/vd. 41010,0E -9s 6o'si,F1W& N ,r ej 7 7-,e Cr Bcoc"r or 7Yau�wain �^os. 0/4) G7.7-/740 //-/G-7.? PRAWN BV 'OV'V zwnr CITY OF NEWPORT BPtLAC R H F '� R PM VT PERM155SO:+i !.*.. S4:':2 "L��i' i; ."..i:"CE+ 'ev "'^:'�'i'�U •-^.'T AND MAMTASH T:'i: TRF ANY ll;- .... `i AND 'Ur CiL IN ACCCEDAN"' Wiir;':a.... 6l G?t1S4:e i9Ft C(P0,!ZDINATOR (7 -/ ¢/? PERMIT NO. Card,- of crr, Gerinit / 2- 3l- 7 ¢ Qr^rg9 coun""y P ra�ast t tlmr: SC1Z2tc S —20-7 AUTy'„-;`�J uti C€iY COUP3CiL DATE DATE .... SEE ATTACHED SHEET Sl'AfE f7 CALIFORNIA RONALD RE.AGAN, Covnrn or CALIF'OIiIA6, COASTAL : ONES CONSE RVATIONI COMMISSION OUl'H COAST CtEGIONAt. COMMISSION 666 E. OCEAH BOULIVARb, SUITE 9107 O \ 1 I,. O.. Imx 1450 �t✓�` vlY�w. LONG LEACH, CALIFORNIA 90901 (219) 4364201 (114) R46-064$ R.ES0LT7T101 OF APPROVAL AND PElUY1,T.I' �v �o�����s a e 3. Applic<ztion Number:p�-G-2-742.961 ¢ r. . Name of Appl:i-c<Lnts _ R. J. Brooks- 6601 Telegraph Rd,, Los Angeles, CA 90040 Permit Type: �xf . Standard Emergency Development- Location: _1.413 Bay Front, Newport Beach` Development Description- VConstruct -a wooden seawall for beach preservation. The.wall is 3"xl2" tongue and groove and is to be buried 8' deep. Top of the.wall will be +$,0 on orjust below existing sand profile. (Sand profile is +$.0 mean low lower waterj_ Commission Resolution: 1. The South Coast Conservation Commission finds that the proposed development: A. Will not have a substantial. adverse environmental or ecolog- ical effect. B. Is cons:isi:ent vath the findings and declarations set forth in Public Resources Code Sections 2'/001 and 27302, C. Is subject to the follooring other resultant statutory pro- visions and policies: City of Newport Beach ordinances, D. Is consistent with the aforesaid other statutory provisions and policies,.in that: approval in concept has been issued. E. The :follotaing la-rlgua.ge anal/or drawings clarify and/or facil- itate carrying out the intent of the South Coast Regional. Zone Conservation Commission: application, site map, plot plan and approval in concept. 6 II. Whereas, at a public hearing held on May 6, 1974 (date)at Long Beach _ by a unanimous tW vote here- . location}�-' by approves the application for Permit Number P-4-2-74-2961 pursuant to the California Coastal Zone Conservation Act of 1972, subject to the following conditions imposed pursuant to the Public Resources Codes Section 27403: None Ill. Said terms and conditions shall be perpetual and bind all future owners and possessors of the property or any part ,thereof unless othervdse specified herein. IV. The grant of this permit is further made subject to the following:. A. That -this permit shall not become effective until the attached verification of permit has been returned to the South Coast Regional Conservation Commission upon which copy all permittees have acknowledged that .they have received a copy of the pezuit and understood its conten-cs. Said acknowledgment should be returned within ten working days following issuance of this permit. B. That said development is to be commenced on or before 360 days from effective date of approval. V. Therefore, said Permit (Standard, meg= ) No. P-4-2--74--2961 is hereby granted for the above described development only, sub- ject to the above conditions and subject to all terms and pro- visions of the Resolution of Approval by the South Coast Regional Conservation Commission. V.I. Executed at Long Beach, California on behalf of the South Coast Regional Conservation Commission on May 20_, 197 LH 2474 OA&tzed . M.J. Cpentdk Execute e Director wk DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY LOS ANGELES DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS P. O. BOX 2711 LOS ANGELES. CALIFORNIA 80083 Public Notice No, 74-76 29 May 1974 YOU ARE INVITED TO COMMENT ON THIS APPLICATION FOR A PERMIT APPLICANT: R. S. Brookes 1413 E. Balboa Boulevard Newport Beach, California ACTIVITY: Proposed construction and installation of a wood seawall (8 feet high by 30 feet long) 45 feet shoreward of the U.S. Bulkhead Line; to remove a portion (shoreward of proposed seawall) of the existing pier; to join bay -- ward portion of the existing pier with the seawall; and to conduct work on Lot No. 7, Block No. N and 23, Tract Eastside Addition, Newport Bay, City of Newport Beach, Orange County, California, as shown on the accompanying drawing. PURPOSE AND USE: Beach preservation. FEDERAL, STATE AND LOCAL AUTHORIZATIONS: Approved by the City of Newport Beach; California Regional Water Quality Control Board - Santa Ana Region has no objections; and Application No. P-4-2-74-2961 filed with the California Coastal Zone Commission - South Coast Region. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT: Based on information received, it is not anticipated that the activity will require the preparation of an Environmental Impact Statement by this office. PUBLIC HEARING: Any person who has an interest which may be adversely affected by the issuance of a permit may request a public hearing. The request must be submitted in writing to the District Engineer within thirty (30) days of the date of this notice and must clearly set forth the interest which may be affected and the manner in which the interest may be affected by the activity. Activities under Section 103 of the Marine Protection, Research and Sanctuaries Act (PL 92-532) and Section 404 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act (PL 92-500) will be considered in conjunction with this notification. CRITERIA: Your written comments or objections should include the number and date of this notice and must reach this office within thirty (30) calendar days. The decision whether to issue a permit will be based on an evaluation of the probable impact of the activity on the public interest. That decision will reflect the national concern for both protection and utilization of important resources. The benefit which reasonably may be expected to accrue from the activity must be balanced against its reasonably foreseeable detri- ments. All factors which may be relevant to the activity will be considered; among those are conservation, economics, aesthetics, general environmental Ci l %i 4F NEWPOR f B15=4 ollsAb0.3OR ApPLIc LTJQN NO New wa// i rfc 'y N e XII ,,p y 0 /5P O�0P 5od +8. E�. J II I 0 1 600 Exis/. San NO SC.eL,E R 7- Ez V(C)"ll-Y SKETCH N. nar 5AY C dmp rl+s be/ow M�ar1 Ln.✓rr Cnw ti%b .'rr. �aA/M y/Y) rang rsF fide Opp raq/nan i.ly /O /A,ri Hp�r bar /iM5 or, ea.?061,5h�d rn /hJg sic/,o,a{'Neiv i•n•/ Bby e oas T v®Ti®N IT --7----- I �( ri /✓Cir/ I i %✓6'// I I I I I I I Qj IIS.�f..,.�� �nc✓ � I ti I lilrBaYAvcRnuc, U 7 � I I ✓9_ aac /E' LTr 6.1-vokes _ 1 Edr%ride N i e -r rE': 6a/boa .B/vd. r��cr C7/�� L7l-/YGo 7 - 407. //-/6-73 — ...: �C.! Lii URi�Lj, COASTAL M di CONS L• WATION COIN kISSIOf l SOUTH COAST REGIONAL CO AL iISSION 65G B. OCF.AFI I'.OViEVAi:D, SUITE 9107 � � P.O. 60X. 1.150 LONG GCACH, CALIFORNIA 90;01 RESOL15'..1"[0N, OF APPROVAL ATND PEICo7T,T Applicatio.i Nts aibe.r: �P--t�-2-714.