The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About109-1519i. STATE OF CALIFORNIA - NATURAL RESOURCES AGENCY ARNOLD S CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION South Cohst Area Office 200 Oceaijgate, Suite 1000 Long Beagh, CA 90802-4302 June 12, 2009 (562)590j5071 Mr. Chris Miller City of Newport Beach/Division of Harbor Resources 829 Harbor Island Drive Newport Beach, CA 92660 Subject: Condition Compliance — Coastal Development Permit 5-06-117 & Conformance with Consistency Certification CC-031-06 - DREDGING Dear Mr. Miller: Commission staff have received information submitted as evidence of compliance with Coastal Development Permit 5-06-117, and/or as evidence of conformance with Consistency Certifications CC-031- 06 for the following sites in the City of Newport Beach: Applicant Site Address Beach Ocean Cumulative Eelgrass Comments Disposal Disposal Total* for Present Eelgrass Survey Qty. Qtyt 2009 between 15 - Date/Expiration; (cu.yds) (cu.yds) 30 Feet of Caulerpa Survey disposal Date/Expirationtt foot rint?5 Newport Aquatic 1 White Cliffs Drive 0 1000 No Eelgrass survey Center 4/24/09 (expires 8/22109); Caulerpa survey 4/24/09 7123109 Lido Isle Community Genoa & Via Lido Nord 215 0 No Eelgrass survey Association 419/09 (expires 8/7/09)' Caulerpa survey 4/9/09 (expires 7/8109 pLumpkh, Lillian 1519 E. Bay Avenue 85 0 No Eelgrass survey 4/9/09 (expires _ 8/7/09)' Caulerpa survey 4/9109 (expires 718/09 Goldsmith, Bram- 921 & 925 Via Lido Soud 214 0 No Eelgrass survey 4/9109 (expires 8/7/09)' Caulerpa survey 419/09 (expires 7/8/09 Ahern, Tom 1306 & 1310 E. Balboa Blvd. 310 0 No Eelgrass survey 417109 (expires 8/5/09)' Caulerpa survey 4/7/09 (expires Not to Exceed 1,000 cubic yards per dredging and beach disposal event Not to Exceed 1,000 cubic yards per dredging and off -shore disposal event Not to Exceed 20,000 cubic yards per year § If "Yes" then if eelgrass is present between 15-30 feet from the proposed dredge material disposal footprint (in any direction), then monitoring of the site for potential eelgrass impacts from disposal operations shall be required.. — All eelgrass survey/mapping efforts must be completed during the active growth phase for the vegetation (typically March through October) and shall be valid fora period of 120 days with the exception of surveys completed in August - October. A survey completed in August - October shall be valid until the resumption of active growth (i.e., March 1). tt Caulerpa taxifolia surveys are valid for 90 days from date of survey -1- DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY LOS ANGELES DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS P.O. BOX 532711 LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90053-2325 June 2, 2009 REPLY T AMMON OP: Office of the Chief Regulatory Division Lillian, Lumpkin c/o Lisa Walters City of Newport Beach, Harbor Resources Division 829 Harbor Island Drive Newport Beach, California 92660 Dear Ms. Lumpkin: This is in reply to your application (File No. SPL-2009-00419-MAS) dated May 19, 2009 for a Department of the Army Permit to discharge fill onto waters of the U.S., in association with the dock dredging in Lower Newport Bay. The proposed work would take place at 1314 Balboa Boulevard in Lower Newport Bay in the City of Newport Beach, Orange County, California (as shown on attached drawing). Based on the information you have provided, the Corps of Engineers has determined that your proposed activity complies with the terms and conditions of Regional General Permit (RGP) No. 54-Maintenance Dredging, Beach Nourishment, and Dock Maintenance. As long as you comply with the general permit conditions of RGP No. 54- Maintenance Dredging, Beach Nourishment, and Dock Maintenance, an individual permit is not required. Specifically, you are authorized to: 1. Dredge 85 cubic yards of material from 0.015 acres at 1314 East Balboa Boulevard in Lower Newport Bay using a 6" suction dredge 2. Dredged material will be placed on 35 linear feet of beach at 1314 East Balboa -2- Boulevard. A general permit does not grant any property rights or exclusive privileges. Also, it does not authorize any injury to the property or rights of others or authorize interference with any existing or proposed Federal project. Furthermore, it does not obviate the need to obtain other Federal, State, or local authorizations required by law. Attached to this verification that your project is authorized by RGP 54 is an approved jurisdictional determination (JD). If you are not in agreement with that approved JD, you can make an administrative appeal under 33 CFR 331. Thank you for participating in our regulatory program. If you have any questions, please contact Melanie Stalder at 213.452.3294 or via e-mail at Melanie.A.Stalder@usace.army.mil. Please be advised that you can now comment on your experience with Regulatory Division by accessing the Corps web -based customer survey form at: http:Lper2.nwl2.usace.army.mil/survey.hbxd. Sincerely, Daniel P. Swenson Senior Project Manager North Coast Branch Regulatory Division Enclosure F NE WPOR T BERCH CITY OF NEWPORT' BERCM / �f R BAY O �— Pyc«,,C pCC�N Jim PETTY ViCi iTY:PtRp SBT 7F1P'CNl' �iV', CfA.IF'ttUIIR Q S7 I'7SI�a5a /.390s��t^.USOa�P< Ufa( .2l�/Os�i'f •U45a.crE �J R � v CZ It y0� iC�i4�1 u 7, rZN / DAC$gr1 sT PRAT I L L IN -� f LY JETTY Sc SOUNDINGS ARE EXPRESSED IN FEET AND DENOTE ELEVATIONS BASED ON MEAN LOWER LOW WATER. Oreo2q, n� Is 1306 13�o I PI.i�N VIE�I 1" �3�rr LICANT �S NRME L ��/a n .�u t q k i r� JOB ADDRESS✓? ORM Printer Friendly JD Form Page 1 of 5 APPROVED JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION FORM U.S. Army Corps of Engineers SECTION I: BACKGROUND INFORMATION A. REPORT COMPLETION DATE FOR APPROVED JURISDICTIONAL DETERMINATION (JD): 02Jun-2009 B. DISTRICT OFFICE, FILE NAME, AND NUMBER: Los Angeles District,SPL-2009-00419WASJDI C. PROJECT LOCATION AND BACKGROUND INFORMATION: State : Countylpa rish/borough: City: Let: Long: Universal Transverse Mercator CA - California Orange Newport Beach 33.59997 -117.89218 Folder UTM List UTM list determined by folder location e NAD83/UTM zone 36S Waters UTM List UTM list determined by waters location e NAD83I UTM zone 36S Name of nearest waterbody: Name of nearest Traditional Navigable Water (TNW): Padfic Ocean Name of watershed or Hydrologic Unit Code (HUC): 18070102 Check if map/diagram of review area and/or potential judsdictional areas is/are available upon request. Check If other sites (e.g., offsite mitigation sites, disposal sites, etcg) are associated with the action and are recorded on a different JD form. D. REVIEW PERFORMED FOR SITE EVALUATION: Office Determination Date: 02-Jun-2009 Field Determination Date(s): SECTION II: SUMMARY OF FINDINGS A. RHA SECTION 10 DETERMINATION OF JURISDICTION There are "navigable waters of the U.S" within Rivers and Harbors Act (RHA) jurisdiction (as defined by 33 CFR part 329) in the review area. Waters subject to the ebb and flow of the tide. Waters are presently used, or have been used in the past, or may be susceptible for use to transport interstate or foreign commerce. Explain: Lower Newport Bay supports commerce and recreation B. CWA SECTION 404 DETERMINATION OF JURISDICTION. There I ]'Waters of the U.S." within Clean Water Act (CWA) jurisdiction (as defined by 33 CFR part 328) in the review area. 1. Waters of the U.S. a. Indicate presence of waters of U.S. In review aree:l Water Name I Water Type(s) Present Lower Newport Bay I TNWs, including territorialseas b. Identify (estimate) size of waters of the U.S. In the review area: Area: 182.1152 (m') Linear: (m) https://orm.usace.army.mil/orm2/f?p=l06:34:767377872713210::NO:: 6/2/2009 ORM Printer Friendly JD Form Page 2 of 5 c. Limits (boundaries) of jurisdiction: based on: Established by mean(average) high waters. OHWM Elevation: (if known) 2. Non -regulated waters/wetlands:s Potentially jurisdictional waters and/or wetlands were assessed within the review area and determined to be not jurisdictional. Explain: SECTION III: CWA ANALYSIS A. TNWs AND WETLANDS ADJACENT TO TNWs 1.TNW TNW Name Summarize rationale supporting determination: Lower Newport Bay Lower Newport Bay supports commerce and recreation 2. Wetland Adjacent to TNW Not Applicable. B. CHARACTERISTICS OF TRIBUTARY (THAT IS NOT A TNW) AND ITS ADJACENT WETLANDS (IF ANY): 1. Characteristics of non-TNWs that flow directly or Indirectly Into TNW it) General Area Conditions: Watershed size: [] Drainage area: [ ] Average annual rainfall: inches Average annual snowfall: inches (II) Physical Characteristics (a) Relationship with TNW: Tributary flows directly into TNW. Tributary flows through [ ] tributaries before entering TNW. :Number of tributaries Project waters are [ j river miles from TNW. Project waters are [ J river miles from RPW. Project Waters are [ J aerial (straight) miles from TNW. Project waters are [ J aerial(straight) miles from RPW. Project waters cross or serve as state boundaries. Explain: Identify flow route to TNW:5 Tributary Stream Order, If known: Not Applicable. (b) General Tributary Characteristics: Tributary is: Not Applicable. Tributary properties with respect to top of bank (estimate): Not Applicable. Primary tributary substrate composition: Not Applicable. Tributary (conditions, stability, presence, geometry, gradient): Not Applicable. https://orm.usace.army.mil/orm2/f?p=106:34:767377872713210::NO:: 6/2/2009 ®RM Printer Friendly JD Form Page 3 of 5 (c) Flow: Not Applicable. Surface Flow is: Not Applicable. Subsurface Flow: Not Applicable. Tributary has: Not Applicable. If factors other than the OHWM were used to determine lateral extent of CWA jurisdiction: High Tide Line Indicated by: Not Applicable. Mean High Water Mark indicated by: Not Applicable. (it!) Chemical Characteristics: Characterize tributary (e.g., water color is clear, discolored, oily film; water quality;general watershed characteristics, etc.). Not Applicable. (Iv) Biological Characteristics. Channel supports: Not Applicable. 2. Characteristics of wetlands adjacent to non-TNW that flow directly or Indirectly into TNW (1) Physical Characteristics: (a) General Wetland Characteristics: Properties: Not Applicable. (b) General Flow Relationship with Non-TNW: Flow is: Not Applicable. Surface flow Is: Not Applicable. Subsurface flow: Not Applicable. (c) Wetland Adjacency Determination with Non-TNW: Not Applicable. (d) Proximity (Relationship) to TNW: Not Applicable. (il) Chemical Characteristics: Characterize tributary (e.g., water color is clear, discolored, oily film; water quality; general watershed characteristics, etc.). Not Applicable. (III) Biological Characteristics. Wetland supports: Not Applicable. 3. Characteristics of all wetlands adjacent to the tributary (If any); All wetlands being considered in the cumulative analysis: Not Applicable. https:Horm.usace.army.mil/orm2/f?p=106:34:767377872713210::NO:: 6/2/2009 ORM Printer Friendly JD Form Page 4 of 5 Summarize overall biological, chemical and physical functions being performed: Not Applicable. C. SIGNIFICANT NEXUS DETERMINATION A significant nexus analysis will assess the flow characteristics and functions of the tributary itself and the functions performed by any wetlands adjacent to the tributary to determine if they significantly affect the chemical, physical, and blolog Ica I integrity of a TNW. For each of the following situations, a significant nexus exists if the tributary, In combination with all of its adjacent wetlands, has more than a speculative or Insubstantial effect on the chemical, physical and/or biological integrity of a TNW. Considerations when evaluating significant nexus include, but are not limited to the volume, duration, and frequency of the flow of water in the tributary and Its proximity to a TNW, and the functions performed by the tributary and all Its adjacent wetlands. It Is not appropriate to determine significant nexus based solely on any specific threshold of distance (e.g. between a tributary and Its adjacent wetland or between a tributary and the TNW). Similarly, the fact an adjacent wetland lies within or outside of a floodplain is not solely determinative of significant nexus. Significant Nexus: Not Applicable D. DETERMINATIONS OF JURISDICTIONAL FINDINGS. THE SUBJECT WATERSMETLANDS ARE: l 1. TNWs and Adjacent Wetlands: Wetland Name Type Size (Linear) (m) Size (Area) (W) Lower Newport Bay TNWs, including territorial seas I - 182.10852 Total: 1 0 182.10852 2. RPWs that flow directly or indirectly into TNWs: Not Applicable. Provide estimates for jurisdictional waters in the review area: Not Applicable. 