HomeMy WebLinkAboutM2002-0109N
ti
,4
�i
ji,�
j
N
4
e
a
r
m
�i
N
a
411,
h
4
c
4
�.t
E
e
Worksheet tor building Combo Permit Application
City of Newport Beach - Building Department
;e print 3 copies
:Building f7 Grading f7':Drainage F Elec Me Ch Plum
Project Address (Not mailing address)
-iant Name(if Applicable)
.................... ................... ...
Description of Work
It
................ .......... ...................... ............ ........................ ........... ....... ...
(Ist House SF Demo House SF Add/Reconstruct House SF
,:ist Gar SF Demo Garage SF Add/Reconstruct Garage SF
F F
TOTAL HOUSE SF
New F7 Add f7... Alter [7 Demo
TOTAL GARAGE SF
...........
k Appropriate Box for Applicant
Floor Suite No
...........
# Units (if Residential)
3. Owner's Name Last First
................
............ 1-1 . .. . . . ............... I .............
Iner's Address
... ........ .... .... .... ..
/v State
. . . . .............. ........ ............
Use
Valuation
/ ...... ............. .. ... ... ..
# Stories
Cu Yd Cut
Cu Yd Fill
Owner's E-mail Address
................. .............. . . .. ....
Zip
. Telephone
.......... .................. : r
.......................
4. Arch itect/Des ig ner's Name Last First Lic. No. F
............ ................
,-chicect/Designer's Address
---------- — ------------
.. . ........... .. .................................................... .................................................................................
State
F777
Arch itect/Desig ne r's E-mail Address
Zip Telephone[777777�
6. Contractor's Name Last
)ntractor's Address
...... ... ... 7 V.1.111-1 . ..... I.r ... ..........
:y C State
- . ............. .............. ............... .............................................. . . : I.:- � .................
'FiCE USE ONLY ENERGY P/C FEE $
GRADING P/C FEE $
s Lic. No., >_ 80ass
�/,F-fr t
...........
Contractor's E-mail Address
I............ ............................. ..............
...............................
2,
zip V 4 Te phon'e*j;��
PERMIT NO.
PLAN CHECK NO.
/ "-50 0
Scope of work:
If If r—(CA-f Ei bl,
$ gq k,:�, 7
1p x-lqw,
I L
-----------------------
C7'
9 fe
HARBOR OUR4DIV
vr
Cl'v ^F NEWPORT BEA"'
4
1poi
Date of Applicaton: /0 Permit Number:
Property Address: 427 Edgewater. NMort Beach- CA 92661
Buyer's Names: Thomas D. Oxley and Amealia S. Oxley
Billing Address:
Telephone No.:
Buyer's Signatur
Seller's Nam
Seller's Signatur
M
�b
1 3- qs9- 999 9
;4_3 -3
Joint Owner:Signature:
Escrow Company: Mariners Escrow Corporation
Escrow Number: 23555 -BF Fax #: 949�721-8157
Inspection Date: Reinspection Date:
Fee Amount:
Date Paid: 0111e 3 Check Number:
Application Approved:
Harbor Resources Signatureffiate
Special Conditions: This permit is revocable by the City Council.
in accordance with Title 17 of the Newport Beach Municipal Code.
0YF -SIGN AND RETURN
R
s
HARBOR PERAHT
TRANSFER APPLICATION
4
1poi
Date of Applicaton: /0 Permit Number:
Property Address: 427 Edgewater. NMort Beach- CA 92661
Buyer's Names: Thomas D. Oxley and Amealia S. Oxley
Billing Address:
Telephone No.:
Buyer's Signatur
Seller's Nam
Seller's Signatur
M
�b
1 3- qs9- 999 9
;4_3 -3
Joint Owner:Signature:
Escrow Company: Mariners Escrow Corporation
Escrow Number: 23555 -BF Fax #: 949�721-8157
Inspection Date: Reinspection Date:
Fee Amount:
Date Paid: 0111e 3 Check Number:
Application Approved:
Harbor Resources Signatureffiate
Special Conditions: This permit is revocable by the City Council.
in accordance with Title 17 of the Newport Beach Municipal Code.
WP-,
CAM
HARBOR PERMIT
TRANSFER APPLICATION
IWO
4
Date� of Applicaton:
Permit Number:
Property Address:
427 Edagwter. NoWort Beach. CA 92fifil
Buyer's Names:
Thomas D. Oxley and Amealia S. Oxley
Billing Address:
Telephone No.:
Buyer's Signatures:
Seller's Name
s B. Collins, Manager
Seller's Signatures:
Peli luffs, LLC
Joint Owner:S ig nature:
Escrow Company:
Mariners Escrow Corporation
Escrow Number:
23555 -BF Fax #: 949-721-8157
Inspection Date:
Reinspection Date:
Fee Amount:
Date Paid:
Check Number:
'Application Approved:
Harbor Resources Signatureffiate
Special Conditions:
This pennit is revocable by the City Council
in accordance with Title 17 of the Newport Beach Municipal Code.
�-4
-1-F 0
Augus 03
Mariners Escrow
949-721-8157
CITY 0
829 Harbor isla
949-6
Re: Pier Permit 112-427
427 Edgewater, Newport Beach, CA
Escrow # 23555 -BF
Dear Sirs:
NEWPORT BEACH
Drive, Newport Beach, CA 92659
-3034/Fax 949-723-0589
I
The City of Newport Beach has inspected the bove property and found that it
meets City standards and the permit will be transferred.
If you require further assistance in this matter, please call 644-3034.
Sincerely,
Lor rojv�
0
ieArcese
Harbor Resources Division
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
LOS ANGELES DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS
P.O. BOX 532711
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90053-2325
FIEPLYTO April 30,2002
ATTENTION OF:
Office of the Chief
Regulatory Branch
City of Newport, Harbor Resources
Attention: Tony Melum.
3,300 Newport Harbor B -',-%7d
PO Box 1768
Newport Beach, California 92658
Dear Mr. Melum:
This is in reply to your applications dated February 26, 2002 and March 14, 2002, for
Department of the Army Permits to conduct maintenance dredging, per RGP 54 in Newport
Bay, Newport Beach, Orange County, California. This letter authorizes, maintenance dredging
at three sites within Newport Bay (see below).
USACE
city
Site Address
Volume
Area (est.)
Beach
Ocean
Base #
Harbor
(Cubic
Oisposal
7D�isposal
Permit #
Yards)
200200881
112-407
401, 401 1h., 403, 405, 407
440
2250 sy
Yes —
No
E. Edgewater Ave
supratidal
zone
200200881
112-427
421, 423, 425, 427 E.
260
1200 sy
Yes —
I
No
Edgewater Place
supratidal
zone
200200762
112-500
Adams Street End at
160
900 sf
Yes —
No
Edgewater
(100 sy)
nearshore
zone
Totals
860
3550sy
860 cy
Based on the.information you have provided, the Corps of Engineers has determined that
your proposed activity complies with the terms and conditions of Regional General Permit
(RGP) No. 54.
-2 -
As long as you comply with the general permit conditions of RGP No. 54, an individual
permit is not required. This letter of verification is valid until July 24, 2005, when RGP No. 54
will expire. A general permit does not grant any property rights exclusive privileges. Also, it
does not authorize any injury to the property or rights of others or authorize interference with
any existing or proposed Federal project. Furthermore, it does not obviate the need to obtain
other Federal, State, or local authorizations required by law.
Thank you for participating in our regulatory program. If you have any questions, please
contact Corice J. Farrar of my staff at (213) 452-3296.
Sincerely,
Mark Durham
Chief, South Coast Section
Regulatory Branch
ra
REPLYTO
ATTENTION OF:
Office of the Chief
Regulatory Branch
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
LOS ANGELES DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS
P.O. BOX 532711
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90053-2325
City of Newport, Harbor Resources
Attention: Tony Melum
NT
oouu 1-4 ewport Harbor BI' -V- U -j
PO Box 1768
Newport Beach, Califomia 92658
Dear Mr. Melum:
April 30,2002
This is in reply to your applications dated February 26, 2002 and March 14, 2002, for
Department of the Army Perrrdts to conduct maintenance dredging,, per RGP 54 in Newport
Bay, Newport Beach, Orange County, California. This letter authorizes maintenance dredging
at three sites within Newport.Bay �see below)
USACE
City
Site Address
Volume
Area (est.)
Beach
Ocean
Base #
Harbor
(Cubic
Disposal
Disposal
Permit #
Yards)
200200881
112-407
401,, 401 1h, 403, 405, 407
440
2250sy
Yes –
No
E. Edgewater Ave
supratidal
zone
200200881
00200881
1'2-427
112-427
421, 423, 425, 427 E.
260
1200sy
Yes –
No
Edgewater Place
supratidal
zone
200200762
112-500
Adams Street End at
160
900 sf
Yes –
No
Edgewater
I
(100 sy)
nearshore
zone
Tot.a--Is,
860
3550sy
860 cyl—
Based on the.information you have provided the Corps of Engineers has determined that
your proposed activity complies with the terms and conditions of Regional General Permit
(RGP) No. 54.
STATE OF CALIFORNIA - THF RFSOURCFS AGENCY GRAY DAVIS, G
CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION
South Coast Area Office
200 Oceangate, Suite 1000
Long Beach, CA 90802-4302 al March 18, 2002
(562) 590-5071
Mr. Tony Melum
Division of Harbor Resources
City of Newport Beach
P.O. Box 1768
Newport Beach, CA 92658-8915
Subject: Condition Compliance — Coastal Development Permit 5-99-282
& Conformance with Consistency Certification CC -078-99
Dear Mr. Melum:
Commission staff have received information submitted as evidence of compliance with Coastal
Development Permit 5-99-282 and/or as evidence of conformance with Consistency Certification
CC -078-99 for the following sites in the City of Newport Beach:
City
Harbor
Permit #
Site Address
Beach
Disposal?
(Yes/No)
Beach
Disposal
Qty'_ (ydS3)
Ocean
Disposal?
(Yes/No) _
Ocean
Disposal
Qty 2 (yds 3
Cumulative
Total3 for
2002
112-407
401. 401-1/2. 403.
405. 407 E. Edaewater
Yes
440
No
0
112-427
421. 423. 425. &
27 E. Eclaewater Place
Yes
1 260
1 No
1 0
Total
1
700
1
1 0
89
Commission staff have reviewed the information submitted and determined that the above
referenced dredging event conforms with Consistency Certification CC -078-99 and that no further
federal consistency review is necessary from the Commission for the dredging component of the
project. In addition, the proposed beach disposal has been reviewed and found by the Executive
Director to be consistent with Special Conditions 1, 2, and 3 of Coastal Development Permit 5-99-
282. No further review is necessary from the Commission for the beach disposal component of
the project.
Please be advised that only the project described in the materials submitted for the site listed
above have been found to conform with Consistency Certification CC -078-99 and/or conform with
the terms and conditions of Coastal Development Permit 5-99-282. Any change in the project may
cause it to lose its status as consistent with CC -078-99 and/or CDP 5-99-282. This certification, is
based on information provided by therecipient of 'thi's letter. if, at a later date, this information is
found to be incorrect or incomplete, this letter will become invalid, and any development occurring
at that time must cease until a new determination regarding ponformance with CC -078-99 and/or
CDP 5-99-282 is obtained.
If you have any questions, please contact me at (562) 590-5071 or Mr. James Raives at (415)
904-5200.
Sincere y,
X�arl Schwingg
Coastal Program Analyst
Cc: Mr. James Raives, California Coastal Commission
Ms. Cori Farrar, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
1 Not to Exceed 500 cubic yards per dredging and beach disposal event
2 Not to Exceed 1,000 cubic yards per dredging and off -shore disposal event
3 Not to Exceed 20,000 cubic yards per year
C
>
-q
February 26, 2002
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
Attn: Susan Sturges, Regulatory Branch
P. 0. Box 532711
Los Angeles, CA 90053-2325
National Marine Fisheries Service
Attn: Bob Hoffman, Southwest Region
501 W. Ocean Blvd., Ste. 4200
Long Beach, CA 90802-4213
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
Attn: Jack Fancher
2730 Loker Ave. West
Carlsbad, CA 92008
California Fish and Game
Attn: Marilyn Fluharty
4949 View Ridge Ave.
San Diego, Ca 92124
CA Coastal Comm./Carl Schwing
P. 0. Box 1450
200 Oceangate, 1 oth Floor
Long Beach, CA 90802-4416
Re: Notification of Commencement of Work
Under U.S. Army Corps of Engineers RGP 54
Dear Sirs:
q )- -7
As required by the above, we are forwarding you the attached exhibits relative to a pending
dredging application.
If you have questions regarding this application..., please call the City of Newport Beach Harbor
Resources 949-644-3041.
Sincerely,
Tony Melum, Director
Division of Harbor Resources
3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach
89C-r,C_'rf1
VICINITY MRP
Jlof= Mrs GAM04(m
I
Tpe.a4j A.
J1 v T6% rha 1141 ka �C
or i cz 'Piaii i,,. +t,"bse-.6
Gf%DiA Wd)) MOiA�A;A,2AC.F_ 'IrmiJ
L t is t'
Pennit is to allow maintenance of existing
rm'
g r
roin wall on private property, i.e. Deeded
11
L
ot
Beach Lotto Mean High Tide Line,
117
ORIGINA
r E
Aw, C
x
RIO? 'Ala
C"44-44
10 ' P�'b I,,
2-1
iA4'j Ar4 Vkt4 U
ri
k.
i5/z
Z -4-
L
DREDGING APP CATION
PERMIT NO. 117
Project Location:
`5 e -o -e-, k � 0 3 q 'F3 I o c V 2 o r &I h
a C�, q q Z,7
r 1,Aw%0v% 14 VC-nnia,, d q Z�, ?IdLc.,
Latitude/Longitude: I
/f/ 3 Gr-� cs- P-5
bd / / ? — �5 -/ - 0 6 S -
Cubic Yards to be Dredged: I
jobs
\J
Method of D d ing:
ackkce-
_Z�Xen-,xv-e
"17 /"-" C /0,01 5; /1& e -',-e 45-�IrVecf-
Nature of Dredged Material (Grain size data) ra Ve.1
Disposition of Dredged Material:
lie- e3�,00!gileW OpI 06y" e e-�q
40rl"tld ;4e Ae-,�
ethod of Material Disposition:
A &- lo XI e -e ---J
/,J" A!�r Co -7 C, 10P�7 al -W Ak,
Effect of Dredging on Contiguous Bulkheading and Beaches:
Z)r&c
Z:fZ;2!2 I-eZZ11 46-2k*iAml- 6-0r- -5:zWee, 6eldezl 6—�x/-syZI 5;
d t1l U
Aa
Project Begins: Project Ends:
Page 2
Dredging Application
I, A (Applicant/Applicant's agent), hereby certify that I have
reaA the U.S./flrmy Corps of Engineers permit, RGP#54 and the California Coastal
Commission pg'rmit #5-99-282 for maintenance dredging in Newport Harbor and that I
will comply with all of the conditions of those permits. I will further hold the City
harmless from and indemnify them against any claim for damages arising out of the
exercise of these permits. In addition, 1, as the applicant shall reimburse the City of
Newport Beach for all attorney's fees and other costs expended by them in defending
any claim, lawsuit, or judgment arising out of the activities of the applicant carried on
under the authority of such permit.
S', lRev(Ja il 1�3rcl UJ P7
Applicant — Please Print
AT,5
/-7-1- 144A se-xt
Contractor — Plelase Print /
0 / /,V
Date /
Signed: ,:� 1,
Applicant/Agpt
-7 2-
9,Y cz� -2 9- 0 3 6
h
MBC SAMPLE ANALYSIS SUMMARY
STATION LOCATION: 423 E. Edgewater, Balboa, CA
SAMPLE COLLECTION DATE: 25 -Jan -02 TEST METHOD: Sieve Analysis:
Method 2 (Plumb 1981)
COLLECTED BY: Randy Brown ANALYSIS START DATE: 25 -Jan -02
A B
DREDGE SITE RECEIVING BEACH
Total Dry Weight of Sample: 160.77 grams (g) 157.63 grams (g)
Analysis Weight (Split Wt.): 79.77 g 77.05 g
Visual Description: Gray medium sand Gray medium sand
Fraction Fraction Fraction Fraction
Weight % of Total Weight % of Total
Gravel / Shell Hash Fraction: 2.16 g 3% 4.07 g 5 %
>2.Omm (> -1�)
#10 Sieve
Sand Fraction: 76.48 g 96% 72.24 g 94%
<2.Omm >0.063mm (< -1� > 4�)
#230 Sieve
Silt / Clay Fraction: 1.13 g I % 0.74 g I %
<0.063mm (< 4
Outline of sample collection and analysis:
COLLECTION
Samples collected by a hand coring device driven into a representative area of the dredge
site and receiving beach. Stored in plastic containers and immediately delivered to the lab.
SAMPLE PREPARATION
Entire sample transferred into 1 liter glass containers, deionized water added, and
mixed to desalt and disperse the sediment. The sediment is allowed to completely
settle and the clear water is removed by siphoning. The sample is placed in a drying
oven at 500C and occasionally stirred until the entire sample is completely dry. The dry
sample is transferred to a desiccator for cooling. The sample is disaggregated and a
Riffle sediment splitter is used to evenly split the sample to reduce the quantity of
material to be analyzed to an allowable retention weight for the sieves.
SAMPLE ANALYSIS
The dry split fraction is processed through a # 10 U.S. standard sieve to remove the
gravel/shell fraction of the sample. The material retained on the sieve is weighed and
value recorded. The material passing through the # 10 sieve is wet sieved through a
#230 sieve to remove the silt/clay fraction. The material retained on the sieve is
transferred back into the glass container and placed back into the drying oven at 500C.
The remaining sample is allowed to completely dry and the material is weighed and
recorded to yield the sand fraction. The silt/clay fraction is calculated by subtracting
the gravel/shell and sand fractions from the total analysis weight.
MBC Applied Environmental Sciences, 3000 Redhill Avenue, Costa Mesa, CA 92626
101
OEA N
'17/ LBOA
&A r
.400 4 CCROMA
VICINITY S K ETCH 0
Newport Day Califomia
Traced From WsAngeles U.S.E.D d"- 81SA-1
/�,feww,7 LQW4--,r 4ow W.&74e.,
OA -
13
T-
L 07- gl.A,� 2
Zb t 4=1-1
ST
Proposed
X(54�1 Pierand Larsding Float
Newpor+ Bay
Newport E�Qa c h, Ca I i Fo rri i c
Apoo"440- by* M -P r7rl s
7// 1AA 6
MOP
HARBOR RESOURCES DIVISION
829 Harbor Island Drive
Newport Beach, CA 92660
949-644-3034/ Fax 949-723-0589
DREDGING PERMIT PROCEDURES
To begin the dredging permit process, you must submit to the Harbor Resources
Division, a Dredging Application, an 8 Y2x 11 drawing and a check for $407.00,
made out to the City of Newport Beach.
2. The drawing must show the area to be dredged and the area for deposi (if not
barged to sea).
3. A copy of the Dredging Application and drawing will be sent to six agencies. U.S.
Corps of Engineers Notice to Proceed is required before the permit can be issued
and work begun. A stamped drawing is the permit and should be at the project site
while work is taking place.
4. The applications and drawing will be checked and a promect site inspection will be
made to verify conformance with the information on the application and conditions
on the general permit.
5. For applications to barge to sea, samples of the material must receive a grain size
analysis and this analysis must be attached to the Dredging Application.
6. A Post Dredging Report must be completed by the dredging contractor within 15
days of project completion.
7. All work scheduled to be done before 7:00 am or after 6:00 pm and on Sundays and
Holidays must be approved by the Harbor Resources Division. Copies will be faxed
to the Orange County Sheriff Harbor Patrol and the City of Newport Beach Police.
11 TY
OF NEWPORT.IBERCH
CITY OF
ME~ mix
WOO I
I rg s
c
NEW
ICINI
-LY.LRP
loom 3w, alvam Jrr7y
s
AleWp4l
IT ..z -;n- 7,
Lle-S
AWet
AAW
6
OL
Ai 14 E 4Q 3 F
V�
vk-
�Mrs WE JOB RMIES X1,11f
RTE 02-
kvwpo*
LICATION
IV,
DREDGING APP
V
4r,
it
PERMIT NO.
VL
Project Location:
J,'3 OF L3 Q QE�
/ZAJ,01,Jb 4S Y I -3 .41
-qo Z JZ— el AE LL)4
-Q
L atitude/�Ongitude:
36 2e
2
Cubic Yards to be D�e—dged-
4)-A0 1A F7
Meth:odol Dredging:
C/0
:'Ni��qttjre�qf —Dredge—d rain sized t
Ai . position of Dredged Material:
2> P( -E -D&C- g� WILL -
Method of Material Disp"ition:
J:�E L4a'E t46,QV 41A -i-4
h
b A/
E� EZD� E 142,412---� (�26 I)OiCe72�7 6UL04EdjL ALP
h04 P v
Effect of Dredging on Contiguous Bulkheading and Beaches:
-DkE-b,sr1,qk=- LJILL 6�Lilj&E:
CK&,47-;!E� B&4 -r -j�� Aw ZACE
ro 47- Z-4 U) -77-b.,=-- /Vo aC- L- &,oCASS
Project Begins: Project Ends:
rz�k 4 t/E-.
�D ,
47-'S'
Page 2
Dredging Application
�j�k- �8.,!g-j:.._._,(ApplicantiApplirant's agent), hereby certify that I have
P—L L �F- -�, -- 4 and the California Coastal
read the U S Army Corps of Engineers permit, RGP#5,
r3ommission perm it #5-99-282 for maintenance dredging in Newport Harbor and that I
will comply with all of the conditions of those permits. I will further hold the City
harmiess from and indemnify them against any claim for darnages arising oUt Ot the
exercise ol these permits. In addition, 1, as the applicant shall reimburse the City of
Newpoft Beach for all attorney's fees and other costs expended by them in defending
any claim. lawsuit, or juogment arising out of the activities of the applicant carried on
under the authority of such permit.
"R, A,,z-0 YTsL,)Az-r r6 0
Applicant - Please Print
P �n n t
ontrac
_<g_- 1=6-cz
Date
Slgned� -, - Oj-ZL
/f Applicant/Agent
MBC SAMPLE ANALYSIS SUMMARY
STATION LOCATION: 403 E. Edgewater, Balboa, CA
SAMPLE COLLECTION DATE, 25 -Jan -02 TEST METHOD� Sieve Analysis:
Method 2 (Plumb 1981)
-Jan-02
ANALYSIS START DATE: 25
COLLECTED BY: Randy Brown
A B
DREDGE SITE RECEIVING BEACH
157-63 grams (g)
'Total Dry Weight of Sample: 241.99 grams (g)
Analysis Weight (Split Wt.): 119.40 g 95.69 g
Visual Description: Gray/brown medium sand Gray/brown medium sand
Fraction Fraction Fraction Fraction
Weight %ofTotal Weight % of Total
G�avel I Shell Hash Fraction: 1.63 g 1 % 1.04 g 1 %
>2.0mm (> -1�)
#10 Sieve
93.9,g 98%
Sand Fraction: 115.65 g 97 %
<2.Qmm >0.063rrm < -10 > 4�)
#230 Sieve
2 % 0.75 g %
Silt/ Clay Fraction: 2.12 g
<0.063mm (< 4 jj_
Outline of sample collection. and analysis:
COLLECTION
Samples collected by a hand coring device driven into a representative area of the dredge
site and receiving beach. Stored in plastic containers and immediately delivered to the lab.
SAMPLE PREPARATION
Entire sample transferred into I liter glass containers, deionized water added, and
mixed to desalt. and disperse the sediment. The sediment is allowed to completely
settle and 'the clear water is removed by siphoning. The sample is placed in a drying
oven at 50"C and occasionally stirred until the entire sample is completely dry. The dry
sample is transferred to a desiccator for cooling, The sample is disaggregated and a
Riffle sediment splitter is used to evenly split the sample to reduce the quantity of
material to be analyzed to an allowable retention weight for the sieves.
SAMPLE ANALYSIS
The dry split fraction is processed through a # 10 U.S. standard sieve to remove the
gravel/shell fraction of the sample. The material retained on the sieve is weighed and
value recorded. The material passing through the # 10 sieve is wet sieved through a
#230 sieve to remove the silt/clay fraction. The material retained on the sieve is
transferred back into the glass container and placed back into the drying oven at 600C.
The remaining sample is allowed to completely dry and the material is weighed and
recorded to yield the sand fraction. The silt/clay fraction is calculated by subtracting
the gravel/shell and sand fractions'from the total analysis weight.
MBC Applied Environmental Sciences, 3000 RedhillAvenue, Costa Mesa, CA 92626
T'
P()
DREDGING APPLICATION
PERMIT NO.
.4
.1po
004
17-y
4VE--
Project Location:
Lu -j-3-11- 10- 13 LE I e--�
-3,
6
Latitude/Longitude:
Cubic Yards-io6e Dredged:
zl") vAg.&S LAUD
Method of Dredging:
Nature of Dredged -Material (Grain size dat
SA
d �
11 I:SEE� 7-;ES7-
ition of Dredged Material:
- - - --------
Method of Material Dlspq�ffion:
SA ts
i,e- &D6EU)A2Zi,-'C C!6JOCkE7-4L�7 d-AIJ)
M-&�P4:EV-8L4
of Dredging on Contiguous Bulkheading and Beaches:
,FE-ff—ect
PkIV&rE B&4 -r Loce--y -�b
AUD -ZR3,
I -T )4=Z�,+7- 47"U-) '77AE� /,V&;
0
Ae 4le- EA
1I Project Begins: Project Ends:
004
17-y
4VE--
Page 2
Dredging Application
11 6�.-PLLE16 �l-iELia�l-:,T--..-.-,(ApplicanVAppl;lrant's agent), hereby certify that I have
read the U S Army Corps of Engineers permit, RGP#54 and the California Coastal
13ommission permit #5-99-282 for maintenance dredging in Newport Harbor and that I
will comply with all of the conditions of those permits. I will further hold the City
harmless from and indemnify them against any claim for darrages arising out of the
exercise of these permits. In addition, 1, as the applicant shall reimburse the City of
Newpoil Beach for all attorney's fees and other costs expended by them in defending
any claim. iawsuit, or judgment arising out of the activities of the applicant carried on
under the authority of such permit.
R, AL.Lc-,� Y-r-Eu)A Por r6- n
-BL)IZAjF- A O-ASSF-�- Q- A
A'� I3Gic;�Tt- Please Print
I --.. -5 / &Ij)y S4,4En 0
AZ jEiQ---
Con r ct6r -- Please'Print
Date
Signed: Jf.
Applicant/Agent
it
Ctry- o.*- lV",wae,-
ble MM MATPOW #,ptAMOM
Ive ROW met mmf-eze
iT
p N-ro
BeAC44
P= rv% -IJI
/ 17- - c/c,
P"JP.,Cl-r
ro
t
e.
—AND vpv-t-�
. .... . ....
VICI AJ I TY SKETCH
Jerry
WPORr &A Ir, C14L IFOMtNIA
510 4/.17 dl. -I fS Or& Y;rc/ 0,5e alo'"v/d.
3 4br16&v Arg, -0,7 Lowdr,� low
ranve. 0/' 111,42ec /0 IIZ.&741.
are C.7 iab A'O-- a, f.;,v ;.I el c Xf a 0.-0 Me ft"xo,-
VII bAY
PRO
-1
f 'TR�
IA
PtATMFMM
OOL-KHRAC>
AVF-,
.56A E3ky-510E.
AWN.,
0 0�
7,C,4-
Ao4oze'ss
-._fCOA,7WACrOAW 0A 7 e
Page 2
Dredging Application
1, �013EP--r S, SCHRIMME-P,,-,(APplicanVAppl�icant's agent), hereby certify that I have
read the US, Army Corps of Engineers permit, RGP#54 and the California Coastal
Commissi3n permit #5-99-282 for maintenance dredging in Newport Harbor and that I
will comply with all of the conditions of those permits. I will further hold the City
harmless from and indemnif-y them against any ciairn for damages arising out of the
exercise of these permits. In addition, 1, as the applicant shall reimburse the City of
Newport Beach for all attorney's fees and other costs expended by them in defending
any claim, lawsuit, or judgment arising out of the activities of the applicant carried on
under the authority of such permit.
Applicant - Please Print
H A E E
A -E -:k -
Contractor - Please Fri:n—t
Date
Signed
F -Int 41 MARM
3
117 -9/0 7
C', r Y', aa. N"Raer &,r-4c,4v.
ro 4.0 0 ScoeA
ax 14� reK PtA-TrOW AqMvTWJ
ROW
A"P
A -r,
.04.c".W
Room., 04"s
REMC�F- ----AN.D L)-UDE4:,
V4
VICIMITY SKETCH
C,4L IVORKIIA
5104/md."�qs ore
off�V:e.4.S belCivv A-YeOP7 1OWdrr' IOW
are caicblesh�-d O7CMTwo*r1 &scrr.
NEwpoR bAY
�Zmer wwa:
10
T T t4 i
PlEAffVA.Cy 1�(NER
v)(
Vito.
AVE
ISO" \ti\
,4p,o4,L r 5 AI,4-4�M r; 94x�, 7,CAC7
Aoczess C&A-awA c no Ar OA7 e
7
117
;,o 4-ov sv,&,rs
i f; 40
tu
IPA,
"4::
Docv�l Fl-oArS,
VICI AJ I TY -SKiTCH
ILL
N&W,'Vffr SAY
CAL IFORN $.A
'go-EAEWT 4*. 45Cf4F4MMP-FZ it lKYSIPEAPPINI.
,PPL. / C��4n, 7' 5 AI,4,4�rge 7--i
40'7 jj�, E�-04SJ�WATCRX ANIa, TI2AJ"tWVIW, IS �-77
- . 4 1 1 lcoA17wAcroAr OA 7-e
AoD ce
5'04,,;d/,ngs Oe
&-X,-.,-cr5ed orl Acrerl ae)a
OFVP� eh 3 bC16&v
ZOW WOAM-I'6
ronpe, */' 101ec /0 V%�&4
are
NEWPoK
VYT04090
E5AY
T I
ri i!
LANER
A
Of
A
a)L41-H&AC:�
'go-EAEWT 4*. 45Cf4F4MMP-FZ it lKYSIPEAPPINI.
,PPL. / C��4n, 7' 5 AI,4,4�rge 7--i
40'7 jj�, E�-04SJ�WATCRX ANIa, TI2AJ"tWVIW, IS �-77
- . 4 1 1 lcoA17wAcroAr OA 7-e
AoD ce
NO 55L GRASS WITHIN 15'OF PROJECT
G PASS IN THE PROJECT AREA
GNATORE
PFRO T# �DF�
FE
19 FT
Lid
6e
Alo ile, Afokg
AW
It
P61A 11& k.
JAS
414 E
Arl 4 Q 3 E. F-
k�sl W
JIF
eA es1z
low"S w JOB FMCFESS BqTE 0/-2 1- 0 2-
0
BALBOA
0
&A r
or
VICINITY S K ETr-H 0
Newport, Bay California 'v
dAOW"W- SCALS 066US
Twed From LmA"eles LI.S.E.11 d". 815M
CAWPJOLhm 64r/ow Lavwwr- Low W.W'v'e'P-
Li
7A;..7 1�6 4
7-7
07
ON,
00
'7.','. 9-
AD;4NIS, S.9
t
Proposed
Xe,4
ot, 3. Pierand Landing Fic
Neewpor+ Beiy
Newport Beach, Ca I i Fc
Appi-404 40- /vfp rrl
CITY OF NRA0--lnr-,T 9PACH
7 -ARE
PERM:�SSIGN IS HF��` AND
MAINTAIN THE FACILIT',
AT THE SITE INDICATED, SUG,,z��!
THE HARBOR POW POUCiii OF
ANY SPSCL#A. CON0nj= USTED HERI:-;�
IS NOT TpANSFOWUMMOUrTHE WRIT" -
THE CnY HARBOR COORDL4XlOR OR Cll'�
RIGHTS GIM UNDER TW FMIT ARE
AND THIS PERMIT MAV BE f&VOM BY THE
IN ACCORDAM VM 1= 17 QF THE MUN I
PERMIT NO.
Z g1V6-,1-W 4-,
TpeA44j -1"Y. 1� eap - ---------
CITY OF NEWPORTBEACH. W"t 9 1 - ---
----T1%ra
'31 K to'
LOA P141il ii.
CITY OF
ME~ BEPM
VMT
AW
LAW
ULM
ISSUMM
BW
Wam
10110-ric 401
OC&W
WESr
July
VICINITY,'PIRP PROF ILE 400
X~ W. OUFQMM J0-4:� S, SOUNDINGS F1RE EXPRESSED IN FEET RM MOTE
O-EVRTIONS BISED ON MEAN L04ER LOW MWM.
Gf%DiA Wd)1 MdiA�WAaAcz 'Irmij.
LPermit is to allow maintenance of existing
groin wall on private property, i.e. Deeded
B c
each Lotto Mean High Tide Line.
U-Mu"INA
-iN ler-4-10wa wl .4asAoe A;Ies
WN'01411
t'firma;n EQA� --f U4 Lt.., a
6
Rap
C4,44fdl-
4#
to P" 1 k
�q Iq
/YeAmd Ar4 ye
46 6
V�
JOB ROMSS
JAPPLIW"s wK 27
AAef
<j
-&J
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
I 1 3 X 10 `X er i ca. Piail i,.
CITY OF
�NEWFOU BEECH
aw
46 W -A
101107rrc
WESr
irm PROF I LE 3 40
VICINITY, MRP
NNW M, aLMUM JEny SOLMINGS F1RE MEM IN FEET FM MOTE
Tol� S, �e- ELEVRTIONS BRSED ON ME1:N LOWER LOW WRTER.
-c3f%DIA W411 Md;A�ajeay1ce 'Irmij.
* P t is
emlit is to allow maintenance of existing
r
groin wall on private property,
i
7
i.e. Deeded
c Lot
LBeach Lotto Mean High Tide Line,
T
7'
U` - R I GINA
i-7-7
IL
w -ea -4o.- A?4re
FJ411 fa Spy
e90"444 E44i
I Aw - 6M�M
IIW411 11.4sk
Prop 40f4 Jj a 6 J�a, le— , 9\
Ave.. .&A w-1 k.