-296:L Name of. Applicant: R. J. Brooks 6601 Telegraph Rd., Los �Angeles, -CA 900.0 Permit Ty' -pe: (,xJ Standard J Emergency Deve.lop,ent Location: 1413 Bay Front, Newport Beach Development Description: Construct a wooden seawall for beach ppreservation.- The.wall is 3"xl2" tongue -and groove and is to be buried b' deep. Top of the,wall will be +$.0 on or just below existing sand profile. (Sand profile is +$.0 mean low lower Commission Resolution: 1. The South Coast Conservation Commission finds that the proposed development: • .. A. Will not have a substantial_ adverse environmental or ecolog- ical effect. B. Is consistent with the :findings and declarations set forth in Public Resources Code Sections 27001 and 27302. C. Is subject to the following other resultmat statutory pro -- visions and polic_i-es: City of Newport Beach ordinances. D. Is consistent with the aforesaid other statutory provisions and policies,in that:. approval in concept has been =issued. - E. The following language and/or drawings clarify and/or facil- itate carrying out the intent of the South Coast Regional Zone Conservation Comiss:ion: application, site man, plot plan and approval in concept. II. Whereas, at a public hearing held on May 6, 1974 date at .Long Beach by aunan:imous t� vote here - (location) by ere- (location)by approves the application for Permit Number P -11-2 -72H -296j_ pursuant to the California Coastal Zone Conservation. Act of 1972, subject to the following conditions imposed pursuant to the Public Resources Codes Section 27403: None III. Said terms and conditions shall be perpetual and bind all future owners and possessors of the property or any part thereof unless otherwise specified herein. IV. The grant of this permit is further made subject to the following: A. That this permit shall not become effective until the attached verification of permit has been returned to the South Coast Regional Conservation Comnission upon which copy all permittees have acknowledged that .they have received a copy of the permit and understood its contents. Said acknowledgment should be returned within ten working days following issuance of this permit. B. That said development is to be commenced on or before 360 days from effective date of approval. V. Therefore, said Permit (Standard, T:cseugz ) No. P-4.-2- 74-2961 is hereby granted for the above described development only, sub- ject to the above conditions and subject to all terms and pro- visions of the Resolution of Approval by the, South Coast Regional Conservation Commission. VI. Executed at Long Beach, California on behalf of the South Coast Regional Conservation Commission on May 20 , 197 4- 211.74 Knot r✓ _ 9 M.J. Cpentdr Executx e Director wk MARINE SAFETY DEPARTMENT 70 Newport Pier February 25, 1974 .' ITEM NO.: F-1 TO:. MAYOR & CITY COUNCIL FROM: Marine Safety Department SUBJECT: JOINT HARBOR COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION; REF. HARBOR PERMIT REVISION APPLICATIONS FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF.A WOODEN SEAWALL 30' BAYWARD OF VACATED EAST BAY AVENUE BETWEEN F & G STREETS ON THF 'RATAOA PF.TTTNRTTT.' Action If desired, (1) deny the revision permits as applied for or (2) approve the permits subject to the Joint Harbor Committee's recommendation that the proposed .bulkhead be built on the bayward most line of Vacated East Bay Avenue with approval for wooden return walls at the F & G Street -ends. Discussion The City Council at their regular meeting on January 28 referred the subject permit revisions to the Joint Harbor Committee for their recommendation. The Joint Harbor Committee met on February 13, 1974, and discussed the attached staff report which was originally prepared for the Council's January 28 meeting. The staff prior to submitting the report to the Joint Harbor Committee "drew" in a second sand berm line representing berm positioning with respect to the proposed bulkhead. This :second berm line measurement was taken in accord- ance with Council's.instructions and represents positioning based on a Public Works survey made on January 29, 1974. The Joint Harbor Committee after reviewing the staff report, quest- ioning of staff and testimony by the applicants recommended that Council not approve the applications as applied for, however, they did recommend that the proposed wooden bulkhead, if built, be con- structed no further bayward than the bayward most line of Vacated East Bay. Avenue,.with approval for wooden return walls at the F & G Street -ends. Page Two Summarily, the Marine Safety Department has no set recommendatii in this matter since it relates strictly to policy. The staff will assist the applicants in processing the permits through the South Coast Regional Zone' Conservation Commission and U. S. Army Corps of Engineers in accordance with Council's policy decision on the loca- tion of the proposed bul head. C R. E. Reed, Director Marine Safety Department RER:DH;lf Attachments MARINE SAFETY DEPARTMENT 70 Newport Pier TO: CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS OF TIIE JOINT HARBOR COMMITTEE FROM: MARINE.SAFETY DEPARTMENT SUBJECT: HARBOR.PERMIT APPLICATIONS FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF A WOODEN SEAWALL 30' DAYWARD OF VACATED EAST BAY AVENUE.BETWEEN F & G STREETS ON THE BALBOA PENINSULA. DISCUSSION: The Newport Beach City Council at their meeting on January 23, reviewed the attached Harbor Permit Application and staff report. The Council referred the Harbor Permit Applications to the Joint Harbor Committee for their review and recommendation. The staff, at the direction of Council,have drawn in a second sand 'berm line' based on the results of a Public Works survey taken on January 29, 1974. The first 'berm line' was measured on December 12, 1973, by the Marine Safety Department staff. The difference between the two 'berm lines' represents beach prograding by homeowners contracting with a small equipment operator who, on an annual or bi-annual.basis, pushes sand, at low tide, _up in front of the homes to maintain beach frontage. R. E, REED, DIRECTOR MARINE SAFETY DEPARTMENT D. Harshbarger, Captain Marine Safety Department RER:DH: dw T 497- MARINE SAFETY DEPARTMENT 70 Newport Pier January 28, 1974 T0: MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL FROM: Marine Safety Department SUBJECT: Harbor Permit Applications for the construction of a wooden seawall 30' bayward of Vacated East Bay Avenue between F & G Streets on The Ba oa Peninsu a. APPLICANTS: Property owners; Eastside Addition Tract; Block N & 23. Listed as follows: Mr. R. English, 1401 E. Balboa Blvd., Lot 1; Mr. G. Stephens, 1405 E. Bal. Blvd., -Lots 3 & 1/2 (4).; Mr. D. McHone, 1409 E. Bal. Blvd. -Lots 1/2 (4),& 5; Mr. C.. Peck, 1411 