3. Non-RPWs that flow directly or indirectly into TNWs:s Not Applicable. Provide estimates for jurisdictional waters in the review area: Not Applicable. 4. Wetlands directly abutting an RPW that flow directly or Indirectly into TNWs. Not Applicable. Provide acreage estimates for jurisdictional wetlands in the review area: Not Applicable. 6. Wetlands adjacent to but not directly abutting an RPW that flow directly or indirectly into TNWs: Not Applicable. Provide acreage estimates for jurisdictional wetlands in the review area: Not Applicable. 6. Wetlands adjacent to non-RPWs that flow directly or indirectly into TNWs: Not Applicable. Provide estimates for jurisdictional wetlands in the review area: Not Applicable. 7. Impoundments of jurisdictional waters:s Not Applicable. E. ISOLATED (INTERSTATE OR INTRA-STATE] WATERS INCLUDING ISOLATED WETLANDS, THE USE, DEGRADATION OR DESTRUCTION OF WHICH COULD AFFECT INTERSTATE COMMERCE, INCLUDING ANY SUCH WATERS:10 Not Applicable. https://ortn.usace.army.miUorm2/f?p=106:34:767377872713210::NO:: 6/2/2009 ORM Printer Friendly JD Form Page 5 of 5 Identify water body and summarize rationale supporting determination: Not Applicable. Provide estimates for jurisdictional waters In the review area: Not Applicable. F. NON -JURISDICTIONAL WATERS. INCLUDING WETLANDS If potential wetlands were assessed within the review area, these areas did not meet the criteria in the 1987 Corps of Engineers Wetland Delineation Manual and/or appropriate Regional Supplements: Review area Included Isolated waters with no substantial nexus to interstate (or foreign) commerce: Prior to the Jan 2001 Supreme Court decision in "SWANCC," the review area would have been regulated based soley on the "Migratory Bird Rule" (MBR): Waters do not meet the "Significant Nexus" standard, where such a finding is required forjurisdiction (Explain): Other (Explain): Provide acreage estimates for non -jurisdictional waters in the review area, where the sole potential basis of jurisdiction is the MBR factors (le., presence of migratory birds, presence of endangered species, use of water for irrigated agriculture), using best professional judgment: Not Applicable. Provide acreage estimates for non -jurisdictional waters in the review area, that do not meet the "Significant Nexus" standard, where such a finding is required for jurisdiction. Not Applicable. SECTION IV: DATA SOURCES. A. SUPPORTING DATA. Data reviewed for JD (listed Items shall be Included in rasa file and where Mac Data Reviewed Source Label Source Description —Maps, plans, plots or plat submitted by or on behalf of the _ Application submitted by Lillian Lumpk(n 2009- applicant1consultant 00419-MAS B. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS TO SUPPORT JD: Not Applicable. 1-Boxes checked below shall be supported by completing the appropriate sections in Section III below. 2-For purposes of this form, an RPW Is defined as a tributary that is not a TNW and that typically flows year-round or has continuous flow at least "seasonally (e.g., typically 3 months). 3-Supporting documentation is presented In Section III.F. 4-Note that the Instructional Guidebook contains additional Information regarding males, ditches, washes, and emsional features generally and in the and West. 5-Flow mute can be described by identifying, e.g., tributary a, which flows through the review area, to flow into tributary b, which then flows Into TNW. a -A natural or man-made discontinuity in the CHAM does not necessarily sever jurisdiction (e.g., where the stream temporarily flows underground, orwhere the OHWM has been removed by development or agricultural practices). Where there is a break In the OHWM that Is unrelated to the waterbodys flow regime (e.g., flow over a rock outcrop or through a culvert), the agencies will look for indicators of flow above and below the break. 7-Ibid. 8-See Footnote #3. a -To complete the analysis refer to the key in Section III.DS of the Instructional Guidebook. 10-Prior to asserting or dedin Ing CWA jurisdiction based solely on this category, Corps Districts will elevate the action to Corps and EPA HO for review consistent with the process described in the Corps/EPA Memorandum Regarding CWA Act Jurisdiction Following Rapanos. https://onn.usace.army.mil/onn2/f7p=106:34:767377872713210::NO:: 6/2/2009 HARBOR RESOURCES DIVISION 829 Harbor Island Drive Newport Beach, CA 92660 (949) 718-1844 Fax (949) 723-0589 www.newport-beacb.ca.us/libr DREDGING APPLICATION Applicant Name: Project Site Address: CITY CHECKLIST 11 lio-^ ® Applicant address, phone number Agent &. Contractor name, address, phone number (if applicable) ® Project site address Assessor's parcel number ® Dredge site latitude and longitude ® Disposed site: ® Beach disposal latitude and longitude ❑ Ocean disposal LA-3 ® Purpose and final goal of dredging ® Method of dredging. Vessel and equipment description. Vessel(s) Captain, Dredging & Disposal Inspector ® Cubic yards dredged and disposed ( must be less than 1,000 cy.) ® Area impacted (in acres) If beach disposal, linear feet of affected beach area Dredging and Disposal Operations Schedule Scaled drawings (plan view and cross sectional view) L� Site address ® Location within the Harbor 829 Harbor Island Drive, Newport Beach, CA 92660 PH: (949) 644-3034 FX: (949) 723-0589 •Website: wxvw.newport-beach.ca.us/HBR/ Dredging Application City Checklist Paget k;l Location of existing dock structures ® Location of existing dock structures on adjacent properties Location of Bulkhead, Pierhead and Project Lines ® Dredge depth (limited to -7 MLLW with a 1' allowable overdraft) Photo(s) of dredge and disposal areas at low tide (including 30' buffer area) Belgrass Survey ® Survey for presence of eelgrass within 30' of the entire project area ❑ Yes ® No Belgrass within 15' of entire project area. Project not Permitted. ❑ If ocean disposal and eelgrass is located greater than 15' from the project area, then no further monitoring required ® If beach disposal and eelgrass is not located within 30' of the project area, then no further monitoring is required ❑ If beach disposal and eelgrass is located between 15' and 30' from the project area, then pre- and post -monitoring is required ❑ Pre -monitoring survey attached ❑ Post -monitoring survey attached. Date submitted: Felgrass Stamp ® Caulerpa Survey ® Survey for Caulerpa within 30' of the entire project area ® Grain Size Analysis ® (1) sample per''/a acre and / or at least (1) sample at dredge site and (1) sample at beach disposal site (if applicable) Beach disposal: ® Sample(s) must beat least 80% sand, or; ❑ At least 75% sand and within 10% of the sand content of the receiver beach ❑ Ocean Disposal: ❑ Sample(s) must be less than 80% sand ® Project is over (check one box): ® City Tidelands n Dredging Application City Checklist Page ❑ County Tidelands (State Lands Commission Dredge Lease Approval) I£ applicable, check one box: ❑ The Irvine Company owner's approved area ❑ Bay Island owner's approved area ❑ Dover Shores owner's approved area ❑ Linda Isle owner's approved area Check made payable to The City of Newport Beach Check for $60 made payable to Santa Ana Regional Water Quality Control Board Signed application Neighbor notification POST DREDGING ❑ Post Dredging Report. Date submitted: ❑ Post eelgrass monitoring (if applicable) CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH I1ARBOR RESOURCES wLl FO R�/ May 13, 2009 California Coastal Commission Attn: Karl Schwing 200 Oceangate, STE 1000 Long Beach, CA 90S02-4416 Army Corps of Engineers Attn: Dan Swenson 915 Wilshire Blvd. Los Angeles, CA 90017 Santa Ana Regional Water Quality Control Board Attn: Adam Fischer 3737 Main Street, STE 500 Riverside, CA 92501-3348 RE: Regional General Permit No. 54 — Dredging Application Submittals Enclosed is the recent monthly batch of dredging applications for your approval, per the California Coastal Commission Permit 5-06-117 & Federal Consistency Certification CC-031-06, the Army Corps of Engineers Permit No. 54 (File No. 200501233-DPS) and the Regional Water Quality Control Board General Certification Permit, $60 Regional Water Board check included for each application. All of these applications have been checked for accuracy and completeness as evidenced by the attached Dredging Application City Checklist. Thank you for your time in reviewing these applications. Please do not hesitate to call if you have any questions. Site addresses included Newport Aquatic Center- 1 White Cliffs Dr. Lido Isle Community Assoc.- Via Genoa & Via Lido Nord Lumpkin- 1519 E. Bay Ave. Goldsmith- 921 & 925 Via Lido Soud Ahern- 1306 &1310 E. Balboa Blvd. Sincerely, Lisa Wafters Harbor Resources Technician (949) 644-3044 829 Harbor Island Drive, Newport Beach, CA 92660 PH: (949) 644-3044 FX: (949) 723-0589 •Website: www.newport-beach.ca.us/HBR/ Print Form HARBOR RESOURCES DIVISION v.6-22-07 829 Harbor island Drive o Newport Beach, CA 92660 (949)644-3044 Fax (949) 723-0589 W Mv. Ile Who I-[- beac 11. c ,I. CIO) br DREDGING APPLICATION Regional General Permit 54 CDP 5-06-117 & CC-031-06 Corps File No. 200501233-DPS Water Board Consistency Permit Valid Until October 4, 2011 Applicant Name, Address, Phone Number: .�'I � ,� / 23 2P A., CA 9?, Agent & Contractor Name, Address, Phone Number (if applicable): ' �" " 9 1'33 - 0 91 cc// P.P. Box qt? I"/? 67r-1,071 A'LIAVC� 4Ald C'j Project Site Parcel Number: E/ B,. tl 0 CL Dredge Site; Latitude Longitude W 1170,53,531 Disposal Site Beach Disposal: Latitude Longitude SA Ocean Disposal (LA-3): Latitude 33'3 11 QQ11 Longitude JLJ° �011 p ur ose and Final Goal of Dredging (Effect on Bulkhead and Beaches): i--etu s4t,4 160 -a Regional Geneml Perini[ 54 Dredging dpplication Method of Dredging (Hydraulic, Clamshell, Tractor ctc...), Vessel and Equipment Description: v 6 // - /YX"iaca�. .S Z4c Vessel(s) Captain j1)%1- K 5, /e 5 Dredging Operations Inspector Disposal Operations Inspector I C rua Cubic Yards Dredged and Disposed (Must be less than 1,000 cy, total): 3SJcu.61c yarJ_S Area Impacted (in acres): If Beach Disposal Is Used, Linear Feet of Affected Beach Area: w Acres 3� Linear Feet Estimate of Quantity of Material Dredged From or Disposed Onto the Site From Previous Activities: dna20x. 70cu yobs eyP2y-S yea es Dredging and Disposal Operations Schedule: I oAr¢cQe�rnS ciay c�;n�, We Please submit the following on a separate page. Use the check boxes to ensure a complete application is filed. Incomplete applications will not be processed. 