Ae 2.1
A&d Ar4 e4--fh'! ye
V�
30 1
NI
-2�
FPPLIW'S WeE el-e�*Ald
JOB RMNSS
<j
C--�/
D
. . ..... .
_______�
------------------------
____WATERLINE
_-------------- �
� --
�0` 7�p�
=�~ ,,n,�.`�/NE 1_-14--00 11 �'
' ~"" ' ' ',. M.
, zL. 6 E/ �V MLLW -� ."_`yV — 0�}� --
"'`"� A)(|A r
^1,
*`
�
ORD|W4A\/ A}GA TIDE LINE PER DECREE NOV, 5` \92A
Y/ 0)
CONCRETE WALL
q`
�/`/\K]/`|)'� r
���/ |\| \ , F\ �- { �- �� | i \ �- \0/ /\ i L/
~'`~'`� / L �� /\��_�V/�( �
�� -
/
' ' {
\ )
) `
,
� \ )
| `
\ ' B -- -^ `^| K
{ i
| � |
`
`
`
|
2 BALB 'OA
}
\
`
TO: - - Newport Beach Marine Department
FROM: Katie Stewart
RE: New Groin Wall on 421 East Edgewater Place, Beach Front.Lot, Newport
Beach, CA 92661
To Whom]t May Concerni
1, Katie Stewart, am the owner of 419 East Edgewater Place, Newport Beach, CA. I understand
that my neighbor, Mr. Randy Brown, at 421 East Edgewater Place is planning to install a new
groin wall between our adjoining beachfront lots; and that this wall will not be on my
property. Further, that Randy Brown (Method Art Corporation) will bear its total expense and
upkeep as necessary.
Finally, that this wa . 11 is intended to help retain our beach sand from eroding in which case I
approve of its installation.
Katie Stewart
10: Newport Beach City Planning Department
Nu
. tn� Gina Garcia
i dni a neighbor of Randy Brown to his west at 411 glEast Edgewater, Balboa. Randy has Shown
427 East
,is the plans for the beach front improvement and the proposed four new homes at 421
i�.Idgewat��r. We consider the beach front project an enhancement to our neighborhood and
Delieve it will help us regain the beaches we lost due to Newport Landing's development of its
1 --oat basin.
the four homes he proposed with the slight encroachment of the second floor cantilevered
i,glcLss railed) balconies will not block our existing view, and, therefore, will have no negative
inipact on out bayfront enjoyment. We support his proposed projects.
Sigrod..
ADO
TO: Newport Beach Marine Department
FROM:
RE: New Groin Wall on 421 East Edgewater Place, Beach Front Lot,. Newport
Beach, CA 926611
To Whom It May Concern:
am the owner of 417 East Edgewater Place, Newport
Beach, CA. I understand that my neighbor, Mr. Randy Brown, at 421 East Edgewater Place
is planning to install a new groin wall one beach front lot away from our bealthfront lot; and
thatthis wall will not beon my property. Further, that Randy Brown (Method Art Corporation)
will bear its total expense and upkeep as necessary.
Finally, that this wall is intended to help retain our beach sand from eroding in which case I
approve of its installation.
c
Signed,
To: Newport Beach City Planning Department
Attn: Gina Garcia
I am a neighbor of Randy Brown to his west at 413 East Edgewater, Balboa. Randy has shown
us the plans for the beach front improvement and the proposed four new homes at 421 - 427 East
Edgewater. We consider the beach front project an enhancement to our neighborhood and
believe it will help us regain the beaches we lost due to Newport Landing's development of its
boat basin.
Also, the four homes he proposed with the slight encroachment of the second floor cantilevered
(glass railed) balconies will not block our existing view, and, therefore, will have no negative
impact on our bayfront enjoyment. We support his proposed projects.
Signed, F _OA (c �4 /�7
; �� ,O_Ne4s A
Z-ai
Z
TO: Newport Beach Marine Department
FROM: Katie Stewart
RE: New Groin Wall on 421 East Edgewater Place, Beach Front Lot, Newport
Beach, CA 92661
To Whom,It May Concerni
1, Katie Stewart, am the owner of 419 East Edgewater Place, Newport Beach, CA. I understand
that my neighbor, Mr. Randy Brown, at 421 East Edgewater Place is planning to install a new
groin wall between our adjoining beachfront lots; and that this wall will not be on my
property. Further, that Randy Brown (Method Art Corporation) will bear its total expense and
upkeep as necessary.
Finally, that this wall is intended to help retain our beach sand from eroding in which case I
approve of its installation.
Katie Stewart 8 /9 9�
I
TO: Newport Beach Marine Department
FROM:
RE: New Groin Wall on 421 East Edgewater Place, Beach Front Lot, Newport
Beach, CA 92661
To Whom It May Concern;
1, w am the owner of 417 East Edgewater Place, Newport
Beach, CA. I understand that my neighbor, Mr. Randy Brown, at 421 East Edgewater Place
is planning to install a new groin wall one beach front lot away from our beachfront lot; and
that this wall will not be on my property. Further, that Randy Brown (Method Art Corporation)
wi I I bear its total expense and upkeep as necessary.
Finally, that this wall is intended to help retain our beach sand from eroding in which case I
approve of its installation.
Signed,
Newport Beach City Planning Department
Ann: Gina Garcia
I din a neighbor of Randy Brown to his West at '(11 CEast Edgewater, Balboa. Randy has shown
us the plant for the beach front improvement and the proposed four new homes at 421 - 427 East
and
Fdgewati:r. We consider the beach front project an enhancement to our neighborhood
A lie ve it �,v help us regain the beaches we lost due to Newport Landing's development of its
1 -moat basin.
,Xl so, the four homes he proposed with the slight encroachment of the second floor cantilevered
(gLtss railed) balconies will not block our existing view, and, therefore, will have no negative
inipact on our bayfront enjoyment. We support his proposed projects.
Signed,
To: Newport Beach City Planning Department
Attn: Gina Garcia
I am a neigh&r of Randy Brown to his west at 413 East Edgewater, Balboa. Randy has shown
us the plans for the beach front improvement and the proposed four new homes at 421 - 427 East
Edge water. We consider the beach front project an enhancement to our neighborhood and
believe it will help us regain the beaches we lost due to Newport Landing's development of its
boat basin.
Also, the four homes he proposed with the slight encroachment of the second floor cantilevered
(glass railed) balconies will not block our existing view, and, therefore, will have no negative
impact on our bayfront enjoyment. We support his proposed projects.
Signed, -gAvo- F4, -IA SA
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH FIREVARINE DEPARTMENT
HARBOR PERMIT APPLICATION (Please print all information)
Aa a A,/- C:��n4 , � - . �Y5 7 2-3,53
1. Applicant (Property Owner) Address Telephone
I zll�
X --- -7
2. Project Address (Sk&t Address) Harbor Permit Number
3. New Construction Revision Maintenance v""' Dredging
4. Fee Check No. Date
5. Brief Description of Proposed Work: 11q 4,
6. Submit 8 1/2" x 11" Drawings (3), Include:
1). Location and dimension of proposed structure including piles and location of existing structures.
on adjacent properties.
2). Location of bulkhead, pierhead and project lines.
3). Location of property lines.
4). Location of channel markers within 200 feet.
5). Lot sizes and lot numbers, if available.
6). Existing ground profile beneath proposed structure.
7). Elevation of top and bottom of bulkheads and piles with respect to M.L.L.W.
8). Area and profile of any proposed dredging with elevations showing depths with respect of M.L.L.W.
9). Any special conditions affecting the construction or affecting boating operations.
10).Complete all information required in information block, bottom of sheet. Note that the OWNER.
of the property is the applicant
I 1).Drawing size shall be 8 - 1/2" x I V.
12).Scale shall be adequate to clearly show the above information.
13).Existing structures shall be shown in light dashes. New work shall be shown in heavy solid lines.
7. Owner -Builder Declaration must be co eted (on reverse side of this sheet)
74
R Ann1irnnV4z1AnPnV_4z Rinnntimp- /�"— /,14� natp.
Joint Permittee Signature (if appricable): / , Date:
9. Work can begin once the City has received evidence of the following additional approvals and you have
been notified to proceed. If you begin prior to the notice you will be in violation of the Newport Beach
Municipal Code and subject to penalties.
10. Your permit will not be final until we have conducted an on site inspection once construction is
completed as per Municipal Code, Section 17.24, if we have not been contacted for a final inspection.
OFFICE USE ONLY
Approval in Concept.
Date
Approval of the City of Newport Beach Council..
Date
Approval ofthe Army Corps of Engineers
Date
Approval of the California Coastal Commission.
Date
Approval of the City's Public Works Department.
Date
Approval of the City's Building Department.
Date
Approval of County of Orange.
Date
Electrical and/or plumbing permit (Building Department)
Date
Issued. (Permit is stamped drawing)
Date
Site Inspection. (call 644-3043 for appointment)
Date
Site Re -Inspection
Date
Conditions:
OWNER -BUILDER DECLARATION
I hereby affirm that I am exempt from the contractor's license law for the following reasons:
(Sec. 7031d.5, Business and professions Code). Any City or County which requires a permit to
construct, alter, improve, demolish, or repair any structure, prior to its issuance, also requires
the applicant for such permit to file a signed statement that he is licensed pursuant to the
provision of the Contractors License Law (Chapter 9, commencing with Section 7000, of
Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code) or that he is exempt therefrom and the basis
for the alleged exemption. Any violation of Section 7031.5 by any applicant for a permit
subjects the applicant to a civil penalty for not more than five hundred dollars ($500).
—�—I, as owner of the property, or my employees with wages as their sole compensation,
will do the work, and the structure is not intended or offered for sale (Sec. 7044, Business and
Professions Code: The Contractor's License Law does not apply to an owner of property who
builds or improves thereon, and who does such work himself or through his own employees,
provided that such improvements are not intended or offered for sale. If, however, the
building or improvement is sold within one year of completion, the owner -builder will have
the burden of proving that he did not build or improve for the purpose of sale).
— L as owner of the property, am exclusively contracting with licensed contractors to
construct the project (Sec. 7044, Business and Professions Code: The Contractor's License Law
does not apply to an owner of property who builds or improves thereon, and who contracts for
such projects who builds or improves thereon, and who contracts for such projects with a
Contractor(s) License pursuant to the Contractor's License Law).
I am exempt under Sec. of Business and Professional Code for this reason:
Owner's Signature: A 9,4W4 Date:
Contractor: Telephone:
Address: a -Ier Afy c- XljO J3 2- 4
License class: State Boar(4 No. City License No.
License Contractor's Declaration
I hereby affirm that I am licensed under provisions of Chapter 9 (commencing with Section
7000) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code, and my license is in full force and
effect.
Contractor's Signature — Date:
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH. '4 01 va -- Tkrea U&Its.
-r i C
CITY w 31, X 10 X 49 0111� C 2, P141a i, +1,"4 . go
NENPORT BE=
sum
-t 7f-
bw
wa I
P19Q;-ZC
ww
VICINITY MRP JEM PROF I LE -31Z :k 40
jaw SOUNDINGS FM MWSSED IN FEET F10 MOTE
S i e- apmTIONS B%D ON WM LMM LOW WRTER.
Grolq wall Mai4wAance 'Irmij.
L't is t'
Permit is to allow maintenance of existing
g r .
rom wall on private property, i.e. Deeded
i
c
Beach Lotto Mean High Tide Line,
r.T
Of
Ewa&; -&F L94 Aloksr
AW Wn
C
k.
qlqE q2
Afeikadki &-rf". IiAL64 Lai
6
lz
Is wc
IMM 7 16 9�1
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
HARBOR PERMIT
PERMISSION 188 HERMY GRANTED TO CONSTRUCT AND
mNTAiN THE FAciLrfy SHOWN ON THE REVERSE HEREOR
TW�PRCPJISIONS OF
:TWIHARBOR PERM POUCIESsOF110*401131=1 z-13FACHAIM
ANY SPECIAL COWITIONS LISTED, HEREON. THIS PERNT
IS NOT TRANSFERAME WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF
T14E CITY HARBOR CDORIXNAMR crry COUNCIL THE
RIGHTS SIM UNDER THIS RE PEPNISSIVE ONLY
ANW PERNI BE R BY THE CRY COUNCIL
IN p 7 THE MUN
crWKARBOR COORDINATO
PERMIT NO. DATE
or�
or,
211
14
CC
Z/ av -fb""
z
ao,
IL X
< 0 w x z
w
2 0 :)
o u w
z z 0
mm
0 ca
co
-41� 4. U < -cc
co 1 5- Tn
aw 2-0 Z-. 2.
q� �w �L- -C
b ..0
U)
0
th (L -2
'41
LLI
:. —
0
�b,
C;
d)
N .4
—.ob
46
0/ -ow ;eb"ov 5;7--V-
a 0
NS
6
a
0
P
4
It
ec
W
t
az
Vi IL
21
NOJ9N1HSVAj'.-
Nt n481
a!
I .I,
A
.133,YLS
mw�
0
-. Z2
o
u
lu
0 flul
4-0 'A UL
r
z
ul z
x
U,
U,
0
tilt
5
0
-. Z2
o
u
lu
It
IS:
0 flul
4-0 'A UL
r
z
ul z
U,
U,
0
5
0
z
CM
It
IS:
0.
. . I B0098598 K1850
Order F—low
N �ber o5z2a4__Number 5829
RFCORD,NG FVEQUFI
. .. . ........... I ........... AT REOULST OF
WHEN RCCORDrD- PLEA$E MAIL TO 71TLE 111S. & I �UST CO -
0
MA L T R E7:
— Q'j - Or
0 DED A I
EC E E 111S UST Co
IRST; , R. 71TL C 17
FIN 014FICIAL RECORDS OF
OrANGF_ COUN' CALIF.
YETHOD kttT CORPORATION .... . . ........ ....... 8:00 AM MAY 9
$2 So
...............
c_70- `S* t e . ...... $2.80 1 i.WYLIECARLYLE.
........... ....... ...
%00 . ...... . ................. . ....................... 5.00
od, Calif- 90028
SPACE A13OVE THIS LINE FOR Rr.:-Pm
(00 PROPOTI MIANSp-M TAX STAMPS $220-00
r ant Deed
........................
............
...................... . . . . . . . . . . .
..................................................... I ......................................
......... . . . . -1 1 do!,..A. hereby
For a Valuable Considerati. on, the rel --'!Pt of which is herchy acknowle ge
nia..cp� .............................. .
.p.orati n .............................
tzrHOD AR C . .......
GW%NT to * ..................... .... g lqt�t
................................................................ .... . ................................................................ ............................................... . .........................
all that real property situated in 'Ne County of .......... PrAnelft ..................................... I State of Calffornia, described as follows'
ATTACFM JEaAL DESCRIPTION AFF,IXTED IF-RETO:
PA!RCEL , 1: Lot 2 in Block 2 of the Balboa BaYside Tracts as per map recorded in Book 4
Page 78 of Miscellaneous Maps$ records of said Orange COIJT'tY-
ownshi� 6 South, Pan!e 10 West, Of
PARCEL 2: That.gortion of Lot S of section.3 P said land fi ed in the
0 ffici plat o
the San Bernardi o Meridian, as per the o
District Land offices August 4s 1890, described an follows:
Beginning at the Northeast corner of Lot 2 in Block Z -of Balboa Bayside Tract as
per map recorded in Book 4, page 78 of Miscellaneous apa in the office of the
county Recorder of said County; thence Northwesterly along the Northeasterly line
of slid Block 2 to the Northwest corner of said.Lot 2;'thence Northeaster;y along
,ation of the Northwesterly line of said Lot 2 to its inter—
the Northeasterly prolong
section with the line of ordinary�high tide of the Pacific Ocean in Newport Bays as
5, 1928 in the Superior Court of the State
established by Decree rendered November . a certified copy of which Decree was
of Ca:Lifon:).ia, in and for the County of Orange, cial Records; thence South—
mber 9, 1928 in Book 215 page 160 of Offi asterly prolongation
recorded Nove ersection with the Northe
easterly along the said tide line to its int of'beginning.
). thence Southwesterly to the point
of the Southeasterly line of said Lot 2,
E=0pting th , erefrom any portion of said land lying within the ordinary mean High
Tide line of the Pacific Ocean in Newport Bay. p recorded, in Book 4
PARCEL 3: Lots 3 and -4 In Block 2 of Balboa Bayside Tract,'as per ma.
page 78 of yicallaneous Mapes records of said Orange County.
Lot 8 in .5 , Township 6 South, Range 0 West of the
.ection 33 1 District
PARCEL 4: That portion of filed in the
San Bernardino Meridian, as per the Official Plat of said land
Land Office August 4, 1890, described as follows:
2 of the Balboa Bayside Tract,
Northeasterly corner of Lot 3 in Block office of the
> Beginning at the page 78 of Miscellaneous MaPst inthe
as per map recorded in Book I Northwesterly along the Northeasterly line of
County Recorder of said County; thence hwesterly corner of said Lot 4j' thence th4
Lott! 3 and 4 in said Block 2 to the Nort
easterly along the Northeasterly prolongation of the Northwesterly li;e of sai.414W
the line of ordinary high tide of the Pacific' Ocean in Newport
to its intersection with Intys Californiap
Bays as described in tne decree of the Superior Court of orange Cot 9, 1928 in
ember 5, 1928, a certified copy of which was recorded November
dated Nov asterly along said tide line to �ts
Book 215, page 160 of official Records, thence Southe
ion with the Northeasterly prolongation of the Southeasterly Line of said
intersect Uon of said Southeasterly line of said',
Lot 3; thence Southwesterly along the prolonge
Lot 3 to the point cf beonning.
hin the ordinary man High Tid
E=epting therefrom any portiRn Of said land wit
ewport Bay.
line of the Pacific Ocean in
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH PO
PA YMENT A UTHORIZA TION
Demand of. Pete Swift
-1 FO
Address: Swift slip
500 30th Street
Newport Beach, CA 92663 Date: 9111198
Amount. $3,067.00
item of Expenditure Invoice jNo. Budget No. Amount
ffB�ala:nce due on constrction. E5340 C2360058 $3,067.00
Work was complete on 8127198.
City of Newport Beach P. 0. #18317
Sales Tax I
TOTAL $3,067.00
1 — c
Description/Special Instructions:
City is joining with the adjacent property owners to build groin wall. Property
owners have contributed $2,240.00 each and these funds have been deposited
to the City Account #C2360058.
Department Approval:
Acctg. Mgr. Approval:
Date: 9111198
Date:
Fin. Dir. Approval: - I Date:
W. vi m 1 "N' 2 w
dt C-AUFORNIA COASTAL comwsstoN
E
N
N
E
E
r
IV
N
s
T
s
u
c
T
0
p
s
ADVANCO CONSTRUCTORS
DIV. OF ZURN CONSTRUCTORS, INC.
1500 WEST NINTH STREET, P.O. BOX 1210
1 UPLAND, CALIFORNIA 91785
FAX COVER SHEET
��Nmqi
'TELEPHONE!
(909) 982-8803
FAX NIO.:
(909) 982�0716
COMPANY:fj:7.�.e-5�- PHONE:
ATTENTION:
FROM: JIM PIERI
LIDO PUMP STATION
NO. PAGES___2
(INCLUDIN,G TFHS SFMET)
949.723.4760
949-723.4675 FAX
SL9t7 2M- 6VE *ON 3NCH6
WULS:6 666T 71 -if
NOIiuls*dk'r6*OGJ7 03N�d('Gb -
7-08-1.998 1:11PM
FROM BECHTEL ENV INC S62 807 2S38
�m
G�-9V ZZ4 EVE : 'ON ENOHd
E d kl,�LS:E eEET'6 7ni
NcIiuis*c�wnd*cG17 c3Ndoou : WC6.�
STATE OF CAUFORNIA-THE RESOURCES �.---a4CY
California Coastal Commission
South Coast Area
200 Oceangate, 1 Oth floor
Long Beach, CA 90802
(562) 590-5071
Re: Application/Appeal No.
PEW VALSOK G*M7W
STATUS LETTER
The status of this matter is noted below.
���Your application was filed o�
Th blic hearing/,;s tentat'vely scheduled on
-- — — 7- Z . , ntative sct4duling ififormation
inT ez This te
is be—in'g pDrTvideed for your convenience and is subject to change.
Written notification of final scheduling of the hearing, along with a
copy of the staff report, wi 1 be mai ed approximately 10 days prior to
the hearing.
---IMPORTANT: The- -encl-osed Notice of Pending Pemit must be posted- on the
site, in a conspicuous place, within 3 days of its receipt.
his application is incomple e and cannot be filed or processed until
the items listed on the atta I hed sheet have been completed and submitted
to the District office. If hese items have not been received by the
date indicated, the entire p�ackage will be returned to you.
Please be advised that the 4ems needed to complete your application
must be submitted to this of f ice by
This file is being returned �as the application submitted is deemed
incomplete. Ths required substantive documents are missing. Please
see the attached sheet.
This appeal was received
to be a valid appeal. You will be not
public hearing.
and has been detemined
fied of the place and date of the
Th . is appeal was received after the expiration
of the appeal period, hencelt is not a valid appeal.
This appeal was received
invalid for the following
10-92/6351E
but has been determined
son:
tions, please contact this office at (310) 590-5071.
NOTICE OF
PENDING PERMIT
A, PERMIT APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT ON THIS SITE IS
PENDING BEFORE THE CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION.
PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT:
Installation of a 48 foot long, 2.5 inch thick plastic groin wall.
The 8 foot plastic panels will be hand jetted into the bay.
LOCATION -
Adams Street streetend (Adams and Edgewater), Newport Beach
(Orange County)
APPLICANT(S):
Newport Beach Fire And Marine Department, Attn: Tony Melum, Deputy
Chief
APPLICATION NUMBER: 5-97-334
DATE NOTICE POSTED:
For further information, please phone or write the office listed below
between 8 AM and 5 PM, weekdays.
CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION
SOUTH COAST AREA
PO Box 1450
200 Oceangate, 10th Floor
LONG BEACH, CA 90802-4416
(562) 590-5071
�Z'
shelimaker inc.
June 9, 1998
City of Newport Beach
Marine Department
P. 0. Box 1768
Newport Beach, CA 92659-1768
Attn: Tony Melum
Re: Dredging @ Adams Street
INVOICE
June8,1998
Dredge to replenish beach.
1 tidal cycle @ $1,400.00/cycle
Overtime Excess - lump sum $150.00*
Total
$1,400.00
$150.00
$1,560.00
*We waived part of the overtime due to the fact that there were 3 nights at adjacent
beaches so the mobilzation was less. We normally get $25. 001hourlman for each hour
before 0706 or after 1530.
Terms: payable upon receipt
Thank You!
875 B West 15th Street, Newport Beach, California 92663 Phone (714) 548-5359 Fax(714)548-5315
General Engineering Contractors/License No. 561434/Marine Construction and Dredging
STATE OF CALIFORNIA - THE RESOURCES AGENCY
CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION
Sbuth Coa?t Area Office
200 Oceangate,.10th Floor
Long Beach, CA 90802-4302
(562) 590-5071
)ETE WILS
Filed: 06-09-98
49th Day: 07-28-98
180th Day: 12-06-98
Staff: RMR-LB*Kft
Staff Report: July 16, 1998
Hearing Date: August 11-14, 1998
commission Action:
STAFF REPORT: REGULAR CALENDAR
APPLICATION NO.: 5-97-334
PROJECT LOCATION: Adams Street Streetend, Newport Beach, Orange County
PROJECT DESCRIPTION: Installation of a 48 foot long, 2.5 inch thick plastic
groin wall. The groin, consisting of eight footlong plastic panels, will be
hand jetted into the harbor in order to reduce turbidity.
SUMMARY OF STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
The staff recommends that the Commission determine that the proposed
development, as conditioned, is consistent with the resource protection
policies of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act. There are no unresolved issues
associated with this project and the applicant does not object to the special
condition regarding protection of the marine environment during construction.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
The Staff recommends that the Commission adopt the following resolution:
The Commission hereby grants, subject to the conditions below, a permit for
the proposed development on the grounds that the development, as conditioned,
will be in conformity with the provisions of Chapter 3 of the California
Coastal Act of 1976, will not prejudice the ability of the local governme I nt
having jurisdiction over the Area to prepare a Local Coastal Program
conforming to the provisions of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act, is located
between the sea and first public toad nearest the shoreline and is in
conformance with the public access.and public recreation policies of Chapter 3
of the Coastal Act, and will not have any ' significant adverse impacts on the
environment within the meaning of the California Environmental Quality Act.
5-97-334
Page 2
LOCAL APPROVALS RECEIVED:
Approval in concept from the City of Newport Beach Fire and Marine Department
SUBSTANTIVE FILE DOCUMENTS:
City of Newport Beach Certified Land Use Plan
11. Standard Conditions
1. Notice of Receipt and-Acknowledcrment. The permit is not valid and
development shall not commence until a copy of the permit, signed by the
permittee or authorized agent, acknowledging re ' ceipt of the permit and
acceptance of the terms and conditions, is returned to the Commission
office.
2. Expiration. If development has not commended, the permit will expire two
years from the date this permit is reported to the Commission.
Development shall be pursued in a diligent manner and completed in a
reasonable period of time. Application for extension of the permit must
be made prior to the expiration date.
3. Compliance. All development must occur in strict compliance with the
proposal as set forth in the application for permit, subject to any
special conditions set forth below. Any deviation from the approved plans
Must be reviewed and approved by the staff and may require Commission
approval.
4. Interpretation. Any questions of intent or interpretation of any
condition will be resolved by the Executive Director or the Commission.
S. Inspections. The Commission staff shall be allowed to inspect the site
and the project during its development, subject to 24-hour advance notice.
6. Assignment., The permit may be assigned to any qualified person, provided
assignee files with the Commission an affidavit accepting all terms and
conditions of the permit.
7. Terms and Conditions Run with the Land. These terms and conditions shall
be perpetual, and it is the intention of the Commission and the permittee
to bind all future owners and POSBessors of the subject property to the
terms and conditions.
III. Special Condition
1. Construction Responsibilities and Debris Removal
The project shall be constructed as proposed, hand -jetted from 1 - and during low
tide, in order to reduce significant adverse impacts on the marine
environment. The applicant agrees not to store any construction materials or
waste where it is subject to wave erosion and dispersion. In addition, no
machinery will be allowed in the intertidal gone at any time. The permittee
shall remove from the beach and streetend area any and all debris which
results from the construction period.
5-97-334
Page 3
IV. Findinas and Declarations:
The Commission hereby finds and declares:
A. Proiect Description
The proposed development consists of the installation of a 48 foot long, 2.5
inch wide plastic sheet groin wall. The groin wall will be hand jetted into
Newport Harbor at the Adams Street streetend. The purpose of the groin is to
block the flow of sand into a deep water marina, maintain a sandy beach and
protect a storm drain outlet (see Exhibit 4).
The proposed development is located in Newport Harbor on the north side of the
Balboa Peninsula at the Adams Street streetend (see Exhibit 1). To the cast
is a deep water marina containing harbor cruise boats, sports fishing boats,
the ferry crossing and the Fun Zone. To the West is residential development
with docks and boats.
There is an existing remnant of a 40 foot long concrete groin located at the
eastern portion of the Adams Street streetend.(see Exhibit 4). This concrete
groin structure was constructed in the 1960s, but has broken up so that only
20 feet of it remains. This old concrete groin served the function of keeping
sand out of the deep water marina adjacent to it. There are no plans to
remove the remnant of the concrete groin.
Exhibit 3 is an aerial of the location showing where the groin wall will be
placed. This exhibit also shows the concrete groin remnant and the eroding
beach. The ferry crossing is shown on the bottom left hand corner of Exhibit
3. Exhibit 4 is a close-up photograph of the Adams St. streetend and Newport
Landing. In the center of this photograph a man is standing on a dock
adjacent to the concrete groin wall remnant, which is to the right of him.
Further right is the storm drain outlet. Exhibit 5 is a photograph looking
east from the eroding beach towards the Adams St. streetend. Exhibit 6 is a
section of the proposed groin wall.
B. Coastal Protection Structures
Section 30235 of the Coastal Act contains the policies for allowing coastal
protection structures. It states:
Revetments, breakwaters, groins, harbor channels, seawalls, cliff
retaining walls, and other such construction that alters natural shoreline
processes shall be permitted when required to serve coastal -dependent uses
or to protect existing structures or public beaches in danger from
erosion, and when designed to eliminate or mitigate adverse impacts on
local shoreline sand supply. Existing marine structures causing water
stagnation contributing to pollution problems and fish kills should be
phased out or upgraded where feasible.
The applicant submitted a letter from Lloyd Dalton, PE, a deiign engineer for
the City of Newport Beach Public Works Department (see Exhibit 8).. In this
letter he discusses the need for the proposed groin wall.
Currently local tidal action has increased in intensity from the west to
the east and has caused a long shore transport of sand from the sandy
sloping i beach, � to,the . storm'.drain: and: � into the deep ;water � marina. The
5-97-334
Page 4
ituation suggests that a groin in this area would slow the observed
rosion thereby maintaining the sandy sloping beach to the west, reducing
erosion across the City street end and retarding deposition of material
from those two locations into the deep water marina.
As recommended by this engineer, the proposed groin wall would be 48 feet
long. The City also states that the individual groin wall panels would be
hand -jetted into place from ' the landward side of the bay. The construction is
estimated at two days and the construction methodology ensures that a minimum
amount of turbidity will occur. The proposed groin would be located within
the U.S. Pierhead Line, within the jurisdiction of the City of Newport Beach,
and will not extend further seaward than the existing adjacent docks.
The Adams St streetend is located between a deep water marina to the east and
recreational boating to the west. immediately to the east of the concrete
groin remnant is a Shell fuel dock and a point of departure for 60-70 foot
long sport fishing and party boats (see Exhibit 3). These services are
available to the public. Further to the east is the ferry crossing. The City
.has an ongoing permit to conduct maintenance dredging in this area. However,.
the City expects that placement of the groin wall will interrupt the flow of
sand into the deep water marina and cut down on the frequency of dredging
required in this area.
Section 30235 of the Coastal Act requires that construction that alters
natural shoreline processses shall be permitted when required to serve
coastal -dependent uses or to protect existing structures or public beaches in
danger from erosion. In this case the deep water marina provides sports
fishing services which are a coastal dependent use. In addition, the groin
wall is designed to prevent the public beach to the west of the streetend from
eroding and silting up the deep -water marina. The proposed groin wall would
have the effect of stopping beach erosion and allowing the beach to build up
west of the groin wall. Therefore, the proposed development is consistent
with Section 30235 of the Coastal Act.
C. Marine Environment
Section 30231 of the Coastal Act states:
The biological productivity and the quality of coastal waters, streams,
wetlands, estuaries, and lakes appropriate to maintain optimum populations
of marine organisms and for the protection of human health shall be
maintained and, where feasible, restored through, among other means,
minimizing adverse effects of waste water discharges and entrainment,
controlling runoff, preventing depletion of ground water supplies and
substantial interference with surface water flow, encouraging waste water
reclamation, maintaining natural vegetation buffer areas that protect
riparian habitats, and minimizing alteration of natural streams.
The proposed development consists of the installation of a groin wall in
Newport Bay. The groin wall panels are 8 feet long and two and a half inches
wide. The panels will be hand -jetted into place by a construction crew
working on the landward side of the bay. No barges will be used in the
installation of the groin wall and any siltation or turbidity would be
minimal, resulting from the hand -jetting of the panels. Construction is
estimated to take two days. Placement of the groin wall would reduce the flow
of sand,into the,.deep-water marinaland reduce,,the frequency.of dredging which
4
5-97-334
Page 5
is currently required. The temporary impacts from placement of the groin wall
are far less than the impacts on dredging on water quality.
Hand -jetting is a process whereby the harbor bottom sand is loosened by the
application of concentrated water. water directed from a hose liquefies the
sand and allows the panels to be shoved into the harbor bottom manually. The
process is conducted at periods of low tide to facilitate placement of the
panels and minimize harbor disturbance. Sand is then placed back against the
panels to help stabilize it. The groin wall would be removed by the same
process. Finally, the top of the wall is connected by 3 x 6 boards and capped
with 2 x 12 boards. The side boards are bolted into the panel and the top
board is then bolted onto the side boards (see Exhibit 6).
Exhibit 9 is a distribution notice from the Army Corps of Engineers. In this
notice the Army Corps notes that there would be no impact to eelgrass or other
sensitive coastal resources. No mitigation will be required from the
California Department of Fish and Game or the Army Corps of Engineers.
Placement of the groin wall will not involve mechanized equipment or other
types of normal construction methods because the groin wall is not a hardened,
engineered structure. Impacts from the placement of the wall are temporary
and localized. However, the project does involve temporary storage of
materials and some construction. In order to ensure that construction debris
does not end up in the harbor, the applicant is conditioned to agree that any
and all construction materials be stored away from the harbor and that any and
all construction debris be removed at the conclusion of the project.
Only as conditioned does the Commission find that the project conforms with
Section 30231 of the Coastal Act.
D. Public Access and Recreation
Section 30604(c) of the Coastal Act requires that every coastal development
permit issued for any development between the nearest public road and the sea
includes a specific finding that the development is in conformance with the
public access and recreation policies of Chapter 3 of the Coastal Act. The
proposed development is located between the sea and the first public road.
Section 30212 of the Coastal Act states, in relevant part:
(a) Public access from the nearest public roadway to the shoreline and
along the coast shall.be provided in new development projects.except
where:
(2) adequate access exists nearby.
The proposed development is located at a public streetend which currently
provides public access to the bay. The applicant has indicated that the
installation of the groin wall will take place over a period of two days. The
project location is not a destination point for tourists and is not a local
beach destination point, although the beach can be utilized by the public.
Therefore, although construction of the groin wall will involve some impacts
on public access to the streetend, these impacts are temporary and not
significant.
5-97-334
Page 6
In addition, the beach along the harbor at this location will benefit from the
build-up Of Band behind the groin wall. Although not a significant beach
destination point, the beach can be utilized by the public and thus the public
will benefit from the placement of the groinwall.
Therefore, the Commission finds that the proposed development does not pose
significant adverse impacts on public access and recreation and is consistent
with Section 30212 of the Coastal Act.
E. Land Use Plan
Section 30604(a) of the Coastal Act provides that the Commission shall issue a
coastal permit only if the project will not prejudice the ability of the local
government having jurisdiction to prepare a Local Coastal Program which
conforms with Chapter 3 policies of the Coastal Act.