E. Bal. Blvd. -Lot 6; Mr. R. Brookes, 1413 E Bal. Blvd. -Lot 7; Mr. R. McLain, 1415 E. Bal. Blvd Lot 8; Mr. F. Rhodes, 1417 E. Bal. Blvd. -Lots 9 & 10. Project Description Seven of the eight property owners bordering the Bay between F & G Streets on the East Balboa Peninsula have applied to the City for harbor permits to allow for the construction of a wooden seawall 30' bayward of "Vacated East Bay Avenue". The wooden seawall is proposed to be built at an elevation of +8 MLL'W with 30' length wooden return walls at the F & G Street -ends. Discussion The subject harbor permit application requires City Council approval because the proposed seawall would be constructed 301 bayward of "Vacated East Bay Avenue". The Harbor Permit Policies (Section 16 Bulkheads) was amended by Council in June of 1973. The following paragraph, applicable to these pending permits states: "The Marine Safety Department may issue permits for bulkheads, between U. S. Bulkhead Station Numbers 112-109 not to exceed the bayward side of the 'Vacated East Bay Avenue'. Concrete bulkheads and wooden retaining wall structures proposed to be constructed bayward of the bayward most line of Vacated East Bay Avenue shall be subject to City Council approval." .The applications for Lots 1 and 10 bordering F & G Street, street - ends show 30' wooden return walls. Because these return walls are Page 2. proposed to be constructed of wood rather than concrete they would also require Council approval to deviate from City Harbor Permit Policies. Section 16 - Bulkheads, paragraph H, of the Harbor Permit Policies address the above and states: "All .private bulkheads constructed along street right: -of -way lines shall conform to the City Standard Drawings for a concrete bulkhead". The U. S. Bulkhead Line is 115' bayward of the zoning setback line for the block between F & G Street. The property between the front of the homes and the U.S. Bulkhead Line is owned in fee by the respective homeowners, but ariy construction within this zone where the tide may ebb and flow requires a harbor permit. Within the majority of the "Harbor, bulkheads.,have been built.on the U. S. Bulkhead Line; however, for this area (Between A and It Streets) it has been the City's basic position that bulkheads or retaining wall structures should be held back from the U. S. Bulkhead Line to the bayward side of "Vacated Last Bay Avenue" for the following reasons: 1. To preclude the possibility of sand -fill below the line of ordinary high.tide. 2. To maintain as much as is possible conformity with respect to Section 16, paragraph A of the City's Harbor Permit Policies establishing a quasi bulkhead line. 3. To retain sand sloping beaches, which are energy absorbing versus bulkhead structures which can reflect wave energy. 4. The possible retention of an undefined public easement over a por- tion of private property over which the tide ebbs and flows. NOTE: It is the staff's understanding (reference the First American Title Insurance Company, that rights and easements for Commerce, Navigation and Fishery is in favor of the public, or the federal, state or municipal government over any portion of the subject property which is submerged. Also, at such time that said submerged lands are filled, in conformance with all applicable permits, to an elevation above the line of ordinary high tide, that the above public easement exception will be thereby eliminated. The attached proposal drawings should warrant_ special Council attent- ion because these are the first harbor permit applications that repre- sent several homeowners requesting a variance to Council. policy. The magnitude of the project could possibly set a precedent for other bayfront property owners within the A to K street zone. The attached summary drawing depicting the F to G street block shows an existing Sand Berm Line plotted by the Marine Safety Department Page 3. staff. This line.on an average is approximately 15' landward of the proposed seawall construction. Currently the sand.elevation at the berm line is approximately an +8.5 MLLW. The sand level at the proposed bulkhead line is approximately a +4.0 MLLW. The zone between the proposed wall and the current sand berm line will require fill. During recent field inspections of the lower harbor with staff members from the Bureau of:Sport Fisheries and Wildlife and the South Coast Regional 'Lone Conservation Commission, bulkhead construction along sand beaches was discussed. In general, these agencies which review and comment on harbor permit applications for. the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers, have held to the position that they are opposed to the continuation of the bulkhead and associated fill process in the lower Newport Bay. It is.their analysis that this can retard water circula- tion resulting in the degradation of water quality. Summarily, the applicants are proposing to construct a quasi wooden bulkhead structure 30' bayward of "Vacated East Bay Avenue" with wooden return walls.at the F & G Street -ends. The wooden wall bulkhead, based on staff inspection., will require limited landside fill. In conclusion, the Marine Safety Department staff has not made a recom- mendation on this application because of the policy nature of the request. The staff°could alter its position on this proposed project if the bulkhead structure was brought back 30' to the bayward most line of Vacated East Bay Avenue. The following alternatives are listed for Council's consideration: 1. Construction of the proposed wooden bulkhead on the Bayward most line of "Vacated East Bay Avenue" (30' landward of the proposed location) with concrete return walls. 2. Construction of the proposed wooden bulkhead on the Bayward most line of "Vacated East Bay Avenue" with approval for wooden return walls. R. E. REED, DIRECTOR D. Harshbarger; Captain Marine Safety Department DH: GEW:lf Attachments CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH HARBOR APPLICATION IVC rI/C'v41 (fJrl Ll.. J, N Oo rs � Q Cr y� r VICI MITY SKETCH wlrr/srr cgfr Nf WPomr 8AY CAC IFDif NIA 4y--—}�.t Jfrrf ATT�d2'JTT/SOLE• k°• SnQ,ffl vxp Fee/ and NQ SCALB del -/As. below ^/con Zowev dinoVe Low Wo /tr, Mpre..faim range aF /id oppr•ox/mo'/s/fir /D - Hor'bor ore eai06/f,54 ire "h:s see/rea orAldwaorl Bob. Sd' g0' I I 1 I { Avg, i + SE awl 1 � Zjf) t 1<1304 . 3z UQ I., !moi Ik��k'I/EED r tr J, IA�a o i I. _, -i 6 7 fi 9 10 I AAACLr��nv NAW L-3 /,�e e O 91 z04VA aaeac a A: or, . 