1 '*"� Scaled drawings of the project and disposal areas (plan view and cross sectional view) (/-" Site address . Location within the Harbor 1—1 Location and physical dimensions of existing structures on subject site (e.g. float, pier, gangway, pile and bulkhead) Rr Location and physical dimensions of existing structures on adjacent properties 1—`� Location of Bulkhead, Pierhead and Project Lines I l Dredge depth (limited to -7 MLLW with a I'allowable overdraft) (% Photo(s) of entire dredge and disposal areas at low tide (including 30' buffer area), with emphasis on eelgrass Regional General Permit 54 Dredging Application Page 4 (Applicant / Agent), hereby certify that the information on this application is accurate and complete. I also certify that I have read the California Coastal Commission Permit 5-06-117 & Federal Consistency Certification CC-031-06, the Army Corps of Engineers Regional General Permit No. 54 (File No. 200501233-DPS) and the California Regional Water Quality Control Board General Certification for Regional General Permit No. 54 for maintenance dredging in Newport Harbor and that I will comply with all of the conditions in those permits. I also certify that by acceptance of this Permit, the applicant acknowledges and agrees that the site may be subject to hazards from waves and erosion. I will further hold the City of Newport Beach harmless from and indemnify the City against any claim for damages arising out of the exercise of these permits. In addition, I shall reimburse the City of Newport Beach for all attorney's fees and other costs expended by them in defending any claim, lawsuit, or judgment arising out of the activities of the applicant carried on under the authority of such Permit. I understand that any work authorized must be completed by October 4 2011 after which a new authorization is required. I also understand that the applicant will submit a Post Dredging Completion Report no later than 30 calendar days after completion of each dredging project. All work scheduled to be completed before 7:00 AM or after 6:00 PM (Monday - Saturday) or on Sundays or holidays must be approved by Harbor Resources. Per the RGP Permit, all dredging applications will be processed by the various agencies through monthly batch submittals sent to them by Harbor Resources. Therefore, all dredgine applications must be submitted to and received by Harbor Resources by the 1"Monday of every month Applications submitted prior to this deadline are encouraged and appreciated. General Information for RGP #54 Contractor: lAark Sites dba Intracoastal Dredging Service, (949) 675-1071 Email: marklsites@yahoo.com License Information: California State Contractor 94 6023 5 Classification: "A" (General Enguieering),"HAZ"(I-lamrdous Remediation) Equipment: Shop built, 6", plain suction, 110 horsepower, hydraulic dredge, 22' X 1.1'. Operator: Mark Sites Experience_1.982-to-present.on-above-equipment - ------..-- ------- Other: No barges or tugs are used. Typically, sand is pumped through a plastic pipeline to a nearby beach disposal / restoration site. P,-a I 11 II OF II IEWVIPOR I� ILAEII11CH J 7 CITY OF q '� NEWPORT DERCH ! � / Iry Uu i _e PROFILE 1• gyp' am mrv, CfA IPpMdiq -SITE ,TCTTY Sir —c d s SOUNDINGS ARE EXPRESSED IN FEET AND AENOTk fq �. ELEVATIONS DRSED ON MERN LOWER L0W WRTER, �n !/L 'p!'�9f'•Y �p (•n(�S 1'r.OIS0.4r!'. EEL GRASS WUSSWgC"oN ©llsa� /�50 �J`^ t710a•�< Eelgrass within 15' of project 7o AcI .2olo f7 •UNsacet ❑ Eeigrass within 15 .30' of project L[Vo Eel rasa in projeot area HI"IARBOR RESOURCES DIV, t CI OF NEWPORi BEACH Sp otion &m Tie c) ` ^� alf(heu. Ars�swl � ....:::...... .. I /3o8 l306 /310 PLAN VIAL i" C3J flPLICANT'S NAME LrIIian ai•ri:r k^ Iron AODRE58,/3/// _ n foa ls� DATE 16 April 2009 o Intracoastal Dredging Service P.O. Box 498 Balboa Island, CA 92662 Attention: Mark Sites Re: Physical Sediment Testing Results Dear Mr. Sites: Enclosed are the results of the grain size testing associated with the Regional General Permit for dredging in Newport Harbor. The testing followed Particle Size: Sieve Analysis: Method 2 as defined in Procedures for Handling and Chemical Analysis of Sediment and Water Samples (Plumb 1981). The analysis requested was for basic testing of the core samples for particle (grain) size and reporting of the percent sand and silt/clay fractions to the nearest 1 % for each fraction. If you have questions regarding the methodology or the results, please do not hesitate to contact me. The MBC staff appreciated the opportunity to work with you on this project. Please let me know if we can assist you on any other environmental projects in the future. Cordially, MBC Applied Environmental Sciences Michael J. Mancuso Vice President Ope ations MBC Applied Environmental Sciences, 3000 Redhill Ave., Costa Mesa, CA 92626 (714) 850-4830 - Websile: mbcnet.net STATION LOCATION: 1312 E. Balboa SAMPLE COLLECTION DATE: 4/9/2009 TEST METHOD: Sieve Analysis: Method 2 (Plumb 1981) COLLECTED BY: Intracoastal Dredging ANALYSIS START DATE: 4/10/20o9 A B DREDGE SITE RECEIVING BEACH Total Dry Weight of Sample: 442.22 grams (g) 57.33 grams (g) Analysis Weight (Split WQ: 67.60 g 57.33 g Visual Description: A light brown course to fine sand A light grey very fine sand with gravel & shell hash. with no shell hash Fraction Fraction Fraction Fraction WeightTotal Weight % of Total Gravel / Shell Hash Fraction: 2.27 g 3 % 0.00 g 0 %' >2.Omm (> -1¢) #10 Sieve Sand Fraction: 64.22 g 95 % 56.84 g 99 % <2.Omm >0.063mm (< -1 � > 4�) #230 Sieve Silt / Clay Fraction: 1.11 g 2 % 0.49 g 1 % <0.063mm (< 4 y) COLLECTION Outline of sample collection and analysis: Samples collected by a hand coring device driven into a representative area of the dredge site and receiving beach. Stored in plastic containers and immediately delivered to the lab. SAMPLE PREPARATION Entire sample transferred into 1 liter glass containers, deionized water added, and mixed to desalt and disperse the sediment. The sediment is allowed to completely settle and the clear water is removed by siphoning. The sample is placed in a drying oven at 50°C and occasionally stirred until the entire sample is completely dry. The dry sample is transferred to a desiccator for cooling. The sample is disaggregated and a Riffle sediment splitter is used to evenly split the sample to reduce the quantity of Material to be analyzed to an allowable retention weight for the sieves. SAMPLE ANALYSIS The dry split fraction is processed through a # 10 U.S. standard sieve to remove the gravel/shell fraction of the sample. The material retained on the sieve is weighed and value recorded. The material passing through the # 10 sieve is wet sieved through a #230 sieve to remove the silt/clay fraction. The material retained on the sieve is transferred back Into the glass container and placed back into the drying oven at 50°C. The remaining sample is allowed to completely dry and the material is weighed and recorded to yield the sand fraction. The silt/clay fraction is calculated by subtracting the gravel/shell and sand fractions from the total analysis weight. MBC Applied Environmental Sciences, 3000 Red Hill Avenue, Costa Mesa, CA 9?02e rI F wwm P ev'' Ej IV Debris Management Plan - 1,5111 lr-: At The sand to be removed from this site is quite clean, with little debris present. This observation comes from past dredging projects at this site. The dredge itself will not pass anything larger than a 4" sphere. Smaller objects, such as shells and cobble, may be pumped to the beach with the sand where they would be difficult to remove before becoming buried. However, shells are a common component of all bay beaches. Most trash, such as plastics, bottles, and old boat covers, becomes lodged in the intake nozzle and creates a clog. The pumping operation is temporarily stopped while the nozzle is lifted and the debris removed and placed to the side for later disposal. Some smaller trash can pass through the pipeline and be deposited along with the sand on the beach. Being lighter than the sand, most of it tends to wash to the sides of the deposited sand along with the tail -water. After the dredging operation is complete, the beach is generally raked in order to level out high and low areas, and to remove any trash that might be on the beach. In addition, any lighter trash that has washed to the sides of the deposited fill is picked up as the tide drops and properly disposed of. Eelgrass Survey Reporting Form (Version 1.0, June 20, 2003) This form is required to be submitted for any surveys conducted for the eelgrass, Zostera marina, that are required to be conducted under federal or state permits and authorizations issued by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the Coastal Commission. The form has been designed to assist in identifying eelgrass while ensuring that the required information is consistently documented. Surveys required to be conducted for this species are subject to modification through publication of revisions to the eelgrass survey policy. It is incumbent upon the authorized permittee to ensure that survey work is following the latest protocols. For further information on these protocols, please contact: Robert Hoffman, National Marine Fisheries Service, (562) 980-4043, or William Paznokas, California Department of Fish & Game, (858) 467-42.18). Site Name: 1314 East Balboa Blvd., Newport Beach (common reference Survey Contact: name, phone, e-mail) Mark Sites 949 675-1071 marklsitesQyahoo.com Permit Reference: (ALOE Permit No., RWQCB Order orCen.No.) ALOE RGP #54 ydrographic System: bay, estuary, lagoon, or arbor) Lower Newport Harbor Specific Location: (UTM, Lat./Long., datum, N 33 35.998' ecuracy level, attach W 117 53.5315 lectronic survey area map if possible) Was Eelgrass Detected: Yes, Eelgrass was found at this site. Q No, Eelgrass was not found at this site within 30' of the project Description of Permitted Work: Maintenance dredging with beach disposal. describe briefly the work to be conducted at the site under e permits identified above) Description of Site: Depth range: (describe the physical and +7' to —9.5' MLLW biological conditions within e survey area at the time of e survey and provide insigh into variability, if known. Please provide units for all mmerical information). Substrate e: and to mud over sand Temperature: 63 F Salinity: NA Dominant ora: None Dominant fauna: Mussels on dock floats and pile. Exotic species encountered, None Other site Third SCUBA survey of this site within an description approximate 6-month period by three separate notes: eelgrass surveyors. No eelgrass found. 