The Commission certified the Land Use Plan for the City of Newport Beach on
May 19, 1982. As conditioned, the proposed development is consistent with the
policies contained in the certified Land Use Plan. Therefore, approval of the
proposed development will not prejudice the City's ability to prepare a Local
Coastal Program for San Clemente that is consistent with the Chapter 3
policies of the Coastal Act as required by Section 30604(a).
F. Consistency.with the California Environmental Ouality Act
Section 13096 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations requires
commission approval of Coastal Development Permits to be supported by a
finding showing the amendment to the coastal development permit, as
Conditioned by any conditions of approval, to be consistent with any
applicable requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).
Section 21080.5(d)(2)(A) of CEQA prohibitb a proposed development from being
approved if there are feasible alternatives or feasible mitigation measures
available which would substantially lessen any significant adverse.effect
which the activity may have on the environment.
The proposed project has been conditioned in order to be found consistent with
the water quality policies of Section 30231 of the Coastal Act. A mitigation
measure; a special condition requiring placement of con truction materials and
removal of construction debris, will minimize all adver:e effects. As
conditioned, there are no feasible alternatives or feasible mitigation
measures available, beyond those required, which would substantially lessen
any significant adverse effect which the activity may have on the -
environment. Therefore, the Commission finds that the proposed project, as
conditioned to mitigate the identified effects, is the least environmentally
damaging feasible alternative and can be found consistent with the
requirements of the Coastal Act to conform to CEQA.
0879G
sela, sox/
Fi
I z 1 3 t 4 1 5 to lq�
4 2, 3
*4Z
&4.S. -01
H504
X/f "6no,&J WAL4
�VWAP x 4 'e�
EXHIBIT NO. 2n
APPLICATIONJ�
camomia constai commission
r
sela, sox/
Fi
I z 1 3 t 4 1 5 to lq�
4 2, 3
*4Z
&4.S. -01
H504
X/f "6no,&J WAL4
�VWAP x 4 'e�
EXHIBIT NO. 2n
APPLICATIONJ�
camomia constai commission
:40
'aZ
ki
4pV oi -,z
i"z m
-,t7
I Ser
41r
-16,
'M
ice
j
't N -V —
E X H 15 1
�T NO.
)N NO
JATIC
APPLI
3*3
California Coastal Commiralon
VM0411YD
r5ta 9 bvw
MN)
Ar
-S A
005
tall;
led.
NJ,
-i t
ms
KHIBIT NO. Ll
)-�— — - - NO.
PLIJATION
No"
a coastai commission
laic callforni,
'Ai
W1
4u. V,
jlVq MA X
1r;
Ol
Ax
RV
.37
j '7�7
IF\
�e . !f5a
Ell
of 0;
gg �.,
�F-40
EXHIBIT N 0.
A LIC110
Itop
x. rr"
it
Californift CoAstal commisolon
gy
DO—' ' r%
S1
nay
r
era
6
EXHIBIT NO.(._
APPLIC&IION
Califorria Coastal Commiss=j
NEWPORT BEACH FIRE AND MARINE DEPARTMENT
March 11, 1998
Ms. Robin Maloney-Rarnes
C/o California Coastal Com'mission
South Coast Area Office
200 Oceangate, 10th Floor
Long Beach, CA 908024302
COASTAL COWISSION
Re: Coastal Development Permit #5-97-334
Dear Robin:
Regarding your request for additional infon-nation:
1. It is my understanding you have received approval both from the
Department of Fish and Game and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
regarding the above project.
2. In discussions with the Regional Water Quality Control Board and the
Army Corp of Engineers, it is proposed that this Corp permit Will be
issued under the Corp's general permit and as a result no Regional
Water Quality Control Board Certification is required. Regarding an
alternative analysis per section 30233, the purpose of the groin is to
maintain an existing beach to the west of the location and existing
depth in a vessel berthing area to the east. At this time there is no
feasible alternative other than groining to do this work unless we just
go to continued and periodic dredging, which seems more obtrusive
than doing a groin and limiting the amount of dredging.
3. We have included photographs of the project site and. an aerial.
Photograph #1 and 2 depict the City street end and the very top of the
storm drain and the deep -water marina to the left of the City street
end. The groin will be -installed on the right hand side of the street
end, parallel and adjacent to the recreational pier that runs from the
bulkhead bayward. In photograph #1 there is a gentlemen standing at
the dock and adjacent to the floating structure is a concrete structure
installeds'ometime in the 1960s. The groin was originally 40 feet long,
but over the years 20 feet of it have been broken off and not reinstalled.
As a result, sand migration from the standy, sloping beach to the west
has excelerated it n-dgration into the deep water marina on the
eastward side. Photograph #3 shows the sandy, sloping beach, which
is slowing eroding away towards the deep water marina and is
anticipated, once the groin is installed on the easterly side of- the
recreational pier, that it will reduce --that erosion.
4. Attached is a report from Pur design engineer with the City of
Newport Beach.
5. The groin wall will be 48 feet long from the bulkhead, 48 feet bayward.
The individual panels are 8 feet long and will be hand -jetted into place
with a small jet pump by the construction crew. The panels
themselves are 2 1/2 inches thick with a 2 inch wailer on either side -for
a total thickness on the cap of approximately 7 inches. The work'�;M
all be done on the landward side of the bay. No barges will be used
during the construction. It is proposed that the wall will installed
w 'thin a 2 day period and there should be a minimum amount of silt
because of the jetting method generated at the site.
6. The City has made application to the Army Corp of Engineers and that
permit is pending.
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
PUBLIC WORK� DEPARTMENT
141FOIX PO. BOX 1768, NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92658-8915
(714) 644-3311
a -10798
Mr. Robin Maloney Ramus
California Coastal Commission M4
200 Oceangate, 10' Floor
Long Beach, CA 908024302 CALIFORNIA
Re: Coas I tal Development Permit # 5-97-334 COASTAL COMMISS'O'%
Dear Mr. Ramus:
Tony Melum, Deputy Chief of the Marine Environmental Division, Fire and Marine Department,
asked that I respond to your request for an engineering perspective on the need for a groin at this
area. The site consists of a sandy sloping beach to the west, a City street end with storm drain
pipes extending into the bay, and a deep water marina to the east of the street end.
Currently local tidal action has increased in intensity from the west to the east and has caused a
long shore transport of sand from the sandy sloping beach, to the storm drain and into the deep-
water marina. The situation suggests that a groin in this area would slow the observed erosion
thereby maintaining the sandy sloping beach to the west, reducing erosion across the City street
end and retarding deposition of material from those two locations into the deep water marina. To
be effective the groin should be at least 48 feet long. Attached is a signed drawing by a
registered structural engineer for a proposed groin that was previously submitted to the Coastal
Commission. The proposed groin would be sufficient when constructed according to the
attached plan to maintain the sand elevations and reduce the erosion experience in this location.
However, it is critical that the sand elevations be maintained as depicted in the plan.
The benefits of the groin installation are threefold. If located as proposed, the groin will assist in
stopping the erosion from the publicly used sandy sloping beach to the west. It will also reduce
the long shore current, which is eroding the City street end and exposing supports for a City
storm drain. And finally, it will reduce sand transport from those two locations into the deep-
water marina to the east. The groin will be jetted in under low pressure. If the need should arise,
the groin could be easily removed using the same, process.
I hope this answers your questions. If I can be of further assistance, please contact me at 949-
644-3328.
Sincerely,
EXHIBIT NO.
EXHIB IT
i
APPLICAEITrio
_9 i '. YW
E
N
,Lfd Dalton, PE
M'sign Engineer
3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach constal commission
Let-
�REGULATORY-L.A. ID:213452 V� gLo�'98 8,' 22 -No. 006 P. 01,
4*9 b 9 U
MAR 2 7 1998
CAUFC-;ZNIA R ECEIVE D
LOS AN G E L &O�MRSPPM'l S I ON MAR 2 4 1998
U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS CALIFORNIA
COASTAL COMMISSION
LOP-FACBM116E TRANSHITTAL
US ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS DISTRICT CONTACT:
LOS ANGELES DISTRICT--SPL-CO-R Name: Spencer MacNeil
P.O. BOX 532711 - Phone: (213) 452-3418
LOS ANGELES, CA 90053-2325 FAX: (213) 452-4196
DATE INITIATED: March 24# 1998 Please review the LOP materials and
provide substantive, site-specific comments to the District on or before
April 8, 1998. If no comments are received by this date, the District
assumes compliance with 33 CFR Part 325.2(c)(1).
AGENCY: FAX number Attn:
[X] California Department of Fish and Game 619-467-4299 M. Fluharty
[X] U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 415-744-1078 R. Tuden
JX1 U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service 760-431-9.624 J. Fancher
JXJ National Marine Fisheries Service 562-514-6194 B. Hoffman
Jx] U.S. Coast Guard 510-437-2961 M. VanHouten
JX] California Coastal Commission 415-904-5400 J. Raives
Lop NumBER _980-00135-813L
EXF1*131T NO.
APPLICANT NAM: City of Newport Beach APPL.LCATION
Attn: Tony Kelm, Deputy -Chief.
P.O. Box 1768
Newport Beach, CA 91658-8915
(714)644-3041
Cafiforni.% constai corumsrion
WATZR'KkY VIAME: Newport Bay
LOCATZONt The proposed work would be done just seaward of 427 Edgewater,
within Newport Bay, in the City of Newport Beach, Orange County, California
(see attached).
33RIET DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED WORX; The applicant -proposes to replace a
failing 40 foot concrete groin constructed during the 1960's with a 48 foot
long 2.5 inch wide plastic groin wall. The new groin would be installed
slightly westward of the failing groin to maximize protection of an
existing sandy beach, City street end, and storm.drain to the west and a
deep water marina to the east. The applicant would hand -jet each 8 -foot
long plastic panel to minimize silt entrainment. The proposed work and the
resulting structure would be within the U.S. Pierhead Line and would not
require dredging or use of a barge. The applicant estimates the work could
be done in 2 days.
AREA OF WATERS MMJZCT To LOSS AS A RESMT OF PROPOSED WORK: -The project
would increase the coverage area of waters of the U.S. by 0.0006 acres.
There would be no impact to eelgrass or other sensitive coastal resources.
NEWPORT BEACH FIRE AND MARINE DEPARTMENT
March 12,1998
California Coastal Commission
South Coast Area
200 Oceangate, 10ffi Floor
Long,Beach, CA 90802
Dear Sirs:
This application is for the construction of a 48 foot groin wall,
immediately bayward of Adams Street streetend. The proposed groin
wall should have the following effect on the adjacent beaches. The
beach immediately to the west is a sandy slopping beach. The area to
the east is a relatively deep -water boat berthing facility. It is assumed
that the groin wall will stabilize the sand on the sandy, sloping beach
and assist in maintaining usable water depth at the marina
irnmediately to the east. It will do this by slowing the n-dgration of
sand from the sandy, sloping beach into the deep -water marina. This
condition will also be augmented by periodic dredging from the deep-
water marina and the placement of the dredged sands on the sandy,
sloping beach to the west.
Sincerely,
Lloyd Dalton
Public Works Design Engineer
a
Marine Consulting& Design
-71, \/ I I,? I-) �-n / J,—
iJ
f--,4. VZ-:T�27-
50G, FZIe
P�-I�qL-77�C Z-1-IMEE-,F
-T, T
M, 04
'Af ;Umooa
ID
STATE OF CALIFORNIA—THE RESOURCES AGENCY
PETE WILSON, Govemor
California Coastal Commission
South Coast Area
200 Oceangate, 1 Oth floor
Long Beach, CA 90802
(562) 59D-5071 APPLICATION FOR COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT
SECTION 1. APPLICANT
1. Name, mailing address, and telephone number of all applicants.
City of Newport Beach
P. 0. Box 1768
Newport Beach, CA 92658
(714) 644-3041
(Area codeldaytime phone number)
Note: All applicants for the development must complete Appendix A, the declaration of campaign
contributions.
2. Name, mailing address and telephone number of applicant's representatives, H any. Please include all
representatives who will communicate on behalf of the applicant or the applicant's business partners, for
compensation, withthe Commission or the staff. (it is the applicant's responsibility to update this list, as
appropriate, including after the application is accepted for filing. Failure to provide this information prior to
communication with the Commission or staff may result in -denial of the permit or criminal penalties)
Tony Melum, Deputy Chief
P. 0. Box 1768
Newport Beach, CA 92658
(714) 644-3041
(Area codeldaytime phone number)
SECTION 11. PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT
Please answer all questions. Where questions do not apply to your project (for instance, project height for a
land divis-10n), indicate Not Applicable or N.A..
1. Project Location. Include street address, city, and/or county. If there is no street address, include
other description such as nearest cross streets.
Adams Street streetend (Adams and Edgewater)
number street
Newport Beach, Orange
City county
Assessor's Parcel Number(s) (obtainable from tax bill or County Assessor): N/A
FOR omcE usE oNL Y RECEIVED
FILED
FEE
APPLICATION NUMBER DATE PAID
4
2. Describe the proposed development in detail. Include secondary improvements such as grading, septic
tanks, water wells, roads, driveways, outbuildings, fences, etc. (Attach additional sheets as necessary.)
Construct a 48 foot long groin wall to stablize an
existing sandy sloping beach and provide protection to
an adjacent marina.
a. If mufti -family residential, state:
Existing Proposed new Net number of units on
- units I - units I completion of project
b. If land division or lot line adjustment, indicate:
Existing Proposed new Net number of lots n
lots ct Exist
lots Completion of projeo
3. Estimated cost of development (not irducling cost of land) $ 7,000.00
4. Project height: Maximum height of structure (ft.)
• above existing (naturw) grade ................................... + 6
• above finished grade ................................................
• as measured from centedine of frontage road .............
5. Total number of floors in structure, including
subterranean floors, lofts, and mezzanines N/A
2
0 rental
0 condominium
0 stock cooperative
0 time share
0 other
6. Gross floor area excluding parking (sq.ft.) N/A
Gross floor area including covered
parking and accessory buildings (sq.ft.) N/A
7. Lot area (within property lines) (sq.ft. or acre) N/A
8. Is any grading proposed? .......................................................................... 0 Yes xgl No
I bte:'ft' fdfloWng.
a) Amount of cut
cu. yds.
d) Maximum height of
ft.
cut slope
b) Amount of fill
cu. yds.
e) Maximum height of
ft.
fill slope
C) Amount of import or
cu. yds.
f) Location of bprrow
eXpOrt (circle which)
or disposal site
Grading and drainage plans must be included with this application. In certain areas, an engineering
geology report must also be included. See Section IV, paragraph 11 for the specifics of these
requirements.
Please list any geologic or other technical reports
of which you are aware that apply to this property
9. Parking: N/A
spaces (Indicii6' .. . ... ....... .
.:.Nuimber' ivhether standad orcbrnpact)�:" .... ..
.... ..... . .
Existing sp, Proposed new spaces Not number of spaces on completion 01
Is any existing parking being removed? ...................................................... Yes No
If yes, how many spaces? size
3
Is tandem parking existing and/or proposed? ............................................... Yes No
If yes, how many tandem sets? size
10. Are utility extensions for the following needed to serve the project? (Please check yes or no)
a) water b) _ms c) sewer d) electfic a) telephone
* Yes 0 Yes 0 Yes C3 Yes 0 Yes
* No xe No X3 No 0 No E] No
Will electric or telephone extensions be above -ground? ................................ 0 Yes
11. Does project include removal of trees or other vegetation? ........................... 0 Yes
If yes, indicate number, type and size of trees
or type and area of other vegetation
F'q-JW@
U91
SEC71ON 111. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
The relationship of the development to the applicable items below must be explained fully. Attach additional
sheets if necessary.
1 . Present use of property.
a. Are there existing structures on the property? ..................................... 0 Yes NO
..........
b. Will any existing structures be demolished? ........................................
0
Yes
13
NO
Will any existing structures be removed? ............................................
0
Yes
!3
No
2. Is the proposed development to be governed by any Development Agreement? 0 Yes El No
4
1
3. Has any application for development on this she including any subdivision
been.submitted previously to the California Coastal Zone Conservation
Commission or the Coastal Commission? ..................................................
If yes, state previous application number(s)
4. . Is the development between the first public road and the sea (including
lagoons, bays, and other bodies of water connected to the sea) ....................
If yes, is public access to the shoreline and along the coast currently available
on the site or near the site?
0 Yes IV No
0 Yes 0 No
0 Yes 0 No
::Tf .. ......... 6:466it!66 and nature.oif the access,'
ves.1ndica e:th including the di-:
stance from the Ii bf
project site,
appupa .... el....-...
5. Does the development involve diking, filling, draining, dredging or placing structures in open coastal
waters, wetlands, estuaries, or lakes? (Please check yes or no)
a) diking b) filling c) dredging d) placement of stnictures
0 Yes 0 Yes 0 Yes 0 Yes
13 No Z No ai No 0 No
Amount of material to be dredged or filled (indicate which) N/A cu. yds.
Location of dredged material disposal she NIA
Has a U.S. Army Corps of Engineers' permit been applied for? .................... a] Yes Wo
6. Will the development extend onto or adjoin any beach, tidelands, submerged
lands or public trust lands? ...................................................................... 23 Yes No
For projects on State-owned lands, additional information may be required as set forth in Section IV,
paragraph 10.
7. Will the development protect existing lower-cost visitor and recreational
facilities? ............................................................................................... Yes tz I No
Will the development provide public or private recreational opportunities? ....... 0 Yes E3 No
....... .....
Yes,:
5
8. Will the proposed development convert land currently or previously used for
agriculture to another use? ..................................... .................................. 0 Yes LV Nb
If Yes, how many acres will be converted?
9. Is the proposed development in or near:
a. Sensitive habitat areas (Biological survey may be required) ......................... 0 Yes Nb
b. Areas of state or federally listed rare, threatened, or endangered species ... 0 Yes 0 No
c. 1 00 -year floodplain (Hydrologic mapping may be required) ...........................
C3
Yes
M
- No
d. Park or recreation area .......................................................................
0
Yes
0
No
10. Is the proposed development Visible f rom:
a. State Highway 1 or other scenic route ...................................................
0
Yes
No
b. Park, beach, or recreation area ............................................................
, 13
Yes
0
No
c. Harbor area ....................................................................................... n Yes 0 No
11. Does the site contain any: (If yes to any of the following, please explain on an attached sheet)
a. Historic resources ............................................................................. 0 Yes 93 No
b. Archaeological resources .................................................................... 0 Yes 0 Nb
c. Paleontological resources .................................................................... 0 Yes R3 No
12. Where a stream or spring is to be diverted, provide the following information:
Estimated streamf low or spring yield (gpm)
If well is to be used, existing yield (gpm)
If water source is on adjacent property
approval. attach Division of Water Rights approval and property owner's
SECTION IV. REQUIRED ATTACHMENTS
The following items must be submitted with this form as part of the application
1. Proof of the applicant's legal interest in the property. A copy of any of the following will be acceptable:
current tax bill, recorded deed, lease, easement, or current policy of title insurance. Preliminary title
reports will not be accepted for this purpose. Documentation reflecting intent to purchase such as a
signed Offer to Purchase along with a receipt of deposit or signed final escrow document is also
acceptable, but in such a case, issuance of the permit may be contingent on submission of evidence
satisfactory to the Executive Director that the sale has been completed.
The identity of all persons or entities which have an ownership interest in the property superior to that of
the applicant must be provided.
R
I
land surveys, legal descriptions, subordination agreements, and other outside agreements will be required prior
to issuance of the permit.
In addition, the Commission may adopt or amend regulations affecting the issuance
of coastal development permits. If you would like notice of such proposals during
the pendency of this application, if such proposals are reasonably related to this
application, indicate that desire .......................................................................... 0 Yes 91 No
SECTION VI. COMMUNICATION WITH COMMISSIONERS
Decisions of the Coastal Commission must be made on the basis of information available to all commissioners
and the public. Therefore, permit appli,7ants and interested parties and their representatives are advised not to
discuss with commissioners any matters relating to a permit outside the public hearing. Such contacts may
jeopardize the fairness of the hearing and result in invalidation of the Coinmission*s decision by court. Any
written material sent to a commissioner should also be sent to the commission office for inclusion in the public
record and distribution to other Commissioners.
SECTION V11. CERTIFICATION
1 - I hereby certify that 1, or my authorized representative, have completed and posted or will post the
Notice of Pending Permit card in a conspicuous place on the property within three days of submitting
the application to the Commission office.
2. 1 hereby certify that I have read this completed application and that, to the best of my knowledge, the
information in this application and all attached appendices and exhibits is complete and correct. I
understand that the failure to provide any requested information or any misstatements submitted in
support of the application shall be grounds for either refusing to accept this application, for denying the
permit, for suspending or revoking a permit issued on the basis of such misrepresentations, or for
seeking of such f urthet relief as may seem proper to the Commission.
3. 1 hereby authorize representatives of the California Coastal Commission to conduct site inspections on
my property. Unless arranged otherwise, these site inspections shall take place between the hours of
8:00 A.M. and 5:00 P.M.
Signature of Authahzed Agent(s) or if no agent, signature of Applicant
NOTE. IF SIGNED ABOVE BY AGENT, APPLICANT MUST SIGN BELOW.
SECTION Vill. AUTHORIZATION OF AGENT
I hereby authorize
and to bind me in all matters concerning this application.
to act as my representative
Signature of A�plicant(s
ere to aut'�
(Only the applicant(s) may sign, I nze an agent)
APPLICATION FOR COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT
APPENDIX- B
LOCAL AGENCY REVIEW FORM
SECTION A (TO BE COMPLETED BY APPLICANT)
Applicant
Project Description
X.- =-#, I
Assessor's Parcel Number
ETED BYIOCAL- PLANNING OR BUILDING INSPECTION DEPA E
RTM Nq:'.....
Zoning Designation
du/ac
General or Community Plan Designation du/ac
Local Discretionary Approvals
• Proposed development meets all zoning requir ements and needs no local permits other than building
permits.
• Proposed development needs
local discretionary approvals noted below.
Needed Received
0 0
Design/kchitectural review
0
Variance for
0
Rezone from
0
Tentative Subdivision/Parcel Map No.
13 0
Grading/Land Development Permit No.
0 0
Planned Residential/Commercial Development Approval
0 0
Site Plan Revipw
0 0
Condominium Conversion Permit
0 0
Conditional, Special, or Major Use Permit No.
0 0
Other
CEQA Status
• Categorically Exempt Class Item
• Negative Declaration Granted (Date)
• Environmental Impact Report Required, Final Report Certified (Datp)
0 Other
Prepared for the City/County of
Date
Title
10
:M
Application No,
APPLICATION FOR COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT
APPENDIX C
LIST OF PROPERTY OWNERS AND OCCUPANTS WITHIN 100 FEET AND THEIR ADDRESSES
(MAKE ADDITIONAL COPIES OF THIS SHEET AS NECESSARY)
APPENDIX D
DECLARATION OF POSTING
Prior to or at the time the application is submitted for filing, the applicant must post, at a conspicuous place,
easily read by the public and as close as possible to the site of the proposed development, notice that an
application for the proposed development has been submitted to the Commission. Such notice shall contain a
general description of the nature of the proposed development. The Commission furnishes the applicant with a
standardized form to be used for such posting. If the applicant fails to post the completed notice form and sign
the Declaration of Posting, the Executive Director of the Commission shall refuse to file the application, or shall
withdraw the application from filing if it has already been filed when he or she learns of such failure. 14 Cal.
Admin. Code Section 13054(b).
Please sign and date this Declaration of Posting form when the site is posted; it serves as proof of posting. It
should be returned to our off ice with the application.
Pursuant to the requirements of Calffomia Administrative Code Section 13054(b), I hereby certify
that on 10/6/97 -, I or my authorized representative posted the Notice
(date of posting)
of Pending Permit for application to obtain a coastal development permit for the development of
48 foot groin wall
(description of development)
Located at Adams Street
(address of development or assessor's parcel number)
The public notice was posted at Adam Street streetend
(a conspicuous place, easily seen by the public and as close as le to th—e -sifte-ol the proposed de—veTop—ment)
; �(�signatur�e)���
a
10/6/97
(date)
NOTE. Your application cannot be processed until this Declaration of Posting is signed and returned to this
office.
FOR omcE usE oNL Y
PERMIT NUMBER
RECEIVED
DECLARATION COMPLETE
12
4=
CD
C14
LO
z
CD
C14
CN
A
CI
cc
LL.
c
C13
CD
cli
0
.5
C/3
0
E
2
LL
LO
qw
CD
E (3)
E
(D
E E
om
(D
cm
r
I
0
.cc m
U3
8 5?
c
78.2
5 1
E
x
C D
CO Cc
E CL
4) m
E
CD
WIS Q
4- -9 U)
-6 E
Zd (A w
cc a) E U.J
E z
,% -= CM C)
0 CU a
.E
cn
cl) o
CD C
4) (D
0
U-
E 4c) o
cn 0 U)
.om
c 0
UJ
CL) a,
(2 ow
CD 4) E
E o
M
0
-t C W
-0
2
o E 4)
0
(D U)
Cc 4)
0
E a-) cau =m
0 ii — 0
E
L
0 m
m -E
m CD
<
t,-3
E E E
E 0 E
0 E 0
CM=
9 0
— m
>0 LLI
0 = 1A
C.) < -a
.2 ui cs
E -R3 !E
—0 0
'M 78
-g ca
0
u
cn
c
go.
Cc
cc
cc
V)
C*
Ul)
(A
Cp
43
Q
Co.,.
ci cc
(D CO m
US
Cc
'2
cc
4)
CL
CC,
cc co
CL
<
a)
to
Lo
'A
U3 'o
LL, C3
Cc C5
CL
cc
C)
FA
(D
ad
Cl)
0 CD CD
0 U)
0 cn
cis
0
ci
CO
4D w E C14
1- 0
- 03
0
0 >,'o '*'
cc
tO
c8a
�,o
C2 -
4)
U)
UJ
0 (n
CN
42)
T
CL 0 Cc (M
0 M
(D
0
(P
a 0 M
n
co cn
m -M
U.) to
(M M
M 0) LO
a < LO
Q
0 m
4) ID
cc cc
cc
< m
CD
&Z —0
C
cc (a
-1 cc co
i- C�j
C14
o 0 CM CD
-0 m CD Cl) Co
c cn
IM (M
e
m co
ar
(D M
go.:.
— C-5
00 00
= uj c
Cc C%4 as
-0 —
C
Cc 0 a
A2
C,4 a
C4
CE CO C) U) co
Cj
C,4
C�o
ci
Cti
F -I
C)
q=
Z?s
(D
(o
PS
11-D
CN
U) — co
s Ln
E
>
U)
(D C-
0
C
0
0=1
CL
U)
E.
-j 0 E uj
CL
rL
. IL''
*CM to
C�
Co
Is m
in o uj U) cn
E
In
(lo-
.., ..... I .
. .......
E
0
E f'-
co
—
fA
m-
co
IA
c
M
00
C4
0
W
= C%l
Q 40
w,
C-0
>
1=
cu
cv)
0
(313
L*
C-4
CD ca = (n
= E 0
<
cc
CO
US (1) 1�-
ul)
(M (=
0
W c g 0 -"-
0
C-) CO
Cc C13 CD
Co.. ,
W
C/3
cr
c
cc < '9
W - CN
cn Cc CN
U)
- - -M
W (A t,
L.
Cc M
to
m
4) C6
E
C13
0
0 Clq
cr-
m m
0 Ln
cri
CD
CD
m U"3
LC)
cc
CL Cc LO
0 E E
0
'T Cc w
m C14
C14
CS
'n Cf)
CD
U- m
LX b- 0 co
Lr)
(D <
W CD (D CO
-a cm :.6:; U'3
W
C4
m
LO
4, < U) to
fA
a.:
.13 E to
CO C) 12
cc
D Cc
0 IX
.... ... . ..
#A
cc
fn
.... ......
IRV
ch
..........
....... ..
...........
cx
It -
CL
............
...............
CJ
(A
Ae A
04
CL Cts
(D c
0) CD
W
—
CD
LO
0
m CO
m
...
Cm <
8 -co
.. .......
cv
tm:=
4)
< co
M W m
(D Lo
cn < co
C4 CJ
0
co
0
0 LO
U,
.3 -, A "
m C)
.:: =::,
<
Lo
co
C'j ctf
— — rr
cc 'o
Co >%
U3
.......
M Q C-) CD 0
LA:
R 8 U) LO
cc x
o Cc cn
U)
LU "r
21% C) rA cf)
Ca
......
0
= a C CD C4
........
M
C
__j co
m
U)
(A
ce I",
(a I --
0 C
— j �a
5
0 CD
-I CL m
cc -L-- cn CD
0 Zo ui t�
0 E C,
CD a C,
P 0 'V
cm
Q Cc Cc 'm
to
ce
LU
z
0
0
U
ui
0
LL.
U)
ui
co:r
,T3
CO
—0
"ts
Lb
Z
cc
U�
QL
to
c
Q
0)
CO
CO)
CL cc
CO)
I=
ca
t. -P
co
C3
7ZS%zz
co %Z
to
C3 CO)
ro
=RL
QL
CX
LU
0
Ag
ca C�
U) CD cr)
t:�:, m
co
m 0) CV
0
CD
Z = � CO
Cc
<
<
fu (j
0
��o
U-3
Co 0) W
E
0 - CN
cc
M cn
c5 <
-C Cld
co CV
0) (D Cj
4) cw)
0,6
CCI 0 to
u c6
2
2 a
(D co
cc ir
(15)
U3 co
0 E m
E
4, Ln
cc
c Lo
0
0 C)
%r C L C-0
ca
LL. co U)
(D ct, cc
CL >
C-4
cr)
LU
uj
0
LL
CV)
CD
<
cc
LZ
cn
0 Q
L)
cn
0 m
E cs
A2 Q
C�
CL M
U.
LL
IRr
CD
C',
— M
(D
<
0 Pn
(D
E
cc E Ln
gl(L = f�
0 c 0
0 --r-r
C=a <
0 M - 0 co
0 cc n =: cn
w 4)0)
_CO m
u U.
U�
, C14
m MG Cc
_: 0
E
Z: Cu -cr
0 CX
0 c
0 w 0. m
?m-% Ur ui i��
c5
o z cc
c
o cc
0 cn
-I -190
m cc, __j
0
m
U,
a
0
C')
C13
tm
>
m
CL
cc
E
co
CD
co
CN
L2 cn
a CD
cc
4)
c C4
E
3: CD
= Cq
0 —
0 r-
CD
o 0) C�
U- = q*: m
0 — m
cp LO
cc < cn
4D CD c,
0
>%.t= <
—S -
= 0 -j <
0 co W
U) 0 .'r
qr
co
Co OL
= -Lo
cl�
-r- "
4D — CU W
46 C�
C14
I
U) C4
CD IRr
Z 6�
IT
cr "r a)
F. Cf)
Z% CD (1)
(5 8
u to
m co cc cl,
sc C—v)
a CN
cn
CIA _j
U)
0
E
=0
Im
0
E
cc
—
m
x
0
UO
E
ca
U)
0
U- CL
0
78
0 0 4)
0 u 4)
0 vJ t= 'r
cc
t:
cc
co
LL 0 ull
m
cn
m
E -
s
s?
—OM
x =<
a) cc
—
C14
<
U'�
cn
C,,
CN
r�-
LL
—
a)
cn
U,
0 0
Q
co
E
M 0) C40
" o C5
CL
CD 0 CO
5 cc —
0 CL ;r M Mr
—0
0.8
co:r
,T3
CO
—0
"ts
Lb
Z
cc
U�
QL
to
c
Q
0)
CO
CO)
CL cc
CO)
I=
ca
t. -P
co
C3
7ZS%zz
co %Z
to
C3 CO)
ro
=RL
QL
CX
LU
0
(a
(D
s
A
(D (D
AD
.0
M
cc
cn
8
(D
cm CD
cc
CL >
U) m
4D Q
U) 'o
0
0 ::.�
cc
.2
w
(D
E
0
E
4
0
m
0
C')
C13
tm
0
C�
w
w
= E
4)
�cn
E E
'MO
CV)
E 8
E
CD
CV)
U)
0
E
CL
=
U cc
E
0
E
cc
—
0
x
0
UO
E
ca
U)
0
E
E
0
78
t:
cc U)
ca 0
8.0
=
0 C3
4)
cc
0
U,
0 0
Q
ca
—ca
"o— 0
M
CL
= C,
"0 cc
8
.!M
w E
E
—0
0.8
0
w
cc
m
0.
— M
CL 0
80
U)
0
a) tm
E
0
(D
(D
E
A2
cc
4)
a)
0.
cc
w
0
U,
U_
.
cc
4)
z
LU
CL
4)
-a E
E
(D
m
0 M
:s
0
g. 8
o
=
o
—
LU
a) E
cc
CL
4)
0) LI)
E
4) ca
75
—
E
m E
Cf
W
M
—0
CL
x
(D
0
§
0
-us
cal
CM
AD
4)
:S 0
.2
U
(D
E
z
0
cc
T
C9
CD
4)
m
ca E
4)
U)
M U2
0 (D
W
CD
E
o
C-)
0
co -V5
4)
.>
— W
(D Cc
>
=
~ ca
0
0 —
co
Z
ca MO
E E
4)
U
u
= (1)
-2
a
=
E E
(D
(D
=
"
m E
-cg E
E Q
E
0
0
0
co
(D :S
tm
MO
M
8 a)
CL
U)
0
3:
M —
0. -
E2
E
(D
= r-
C13
LU
.2
—
(1) (D
>
E
—0
<
8.2
U3
0
w
(D 0
CL CL
4)
CL
x
C13
o w
E
"
0
-a 2
4)
cc
LU
5
E
CD
C13 Cts
E
o
.2
ca
U,
Cb
(D CC
0
CC
'2
tm U)
U)
tit E
m
2
0
=
0
.�"o
—E
o A2
ca
.0
(D
cc E
= 0
m
cn
m
E
0
t" (D
C
(D 72
2
< (D
E
0
U) CD
CL
2
LF 8
C;L (D
CD
CD —0
C4
w
Cc = ~
M Cr 0
0
0
(D
E EL
X (D 0
-v u=' E
0
u' Z
E
8 E2
4 =
E
—
cu
0
ca
ca 4)
cc
E
E
8
0 Mm
E
75
CD
cc
cc
0
U3
cc
(D
> Cts
1
E (D
-0
cc :2
ca
.—.e
CL
E
=
CM
M
cc
E .0
cc (1)
C�
0
CL 75
E
(D go
(D 4)
U) tt:
U) Cc
3.