1Z%eAWM,VY,rA,d1 AJ,Sf lwnr %o6�t J.13 L� 6601 Teleg>ap6 Road L.. A gJ", C.Iif..ia 90022 February 7, 1975 Mr. R. E. Reed, Director Marine Dept., City of Newport Beach 3300 W. Newport Blvd. Newport Beach, California Dear Mr. Reed: This will acknowledge your letter of January 14, 1975. Unfor- tunately, I was out of town when your letter arrived, and have just now had a chance to review the letter. Your opening paragraph indicates that the Army Corps of Engineers has recorded an offense against me. Since the statements contained W your letter are incorrect, Iwould appreciate it if you would immediately notify the Army Corps of Engineers accordingly so that this recorded offense can be erased. We have not placed sand bayward of the recently installed retaining walls, nor do we have any intention of placing sand bayward of this retaining wall. As you know, we spent many months obtaining approval of all in- terested departments to build this seawall. We have, in all respects, lived up to the approval that was given to us. Hence, I would most appreciate your assistance in correcting the matter with the Army Corps of Engineers. Thanking you in advance for your assistance. RJB/km /07- 1113 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH CALIFORNIA MARINE DEPARTMENT City Hall 3300 W, Newport Blvd. Area Code 714 673-2110 January 14, 1975 " gnglish, Pittroef, Stephens, MCHone, Brookes, Peck:, MCLain,.Rhodes Dear Sir: The Los Angeles District of the Arany Corps of Engineers has notified us that you have been placing sand ba.yward of your recently installed retaining walls between F and G Streets on the Balboa Peninsula. Further, they have requested that we contact you on this first recorded offense. The placement of any fill material in the bay is an illegal act, punishable by federal action, unless prior approval is granted by the Army. The material must be analyzed for con- taminant content before being placed anywhere within the harbor. The analysis of samples is an expense to be born by the tidelands user, and the samples must meet certain stand- ards. The standards are reviewed.by the Environmental Pro- tection Agency, the California Fish and Game, the Regional Water Quality Control Board, and the Department of Interior, River Basin Studies. Since this activity is now under very close surveillance by the Corps of Engineers, and other agencies, we strongly suggest that you contact this department before any further fill mater- ial is contemplated to be placed along the shoreline. The permit procedure must now be strictly adhered to, or, as the Army related to us, they will file with the Attorney General for prosecution. This letter is written in order to inform you of the situation in the event you were previously not aware of it. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact the U. S. Army Corps of. Page Two Engineers, Los Angeles District, Harbors, and Waterways Division, Attention: Mr. John McVey, Area Manager - South Coast Areas, P. O. Box 2711, Los Angeles; California 90053 (Tele. (213)688-5607). We refer you to his office, since the material has already been placed, taking the situation from local control. Again, if any further fill material placement is contemplated, please do not fail to file for the necessary permits with the City of Newport Beach Marine Department. This way, we can all assist in retaining the necessary controls at the local level. Very truly yours, MARINE DEPARTMENT CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH f � R. E. Reed, Director RER:lf ..519.1E V CAINORNIA CALIFORNIA COASTAL ZOI' vONSERVATION COMMISSIO, SOUTH COAST REGIONAL COMYJSSION 655 E. OCEAN 6OULEVA90, SUITE 0107 P.O. Box 1450 NI 9 B0 lOND BEACH, CALIEOR A 0 I (^.10) 106.4701 (714) 6445-045.6 April 15r 1974 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING RONA0 REAGAN, 0,,,n., Pursuant to order of the California Coastal Zone. Conservation Commission, notice of public hearing is hereby given. Said public ..hearing is .scheduled on the Mav 6, 1.971; Agenda for application for Permit, i\u_mber *** as submitted by R. Brooks. The subject request is to permit for beach preservation P-4-2-74-2961 Construction of a wooden seawall at 1413 Bay Front, Newport Beach Said agenda public hearings will commence at 9700 an, on May 6, 1974 at Long Beach Harbor Department 925 Harbor Plaza, Long Beach, 6th Floor, Board Room during crhich time all persons either favoring or opposing the application will be heard. Any written correspondence regarding the application should be directed to this office prior to the hear- ing date. All interested individuals who wish additional information may con- tact this office.."' M. J. C�-pent4.- - Executitie Director wk *** FOR APPLICANT ONLY... COPY OF THIS NOTICE IS TO BE POSTED ON SUBJECT PROPERTY STATUS SHEET HARBOR PERMITS LOCATION ��/3 �jg�C7Gb ��Ud New /i Ly Revision Dredging u Dace Rec'v 1,C-3 -,7-3 Fee Amt. 40 Fee Processed Date Reviewed by M.S.D. / Z- j-7 Approved Denied Correction Req'd. - Desc. City Council: Ajcrtved Denied Remarks Z-7 �- 7V REMARKS /SS bi�6 -0--14-7 5- J.H.C. Or.Co. T.I.C. 2-1 i -W DATE MATERIAL SENT/APPROVED C.O.E. SCRZCC SARWQCD 1. Application Z -27-7Q 2 - 2 ?,'74/ 2. Consent Letter 3. "Waste" Letter 4. Drawings 5. Staff Report 6. 7. 8. REMARKS /SS bi�6 -0--14-7 5- J.H.C. Or.Co. T.I.C. 2-1 i -W 2410 Newport Boulevard T R A U T WV E I N BROTHERS : OATS AND BULKHEADS Newport Beach, Calif. 92660 PIERS, PILE DRIVING, ETC. GENERAL .ENGINEERING CONTRACTORS Contractors License No. 268976A Phone (714) 673-1960 Glen: . I do not have the Corps permit for Brookes, Mr. Brookes has it. Sam DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY LOS ANGELES DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS P. O. BOX 2711 LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 80058 Public Notice No. 74-75 29 May 1974 YOU ARE INVITED TO COMMENT ON THIS APPLICATION FOR A PERMIT APPLICANT: C. L. Peck 1411 E. Balboa Boulevard Newport Beach, California ACTIVITY: Proposed construction and installation of a wood seawall (8 feet high by 30 feet long) 45 feet shoreward of the U.S. Bulkhead Line; to remove _ a portion (shoreward of proposed seawall) of the existing pier; to join bayward portion of the existing pier with the seawall; and to conduct work on Lot No. 6, Block No,N and 23, Tract Eastside Addition, Newport Bay, City of Newport Beach, Orange County, California, as shown on the drawing accompany- ing this notice. PURPOSE AND USE: Beach preservation. FEDERAL, STATE AND LOCAL AUTHORIZATIONS: Approved by the City of Newport Beach; California Regional Water Quality Control Board - Santa Ana Region has no objections; and Application No. P-3053 filed with the California Coastal Zone Commission - South Coast Region, ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT: Based on information received, it is not anticipated that the activity will require the preparation of an Environmental Impact Statement by this office. PUBLIC HEARING: Any person who has an interest which may be adversely affected by the issuance of a permit may request a public hearing. The request must be submitted in writing to the District Engineer within thirty (30) days of the date. of this notice and must clearly set forth the interest which may be affected and the manner,in