HomeMy WebLinkAbout19 - Approval of the Reorganization of the Building Department and BudgetCITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
CITY COUNCIL STAFF REPORT
Agenda Item No. 19
December 11, 2007
TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
FROM: Building Department
Jay Elbettar, 644 -3282, ielbettar city.newport- beach.ca.us
SUBJECT: Approval of the Reorganization of the Building Department and Budget
Amendment
ISSUE:
With the annexation of West Santa Ana Heights and the adoption of a new family of codes,
how will the Building Department continue to maintain its current service level of timely
plan reviews and inspections?
RECOMMENDATION:
Approve the proposed reorganization plan including three new and five
reclassified positions for the Building Department.
Approve a budget amendment to appropriate $173,045 from the General
Fund balance to the Building Department's salary and benefits account
numbers 2910 - 7000,2920 -7000, and 2930 -7000.
DISCUSSION:
The attached proposed reorganization is necessary to address the challenges the Building
Department will be facing beginning January 2008. The adoption of new codes by the
State of California differ in philosophy and approach from the codes we had in place for the
past 80 plus years, and the annexation of West Santa Ana Heights will increase the
department workload. Both of these factors will impact the service delivery and timeliness
of plan review and inspection. Since the annexation of Newport Coast in 2001, the
Building Department has been increasingly assuming responsibility for issuing permits for
site improvements, additions and alterations to properties in areas turned over from the
County to the City after construction is completed. The Building Department has not
added any staff in response to this increased demand.
Proposed Chanties to the Inspection Division
The Building Inspections Division is divided into two teams, a residential team and a
commercial team. Each team is headed by a principal inspector. Currently there is one
Approval of Reorganization of the Building Department
December 11, 2007
Page 2 of 7
vacant building inspector II position in the residential team that is filled by a contract
inspector. The proposal recommended is to reclassify this position to a senior building
inspector _position and to add a new senior building inspector position to the residential
team.
The proposed changes are necessary due to the new codes requiring higher level of
knowledge and more involved inspections of construction projects. Material specifications
and installation standards are no longer readily available in the code and inspectors must
have higher levels of technical knowledge of industry standards to evaluate and approve
construction. The plans will be more detailed to ensure and document performance
standards, which will require more inspection time and higher levels of knowledge and
experience.
Currently we are experiencing heavy commercial construction activity, while residential
construction is becoming more complex with larger homes built with basements and
several multi - family dwellings on the horizon. The Building Department did not adjust
staffing levels when the City annexed Newport Coast, East Santa Ana Heights, and Bay
Knolls. There have been many commercial and residential improvement projects in East
Santa Ana Heights and Bay Knolls since the annexation. The Newport Coast work load
has increased incrementally as more of the County's planning areas have been turned
over to the City's authority by the County. As a result we are handling more inspections for
much larger portions of that area. In Newport Coast, we have conducted 10,716
inspections for 3,418 permits. We expect Orange County to turn over eight more tracts to
the City within the next six months. In East Santa Ana Heights we have conducted 4,905
inspections for 1,184 permits, in addition to several code enforcement issues that involved
Building Department staff time to resolve. East Santa Ana Heights' inspection volume
should remain at similar levels, but Newport Coast inspection numbers should continue to
increase as more of the area's permitting jurisdiction is turned over to Newport Beach.
The January 1, 2008, annexation of the west side of Santa Ana Heights has the potential
for more code enforcement issues that will involve the Building Department.
The Building Department rotates the senior inspectors, who possess more technical
knowledge, to conduct commercial and more complex residential inspections for the
purposes of cross training and to provide flexibility to adjust to needs at any given time.
Currently, the residential team has only one senior position while the commercial unit has
two. Reclassifying one building inspector II to a senior position and adding a senior
position to the residential unit will balance the two teams, allow the department to meet the
increased work load due to the three annexed areas, and handle the anticipated increased
inspection time due to the complexity of the new codes.