C�
CD
E
-1Z 0
Q r".L
cc
—0
1 >.
E 0
Co CL
C*
E
co 01
(D
:9
(D
(D
.0
0 0. co
a)
cc C,
E a)L
0 C=o
Z
>
CL
cc
2 —(D
rL
M
co:r
,T3
CO
—0
"ts
Lb
Z
cc
U�
QL
to
c
Q
0)
CO
CO)
CL cc
CO)
I=
ca
t. -P
co
C3
7ZS%zz
co %Z
to
C3 CO)
ro
=RL
QL
CX
LU
0
APPENDIX E
PERMIT APPLICATION FEE SCHEDULE
1. RESIDENTIAL PROJECTS
A. New single-family dwellings
Deminimis waiver ..........................................................................................
0 $
Administrative permit or consent calendar .....................................................
13 $
Regular calendar
If 1,500 square feet I or less ..................................................................
[:] $
If between 1,501 and 5,000 square feet 2 ..............................................
0 $
If over 5,000 square feet 2 ......................................................................
[:] $
B. Additions or improvements to single-family dwellings
Deminimis waiver ..........................................................................................
E] $
If handled as an amendment to a previous coastal development permit,
see Amendments (Section III.D.) below.
If not a waiver or an amendment to a previous coastal development permit,
the fee is assessed according to the schedule in A. above (i.e., based on
the calendar and/or size of the addition, plus the grading fee, if applicable).
C. Multiple residential projects (including residential subdivisions,
resubdivisions and condominium conversions) 4
200
2501
2503
:500 3
1,0003
KY
24 units ......................................................................................................... .0 $ 6003
5-16 units ....................................................................................................... E3 $ 2,0003
17-166 units ................................................................................................... 13 $ 120 /unit 3
167 units or more ........................................................................................... E3 $ 20,0003
D.. Lot line adjustment ....................................................................................... El $ 6003
Fee does not change if application is removed from the Consent Calendar by the Commission and rescheduled on the Regular
Calendar. Fee does change if removed from the Administrative Calendar and rescheduled on the Regular Calendar.
2 Including gross internal floor space of main house, attached garage(s), covered patios, plus any detached structures intended
for human habitation (e.g., guest houses, detached bedrooms, in-law units); not including patios or decks open to the sky,
detached garages, barns, art studios, tool sheds, and other outbuildings not primarily intended for human habitation.
3 Grading fee applies; see Item F.
4 No additional fee is charged for construction of single-family residence(s), if proposed together with a land division
13
E. Divisions of land where there are single-family
residences already built and only one new lot is created ......................... 0 $ - 6003
F. Grading fee for residential projects
If more than 75 cubic yards of grading is proposed,
an additional fee of $200 plus $5 per 1,000 cubic
yards in excess of 75 cubic yards shall be assessed ..................................... 0 $
II. OFFICE, COMMERCIAL, CONVENTION, INDUSTRIAL
A. New structures
Up to and including 10,000 sq.ft. (gross) ........................................................
0
$
2,000
10,001 sq.ft. up to 25,000 sq.ft. (gross) ..........................................................
[:]
$
4,000
25,001 sq.ft. up to 50,000 sq.ft. (gross) ..........................................................
Ej
$
8,000
50,001 sq.ft. up to 100,000 sq.ft. (gross) ........................................................
0
$
12,000
Over 100,000 sq.ft. (gross) .............................................................................
E3
$
20,000
Major energy production or fuel processing facility ........................................
E 3
$
20,000
B. Additions or improvements
Immaterial amendments .........................................................................
0
$
Regular calendar: see II.A. above
Otherwise: see Ill. below
111. FEES FOR PROJECTS NOT COVERED IN 1. OR 11. ABOVE
A..
Administrative permit (except single-family residence) ...................................
0$
2001
B.
Emergency permit ...........................................................................................
r-1
$
2005
C.
Consent calendar item ....................................................................................
0
$
2501
D.
Amendments
Immaterial amendments .........................................................................
0
$
200
Material amendments ............................... [50% of original permit fee] 6
E3
$_
5 When followed by a regular permit application, the $200 emergency application fee is credited toward the follow-up permit fee.
6 *Original permit fee" means fee actually paid with original application.
14
E. Extensions 7 and Reconsiderations
Single-family residences ........................................................................ 13 $ 200
All other developments ........................................................................... 13 $ 400
F. Assignments .................................................................................................... E3 $ 200
G. Request for continuance
Ist request ............................................................................................. 0 No charge
Each subsequent request
(where Commission approves the continuance) .................................... 13 $ 100
H. De minimis waivers ......................................................................................... $ 200
1. Public works facilities ........................................ [if public agency is applicant] No charge
IV. ANY OTHER DEVELOPMENT NOT OTHERWISE COVERED
Development cost up to and including $100,000 ....................................................
0
$
600
$100,001 to $500,000 ............................................................................................
0
$
2,000
$500,001 to $1,250,000 .........................................................................................
0
$
4,000
$1,250,001 to $2,500,000 ......................................................................................
0
$
8,000
$2,500,001 to $5,000,000 ......................................................................................
0
$
12,000
over$5,000,000 .....................................................................................................
0
$
20,000
TOTALSUBMITTED ................................................................................................... $
ADDITIONAL NOTES
1 . Fees are assessed at the time of application, based on the project as proposed initially. If the size of a
proposed dwelling or the amount of proposed grading is amended during the application review
process, the fee is not changed.
2. If different types of development are included on one site under one application, the fee is based on
the development with the largest fee.
3. Fees for after -the -fact permits shall normally be double the regular permit fee unless such added
increases are waived by the Executive Director when it is determined that the permit could be
processed by staff without significant additional review time resulting from the processing of the
violation.
7 If permit extension is objected to by Commission and application is set for a new hearing, then a new application fee is
required, based on type of development and/or applicable calendar.
15
4. Permits shall not be issued without full payment of all applicable fees. If overpayment of a fee occurs,
a refund will be issued.
5. If a permit application is withdrawn, a refund will be due only if no significant staff review time has been
expended (e.g., the staff report has not yet been prepared). Denial of a permit application by the
Commission is not grounds for a refund.
6. The application fee shall be determined from the type and size of the proposed development, except
that where there is,conflict over the applicable fee, the Executive Director may use the project cost to
determine the fee.
7. In addition to the above fees, the Commission may require the applicant to reimburse it for any
additional reasonable expenses incurred in its consideration of the permit application, including the
costs of providing public notice.
8. The Executive Director shall waive the application fee where requested by resolution of the
Commission.
SEE SECTION 13055 OF THE COMMISSION'S REGULATIONS (CALIFORNIA CODE OF REGULATIONS,
TITLE 14) FOR FULL TEXT OF THE REQUIREMENTS.
SUBMITTED FEE VERIFIED BY. -
IS SUBMITTED AMOUNT CORRECT'2
El Yes. Applicant has correctly
characterized the development,
and payment is appropriate.
TO BE COMPLETED BY STAFF
DATE:
0 Applicant did not fill out form,
thus staff has marked the form
to compute the fee, and applicant
has paid fee.
REFUND OR ADDMONAL FEE REQUIRED? (STATE REASON)
E3 Refund amount
13 Additional fee amount (
FINAL FEE VERIFIED BY: (TO BE COMPLETED AFTER COMMISSION ACTION) I DA TE.
20ftBMTWFMSC�M.DOC
16
0 No. Why?
REPLY TO
AT7 ENTION OF:
Office of the Chief
Regulatory Branch
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
LOS ANGELES DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS
P.O BOX 532711
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90053-2325
April 14,1998
City of Newport Beach
Attn: Tony Melum, Deputy Chief
P.O. Box 1768
Newport Beach, California 92658-8915
Dear Sirs:
Reference is made to your request of October 6, 1997 (File No. 98-00135-SDM) to
construct a plastic groin wall to protect an existing sandy beach, City street end, and storm
drain to the west, and a deep water marina to the east. Under the provisions of Section 10 of
the Rivers and Harbors Act of March 3, 1899 (33 U.S.C. 403), you are hereby authorized to
construct a 48 -foot long recycled plastic groin wall, composed of 8 -foot long plastic panels,
seaward of 427 Edgewater, within Newport Bay, in the City of Newport Beach, Orange
County, California, as shown on the enclosed drawings.
The owner or authorized responsible official must sign and date all copies of this Letter
of Permission (LOP) indicating that he/she agrees to the work as described and will comply
with all conditions. One of the signed copies of this Letter of Permission must be returned to
the Corps of Engineers (a pre -addressed envelope is enclosed). In addition, please use the
two attached postcards to notify this office as to the dates of commencement (within 10 days
prior to the start of construction) and completion of the activity (within 10 days following the
end of construction).
Thank you for participating in our regulatory program.
PERMITTEE
Sincerely,
Richard J. Schubel
Chief, Regulatory Branch
DATE
SPA
When the structures or work authorized by this permit are still in existence at the time
the property is transferred, the terms and conditions of this LOP will continue to be binding
on the new owner(s) of the property. To validate the transfer of this permit and the
liabilities associated with compliance with its terms and conditions, have the transferee sign
and date below.
TRANSFEREE
Enclosure(s)
DATE
-3 -
PERMIT CONDITIONS
General Conditions:
1. The time limit for completing the authorized activity ends on April 14, 2000. If you find
that you need more time to complete the authorized activity, submit your request for a time
extension to this office for consideration at least one month before the above date is reached.
2. You must maintain the activity authorized by this permit in good condition and in
conformance with the terms and conditions of this permit. You are not relieved of this
requirement if you abandon the permitted activity, although you may make a good faith
transfer to a third party in compliance with General Condition 4 below. Should you wish to
cease to maintain the authorized activity or should you desire to abandon it without a good
faith transfer, you must obtain a modification of this permit from this office, which may
require restoration of the area.
3. If you discover any previously unknown historic or archeological remains while
accomplishing the activity authorized by this permit, you must immediately notify this office
of what you have found. We will initiate the Federal and state coordination required to
determine if the remains warrant a recovery effort or if the site is eligible for listing in the
National Register of Historic Places.
4. If you sell the property associated with this permit, you must obtain the signature of the
new owner in the space provided and forward a copy of the permit to this office to validate
the transfer of this authorization.
5. You must allow representatives from this office to inspect the authorized activity at any
time deemed necessary to ensure that it is being or has been accomplished with the terms
and conditions of your permit.
Special Conditions: See attached sheet.
-4 -
Further Information:
1. Congressional Authorities: You have been authorized to undertake the activity described
above pursuant to Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899 (33 U.S.C. 403).
2. Limits of this authorization.
a. This permit does not obviate the need to obtain other Federal, state, or local
authorizations required by law.
b. This permit does not grant any property rights or exclusive privileges.
c. This permit does not authorize any injury to the property or rights of others.
d. This permit does not authorize interference with any existing or proposed Federal
project.
3. Lirrdts of Federal Liability. In. issuing this permit, the Federal Government does not
assume any liability for the following:
a. Damages to the permitted project or uses thereof as a result of other permitted or
unpermitted activities or from natural causes.
b. Damages to the permitted project or uses thereof as a result of current or future
activities undertaken by or on behalf of the United States in the public interest.
c. Damages to persons, property, or to other permitted or unpern-dtted activities or
structures caused by the activity authorized by this permit.
d. Design or construction deficiencies associated with the permitted work.
e. Damage claims associated with any future modification, suspension, or revocation of
this permit.
4. Reliance on Applicant's Data: The determination of this office that issuance of this permit
is not contrary to the public interest was made in reliance on the information you provided.
5. Reevaluation of Permit Decision. This office may reevaluate its decision on this permit at
any time the circumstances warrant. Circumstances that could require a reevaluation
include, but are not limited to, the following:
a. You fail to comply with the terms and conditions of this permit.
b. The information provided by you in support of your permit application proves to
have been false, incomplete, or inaccurate (See 4 above).
-5-
c. Significant new information surfaces which this office did not consider in reaching
the original public interest decision.
Such a reevaluation may result in a determination that it is appropriate to use the
suspension, modification, and revocation procedures contained in 33 CFR 325.7 or
enforcement procedures such as those contained in 33 CFR 326.4 and 326.5. The referenced
enforcement procedures provide for the issuance of an administrative order requiring you to
comply with the terms and conditions of your permit and for the initiation of legal action
where appropriate. You will be required to pay for any corrective measure ordered by this
office, and if you fail to comply with such directive, this office may in certain situations (such
as those specified in 33 CFR 209.170) accomplish the corrective measures by contract or
otherwise and bill you for the cost.
6. Extensions. General condition 1 establishes a time limit for the completion of the activity
authorized by this permit. Unless there are circumstances requiring either a prompt
completion of the authorized activity or a reevaluation of the public interest decision, the
Corps will normally give you favorable consideration to a request for an extension of this
time limit.
la
SPECIAL CONDITIONS FOR PERMIT NO. 98-00135-SDM
The permitted activity shall not interfere with the public's right to free navigation on all
navigable waters of the United States.
2. No dredging or earthwork is authorized by this Letter of Permission.
3. No creosote treated pilings shall be placed within Newport Bay.
4. The permittee shall notify the Army Corps of Engineers of the date of commencement
of operations and the date of completion of operations at least five days prior to such
completion.
5. No other modifications or work shall occur to the docking structure.
6. No debris, soil, silt, sand, sawdust, rubbish, cement or concrete washings thereof, oil or
petroleum products, from construction shall be allowed to enter into or placed where it
may be washed by rainfall or runoff into Newport Bay. Upon completion of berthing
improvements, any excess material or debris shall be removed from the work area. No
rubbish shall be deposited within Newport Bay.
7. That the permittee shall notify the Commander (can) Eleventh Coast Guard District,
BLDG 50-6, Coast Guard Island, Alameda, California, 94501-5000, (510) 437-2968, at
least two weeks prior to start of activity and 30 days if buoys are to be placed. The
notification should include the following information:
a. the location of the work site;
b. the size and type of equipment that will be performing the work;
c. name and radio call signs for working vessels, if applicable;
d. telephone number for on-site contact with project engineers; and
e. the schedule for completing the project.
8. A copy of the post -survey drawings shall be sent to the following address:
Director, Charting and Geodetic Services
ATTENTION: N/CG22
National Ocean Services, NOAA
Rockville, Maryland 20852-3806
LOS ANGELES DISTRICT
U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS
CERTIFICATION OF COMPLIANCE WITH
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY PERMIT
Permit Number: 98-00135-SDM
Name of Permittee: City of Newport Beach
Date of Issuance: April 14, 1998
Upon completion of the activity authorized by this permit, sign this certification and
return it to the following address:
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
Regulatory Branch
ATTN: CESPL-CO-R-98-00135-SDM
P.0 Box 532711 Los Angeles, CA 90053-2325
Please note that your permitted activity is subject to a compliance inspection by an
Army Corps of Engineers representative. If you fail to comply with this permit you may be
subject to permit suspension, modification, or revocation.
I hereby certify that the work authorized by the above referenced permit has been
completed in accordance with the terms and conditions of said permit.
Signature of Permittee
Date
LIRY
OC-Irtc
R/V
H:ST
VICINITY MRP JEM
IFMCR /T'E
IROF I LE
EF67 40'
JEM
S%MINGS ARE E S�
RTI s A
I�E EXPRESK�D IN FEET FIND DENOTE
E;LEVRTIONS BASED; -ON MEAN LOWER LOW WATER.
ot
F-
1 3
T
'LICflNT'
NAME
-3or
-'/8' . 6now WdAu-
(OrO FROFF-k7Y
N F-
-4-
P1FN-iYl0LtJ
ty
growfj
JOB RDDRESS
SAIISBURY EXrERPRISES, IMC.
17042GiClette Avenue
Irvine, CaRfornia 92614-56oi
(949) -?5i-488o
FAX (94,9) 251-0524
June 5, 1998
IN& Tony Melum
Deputy Chief Marind Division
City of Newport Beach
P.O. Box 1768
Newport Beach, California 92658-8915
Re: Newport Landing Marina
Dredging, Groin Wall and Storm Drain
Dear Tony:
Thank you for your time on the telephone this morning and for the updates in connection
with the dredging, groin wall installation and storm drain extension matters.
First, in connection with the proposed Shellmaker's dredging, scheduled for June 8 th, 9th
and 10th, Landing Associates will share in one-third (1/3) of the total dredging costs
($1400 per day). We will want Shellmaker to provide as much depth as possible in the
entire Newport Landing�Marina, including the side tie area underneath the sportfishing
boat birth in the marina. If the bait receivers and/or the electric boats toward the
bulkhead need to be temporarily relocated, please have Shellmaker or Lisa let me know
so I can coordinate the schedule required with the fuel dock, electric boat and
-sportfishing tenants. My office number is (949) 251-4880. Thank you!
I was happy to hear that everything requested by the Coastal Commission is in and that,
hopefully, we will obtain this last required approval for the groin wall installation in the
next thirty (30 to sixty (60) days. As you know, Landing Associates prepaid in full its
share of the expense last year.
I was also happy to learn that you have placed the work order to have the Adams Street
end storm drain pipe appropriately extended out into the bay in order to reduce the
current scouring effect and the movement of sand from the street end into our marina
area.
Mr. Tony Melum
June 5, 1998
Page Two
Tony, thank you for all of your time and effort in coordinating all of the above. It is very
much appreciated by all of us.
Very truly,
Q�c"<�'
Douglas L. Salisbury
President
General PartneriLanding Associates
DLS:chn
cc: David Salisbury
Randy Brown (via fax and mail)
Jim and Pam Watts
John Van Dixhom (via fax)
Ralph Rodheim (via fax)
PO
> CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
r)
z PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
-1/1 Fog PO. BOX 1768, NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92658-8915
(714) 644-3311
June 2, 1998
- r -
Mr. Robin Maloney Ramus,
California Coastal Commission
200 Oceangate, I Ob Floor
Long Beach, CA 90802-4302
Re: Coastal Development Permit # 5-97-334
Dear Mr. Ramus:
Tony Melum, Deputy Chief of the Marine Environinental Division, Fire and Marine Department,
asked that I respond to your request for an engineering perspective on the need for a groin at this
area. The site consists of a sandy sloping beach to the west, a City street end with storm drain
pipes extending into the bay, and a deep water marina to the east of the street end.
Currently local tidal action has increased in intensity from the west to the east and has caused a
long shore transport of sand ftom the sandy sloping beach, to the storm drain and into the deep-
water marina. The situation suggests that a groin in this area would slow the observed erosion
thereby maintaining the sandy sloping beach to the west, reducing erosion across the City street
end and retarding deposition of material from those two locations into the deep water marina. To
be effective the gromi should be at least 48 feet long. Attached is a signed drawing by a
registered structural engineer for a proposed groin that was previously submitted to the Coastal
Commission. The proposed groin would be sufficient when constructed according to the
attachedplan to maintain the sand elevations and reduce the erosion experience in this location.
However, it is critical that the sand elevations be maintained as depicted in the plan.
The benefits of the groin installation are threefold. If located as proposed, the groin will assist in
stopping the erosion from the publicly used sandy sloping beach to the west. It win also reduce
the long shore current, which is eroding the City street end and exposing supports for a City
storm drain. And finally, it will reduce sand transport from those two locations into the deep-
water marina to the east. The groin will be jetted in under low pressure. If the need should arise,
the groin could be easily removed using the same process.
I hope this answers your questions. If I can be of finther assistance, please contact me at 949-
644-3328.
Sincerely,
LJd Dalton, PE
Design Engineer
3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach
WORK ORDER REQUEST
FOR GENERAL SERVICES DEPT.
FROM THE FIRE MARINE DEPARTMENT
Date: 1 -Jun -98
Description & Location of work:
El Submit in Duplicate to General Services
1E Copy to Admin
EXTEND ADAM STREET STORM DRAIN AT ADAMS AND EDGEWATER
OUT AS FAR AS POSSIBLE.
Contact is Tony Melurn, 3041.
Attach drawings or sketches for any construction work, or additional notes.
Desired Completion Date: ASAP Charge to Budget #
For Information Contact: TonV Melum Phone #: 644-3041
Work Assigned To:
Remarks:
Authorized Signature of Department:
(For use by General Services Department)
Date:
PLEASE SUBMIT ANY AND ALL COSTS TO THE FIRE & MARINE ADMINISTRATION DIVISION,
INCLUDING CHARGES TO VENDOR ACCOUNTS. Thank you 1!
Date Completed:
Total Completed Costs: $
General Services Director
Foreman
14
FqA
Oc.
ViCINIT -SKF7TCH
we* cP.W'='-a'W.W -a al 0r Oct -*4 �0�0"0060 a,
/_Owv W-ar-OM-t
0.",
Al 4- kv .7 -
IT
";ok
Ooz 4, t'
ArAa
he
7�OA
V1%
W
IVL
5'
14=1L A /V
/-v .0 jo -00 X.P
thod Art'Corp.
421Z427 E. Edgewater.
Newport Beach,- CA
C,AAfrackr.' Si�e-lltvotw
I
Clr( OF NEWPORT BEAC�!
HARBOR PERMIT
"ERMISSION IS HEREBY GRANTED TO' CONSTRUCT AND
MAINTAIN THE FACILITY SHOWN ON THE REVERSE HEREOF.
AT THE SITE INDICATED, SUBJECT To THE PROVISIONS OF
THE HARBOR PERMIT POLICIES OF,NEWPORT 9EACH AND
ANY SPECIAL CONDITIONS LISTED HEREON. THIS PERMIT
IS NOT TRANSFERABLE WITHOUT THE W N CONSENT OF
THE CITY HARBOR COORDINATOR 0 COUNCIL T
RIGHTS GIVEN UNDER 7H S PERMIT - E PERMISSIVE il' Y
AND THIS PERMIT M H 9 OK - v THF cITY Co
IN ACCORDAANCE 17 MUNICIPAL 0
ESMIT NA rz
SUBJECT ro
SEjjqQ
OD ART CORPOR TION
507 West Edgewater
Newport Beach, CA 92661-1155
949-723-4567 FAX: 949-673-1339
May 29, 1998
Mr T. Melum
Deputy Chief Marine Department Division
Newport Beach Fire & Marine Department
P.O. Box 1768
NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92658-8915
Dear Tony
RE: BEACH EROSION * ADAMS & E. EDGEWATER
I
I met two weeks ago (5/11/98) with two city employees, Mr Steve Lui and Mr Greeney. The subject
of our meeting was the advanced reduction of the sand supporting the Edgewater sea wall and my
adjoining beach lots and pier pilings. Our 423 E. Edgewater Pier almost collapsed last week so we
tracked in sand on an emergency basis.
Large cracks going completely through the sea wall and sidewalk at the end of Adams Street have
recently appeared as well as sink holes in my adjoining parking lot. Mr Lui expressed concern that
the sand was migrating under the sea wall leaving the City sidewalk hollow underneath.
As you well know we (Newport Beach City, Newport Landing Restaurant and Method Art
Corporation) have an agreement to install a 44' groin wall. That wall has not been installed even
though it was fully paid for in 1997 and the materials have been on hand for nearly a year at Pete
Swift's yard. Since the groin wall permits procedurement and construction (which is currently in
the hands of Newport Beach City Agencies) is so far behind schedule I think the City should put sand
in as soon as possible.
My dredging permit is on file and available for use at this site and Shellmaker set June 8, 9 and 10,
1998 as the next available high tide for the said dredging. I would be happy to allow my permit to
2.
be used for this project.
It seems clear to assume that it would be cost effective to dredge and refill the beach before the sea
wall and sidewalk cave in AGAIN (as itdid in the late 1980's when 25' of sidewalk collapsed here)
at unnecessary expense to the City of Newport Beach.
I have held back on dredging my property as the sand will only migrate into your huge pot hole at the
end of the City's storm drain. It is also obvious that the storm drain pipe is flushing away a pool size
mass of sand during each rain storm. An extension of 20' to this storm drain pipe would cure this
flushing action. Enclosed please find photos to document erosion action dated May 1998.
In effect the lack of the groin wall and the scouring effect of the short storm drain is damaging all
three parties. My beach is greatly diminished, the support for my two piers is threatened, Newport
Landing Restaurant's boat basin is full of sand and the City sea wall and sidewalk may also subside.
Remember, there are 6' 2 " fuel supply pipes to the Shell Station that run -under the biggest crack in
the concrete walkway. A major spillage disaster could occur if any of those 6 pipes was ruptured and
the fuel spilled into the bay!
I've tried for three years now to get this problem corrected and I have no control over the Coastal
Commission's issuance of the groin wall permit.
It is not my responsibility to take unilateral action on behalf of the City. All I can do is express my
concern again and request that your office press for extending the storm drain and pressure the
Coastal Comniission to clear the permit as soon as possible for the new groin wall and dredge at the
Adams Street storm drain before a Newsworthy sink hole gobbles up one of my tenants cars or a
tourist walks into where the side walk should have been!
Thanking you.
Sincerely
RANDY BROWN for and on behalf of
METHOD ART CORPORATION
encs.
cc David & Doug Salisbury
Newport Landing Restaurant
e
e
i"
REPLY TO
Office 6FfhWUFief
Regulatory Branch
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
LOS ANGELES DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS
P.O BOX 532711
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90053-2325
April 14, 1998
City of Newport Beach
Attn: Tony Melum, Deputy Chief
P.O. Box 1768
Newport Beach, California 92658-8915
Dear Sirs:
Reference is made to your application dated October 6, 1997, for a Department of the
Army (DA) permit to construct a 48 -foot long groin wall seaward of 427 Edgewater, within
Newport Bay, in the City of Newport Beach, Orange County, California.
Enclosed is a "Provisional Letter of Permission" (provisional LOP). This provisional
LOP is NOT VALID and does not constitute authorization for you to do work. The
provisional LOP describes the work that will be authorized, including general and special
conditions which will be placed on your final DA permit, should you receive Coastal Zone
Management (CZM) consistency concurrence from the California Coastal Commission (CCC).
No work is to be performed until you have received a validated copy of the DA permit.
By Federal law, no DA permit can be issued until the state has concurred with a permit
applicant's CZM consistency certification. This requirement can be satisfied by obtaining
CZM consistency concurrence, or providing evidence that 6 months have passed since you
applied to the CCC for concurrence. Be aware that any conditions on your CZM consistency
concurrence will become conditions on your DA permit, unless the Corps of Engineers deems
these conditions to be either unreasonable or unenforceable.
WHEN YOU RECEIVE CZM CONSISTENCY CONCURRENCE, THE FOLLOWING
STEPS NEED TO BE COMPLETED:
1. The owner or authorized responsible official must sign and date both copies
of the provisional LOP indicating that he/she agrees to comply with all
conditions stated in the permit.
2. The signer's name and title (if any) must be typed or printed below the
signature.
3. Both signed provisional LOPs must be returned to the Corps of Engineers at
the above address (Attention: CESPL-CO-R).
4. The CZM concurrence must be sent to the Corps of Engineers with the
signed provisional LOPs.
-2 -
Should the CZM consistency concurrence contain conditions which might result in a
modification to the provisional LOP, by signing and dating both copies of the provisional
permit and returning it to the Corps of Engineers (along with the permit fee and CZM
concurrence), the Corps of Engineers will assume the applicant agrees to comply with all
CZM conditions which are added to the final permit.
Should the CCC deny the required concurrence, then the DA permit is considered
denied without prejudice. If you subsequently obtain CZM concurrence, you should contact
this office to determine how to proceed with your permit application.
If you have any questions, please contact Spencer D. MacNeil of my staff at
(213) 452-3418.
Sincerely,
Richard J. Sch ibel
Chief, Regulal:)ry Branch
Enclosure(s)
REPLY TO
ATTENTION OF:
Office of the Chief
Regulatory Branch
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
LOS ANGELES DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS
P.O BOX 532711
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90053-2325
April 14, 1998
City of Newport Beach
Attn: Tony Melum, Deputy Chief
P.O. Box 1768
Newport Beach, California 92658-8915
Dear Sirs:
Reference is made to your request of October 6, 1997 (File No. 98-00135-SDM) to
construct a plastic groin wall to protect an existing sandy beach, City street end, and storm
drain to the west, and a deep water marina to the east. Under the provisions of Section 10 of
the Rivers and Harbors Act of March 3, 1899 (33 U.S.C. 403), you are hereby authorized to
construct a 48 -foot long recycled plastic groin wall, composed of 8 -foot long plastic panels,
seaward of 427 Edgewater, within Newport Bay, in the City of Newport Beach, Orange
County� California, as shown on the enclosed drawings.
The owner or authorized responsible official must sign and date all copies of this Letter
of Permission (LOP) indicating that he/she agrees to the work as described and will comply
with all conditions. One of the signed copies of this Letter of Permission must be returned to
the Corps of Engineers (a pre -addressed envelope is enclosed). In addition, please use the
two attached postcards to notify this office as to the dates of commencement (within 10 days
prior to the start of construction) and completion of the activity (within 10 days following the
end of construction).
Thank you for partici ati
I p _ng in our regulatory program.
PERMITTEE
Sincerely,
Richard J. Schu 1
Chief, Regulato Branch
DkE
STATE, OF CALIFORNIA - THE RESOURCES AGENCY PETE WILSON, Govemor
-CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION
South Coast Area Office Page: 1 of 3
200 Oceangate, Suite 1000
Long Beach, CA 90802-4302 Date: August 25, 1998
(562) 590-5071 Permit Application No.: 5-97-334
NOTICE OF INTENT TO ISSUE PERMIT
On 13 August 1998, the California Coastal Commission granted to Newport Beach
Fire & Marine Dept. Coastal Development Permit 5-97-334, subject to the attached
conditions, for development consisting of: installation of a 48 foot long, 2.5 inch
thick plastic groin wall. The groin, consisting of eight foot long plastic panels, will
be hand jetted into the harbor in order to reduce turbidity. More specifically
described in the application file in the Commission offices.
The development is within the coastal zone in Orange County
at Adams Street Streetend, Newport Beach.
The actual development permit is being held in the Commission office until
fulfillment of the Special Conditions imposed by the Commission. Once these
conditions have been fulfilled, the permit will be issued. For your information, all
the imposed conditions are attached.
Issued on behalf of the California Coastal Commission on August 25, 1998.
PETER DOUGLAS By:
Executive Director Title: Coastal Progra4Analyst
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
11 he undersigned permittee acknowledges receipt of this notice of the California
Coastal Commission determination on Permit No. 5-97-334, and fully understands
its contents, including all conditions imposed.
!2
Date
'I- �1_1
/A
rmittee
Please sign and return one copy of this form to the Commission office at the above
address.
NOTICE OF INTENT TO ISSUE PERMIT
Permit Application No. 5-97-334
Page 2 of 3
STANDARD CONDITIONS
1 Notice of Receipt and Acknowledgment. The permit is not valid and
development shall not commence until a copy of the permit, signed by the
permittee or authorized agent, acknowledging receipt of the permit and
acceptance of the terms and conditions, is returned to the Commission
office.
2. Expiration. If development has not commenced, the permit will expire two
years from the date on which the Commission voted on the application.
Development shall be pursued in a diligent manner and completed in a
reasonable period of time. Application for extension of the permit must be
made prior to the expiration date.
3. Compliance. All development must occur in strict compliance with the
proposal set forth in'the application for permit, subject to any special
conditions set forth below. Any deviation from the approved plans must be
reviewed and approved by the staff and may require Commission approval.
4. Interpretation. Any questions of intent or interpretation of any condition will
be resolved by the Executive Director or the Commission.
5. Inspections. The Commission staff shall be allowed to inspect the site and
the project during its development, subject to 24-hour advance notice.
6. Assignment. The permit may be assigned to any qualified person, provided
assignee files with the Commission an affidavit accepting all terms and
conditions of the permit.
7. Terms and Conditions Run with the Land. These terms and conditions shall
be perpetual, and it is the intention of the Commission and the permittee to
bind all future owners and possessors of the subject property to the terms
and conditions.
SPECIAL CONDITIONS:
1 . Construction Responsibilities and Debris Removal
The project shall be constructed as proposed, hand -jetted from land during low tide,
in order to reduce significant adverse impacts on the marine environment. The
applicant agrees not to store any construction materials or waste where it is subject
to wave erosion and dispersion. In addition, no machinery will be allowed in the
NOTICE OF INTENT TO ISSUE PERMIT
Permit Application No. 5-97-334
Page 3 of 3
intertidal zone at any time. The permittee shall remove from the beach and
streetend area any and all debris which results from the construction period.
RMR: 11
97334-i.d...
c:\msoffice\winword\template\regnoi.dot Printed on August 25, 1998
NEWPORT BEACH FIRE AND MARINE DEPARTMENT
April 8,1998
Mr. Robin Maloney-Rames
California Coastal Commission
200 Oceangate, 101h Floor
Long Beach, CA 90802-4302
Re: Coastal Development Permit #5-97-334
Dear Robin:
As I mentioned in earlier correspondence, the proposed groin wall
serves the purpose of maintaining an existing public beach and to
maintaining depth in an adjacent public marina. The existing groin,
which was broken off some years ago, is so close to the marina that it is
not effective in maintaining the sand at the adjacent beach. In its
current condition it is not effective in maintaining the sand on the City
street end which supports a public storm drain.
The only alternative to a groin wall in fl -ds location would be ongoing
maintenance dredging, which agencies such as Fish and Game and the
National Marine Fisheries will see as a more intrusive alternative to the
marme habitat than the installation of the groin. I believe that Fish and
Game and the National Marine Fisheries have contacted you and they
do not see any significant environmental impact with the installation of
the groin in the proposed location. To rebuild it in it prior location
does not serve the purpose of maintaining the public beach and in its
proposed location it is more effective in protecting the City's storm
drain at the street end.
The existing marina alongside the street end is a public serving marina,
with rental boats, a public gas dock and berthing for public sport
fishing operation so it is important for this facility maintain depth to
facilitate its operations.
The groin wall is more economically feasible than continual dredging,
less environmentally intrusive and serves to make this visitor serving
operation fiscally sound. The installation will be done with a small
hand jet which should create a very small amount of turbitity and a
very minimal amount of inter tidal area displacement as evidence by
approval from the above mentioned agencies.
I hope this answers your question and if I can be of any further help
please contact me at 714-644-3041.
Sincerely,
Tony Melurn
Deputy Chief Marine Environmental Division
-2 -
When the structures or work authorized by this permit are still in existence at the time
the property is transferred, the terms and conditions of this LOP will continue to be binding
on the new owner(s) of the property. To validate the transfer of this permit and the
liabilities associated with compliance with its terms and conditions, have the transferee sign
and date below.