which the interest may be affected by the activity. Activities under Section 103 of the Marine Protection, Research and Sanctuaries Act (PL 92-532) and Section 404 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act (PL 92-500) will be considered in conjunction with this notification. CRITERIA: Your written comments or objections should include the number and date of this notice and must reach this office within thirty (30) calendar days. The decision whether to issue a permit will be based on an evaluation of the probable impact of the activity on the public interest. That decision will reflect the national concern for both protection and utilization of important resources. The benefit which reasonably may be expected to accrue from the activity must be balanced against its reasonably foreseeable detri- ments. All factors which may be relevant to the activity will be considered; Public.Notice No. 74-75 APPLICANT: C. L. Peck 29 May 19.74 among:those are conservation, economics,.aestheti.cs, general environmental. concerns, historic values, fish and wildlife values, flood damage preven- tion, land use classific.ation,.navigation, recreation, water supply, water quality, and, in general, the needs.and welfare of the people. Details -of changed conditions on the final permit.action will be provided upon request, FOR THE.DISTRICT ENGINEER: n; JAMES MET/ALIOS . LTC, CE Deputy District Engineer 2 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH HARBOR APPWCATION NO.� L New wo 3'x 4? " Tit G 8 0 uldjl � }8oE�5 I �r\•?� I Iva Exlsf. Son d I I �f2OF/,L E� Nd SCAG� n•i.4 c��y.. •,Le fee a 9..r p./ r r.f5• � ro _ VICINITY SKETCH Nti N((rJfrPr ; N -if -Or 6Ay CAL iF,Qlll f ^ Nor :i n[/n d/nq5 ore r.dpre s's ed /n !eef and o'rn.p (n. dvp/hs be/ow Meon Lover Low Wafer. .'L0,^f L....•m range of Yi de Opp rLlk/•no fe/�' /O /ee f. //arbor fines are ealob/;shed /n thJs section armew,nnr.. Bar. 77-7T7-11 �I 111 1, II I ! IJ" - tll-- J, I N LVc�cy G4/ fi� I A60 j � I� i AveViucl I I T- I I I (/ S. PFk ND Line I v s 'g c I[r'd 1 11 L;nc 30/ I I I ovc analI i I i I (t�tlrcalc ' I I I APDL/Cq/ II ✓ Aoo C..4. PC -c,4 ,t7 .Ba/,(a o, &/v o� E" ea/600 &/vc/ I" i' 1 (*7/9) 67J -/96a CALIFORHIIA COASTAL ZON ONSERVATION COWAISSIO SOUTH COAST F,EGIC)"AL COIF WSSION { 666 E. OCFAN DOULEVARD, SUITE 9107 P.O. EOX 1450 1 LONG BEACH, CALIFORNIA 90301 May , 1 1974 {213) 406J201 (714) 846-0648 y 3 s ' NOTICE OF PU?LIC HEARING Pursuant to order of the California Coastal Zone Conservation Commission, notice of public hearing is hereby given. Said public hearing is scheduled on the June 3, 1974 Agenda for application for Permit, dumber P-4-11-74-3053 *** as.submitted by C.L. Peck The subject request is to permit Replace existing seawall with new wood seawall at 1411 E. Bay Front, Newport Beach Said agenda public hearings will commence at 9:00 am on Jure 3, 1974 at Long Beach Harbor Administration Building 925 Harbor Plaza., Long Beach - 6th Floor, Board Room during which time all persons either favoring or opposing the application will be h:'ard. Any written correspondence regarding the application should be directed to this office prior to the hear- ing date. All interested individuals who wish additional information may con tact this office.' M. J. Cc1),penttix Executive Director w.c ** FOR APPLICANT ONLY... COPY OF THIS NOTICE IS TO BE POSTED ON SUBJECT PROPERTY STATUS SHEET HARBOR PERMITS LOCATION /�'411 &, Date Rec'v /- Fee Amt. Date Reviewed by M.S,D. Approved _- --7 Denied Correction Req'd. - Desc. City Council: Remarks 1. Application 2. Consent Letter 3. "Waste" Letter 4. Drawings 5. Staff Report 6. 8. REMARKS Appio ed 2-'z%,7�- DATE MATERIAL SENT/APPROVED 2-V ?¢/ ?_/p.74- C.O.E. SCRZCC II �� 'P New Revision Dredging Fee Processed Denied SARWQCD' J.H.C. Or.Co. 2-V ?¢/ ?_/p.74- T.I.C. A 1 SPLCO-N _ - DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY-. LOS ANGELES DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS P. O. SOX 2711 LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA ®OOHS C. L. Peck 1411 'E. Balboa Boulevard Newport Beach, California 92661 Dear Mr. Peck: 15 August 1974 Your permit, dated 15 August 1974 (74-75), has been validated and is inclosed. Notice of Authorization and copies of forms for reporting the status of work are also inclosed. Sincerely yours, C zc 3 Incl r JOHN V. FOLEY 1. Permit COL, CE 2. Notice of Authorization District Engineer 3. Work Status (dupe) Appl'_.cation No, 74-75 U. S. Army Engineer District, Los Angeles Name -of Applicant (,,_ T._ pR,k Corps of Engineers Effective Date 1t Alagu,. 1974 Los Angeles, California Expiration Date 31 Peeemtier 1977 DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY PERMIT Referring to written request dated 26 November 1973 for a FX) erfform work in or affecting navigable waters of the United States, upon the recommendation of the Chief of Engineers, pursuant to Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act of March 3, 1899 (33 U S C 401)•- ge reaged or fill material into navigable waters upon the issuance of a permit from the Secretary of the Army acting through the Chief of Engineers pursuant to Section 404 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act (86 Stat. 816, P. L. 92-500); Transport re ged material for the purpose of dumping it into ocean waters upon the issuance of a permit from the Secretary of the Army acting through the Chief of Engineers pursuant to Section 103 of the Marine Protection, Research and Sanctuaries Act of 19,712 (86 Stat. 1052; P. L. 92-532); C. L. Peck 1411 E. Balboa Boulevard Newport Beach, California 92661 is hereby authorized by the Secretary of the Army: to construct and install a. wood seawall (8 feet high by 30 feet long) 45 feet shoreward of the U. S, Bulkhead Line; to remove a portion (shoreward of proposed seawall) of the existing pier; to join bayward portion of the existing pier with the seawall Newport Bay (Pacific Ocean) Ir Lot No. 6, Block N and 23, Tract Eastside Addition, Newport Bay, City of Newport Beach, Orange County, California rn accordance with the plans and drawings attached hereto which are incorporated in and made a part of this permit on drawings: "C. L. Peck, 1411 E. Balboa Blvd., Tract Eastside Addition, Block N and 23, Lot No. 6, Drawn by Trautwein Bros. Dated 16 Novem e" -SmtTecr To—t e o owing conditions: _FORM OL I MAY 74 581 (ER 114..5-2-303) Page 1 of 5 `� ) PREVIOUS EDITIONS ARE OBSOLETE_ signature. Permittee hereby accepts and agrees to comply with the terms and conditions of this permit. Permittee Date/ Bhor'.ty�o he Secretary of the Army: at� /� , I L= JOHN U. FOLEY, COL, CE District Engineer I S A,a,,n+ 1974 Date Transferee hereby agrees.to comply with the terms and conditions of this permit. Tr,ansferee Date Page 5 of 5 'W Ck�I'i91tfi 4, DEPARTMENT OF THE AVWY I CORPS OF ENGONEZ:-RS NOTICE of Allmonlavlon v I A PERMIT TO constru<!t 15 August 19 71,1 he Joj f3l" bY 30 fee c 45 feet shoreward t, rocs (smorevard of prop,)sed seawall " blxle to rernove a 017 .. -Q of the I OoXistjjj,� 1.