The Plan Check and Permit Services Division is responsible for the project plan review and
approval leading to permit issuance. Currently it is divided into two teams, plan check and
permit counter. The plan check team includes six in -house plan check engineers and five
outside consultants. Four outside plan check consultants perform overflow plan review
when the work load exceeds in -house staff capacity, and one consultant performs grading
Approval of Reorganization of the Building Department
December 11, 2007
Page 3 of 7
and geotechnical reviews of complex projects. The plan check engineer positions are
flexibly staffed from the associate to the senior level because previous recruitments failed
to yield experienced candidates at the senior level. The Human Resources Director
recommended this approach to enable the department to fill the positions at the lower
classification and gives employees career advancement opportunities enabling us to retain
these valuable employees that are difficult to recruit.
Three changes are proposed to the Plan Check Division as follows:
A. Add two new flexibiv- staffed Plan Check Enaineer position.
This proposal is to add two in -house plan check engineer positions to reduce the
reliance on the outside consultants and provide a full time engineer available at the permit
counter for public assistance.
Compared to other communities, projects in Newport Beach are more complex in nature.
Residential projects may involve basements, shoring, dewatering, fire alarm and sprinkler
systems, sea walls and boat dock construction. All these are elements the Building
Department reviews and inspects. Because of this complexity and our outdated fees,
some consultants who have been working with the Building Department are either refusing
to take on more work or have specifically asked to end their relationship with the City. The
Building Department in the past year has tried four new consultants, which is not efficient
for our customers and the department due to transition and training demands. In addition,
the use of outside consultants does not provide optimal customer service in which the
customer and plan reviewer interaction is limited. We frequently receive complaints
related to outside consultants' service and requests for in -house plan review.
Currently the plan check engineers have a rotating counter schedule. The engineers
respond to the counter as needed; the engineer serving his /her counter hours will report to
the counter when called by a permit technician. Having an engineer available at the
Permit Counter is a very important customer service practice, allowing the engineers to
answer code questions, complete plan revisions, approve less complex projects and
explain policy and procedures to walk in customers without appointment. This need will
grow even more important with the new codes.
The rotating schedule for counter hours takes away from valuable plan check time, creates
frequent disruptions for the engineers and can create increased wait times for the
customers as they have to wait for the engineer response. The customers may not be
able to see the same engineer on repeat visits to the permit counter which can lead to
confusion and the appearance of inconsistency.
We propose to create a full time plan check engineer position dedicated to service the
permit counter on a full time basis. In addition to providing the counter services mentioned
above, a full time counter engineer will be able to provide screening for plan check
submittals, will allow customers to see the same engineer on repeat visits and to receive
consistent information and code interpretation.
Approval of Reorganization of the Building Department
December 11, 2007
Page 4 of 7
We have in the past considered adding more staff to eliminate the need for outside
consultants and to provide a more effective counter service. However, space limitations
have precluded us from this consideration. Despite our reservations, we do not feel that
using outside consultants is the most effective solution and adding additional plan check
staff is necessary. We will explore alternatives to solving the space issues, including but
not limited to the consideration of off -site office space. Once we have appropriately
addressed the space limitations we can fill the two plan check engineer positions.
The new codes will require more facilitation and training by our staff to the design
community. By adding two in -house plan check engineers, we will be able to plan check
more projects in- house, providing direct interaction with the customers, and lessen the
impact of the consultants' turnover.
B. To reclassify two Plan Check Engineer positions to two Principal Plan
Check Enaineer positions.
This division has two vacant engineer positions, presenting the opportunity for this
proposed change. As stated earlier, the new codes have changed drastically compared to
the present codes, and will require more facilitation and training by our staff to the design
community, more exercise of independent judgment by staff and a higher level of
knowledge and expertise. The designers will need to consult with staff to agree on which
approach is to be followed in his/her project design early in the process. As such, the
need to conduct preliminary reviews and early dialogue will increase. The Principal
Engineer positions will provide code interpretations and assist the Deputy Building Official
with the preliminary reviews.