TRANSFEREE
Enclosure(s)
1,93.1,11
-3 -
PERMIT CONDITIONS
General Conditions:
1. The time limit for completing the authorized activity ends on April 14, 2000. If you find
that you need more time to complete the authorized activity, submit your request for a time
extension to this office for consideration at least one month before the above date is reached.
2. You must maintain the activity authorized by this permit in good condition and in
conformance with the terms and conditions of this permit. You are not relieved of this
requirement if you abandon the permitted activity, although you may make a good faith
transfer to a third party in compliance with General Condition 4 below. Should you wish to
cease to maintain the authorized activity or should you desire to abandon it without a good
faith transfer, you must obtain a modification of this permit from this office, which may
require restoration of the area.
3. If you discover any previously unknown historic or archeological remains while
accomplishing the activity authorized by this permit, you must immediately notify this office
of what you have found. We will initiate the Federal and state coordination required to
determine if the remains warrant a recovery effort or if the site is eligible for listing in the
National Register of Historic Places.
4. If you sell the property associated with this permit, you must obtain the signature of the
new owner in the space provided and forward a copy of the permit to this office to validate
the transfer of this authorization.
5. You must allow representatives from this office to inspect the authorized activity at any
time deemed necessary to ensure that it is being or has been accomplished with the terms
and conditions of your permit.
Special Conditions: See attached sheet.
me
Further Information:
1. Congressional Authorities: You have been authorized to undertake the activity described
above pursuant to Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899 (33 U.S.C. 403).
2. Lin -tits of this authorization.
a. This permit does not obviate the need to obtain other Federal, state, or local
authorizations required by law.
b. This pern-dt does not grant any property rights or exclusive privileges.
c. This permit does not authorize any injury to the property or rights of others.
d. This permit does not authorize interference with any existing or proposed Federal
project.
3. Limits of Federal Liability. In issuing this permit, the Federal Government does not
assume any liability for the following:
a. Damages to the permitted project or uses thereof as a result of other pern-dtted or
unpermitted activities or from natural causes.
b. Damages to the pern-titted project or uses thereof as a result of current or future
activities undertaken by or on behalf of the United States in the public interest.
c. Damages to persons, property, or to other permitted or unpermitted activities or
structures caused by the activity authorized by this permit.
d. Design or construction deficiencies associated with the permitted work.
e. Damage claims associated with any future modification, suspension, or revocation of
this permit.
4. Reliance on Applicant's Data: The determination of this office that issuance of this permit
is not contrary to the public interest was made in reliance on the information you provided.
5. Reevaluation of Permit Decision. This office may reevaluate its decision on this permit at
any time the circumstances warrant. Circumstances that could require a reevaluation
include, but are not limited to, the following:
a. You fail to comply with the terms and conditions of this permit.
b. The information provided by you in support of your permit application proves to
have been false, incomplete, or inaccurate (See 4 above).
-5-
c. Significant new information surfaces which this office did not consider in reaching
the original public interest decision.
Such a reevaluation may result in a determination that it is appropriate to use the
suspension, modification, and revocation procedures contained in 33 CFR 325.7 or
enforcement procedures such as those contained in 33 CFR 326.4 and 326.5. The referenced
enforcement procedures provide for the issuance of an administrative order requiring you to
comply with the terms and conditions of your permit and for the initiation of legal action
where appropriate. You will be required to pay for any corrective measure ordered by this
office, and if you fail to comply with such directive, this office may in certain situations (such
as those specified in 33 CFR 209.170) accomplish the corrective measures by contract or
otherwise and bill you for the cost.
6. Extensions. General condition 1 establishes a time limit for the completion of the activity
authorized by this permit. Unless there are circumstances requiring either a prompt
completion of the authorized activity or a reevaluation of the public interest decision, the
Corps will normally give you favorable consideration to a request for an extension of this
time limit.
SPECIAL CONDITIONS FOR PERMIT NO. 98-00135-SDM
The permitted activity shall not interfere with the public's right to free navigation on all
navigable waters of the United States.
2. No dredging or earthwork is authorized by this Letter of Permission.
3. No creosote treated pilings shall be placed within Newport Bay.
4. The permittee shall notify the Army Corps of Engineers of the date of commencement
of operations and the date of completion of operations at least five days prior to such
completion.
5. No other modifications or work shall occur to the docking structure.
6. No debris, soil, silt, sand, sawdust, rubbish, cement or concrete washings thereof, oil or
petroleum products, from construction shall be allowed to enter into or placed where it
may be washed by rainfall or runoff into Newport Bay. Upon completion of berthing
improvements, any excess material or debris shall be removed from the work area. No
rubbish shall be deposited within Newport Bay.
7. That the permittee shall notify the Commander (oan) Eleventh Coast Guard District,
BLDG 50-6, Coast Guard Island, Alameda, California, 94501-5000, (510) 437-2968, at
least two weeks prior to start of activity and 30 days if buoys are to be placed. The
notification should include the following information:
a. the location of the work site;
b. the size and type of equipment that will be performing the work;
c. name and radio call signs for working vessels, if applicable;
d. telephone number for on-site contact with project engineers; and
e. the schedule for completing the project.
8. A copy of the post -survey drawings shall be sent to the following address:
Director, Charting and Geodetic Services
ATTENTION: N/CG22
National Ocean Services, NOAA
Rockville, Maryland 20852-3806
W, 11 1
LOS ANGELES DISTRICT
U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS
CERTIFICATION OF COMPLIANCE WITH
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY PERMIT
Permit Number: 98-00135-SDM
Name of Permittee: City of Newport Beach
Date of Issuance: April 14, 1998
Upon completion of the activity authorized by this permit, sign this certification and
return it to the following address:
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
Regulatory Branch
ATTN: CESPL-CO-R-98-00135-SDM
P.0 Box 532711 Los Angeles, CA 90053-2325
Please note that your permitted activity is subject to a compliance inspection by an
Army Corps of Engineers representative. If you fail to comply with this permit you may be
subject to pern-dt suspension, modification, or revocation.
I hereby certify that the work authorized by the above referenced permit has been
completed in accordance with the terms and conditions of said permit.
Signature of Permittee
Date
STATE OF CALIFORNIA - THE RESOURCES AGENCY PETE WILSON, Govemor
CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION
South Coast Area Office
200 Oceangate,.10th Floor
Long Beach, CA 90802-4302
(562) 590-5071
April 2, 1998
Tony Mellum
Fire and Marine Dept.
City of New -port Beach
P.O. Box 1768
Newport Beach, CA 92658-58915
Re: Coastal Development Permit 5-97-334
Dear Tony:
On March 27, 1998 1 received the letter from the Army Corps of Engineers
concerning the placement of the 48 foot long, 2.5" wide plastic groin wall to
be placed in the harbor at the termination of the the Adams Street streetend.
On November 19, 1997 1 sent you a letter deeming the project incomplete
pending certain information.' Your letter in response arrive at our offices on
March 16, 1998.
Any project involving a shoreline protective measure which interferes with
shoreline processes and'or/fill'of open coastal waters requires an analysis
under Section 30233 or 30235 of the Coastal Act.'which state:
Section 30233 states:
(a) The diking, filling, or dredging of open coastal waters, wetlands,
estuaries, and lakes shall be permitted in accordance with other
applicable provisions of this division, where there is no feasible less
environmentally_�Iag�@, �J_na alternative, and where feas�b e mitigation
ig
measures have been provided to minimize adverse environmental effects, and
shall be limited to the following: (emphasis added)
(1) New or expanded port, energy, and coastal -dependent industrial
facilities, including commercial fishing facilities.
(2) Maintaining existing, or restoring previously dredged, depths in
existing navigational channels, turning basins, vessel berthing and
mooring areas, and boat launching ramps.
(3) In wetland areas only, entrance channels for new or expanded
boating facilities; and in a degraded wetland, identified by the
Department of Fish and Game pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 30411,
5-97-334
Letter of Incompletion
Page 2
for boating facilities if, in conjunction with such boating facilities, a
substantial portion of the degraded wetland is restored and maintained as
a biologically productive wetland. The size of the wetland area used for
boating facilities, including berthing space, turning basins, necessary
navigation channels, and any necessary support service facilities, shall
not exceed 25 percent of the degraded wetland.
(4) In open coastal waters, other than wetlands, including streams,
estuaries, and lakes, new or expanded boating facilities and the placement
of structural pilings for public recreational piers that provide public
access and recreational opportunities.
(5) Incidental public service purposes, including but not limited
to, burying cables and pipes or inspection of piers and maintenance of
existing intake and outfall lines.
(6) Mineral extraction, including sand for restoring beaches, except
in environmentally sensitive areas.
(7) Restoration purposes.
(8) Nature study, aquaculture, or similar resource dependent
activities.
(b) Dredging and spoils disposal shall be planned and carried out to
avoid significant disruption to marine and wildlife habitats and water
circulation. Dredge spoils suitable for beach replenishment should be
transported for such purposes to appropriate beaches or into suitable long
shore current systems.
Section 30235 states:
Revetments, breakwaters, groins, harbor channels, seawalls, cliff
retaining walls, and other such construction that alters natural shoreline
processes shall be permitted when required to serve coastal -dependent uses
or to protect existing structures or public beaches in danger from
erosion, and when designed.to eliminate or mitigate adverse impacts on
local shoreline sand supply. Existing marine structures causing water
stagnation contributing to pollution problems and fish kills should be
phased out or upgraded where feasible.
Clearly, the proposed development is consistent with Section 30235 in that the
proposed groin would act to: 1) build up the sand supply on the streetend
beach, and 2) prevent sedimentation of the adjoining marina.
However, the proposed development also requires a Section 30233 analysis,
which is more complicated than 30235. The 30233 analysis requires that: 1)
the proposed development is an allowable use, 2) the proposed development be
the least environmentally damaging alternative, and 3) the project incorporate
feasible mitigation measures to minimize adverse environmental impacts.
The project appears to be a permitted use under 30233(a)(2) to maintain
existing depths in vessel berthing areas. In my letter of November 19, 1997
(see attached) I requested certain information which is necessary to make the
5-97-334
Letter of Incompletion
Page 3
findings required by the 30233 analysis. Without the background information I
cannot make the finding, cannot put forth a recommendation in a staff report,
and cannot go to hearing.
For the alternative analysis I need you to discuss a range of options and why
they are or are not feasible. For instance, one alternative might be to
reconstruct the damaged concrete groin. Another alternative which you
mentioned is to do nothing and continue dredging the marina. Another
alternative might be to build an entirely new concrete groin.
Apparently the main purpose of the proposed project is to protect the marina
from sedimentation and disrupt the flow of sand. Will this project serve
other functions, for instance, to protect the storm drain pipe at the
streetend? I noticed at a site visit that the marina serves Newport Harbor
tour boats. This is a relevant factor in that the purpose of this activity is
visitor -serving.
Finally, what mitigation measures will be taken to ensure that there are no
adverse impacts to coastal resources? This is part of the 30233 analysis.
I know that for you and the City this is a simple project which is necessary
and will prevent the expenditure of ongoing funds for dredging. I do not mean
to put up obstacles or make this project into something more than it is, but I
must have the minimum information necessary to make the findings in a staff
report. If you provide the information I have asked for in this letter I
believe we can proceed to hearing with a recommendation of approval so that
you can implement this project.
Thank you for your cooperation. If you have any questions, please call me at
(562) 590-5071.
Sincerely yours,
Robin Maloney-Rames
Coastal Program Analyst II
cc: RR, RMR, File, SR
0542G
STATE OF CALIFORNIA - THE RESOURCES AGENCY PETE WILSON, Governor
CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION
South Coast Area Office
200 Oceangate,.10th Floor
Long Beach, CA 90802-4302
(562) 59D-5071
November 19, 1997
Tony Mellum
Newport Beach Fire and Marine Department
3300 Newport Boulevard
P.O.Box 1768
Newport Beach,CA 92658-8915
Re: Coastal Development Permit 5-97-334
Dear Tony:
I received your application for a 48 foot groin wall bayward of the Adams
Street streetend. At this time the application is incomplete pending receipt
of the following information.
1. Dept. of Fish and Game & USFWS review;
2. Letter from the Regional Water Quality Control Board;
3. An alternatives analysis, as per Section 30233 (below);
4. Detailed description of the existing situation and the need for the groin
wall,
threats to storm drain,
threats to streetend
beach erosion
Copies of any engineering reports and studies prepared by a qualified
professional, including an assessment of potential impacts;
6. Description of method of construction
piling supports
dredging and quantity
quantity of fill, if any
placement of plastic lumber
7. Measures taken to prevent siltation & adverse impacts to water quality;
8. Measures to protect water quality during construction.
-2 -
Letter of Incompletion
5-97-344
9. Detailed summary of impacts to coastal resources (temporary / permanent)
intertidal water
harbor bottom
10. Proposed mitigation & monitoring measures, if any, for lost resources;
11. Letter inviting the adjoining landowner to be a co -applicant, if the
project occurs on the adjoining property;
12. Measures to avoid potential adverse impacts on coastal access during
construction -
There are several policies of the Coastal Act which apply to this type of
project. As you know, any proposed development is analyzed according to these
policies and the Commission must find that the development conforms to these
policies prior to approving a project. These policies include:
Coastal Act Section 30230:
Marine resources shall be maintained, enhanced, and where feasible,
restored. Special protection shall be given to areas and species of
special biological or economic significance. Uses of the marine
environment shall be carried out in a manner that will sustain the
biological productivity of coastal waters and that will maintain healthy
populations of all species of marine organisms adequate for long-term
commercial, recreational, scientific, and educational purposes.
Coastal Act Section 30231:
The biological productivity and the quality of coastal waters, streams,
wetlands, estuaries, and lakes appropriate to maintain optimum populations
of marine organisms and for the protection of human health shall be
maintained and, where feasible, restored through, among other means,
minimizing adverse effects of waste water discharges and entrainment,
controlling runoff, preventing depletion of ground water supplies ind
substantial interference with surface water flow, encouraging waste water
reclamation, maintaining natural vegetation buffer areas that protect
riparian habitats, and minimizing alteration of natural streams.
Coastal Act Section 30233:
(a) The diking, filling, or dredging of open coastal waters, wetlands,
estuaries, and lakes shall be permitted in accordance with other
applicable provisions of this division, where there is no feasible less
environmentally damaging alternative, and where feasible mitigation
measures have been provided to minimize adverse environmental effects, and
shall be limited to the following:
(1) New or expanded port, energy, and coastal-Aependent industrial
facilities, including commercial fishing facilities.
.(2) Maintaining existing, or restoring previously dredged, depths in
existing navigational channels, turning basins, vessel berthing and
mooring areas, and boat launching ramps.
-3 -
Letter of Incompletion'
5-97-344
(3) In wetland areas only, entrance channels for new or expanded
boating facilities; and in a degraded wetland, identified by the
Department of Fish and Game pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 30411,
for boating facilities if, in conjunction with such boating facilities, a
substantial portion of the degraded wetland is restored and maintained as
a biologically productive wetland. The size of the wetland area used for
boating facilities, including berthing space, turning basins, necessary
navigation channels, and any necessary support service facilities, shall
not exceed 25 percent of the.degraded wetland.
(4) In open coastal waters, other than wetlands, including streams,
estuaries, and lakes, new or expanded boating facilities and the placement
of structural pilings for public recreational piers that provide public
access and recreational opportunities.
(5). Incidental public service purposes, including but not 11miteed
to, burying cables and pipes or inspection of piers.and maintenance of
existing intake and outfall lines.
(6) Mineral extraction, including sand for restoring beaches, except
in environmentally sensitive areas.
(7) Restoration purposes.
(8) Nature study, aquaculture, or similar resource dependent
activities.
(b) Dredging and spoils disposal shall be planned and carried out to
avoid significant disruption to marine and wildlife habitats and water
circulation. Dredge spoils suitable for beach replenishment should be
transported for such purposes to appropriate beaches or into suitable long
shore current systems.
(c) In addition to the other provisions of this section, diking,
filling, or dredging in existing estuaries and wetlands shall maintain or
enhance the functional capacity of the wetland or estuary. Any alteration
of coastal wetlands identified by the Department of Fish and Gamej-
including, but not limited to, the 19 coastal wetlands identified in its
report entitled, "Acquisition Priorities for the Coastal Wetlands of
California", shall be limited to very minor incidental public facilities,
restorative measures, nature study, commercial fishing facilities in
Bodega Bay, and development in already developed parts of south San Diego
Bay, if otherwise in accordance with this division.
For the purposes of this section, "commercial fishing facilities in
Bodega Bay" means that not less than 80 percent of all boating facilities
proposed to be developed or improved, where such improvement would create
additional berths in Bodega Bay, shall be designed and used for commercial
fishing activities.
(d) Erosion control and flood control facilities constructed on
water courses can impede the -movement of sediment and nutrients which
would otherwise be carried by storm runoff into coastal waters. To
facilitate the continued delivery of these sediments to.the littoral zone,
-4-
Letter of Incompletion
5-97-344
whenever feasible, the material removed ' from these facilities may be
placed at appropriate points on the shoreline in accordance with other
applicable provisions of this division, where feasible mitigation measures
have been provided to minimize adverse environmental effects. Aspects
that shall be considered before issuing a coastal development permit for
such purposes are the method of placement, time,of year of placement, and
sensitivity of the placement area.
Coastal Act Section 30235:
Revetments, breakwaters, groins, harbor channels, seawalls, cliff
retaining walls, and other such construction that alters natural shoreline
processes shall be permitted when required to serve coastal -dependent uses
or to protect existing structures or public beaches in danger from
erosion, and when designed to eliminate or mitigate adverse impacts on
local shoreline sand supply. Existing marine'structures causing water
stagnation contributing to pollution problems+and fish kills should be
phased out or upgraded where feasible.
As soon as I receive the requested information I can begin to analyze the
project and schedule it for hearing. If you have any questions , please call
me at (562) 590-5071.
Sincerely yours,
R, W
PUr
Robin Maloney-Rames
CPA II
cc: SR. RMR, RR
0204G
NEWPORT BEACH FIRE AND MARINE DEPARTMENT
March 11, 1998
Mr. Mark Durham
L. A. Dist. Corp of Engineers/ Regulatory Branch
P. 0. Box 532711
Los Angeles, CA 90053-2325
Re: File #98-00135-SDM
Dear Durham:
I have taken your list of requests for additional information on the
above file and numbered each one andwill respond to them based on
that numbering. Please find the enclosed as follows:
1. The groin wall will be 48 feet long from the bulkhead, 48 feet
bayward. The individual panels are 8 feet long and will be hand -
jetted into place with a small jet pump by the construction
members. The panels themselves are 2 1/2 inches thick with a 2
inch wailer on either side for a total thickness on the cap of
approximately 7 inches. The work will all be done on the
landward side of the bay. No barges will be used during the
construction. It is proposed that the wall will installed within a 2
day period and there should be a rninimum amount of silt because
of the jetting method generated at the site.
2. The construction footprint is the width of the individual panel
times the length (2 inches wide and 48 feet long) which equals 8
feet as far as sub -straight impacted by the groin insulation.
3. At this time, the project will require no dredging. It is being done
to stabilize an existing beach on the westward side and to stabilize
a deep water marina on the eastward side.
4. The project will stabilize a sandy sloping on the western side used
by the adjacent property owners and should prevent material
eroding into a deep water marina on the eastward side used for
rental boats and sports fishing.
5. There are 3 property owners involved in this project. The streetend
is owned by the City of Newport Beach. The adjoining owner to the
west is Method Art, Corp., 507 West Edgewater, Newport Beach,
CA 92661. The property owner adjacent to the project on the
eastward side is Landing Associates, 17041 Gillette Ave., Irvine, CA
92614.
6. The City has made application to the California Coastal
Commission and that permit is pending. (Pern-dt 5-97-334)
7. We are hoping that this project will qualify under one of the Army
Corp of Engineers Nationwide Permits and that 401 certification
will not be necessary.
8. We have included photographs of the project site and an aerial.
Photograph #1 and 2 depict the City street end and the very top of
the storm drain and the deep water marina to the left of the City
street end. The groin will be installed on the right hand side of the
street end, parallel and adjacent to the recreational pier that runs
from the bulkhead bayward. In photograph #1 there is a gentlemen
standing at the dock and adjacent to the floating structure is a
concrete structure installed sometime in the 1960s. The groin was
originally 40 feet long, but over the years 20 feet of it have been
broken off and not reinstalled. As a result, sand migration from the
standy, sloping beach to the west has excelerated it migration into
the deep water marina on the eastward side. Photograph #3 shows
the sandy, sloping beach, which is slowing eroding away towards
the deep water marina and is anticipated, once the groin is installed
on the easterly side of the recreational pier, that it will reduce that
erosion.
9. There are no biological resources at the site other than sandy,
sloping and there is no eel grass in the location.
10. Attached is an engineering letter from the City of Newport Beach
Design Engineer, Lloyd Dalton.
11. Both California Fish and Game and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service have reviewed the project and given their approvals to the
California Coastal Commission.
Essentially, we are reinstalling this groin after the deterioration of the
groin on the easterly side of the street since it has fallen into disrepair
and has lost 40% of its length and is no longer effective in stabilizing
the beach and protecting the deep water marina. Therefor, we are
rebuilding the groin in a more convenient location for construction on
the westerly side of the street end.
If there is additional information that I need to provide, please contact
me at 714-644-3041.
Sincerely,
Tony Melum
Deputy Chief Marine Environmental Division
NEWPORT BEACH FIRE AND MARINE DEPARTMENT
March 11, 1998
MA.
,M9'Robin Maloney-Rames
C/o California Coastal Conu-nission
South Coast Area Office
200 Oceangate, 10th Floor
Long Beach, CA 90802-4302
Re: Coastal Development Permit #5-97-334
Dear Robin:
Regarding your request for additional information:
1. It is my understanding you have received approval both from the
Department of Fish and Game and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
regarding the above project.
2. In discussions with the Regional Water Quality Control Board and the
Army Corp of Engineers, it is proposed that this Corp permit will be
issued under the Corp's general permit and as a result -no Regional
Water Quality Control Board Certification is required. Regarding an
alternative analysis per section 30233, the purpose of the groin is to
maintain an existing beach to the west of the location and existing
depth in a vessel berthing area to the east. At this time there is no
feasible alternative other than groining to do this work unless we just
go to continued and periodic dredging, which seems more obtrusive
than doing a groin and limiting the amount of dredging.
3. We have included photographs of the project site and an aerial.
Photograph #1 and 2 depict the City street end and the very top of the
storm drain and the deep -water marina to the left of the City street
end. The groin will be installed on the right hand side of the street
end, parallel and adjacent to the recreational pier that runs from the
bulkhead bayward. In photograph #1 there is a gentlemen standing at
the dock and adjacent tothe floating structure is a concrete structure
installed sometime in the 1960s. The groin was originally 40 feet long,
but over the years 20 feet of it have been broken off and not reinstalled.
As a result, sand n-dgration from the standy, sloping beach to the west
has excelerated it migration into the deep water marina on the
eastward side. Photograph #3 shows the sandy, sloping beach, which
is slowing eroding away towards the deep water marina and is
anticipated, once the groin is installed on the easterly side of the
recreational pier, that it will reduce that erosion.
4. Attached is a report from our design engineer with the City of
Newport Beach.
5. The groin wall will be 48 feet long from the bulkhead, 48 feet bayward.
The individual panels are 8 feet long and will be hand -jetted into place
with a small jet pump by the construction crew. The panels
themselves are 2 1/ 2 inches thick with a 2 inch wailer on either side for
a total thickness on the cap of approximately 7 inches. The work will
all be done on the landward side of the bay. No barges will be used
during the construction. It is proposed that the wall will installed
within a 2 day period and there should be a minimum amount of silt
because of the jetting method generated at the site.
6. The City has made application to the Army Corp of Engineers and that
permit is pending.
7. There will be no impacts to the inner -tidal zone and the harbor bottom
except those minimal impacts mentioned in #6 above during
construction.
8. N/A
9. N/ A
10. There are no potential adverse impacts on coastal access during the
construction.
I hope this answers your questions and if I can be of further assistance
please contact me at 714-644-3041.
Sincerely,
A'A-�
/000/
Tony Melum
Deputy Chief Marine Environmental Division
NEWPORT BEACH FIRE AND MARINE DEPARTMENT
February 11, 1998
Ms. Susan Wynne
2730 Hooker Ave. West
Carlsbad, CA 92008
Dear Ms. Wynne:
Attached is the information requested relative to our Permit
Application to the Coast Coalition and the Army Corp of Engineers for
the installation of a 48 foot groin across City tidelands. The purpose of
the groin is to stabilize a sandy sloping beach which is depicted in
photograph number 3. It will also stabilize the sand at the City street
end which is depicted in photograph number 2 and protect the depth of
a deep water marina shown on the left side of photograph number 1.
The groin itself will come out perpendicular from the street end, right
adjacent to the dock, shown on photograph number 2. As you are
looking from the water into the street end, the groin would be on the
right. The design section shows the size of the wall, 8 feet long, jetted
in place using a low pressure water jet and should have very little
displacement of sand and crealte very little turbidity. The plot plan
shows the location of the groin wall adjacent to the dock and the street.
An aerial photograph is also enclosed.
Again, the groin is being built solely on City owned property and its
purpose is to stabilize a sandy sloping beacl� to the west and protect a
deep -water marina to the east. We have made application to both the
Coastal Commission (#597-334) and the Army Corps of Engineers (#98-
00135-SDM), both of the agencies have asked for a letter from your
agencies relative to'the groin installation. If you need to discuss this
with me further please contact me at 714-644-3041.
Sincerely,
Tony Melu
Deputy Chief Marine Environmental Division
JEWPORT BEACH FIRE AND MARINE DEPARTMENT
January 12, 1998
�6e I eo -3
4949 Vie ge
S�a lego, �CA
Ms. Susan Wynne (140)� f q4O
2730 Hooker Ave. West
Carlsbad, CA 92008
Dear Ms- Wynne:
Attached is the information requested relative to our Permit
Application to the Coast Coalition and the Army Corp of Engineers for
the installation of a 48 foot groin across City tidelands. The purpose of
the groin is io stabilize a sandy sloping beach which is depicted in
photograph number 3. It will also stabilize the sand at the City street
end which is depicted in photograph number 2 and protect the depth of
a deep water marina shown on the left side of photograph number 1.
The groin itself will come out perpendicular from the street end, right
adjacent to the dock, shown on photograph number 2., As you are
looking from the water into the street end, -the groin would be on the
right. The design section shows the size of the wall, 8 feet long, jetted
in place using a low pressure water jet and should have very. little
displacement of sand and create very little turbidity. The plot plan
shows the location of the groin wall adjacent to the dock and the street.
An aerial photograph is also enclosed.
Again, the groin is being built solely on City owned property and its
purpose is to stabilize a sandy sloping beach to the West and protect a
T 111 P P-Raq
deep -water marina to the east. It'i
I I � �! �: 1 : � I �!� � 11: i � A -appRea-tion - both of the
affUGati � , ! , - — n,,,y Cor -p of F. agiueer
agencies have asked for a letter from your agencies relative to the groin
installation. if you need to discuss this with me further please contact
me at 714-644-3041.
11 45:-y
Sincerely,
Tony elum
Deputy Cl -def Marine Environmental Division
A R'
"M
of;�T
NEWPORT BEACH FIRE AND MARINE DEPARTMENT
January 12, 1998
Ms. Marilyn Fluharty (4� t
4949 View Ridge '
San Diego, CA 99123
Ms. Susan Wynne (160)f
2730 Hooker Ave. West
Carlsbad, CA 92008
Dear Ms. Fluharty and Ms. Wynne:
Attached is the information requested relative to our,Pern-dt
Application to the Coast Coalition and the Army Corp of Engineers for
the installation of a 48 foot groin across City tidelands. The- purpose of
the groin is to stabilize a sandy sloping beach which is depicted in
photograph number 3. It will also stabilize the sand at the City street
end which is depicted in photograph number 2 and protect the depth of
a deep water marina shown on the left side of photograph number 1.
The groin itself will come out perpendicular from the street end, right
adjacent to the dock, shown on photograph number 2. As you are
looking from the water into the street end, the groin would be on the
right. The design section shows the size of the wall, 8 feet long, jetted
in place using a low pressure water jet and should have very little
displacement of sand and create very little turbidity. The plot plan
shows the location of the groin wall adjacent to the dock and the street.
An aerial photograph is also enclosed.
Again, the groin is being built solely on City owned property and its
purpose is to stabilize a sandy sloping beach to the west and protect a
deep -water marina to the east. Included are copies of the coastal
application and the Army Corp of Engineer application. Both of the
agencies have asked for a letter from your agencies relative to the groin
installation. If you need to discuss this with me further please contact
me at 714-644-3041.
Sincerely,
Tony 2elum
Denutv Chief Marine Environmental Division
STATE OF CALIFORNIA—THE RESOURCES AGENCY PETE WILSON, Govemor
DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND GAME
411 BURGESS DRIVE
MENLO PARK, CA 94025
(415) 688-6340
January 26, 1998
Mr. Tony Melum
Deputy Chief Marine Environmental Division
Newport Beach Fire and Marine Department
3300 Newport Blvd.
P.O. Box 1768
Newpor . t Beach, California 92658-8915
Dear Mr. Melum:
Department of Fish and Game (DFG) personnel have reviewed the proposed
installation of a 48 -foot groin wall across City (Newport Beach) tidelands to protect a
deep water marina and stabilize a sandy sloping beach. The groin wall would be
installed perpendicular from the end of Adams Street, adjacent to an existing dock.
The DFG believes that the project, as currently described in your January 12,
1998 letter, would not have a significant effect on existing marine resources and
habitats -within the area, and the DFG does not object to the issuance of Coastal
Commission or other regulatory agency permits for the proposed project. If, however,
there are substantive modifications to the project proposal as it moves forward through
the regulatory process, the DFG wishes to review these changes.
As always, DFG personnel are available to discuss our comments and concerns
in greater detail. To arrange for a discussion, please contact Ms. Marilyn Fluharty,
Environmental Specialist, California Department of Fish and Game, 4949 Viewridge
Avenue, San Diego, CA 92123, telephone (619) 467-4231.
Sincerely,
6?101_4� -
Robert N. Tasto, Supervisor
Marine Project Review/Water Quality Unit
cc: Fluharty
4
4,
J1
d"
0
4
ill
6%(5
j,�
STATE OF CALIFORNIA - THE RESOURCES AGENCY PETE WILSON, Govemor
CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION
South Coast Area Office
200 Oceangate,.10th Floor
Long Beach, CA 90802-4302
(562) 590-5071
November 19, 1997
Tony Mellum
Newport Beach Fire and Marine Department
3300 Newport Boulevard
P.O.Box 1768
Newport Beach,CA 92658-8915
Re: Coastal Development Permit 5-97-334
Dear Tony:
I received your application for
Street streetend. At this time -the
of the following information.
a 48 foot groin wall bayward of the Adams
application is incomplete pending receipt
1.
P-1 andiGame -,,&,,,U,$-FWS revi'ew;
2.
Let -ter, fr6m,'the .,Re.gidn,a:l�-:�Wate,r,,Qu�lif
y Control .,:Board;
3.�_;.:'At-
ern a
4:1t ti�v�ts��,�inalysis,-.;.,,;.�,4s
.,pler .&ecti on, 30233-
(:bel aw)
4.-', of �the
wa 1
existing situation
and the need for,the groin
threats to storm drain,
threats to streetend
beach erosion
5. Copies of any engineering reports and studies prepared by a qualified
professional, including an assessment of potential impacts;
6. Description of method of construction
piling supports
dredging and quantity
quantity of fill, if any
placement of plastic lumber
7. Measures taken to prevent siltation & adverse impacts to water quality;
8. Measures to protect water quality during construction.
-2 -
Letter of Incompletion
5-97-344
9. Detailed summary of impacts to coastal resources (temporary / permanent)
intertidal water
harbor bottom
10. Proposed mitigation & monitoring measures, if any, for lost resources;
11. Letter inviting the adjoining landowner to be a co -applicant, if the
project occurs on the adjoining property; -n-v
12. Measures to avoid potential adverse impacts on coastal access during
construction
There are several policies of the Coastal Act which apply to this type of
project. As,you know, any proposed development is analyzed according to these
policies and the Commission must flind that the development conforms to these
policies prior to approving a project. These policies include:
Coastal Act Section 30230:
Marine resources shall be maintained, enhanced, and where feasible,
restored. Special: protection shall be given to areas and species of
special biological or economic significance. Uses of the marine
environment shall be carried out in a manner that will sustain the
biological productivity of coastal waters and that will maintain healthy
populations of all species of marine organisms adequate for long-term
commercial, recreational, scientific, and educational purposes.
Coastal Act Section 30231:
The biological productivity and the quality of coastal waters, streams,
wetlands, estuaries, and lakes appropriate to maintain optimum populations
of marine organisms and for the protection of human health shall be
maintained and, where feasible, restored through, among other means,
minimizing adverse effects of waste water discharges and entrainment,
controlling runoff, preventing depletion of ground water supplies and
substantial interference with surface water flow, encouraging waste water
reclamation, maintaining natural vegetation buffer areas that protect
riparian habitats, and minimizing alteration of natural streams.
Coastal Act Section 30233:
(a) The diking, filling, or dredging of open coastal waters, wetlands,
estuaries, and lakes shall be permitted in accordance with other
applicable provisions of this division, where there is no feasible less
environmentally damaging alternative, and where feasible mitigation
measures have been provided to minimize adverse environmental effects, and
shall be limited to the following:
(1) New or expanded port, energy, and coastal -dependent industrial
facilities, including commercial fishing facilities.
(2) Maintaining existing, or restoring previously dredged, depths in
existing navigational channels, turning basins, vessel berthing and
mooring areas, and boat launching ramps.
-3 -
Letter of Incompletion
5-97-344
(3) In wetland areas only, entrance channels for new or expanded
boating facilities; and in a degraded wetland, identified by the
Department of Fish and Game pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 30411,
for boating facilities if, in conjunction with such boating facilities, a
substantial portion of the degraded wetland is restored and maintained as
a biologically productive wetland. The size of the wetland area used for
boating facilities, including berthing space, turning basins, necessary
navigation channels, and any necessary support service facilities, shall
not exceed 25 percent of the degraded wetland.