2 escription^ofSurvey Survey date Effort- and time April 9, 2009 1550-1640 (please describe the surveys period: conducted including type of survey (SCUBA, remote video, etc.) and survey methods employed, date of work, and survey, density estimated percentage-af the bottom. actually viewed). Describe any limitations encountered during the survey efforts. Horizontal visibility in <3' water: urvey type andmethods: SCUBA survey. Diver used a tether attached to dock Iles and swam decreasing diameter circular patterns due to poor visibility. All of the disposal area and the southern portion of the dredging site were viewed dry t low tide. survey rsonnel: Mark Sites urvey density Over 80% Survey imitations: Poor visibility due to turbidity caused by upper bay dredging projects and heavy tug and barge traffic. Other Information: use this space to provide any additional information or +0.8' MLLW flood tide references to attached materials such .as.maps, Drawing and aerial attached reports, etc,) Eetgrass Survey Reporting Form (version 1.0, 6/17/03) 3 CITY OF �. NEWPORT AERCH 79sr �' ri0r Lq pR�?r�1 }��R YI' \ tCINIiY.. MRP nrry PFiQF14EMST a oRr K fl ~� JETTY SQUN INCS RRE EXPRC55ETl IN FEET AND DENOTE ELEVATION$ BASED ON MEAN LOWER LOW WATER. nr _ 1 �.::Ba./hea hl✓rXIDATEd/ r z t1f 10 N, � Caulerpa Survey Reporting Form This form is requiredto be submitted for any surveys conducted for the invasive exotic alga Caulerpa taxifolia that. are. required : to, be conducted under federal or state, permits and authorizations issued by the U.S. Army Corps, of Engineers. or Regional Water Quality Control Boards (Regions 8 & 9.), The form has been designed to assist in controlling the costs of reporting while ensuring that the required information necessary to identify and control any potential impacts of the authorized actions on the spread of Caulerpa. Surveys required to be conducted for this species are subject to modification through publication of revisions to the Caulerpa survey policy. It is incumbent upon the authorized permittee to ensure that survey work is following the latest protocols., For further information on these. protocols, please contact: Robert Hoffman, National: Marine Fisheries. Service (NQ,AA Fisheries), (562} 980-4043, or WiUiam Paznokas, California Department of Fish & Game, (85.8).467-4218.). ReportDate:.. AprA 23, 2009.. N.a.me of bay,, estuary,. lagoon, or. harbor: Lower Newport Harbor Specific Location Name: (address or common reference) 1314 E. Balboa Blvd., Newport Beach Site Coordinates: (UTM, Lat./Long., datum, N 33 35,998' accuracy level, and an W 117 53.531' electronic survey area map or hard copy of the map must be included) Survey Contact: (name, phone, e-mail) Mark Sites 949 675-1071 marklsitesRyphooxorn Personnel Conducting Survey (if other than above): (name, phone, e-mail) same Permit Reference: (ACOE Permit No., RWQCB Order or Cert. No.) ACOE RGP #54 Is this the first or second curve for thisproject? first Was Caulerpa Yes, Caulerpa was found at this site and Detected?: (if Caulerpa is found, please immediately has been contacted on date. contact NOAA Fisheries or CDFG personnel identified above) No, Caulerpa was not found at this site. Description of Permitted Work: (describe briefly the Maintenance dredging of existing boat slip with beach disposal, work to be. conducted at the site under the permits identified above) Description of Site: Depth range: +T to —9.5' MLLW (describe the physical and biological conditions within the survey area at the time of the survey and provide insight into variability, if known. Please Substrate type: Sand to mud over sand Temperature: 63 F Salinity: NA Dominant flora. provide units for all numerical information). None Dominant fauna: Mussels on dock floats and pile Exotic species encountered (including any other Caulerpa None species): Other site description notes: None Description of Survey Survey date and Effort: time period: Aril 9, 2009 1550-1640 (please describe the surveys Horizontal conducted including type of survey (SCUBA, remote video, etc.) and survey methods employed, date of work, and survey density (estimated percentage ).the bottom actually viewed). visibility in water: c3 f Survey .type and methods: Surveillance level SCUBA survey. Diver used a tether attached to dock piles and swam decreasingdiameter circular patterns due to poor visibility, All of the disposal p ty area and the southern portion of the Describe any limitations dredging site were viewed dry at low tide. Survey personnel., encountered during the survey efforts. Mark Sites Survey density: Over 80% Survey limitations: Poor visibility due to upper bay dredging and heavy tug and barge traffic. Other Information: (use this space to provide +0.8' MLLW flood tide additional information or references to attached maps, reports, etc.) Drawing and aerial attached Caulerpa Survey Reporting Form (version 1.2, 10/31/04) CITY OF NEWPORT DESCH_ /✓� NE POTf ll Dlq#+' ,� 7Fo + 7 BABY �2N / ip TT CEN 1[fY VtITY NRPsin: PROFILE SQUFMT NDTXNCa FARE EXPRESSED IN FEET AND DENOTE ELEVATIONS HR9ED ON MERN LOWER LOW WATER, kICANT'S NAME :L ilX. Lu.r+�? = k, h"�` TOH pDDRE5S Description of Permitted Work: (describe briefly the Maintenance dredging of existing boat slip with beach disposal. work to be conducted at the site under the permits identified above) Description of Site: Depth range: +7' to —9.5' MLLW (describe the physical and Substrate type: Sand to mud over sand biological conditions within the survey area at the time of the survey and provide insight into variability, if known. Please Temperature: 63 F Salinity: NA Dominantflora: provide units for all numerical information). None Dominantfauna: Mussels on dock floats and pile &otic species encountered (including any other Caulerpa None species): Other site description notes: None Description of Survey Survey date and Effort: time period: Aril 9, 2009 1550-1640 (please describe the surveys Horizontal conducted including type of survey (SCUBA, remote video, etc.) and survey methods employed, date of work, and survey density (estimated percentage ),the bottom actually viewed). visibility in water: {3 ' Survey type and methods: Surveillance level SCUBA survey. Diver used a tether attached to dock piles and swam decreasingdiameter circular patterns due to poor visibility. All of the disposal P ty area and the southern portion of the Describe any limitations dredging site were viewed dry at low tide. Survey personnel: encountered during the survey efforts. Mark Sites Survey density: Over 80% Survey limitations: Poor visibility due to upper bay dredging and heavy tug and barge traffic. Other Information: (use this space to provide +0,8' MLLW flood tide additional information or references to attached maps, reports, etc.) Drawing and aerial attached Caulerpa Survey Reporting Form (version 1.2, 10/31/04) CITY OF NEWPORT .AERCH 9)Fi*+I-j r 71 ? , A FC 16 POST DREDGING COMPLETION REPORT ,rzroal The permittee shall send one (1) copy of the post -dredging report For each completed individual dredging project to the Corps and the CCC documenting compliance with all general and special conditions defined in this permit. The post -dredging report shall be sent within 45 days after completion of the complete individual dredging project authorized in this permit. The post -dredging report shall include the following information for the completed individual dredging project: 1. Permit Number: /y e1 2. Start Date: (. l 7. of / r9 1 3. Total dredged material to Beach: to Sea (LA3): 4. Mode of dredging and transpo 1.414oir2a_� (I'e / n, A 1. Completion Date: )U and method and frequency of disposal: 5. Tug or other vessel logs documenting contact with USCG MSO Long Beach before each trip to the LA-3 ocean disposal site. L � USCG Contact: Yes No; 6. Form of dredged material: Slurry X • Cohesive 7. Prouure and location where the disposal barge or scow was washed: ( QP 8. A certified report from the dredging site inspector and the captain of any tug or other vessel used to transport and dispose of dredged material at LA-3 indicating all general and special permit conditions were met. Any violations of the permit shall explained in detail. All conditioning permits were met: Yes _ No IV 9. Post -project surveys of Belgrass beds potentially ected by the dredging: 10. The post -dredging report shall be signed by a duly authorized representative of the permittee. The permittee's representative shall make the following certification: 1 cerHfij under penalhj of lazo that this document and all attachments zvere prepared under my direction or supervision in accordance With a system designed to ensure that qualified personnel properly gather and evaluate the information submitted. Based on ray inquiry of the person or persons uoho ruanage the system, or those. directly responsible for gathering the infornsation, the information submitted is, to the best of my lnzoznledge and belief, true, accurate, and complete. 1 am aware that there are significant penalties for submitting false information, including the possibility of fine and imprisonment far lcnozoing violations. Signature _.c,RMIT NO. _/—e' Z_/.� ED DREDGING APPLICATION Se>utl� CRECEIoast Region Project Location: 1513-1519 E. Bay Ave.,Newport Beach MAR 2 6 HN Latitude/Longitude: N 33 35.993 W 117 53.396 �-ALIFOI;NA Cubic Yards to be Dredged: �,00 Method of Dredging: Hydraulic Suction Nature of Dredged Material (Grain size data): Attached Disposition of Dredged Material: Used for beach replinishment within Newport Bay Method of Material. Disposit. Pipeline transport to beach restoration site. Effect of Dredging on Contiguous Bulkheading and Beaches: existing bulkheads, restores sand to depleted beaches. Reinforces and protects Project Begins: may, 2001 Project Ends: May, 2001 I Mark Sites .(Applicant/Applicant's agent), hereby certify that I have read the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers permit, RGP#54 and the California Coastal Commission permit #5-99-282 for maintenance dredging in Newport Harbor and that I will comply with all of the conditions of those permits. I will further hold the City harmless from and indemnify them against any claim for damages arising out of the exercise of these permits. In addition, I,as the applicant shall reimburse the City of Newport Beach for all attorney's fees and other costs expended by them in defending any claim, lawsuit, or judgement arising out of the activities of the applicant carried on under the authority of such permit. Lillian Lumpkin Mark Sites Applicant - Please Print 3ZO1101 Date Contractor - Please Print Signed: Applicant/Agent r� ITS Yji l I I +r I � n r-1 IFl I _ a i l 1 I I I I i I I I s9/secs I EEL GRASS INSPECTION ,,NO EEL GRASS WITHIN 15' OF EEL GRASS 3N THE PROJECT /SIGNATURE PERMIT # [ � I ntr •*ra-,,, 4 �Ac aa,a 9 �rR ��YY77 lZ a aea °.re k/ICIIJl-ry 5XE7C'H woa sarr1 kcr°, ,// II I Nswro RT �.aY C.0 lcoaw,,n yr � JaI/y Sounamg-1--norm &A,p cssed ,n dRmi one cm /w - a'sp/As below �aeor! Laver Low Wpr�e>, N1ov,...u•.aa range or- r/de 4pP vuAJ doaq rm/y. /C ✓7rr, Hor eov 44e5 are d, io6/,'sAce ,rw a<h:s secr`,oar of'New,~/ Bor I• A i 6 p Il 1� l OJECT EA { I i 'E _u _ _�_ .,, ...�.• .�...r .. _... ..�".'.m. a��,.: �� • �• r� .i • � er e...r�.m,...�,..��..;'„ ..x-ro ... >.. �..•y`r..,.:ss:e.=. CITY OF NPNPORT BEACH FIRE MARINE DEr \RTMENT HARBOR, - RMIT APPLICATION (Please print aij o!formation) 3. New Construction Revision Maintenance Dredging (10 cQ 4. Fee 3 % % '� Check No. ?3 Date -� 5. Brief Description of Proposed 6. Submit 8 1/2" x 11" Drawings (3), Include: 1). Location and dimension of proposed structure including piles and location of existing structures. on adjacent properties. 2). Location of bulkhead, pierhead and project lines. 3). Location of property lines. 4). Location of channel markers within 200 feet. 5). Lot sizes and lot numbers, if available. 6). Existing ground profile beneath proposed structure. 7). Elevation of top and bottom of bulkheads and piles with respect to M.L.L.W. 8). Area and profile of any proposed dredging with elevations showing depths with respect of M.L.L.W. 9). Any special conditions affecting the construction or affecting boating operations. 10).Complete all information required in information block, bottom of sheet. Note that the OWNER, of the property is the applicant. 11).Drawing size shall be 8 - 1/2" x 1 V. 12).Scale shall be adequate to clearly show the above information. 13).Existing structures shall be shown in light dashes. New work shall be shown in heavy solid lines. 7. Owner -Builder Declaration must be completed (o reverse side of this sheet) 8. Applicant's/Agent's Signature: /` /l Date: 3 K Q I_ Joint Permittee Signature (If applicable): Date: 9. Work can begin once the City has received evidence of the following additional approvals and you have been notified to proceed. If you begin prior to the notice you will be in violation of the Newport Beach Municipal Code and subject to penalties. 