— 1:0 join "OLlyl, r . pier t,7.jj:h Lhe .,. IL �evoport �.J,,jy Ci AT LOL 6, Plock N and 23, T1'7act Easo� :ca 10 sirl (Pacii7i J"leacl Orar� sirlo Addjt.j.c)jj, :kow' ort 11 z. I go-' COUWYCalifora:�,,, p nay, CiL.; HAS BEEN ISSUE -F) To C. L. Pecqt ON3.5 19 74 ADDRESS OF PERMITTEE Baj.hoa re, PERMIT �,Tewpor- Brad:, Cali.For- NUMBER --- - - -------- , ERG porn? 4136 Jul 70 THIS NOTICE IMUST E. CONSPICUOUSLY CISPLAYED 17 'I'llf 'grE of vfflpollt *G�'O; 1971 3 CAL. FORNIA COASTAL ZONE CONSERVATION COMMiaSIQN SOUTH COAST REGIONAL COMMISSION 666 E. OCEAN BOULEVARD, SUITE 3107 . P.O. BOX 1450 LONG BEACH, CALIFORNIA 90801 (713) 4364201 (714) 8464648 PERMIT NO. VERIFICATION OF PERMIT The regulations of the California Coastal Zone Con— servation Commission, Section 33510, specifies that no permit shall become effective until a copy thereof has been returned to the Regional Commission, upon which all permittees have acknowledged that they have received a' copy of the permit and understand its contents. You are therefore requested to verify the following statement after completely reviewing your permit and return the signed verification to the Coastal Commission within ten (10) working days following the permit issuance. The undersigned permittee acknowledges receipt of the California Coastal Commission's approval of Permit Number I "8 L Z=> and thoroughly understands the contents of the permit, including any conditions imposed. Date 2474 Permittee°s Signature A-) STATE OF CALIFORNIA RONALD REAGAN, Governor CALIFORNIA COASTAL ZONE CONSERVATION COWAISSIOM SOUTH COAST REGIONAL- COMMISSION 666 E. OCEAN BOULEVARD, SUITE 3107 9 `' 'o P.O. BOX 1450 LONG BEACH, CALIFORNIA 90801 (213) 4364201 (714) 846-0648 �, �6� t'�� RESOLUTION OF APPROVAL AND PERMIT 1 �' Application Number: P-4-11-7Lv-30 Name of. Applicant:. C.L. Peck Avg: 1411 E. Bayfnent,, Ne Permit Type: Standard [� Emergency / Development Location: _1¢11 E. BarFront,.NE )ort Beach 926 " Development Description: Replace existing seawall°with new wood seawall Commission Resolution: I. The South Coast Conservation Commission finds that the proposed development: A. Will not have a substantial adverse environmental or ecolog— ical effect. B. Is consistent with the findings and declarations set forth . in Public Resources Code Sections 27001 and 27302. C. Is subject. to the following other resultant statutory pro— visions and policies: City of Newport Beach ordinances. D. .Is consistent with the aforesaid other statutory provisions and policies in that: approval in concept has been issued. E. The following language and/or drawings clarify and/or facil— itate carrying out the intent of the South.Coast Regional. Zone Conservation Commission: application, site map;' plot plan and approval in concept. esolution of Approve' and Permit A .Page 2 II. Whereas, at a public hearing held on June 3 1974 date . at Long Beach by aunanimous X?b vote here - location) by approves the. application for Permit Number P-4-11-74-3053 pursuant to the California.Coastal Zone Conservation'Act of 1972, subject to the following conditions imposed pursuant to the Public Resources Codes Section 27403 III. IV. V. None Said terms and conditions shall be perpetual and bind all future owners and possessors of the property or any part thereof unless otherwise specified herein. The grant of -this permit is further made subject to the following: A. That this permit.shall not become effective until the attached verification of permit has been returned to the South Coast - Regional Conservation Commission upon which copy all permittees have acknowledged that they have received a copy of the permit and understood its contents. Said acknowledgment should be returned within ten working days following issuance of this permit. B. That said development is to be commenced on or. before 360 days from effective date of approval. Therefore, said Permit (Standard,epg� -) No. P-4.- 11-74--305 is hereby granted for the above described development only, sub- ject to the above conditions and subject to all terms and pro- visions rovisions of the Resolution of Approval by the South Coast Regional Conservation Commission. VI. Executed at Long Beach, California on behalf of the South Coast Regional Conservation Commission on June 18 197 4 M.J. Carp ter 2474 Executive Director Wk r' G� ..:. :",f� u, .F. Px ' :»I1 ..>i.ry b La 1.F -:. , 140- 'y 0f 'As � b �` �! 6"' d S� v� a� � u"""� N I ' ..: va v�o C'� a �aw�t n w x,�h,d �'�$ F` , x'Y12Tf cl Ci . tl.AG 407 `� /y ✓f yR Y. '1 cy ^. we.rr' JFI'rr' I VecrNlrY �ar<cre.w � .�.. Nli Polr DAY CAf.IPORNI/.l I _r SO4n rimy^ ore axf�ra sgGyrJ rn {r. c/ c.n �r'.v.ofr: I /I/© ��.�L� dep fhs Ge/ofv Mt-nr� Lv rver La.✓ Wi�fev. •7.7cri.n✓.r. I vUnya of Ir'dG o/op+rt�ki rnv d.r/Y� /O /cef /,: �• Ln. �, n•, •• pre es lob/r'5had h'> /h;5 secf.on vFn/,t ,vFu.f G•a/: ; I i I II' ll 1 J1 rfhrr"So` I II"_i L I il. II I I U.S. !A '4 -fC:IJ 4//]C I I I �I I I I I I 30 I I ea;;: { I t I ::f, i • +•'{ A'CPr .J✓� Crnl? I { I i RA ...' ai 1:... .. { 47ayI E Ii 4vEY7Iuc+ { dal i (�✓krcfca°f �tlQ✓% I I �`' l I I I j I I / ^'r�/ / _ �A— .CA'"G)'/.ii' c'.! iY ,!`l"%4� C.✓. I .4,' ea/boa 6/vd l , 7e^ra�d•frcrt/t.Fa'~ F:1'r^o A'..T—.--_._.__. .. CITY OF NEWPOR',,^,. HARBOR PER- rvH'b PERMISSION IS HEREBY GRANTl:1 TO COK!' TiiUCT AN:: MAINTAIN THE FACILITY SHOVJN ON YHt: f;GV :.0 c'. NERCOi AT THE SITE iUDSCAi Mi, Sly'J c:;c TO TAIL S,tGV.SIONS O THE HARBOR PERMIT vi. 4,11 5 OF N3iVP LINT LEACH AP,. ANY SPECIAL CC'':G:isC:: LI.', -TPD NU.S< VN, THIS PERM' IS NOT YRANSr LRACLE IViTNOi7T ":Ni. 4'I iii T7Eii Cu;1S7ENT L- THE CIYY HARBOR OR STY COUNC L. T. RIGHTS GIVEN U)IOER OHL AND Yti1S P LE W!1 MAY S r`.Eb.i Prt s E.1' Tlis. CITY COUNC:-. IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 OF THE MUKICIf'AL "DE. CITY HARCiOR CIDOfG:.:t.(Olt PERMIT NO. AUT:i U."jX" 6Y CITY �COUNCIL fix -Z L it - -7`f 9 SPECIAL CONDITIONS: Corps of Engineers Permit V'-1 s'- 7 �l Orange County Permit Other. SCozc"G G`if--y� ATE LI(DNSTR i_ G' tO;l 4Y'�i�l�1Ii DATE S E ATTACHED SH, (��1�� � a U. S. Corps of Engineers Post Office Box 2711 Los Angeles, California 90053 Attention: waterways Control section c Subject: Harbor Permit Application No. c ��;"1 --- Dear Sir: I hereby request a U. S. Corps of Engineers` Permit for the construction and installation of a wood seawall and appurtenances thereto, to be locatedinewp'Ft-�`ort Bay;—Fa--oi Lot No. 6 , Block No. N&23, Tract Eastside Addition , Newport Beach, Cil-i-F—ornia. I am UF -6 owner of.t e a orementione property, and I have made application for a Harbor Permit to the City of Newport Beach. The adjoining property owners are: Lot z4&5 , Block N&23 . Tract Eastside A i ion Dom McHone .1409 E. Balboa Blvd. _ Lot 7 , Block N&23 Trac£—Ea'Stside Adc}ition R.J. Brookes 1413 E. Balboa Blvd. Na�crt Bpach. California Respectfully subm' Date 11/26/73 Eric. Plans dated 11/16/73 C.L. Pec 3 Sepia 1411 E. Balboa Blvd. _ 7 copies Newport Beach, California CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH APPROVAL The Harbor and Tidelands Administrator of the ity of Newport .Beach has reviewed Harbor Permit application by � ; and subject to the approval of the U. S. Corps of Engineers, will issue' Harbor Permit No. . A -)j— / 4,// Date �7- Cc: Harshbarger, Captain . Marine Safetv Department Wol I ... 