(4) In open coastal waters, other than wetlands, including streams,
estuaries, and lakes, new or expanded boating facilities and the placement
of structural pilings for public recreational piers that provide public
access and recreational opportunities.
(5) Incidental public service purposes, including but not limited
to, burying cables and pipes or inspection of piers and maintenance of
existing intake and outfall lines.
(6) Mineral extraction, including sand for restoring beaches, except
in environmentally sensitive areas.
(7) Restoration purposes.
(8) Nature study, aquaculture, or similar resource dependent
activities.
(b) Dredging and spoils disposal shall be planned and carried out to
avoid significant disruption to marine and wildlife habitats and water
circulation. Dredge spoils suitable for beach replenishment should be
transported for such purposes to appropriate beaches or into suitable long
shore current systems.
(c) In addition to the other provisions of this section, diking,
filling, or dredging in existing estuaries and wetlands shall maintain or
enhance the functional capacity of the wetland or estuary. Any alteration
of coastal wetlands identified by the Department of Fish and Game,
including, but not limited to, the 19 coastal wetlan,ds identified In its
report entitled, "Acquisition Priorities for the Coastal Wetlands of
California", shall be limited to very minor incidental public facilities,
restorative measures, nature study, commercial fishing facilities in
Bodega Bay, and development in already developed parts of south San Diego
Bay, if otherwise in accordance with this division.
For the purposes of this section, "commercial fishing facilities in
Bodega Bay" means that not less than 80 percent of all boating facilities
proposed to be developed or improved, where such improvement would create
additional berths in Bodega Bay, shall be designed and used for commercial
fishing activities.
(d) Erosion control and flood control facilities constructed on
water courses can impede the movement of sediment and nutrients which
would otherwise be carried by storm runoff into coastal waters. To
facilitate the continued delivery of these sediments to the littoral zone,
-4 -
Letter of Incompletion
5-97-344
whenever feasible, the material removed from these facilities may be
placed at appropriate points on the shoreline in accordance with other
applicable provisions of this division, where feasible mitigation measures
have been provided to minimize adverse environmental effects. Aspects
that shall be considered before issuing a coastal development permit for
such purposes are the method of placement, time of year of placement, and
sensitivity of the placement area.
Coastal Act Section 30235:
Revetments, breakwaters, groins, harbor channels, seawalls, cliff
retaining walls, and other such construction that alters natural shoreline
processes shall be permitted when required to serve coastal -dependent uses
or to protect existing structures or public beaches in danger from
erosion, and when designed to eliminate or mitigate adverse impacts on
local shoreline sand supply. Existing marine structures causing water
stagnation contributing to pollution problems and fish kills should be
phased out or upgraded where feasible.
As soon as I receive the requested information I can begin to analyze the
project and schedule it for hearing. If you have any questions , please call
me at (562) 590-5071.
Sincerely yours,
R O&tr — A�K'
Robin Maloney-Rames
CPA II
cc: SR, RMR, RR
0204G
NEWPORT BEACH FIRE AND MARINE DEPARTMENT
November 7,1997
Mr. Randy Brown
Method Art Corporation
507 West Edgewater
Newport Beach, CA 92661-1155
Re: Letter dated October 27, 1997
Dear Randy:
The permit process has become a lot more involved than we had
originally anticipated and whether the groin will be allowed by the
Coastal Commission or the Army Corp of Engineers is now an open
question.
I have recently inspected the street end at Adams Street and there is no
immediate danger to the City storm drain end. We are concerned that
by dumping sand onto the street end all we will do is increase the
material building up underneath your floating structures and fill in the
deep water area in front of Newport Landing.
There is a blanket maintenance dredging permit available if you feel it
is necessary to dredge now to protect the structures in your permit
zone. We would be available to assist you in that process. In the
meantime we are diligently pursuing the permit for the groin wall
which we perceive as a possible long-term solution of the problem.
If I can be of further assistance please give me a call at 644-3041.
Sincerely,
Tony Melum.
Deputy Chief Marine Environmental Division
METHOD ART CORPORATION
507 West Edgewater
Newport Beach, CA 92661-1155
714-723-4567 FAX: 714-673-1339
October 27, 1997
Tony Mellum
Deputy Chief Marine Environmental Division
Newport Beach Fire and Marine Department
P.O. Box 1768
Newport Beach, CA 92658-8915
Dear Tony:
This letter is to inform you that both our piers at 423 and 427 East Edgewater and the city
storm drain at the end of Adams Street are dangerously under -supported due to accelerated
sand erosion.
As you well know the groin wall installation at Adams Street has not been completed for
at least 90 days past the date when all contract, agreements and funds were ready.
The first delay for about 90 days was caused by materials delays out of any of our control,
However, during that time the permit from the Coastal Commission was not procured and
we are now in an extended waiting period until Coastal allows us to install the wall.
This latest problem may allow the sand erosion to undercut my pier support structures to
the point where they become unsafe or worse, they may collapse.
I have made every effort to get this groin wall installed and dredging to follow a.s.a.p.
before damage occurs. However, the Marine Department failed to procure (in a timely
manner) the Coastal Commission permit.
I feel that a stop gap remedy would be dumping three or more truck loads of beach sand
at the end of Adams Street. This would protect the city storm drain and decrease the angle
of the beach, thereby slowing the flow of beach sand into the Newport Landing Marina
11pit.11
Tony Mellurn
Page Two
October 27, 1997
Please contact me as soon as you can with a plan of action, so that any property damage
can be avoided pending the wall's installation.
Thanks for your prompt attention to this dilemma.
Sincerely,
Randy Brown
EPLY TO
ATTENTION OF:
Office of the Chief
Regulatory Branch
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
LOS ANGELES DISTRICT, CORPS OF ENGINEERS
P.O BOX 532711
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90053-2325
City of Newport Beach
Attn: Tony Melum, Deputy Chief
P.O. Box 1768
Newport Beach, California 92658-8915
Gentlemen:
October 24, 1997
Reference is made to your request (File No. 98-00135-SDM) dated October 6, 1997, for
Department of the Army authorization to construct a groin wall in Newport Bay, in the City
of Newport Beach, Orange County, California. In order to continue processing your request,
the information designated on the attached checklist is required. If the requested information
is not submitted to our office within 30 days from the date of this letter, your application will
be withdrawn.
If you have any questions, please contact Spencer D. MacNeil of my staff at
(213) 452-3417.
Sincerely,
Mark Durham
Chief, South Coast Section
Regulatory Branch
-2 -
LIST OF ADDITIONAL INFORMATION REQUIRED
FOR COMPLETE APPLICATION
APPLICANT
Complete the enclosed ENG Form 4345 signature of Applicant/ signature of Agent
Signature for statement designating official agent
Telephone number during business hours
DESCRIPTION OF ACTIVITY
-X— Complete written description of activity to be permitted (i.e., include width of groin
wall, equipment to be used and whether any equipment will require work within
jurisdictional areas or can be done from landward, timeline for construction, silt -
control methods proposed)
Complete description of overall. project
Location and name of watercourse
-X— Estimated area in acres of waters of the United States and adjacent wetlands that will
be impacted by the entire proposed activity (i.e., construction footprint: there would be
some substrate removed/ disturbed during installation of the groinwall - how large an
area?)
-X— Quantity in cubic yard of material to be dredged or used as fill (i.e., during installation
of the groin wall)
Method of clearing/ dredging
Method of transporting dredged material
Location of disposal site for dredged material
Source and composition of fill material
Proposed use of fill area, including specific structures to be erected on fill
PROJECT PURPOSE
Overall project purpose (if different from activity needing a permit)
Purpose of proposed fill/activity
,"a,) -X— Need for project (i.e., how much beach has been lost, has the street end and/or storm
drain been damaged or has protective material been eroded, is there a real concern that
water depth would not be maintained on the adjacent property?)
Names and addresses of adjoining property owners/lessees (if greater than five, please
X
6-7 - —
submit these on a disk in theformat shown on the attached page)
STATUS OF ADDITIONAL PERMITS OR CERTIFICATIONS
–X— California Coastal Conunission - federal consistency determination
_X_ Regional Water Quality Control Board - 401 certification
California Department of Fish and Game - Strearnbed Alteration Agreement
State Historic Preservation Officer - documentation of contact
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service - documentation of contact
National Marine Fisheries Service - documentation of contact
0
REQUIRED DIAGRAMS
All diagrams should be legible, and on 8 1/2 x 11" white paper, including a north arrow,
scale, and pertinent project information,
Vicinity map
Scale plan view diagram of existing (preproject) conditions
Scale plan view diagram of proposed conditions following construction of project
Cross section or lateral view of proposed activity
Project site as sketched on a xeroxed portion of USGS quad map identifying quadrangle
name, township and section
All drawings and maps should be properly labeled and show the following:
River mile if known
Name of water body
Identifiable landmarks
Area of Corps jurisdictional delineation indicating ordinary high water mark
and adjacent wetlands juxtaposed on project plans
Mean and maximum (spring) high tide lines
Average water depth around the activity
Dimensions of the activity and distance it extends from ordinary high water
mark into water
Location of structures and dimensions immediately adjacent to the proposed
activity
LIST OF ADDITIONAL INFORMATION RECOMMENDED
TO EXPEDITE PERMIT EVALUATION
Bioassay results for Ocean Disposal projects
X Photographs of the project site (aerials if available)
–X— Report describing the biological resources on the project site
Results o focused surveys for endangered species. Contact: U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Services, (805) 644-1766
–X— Engineering Studies of the proposed project's potential effects on adjacent properties
Report ol archeological /historical resources on/near project site compiled from a record
search by a qualified professional archeologist/historian at the regional center in your
locale (see below).
U.C.L.A. - (213) 825-1980: Los Angeles, Orange, and Ventura Counties
Cal State, San Diego - (619) 265-6300: San Diego County
C. Riverside - (714) 787-3885: Inyo, Mono, and Riverside Counties
C.S.B. - (805) 961-2474: San Luis Obispo and Santa Barbara Counties
an Bernardino County Museum - (714) 792-1497: San Bernardino County
-5 -
Format for additional addresses
SAMPLES
"COMPANY","COMPLETE NAME","STREET ADDRESS","PO BOX","CITY","STATE","ZIP+4"
-IF NAME OMITTED -
"COMPANY .......... STREET ADDRESS","PO BOX","CITY","STATE","ZIP+4"
-IF COMPANY & PO BOX OMITTED-
....... COMPLETE NAME","STREET ADDRESS .......... CITY","STATE","ZIP+4"
-IF COMPANY & STREET ADDRESS OMITTED-
....... COMPLETE NAME .......... PO BOX","CITY'7,"STATE","ZIP+4"
Save As: Word Perfect=ANSI (windows) delimited text (*.*)
There should be no spaces in between quotations or commas.
la -20-11397 OB.:27RM FROI-SWIFT SLIP DOCK/PIER 81-D. TO S733056 P.02
Swift SHP inquiry—"zELA.
-9W 30th Stmet Date 10 =.Z2- 9 -7
Newport Bead -4 CA 92663
(714) 7Z3-5550 Ter= Due
FAX (714) 723�
Deliver),
CL# 502093-A Pill
Estimate
Atta: Tony Melum DOCK M ID PIER Expires
City, of Newport Beach BUILr "EIRS
ka TAIRMI 1:11
-xIE73
Re; 'Your P.O. #18317
Reimbursement materials
-Z-: e --j
4LO-20-1397 De:29AM FROK-SWIFT SLIP DOCK/PIER BLD. TO
W/&� 65-, 7w" 4:zie�
\,-i. KATELLA.��'�,_:NQE --ANGE, CA 92867
PHQNE, 714-997-140Q FA i 714-997-�3400
NEI, R !,%AY�.
WIFT SLIP
DUE N.Til IM2/17
p
T
T
.Q
AL �IAST VUEi INVOiCES SUBJECT TO 1-5% PER %10 NTH SEFIVIC S CHAA 3 E� CV$701,A DAGAM
Tt,r �Y ATTORNEY FEES ANU COLLECTION EXPeN$E M THE EVIENT QF OEUNQV�;Nl PAYMENT,
X___
AFCEIVEID 5Y
29
6733356 P.03
�X)py�
;7
41.EM /-u,
�,mqs
714;
77q, 39,
.17
TDTqL
P.03
Newport Beadi., CA 92663
Telephone: (71 cl) 723-5550
FAX CONTI* LETTER
FAX #-. (71, 1) 723-6502
DATE: 1145�1-94. 1,
PAGES TRANSM17=, INCLUDING COVER LFI -M:
TO:
COMPANY NAME:
FAX NUMBER, 4.
SUBJECT,
MES,SAGE:
?LEASE RESPOND F*OR YOUR INFORMAnON
lil� �41 R
FROM: ���-QREA
q ri
10-13-1997 02:15PI FRO�LSWIFT SLIP DOCK/PIER BLD. TO S73305S
W F S L l-t`.ta
I)OCK AND pll,,]I;t WELDERS
500 - 30(1 Street
NevTort Beac i, CA 92663
Telephone: (71,4) 723 -55 -50 -
,.In A '%7- J-1 1-%'% ITT 170 ir U"rlrlVID
P. 0 1
PLEASE RESPOND F'Ok YOUR INFORMAnON
ORIGINALS MAILED 11VAMC3 FOR YOUR REPLY
FROM:
IFYOU DO NOT RECEIVEALL OF YOUR PA, i:ES, PLEASE CUL VS AS SOON AS POSSIBLE,
28386
KAREN ORDER# 20412
MET 38 DAYS BD
9 16:32
2,559.98
PLASTIC LUMBER.
SWIFT SLIP
EA FRT
DATE: "16/12i97
DOC4 832882
L 500 30TH ST.
774.99 *N
��DUE
..........
. . . . . . . . . .
INVOICE
NEWPORT BEACH
CA 926613 T
-0,
Sp p
'SL R:, PL LASTIC LUMBER
X' 936 ORANGE
PAST DUE iNVOiCES
SUBJECT TO 1.5% PER MONTH SERVICE CHARGE.
CUST'ON4,
tR-.AGREES
T PAY ATTO N
8 EY FEES
AND,
COLLECTION EXPENSE IN THE EVENT OF
DELINQUENfkYMENT.
wl,
62 En 'FZI
3'116181 TONGUE AND OR 29
41.29 /EA
2,559.98
PLASTIC LUMBER.
EA FRT
FREIGHT CHARGE
74 99
774.99 /EA
774.99 *N
..........
. . . . . . . . . .
w
X06s
kN-TAXABLE
:SUBTOTAL
-3,334.17
RECEIVED BY
wl,
From:
Dalton, Lloyd
Sent:
Thursday, October 09, 1997 3:45 PM
To:
Melum, Tony
Cc:
Patapoff, Bill
Subject:
Adams Street end groin
R, I
Adams-01.doc
Tony ...... you must make sure that the marina owner agrees to dredge and do all
else needed to maintain sand height against the groin from now on. I'm afraid
that he will not do so without a lot of coersion from the City. If the dredging is not
done, the street end will end up with a terrible dropoff from the coping, and the
City may have all sorts of claims of injury at the street end.
FIRE AND MARINE DEPARTMENT
MARINE DIVISION
70 Newport Pier
APPROVAL IN CONCEPT
APPROVAL IN CONCEPT BY THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH as required for
permit application to the South Coast Regional Commission pursuant
to California Administrative Code, Sections 13210 and 13211.
General Description of Proposed Development: AI—f
7- 0
Property Address: aor-~1111 I
le'
Legal Description:
City Harbor Permit Number:
Applicant: w,
Ad -
Applicant's Mailing Address: 2 / Ile 7 0 elf— '. -1-/ 7
Applicant's Telephone Number:
I have reviewed the plans for the foregoing development including:
1 The general site plan, including any roads and public
access to the shoreline.
2. The grading plan, if any.
3. The general uses and intensity of use proposed for each
part of the area covered in the application.
and f ind
They comply with the current adopted Newport Beach
General Plan, Zoning ordinance, Subdivision Ordinance,
and any applicable specific or precise plans or
That a variance or exception has been approved and is
f inal.
A copy of any variance, exception, conditional use permit, or other
issued permit is attached together with all conditions of approval
and all approved plans including approved tentative tract maps. On
the basis of this finding, these plans are approved in concept and
said approval has been written upon said plans, signed, and dated.
Should Newport Beach adopt an ordinance deleting, amending, or
adding to the Zoning Ordinance or other regulations in any manner
that would af f ect the use of the property or the design of a
project located thereon, this approval in concept shall become null
and void as of the effective date of this said ordinance.
In accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act of
1970, and state and local guidelines adopted thereunder, this
development:
Has been determined to be ministerial or categorically
exempt.
Has received a final Exemption Declaration or final
Negative Declaration (copy attached).
Has received a Final Environmental Impact Report (copy
attached).
All discretionary approvals legally required of Newport Beach prior
to issuance of a building permit have been given and are final.
The development is not subject to rejection in principal by Newport
Beach unless a substantial change in it is proposed.
This concept approval in no way excuses the applicant from
complying with all applicable policies, ordinances, codes, and
regulations of Newport Beach.
Tony Melum, Marine Deputy Chief
By:
Signatdre
Printed name and title of signer
Date:
Attachments:
2.
3.
4.
lu;-
-UTY,OF NEWPORT --BEACH
CITY OF
NEIPORT BERCH
KST LJPIPER
NEWPORT
BRY
BRY
I)RCI-p-
tC OC28RIV,
VICIN-ITY-MRP 6 1rE-
NNW My. CFLIFMaR
WEST
JETTY
3 �' 4 1 5 1 c.-,
:x
6Aopmw44A-o
r irkLik noij
ke
1�4-- 014 Ail
-ASTI C
_0 P/
VjA L -L
i-t-�.o rurtvAllou
PWF I LE I v = 401
MMINGS ARE DPRESSED IN FEET AND DENOTE
ELEVATIONS BRSED-ON MEAN LOWER LOW WATER.
30r
3
FIRE MARINE D I
CITY OF NEWPORT BERCH
lit
0
&o;
a
r, I
PLAN VIEW lw = 40'
j7-
FPPLICANT'S NAME P4r)dX gr'OWV\J '. OB ADDRESS Z/2:f IDRTES-7-97-
CITY OF NL --,PORT BEACH FIRE MARINE DE. �RTMENT
HARBOR PERMIT APPLICATION
(Please print all information)
Randy Brown, 427 Edgewater, Newport Beach, CA 92661 714-723-4567
Landing Associates, 17042 Gillette Ave., Irvine, CA 92614-5601 714-251-4880_
1. Applicant (Property Owner) Address Telephone
427 Edgewater, Newport Beach, CA 92661 712-0427-1
2. Project Address (Street Address) Harbor Permit Number
3. New Construction X Revision Maintenance - Dredging
4. Fee Waived Check No. N/A Date N/A
5. Brief Description of Proposed Work:
43' groin wall adjacent and westerly of permit line between 427 Edgewater
and Adams streetend.
6. Submit 8 1/2" x 11" Drawings (3), Include:
1 . Location and dimension of proposed structure.
2. Location of bulkhead.
3. Location of property lines and lot size.
4. Location of -channel markers within 200 feet of proposed project.
5. Existing ground profile, and area and profile of any dredging with elevations showing depth relative
to MLLW.
6. Elevations of top and bottom of piles and bulkheads with respect to MLLW.
7. Any special conditions affecting the construction or affecting boating operations.
8. Owner Builder/Contractor Declaration/insurance Information.
7. Owner -Builder Declaration must be corqleted�( ide of this sheet)
8. Applicant's/Agent's Signature:Q Qqm�= Date: az
2) � P Date: / /
9. Work can begin once the City has received evidence of the following additional approvals and you have
been notified to proceed. If you begin prior to the notice you will be in violation of the Newport Beach
Municipal Code and subject to penalties.
10. Your permit will not be final until we have conducted an on site inspection once construction is
completed as per Municipal Code, Section 17.24, if we have not been contacted for a final inspection.
OFFICE USE ONLY
Approval in Concept.
Date
Approval of the City of Newport Beach Council.
Date
Approval of the Army Corps of Engineers
Date
V", Approval of the California Coastal Commission.
Date
V1 Approval of the City's Public Works Department.
Date
Approval of the City's Building Department. Date
Approval of County of Orange. Date
Issued. (Permit is stamped drawing. Date
Site Inspection. (call 644-3043 for appointment) Date
Site Re -Inspection Date
Conditions: (See attached conditions)
s-AL.TSBUP.y EXTERPRJSES, -TWC.
170420ffiette Avenue
-Trvine, CaCifornia92614-5601
(714) 251-488o
August 25, 1997
Tony Melum
City of Newport Beach
Marine Department
Post Office Box 1768
Newport Beach, California 92658-8915
Re: Agreement for Groin Wall
Adams Street End, Balboa
Harbor Permit 112-0427-1
Dear Tony:
Thank you for providing the Amended Harbor Permit application last week. I am returning
herewith a fully executed copy of the Harbor Permit Application reflecting the 48 foot
length of the groin wall, along with the Conditions thereto and the location drawing, both
of which I have initialed. Per our discussion, I have changed the dimension between the
U.S. Bulkhead line and the U.S. Pierhead line to reflect 80 feet (vs. 75 feet originally
reflected).
I have also enclosed herewith a check payable to the City of Newport Beach for $2,240.00.
This equals one-third of the maximum total expense, including engineering, related to the
project. Any overage amount will be returned to us following completion of the project.
Pete Swift has requested that one person be his contact for ease in ' coordinating and
completing the project. Thank you for agreeing to represent us and Randy Brown in this
capacity.
Tony Melum
August 25, 1997
Page Two
We will look forward to completion of the groin wall project at an early date. Thank you
very much for all of your participation and support.
Very truly,
Douglas L. Salisbury
President
General Partner/Landing Associates
DLS:sd
Enclosures
cc: Randy Brown (w/encl.)
David Salisbury (w/encl.)
cl, 1p.
I P o P. i �!,.; j
'Aar1[TwTqT
FIRE AND MARINE Dtr
TO:
FAX:
FROM:
DATE:
70 NMPORT
NEWPORT BEACH, CALWORI,,-JU 9Z,58
PHOI�JE #: 714-644-3047 OR 714-644-3044
F -AX # 71"73-3056
FAX COVER SIIEET
NUMBER OF PAGES:
REMARKS:
SALISBURY EWtERPRJSES1.TXC-
17042 qiffiette Avenue
Irvine, CaC#i)rnia 92614-56oi
(714) 251-488o
July 15, 1997
Tony Melum
City of Newport Beach Marine Department
Post Office Box 1768
Newport Beach, California 92658-8915
Re: Agreement for Groin Wall Installation
Adams Street End, Balboa
Harbor Permit 712-0427-1
Dear Tony:
�7
Newport Landing Restaurant forwarded to me a copy of the Harbor Permit Application for
the installation of a 43 foot groin wall at the Adams Street end. We would like to see this
application processed and approved promptly by the appropriate parties, and would
appreciate the following.
1 . A new Harbor Permit Application completed showing "Landing Associates"
as one of the joint Permit holders to replace "David Salisbury, Newport
Landing ". Landing Associates is the owner of the leasehold interest and our
address is 17042 Gillette Avenue, Irvine, California 92614-5601. Our
telephone number is (714) 251-4880.
2. A copy of the drawings reflecting the installation, location and specification
for the groin wall.
3. A copy of the proposed Agreement reflecting the shared costs (1/3 each)
between the City, Method Art Corporation (Randy Brown) and Landing
Associates for the installation of the groin wall. It is our belief that this
Agreement should also reflect shared costs (1/3 each)for reasonably
maintaining sufficient sand elevations on both sides of the support wall for
some fixed period of time into the future.
4. We are in receipt of a March 1 Oth proposal from Shellmaker, Inc. for the groin
wall installation ($6,370) and understand that a competitive proposal was
also going to be submitted by Swift Slip. Is this proposal available at this
time?
Tony Melum
July 15, 1997
Page Two
Tony, Landing Associates is committed to participating in the installation of the groin wall
at an early date. Should you have any questions or require any additional information,
please do not hesitate to call me at (714) 251-4880. Thank you for your assistance with
and support of this proposed project.
Very truly,
Douglas L. Salisbury
President
General Partner/Landing Associates
DLS:sd
cc: Davie A. Salisbury
Randy Brown
APPROVT-- 1 1997 Meeting Dates and Loc., 'ons
California Coastal Commission
January 7-10, 1997
July 8-11, 1997
CROWNE PLAZA - HOLIDAY INN - LAX
HOLIDAY --INN - VENTURA
5985 West Century Blvd.
450 ' East Harbor Blvd.
Los Angeles, CA 90045-5463
Ventura, CA 93001
(310) 642-7500
(805) 648-7731
February 4-7, 1997
August 12-15, 1997
PRINCESS RESORT
CROWNE PLAZA - HOLIDAY INN - LAX
1404 West Vacation Road
5985 West Century Blvd.
San Diego, CA 92109,
Los Angeles, CA 90045-5463
(619) 581-5914
1310) 642-7500
March 11-14,1997
September 9-12, 1997
CARMEL MISSION INN
EUREKAINN
3665 Rio Road
7th & "F" Streets
Carmel, CA 93923
Eureka, CA 95501
(408) 624-1841
(707442-6441
April 8-11,1997
October 7-10, 1997
WATERFRONT HILTON
DEL MAR FAIR GROUNDS
BEACH RESORT
2_260 Jimmy Durante Blvd.
21100 Pacific Coast Hwy.
Del Mar, CA 92014
Huntington Beach, CA 92648
(Ph. no. to be added prior to mtg.)
(714) 960-7873
May 13-16,1997
November 4-7, 1997
RADISSON HOTEL - SANTA BARBARA
RADISSON HOTEL - AGOURA HIL11jS
1111 E. Cabrillo Blvd.
30100 Agoura Road
Santa Barbara, CA 93103
Agoura Hills, CA 91301
(805) 963-0744
(818) 707-1220
June 10-13,1997
December 9-12, 1997
MARIN COUNTY BOARD OF
MARIN COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS CHAMBERS
SUPERVISORS CHAMBERS
Administrative Bldg., Rm. 322
Administrative Bldg., Rm. 322
Marin County Civic Center
Marin County Civic Center
San Rafael, CA 94903
San Rafael, CA 94903
(415) 499-7331
(415) 499-7331
From: Tony Melum
I contacted the Coast Commission and as part of our permit application, they
need a letter from our engineers outlining the impact of the groin installation
on adjacent City beaches. I know this is not an exact science but we need to
frame it as best we can to assist in our permit application. It would be my
suggestion that we do some wording, such as the following.
"This application is for the construction of a 48 foot groin wall, immediately
bayward of Adams Street streetend. The proposed groin wall should have the
following effect on the adjacent beaches. The beach immediately to the west is a
sandy slopping beach. The area to the east is a relatively deep -water boat
berthing facility. It is assumed that the groin wall will stabilize the sand on the
sandy, sloping beach and assist in maintaining usable water depth at the marina
immediately to the east. It will do this by slowing the migration of sand from the
sandy, sloping beach into the deep -water marina. This condition will also be
augmented by periodic dredging from the deep -water marina and the placement
of the dredged sands on the sandy, sloping beach to the west."
It you need to add anything or want to discuss this give me a call.
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH FIRE MARINE DEPARTMENT
HAR13OR PERMIT APPLICATION
(Fisaic print all lnforin�nn)
Randy brol�m, 427 Edgewater, Newport Deacb, CA 52661 714-723-4567
Landing Associates, 17042 Gillette Avc-, Irvine, CA 92614-5601 714-251-488(
421 Edgewater. eWPOtt Beg
2. ProJect Address (5treet Address)
3, Now Construction X Revision - Maintenance Dreviging
4. Fee Wftivdd Check No, NIA Date N/A
5. Brief Dagcription of proposed Work:
49' groin wall adjacent and westerly Of permit line between 427 Edgewater
and Adams streetend.
6. Submit 8 11211 x 11 " Drawings (3), Include -
1. Lomtion and dimenrplon of proposed structurs.
2. Location of bulkhead.
3. Lomton of property lines and lot 3ize.
4. Location of channel marKers w1thln 200 feet of proposed project.
5, Existing ground proffle, and area and profile of any dredging with elevations showing depth relative
to MLLW.
6, Glevations of top 2nd bottom of piles and bulkheads with respect to MLLW.
7. Any special conditions affeefing the construction or affecting boating operations.
8, Owner Builder/Contractor Declaration)Insurance Inf6rmation.
T Owner -Builder Declaration must be co lated (onj�everse side of this 3hcet)
7&'777
8. Applicant's/Agent's Signaturel)— Date:
2) Date.--. > -ZSk01_\
9. Work can begin once the City has rec&ed e� ridence of the following additional approvals and you have
been notified to proceed. if you bagin piior to the notice you will be in violation of the Nswpart Bf)ach
Municipal Ccde and subiact to pon2ldes
10. Your permit will nvt be final until we have conducted an on site in3pection once ccnstruction is
completed as per Municipal Code, Section 17.24, If we nave not Oeen contacted far a finai inupvrtion -
OFFICE USE ONLY
Ve Approval in Concept.
Approval of ft City of Newport Beach Council.
V" Approval of the Army Corps of Engineers
Approval of the Caftmia Coastal Commission.
Approval of ft City's Public Works Dapartment.
Approval of the City's Building Departrnent.
Approval of County of Orange.
Issuad- (Permit Is stamped drawling.
Sit* Inepeation, (gall 644-3043 for appOintment)
Site Re-InapeCtIon
Conditions: (See attacbed conditions)
Date
Date
Date
Date
Datg
Date
Date
Date
Dato
Date
I RN i
Pern-di # 1122-G427-1
Joint Permittee acknowledges that an integral part of the groin wall
as proposed is sufficient sand elevation on both the westerly and
easterly 5ide of the groin wall as determined by the City.
A). joint Permittee at 427 Edgewater shall be re5ponsible for
maintaining sufficient -sand, ek�vation on the westerly side to
support the wall.
B). joint Permittee at 505 Edgewater shall be responsible for
maintaining sufficimt sand elevation on the easterly side to
support the wall.
%I -PS
03-27-1997 03:53PM FROM SWIFT SLIP DOCK/PIER BLD
<*
Swift'sup
500 30th Street
Newport Beach, CA 92663
(714),723-5550
FAX (714) 723-6502
City of Newport Beach
TO S73305S P.02
2-- c/ 2-7
Inquiry- #44 29 1 1
ip, 11 zr�-Vzl 914 1:0
t
TonY Melum BUILDERS
ESTIMATE
Date
10% down, balance on
Tf=5 completiS2n
Generate plans for 47' long groin wall
Build groin wall with the following;
1) 8' long 3 X 10 tongue and groove dark grey recycled plasticIr minim"Um—.
4' penetration.
2) (2) 4 X 6 Douglas fir beams on each side of top edge of wall bolted
.at each plank.
3) 2 X 12 cap attached with stainless steel screws.
LUMP SUM: $6,175.00
'Note:
This does not include our permit costs or later I drift type calcula-
Ac,ceptj&d,' by: Date:
Plea se sign and return with a 10% down payment if yc
authokizd the price and work contained in this estil
FOR CALUNG SWVr SU?
would like to
e.
TOTRL P.02
APPROVED 1907 Meeting Dates and Locatiow,---
Califorirta Coastal Commission
January 7-10, 1997
July 8-11, 1997
CROWNE PLAZA - HOLIDAY INN - LAX
HOLIDAY INN - VENTURA
5985 West Century Blvd.
450 East Harbor Blvd.
Los Angeles, CA 90045-5463
Ventura, CA 93001
(310) 642-7500
(805) 648-7731
February 4-7, 1997
August 12-15, 1997
PRINCESS RESORT
CROWNE PLAZA - HOLIDAY INN - LAX
1404 West Vacation Road
5985 West Century Blvd.
San Diego, CA 92100
Los Angeles, CA 90045-5463
(619) 581-5914
.(310) 642-7500
March 11-14,1997
September 9-12, 1997
CARMEL MISSION INN
EUREKAINN
3665 Rio Road
7th & "F" Streets
Carmel, CA 93923
Eureka, CA 95501
(408) 624-1841
(707442-6441
April 8-11,1997
October 7-109 1997
WATERFRONT HILTON
DEL MAR FAIR GROUNDS
BEACH RESORT
2260 Jimmy Durante Blvd.
21100 Pacific Coast Hwy.
Del Mar, CA 92014
Huntington Beach, CA 92648
(Ph. no. to be added prior to mtg.)
(714) 960-7873
May 13-16,1997
November 4-7, 1997
RADISSON HOTEL - SANTA BARBARA
RADISSON HOTEL - AGOURA HILILS
1111 E. Cabrillo Blvd.
30100 Agoura Road
Santa Barbara, CA 93103
Agoura Hills, CA 91301
(805) 963-0744
(818) 707-1220
June 10-13,1997
December 9-12, 1997
MARIN COUNTY BOARD OF
MARIN COUNTY BOARD OF
SUPERVISORS CHAMBERS
SUPERVISORS CHAMBERS
Administrative Bldg., Rm. 322
Administrative Bldg., Rm. 322
Marin County Civic Center
Marin County Civic Center
San Rafael, CA 94903
San Rafael, CA 94903
(415) 499-7331
(415) 499-7331
STATE OF CALIFORNIA—THE RESOURCES AGENCY PETE WILSON, Govemor
-California Coastal Commission
South Coast District
200 Oceangate, 1 Oth Floor
Long Beach, CA 90802
(562) 590-5071
PERMIT APPLICATION INSTRUCTIONS
A completed application includes the APPLICATION FOR COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT, the appendices to the
application, and Required Attachments.
• Please answer all questions. If a question is not applicable to your project, indicate "N.A."
• Refer to pages 6 - 7 of the AppucxnON for a list of Required Attachments.
• Incomplete applications will -not be accepted for filing.
• All exhibits must be legible.
The following checklist is provided for the convenience of applicants in gathering necessary application
materials; it is not a complete statement of filing requirements.
Proof of applicant's interest in the property . ...........................................................
Assessors parcel map(s) showing the proposed development site and all adjacent
properties within 100 feet of the property boundary . ................................................
Stamped envelopes (no postage meter please) addressed to neighboring property
owners and occupants and other interested parties and a list of the same . ................
Vicinitymap . .....................................................................................................
Two sets of project plan(s) and site plan(s); in the City of Los Angeles three sets of
plans.
Copy of any environmental documents (DRAFT AND FINAL Eft ElSs, NEGATIVE
DECLARATION) I prepai7edifor the project and any. comme -its and tesporus . .............