10. Your permit will not be final until we have conducted an on site inspection once construction is completed as per Municipal Code, Section 17.24, if we have not been contacted for a final inspection. OFFICE USE ONLY Approval in Concept. Date Approval of the City of Newport Beach Council. Date Approval of the Army Corps of Engineers. Date Approval of the California Coastal Commission. Date Approval of the City's Public Works Department. Date Approval of the City's Building Department. Date Approval of County of Orange. Date Electrical and/or plumbing permit (Building Department) Date Issued. (Permit is stamped drawing) Date Site Inspection. (call 644-3043 for appointment) Date Site Re -Inspection Date Conditions: PERMIT NO. %�-/9'/f DREDGING APPLICATION Project Location: 1513-1519 E. Bay Ave.,Newoort Beach Latitude/Longitude: N 33 35.993 W 117 53.396 Cubic Yards to be Dredged: Method of Dredging: Hydraulic suction Nature of Dredged Material (Grain size data): Attached Disposition of Dredged Material: Used for beach replinishment within Newport Method of Material Disposition: Pipeline- transport to beach restoration site. Effect of Dredging on Contiguous Bulidieading and Beaches: Reinforces and protects existing bulkheads, restores sand to depleted beaches. Project Begins: May, 2001 Project Ends; _ �yf 2001 I hark sites .(Applicant/Applicant's agent), hereby certify that I havd read the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers permit, RGP#54 and the California Coastal Commission permit 05-99-282 for maintenance dredging in Newport Harbor and that I will complywithall of the conditions of those permits. I will ffwther hold the City harmless from and indemnify them against any claim for damages arising out of the exercise of these permits. In addition, I,as the applicant shall reimburse the City of Newport Beach for all attorney's fees and other costs expended by them in defending any claim, lawsuit, or judgement arising out of the activities of the applicant carried on under the authority of such permit. Lillian Lumpkin Applicant - Please Print 3/01/01 _ Date Mark Sites Contractor- Please Print Signed:.— �---- Applicant/Agent j �`• i � si •,if hi . H7- 4e3 --4— ,5r .Ts }llj _� �� { I P a I ✓: (# i Od.^fx Q O (p AApM� �(� no.�/r,i d J 1 rO 166.//1 a R/ I L I NJ 16 Y 5 X E T &.. l-i bYaaF D6)TT1 "� �Y'aor NawvagT DAY CA4 Jr.RNIA Sau.nd n95 oPa B,rAr-e ss ed Jn aWy/ and Jana d,v dep de,s befow ^'�fcon Cm avar Lam( !n/�ad:Tr. .YJA,vJowam tany� o{ lldu App rcrgJ.mr®+�a/j( lC ++:a�>< Mardor inns ' are ealad/r'sArd ✓n da+s sw. Af.oy onv,�fe wbe+ro..f boy: Sd� ' 1`t . ✓I '1��,1� � '1��4'—^. "d1.0 � i �'S._r'1 j I':��I' f i { �' ! ' GPI L•-� �' ; �II�:, i, ✓ f ,% 1 I , � a' i'—— :V c. 'I EEL GRASS INSPECTION ENO EEL GRASS WITH 15' OF PROJECT f EEL GRASS IN THE PROJECT ARCH ! � JJIUItl PERMIT # ,STATE OF CALIFORNIA -THE RESOURCES AGENCY GRAY DAVIS Govemor CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION South Coast Area Office 200 Oceangate, Suite 1000 Long Beach, CA 90802-4302 (562) 590-5071 March 29, 2001 Mr. Tony Melum Division of Harbor Resources City of Newport Beach P.O. Box 1768 Newport Beach, CA 92658-8915 Subject: Condition Compliance — Coastal Development Permit 5-99-282 & Conformance with Consistency Certification CC-078-99 Dear Mr. Melum: Commission staff have received information submitted as evidence of compliance with Coastal Development Permit 5-99-282 and/or as evidence of conformance with Consistency Certification CC-078-99 for the following sites in the City of Newport Beach: City Harbor Permit # s ;6310;)1&1 ;634 Date Received Beach Disposal? (Yes/No) Ocean Disposal? (Yes/No) 175-630 Via Lido Nord 03/26/200.1 Yes No 110-1220 1216-1222 E. Balboa Ave. 03/26/2001 Yes No 115-328 328, 332, 334, 336 Buena Visa. Blvd. 03/26/2001 Yes Yes 109-201 2018 E. Bay Ave. 03/26/2001 Yes No 511513-1519 E. Bay Ave. 03/26/2001 Yes No 522525 r25 Ocean Blvd. 03/26/2001 Yes No 9 Beacon Bay Community Association Docks 03/26/2001 Yes No Commission staff have reviewed the information submitted and determined that the above referenced dredging event conforms with Consistency Certification CC-078-99 and that no further federal consistency review is necessary from the Commission for the dredging component of the project. In addition, the proposed beach disposal has been reviewed and found by the Executive Director to be consistent with Special Conditions 1, 2, and 3 of Coastal Development Permit 5-99-282. No further review is necessary from the Commission for the beach disposal components of the project. Please be advised that only the project described in the materials submitted for the sites listed above have been found to conform with Consistency Certification CC-078-99 and/or conform with the terms and conditions of Coastal Development Permit 5-99-282. Any change in the project may cause it to lose its status as consistent with CC-078-99 and/or CDP 5-99-282. This certification is based on information provided by the recipient of this letter. If, at a later date, this information is found to be incorrect or incomplete, this letter will become invalid, and any development occurring at that time must cease until a new determination regarding conformance with CC-078-99 and/or CDP 5-99-282 is obtained. Also, your submittal received on March 26, 2001, included two dredging applications (Harbor Permit #s 130-2692 and 109-191 1) for dredging located at 2692 Bayshore Drive and 1911 & DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY LOS ANGELES DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS P.O BOX 532711 LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90053-2325 kr: 1rr REPLY TO April 10, 2001 Office of the Chief Regulatory Branch City of Newport Beach Attention: TonyMelum 3300 Newport Boulevard P.O. Box 1768 Newport Beach, California 92658-8915 Dear Mr. Melum: This is in reply to your application (File No. 200100817-ESL) dated March 21, 2001, for a Department of the Army Permit to conduct maintenance dredging, per RGP 54, in Newport Bay, Newport Beach, Orange County, California.:This letter, authorizes dredging at seven sites ;within Newport Bay (see_below). Site Address Cubic Yards Square feet Beach Dis osal Ocean Dis osal 630 634 Via Lido Nord 240 beach 2450 Yes No 1216-1222 E. Balboa Ave. 280 beach 3000 Yes No 328 332 334 336 Buena Vista Blvd. 385 580 4800 2400 2400 4000 Yes (385 cy) Yes (580 cy) 2018 E. Bav Ave. 120 600 Yes No ,1513-1519 E. Bay Ave. 300 1800 Yes No 2525 Ocean Blvd. 500 3750 Yes No Beacon Bay Community Association Docks 500 1350 Yes No Totals: 2905 26,550 2325 cy 580 c Based on the information you have provided, the Corps of Engineers has determined that your proposed activity complies with the terms and conditions of Regional General Permit (RGP) No. 54. Your original submittal of March 26, 2001, included two dredging applications for dredging located.at.2692 Bayshore Drive and 1911/1913 E. Bay Ave. These locations have not yet been approved by the. California Coastal Commission and will be addressed in a subsequent letter from our office. J j/1 d -2- As long as you comply with the general pemvt conditions of RGP No. 54, an individual permit is not required. This letter of verification is valid until July 24, 2005, when RGP No. 54 will expire. A general permit does not grant any property rights exclusive privileges. Also, it does not authorize any injury to the property or rights of others or authorize interference with any existing or proposed Federal project. Furthermore, it does not obviate the need to obtain other Federal, State, or local authorizations required by law. Thank you for participating in our regulatory program. if you have any questions, please contact Erik S. Larsen of my staff at 213-452-3417. Sincerely, IM 6zil" 6- Mark Durham Chief, South Coast Section Regulatory Branch EPLV TO ATTENTION OF: Office of the Chief Regulatory Branch Mr. Wes Armand City of Newport Beach P.O. Box 1768 Newport Beach, California DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY LOS ANGELES DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS P.O BOX 532711 LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90053-2325 92658-8915 January 26, 1999 SUBJECT: NOTICE TO PROCEED (File No. 1999-15169-YJC) Dear Mr. Armand: Reference is made to your letter dated January 11, 1999 in which you submitted on behalf of Ms. Lillian Lumpkin who resides at 1519 E. Balboa Blvd., Newport Beach, a notification for the maintenance dredging of 280 cubic yards of sand and silt material by hydraulic suction and disposal of the dredged material on the adjacent beach. Based on the furnished information, we have determined that the proposed maintenance dredging activity complies with the terms and conditions of Permit No. 89-211- GS provided that Ms. Lumpkin's contractor does not exceed the maximum dredging design depth of -5 feet MLLW with a maximum allowable overdepth of -1 foot MLLW. If you have any questions, please contact Jae Chung of my staff at (213) 452-3292. Please refer to this letter and 1999-15169-YJC in your reply. Sincerely, 0 � Mark Durham Chief, South Coast Section Enclosure(s) HARBOR . =T APPLICATION C;tv of Ne port Beach Fire & Marine Department Please Print: (Front & Back) Lillian Lumpkin 1519 E Bay Ave 673-6036 1. App icant Property Owner Address Te ep one 1513-1519 E. Bay Ave 3. New Construction✓ Revision Maintenance Dredging 4. Fee i �� ✓ Check No . 2_ / Date /- 12- s� 5. Brief Description of Proposed Work: Maintenance Dredging 6. Suixmit Drawings (3) Include: 1.Location and dimension of proposed structure'2_. Location of bulkhead 3. Location of property lines and lot size 4. Location of channel markers within ..200 feet of proposed project 5:.Existing..ground -profile, and area and profile of any-dredginCr with elevations showing depth relative to. MLLW 6. Elevations of top and bottom of piles and. bulkheads with respect to. MLLW.7. A�iy special conditions affecting the constructicn-or affecting boating operations., 7. Owner Builder/Contractor Declaration/ orniati'M 7., Applicant' a/Agent's Signature, Date 1-12-99 . 8. Work can begin once the.•City has received, evidence of the,. following additional.:approvals.:and y, have been notified to proceed: OFFICE USE ONLY Approval in Concept. Date Approval of the.City of Newport Beach Council: Date Approval of .the Army Corps of Engineers. Date Approval of the California Coastal Commission. Date.. Approval of the City's Public Works Department. Date. Approval of the City's Building Department. Date County of Orange. Date Issued. (Permit is stamped drawing) Date Site Ins ection.(call 644-3043 for appointment) Date Site Re -Inspection. Date Conditions: OMM-BUILDER DECLARATION I hereby affirm that I am .exempt from the contractor's license law for the following reasons:.