1 /09-///// r�I ooh I - �✓.!!.6' it I it 4 �I PROF/,C,E �� h SCAT -E /N ICY �I EX/ST/N6 PROPOs,EL7 4 X3�� /P/CPQ Al a97 F/NG Et i/ Di9T 4/,v. uFIx t fi/voF' .i U, S. BUtfNFA.� ti.v� .Fx s Tiv ¢ S 6 T 8 9 io c� ASR PFG.0 30 30 30 30 O 3oA 47 ri a I' /9 V L s�tLsz�aIcadcira �E � I I ¢ 6- 6 7 8 9 /O .EAS s/oma -900/ /av r aA ,q TiP c,T f'Ro�o�,�.> F<a9,�Y Rlwp --� N.EI^/PORT f3Al Pk,q At o io r� e o A 19/l f_P�, t C.CA/R . Cf�' MARINE SAFETY DEPARTMENT 70 Newport Pier February '25, 1974 TO: MAYOR & CITY COUNCIL ITEM NO.: F-1 FROM: Marine Safety Department SUBJECT: JOINT HARBOR COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION; REF. HARBOR PERMIT REVISION APPLICATIONS FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF A WOODEN SEAWALL 30' BAYWARD OF VACATED EAST BAY Action If desired, (1) deny the revision permits as applied for or (2) approve the permits subject to the Joint Harbor Committee's recommendation that the proposed bulkhead be built on the bayward most line of Vacated East Bay Avenue with approval for wooden return walls at the.F & G Street -ends. Discussion The City Council at their regular meeting on January 28 referred the subject permit revisions to the Joint Harbor. Committee for their recommendation. - The Joint Harbor Committee met on February 13, 1974, and discussed the attached staff report which was originally prepared for the Council's January 28 meeting. The staff prior to submitting the report to the Joint Harbor Committee "drew" in a second sand berm line representing berm positioning with respect to the proposed bulkhead. This second berm line measurement was taken in accord- ance with Council's instructions and represents positioning based on a Public Works survey made on January 29, 1974. The Joint Harbor Committee after reviewing the staff report, quest- ioning of staff and testimony by the applicants recommended that Council not approve the applications as applied for, however, they did recommend that the proposed wooden bulkhead, if built, be con- structed no further bayward than the bayward most line of Vacated East Bay Avenue,:with approval for wooden return walls at the F & G Street -ends.. Page Two Summarily, the Marine Safety Department has no set recommendations in this matter since it relates stridtly to policy. The staff will assist the applicants in processing the permits through the South Coast Regional Zone Conservation. Commission and U. S. Army Corps of Engineers in accordance with Council's policy decision on the loca- tion of the proposed bul head. mss' (C f R. E. Reed, Director Marine Safety Department RER:DH: lf Attachments MARINE SAFETY DEPARTMENT 70 Newport Pier TO: CHAIRMAN AND MEMBERS OF THE JOI14T HARBOR COMMIITTEE FROM: I-LARI14E SAFETY DEPARTMENT SUBJECT: HARBOR PERMIT APPLICATIONS FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF A WOODEN SEAWALL 30' DAYWARD OF VACATED EAST BAY AVEN.UE.BETWEEN F & G STREETS ON THE BALBOA PENINSULA. DISCUSSION: The 'Newport Beach City Council at their meeting on January 23, reviewed the attached Harbor Permit Application and staff. report. The Council referred the harbor Permit Applications to the Joint Harbor Committee for their review and recommendation. The staff, at the direction of Council,have drawn in a second sand 'berm line' based on the results of a Public Works survey taken on January 29, 1974. The first 'berm line.' was measured on December 12, 1973, by the Marine Safety Department staff. The difference between the two 'berm lines' represents beach prograding by homeowners contracting with a small equipment operator who, on an annual or bi-annual basis, pushes sand, at low tide, up in front of the homes to maintain beach frontage. R. E. REED, DIRECTOR MARINE SAFETY DEPARTMENT D. Harshbarger, Captain Marine Safety Department RER:DH:dw 2,99 Awl WO &—y"It _57 . . ... .... . ..... v A�q MARINE SAFETY DEPARTMENT 70 'Newport Pier January 28, 1974 TO: MAYOR A14D CITY COUNCIL FROM: Marina Safety Department SUBJECT: Harbor Permit Applications for the construction of a wooden seawall 30' ba ward of Vacated East Bay Avenue between7F & G Streets on The Balboa Peninsu a. APPLICANTS: Property owners; Eastside Addition Tract; Block N & 23. Listed as follows: Mr, R. English, 1401 E. Balboa Blvd., Lot I.; -Mr. G. Stephens, 1405 E. Bal. Blvd., -Lots 3 & 1/2 (4); Mr. D. McHone, 1409 E. Bal. Blvd. -Lots 1/2 (4) & 5, Mr. C. Peck, 1411 E. Bal. Blvd. -Lot 6; Mr_. R. Brookes, 1413 E. Bal. Blvd. -Lot 7; Mr. R. McLain, 1415 E. Bal. Blvd Lot:B; Mr. F. Rhodes, 1417 E. Bal. 31vd.-Lots 9 & 10. Project Descriptioh' Seven of the eight property owners bordering the Bay between F & G Streets on the East.Balboa Peninsula have applied to the City for, harbor permits to allow for the construction of a wooden seawall 30' bayward of "Vacated last Bay Avenue". The wooden seawall is proposed to be built at an elevation of. +8 PILLW with 30' length wooden return walls at the F & G Street -ends. Discussion The subject harbor permit application requires City Council approval because the proposed seawall would be constructed 30' bayward of "Vacated East Bay Avenue". The Harbor Permit Policies (Section 16 Bulkheads) was amended by Council in June of 1973. The following paragraph, applicable to these pending permits states: "The Marine Safety Department may issue permits for bulkheads, between U. S. Bulkhead Station Numbers 112-109 not to exceed the bayward side of the 'Vacated East Bay Avenue'. Concrete bulkheads and wooden retaining wall structures proposed to be constructed bayward of the bayward most line of Vacated East Bay Avenue shall be subject to City Council approval." The applications for Lots 1 and 10 bordering F & G Street, street - ends show 30' woodei4 return walls. Because these return walls are Page 2. proposed to be constructed of wood rather than concrete they would also require Council approval to deviate from City Ilarbor Permit Policies. Section 16 - Bulkheads, paragraph H, of the harbor Permit Policies address the above and states: "All.private bulkheads constructed along street right-of-way lines shall conform to the City Standard Drawings for a concrete bulkhead". The U. S. Bulkhead Line is 115' bayward of the zoning setback line for the block between F'& G Street. The property between the front of the homes and the U. S. Bulkhead Line is owned in fee by the respective homeowners, but any construction within this zone where the tide may ebb and flow requires a harbor permit, within the majority of the Harbor, bulkheads have been built on the U. S. Bulkhead Line; however, for this area (Between A and K Streets) it has been the City's basic position that bulkheads or retaining wall structures should be held back from the U. S: Bulkhead Line to the bayward side of "Vacated Last Bay Avenue" for the following reasons: 1. To preclude the possibility of sand -fill below the line of ordinary high tide. 2. To maintain as much as is possible conformity with respect to Section 16, paragraph A of the City's harbor Permit Policies establishing a quasi bulkhead line. 3. To retain sand sloping beaches, which are energy absorbing versus bulkhead structures which can reflect wave energy. 