Verification of all other permits, permissions or approvals applied for or granted by
pubrcagencies . .................................................................................................
Copy of geology or soils report (if necessary) . ........................................................
Local approval of the project. ................
Has the Notice of Pending Permit been posted in a conspicuous place? ....................
Filingfee . ..........................................................................................................
Page
Item
6
1
7
2
7
4,5
7
6
7
7
7
9
7
10
7
1 11
Appendix B
D
—Appencrix
, Appendix E
Have you.and the agent (if appropriate) signed the application at the appropriate lines on pages 8, 9,
and 127
2. Describe the proposed development in detail. Include secondary improvements such as grading, septic
tanks, water wells, roads, driveways, outbuildings, fences, etc. (Attach additional sheets as necessary.)
a. If multi-familly residential, state:
Existing Proposed new Net number of units on
u I units completion of project
b. If land division or lot line adjustment, indicate:
0 rental
0 condominium
0 stock cooperative
0 time share
0 other
Existing Proposed new Net number of lots on
lots lots COMDletion of v- Existing Proposed
3. Estimated cost of development (not including cost of land) $
4. Project height: Maximum height of structure (ft.)
• above existing (natural) grade ...................................
• above finished grade ...............................................
• as measured from centedine of frontage mad .............
5. Total number of floors in structure, including
subterranean floors, lofts, and mezzanines
2
Is tandem parking existing and/or proposed? ............................................... C] Yes o No
If yes, how many tandem sets? size
10. Are utility extensions for the following needed to serve the project? (Please check yes or no)
a) water b) gas c) sewer d) electfic a) telephone
0 Yes C3 Yes C3 Yes C3 Yes C3 Yes
C] No 0 No 0 No No L'j N o
Will electric or telephone extensions be above -ground? ................................ C] Yes 1:7 1 No'
11. Does project include removal of trees or other vegetation? ........................... C3 Yes 0 No
If yes, indicate number, type and size of trees
or type and area of other vegetation
SECTION Ill. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
The relationship of the development to the applicable items below must be explained fully. Attach additional
sheets if necessary.
1. Present use of property.
a. Are there existing structures on the property? ..................................... 0 Yes [3 No
........ ..
b. Will any existing structures be demolished? ........................................
0
Yes
No
I Will any existing structures be removed? ............................................
0
Yes
No
2. Is the proposed development to be governed by any Development Agreement? 0 Yes 0 No
4
8. Will the proposed deve'lopment convert land currently or previously used for
agriculture to another use? ....................................................................... Yes No
If yes, how many acres will be converted?
9. Is the proposed developmeM in or near:
a. Sensitive habitat areas (Biological survey may be required) .........................
0
Yes
C3
No
b. Areas of state or federally listed rare, threatened, or endangered species ...
0
Yes
0
No
c. 100 -year floodplain (Hydrologic mapping may be required) ...........................
C3
Yes
0.
No
d. Park or recreation area .......................................................................
C3
Yes
C]
No
10. Is the proposed development visible from:
a. State Highway 1 or other scenic route ..................................................
0
Yes
L-3
No
b. Park, beach, or recreation area ............................................................
0
Yes
No
c. Harbor area ........................................................................................
0
Yes
No
11. Does the site contain any: (If yes to any of the following, please explain on an attached
sheet.)
a. Historic resources .............................................................................
0
Yes
No
b. Archaeological resources ....................................................................
0
Yes
No
c. Paleontological resources ....................................................................
0
Yes
No
12. Where a stream or spring is to be diverted, provide the following information:
Estimated strearnflow or spring yield (gpm)
If well is to be used, existing yield (gpm)
If water source is on adjacent property, attach Division of Water Rights approval and property owner's
approval.
SECTION IV. REQUIRED ATTACHMENTS
The following items must be submitted with this form as pan of the application
1. Proof of the applicant's legal interest in the property. A copy of any of the following will be acceptable:
current tax bill, recorded deed, lease, easement, or current policy of title insurance. Preliminary title
reports will not be accepted for this purpose. Documentation reflecting intent to purchase such as a
signed Offer to Purchase along with a receipt of deposit or signed final escrow document is also
acceptable, but in such a case, issuance of the permit may be contingent on submission of evidence
satisfactory to the Executive Director that the sale has been completed.
The identity of all persons or entities which have an ownership interest in the property superior to that of
the applicat must be provided.
R
I
land surveys, legal descriptions, subordination agreements, and other outside agreements will be required prior
to issuance of the permit.
In addition, the Commission may adopt or amend regulations affecting the issuance
of coastal development permits. If you would like notice of such proposals during
the pendency of this application, if such proposals are reasonably related to this
application, indicate that desire .......................................................................... 0 Yes No
SECTION VI. COMMUNICATION WITH COMMISSIONERS
Decisions of the Coastal Commission must be made on the basis of information available to all commissioners
and the public. Therefore, permit applinants and interested parties and their representatives are advised not to
discuss with commissioners any matters relating to a permit outside the public hearing. Such contacts may
jeopardize the fairness of the hearing and result in invalidation of the Cornmission's decision by court. Any
written material sent to a commissioner should also be sent to the commission off ice for inclusion in the public
record and distribution to other Commissioners.
SECTION VII. CERTIFICATION
1. 1 hereby certify that 1, or my authorized representative, have completed and posted or will post the
Notice of Pending Permit card in a conspicuous place on the property within three days of submitting
the application to the Commission off ice.
2. 1 hereby certify that I have read this completed application and that, to the best of my knowledge, the
information in this application and all attached appendices and exhibits is complete and correct. I
understand that the failure to provide any requested information or any misstatements submitted in
support of the application shall be grounds for either refusing to accept this application, for denying the
permit, for suspending or revoking a permit issued on the basis of such misrepresentations, or for
seeking of such f urthor relief as may seem proper to the Cornrhission.
3. 1 hereby authorize representatives of the Calffomia Coastal Commission to conduct site inspections on
my property. Unless arranged otherwise, these site inspections shall take place between the hours of
8:00 A.M. and 5:00 P.M.
Signature of Authorized Agent(s) or if no agent, signature of Applicant
NOTE. IF SIGNED ABOVE BY AGENT, APPLICANT MUST SIGN BELOW.
SECTION VIII. AUTHORIZATION OF AGENT
I hereby authorize
and to bind me in all matters concerning this application.
to act as my representative
Signature of A�plicant(s� .
(On� the applicant(s) may sign, ere to aut nze an agent)
APPLICATION FOR COASTAL DEVELOPMENT PERMIT
APPENDIX B
LOCAL AGENCY REVIEW FORM
SECTION A (TO BE COMPLETED BY APPLICANT)
Applicant
Project Description
Assessor's Parcel Number
SECTION B
PE.COMPLETED BY LOCAL PLANNING OR BUILDING INSPECTION DEPARTIVIENT)�:.:
I Zoning Designation
I General or Community Plan Designation
du/ac
du/ac
Local Discretionary Approvals
• Proposed development meets all zoning requirements and needs no local permits other than building
permits.
• Proposed development needs local discretionary approvals noted below.
Needed Received
0
0
Design/Architectural review
0
Variance for
0
Rezone f rom
0
Tentative Subdivision/Parcel Map No.
0
Grading/Land Development Permit No.
0
0
Planned Residential/Commercial Development Approval
0
0
Site Plan Review
0
0
Condominium Conversion Permit
0
0
Conditional, Special, or Major Use Permit No.
0
0
Other
CEQA Status
0 Categorically Exempt Class Item
1:1 Negative Declaration Granted (Date)
0 Environmental Impact Report Required, Final Report Certified (Dat�)
0 Other
Prepared for the City/County of by
Date Title
10
APPENDIX D
DECLARATION OF POSTING
Prior to or at the time the application is submitted for filing, the applicant must post, at a conspicuous place,
easily read by the public and as close as possible to the site of the proposed development, notice that an
application for the proposed development has been submitted to the Commission. Such notice shall contain a
general description of the nature of the proposed development. The Commission furnishes the applicant with a
standardized form to be used for such posting. If the applicant fails to post the completed notice form and sign
the Declaration of Posting, the Executive Director of the Commission shall refuse to file the application, or shall
withdraw the application from filing if it has already been filed when he or she learns of such failure. 14 Cal.
Admin. Code Section 13054(b).
Please sign and date this Declaration of Posting form when the site is posted; it serves as proof of posting. It
should be returned to our off ice with the application.
Pursuant to the requirements of California Administrative Code Section 13054(b), I hereby certify
that on (date of postinF) -' I or my authorized representative posted the Notice
of Pending Permit for application to obtain a coastal development permit for the development of
(descri p tj`on—oFde-v-eTo p men t)
Located at
(address of development or assessors parcel number)
The public notice was posted at
(a conspjcuous place, easily seen by the public and as close as possibfe—to-IfFe-site of the proposed development)
(signature)
(date)
N07E. Your application cannot be processed until this Declaration of Posting is signed and returned to this
office.
FOR oFFIcE usE oNLY
PERMIT NUMBER
RECEIVED
DECLARATION COMPLETE
12
CD
9
CO)
co
cn
0
CD
sz
C43
CO
SL
CA,
0)
cn
CD
CD
CO)
CD
CD
CD
CO)
Cl)
CO
(b
W
C4
co
Cb
CD
Ct.-
tQ
(D
(D
=r
CD
0
0
03
cn
3
=9.
co
se;
0
CL
CD
Q.
cn
co
23
CL
CD
0
CD
cr
w
In
C3
to
LD.
Er
cr
23
0
CD
CL
CD
t7
F)
CD
ca
CD
z
fn
Qt
PC
m
m
m
ra
m
CO)
-4
0= C.D
0 CD
@ *
CD
cc R a,
CL
a m 0
CS
u
2,), C=D G)
a
g7
C-) >
C'S.9
rn C)
CD 0 CZ) 0
>
=
CD
r,3 >
cc cc 0 so
w
>
C.0
to Q
M 0
co
4�b (A to
cz co n
co
CD 8
-0
o m
g
a.
-=n-
CD
= 6
cr
Ic
2)
CD
CD
CL =
CD cn
L
=.
a)
CO Q) co
W
co
a
C<D
M= CID
Cr
�c
co
CL
w
=4
-4
S CWI 0 W
8 -D
SIF
8 03 =za
= Z C-)
Cc ?e Z; =
ur
rL
cr
tu
CD
23
0
cc
CD
co
ca
> =0
:—
CO --m Fr -��
=r
sR
8
-4
CD cr 0
CD
=0 C -A,
CA)
cn CD
CD
�
4= RL
CD
w -n
co
co
0
CA .0
0
to
CD
2) a
0
Co
0 CD
CD
=r
CD C,
cr
to
CD
o
(D
m
CD
r- cD G)
a)
Cn 0 >
-Z4 cn z r- r -
CD M 0
M Q
cn
o
-4
— SUE)'
zr-
o
's ID
7;:
Co
%c
CD
0
CD
w
cis
m
40 5
cm w
-n
CD
Cc
w
CD
K
S
23
Z-0
Ll
(D
cn
ciD
Lo. cr
0
CD fa
co
CD 2
CD
a cc 5,
CD
S4
C.)
9D CD
Q--
Cn
CA
6 to
=
r -L
a
Z
cr CD
8 8
CD
cn
S -F
:5 a
CD
o a
0
0
5
-
Sr
CD
0
5 2.
0
CD
CL
-0
03
CA 0
CA
o
a)
CD
CO)
o
C4 a) PC
CD CD
cn
- @
"- w Cl)
0
cc S 0
3f -
A
--
0
=r
CD
co
jF 23
co %C <
W
— -n
0
Cl)
CD gas
fA
CD
2)
0
3
0
CD X
CD M=
0
CD
CA CA
S2. U)
-
i
0 -
CD 0
co
ca
o 0
= =
0
CA
CD
cn 'a
CD CD
CD
C=,
0 Fr-
23 CA
co
90
.m
0
CL
M M
X
5*
0
CD
-
CD
-a
2) CD
0
-
0
CL
5-
:L �c
=
-
CD
cc
0
w
CD
cn CD
co
cr
CL
CD
tu
0
CD
Err -0
w
23
CA
90
CD CL
C)
cn
0 CL
C-) CD
CA
Fr
Fr'
06
CD 0
CD w
cn 0)
0
-
co 0
CD
C-)
0 co
t =
7:
Fr-
rL r,
-
co
0)
a -
CO)
CD CD
CD
CD
ca
CD
x
-0
0
sr
CD
,
cn
:3
FS:
a
5
sr
SD
= cn
CD
0
03
CA ca
CD
CO)
(A
CO3
CA)
CD CD
03
w
co
CD
CL ca
CL
0
03 p.,
= :-
CA
CL
a) J
0
cr CD
CL ca
CD CD
cr
CD 2)
cr
(D
CD
cm
CD
CL cr
CL CD
M =
= CD
ca
2. :e
S,
CL CL
CD
ca
z
fn
Qt
PC
m
m
m
ra
m
CO)
-4
0= C.D
0 CD
@ *
C)
a,
cc R a,
CL
a m 0
CS
n
2,), C=D G)
a
a
C-) >
C'S.9
rn C)
CD 0 CZ) 0
>
=
CD
r,3 >
cc cc 0 so
w
>
C.0
to Q
M 0
co
4�b (A to
cz co n
co
CD 8
-0
-=n-
CD
= 6
cr
00
= SIL
CD 0
co
rCT c-
Cil c
r- c-
2) co w
-4
S CWI 0 W
Jitr. -- zr
C.) CD -C
�l CD =
;m* m n
CD
*
8 03 =za
= Z C-)
Cc ?e Z; =
ur
>
F-3 R w
CD
10 C-
- M =,
C7) CL
-4- 5 ,
rL
m C') cn
-(D =r
k C) n (4
Wn
Cl)
-4 C Cn C, =nr
> =
> cr
CD
> =0
:—
CO --m Fr -��
co
= a
fc.0
CD C") CD
2
-4
CD cr 0
CD
co -0 c -)
CA)
A
�
4= RL
CD
w -n
co
co
M
ILn
CD
(A
m
CD
r- cD G)
a)
Cn 0 >
-Z4 cn z r- r -
CD M 0
M Q
cn
;o
-4
— SUE)'
zr-
CO'O cf) 0 G)
=
-1
7;:
Co
4L 20) W
-0
-n n
co 0 w
a)
44 M. m
0
-4 = C7
.A. >
C= =
c) S'L
CA) a)
w C-) to
>
cm w
-n
CD
Cc
w
CO)
C')
c,) -n
23
Z-0
c J
CD fa
co
0 23
> = co
CD
0
to
C.)
0
Cn
CA
m
;o
Z
Cn cO r- G)
2) CD
Cn co -n
CD
-u j:,-- 0
0 CD 0
co 0 C)
" to
I
"
Cn
—
C,
C', Ln
cu -
a 17 = �o
CD
cc a
C,
— Cf)
-sk- M W
-P� (D Cl) lu
C;- = M
w CD cb
9"- = 0
cr so
Cc CD
90 =
CD ca
CD CD
o
C4 a) PC
C,) M
C.) X-- p A
> CD 0—
m
- @
"- w Cl)
CD
CA -
cc S 0
3f -
C-)
-n
C-5
cc 2L z
co
co
jF 23
co %C <
W
— -n
0
CD
C.) Cl)
R If
CD gas
2r
®R
m
m
z
m
(a
-n
0
M
m
CO)
CO2
0
z
m
M
ca
APPENDIX E
PERMIT APPLICATION FEE SCHEDULE
1. RESIDENTIAL PROJECTS
A. New single-family dwellings
De minimis waiver ..................
...................................................... [I $
Administrative permit or consent calendar ..................................................... 13 $
Regular calendar
If 1,500 square feet 2or less .................................................................. 13 $
If between 1,501 and 5,000 square feet 2 .............................................. 13 $
If over 5,000 square feet 2 ...................................................................... 13 $
B. Additions or improvements to single-family dwellings
200
2501
2503
:500 3
1,0003
Deminimis waiver .......................................................................................... 13 $ 200
If handled as an amendment to a previous coastal development permit,
see Amendments (Section III.D.) below.
If not a waiver or an amendment to a previous coastal development permit,
the fee is assessed according to the schedule in A. above (i.e., based on
the calendar and/or size of the addition, plus the grading fee, if applicable).
C. Multiple residential projects (including residential subdivisions,
resubdivisions and condominium conversions) 4
2-4 units ......................................................................................................... .0 $ 6003
5-16 units ....................................................................................................... E3 $ 2,0003
17-166 units ................................................................................................... E3 $ 120 /unit 3
167 units or more ........................................................................................... E3 $ 20,0003
D.. Lot line adjustment ....................................................................................... E3 $ 6003
Fee does not change if application is removed from the Consent Calendar by the Commission and rescheduled on the Regular
Calendar. Fee does change if removed from the Administrative Calendar and rescheduled on the Regular Calendar.
2 Including gross internal floor space of main house, attached garage(s), covered patios, plus any detached structures intended
for human habitation (e.g., guest houses, detached bedrooms, in-law units); not including patios or decks open to the sky,
detached garages, barns, art studios, tool sheds, and other outbuildings not primarily intended for human habitation.
3 Grading fee applies; see Item F.
4 No additional fee is charged for construction of single-family residence(s), if proposed together with a land division.
13
E. Extensions 7 and Reconsiderations
Single-family residences ........................................................................ El $ 200
All other developments ........................................................................... [] $ 400
F. Assignments ................................................................................................... [I $ 200
G. Request for continuance
1strequest ............................................................................................. E3 No charge
Each subsequent request
(where Commission approves the continuance) .................................... 0 $ 100
H. De minimis waivers ......................................................................................... 0 $ 200
1. Public works facilities ........................................ [if public agency is applicant] E3 No charge
IV. ANY OTHER DEVELOPMENT NOT OTHERWISE COVERED
Development cost up to and including $100,000 ....................................................
$100,001 to $500,000 .............................................................................................
$500,001 to $1,250,000 .........................................................................................
$1,250,001 to $2,500,000 ......................................................................................
$2,500,001 to $5,000,000 ......................................................................................
over$5,000,000 ......................................................................................................
TOTALSUBMITTED ................................................................................................... $
ADDITIONAL NOTES
0
$
600
$
2,000
$
4,000
$
8,000
0
$
12,000
0
$
20,000
1. Fees are assessed at the time of application, based on the project as proposed initially. If the size of a
proposed dwelling or the amount of proposed grading is amended during the application review
process, the fee is not changed.
2. If different types of development are included on one site under one application, the fee is based on
the development with the largest fee.
3. Fees for after -the -fact permits shall normally be double the regular permit fee unless such added
increases are waived by the Executive Director when it is determined that the permit could be
processed by staff without significant additional review time resulting from the processing of the
violation.
7 If permit extension is objected to by Commission and application is set for a new hearing, then a new application fee is
required, based on type of development and/or applicable calendar.
15
Z, C,
NEWPORT LANDING
June 2, 1997
Toni Mellum
Newport Beach Marine Department
3300 Newport Blvd.
Newport Beach, Ca 92658
Re: Groin Wall
Dear Toni,
Randy and Landing Associates (Landlord to Newport Landing) has
agreed to share the cost of the Groin Wall construction by 1/3, but
not to exceed $2200.
Based on our last conversation the City will share in that cost
also by 1/3 and will handle the bids, design, permits and
installation of the (43">) Groin Wall.
This letter will serve as confirmation Landing Associates will
participate in that project.
If you have any questions, please don't hesitate to contact me at
my office at (714) 261-9013.
Sincerely,
W J J�-
David A.Salisbury
Vice President
cc Randy Brown
Doug Salisbury
cityltr
RESTAURANT - 503 E. Edgewater * Newport Beach, CA 92661 -, (714) 675-2373 0 Fax (714) 675-0682
CORPORATE OFFICES - 17042 Gillette Avenue, Suite 400 - Irvine, CA 92714 -, (714) 261-9013 - Fax (714) 261-0568
ORT
4q
NEWPORT BEACH FIRE AND MARINE DEPARTMENT
8,M
CONDITIONS
Permit # 112-0427-1
joint Pern-dttee acknowledges that an integral part of the groin wall
as proposed is sufficient sand elevation on both the westerly and
easterly side of the groin wall as determined by the City.
A). joint Permittee at 427 Edgewater shall be responsible for
maintaining sufficient sand elevation on the westerly side to
support the wall.
B). joint Permittee at 503 Edgewater shall be responsible for
maintaining sufficient sand elevation on the easterly side to
support the wall.
Purchase PO
Requisition CITY OF
NEWPORT
BEACH
P.O. No.
(If Reserved) Date: 6/10/97
Dept: FIRE & MARINE DEPT.
Suggested Vendor: Ship To:
Swift Slip City of Newport Beach
500 30th Street P. 0. Box 1768
Newport Beach, CA 92663 Newport Beach, CA 92659
Attention: Tony Meluin
Attention: Phone No.
Quantity Unit Price Amount Budget #
1 Construct a 47 foot long groin wall at the 2,200.00 2,200.00 C2360058
Street end of Adams Street in Newport Beach.
(The City will pay a 1/3 share based on
agreement with 2 adjacent property owners).
There were 2 bids on the project, $6,175 by
Swift Slip and $6,375 by Shellmaker Inc.,
the only 2 marine contractors in the City.
We are requesting an additional $425.00 in
the overall cost of the project to cover the
cost of engineering and permits. The City's
portion of this bill (a 1/3 share)
would be $2,200.00, the unit price.
Comments: Please provide as soon as possible. Sub IotaI 2,200.017
Tax
Total 2,200.00
jDate Required: ASAP I F.O.B. ITenns: InvoiceNetM
Code Amount
or person authorized to execute requisitions, under $500.00)
Director
Director (Approval required for purchases exceeding
Te'a 7bici
Mark Sites
P.O. Dox 4�98
Balboa Island,,CA 92662
TELEPHONE 673-3056 TELEPHONE .... ... ............
PAGE NO. PAGIE$
DATE DATEOFFLAAS $TART WORK DATE YOUR ]NOUIRY NO. PROPOSALNO.
5/25/96 June
Dredging beach restoration at Alvorado & Edgewater ...... $1400.00
Dredge public pier at Coral Street & South Bay Froat, Balboa island
to -59 MLLW.....&.*# ........ $1400.00
TH
401ER-�AL AND LA$ I H. vE..
T.,
SATIS-
THE ABOVE PRICES, SPIECIFtCATPONS AND CONDITION$ Aqr
FOR THE FACTORY ANO -ARE HEREBY ACCOTED. YOU ARE AUTHORIZED TO:
SUNCOFTWppty-j�j 144t .�Uadj:&
COMPLEA THIS CONTRACT AS SPECFF-0, PAYMENT WILL BE MADE
PA-YMEJ47. TO S.E. Due �-Pp�i��PQPP!etiP;V
VAAD$� AS.FOLLCWS.'. AS. OUTLINEP TO THE LEFT.
All' materisfi6�guarantaeJtq bgras specified; in �-wor�crp4nfikh. 610ATURE OR -COMPANY
immer acoarding to �5taNafd P(Wic&s�- Any alteiratjon or deviallon from above spsciffc;w�
tjqns involving extra costs w��j ot exequted only upcm writttt) ordws, and will btcom'�-- 30
e'xtra' oharge over and FAbove the arst6�.. �,jj aoD*p4nts oontingent upon sleikes, sc-
aidants or., doloys �beyond our:c'ontrcl� Owner to aaag fire,tornado and ofte necessary
insuranc<�, our w"ers are"tuily, cov"d by Workman!.- cornpenratiorl Insor6noe, AUTHORIZED SIGNATURE
NOTL THIS PROPr.O- N:7D NOY ACCFPTED WITKLN j —0 CA",
SIGNATUR9
ngpffnRM. 4W460
TO' d SS0=9 0-L
04TE 0;: ACCEPTANCE
carbonlaffiff
kC6--d sv:Ee 0000-TO-Nuf
S E 1`417: S y C!,A� 5 I'll Davco En".e,�Pr,,., ?14673133S:# 1
-1 1
MaY' 8 , 1997
Mr. Randy Brown
507 W. Edgewater
Newport Boach, California 92661
Re: Groin W&I.1
Dear Randy, . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ar, sorry we have not Connected by telephone, so T thought I would
fax you a short letter to you.
I wanted to discuss the groin wall proposal with you. As -you may
know, this proposal had to be researched and presented to Landing
Associates, th-,�L Landlord for Newport Landing Restaurant. As both
th e ci t,
1� .1
I and :subcOntr&ctors stated, there is no guarantee that
.Liand-ing wij.,, see a =st saving in reduced frequency of
dredi;�'.`nq aost due -0 'e
th groin wall. On the other hand , the
i. Ion ,,)f j./3
contritc f the cost the groin wall appears it could
glve- you back -our �,aach by retaining the sand from falling . back
t C 1'r
,_-rara
Your prop.) -sal to Landing kssociatps to Participate in 1/3 of the
cost, nOt., Y,:O ex-ceed $2200 $6600 Total) , has been approved by the
Pftrtnvrs�-, I wi .-h tl ap,,,
that You M ight assist us in return.
Landing as the Landlord for Newport Landing Restaurant,
would apP:�Gcldte Vour . Support in the Restaurant's on-going
P -P -Plication to the Alocholic Beverage control (A.B.C.) to license
the Outside patiO directly in front of the Restaurant. A brief
letter of suPPOrt tO./tha A.B.C. Would be aPPreciated by both the
Landlord and Tenant. The license posting and notification will
begin ths niddla o -f thia montil.
.1 know you would like to begin the work on this wall, and we also
-L
hope we ca. -i conclude the process of licensing our patio area in the
30 -day posting period. once you have reviewQd this letter, please
give ne a call at either .ty oftice (261-9013N or my pager (291-
SENT Pv:DAV"" ENITEF E, T - - "
t
Mr. Randy Brown
May 8, 1997
Page Two
71451131330;# 2
156A"M Cavco Einte;
Looking forward to talking with you soon.
Sincereiy,
nj'_"11/1�
DaVe SalisbUry
President
DAS/clm
CC: Doug SdjjSbjjrV
\wP5-1\nll\rb. )-tr
*Pn
AVO
- - - - - - - - ...
OWDOME
of
ADDRESS OF PROPOSED FACILITY
TPERMIT #
MAILING ADDRESS
7E,__,,ZNE No.
FEE
CHECK NO.
APPfMVED BY: DATE
F
APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE FOR A HARBOR PERMIT TO
OCHD
C4*�Q;RWG;H�SE A
ENGR
AT THE ABOVE LOCATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE CITY OF
NEWPORT BEACH PERMIT POLICIES AND THE ATTACHED DRAWING
COUNCIL
By
COMPANY
PUBLIC WORKS
DATED
DEPT.
El
DATE
ESCROW
INSPECTION
SIGNATURE
2
7-z-
7154 2 2- Y", 6
to
0
0 BALBOA
&A r
80A
'4
CU
OIL
VICINITY 5 K ETCH 0
Newport Say California
0
6ROWN-f. 3C^Lg MOLES
Praced From LwAngeles LI.S.E.1) d" 81SA'!i
ofi &WW P-WALM ercif j" 'AW0.94 dr"ce adr"030
'Wm.'W" Lawa.- Low W -W
.0,0c, Yler -WR'P"0-W.
Lj
A
1A T 04
;r 91. or.
7-1
K
1140;41YIS, ST
Proposed
Pierand Landincj F104
Newpor+ Bdy
Neyvport Beach, Cal I i 1`01
Apo""O. by, Mp rrl ... ....
CITY OF NEWPOP-7 REEACH
A R B
PERMISSION IS HEREF
AND
MAINTAIN THE FACUT!
AT THE SITE INDICATED, SUBJEU
THE NOMIN PMW, POUCiES OF NEVI -1
ANY SPSCL& CoftnOW LISTED HEK-Of'!
IS NOT VANSFOOMEWOMMTHE WRIT7
THE CITY HAPJWR 6016WOMW OR CRY
RIGHTS GIVEN UNM 7W MMiT ARE FE
Ly
AND THIS PERMff MML-'.BE.NMQM BY THE 'Xi
IN ACCORDAIlU Ujf�,QF THE Muj�el IL
- ,,*ffHMS0RC00P NIATO,
71
PERMIT NO.
xg
�-Warline consulting 4si"
407
esign
c4z-
Wimp /-o-w- o -r 1.-57- f
4 e0v APPI- IIFP 14 7- HI -1- W,,
44
)o 41t, rA v I All
-34'
-F
Kz'
-2 4'6,014 T
C L.�-Al 7 -E -K` OC- )go,4? 7'
-Z- 4 itlAW
54
,7
7=-
3q 804 T
c)f
Xp
EIFB.Y PUBLIC VNigiclilpliS p - MR.
9
1S, T A. M
ES
g& -71,c> of
S3812
KA11.4 AND 4113
:z�
-?,y 9 7
-A e.
OF
.450 chqrafer
typicnit top
bottom
bE9CP'eT10N
DRAWN
Woricing stren Itb 16? 0 rsi
-ess mc, Tmi
HARBOR PRECAST COMPANY
LONG DEACH. CALIFORNIA
'RESTRESSED CONCRETE PILES
E CRE 0
5::A'_r DWG No.
FORM moco �2 300 1j.kV I.AA261
J
L
6jP;q_ps1 at 28 day.�_
0
L
fi -4,000. val at transfer
strand.
14-3/8"
ClUmatn-
3"
spiral
OOQ_Ibs
1.55-
"Z
-Working v and 25.110 1-��s
8
_TQf -Kng rce lbs
13-5/8"
3A". ebamfer
196 in 2
4 . ed.gem
-E.f-f ectly.p—prestre.-ss- 1.025 Dai
.450 chqrafer
typicnit top
bottom
bE9CP'eT10N
DRAWN
Woricing stren Itb 16? 0 rsi
-ess mc, Tmi
HARBOR PRECAST COMPANY
LONG DEACH. CALIFORNIA
'RESTRESSED CONCRETE PILES
E CRE 0
5::A'_r DWG No.
FORM moco �2 300 1j.kV I.AA261
J
L
L
.450 chqrafer
typicnit top
bottom
bE9CP'eT10N
DRAWN
Woricing stren Itb 16? 0 rsi
-ess mc, Tmi
HARBOR PRECAST COMPANY
LONG DEACH. CALIFORNIA
'RESTRESSED CONCRETE PILES
E CRE 0
5::A'_r DWG No.
FORM moco �2 300 1j.kV I.AA261
0 ASSOC
324 EL MODENA AVE.
June 23, 1995
WIIZ-4Z7
dba. Marine Consulting& Design
NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92663 9 USA e PHONE (714) 642-2206
Department of Public Viorks
City of Newport Beach
Subject: Pier Reple.cement
427 E. Edgewater
Newport Beach, CA
The three existing tee piling in the replacement area appear
to be in relatively good condition. There are a few hairline
cracks, but no bleeding rust. Unless conditions change
existing piling should be satisfactory.
Sincerely,
Roland S. Hornby
RSH/bh
RE— - -: --- � - " �
- C-FEAVED
FJUN 2 7 W5
�P L �10
Jew Us C
P, Ri's
& Nalill Vol' UPPe'llIP-1111
TOM
'i'viethod Art Col , tioll,
5(),., lVest I? (1gelvater
Newport Beach, CA 92661-1155
714-723-4567
0011 LIZ 1-FUJULL lylillli%Uk e
Ditc: 6-2-9:—,�
eq a -Y
Ll 2 -S -1. 'Ji �f c 0 c
V, 4 0 -k VN
C /vO
A/c
11, PP, f, —A I
0
V,
4- — J
t
G�.
hl
17 ;t
rb
I ILA
o
Lr� Is
01
I tj
/-/2 7
I cl cv) at I L
r%
S4
c�
jjO
0
0 0
LZ
M
VN
z 47�
Q
9,)
I
�2 K6 6)ps.
flz I,/ 16a- rs Z:;�,q z &Z;. Cllyp)
t
12** MAY, OPENING
-,550Z-1Z2 LTLOClf /AV
-=V,4� �A' 18 - AJ3.
3X 7- X 12�
n;
TEE PILE
CIIA"
REPAIRS TO INCLUDE:
16 gju�, OL�L- 01(1%v�-1 Vr.
TREATED WITI I ACA ACZ& . , . -
1.
Replace 2" x 8" stringers with
2. FIELD CUTS AND BORED jioCEs sILAL4 :
1
211 x 1211
FIECEWE A BRUSH CQAT OF CONCENTRATT-9
2.
Replace handrails 2" x 3" with
ACA OR ACZA.
3. BRACKETS Anb FWEI-IbIS'SHALL 13E HOT
411 x 411
DIP GALVANIZED, EPDXY COATED OR
3.
Replace handrail caps 2" x V
STAINLES%
with 2" x 6"
4.-VALKING SURFACES SI (ALL 14AVIE A
4.
Add 6" x 12" pile cap to existing,.
SKID RESI.STANT FINISIL SUCII AS (jnpAINT-
6" x 12" cdp and use 2 x 10" x 3/411
ED -nMBER OR GMt on -nhiaRR
lag bolts to secure second pile
STIRINGER SPLICES ARE noT pErMTTEj)
cap
-BETWEEN PILES.
L "::* I / /-- I - /,�- 0 �
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
SINGLE OR JOINT RESIDENTIAL
USE PIER SECTIONS
I
DRAWNT!� �DrOWDATE 7 5 -
APPROVED,
PU13LIC WORKS DIRECTOK.
R.E. NO. �
DRAWING -HO. 67-,E? - (:�-,7 a 9 L
June 1, 1995
Randy:
The scope of
Edgewater is
consequently,
project.
the proposed work to the pier and dock at 427 E.
of a much larger project than we anticipated, and
the department must require working plans for this
We would like to be able to continue with the Maintenance Permit
only and not require Coastal Commission and Army Corp approval,
but it will be necessary for you to provide the following:
1. You must prepare and submit workin�r drawings and
calculations for the dock indicating its structural
intergity as required by the City of Newport Beach Public
Works Department.
2. Ret urn the application for the Maintenance Permit, the
Owner -Builder Declaration, and a Check for $60 made out to
the City.
If I can assist you with there iFequirements, please call me at
644-3044 at your earlist convenience.
Sincerely,
Wes Armand
A�
4'dWW fO7 X-WWJ'- ClFre� �-%Of R
Lo%overr .4ow Wcv Affr-*
0,04, 011ee IOAA
ki
r 0 04
r
io
ST.
Proposed
Pierand Landing MO.&
Newpor+ B -5Y
Newport Bea c h, Ca I i Fo rr
rjp rrl s ... ......