(Sec.7031d.51 Business and Professions Code) Any City or County which requiressa permit to construct, alter, improve, demolish, or repair any prior to its issuance, .also requires the applicant for such permit to file a signed statement that he is licensed pursuant to the provision of the Contractors License Law (Chapter 9, commencing with Section 7000) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code) or that he is exempt therefrom and the basis for the alleged exemption. Any violation of section 7031.5 by any applicant for a permit subjects the applicant to a civil pernalty for not more than five hundred dollars ($500).. I, as owner of the property, or my employees with wages as their sole compensation, will do thework, and the structure is not intended or offered for sale (Sec: 7044, Business and Professions Code: The Contractor's License Law does, not apply to an owner of property who builds.or improves thereon, and who does such work himself or through.his own employees, provided that such. improvements .are not.intended-or .offered for sale.. If, however, the building or improvement is sold within one yrovi�ng f.. coiletion, the.owner-builder will have the burden P that he dial not build or improve for.. the pYupose . for sale . ) I, as owner of the property , am.exciusively contracting ;i—q=icensed contractors to construct the project (Sec. 7044, Business and Professions Code: The Contractor's License Law does. not aapppply to an owner of property who builds or improves thereon,. and who contracts for such pro'ects with a Contractor'(s). License .. pursuant to the Contractor's License Law). I am exempt under Sec. of Business and yro-yessions Code for this reason: owner signature Contractor Mark Sites Date Telephone 675-1 071 Address P.O. Box 498, Balboa Island, CA 92662 /HAZ 460235 97021127 A License Class State Board No. City License No. LICENSED CDNTRACTOR'S DECLARATION I hereby affirm that I am licensed under provisions of Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 7000) of D'p1sn 3 of the Business and Professsions Code, and ce ull forDate e and fect. Contractor Signature %�' _ I t - _ � ram• - _.�.I y C 044 . a JV VICfIV1TY SKETCH ~f"v'ry i 1 Cam. artl• I, Pro i Ie Scale•• I .,,. Na w.O1YI ®AY CAG If OYNIA Jff�f ' Soup d�n9s wJ ..fpve ss sd in !gel ;ond dno J� dap./A3 below Msan Gofver lew "Arr. MOee� ' ronye of /ide Opprutimo%/p /O f1eL .Ywbor 'Gates fhiE Ora as4ob/>'Shed .n -sec/.M of.Ve✓p ri 60y I .. .. ` P •"'7r�1 I 1 I�' /j 1 LI � 1 I (3oy I Ave hue 7 FS Tjj Rm m ,Zia L, 11 7- g e41c• bo. ®4vd. ICWT&Aerag OfITE jREDGING APPLICATION Project Location: 1513-1519 E. Bay Ave. Cubic Yards to be Dredged: 280 Method of Dredging: Hydraulic Suction Nature of Dredged Material: Sand/Silt Disposition of Dredged Material: Beach restoration Method of Material Disposition: Pipeline transport to beach restoration site. Turbidity Control Method: .Reduced discharge velocity Effect of dredging. on..contiguous bulkheading and beaches Proms and reinforces existing seawalls and bay beaches. I, Mark .Sites ,. hereby .state that I have -read' the U. S. Army (print name) Corps.of Engineers permit for maintenance: dredging in Newport Harbor; the City. of Newport Beach and Orange .County Harbors, Beaches and .Parks District (if applicable) permit for: maintenance dredging and that I accept all the provisions therein. Additionally I guarantee that the proposed dredging will not occur because of -any altering of existing use of the affected zone. Lillian Lum kin App scant -type name 1-11-99 (Date Mark Site Contractor -type name Signed:7��e/� Contractor s Representative .. . ' v ., r. .I,tN o •, „ . J O O 1 CIfIY1 w rt, •11. nQy,�.y VICINITY SKETCH Qs~oar bAr, CK II PQNIA Soundings we a.cpreea�d rn !iol ;oAd almode dapl/.a be/ow ASFon Lorvwr Low "vlrr, Motr..Law e.p. aF bV., Qp/rOFIMp la/,v /o rlel. Harbor /,met are e. Jo b//shed rn fti:s Srcf,., of'.Ne✓p rf 6oj: P' - A 1 3s• � 14 at 1 1 '.lr' It3ay' Ave tLAI- (s eci) I i3 !.S r1m lJ Scgl -50' g CL (oboa Blvd. (caw,crp.c t�gTE'9f�r7/; 47-t,17AIrIC OARIAaA -THOMPSON-fLOA-T-Afi-ON-;—INCORPOnA-TEi)- 1615 Monrovia Avenue I Costa Mesa, CA 92627 (711) 615-2812 A Telex 678308 THOMPSON CSMA Flange width 3' on all 1 1 sides FIGURE 2- FLOATATION UNIT DIMENSIONS mene I one (inl Weight ( lbs) Buoyancy ( lba with plywood In water Model A B c top cover per Inch Totf;1 11.17 66 36 16 96 68.95 1,103.2 1.1113 Go 36II 20 103 68.95 1,379,0 1119 Y 63 3V In go 68.95 973.9 1129 51 601 11311 a.1 1.01 84.06 1,187.6 1130 18 I; 122 102. 7 i 1,451.2 1131 91 96 161, 1230 7-4- 1,657.7 1231 ff'96 in 16 167 110.0-1, 2,259,0 1130 102.71 2,376.9 1131 � 1 96 18 25 198 110.01 3,519.8 P41WIl No. 0 270 329 s � L A— i at tran5fer 7 l �l f Clr.,/to ui spl.rul -No rk Ang frtrLngth____.__.._ 21M-lbs n c Q rxpa r g:L jrN i i d 2%llp ----------------- _TQ-tal, vo A*! i tforc e_.._200,880 Ibis 196 1 D2 jj_ W A -Ai _strengtA., 162 000 At '9trese Did, _Ini ti fa-i acklag -for Q 0.. _.__10. 550 lbs 450 or t�plcal, Carr & HARBOR PRECAST COMPANY LONG BEACH. CALIFORNIA PRESTRESSED CONCRETE PILES 14n 54UAFg o T 1 0 vi AFT KO� ED ......... . 11--_ D\VG No. MAILING AODPFSS KQ h •✓� /syr APPROVED BY: DATE OCHD El ENGR COUNCIL PUBLIC WORKS DEPT. ❑ ESCROW INSPECTICA4 CONDITIONS: WtV 1A1I1LITY PERMNX ELEPHC J. F CHECK NO DATE is5�/ 2 _0 76 APPLICATION IS HERESY MADE FOR A HARBOR ERMR20 CONSTRUCTIREVISE A,/ V�OLpC LU cf cL 7 AT THE ABOVE LOCATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE CITY OF BEWPOPT B�CB PERMR POyCIEB qNO IyE.A1Ng71 �µ1N0 COMPANY DATED S V/ ///I Q /-1 91 9��jT�P`Ul- DATE /_ —11 15 - -- --I SIGNATURE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH. CALIF. W% FORM e8-1010 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH P.O. BOX 1768, NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92658.8915 September 14, 1995 Swift Slip 500 30th Street Newport Beach, CA 92663 Attention: Pete Swift Re: Lumpkin dock. at 1519 East Bay Dear Pete: To resolve the current situation at the Lumpkin property, it would be necessary for the submittal for a Maintenance Permit indicating the as built dimensions of the current structure. We would also need plans and engineering for the work done on the pier so it can be reviewed and approved by our Public Works Department. If you have any questions regarding the above, please contact me at (714) 644-3044. Sincerely, Tony Melum Deputy chief 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH P.O. BOX 1768, NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92658-8915 August 29, 1995 Keith Lumkin 1519 East Bay Ave. Newport Beach, Ca. 92661 Re: Pier Permit 0109-1519-1 Dear Mr. Lumkin: Chapter 17 of the City of Newport Beach Municipal Code requires all construction/maintenance work on structures over City Tidelands receive a Harbor Permit prior to commencing work. This permit is issued once all the necessary approvals have been obtained by the applicant. A field inspection revealed that a groin seawall has been replaced along the eastern boundary of your property and work is in progress to your pier. There is no evidence of an application for the above mentioned work and therefore you are in violation of the section 17 of the Municipal Code. In addition, the pier walkway now has a width which extends to the property line and does not have the required 5' setback. Please call this office to discuss this matter further. Ask to speak to Tony Melum, Deputy Chief, Marine Division, or myself. Sincerel ,) 4 �/v es d Harbor Inspector 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach NAME APPROVED BY: DATE l OCHD ENGR Iy��/ GJ COUNCIL PUBLIC WORKS DEPT ESCR ESCROW ❑ INSPECTION El SPECIAL CONDITIONS: DRESS OF PROPOSED FACILITY 1519 r Bav Av FEE HEREBY MADE FOR A HARBOR PERMIT TO AT THE ABOVE LOCATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE CRY OF NEWPORT BEACH PERMIT POLICIES AND THE ATTACHED DRAWING BY ms DATED 12/15/95 DATE w SIGNATURE CRY OF NEWPORT BEACH, CALIF. -/ 5/9' DATE /1i/Z -QS COMPANY W%FORM WIDIO DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY LOS ANGELES DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS 300 NORTH LOS ANGELES STREET LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90012 EPLY TO ATTENTION OF: Office of the Chief Regulatory Branch Mr. Tony Melum Tidelands Administrator City of Newport Beach P.O. Box 1768 Newport Beach, California 92659-1768 March 12, 1996 SUBJECT: NOTICE TO PROCEED (File No. 96-00152-MFS) Dear Mr. Melum: Reference is made to your letter dated January 9, 1995 in which you submitted on behalf of California Recreation at 2930 Bayshore Drive, a notification for the maintenance dredging of 140 cubic yards of sand and silt material by hydraulic suction and disposal of the dredged material on the adjacent beach. Based on the furnished information, we have determined that the proposed maintenance dredging activity complies with the terms and conditions of Permit No. 89-211- GS provided that the California Recreations' contractor does not exceed the maximum dredging design depth of -5 feet MLLW with a maximum allowable overdepth of -1 foot MLLW. Thank you for participating in our regulatory program. If you have any questions, please contact Mark F. Sudol of my staff at (213) 894-0353. Sincerely Mark Durham Chief, South Coast Section Regulatory Branch Enclosure P. 4IT NO. DREDGING APPLICATION Project Location: 1519 E. Bay Ave. - 1515 E. Bay Ave. Cubic Yards to be Dredged: 200 Method of Dredging:_ Hydraulic suction Nature of Dredged Material: Sand / silt Disposition of Dredged Material: Sand replenishment for existing bay beaches Method of Material Disposition: Pipeline transport to beach restoration site Turbidity Control method: -Reduced discharge velocity Effect of dredging on contiguous bulkheading and beaches Restores sand to depleted beaches Sand fill reinforces and protects existing bulkheads. I, Mark Sites , hereby state that I have read the U. S. Army (print name) Corps of Engineers permit for maintenance dredging in Newport Harbor, the City of. ;Newport Beach and Orange County Harbors,Beaches and Parks District (if applicable) permit for maintenance dredging and that I accept all the provisions therein. Additionally I guarantee that the proposed dredging will not occur because of any altering of existing use of the affected zone. Lillian Lumpkin (Applicant -type name 12/15/95 (Date) Intraocastal Dredging Contractor. -type name) Signed: on 4 tractor s Representative C/TY Nxyc0,Pr '�ACN�v • �r3n�S.:.1 �'l r' 3I ,�'I%� to _ ;,�y� S�%'" oot pi- n•i +'~ .,. .. :. TQ ♦a doe 'cl� •• 0 IA I4 c Orbs 7D 4,Lr N /�': ya;mn_ t VECf.h11 iY SuET'CF-1',Aorr �..r H•Nooer 9AY; CAL I/OAH,A�. w Sovndngs 'or. VA'aparred rn /.e/ onAl<'dwrA�s,; +dip/ha WOW Mean Lower 6oN M.fp'/� iMOthwr/ rdnye oF'/Yde aprruxrnro>✓dy /b�ie.f ,�+r0/f0%"/iD' �!: vre es�o6%r'shsd i%r phis , aeefie.r or'Ne f,:0or E E I (J 5. Bur", EAG Z. /NF onv do YA [f17 0 l q ' OAourds "� LoT /D BLX, 2 C ODIii' GovTRACre.r /('ri ?iQ,�x"m /5-9 o IEWPORT BEACH HAF`0,OR PERMIT PERMISSION IS H'c"' RY (iRI�N1E0 TO C MAINTAIN THE FACILIT+ SHOYYN ON THE R AT THE SITE THE HARSOR INDICATE". BUBdECT TONH THE ANV SPECIAL CO D TION9pL181IDREC IS NOT TRANSFERABLE WITHOUTTHE WRIT THE CFIV HARBOR COOROINA7T)R OR C11 RIGHTS GIVEN UNDER 1 HIB PENMFF ARE F AND THIS PERMIT AY BE T IN ACCORDANCE y jH�TM T7 I PERMIT NO. DATE AND %J NO APPROVED BY: DATE APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE F R HARBOR PERMIT O1 CONSTRUCTIREVISE AvSi. 4X� rJ9 AT THE ABOVE LOCATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE CITY OF if ENDR NEWPORT BEACH PERMIT POLI NO THE ATTACHED DRAW N COUNCIL ❑ L 7 BY _ tl�/ /JSS� COMPANY PUBLIC WORKS ` • — DATED / r f DEPT. ❑ ESCRO� DATE SIGNATURE dxvq SPECIAL CONDITIONS: A BUYERS' NAME(S) rPPROVED BY: %_ f DATE ❑ OCHD ENG ❑ COUNSIL L . :..:. .,:..�.:..,,,....;.... ; ❑ PUBLIC WORKS PUBLIC DE PT. ❑ ESCROW I CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH, CALIF. WK FORM W1010 ADDRESS OF FACILITY: A519 EA41 BAY PERMIT WL "if CA 109-151I-/ TELEPHO E HECK N0. DATE tales EHt `•' <'iN (APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE TO TRANSFER HARBOR PERMIT SELLERS' NAMES) BUYERS' NAME(S) (ABOVE NAMES TO BE TYPED) _ S NATURE OF SELLER ,:,y�:��, SIGNATURE OF BUYER i1tr1 n J. ©lean Keith C,Laapkin SIGNATURE OF SELLER T 'SIGNATURE OF BUYER Susan M. Q1saa Lillian R. Luapkin INSPECTION SIGNATURE OF JOINT OWNER ❑ "' `/ �APPLICATION APPROVED (DATE) z �7 ❑ CITY HA969R coo INA TO a""' SPECIAL CONDITIONS: THIS PERMIT IS REVOCABLE BYTHE CI Y COUNCIL IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 17 OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE. �I CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH. CALIF. Wx FORM 46.1013 111, STATE OF CALIFORNIA—THE RESOURCES AGENCY PETE WILSON Gowmor CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION SOUTH COAST AREA 245 W. BROADWAY, STE. 380 P.O. BOX 1450 0 LONG BEACH, CA 90802-4416 (310) 59a5071 Date:__. 