4. The possible retention of an undefined public easement over a por- tion of private property over which the tide ebbs and flows NOTE: It is tie staff's understanding (reference the First American Title Insurance Company, that rights and easements for Commerce, Navigation and Fishery is in favor of the public, or the federal, state or municipal government over any portion of the subject property which is submerged. Also, at such time that said submerged lands are filled, in conformance with all applicable permits, to an elevation above the line of ordinary high tide, that the above public easement exception will be thereby eliminated. The attached proposal drawings should warrant special Council attent- ion because these are the first harbor permit applications that repre- sent several homeowners requesting a variance to Council policy. The magnitude of the project could possibly set a precedent for other bayfront property owners within the A to K street zone. The attached summary drawing depicting the F to G street block shows an existing Sand Berm Lj.ne plotted by the Marine Safety Department Page 3. staff. This line.on an average is approximately 15' landward of the proposed seawall construction. Currently the sand elevation at the berm line is approximately an +8,5 MLLW. The sand level at the proposed bulkhead line is approximately a +4.0 MLLW. The zone between.the proposed wall and the current sand berm line will require fill. During recent field inspections of the lower harbor with staff members from the Bureau of Sport Fisheries and Wildlife and the South Coast Regional 'Lone Conservation Commission, bulkhead construction along sand beaches was discussed. In general, these agencies which review and comment on harbor permit applications for the U. S. Army Corps of Engineers, have held to the position that they are opposed to the continuation of the bulkhead and associated fill process in the lower Newport Bay. It is.their analysis that this can retard water circula- tion resulting in the degradation of water quality. Summarily, the applicants are proposing to construct a quasi wooden bulkhead structure 30' bayward of "Vacated East Bay Avenue" with wooden return walls.at the F & G Street -ends. The wooden wall bulkhead, based on staff inspection, will require limited landside fill. In conclusion, the marine Safety Department staff has not made a recom- mendation on this' application because of the policy nature of the request. The staff could alter its position on this proposed project if the bulkhead structure was brought back 30' to the bayward most line of Vacated East Bay Avenue. The following alternatives are listed for Council's consideration: 1. Construction of the proposed wooden bulkhead on the Bayward most line of "Vacated East Bay Avenue" (30' landward of the proposed location) with concrete return walls„ 2. Construction of the proposed wooden bulkhead on the Bayward most line of "Vacated East Bay Avenue" with approval for wooden return wails. R. E. REED, DIRECTOR D. Harshbarger; Captain Marine Safety Department DH:GEW:lf Attachments CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH HARBOR APPLICATION NO..�..._. i I fK_..._ .r....._f........-_ I ,�I ! 2 3 9 r Ji 3 .•X l� �¢( -Age Co• rook in•r.? . Q' b L R ALaeA I l / 7 Core..a EXl3 T. H J /-2.9- 7/ t yv ici&II I SkETLfI wart l6lY/ l fwar Ngp poor DAY, QAL IFORNIA l 5bvnq'1n9s ora expecssed ,, Feel and danoIe depths, below Moon Lower Law wor`en Morrnrurn ronye aFqpp roRimo/a/Y /O !¢e{ Norbar.hi�eb are ea lob/r'she}sd l >`h:s secbon o{Ne,/ Esor m-1111kV,mm WIN= go - j 'AG 13 0F1 z V4 it �I Ii I! Ai 7 9 0 I 1Z,20 f.. -Joe A,0ZWe-VJ9 645r's//JE App. 4 43- : / /O JG73'-/9Gb �'rZ5�7,,3 ✓,v MY r4 Al esi,tf GLOTdC CALIFORNIA MARINE DEPARTMENT January 14, 1975 City Hall 3300 W. Newport Blvd. Area Code 714 673.2110 4nglish, Pittroef, Stephens, MCHbne, Brookes, Peck., McLain, Rhodes Dear Sir: The Los Angeles District of the Army Corps of Engineers has notified us that you have been placing sand bayward of your recently installed retaining walls between F and G Streets on the Balboa Peninsula. Further, they have requested that we contact you on.•this first recorded offense. The placement of any fill material in the bay is an illegal act, punishable by federal action, unless prior approval is granted by the Army. The material must be analyzed for con- taminant content before being placed anywhere within the harbor. The analysis of samples is an expense to be born by the tidelands user, and the samples must meet certain stand- ards. The standards are reviewed by the Environmental Pro- tection Agency, the California Fish and Game, the Regional Water Quality Control Board, and the Department of Interior, River Basin Studies. Since this activity is now under very close surveillance by the Corps of Engineers, and other agencies, we strongly suggest that you contact this department before any further fill mater- ial is contemplated to be placed along the shoreline. The permit procedure must now be strictly adhered to, or, as the Army related to us, they will file with the Attorney General for prosecution. This letter is written in order to inform you of the situation .in the event you were previously not aware of it. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact the U. S. Army Corps .of Page Two Engineers, Los Angeles District, Harbors, and Waterways Division, Attention: Mr. John McVey, Area Manager - South Coast Areas, P. O. Box 2711, Los Angeles; California 90053 (Tele. (213)688-5607) We refer you to his office, since the material has already been placed, taking the situation from local control. Again, if any further fill material placement is contemplated, please do not fail to file for the necessary permits with the City of Newport Beach Marine Department. This way, we can all assist in retaining the necessary controls at the local level. Very truly yours, MARINE DEPARTMENT CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH R. E. Reed, Director RER:lf