Z'
4:6
T --- 5F,�Iliq-ann v—on i uppenneini
rdethod Art Corporation
507 West Edgewater
Newport Beach, CA 92661-1155
714-723-4567
&o-11 &-ri�oj—ect-ivfa-nxger.--j&anay-D-roww--
Date: 6-2-95--,,
-S 4. TDo Ck"
vi 4 0 VN Ca
14�0
f.C-k 171r --
IE
v%
>(
tA 4r -
St
IA K
TA
AWL
0
LR
c-3 'J L
U,
:3
I V
J 1" 7
M.
0
IF
22
A
0
V\
a",
i .1r,
VT
� 1 15, i
2 X 4 eAll_ W,9,f-T),K115 - A0a' 77 77k
I � L
A_3jr4 s4s "-03rse
4 S 4-9 W1.0 - 8 d P�5_R 94S 7,- TYC-1 5'a.c. mw, moo'
4�
12" MAX * OPENING 1/2" BOLTS WITH
L3x3x'4xIO LONG W1 3-/Z%�13OLTS 2-0 WASHERS, TYP.
EACH LEG (TYP.)
2 DECKING SPACED 1/4" MAX, Typ. TYP. (USE 1-1 /2"
A6. EDGE DISTANCE IN
-,w STINGERS AND
..CENTER IN 4"
POST WIDTH)
9Te1,v,::F-=,e6 PE-A;l 7-49L,6 1-16-ReoAj r
yoll
6 X 12 1
4
aw,!; x 2. a -A. 5
PRECAST PILE ..........
j PILE SPACING
-rv,olZ^AL .4olew "o j9V..4r�dcroVM Ah',C2-140N
ecw_ Ile
z _3X3 x f44 x 10"1-44.0 Jq//
,q - l/Z # , a& rf , F, 4e, q Z - --a. c./yo)
12" MAX. OPENING
,0 SW,_^K1AV
,5/.4f -A' 18- AJ3.
,OX12
.447ze 6407
/t -&O
M.4X.
TEE PILE
7, AWO
Pl- A 7'A'0--e1W fhrC r/40m
5C,4L,e:
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
to
to
I
SINGLE OR JOINT RESIDENTIAL
USE PIER SECTIONS
a
'STRINGERS'
SPAN
2XG S45 0 Z-0-
10`-0" MAX
3X6 S4s fft,_'O"
iz-6" MAX
2X6 RS P_ r-4-
14* -3 -'MAX
.4xG IRS @ 4-4
ir-2 MAX
3X8 RS- Ill C-47
.22'40 -MAX
NOTES
L TIM13ER SHALL BE SEL STRUCT D.F.
TREATED WrM ACA ACZA.
2. FIELD CUTS AND BORED -HOLES SHAL�
RECEIVE A BRUSH COAT OF CONCENTRATEE
ACA OR ACZA.
3. BRACKETS AN15 FAST04tRS*SHALL BE HOT
DIP QALVANIZO, EPDXY COATED OR
STAMLES&
4;. 'WALKING SURIFACES SHALL HAVE A
SlaD RESISTANT FRGSK SUQi AS LINPAINT-
ED TWER OR GI;dT ON TIMBER
-5. sTFJNGER SPLJCES ARE NOT
-BETWEEN PLES.
REV. 3/4/92 JW
REV.2/27/91
4 - 7-,5.5
I_Z4 -670 leG.
DRAWN -4- L- DATE 3-1-70
Z-. -(_*�_O_ff. SL,
UBL(C WORKS DIRECTOR
R.E. No. 91537
DRAWIN"0-,67'A9— a,09- /-
MethodArt Corporation Date: 6-2-95-1
507,West Edgewater
Newport Beach, CA 92661-1155
714-723-4567
'9 Add 4
A/0
10 PJ1.
14�0
f r Q
t4
I 4C
-73
XA K'*,
fA
57
U
b
0
5)
lob
Pj.:
EA�
04
06,
I
0 0
b a
FA-
oo 4--
M—
c
(L
Lf� U
M
VN in
('\f—
(b
Or
LIV,
"4-
D
Z�
-Ij
(A
0 0
b a
FA-
oo 4--
M—
c
(L
Lf� U
M
VN in
('\f—
(b
Or
LIV,
"4-
D
Z�
1ARBOR PERMIT NO.O//.?--o Z1,77
Da'�e h )5 s-
PARTME., A,,RRLE.�,CATION FOR%HARBOR, PERMIT,,
CI @F�NEWPORT BEACH-MARINE,DE
E,
Site. address 'T Cl
phone
Tele
19we
Owner7z-& al
Owner Mailing Address, IAJ a 14e city & zi i39/�OCL
Description of work:;New Revision Maintenance Other,
"4-0
,Work to be done:
OWNER -BUILDER DECLARATION
J�hereby:affirm that I am exempt from.,�_he_ dc)filariact6j�`,s- lidense law'because:
(Sec,.7031.5, Business and Professions Code) Any, City or County which requires� 'a permilt :to
construct, alter improve, demolish, or repair an structure, prior to its�iss.uance, also re -
V
qu i re -S the -appl:i,cant I for such permit to file a signed statement that he is licensed pursuant.
or _Law*(Chaper 9 (commencing with Section 7000) -
to the provision of the Contractsliciefis6 of
Divi'sion 3.c:f the Business -and.Professi.ons Code) -or that.he-,is exempt therefrom and the basis
for the alleged exemption. Any viola- ' ti on b ' f'Se'ct ' i'on 7031.5 by any appl i cant f or a permi t'
jects he applicant to a civil penalty of-'n'ot more than five hundred dollars ($500).
I, . a . s owner of.the, property, or,my empl'byees with wages as their sole compensation, will,
he
r for:sale (Sec.,7044, Business and
_6�do _t . wd�k, ._.and,-_the,_-stru.cture. i's..not intended orl of fe ed
Professions Codei The Contractor's LicenseJ'aw does not apply to -anlowner of property who
builds�or improves thereon, and who does such work himself or,thmugh his owh:,employees, pro�
vided that such improvements are., not intended or, offered- for sale... Jf, however, the building
or improvement is sold within one,year of completion,the.owner-builder will have the burden of
proving that he did not build,or improve for:the purpose of sal&.)
1, as owner of the prdpe'rty, am exclusively. '6ontracting with licensed 'contractors to
construct thepr6ject (Sec. 7044, Business and Professions Code: The Contractor's License
Law does not apply, to an owner of property who builds or improves thereon, and who contracts-
i-cense-purs
n t "a f6r": ( s) L uant-to-the Cohtra-ctor-s,-L-.i�c-ense-�taw)-----
for such projects with a o r c
Code for this reason:
—..I. a m exempt under Sec. of,Business and Professions
Date
Owner Signature
t
Contractor Telephone
Address �'City & Zip
License - Class State License No. City License No.
t
LICENSED CONTRACTOR'S DECLARATION
I -hereby affirm that I am licensed :under provisions of -Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 7000.)
f
of Division 3 -of the Business and Professi'ons Code,, -,and license is infull force and ef 6tt.
MY
Contractor signature Date.
INSURANCE: INFORMATION-:.
Workers' Compeinsation-Declaration
r a' Certificate of
hereby affirm that I have a Certificate. of Consent to self -insure, o
Workers',Compen§ation Insurance, or a..C.ertified Copy thereof. (Sec. 3800 LAB. -,C,.
.Policy No.
Company
"tertif i ed Copy is 'hereby- furnished- Certi f i ed Copy is filed with Marine, Dept..
Date Applicant
Federal Longshoremen &,Harbor,Workers'. Insurance Declaration
breman .& -Harbor Workers
I he reby �,a f f i. rm, iha' t I hav- I e a- C . ertificatle of Insurance for Lo,ngs'h,
Insurance as,required.by.Federal Law.
Date Applicant
Certificate of Exemption f rom Wor,ko�rs' Compensation
6re'men and
Insurance/Federal Longsh* Harbor Workqrs'�' insurance
I certifythat,"in the of the wbrk'fo hich this m
r w per it. is issued,,,. .1-shal 1 not.
per._
f
employ,any person7,ih any manner so,'.'as to become subject' to the.Workerl'S ompensation�Laws o
California or Federal Longshorema'n A, Harbor Wo---"rs-' Irls'uranc'e.
Date Applicant
Note to Applicant: If, after maki"ng thia�certlfica,te 6f,exemption,.'you should become isubject
to the Worker's Compensation provisions of the Labor Code,' or th-e,Federal Lo'� ho eme
�gs r n and
Harbor Workers' Act, you must forthwith comply with sitch. provisions. or this,permit shall be
deemed revoked.
I certify -that I have -read this ap "lication and state that the above infomati i
p- � . ion- is correct.
1 agree to comply with all City and County ordinances and,State laws relating to. building
construction,''and h6reb"�avthortze represen-ta:tives of thi-s -.Ci'ty to �enter-,upon..the. above-
mentioned,property for i�nspection...purposes.
Signature.of,permittee D at. e
011
t.q 7, 1
3.
4e 9 n A. AISAA
Ormea rrm w3it"eles
i5CWJ7COVJVgZ aVW
'40W
'00
T- tj 4
ST
li?
t
Proposed
Pierand Landing Fic
Newpor+ BaY
Newport Beach, Ca I i Fc
�jprrls
I
CITY OF NEkA,`-lr`r-`r" 07-ACH
PERIMISSIGN IS HFRF:;
MAINTAIN THE FACII-17,
AT THE SITE INDICATED, SUB-�c(��f
THE HARBOR PERWr POLICIES OF
ANY SPECL40JL commoks LISTED H6L.��,
IS NOT TRANSFERABLE VMHWrTHE WRIT' -
THE CITY HARBOR COOROKAM OR C)"i
RIGHTS GIVEN UNDO TH6 MWIT ARE
AND THIS POW MN BE REVWD BY THE C!
IN A=RoA= VM I= 17 OF THE MUN I
0ffjWBOR C00f-r-!NAT-Fz
PERMIT NO.
, �4
&�,55,5 Z�,
WAX,
N Vo 1, 1 C ��P. ADDRESS OF PROPOSED FACILITY PERMIT
r -c w VA ig"
MAILING ADDRES4 TELEPH16NE NO. EE/ CHECK NO DATE
50_7,W, ECl, �a te,_ 12-33
le
,V
7
APPROVED BY: DATE APPLICATION IS HEREBYMADE FOR A HARBOR PERMIT TO
OCHD
AT THE ABOVE LOCATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE CITY OF
ENGR NEWPORT BEAcl� PE51AS POLICIES AND THE AATHEP DR�,w
B efaArt(2,-'-cpC
COUNCIL OMPANY
PUBLIC WORKS DATED t6 1 //,3
'DEPT.
ESCROW DATE
INSPECTION SIGNATURE
SPECIAL CONDITIONS:
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH, CALIF. WX FORM 68-1010
rJqAME(S)
1! 1,RES S 6F*iClLITY-;
::E d�
:R]
�MAI
ra
CHECK NO.
A ,W#RVVW
WATt
APP MADE, TO TRANSFER HARBOR PERMIT
�OCHD
LIM
BUYERS',:,NAME(Sp-
govilp"Woko 5
...........
77'
-4, A 4, -444
A;, ,
oz"
"T
N
TWA
PATEK
j..
S PEC.IAL CONDITION
OF T14E MomcipAL CODE.�, 1,,TY'C;OUNCJL IMACdO�i,ClAkCE WFTj;TITLE 17
NEWPOR
'T�,BE CH. CALIF. WX FORM 69-101�3 Rigv
. .. . . ....... . . .. .....
Ae
STATUS SHEET
HARBOR PERMITS
TRAMSFER 2_
LOCATIO
Seller -Buyer
P Date Fee Ree'v:
Date Application
Ile.
Oral Request for -Inspection
Escrow Date
.Offi ce Escrow
Escrow,
Date Inspection Made
Date Deficiency Letter Sent (if appli *6 cable)
Date Deficiemy Corrected (if applicable)
Date Orange county Notified (if applicable)
Date Transfer Completed
1. Location:
2.
_L22— —
3. Electrical:, � —6/1: �5�
4. Structural:
REMAW:
Inspector's Initials____�
n -T
�DIDNAc�,;�EYS
A PARTNERSHIP OF
PROFESSIONAL LAW CORPORATIONS
1401 DOVE STREET SUITE 300
NEWPORT BEACH. CA 92660
(714) 752-7030 FAX: (714) 752-8770
February 5, 1991
By Messenger
City of Newport Beach
Marine Department
Newport Pier
Newport Beach, CA 92660
Re: Transfer of Dock Permit No. 112-427 for 427 Edgewater,
Newport Beach
To Whom It May Concern:
Enclosed please find the fully executed Application for
Transfer of Dock Permit for 427 Edgewater, Newport Beach,
California along with Bidna & Keys check in the amount of $275.00
for the transfer fee.
All repair work referenced in the letter has been completed
(see enclosed electrical permit application E-17410 and plumbing
permit application P-29983) and has been signed off by the
appropriate inspectors.
I would appreciate it if you would take all additional steps
to transfer the dock permit and advise me of approval of such
transfer at (714) 752-7030.
Thank you.
Very truly yours,
BIDNA & KEYS
Harvey M. Moore
HMM: r s
cc: Paul Fukushima, Esq.
Method Art, Inc.
518103M283
P
C -OF NEWPORT BEACH
ITY
X P.O. BOX 1768, NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92659-1768
_q /Fog
April 13, 1990
Melvin Parsons
PO Box 123
Downey, CA 90240
Re: Harbor Permit 112-427 for the pier and float bayward of
427 Edgewater
Dear Mr. Parsons:
I will attach for your information a copy of the drawing for the
pier permit at the above address. The permit zone is generally
delineated by the bayward prolongation of the side property lines.
That, in effect, is the area you occupy under the permit and is
your permit zone. Adjacent proprty owners are precluded from
encroaching into your permit zone as outlined in Section 21.A. of
the Harbor Permit Policies, which reads:
21.A. "Moorings. Boats moored at private or public docks
shall not extend beyond the projection of the property lines of
the property to which the dock facility is connected, in accordance
with Section 20-C.
20.C. "Setbacks. The projection of the property line bayward
of the sa ' me bearing from the bulkhead shall generally be used in
determining the allowable set -backs for piers and floats."
In light of the two sections quoted above, vessels berthed at
adjacent properties that encroach across your property lines would
be in violation of the Harbor Permit Policies, and those vessels
should be relocated.
I hope this answers your questions.
plese call me at 644-3044.
Sincerely,
Tony Me)7um
Tidelands Administrator
If Ican be of further help
3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach
PO
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
tn: P.O. BOX 1768, NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92659-1768
,qj4IF01R
IFO
January 14,1991
Method Art Corp
427 Edgewater
Balboa, CA 92661
S irs:
The City of Newport Beach Marine Department has received a request
to transfer pier permit 112-427 for the property located at 427
Edgewater,- Newport Beach, CA.� The facility was inspected on
1/11/91.
We cannot transfer the pier permit until the following
deficiency(ies) has/have been corrected and WE HAVE BEEN NOTIFIED
OF THE CORRECTION:
A City -approved anti -syphon device is required at the water
connection for the water supply to the pier and float. A sketch
showing the approved type of device and its installation is
enclosed.
The electrical boxes need covers and one plug box should be
replaced.
The City Harbor Permit Policies state:
10. D. "At the time of transfer, all harbor structures
shall be inspected for compliance with the City's minimum
plumbing, electrical and structural requiremenmts, and
the conditions of the existing permit. All structural
deficiencies must be corrected prior to transfer of the
permit."
A permit for plumbing or electrical work must be obtained from the
Building Department of the City.
PLEASE ADVISE THIS DEPARTMENT WHEN THE ABOVE DEFICIENCIES HAVE BEEN
CORRECTED. When we have been notified, the structure will again be
inspected and when the requirements have been met the pier permit
will be transferred. Included in requirements for transfer of the
pier permit is the $275 transfer fee and the signed transfer card.
You can telephone 714-644-3044 to request a reinspection of the
structi),re.,.,If you have questions, please call this number.
lei
7
Tony MpW
_T,'Tidelands Administrator
3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach
Date Fee Rec v:
Date Application Rec V:;-'
I :,,z
Oral Request for -Inspection
Escrew Date
Escrow'Officep Escrow #
Date Inspection Made
Date. Deficiency Letter Sent (if appli I cable)
Date Deficiency Corrected (if applicable)
Date Orange County Notified (if applicable)
Date Transfer Completed
1. Location: -
2. Plumbing:
1 3.
4.
REMARKS:
W
Inspector's initials
LA3yu,#nj i mmal
BaY
Newpori
Newport E�ea c h, Ca I i Fo rm i a
AWocsft- byi .......
Ml
December 6, 1989
City Hall
Marine Division
P.O. Box 1768
Newport Beach, Ca 92659
Attn: Mr. Tony Melun
Dear Mr. Melun
I wish to complain about the live -a -board or camper located
next to the Texaco station at the foot of Adams Street.
I believe this individual is living in unsanitary conditions
due to the fact that he has no bathroom.
I wish him to be removed.
Very truly yours,
Ro ert Baker
Newport Beach
P0
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
X RO. BOX 1768, NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92659-1768
September 29, 1989
R. E. Bennett
301 North Michael Aven.
Fullerton, CA 92633
Re: Dredging at Newport Landing, 503 Edgewater
Dear Sir:
Within the next two or three weeks the City of Newport Beach, under
its Maintenance Dredging Permit, proposes to issue a permit to
dredge at Newport Landing, with disposal of the dredged materials
to be at the Adams Street end and the adjacent private beaches.
The purpose of disposal in these areas is to buttress the City
bulkheads in those locations. As the enclosed drawing indicates,
they are proposing to dredge approximately 140 cubic yards of
material and place it on the street end,and beaches.
If you have any questions regarding this dredging project, please
contact me at 644-3044.
Sincerely,
Tony M=m
Tidelands Administrator
3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach
7-
,)7
EL -4`9
3 -,f sivc
Vlcl Ai I TY 5 K E TC H
5AY, CA4 1004aP44A
C2 r c .7 0 C2, ,or i, c 0.7 o V -:"Me .0,00P
Alp
tA
��H
NT.
teL (P7'
RT- L-A H t:= I H4o
7' S 1-.::f =' 7-
r
t�
LEIA
PO
0
August 4, 1989
Milli F
P.O. BOX 1768, NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92658-8915
R.E. Bennett
301 North Michael Avenue
Fullerton, CA 92633
Re.: Harbor Permit 112-427 for the pier at 427 Edgewater
Dear Mt. Bennett: I
The City of Newport Beach has received several complaints
"regarding the use of your pier and float bayward of the above
address. Specifically, the complaints are that individuals are
using the pier and float in violation of Section l.A. and 4.K. of
the Harbor Permit Policiest which state:
l.A."Shore connected piers and floats bayward of residential
zoned areas shall be reserved for, the occupants of the abutting
upland property and controlled by the Harbor Permittee. Vessels
moored at residential piers shall not create a nuisance with
regard to vehicle parking, vessel waste, liveaboards, or noise
disturbances to adjoining residents'.
4.K. "In those areas of the harbor where the piers and floats-�
are bayward of residential zoned areas and are reseved for the
occupants of the abutting upland property, liveaboards shall not
be permitted".
The City of Newport Beach Marine Department requested, based on
the complaintst that the Harbor Department monitor the property
for a period of time to determine if, in facty people are living
aboard vessels at the dock.
As a result of that investigation 'the Harbor Department has
indicated to the Marine Department that in their opinion
indivivals are living aboard vessels berthed at the dock.
To remedy this situation and to preclude further action by the
Marine Depart ment, this liveaboard situation and the accompanying
nuisances must cease.
If you have questions in this regard please call me at 644-3044.
Sincerely,
Tony M61um
Tidelands Administrator
3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach
(K
CORRECTIONIREVISIONS
PIER PERMIT FRE
...... . ....
0
.........
F
RE
To Otis
0112 0427 1 U7
OWNER (LISTED S1NGLY1
JEPSCN, ROBERT 9
BENNETTt R4E.
0
N G ,..S..X.R E E I ADDRESS
11j!,j,;"jjFORN1A
111,1,11H MICHAEL AVE
.......... A
..........
mmummmmuf MONA Mmono
L
VISA
SENT
0 i 11
1 Q oil P 00
.............. ..
TELEPHONED
PLEASE CALL
RETURNED YOUR CALL
WILL CALL AGAIN
CAME IN To SEE YOU
URGENT
PO
0
P.O. BOX 1768, NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92658-8915
December 16, 1988
Stephen G. Oppenheim
507 West Edgewater
Newport Beach, cA 92661
Robert K. Jepsen
1109 North California
Burbank, CA 91505
Re: Harbor Permit 112-421 for
�and Harbor Permit 112-427
Edgewater
Dear Sirs:
the property at 421 Edgewater
for the property at 427
In the area of the above properties, the City of Newport
Beach has an easement for a sidewalk and bulkhead. Because
erosion adjacent to the bulkhead, it will be necessary
within the next several months, for the City to do dredging
to support the bulkhead wall. It is likely that the
dredged material will be taken from the beaches adjacent
to the bulkhead wall and pushed up against the wall to
support it and thereby support the sidewalk.
When definite dates for the tractor work are determined,
adjacent property owners will be notified.
If you have questions regarding the above, please contact
met at 644-3044.
Sincerely,
Tony Mmu-m-
Tidelands Administrator
3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach
Pr -
August 10, 1988 -
Tony Melum
Tidelands Administrator
City of Newport Beach
Marine Department
3300 Newport Blvd.
P.0 Box 1768
Newport Beach, Ca. 92658-8915
Dear Tony:
I am writing you this letter to inquire about a situation next to
my restaurant, "Newport Landing", which upsets me very much.
Since I purchased this restaurant in July of 1987, 1 have put up
with a couple who live both in their camper, next to a public
Walkway, and on their boat in front of private property,. My un-
derstanding is that you're not allowed to live on your boat un-
less it's infront of a commercial. property and that living ina
camper is not allowed in the City of Newport Beach.
Their names are Jeff and Patti Lewis and ever since I've been
here, it has been nothing but a problem for the neighbors and my
business. Besides the unsightly mess they create with used
refrigerators and old boats, I don't understand how this kind of
living situation can occur.
I would sure appreciate any help or advise you could give me to
solve this problem. I will cooperate in any manner to eliminate
these individuals from the property. If you have any questions,
please don't hesitate to call.
Sincerely,
Dave Salisbury
Owner, Newport Landing Restaurant
DS/cd Y
NL23
503 E. EDGEWATER, NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92661 714 - 675 - 2373 W
SM1IFF'S DEPAR'RENT, ORMGE COU�=
Santa Ana, California
LT. D. MILEWSKI
.4- DEP. C. CASLER DATE: 8-1-89
INTRA-DEPARTTEW �E7,n
501 & 503 W. EDGEWATER
Dave.9there are two old trawler type boats at the dock at Adams and Edgewater. They
are owned by the same person. This person and his wife also have a camper parked
in a vacant lot in front of the boats. After checking around the dock, it appears
the boat and the camper are being used as their residence. Theiv is a 28 ft.
bayliner tied next their boats that belongs to one of their relatives.
1948 HUNTER 34 foot p/b CF9444FS
OTHER OLD BOAT HAS NO CF's
1982 BAYLINER 28 foot p/b CF2006JU
see 28 info attached
;21(11/85)
(-Pev. 8/8o)
'Al' lu (Rev. 7/84)
DEP. C. CASLER #187
10
B19444FS
00030 ZAQ UP
OSK 00074-08/01/89 20. 39. 1&
ZAQl 2VI692 08/01/89 20.39.08
FROM CLETS:IV'
DATE: 08/01'/89' TIME: 20:39
EXP :12/31/88 LIC#: 9444FS MAKE:HUNTER BTM :VESSEL VIN :27JI42
R/O :DON CORNELIUS P INC, 9110 SUNSET BL CITY:LOS ANGELES
C.C..-19 zip#:90089,
SOLD:11/11'/80'RCID:04/23/81 LOCD.-9,�'..-
TYPE.-VI POWR:G VEW:82 BODY. -C CLAS-.-.�'*-YR:48�'FEE :0005-
HULM:W PRPL:I FEET:034 INCH:00
END
ZAQIV 3B2006JU
.... ...... . ..
7.7, '71
'"00031 ZAQ UP
00031 ZAQ UP
at, er ;t
�v 1,� 7. i,
d
A,l4 �7j �1;
wl�
OSK 00075,1,�-'08/0 i 'z-8 9,�� o 3g,
ZAQ1 2070-0,,J48/01/,89� 20-8L9. 2,8,�
�'FROM CLEI* IV'
S
DATE'i,08/Q 8" "1 ' " �4
M F/ 13
.-4o
612/31/89"Lic#.-,�!;�2006JU Y RMD 88 BM
MAKE:BAYLINER' T
'VIN`.-iBLBA86CDAE88
R/O LAK INS'.GEORGE, 42-1 E EDGEWATER CITY:B.ALBOA C. C. 30 z I P# 9,-- 66 k
SOLD t08/19,1�84,,RCID.* 10/07/88 OCID:10/05/86: LOCD:8
t
L/O -BROOKLAND,."�-,FINI 1371'REYNOLDS,CITY.-IRVINE
TYPE:V1 POWR:G VEH :82 BODY:C CLAS.IKE'FEr- :0005
HUL14:P-PRPL:N FEET:026 INCH. -OO,
CLEARANCE INFORMATION RECORDS,
OFFICE, 'WORK DATE TECH/ID SED # VALUE FICHE DATE"
128, 09/22/88,� 00009. 00- 00/00/00 - - - DOO
127 09/07/88 18 0036 00009.00 PRIOR SUSPENSE
542 10/07/88 17 0026 00005.00 00/00/00 HOO
END
PO
0 1 1 1;:�
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
P.O. BOX 1768, NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92663-3884
"o R'tA"�_
September 25, 1984
Robert K. Jepsen
1109 N. California
Burbank, CA 91505
Dear Mr. Jepsen:
The Newport Beach Marine Department has received a complaint
regarding the residential dock bayward of 427 Edgewater in
Newport Beach. Specifically the complaint is that a vessel
using the southeasterly side tie is doing so in violation of
Section 21.B of the Newport Beach Harbor Permit Policies,
which states:
21.B. "Any boat moored at a pier, -dock, or float shall not
extend bayward a distance of more than the width of its
beam beyond the pter-� -dock. or float."
The attached photographs (supplied to the Marine Department by
the complaining party).suggest that the vessel is extending
beyond the float more than the vessel's width.
This problem can be,resolved by requiring that this baywardmost
vessel be tied up in such a manner so as to comply -with the
above quoted section.
If you have any questions in this regard, please call me at
640-2156.
Very truly yours,
Tony M tell u im
Tidelands Administrator
TM: db
3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach
September 24f 1984
Tony Melum
Tidelands Administrator
City of Newport Beach
3300 Newport Boulevard
Newport Beach, CA 92663
Dear Tony:
As you know, from several past -conversations reqarding the
Hunter power boat docked on the West side of Adams St., we con-
tinue to be concerned about the potential for problems arising
out of the location of the vessel. The problem, specificall . y,
relates to the inability of boats to safely approach and depart
the fuel dock. our concern is the possibility of an accident
with property damage and bodily injury.
The enclosed photos depict the problemvery graphically.
The possibility exists that the vessel extends bayward of the
U.S. Project Line excessively.
Please give this matter your attention at your earliest
convenience.
Sincerely,
Ken Nelso?�
Project Manager
KN/ml
503 E. EDGEWATER, NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92661 714-675-0550
0
Robert K. Jepsen
*1109 N. California
Burbank, CA 91505
Dear Mr. Jepsen:
ty�-927
CITY OF NEWPORT BE.ACH
July 31, 198i
The Newport Beach Marine Department had received a complaint regarding
the use of your residential.pier and float at 427 Edgewater. Specifically,
the complaint is that a business is being conducted off the dock,(i..e.
boat tours).
This activity is in violation of Section IA of the Harbor.Permit Policies
as well' as Section 17:41 of the Newport Beach Municipal Code * Please
contact this department immediately so that this problem,can be resolved.
Very truly yours,
i
Tony Melum
Tidelands Administrator
I TM:eI
Eli
City Hall - 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California 92663
Ai
JUNE 11., 19&
MR. RALPH PETT IT
7359 CRAMER STREET
SUN VALLEY1 CAUIFORNtA
DEAR MR. PETTIT'#
IN ANSWtR TO YOUR utrytit or MAY 16o 1964,,, THE ENetureams 0ovistoN
HAS CHECKED THE $AND PROFILE AT THE END OF ADAMS STREET A*0'ftA8
F04,010 THAT THE EXI$TJ%6 PROFILE IS SifiVSTANTIALLY. AS WOULD BE
EXPECTED. MAINTENANCE DREDGtN6 IN T14C AREA Of A $LIP IS T14E RESPOrv-
SISKITY Of T14E OWNER OR LONG-TERM LESSEE*
THE JOf-NT HAR9*R COWMEZ 14AS NO RECORD Of A TRANSFER OF THE SUS-
JECT PIER I"ROM RALPH MORRIS TO ANOTHER oWNE.a. YOUR AirmotOm Is
DIRECTED TO YHE ENCLOSED COPY Or THE HARS*R PERMIT POLICIES WITH
PARTICULAR EMPHASIS TO SECTION 81 TRANSFER$ SECTION 11, SANITARY
REQULF!QtNTS AND SECTION T -4,t SET lAtc-MR14C APPARENT VIOLATION$
F THESE SE010*3 14AY 40STIfY THE REVOCATION Of THIS PIER PERMIT
AND Ali ORDER FROM THE CITY TO 14AVE T14E PIER *EMOVE04: , -
PLEASE EXPtAtli YOUR 'CONTROL OF THIS PIER AND FLOAT.
VERYITRULY YOUR$$
v J. S I Mpsom
SECRETARY TO THE JOINT HARWR COMMITTEE
ccl mft- RALLP14 Roan 'St P-0- Box 711,, BALSOA
VJS;vs
Combined Harbor Commission
City of Newport Beach Cal*
May 16tl964
7359 Craner St.
Sun Valley Cal.
Dear sirs,
I have a problem...I control the pier and float at the foot of
Adams St, on the bay side* 427 EdgewaterSt.
In the past there has been quite a problem with boats hitting the
metal pipe that overflows the street water into the bay. But now the situat-
ion has become re'diculus. The pipe is a good two feet higher than it ever was*
When the contractor installed the bulkhead and groin for the new
Associated fuel dock, they pumped all of the sand,from. their dredging oper-
ation into the space behind the bulkhead before they sealed,off the sides*
Naturally all of the sand poured thruugh the ppening and filled up the street
end and raised the bottom level under my pier and floats at least two feet.
The first float is on bot.tom. most of the time and it is wearing
through the fiberglass by its grating on the sand* I have had one boat have
to move out because it was ruining the bow. This condition exists for about
fifty feet at low tide. It is impossible to come -into the dock with power.
We must shut down -and hope that the wheel will not hit bottom,
I have spoken to the operator of -the Fuel dock., and he is of the
same mind. It makes it almost impossible to get into his back moorings at a
low tide e
The street drain pipe is now clogged up as it is under the sand
at the ende During the construction of the bulkhead when the pipe was seen
to be going under the sand, they merely lifted up the end so that it would
still be above the bottom. This in turn raised the level of the whole pipe.
I'would.like.to know what steps must be taken to remedy this mess.
Is the contractor liable for dredging it out or is it the responsibility of
the city* Or is it up to me to hire the dredge to take out all of the sand
that they dumped there? yours truly, Ralph Pettit-,r____�
R F r r n
TO: JOINT HARBOR COMMITTEE
A CHECK OF THE STATEMENTS IN THE ATTACHED LETTER REVEALS THE FOLLOWING:
1. RALPH PETTIT IS NOT THE OWNER OF RECORD OF LOT 1, BLOCK 2,
BALBOA BAYSIDE TRACT - 427 EDGEWATER STREET. E. RALPH MORRIS,
THE OWNER! OF RECORDI OBTAINED THE PERMIT FOR THIS PIER IN 1946
AND SIGNED THE REGULAR CITY AGREEMENT REQUIRED AT THAT TIME�
AGREED THAT THE PIER SHOULD NOT BE SOLD, LEASED, SUBLET OR
TRANSFERRED WITHOUT PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE CITY.,
2. THERE IS:NO BUILDING ON THIS PROPERTY.
3. THIS IS AN R-4 ZONE.
4. THIS LETTER IMPLIES AND CONDITIONS INDICATE THAT THIS STRUCTURE
IS LEASED TO MORE THAN ONE BOAT OWNER. (ON MAY 18 THERE WERE 3
POWER -OPERATED BOATS AND 4 ROW BOATS TIED TO THIS PIER AND FLOAT.)
5. THE PIPE IN QUESTION DOES NOT EXTEND INTO THE SAY AS FAR AS THE
FAR END OF THE PIER AND THE BAY END OF THE PIPE IS APPROXIMATELY
20 FEET FROM THE PIER� THE PIER DOES NOT HAVE THE CURRENTLY
REQUIRED 5' SET BACK FROM THE PROPERTY LINE EXTENDED.
6. THE SAND�PROFILE ALONG THE STREET SIDE OF THE PIER 13 ALMOST
EXACTLY AS WE WOULD PREDICT IN THE FIRST 20 FEET FROM THE SIDE-
WALK AND IS ONLY o.8 FOOT HIGH AT 36 FEET BAYWARD FROM THE
SIDEWALK-: ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE PIER (AWAY FROM THE STREET)
THE SAND ' is 1.8 FEET HIGHER THAN PREDICTABLE AT 36 FEET BAYWARD
FROM THE SIDEWALK. AT 50 FEET FROM THE SIDEWALK, THE SAND IS
0.9 LOWER ON THE STREET SIDE OF THE PIER THAN ON THE SIDE AWAY
FROM THE STREET -
THERE 15 NOTHING IN THE PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT OFFICE TO PROVE OR DISPROVE
THE CLA IM OF AN ACCUMULATION OF SAND AT THE STREET.
0
---------- DATE -5 - -,f7--64 -.,JECT ------ 6,41,10 ---- PP0FW--C--6 -7- SHEET NO ---- / ------ OF
CHKD. BY-V'�-/��DATE -------------- -------- 67. 41CID --- JOB NO ---------------- - ----------- - -
----- ------- 7 ---- --
6
Ay ------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------ ---- ---------------------