3-21-94 Waiver # 5-94-0 NOTICE OF PERMIT WAIVER EFFECTIVENESS Applicant: Keith Lumpkin, Sr Please be advised that Waiver # 5-94-039 , which was reported to the Commission on March 17, 1994 became effective as of that date. Any deviation from the application and plans on file in the Commission office may require a coastal development permit for the entire project. Should you have any questions, please contact our office. PETER M. DOUGLAS Executive Director By: Title: Staff Anal Pst E6: 4/88 1464F JA/lm STATE OF CALIFORNIA—THE RESOURCES AGENCY PETE WILSON, Gowm r CALIFORNIA COASTA L_ COMMISSION SOUTH COAST AREA 245 W. BROADWAY, STE. 3B0 P.O. Box 1450 LONG BEACH, CA M02-4416 ;310) 590-5071 TO: Karen Torkildson Swift Slip 500 30th Street Newport Beach, CA 92663 1.February SUBJECT: Maiver of Coastal Development Permit Requirement/De Minimis Developments —Section 30624.7 of the Coastal Act Based on your project plans and information provided in your permit application for the development described below, the Executive Director of the Coastal Commission hereby waives the requirement for a Coastal Development Permit pursuant to Section 13238.1, Title 14, California Administrative Code. If, at a later date, this information is found to be incorrect or the plans revised, this.decision will become invalid; and, any development occurring must cease until a coastal development permit is obtained or any discrepancy is resolved in writing. WAIVER #5-94-039 APPLICANT: Keith Lumpkin. Sr. LOCATION: 1519 East Bay Avenue. City of Newport Beach. Coup of Orange PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT: Revision of an existing dock. The proposed dock will be "U" shaped and will be 501x21.51 in overall size. RATIONALE: The proposed development is located in coastal waters and is therefore not an exempt class of development. The proposed development has received clearance from the Regional Water Quality Control Board and will not exceed the U.S. Pierhead line. Navigation in the adjacent harbor channel thus will not be impeded. The proposed development therefore will not result in significant adverse impacts to coastal access, coastal resources, or public recreation opportunities, will not prejudice the ability of the City of Newport Beach to prepare a local coastal program in conformity with Chapter Three of the Coastal Act, and is consistent with past Commission actions in the area and Chapter Three policies of the Coastal Act. This waiver will not become effective until reported to the Commission at their March 15-18. 1994 , meeting and the site of the proposed development has been appropriately noticed, pursuant to 13054(b) of the Administrative Code. The enclosed Notice Card shall remain posted at the site until the waiver has been validated and no less than seven days prior to the Commission hearing. If four (4) Commissioners object to this waiver of permit requirements, a coastal development permit will be r quired. by: CHARLES DAMM South Coast District Director cc: Commissioners/File 1223F:jta 0061 i Sim 1 1,��v�_ .�oQ Ilr„�Y� in � �' wr..a.•� /\4r, '� W p O � T O -i r,rq III 4sa.�, Q BAi1pA 1 V!'d %ltavyal�e�i: "'. rff� nm •e. r. n/-.- �. e" e�c4A l ? .. GPPa D flo II v1 c,.&r(TY SkE TIC -zw Awry � CAF✓ Nm we Wtr BAY. CAL 1F04MIA ��, ---� � JBYPY So Un d,ngs are expr,earsed in Feerf end", be/own.aQnrr Lawev iowm Hm�Beepvp,d�®trwp�a. ron9� of fr•e% aprru&erns doAp^ /p i�Bq agWQF'6dgsm"ir7 arr ralab%r'shad ,n phis sere✓u®m eekg°Nsanv .�':;6 - ._ 3 a /as' rTrs' r6 , i� Q is 1 r 1 Z"ot'TrobPA1410New lmkgorf A p; 1�nPas dip ' ° - �- iIY._._,. i / (I . ( i ' mac'\ i !C. -�,,• '�+��6�'��/ �A'PCL .. /34 V qv'� V/1 c>I t % (� w ( In tj�_-_l Ud�It�(<1�° A�. xs__ ark Gar 0 / CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH HARBOR PERMIT PERMISSION IS HEREBY GRANTED TO CONSTRUCT AND MAINTAIN THE FACILITY SHOWN ON THE REVERSE HEREOF, AT THE SITE INDICATED, SUBJECT TO THE PROVISIONS OF ::_.............. THE HARBOR-PERMR POLICIES OF NEWPORT BEACH AND ANY SPECIAL CONDITIONS LISTED HEREON. THIS PERMIT IS NOT TRANSFERABLE WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE CRY HARBOR COORDINATOR OR CITY COUNCIL THE RIGHTS GIVEN UNDER THIS PERMIT ARE PERMISSIVE ONLY AND THIS PERMIT MAY BE RE,_I(OKED BY THE CITY COUNCIL IN ACCORDANCE WIT,.T,1AT6dE 77 OF THE .Mp y1cl COOS PERMIT NO. DATE ' s 7 lu :'♦fill.;~ �°Ck:�i C:Yr'.i:t'i__:"'��0.�1 n'iL �_/-:. MARINE DEPAPU7�1,jr 14 CRY MU 30 19W#OnT SLY1 UWAti ILUK CA Ae 64 V, llv� VA eA I E. /5')'? F=. FEB 2 1994 1r Q VICIMITY SKETCH W"r -lorry Vci 1 9411 �Jm-poxrr DAY, CusjroaNiA sloundnqs are e'r'OiCvseci 1. r,.l and OrAfflave Lyflp "'J be/OW Meon 40WOr LOW 1110"dle. MVXJ.w✓,n To /w/'Y /0 Ora" *Yap&*, /,;I es are c vohlt'shff /;7 Ith's secpl'*n Ofrmcw'~'4 Bob. & V. 10P" TEe. 7 t /IVE 0 4.1 tw:� p1r- I A/ mouth coast Distzict Offlae APPROC 9 4 JJJ ]Permit j,TO ,�j . ...... N4 Pyl V) �ear- /0 Jfec, y ZeAcr IcvA1r-vAcrcw 5'VJI,`T OArel' Rr ( a i CAA r rA .7 w ��F/t.rlll"Jrti nq' �`" r $, {� r��5$lA :;i F.✓�'. I i r�r.. a.,r �� •P're ° 4: T� 0 /�<�oA .�� 1 i ��,� i 1�� II I ^�._, /, Du•✓. ..__��s`D._�t___—� ire �P° n�D7 D g 'fit � VICINITY SKETCH wui�in1 Nx wD,o Nr DAY CAL If ORNIA �e�4 �`i69.. V• ,.....».. _ ___ Yf t+� l,VI ert w rne--rtrrw�r rs Sa�at�y.apix��,r�ysi� ;y �' S"cv�I den95 ore aXpre ased /n po r><yr�oAd,�eV k`� I' W44Wfi� IY� Y de,v r 11 J L'C/Ow IL{ con La war Low Wpjp/. q oppr•ox/no�a/ ' % sec0 oN of SM r r u a PAK M-yt'p �F 1.. `t'7 i✓L- a 7 ov— :`S�V�t� k �a a° I u j . t. , I �72 t't NO Sc Cl w 1 � iyad,j AsBr'.,tt. ix e 1 t AMf LuNIM iV S Cj ff. . Oky o �.1 7- 1v4rAP1POqrj&A-,4cL1 I (Pfi A � T i I II O i' S CIILv. VICI IV, TY SkEiCN wFtF dfFy✓ i QArP f Nk wrwp py- j3M 1� CAC dF'O ANrA j I.A Souno4ngs or1 adaiersad 'in i'maJ:" on„c'.;�'; dIp 1 be/ow Mear7 haw, Low Wofern,:-�; YloYhaa:ir.:.. j .. ran y>c of" ,�r•�e app r•�zlrno Y /O dk( �Idrboi^/�i7r5 are:.alab/r:,had in phis ,.3're7linn uf've wrapPf. Bob- l�t.+JlCJ�, x c r �f 4° d.. r ,----026,SU Pier ,+c, I V? H } f �Er I -•./Q fa /i Qo.{F :,i I �J ( C - �..._- •-- Ca.vra,ae ro.m r F`7-'.i®:g�' d;'�5' :g.� PERMIT NO. DREDGING APPLICATION Project Location: 1519 F_ Rav Cubic Y4rds to be Dredged: 200 cubic yards Method of Dredging: Hydraulic Suction Nature of Dredged Material: Sand / Silt Disposition of Dredged Material: on adjacent beach Method of Material Disposition: pioetine Turbidity Control Method: Turbidity curtain as required Effect of dredging on contiguous bulkheading, and beaches ReshnraR beach and reinforces the bulkhead I, Lorenzo C. Miller , hereby state that I have read the U. S. Army (print name) Corps of Engineers permit for maintenance dredging in Newport Harbor, the City of Newport Beach and Orange County Harbors,Beaches and Parks District (if applicable) permit for maintenance dredging and that I accept all the provisions therein. Additionally I guarantee that the proposed dredging will not occur because of any altering of existing use of the affected zone. Kith Lum kin Sr. Shellmaker Inc. App scant -type name Contractor -type name) June 9, 1994 (Date) Signed. C ntractor s president Representative C/ T Y o� /VFiYpo Pr.., ��'ACh/ •, a f r 1 •o n /rl� 41v/11 VG •\ N P �e / 11 , �� II qua J �♦ may: Q � .a�bt •1 I' I ~ �I✓ � II ' `I _. � � �f� !I •II' � ��,� Iwt`• 'fie t �N J w Greg a Ctrer/ ///:.ryo° VICIIVfiY SKETCH doo�&Nlwnoar 9A Y, CAC I{eANIA 3- Pct�P �` SoUn dings ore r.fp/ersd e(n ire¢ pqe/ `NMip¢ f +dep ?oh be/ow Mroq Yowr� Cew Wo¢tn,YJa,r,.rvi`` rc>ny y of Lida OpProx/rno>lr/y ID +rJ.r c H4+bo`0", "i Ore aaioG%r'shed ,:. �h/s,secr<ie,� ofNaw`rf oy+ f N�tv yl�e 7 s /ve FT I r jx�cl>7ihs 'lh'HM>NtWlacrxk-tod � 'YY�:, F I �1gpPc, If I- AT .. _.11w I i %�•5. 6Ulf EA4 L. Wr _ i I I 6 iy I ; NC- I S i , . �. • t SCR�C z r�,'Gj � �a '� /Ssl y �vt YA N i` r ;I\ Y C'AlJTS LUNraK)NLZ �D �LA<• vn iASJS/ /Am ,err &je CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH HARBOR PERMIT 551om IS HEREBY GRANTED TO CONSTRUCT AND AIN THE FACIUTY SHOWN ON THE REVERSE HEREOF Qkw mnlrAirn. qunjscT To THE 13ROVISIOns OF AND THIS PERMIT MAY BE IN ACCORDANCE CITY PERMIT NO. FERMI 14mm wwwr to OR'MOK fWATERIAL VEING NAULrDTo,qr,A ------- P DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY LOS ANGELES DISTRICT. CORPS OF ENGINEERS P.O. BOX 2211 LOS ANGELES. CALIF04NIA W052 2225 April 4, 1994 REPLY TO ATTENTION OF Office of the Chief Regulatory Branch Mr. Keith Lumpkin c/o Swift Slip Dock and Pier Builders 500 30th Street Newport Beach, California 92663 Dear Mr. Lumpkin: Reference is made to your request of January 26, 1994 (COE File No. 94-379-BH). Under the provisions of Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act of March 3, 1899 (33 U.S.C. 403), you are hereby authorized to revise an existing slip in Newport Harbor at 1519 East Bay, Balboa, California. The improvements are shown on the enclosed drawings and consist of: 1. Expansion of an existing float, and the addition of a 50-foot by 21.5-foot slip. The owner or authorized responsible official must sign and date all copies of this Letter of Permission (LOP) indicating that he/she agrees to the work as described and to comply with all conditions. One of the signed copies of this Letter of Permission must be returned to the Corps of Engineers (a pre -addressed envelope is enclosed for your convenience). Notice of the commencement of the activity must reach this office at least 10 days before the activity actually starts. Please use the enclosed card. Sincerely, Jo n A. Gill Chief, Regulatory Branch (DA ) DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY LOS ANGELES DISTRICT. CORPS Of ENGINEERS P.O. BOX 27I I LOS ANGELES. CALIFORNIA M52 232S July 29, 1994 REPLY TO ATTENTION OF Office of the Chief Regulatory Branch Mr. Tony Melum Tidelands Administrator City of Newport Beach P.O. Box 1768 Newport Beach, California 92659-1768 SUBJECT: NOTICE TO PROCEED (No. 94-894-BH) Dear Mr. Melum: Reference is made to your letter dated July 21, 1994 in which you submitted on behalf of Mr. Keith Lumpkin Sr. at 1519 E. Bay, a notification for the maintenance dredging of 200 cubic yards of sand and silt material by hydraulic suction and disposal of the dredged material to an adjacent beach reclamation area. Based on the furnished information, we have determined that the proposed maintenance dredging activity complies with the terms and conditions of Permit No. 89-211-GS provided that Mr. Lumpkin's contractor does not exceed the maximum dredging design depth of -5 feet MLLW with a maximum allowable overdepth of -1 foot MLLW. If you have any questions, please contact Bruce Henderson at (213) 894-0351. Sincerely, cf. ZVC John A. Gill Chief, Regulatory Branch shellmaker inc. June 20, 1994 City of Newport Beach Marine Department P.O. Box 1768 Newport Beach, CA 92659-1768 Re: Dredging @ Lumpkin Residence 1519 E. Bay Ave. Gentlemen: Due to the only acceptable tides for dredging the referenced job occuring in the evening of June 20, we are forced to work until 10:00 p.m.. We have mentioned this to the owner of the project who will inform his neighbors. Thank you for your cooperation and should you have any questions, please call. Sincerely, Shannon West Office Manager cc/ Police Dept. Harbor Dept. File 875 B West 15th Street, Newport Beach, California 92663 Phone (714) 548-5359 Fax (714) 548-5315 General Engineering Contractors/License No. 561434/Marine Construction and Dredging P.O. BOX 1768, NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92658-8915 29, 1993 Residential Escrow 120 Newport Center Drive Suite 160 Newport Beach, CA 92660 Re: Escrow No. 1512OMS Dear Robin: On December 28, 1993, we inspected the property at 1519 East Bay Avenue, as required by Section 10-B of the City of Newport Beach Harbor.Permit Policies, which states: "Whenever a permittee sells the abutting upland property, a request shall be made to the City to transfer the per- mit. Forms for this purpose may be obtained from the Marine Department." At the time of the inspection, it was noted that the float portion of the pier did not conform to the drawing on file with the City of Newport Beach, Marine Department, a copy of which is attached for your information. Specifically, the float appears to encroach across the property line and into the City street end, whereas the permit drawing shows the float with the required 5 foot set back from the property line. This deviation of the structure from the permit on file with the Marine Department could be grounds for revocation of the Harbor Permit, as provided by Section 17.24.090 of the.Newport Beach Municipal Code, which states: Revocation of Permit. A. GROUND FOR REVOCATION. Any permit heretofore granted for any structure or work in the waters of Newport Harbor or the Pacific Ocean may be revoked by the City Council upon any of the following grounds: Section 3. The work or structure does not comply with the permit or does not meet the standards adopted by the Citv Council for such work or structure. If you have any further questions in this regard, please contact me at (714) 644-3044. Sincerely, � Tony Melum Deputy Director tmpi er.ins p 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach X,r-� v/90 - J'-7 z STATUS SHEET NPr,:OP PERMIT TRANSFER LOCATIONPERMIT NO.� --- Sel 1 er —Buyer— r� Cate Application Received: Date fee Received: Request for Inspection made by: Escrow Co. � //-r_neril Date /z `l E Escrow Officer�Esc/roow No.�-�%20 Address Date Inspection made:_ ------------ Deficiency Letter sent: Deficiency corrected: Transfer corpleted:�_Date Inspection: 1. Location 2. Plumbing: tl . 4, Structural:` 5,OTHER: REMARKS: Inspected by' /472:7 ��` ilY•59' 4 v� dog /?PF/G� VICPN1iY S94E"i"ClV��'� ri_� NEWPORT"SAY, C_AI.IFORNIA ..be/ow A4L-osrore er or.: S.s a�✓..» r`��},��'.1r.-roi� r1rF�/hs . L tar+.�Yr' L ow YC'er.ran ,.i mv,r -rrc"m 'Way, /'ide crpororrm,cr/'e/y. /C! r"g,�h .VorLor Lina.r nre . .aslob/ishe�in fh,.,'r sacr�on rrt /V'ravF+or-}..sdy. . t ' f 64y. j i 1 ✓f G rE r' I I � Vim- a I 30 � r � j1 T5%Q 7'lG)RA BAY. S. �Tv. AccL7' rT xtapcas��a :4INA t1 ,. �.._..:.._--•--.-.-..._._....__..,.__._..:..._._______\.I ._...__...._..__ . axa'i fi`tAy«nog Yt i rtr+�> F't r9 /w.•a rY G { a. �t5 r'R }�7iaF rsy - r nnY f .,. �..._°_.. _. ........,. /92 - /,57/� v 'ark Abq lt7,0 y,` �� • _ G .+ - 4 9----a-j Ci • • -. 36" � ,r,.'�—'Fib. s..... ,�•e� .4� j1 nrr ' EX/SYinc, 1J104n. '� 3'?t�t,� ��y'�a �n♦+�o6. PPOF/L� VICINITY 5KErChi p� •"� w.�\ M(W VORT SAY, C♦L.IF 6RNi,! ` I � Soundiiiy.r ore e./picd.l ccr .n fBc/ onH 1,!.vo/y •fr.P /hy be/ow ,NMrr LQ1+'e." Le.w LL over'. .ANoii, �.-.c•m .-b,�ye of hb'e oppra�-iin uts/y /O tecf ffor-Der Liner vrC a.Ftob/.;rhrd i.> /n,,r reef 4�.'+ n�Nc�rvt-w.-P c9.>y N —.__ _.— __-...-_. � .�-.Zs. S. _/•7/Ere N.r''--A/J .: 'rlE j I , i w" OJ &,4y ✓AC o sE ' I A vr- 30 !BLOGi�C 6ATs/off .,1�/r�oeo ! NEK'x�QeT L3Ar 3e' 'L 30 ` iz'� '31. 30 � I `✓IJCU G'�>O/N C 1 I .LJ�7/.ca /ion bJ SNE2 /? CR ARY I /519 E -5A460A OLD y7 /�� f//ilBM, GgLIF J �E {f E ' i- f _ ,.. , j. .__. q t _ �I t of I i It 3 � NO. i DATE I RF_V1570R': l =f �I 1 F ,! i. 7 i t iiK c`t xz " @'t'a5 trs ux1� ", fin `d�"inYTM say S 'rat .^^e t y Ti t r it (Vf yV .Vi ii ,£ 4 Y N£A.[� .: !Y 11 .3 i3y. 4 ly P3 I t { y ^` 1 h"Ff hrN N�� ll/ j 6 `�J r : t V t { - V. i e y..:\ 1. i ova )� ll x y Sr,^ e yt x t t t 1 sN x F :aS h Y t 1 " -i Y sf £tf Y a'` eaz4rtr ) .,h"�rk E £ �. [ a r,t t } F y1 4 a s 'SS ' < t tt �`�e` `' u'csfi YYxt il.:{zw °x r.u'.,sa ro £ y ° f ''�x, '+i '$ ,,r: v� - 7 t Ss ix 'r u� 1+t''.., 14reu'E hP 3j l° M 1 U:rcs J{ t i y;, Y� 1 yet P f 4 y Y ?.9S Y l'Cy L"t ("'� H :}. 3'f`N ` t r 1 i x, 5 a G t Nysxn >r x?t,c r' ",a;�:% t l'a 'yam 1 i x p 1 d l r1„s't ti- ^` � s'' t „✓ 1 ' / c �.:. ',s-w?; r '4"t [ Md'�vY �� YF� ✓ 1� k r` -r s � � � �✓ `� f "+ {" c y M, F ;a x ilbir `�, r '° # > 5' t I �... } -y �'' .0 i` �`:4 �c��,f� - k r r" t5 d $ at uY t a i.. t� y •i-�,s,;'^ < j t L e 4 , f y1 jr tip" ,.� i a ` c v,x - u. c k 5� r., +, ¢ 'C , s sis r 1+ a,a �i i., tin S ;K'7 3' £ Y" lwt ct�S C r r!. L.`'r#a x F �.-t r i'. y 4 r: # Ns ax's _a'`d rsx r 5 a �` ' ys'' ! a i .y I r` S ;i �° v t' a S ? e y s x ,,i 5 c ys i a __J" ..,.: f �^ k: K' 3. r h J T g �t air& Y ? 7 E .;� l e. .r_.. ...,...:...- -t.-- _,... ........ ,. p Y , r 1 o f ""t m" i5 d t*- .r` r :1 5, h , OI, p j t v N J r F il� 1 -a\ 4 .; f5�j'b # r K t t 1 �i Y`�>3 4 3 ° 4� {s�, ,� "r'�.. tg 9 l l M f t t 4 6 a 'sI 1 a, ! X,y+� �"'. .�9 _ i 3r t ( S rvr ,� t A t # YS i t G�, a •,S' 3 ' y r. a'+ l `� r-. `'t r .5 '�' ! s r c 1 p ! !,I _it �i £e <-ti ...n..:.F�• _ 4 . i 'ixs r �,, 3 e ,b'., h {.� x, �xa £ r �t ;�^- �k r.•ut{ J ,!'.. d p 3 3 �{,4. y S fiY F _ 4 _f_____...trt' 1 ^� l # Y t ; R + 'L r SS " sar ! �° ".x ei r ;r 4s ?£.>r Sr> t� 7 i x a S i y a r S r u )t gY z xk" 6 y.�Yx. 2 Il ;. ., : t r :.' r ,+ t ¢+:'..ems t s Jr z e �'"sq f�r:i� x F i <.,,, s'"-trz r'. �ta- d'` �y°a ! s! as s S 5u r y': z si ! �„,.. f a -f{f{{" C�� >r is �/ Ms ''i'r �"." Y'' t i,1, rh^ - a s 'S nr 9 ; h s "' ..Sat 'e `,, < r u e r _a r °.S. 4.:.e x J 1 �§ ss"s� # r rr S" .�- , v e "r, ..N r Y s - A-."', /,�+� Jam,, .- , - r� -,, E i t o ^£ a t° 4 4 .f .r' -- r l t Y f 1 t .: J l ¢+ SY q s a } '' 4 t :,,r. t S iWv 1> t .s✓ d S } snY1 t ` �� r. C ! rK t Ft°tin z 4'H rr 1. t ,�N £5't'+ty t '�i 1 41� } {'� i t 'r� Y' 1 r s ..� S s'.: �' rt e N f.Se. G •x3 t r n r sxx). N rl a,alM`+ "a SG t " r� i .' .1 .;. .!, i t n s X. u5 rr r_11:.' r z1r r1 s x v{ t t r °, v :.o ... cn'`v, tits it ee t s - r. _� t - i t ! h3 i r': a t X`a^> `G a 3 x .t 'r 1 i t� ; 1 i ` ," u y t i. S s.'o-r 3 a u c i s : v e S ' ( 1 �... ..<.. ... _n ..,�. C S F 1 ". y .. ,.,, ,Lz. r� e ,., 1. r i; ,<<. .;,,r .t t?r xyla '3.:F :� ur' .4. ` .5' e F 1 a � ,rr' i i Il a,l, xns,i1 ,.,,.l�<il,.. .a.,,.m ,,a AOe' _...,.nn., -. d'r _ n ' tas "`ik Sc j.`�3ex°;ti pert pr. �e2�E 2 YESi cs ''4�yv?f .. �, r l .'t ry'9 w �r .:.i �x £'�* viak� a u1�'`itrio 'r'S xr.� J� sfx e e :�2 Y.. { u ! r i t YN F'" sJ , rtss;. ifFS €. s;.Yi s 7 b 4 ;. s s i + t: t r y r° n�M �.>r nr'x`� �'+E `vex ir�sS;vxap YA!`"�` ,+ e k. ! r fr .. I + .r 'x ,1 a t 3 ir"3�+ 3t"7., s n,, x>, +r°^ y: `F'" i4u i.. e5 i`t u 1 1 51 c^1a'+ i a r r ,,' Sa .F; `c.d r '» x e' K„ t`v '' r l"i kse v "` `ram Y ' t s 1 Y I 7r > v 5 z tii. 1 z,#�^4' 1'rie ?ieiN �# S .v V r t p r r ;yj£ y .,n k ., e.{'i.. # k s "'xaa l hsy `S x i e ♦ t t 1 t 1 h Y'` i F.,...y 3 �y.. .�L, ai. S(:,{ SP t V i .4 ei' it t '�yi } S trx ue s H.:z�^H4�S,*"""n�e-•f Fxxar 'F' r..l rS Ys IX 4 t r y�� y f .h. + t i j', 'i is ;,<', '- x ax S f-"a'.N x rc wx S� re rx "f. r < [ 'r,. sts:t ( t� <n .c si tptt b ,R.,t > It �p ti ? p G y?` s ,y,F :. `a,```�t',�T1i;+xvg. ".:�;y�S`"M rr"< �'r r a; jj § 1 `''34x ca S a.. k:r°` r.. ri.,ey.. o- �, rlyas:... wl#v t. .� :{ e cm #}(: i s i 1; �il.. 'u f < >, •.; *� ,x ..xL„n,, t a>�? ^sr ts, ,ScJ.. i ; S v F r . t S 1... ' 1 Y ,ey ^-s�4.'x : %'p. a.x x i :.: ,�y.a+ +' .1: Hs >`" .�s,a rx,.r„ s3 -_ ,x .A a `�^....�i; Y ryn r,, Z '' V 1 1. :A y�f ��yyyyyy t //tt 2 t L 1 ) a(£,.: A, r .... t[' :.r=9 .,,�i`' _ ,�� I.. .< ;Y iE!ur��r{ ..-^ > ir,H Y A %..!'.� 41 •I.: a C -! N C f, 'f: 1�' # ..v } R) :1+,".. y st: l'� i .. _ {: iY' gip' �` fi� ..! i' •I , . .,.," . v £ „N.at e >d .a''s4ri#`z i}."�.S�`J'� a ..F ✓ '�4 ., `k. ytt �,+f✓�.'a. x 4s S # 3 -:a x,,„ r rs riv .3,_,, d >~-1 r+... < 3N�3 i'x a t . x _ r 1 :E t} z x x 4.'G. a Yatr'ky ?z� 'az v 2t au. z'x�'s �.. J ^r #, r i ,�, e , t' srr s ,c,.. ,h r'"" .+ ef«, 2, F.r�-."',�,ct 's 3 .L ✓", vs"5'v �"�tiu x#, "+ ! t*°F i, i<n. i, x { e +, _ � 4 ? i Z.. ryt '� t ) ..Cy..V s,.mw:.'i,. t a^ <£ >..>-s 4+na `#tv c., T` y xr - r v ,^ ' e'.lk' s� s:'..s h f e 37 "*n.3'i?'v. a ": t 5S' 4 ,l�.rr /' :ra .: ns.. c t Fsz =a`^F. w.a. .�. t., u r _ v; ..±i,•. E' v"rS Fy f,i,dy.. ,r ..<�.`,,s,y ( 'Nz z k k: x 'xf; Y i f.-.7 j^+'a'�..-iM1<Frh>`ai41 'R:` ,;y'i r . '., u 1`' .✓��. ..5,,..,+, . E . r ; lr d v. x} �+r' ?z , p, , „p'G se 1i Y u .. a 3� .a ,rk S 1 a .. M �' ....t o r s "v` j { rq �:x �,�x�^'x s"?? Su^M a2.k� 1 : hvax5.,.u•Sfs i "tx 1 i+�t. ^y nr`L Y i z r ice. 1r d S ter. � 4' .. , a , < ! ` 5 r ] 3 ..,E S6; M ., ;, >�. "' ,c '< b f.. i s ,. ^<yA� ,ase +� t s w l ,.# l lrs. N` x i e a e ;. .. ! ! i' t �. x s i .. J:SSY�u's�?t'i`.4Y'x.Y, S £ c'`'"J ,t 1, h. r ! r s r,'..p H£ . x c,. `tials ,+"' 'l, r ila ft xGb "l v s c,+" ^v� a ' v ,,r ke.,E�. -` .1 `..i '..', e�vP s 5 ,.�,�y�,, T ,?Ese �r rFs'sy'� ",i, mnr ) 1 4 v :v i vs d,a>r s < ,.:;Y*?h' .-x. , `tk t� 2 a;;. . �zx., f „.. . �, �.�r �.f'. L`.m,. l,s. - ? ate '' > gy4 ,^.1; s x{L,F 2' t ` fi'§,.:. sE�S%� :,<. •m£.-U s '.a,4 z t �.1 e::F ',jd.? (,''£z# ! S Pam.; nX e. 5' 1 v 1� } 'r'�+. -rs ce �..; '�.S' fi+'`�"r - 'i . ,f.. x 5 r°" yt. 6um'iRr 1 r Bn"'�.,. Fy Sys}'. 7i' t h�aq. i .,, t t ['i S £ ✓ ,iY'✓s-?, aZT»v: ,✓ c. s 1 ,.^q r'L,y .,Z, t::2 w �£ii z a t�;: >` 5ar rCks�..`i°k-��'„( C ro ".,+�.. sb+�.'€ a 3 ::+xy<. n �` sr > t t . ,...�sw...}"E4 lass- s i m tip'=-�"�..""r ... 1 ' �, a r a `v .+ 4t � ro y' F l h; t t o z" �. , ' £ .I - .. ";i:?y'5 "^ `' x 5: Skr" um.„..� t sy...: ,. r x �u "x� l,e.Fa `�.. .i.,.'�+ j F : �'. ' o. s sa t 1 f4n c f F-vi..�ur'E, `�,C•Kh• �. is€h 1•, r'" �jc�.:`, <t,c xs. E r M 't G e , s. (,v a x! ++ a� r z3r �'' ra sj`h;r is` ,t 'Aq �- . u:. tfws'x, i ,�rt`:```a ° ; rd u;_,g;iit 4zr.. ,kt.—.,�,� 2'.k� '^„. ra r .: via it , t _y ` < J, � � s #. � a Yy t, .`kS t a"� ,F# s � �n h+r i 1 ek �` £xs i' 1- y. �,. f v�r Y�ih i 3f� C.: i1 x F..r4..: ly t -t 9Ypk,s P� xs u£a.,>t CC ;i'kctxdrp r 1yi,>. kxl NF'1.izxSxr. yte zV.{ E y i x t i sy '� c;�` cl stfi4r au .isFie �r'S 1 xa ,max?y�y ty'F' N'�' t `.' r;X oy i a' { t » 'ie r-rdZr.n` t r4 , xS p� `'i u / y'' r 1 y , c''`` f''.. ..:.�z a+»L ` r"�;skC+ t �,. x s ,y sn yt1 s e ', s 1 Gp t n. 3> { k Y a`S � � *J`e ry`v X t 4 x e `! '" ur£ L S r 3i:>t x Mtf.'c rx"'tY .;q § ,.,( U".: s'1'�w t k e! 't��' c" �r: x'E, t v$� e:.#3 r�za` a2Ya4 v.Ss �s t s 2S 1' a? "g^`"Ye^dc Y` i c z 1 �t A E r, i,. r t l i. �' e i ;r Ci'uH Td^» ,frC,C w� } a M, l BY'S su'.44g 1". gx st t Y ' '' } s ''tl„ j y 1 ., it , ° e {£ <';, . -e C ZSry a(y ;} ;?1 tx i s- .,. Y�s,±,t >C�,i k`tA by : tl, k #',r, a S t bt3. ax s y F .+..^5N +(' Sy, dty.. x3rt a y a 5y ✓+ a z rll�3 .+_. �` i.:.Z. r '�j x�i. S�,li £�4"4raex',rt S �a Y 52 1x s; o ! ` x § ''M' sf y T a i ^`' uJ, x- m % m ru'. r r t'✓ „ice S i M s .ai 1Yn .. S�`4''4 r i�tr rF.@y= P' c 6 y.. t �, f .: yy,' ° u{ 9 1 .i :`S't 1 +riffs`.-k=t 3k �2 �xP�. tAb s Yz5 t3 a '' s xss e l ! r.' u;: 1 .:,+,, n ." £ ati,. r`Jr xznMz°1fy i i"^?#`� i b�; °s aSr.a-n1.. fH"'' �s s x .1'. t ,s 5 tc e ,r: ,t 5x13m F �1 �i s +1+, . a'£ +a ,1 'r ^r', [ ,' n s : t1 s p ez x s,tv dt5 t'S .ar � i kX, #>, z> sy s s,1d ro ,s £ 1 zs ` a a s J.. i�zs4 'l w"i. v Ey suer a. F4 .xr .4e��Yx w'*t 4.4 h!'.M 4 s r'4 , :ur 'r' ivt F� ath.t?z I s `l>, i x s cw. �`.;i` c '+ t y t. t t y`. Ha` a . s= <r �, ':r Yt ` �i'i,. E r ^.rr„ ! f rat, r r} t ,1. .[ g„ t A e S s t r7 S. ,i9r� 1y,iS e'. E-✓r ^c i s^' Y � n3.. �4.�' T t� '1 -1 < {3 v'S� + t,.ii t. ... �� 4 _ 1 i s +fl i 1 4 q i ' Y`�` f k x�' ,— d ,� ,,,,,.+t^t «� 2 '� >"i1 h5 k ..;( .i 4 S J! I. s . a .... .:-2s . Y.. m...= -_. .h �.. ;>,ay. k ,t uar..,<>". _.f �'9 .,.tR.. , r r., c_ , ,,Lr