The Plan Check and Permit Services Division will be divided into two teams, with each
principal engineer responsible for one team. The counter operation, over the counter plan
check and technical service, customer support and the trade permits approval will be
supervised by one position, who will also oversee the counter to insure technical customer
interaction is available, and that appropriate screening of plans for completeness at the
submittal stage for plan review is conducted. The other principal engineer will oversee the
plan check team including the consultants.
This proposal will create an efficient organization in which the two principal engineers will
supervise the two teams under the direction of the Deputy Building Official. This will
eliminate a current span of control issue, with the Deputy Building Official having to
supervise 18 staff members and outside consultants, as well as resolve most code issues.
C. Reclassify an Office Assistant position to a newly created Building
Department Specialist position.
The Building Department clerical staff is currently pooled under the Administration
Division. This proposal is to reclassify one office assistant position to a newly established
position analogous to the Public Works Specialist position. The position will be moved
from the Administration Division to the Plan Check and Permit Services Division.
Approval of Reorganization of the Building Department
December 11, 2007
Page 5 of 7
The clerical staff performs many technical tasks that exceed clerical duties due to its
technical nature, importance, and required level of responsibility. The following is a list of
these tasks:
1. Processes permit applications after permit final.
2. Produces monthly statistical reports on construction activities within
the City of Newport Beach and produces reports for the Census
Bureau and the Dodge National Construction Activity Statistics.
These reports were previously produced by a permit technician and
reassigned to reduce the work load at the permit counter.
3. Processes an average annual volume of 150 requests for building
code modifications and requests for use of alternate construction
materials and methods. It is anticipated that this number will
quadruple with the adoption of the new codes. The position will
facilitate the processing by insuring the proper justifications and
equivalencies are provided and the correct code provision is cited.
4. Run computer programs and produce the Building Department's
monthly construction activity and construction valuation reports. Also
compile the data and produce mid -year and annual reports.
These reports were previously produced by a permit technician and
reassigned to reduce the work load at the permit counter.
5. Design, create and maintain the Building Department web page.
6. Produce a quarterly, "Strong Motion Instrumentation and Seismic
Hazard Mapping Fee" report. This report is sent to the State of
California with a check for the collected seismic fees.
This report was previously produced by a permit technician and
reassigned to reduce the work load at the permit counter.
7. Make floodplain determinations and provide information to calling
customers whether a property is located within a special flood hazard
area using Federal Flood Insurance Rate Maps.
Proposed Chancres to the Administration Division
The Building Department's clerical services are pooled in the Administrative Division. The
division's clerical staff includes one Administrative Assistant, one Department Assistant,
one Office Assistant, one part time Office Assistant and Student Aides, who perform less
complex clerical tasks, led by the Administrative Assistant. With the proposed
reorganization, the office assistant position will be moved to the Plan Check and Permit
Services Division and reclassified as previously discussed. The proposed change is to
replace the part time office assistant position and two student aides with one full time office
assistant position. The student aides have proven to be invaluable help to the department
for the past 14 years; however the difficulty we now face in their recruitment and retention
Approval of Reorganization of the Building Department
December 11, 2007
Page 6 of 7
is unproductive to the Building and Human Resources Departments. The Building
Department has hired 21 student aides since 2004.
COST CONSIDERATIONS:
The following table represents the Building Department annual budget adjustment that is
needed to implement this reorganization, by position. The attached budget amendment
represents the adjustment needed for the reminder of this FY 2007/2008. The Building
Department is a fee - for - service operation.
Annual Cost of Staffing Reorganization
CONCLUSION:
Contracting out for additional plan check and inspection services does not appear to be a
viable solution in addressing the Department's additional demands caused by increased
annexation activity and new Code demands. Staff feels this reorganization proposal will
allow the Building Department to provide its current level of customer service.
NEW
Senior Inspector
1 Position
$92,682
[Step 4]
NEW
Civil Engineer, Plan
2 Positions
$110,606 x 2 =
Check [Step 41
$221,212
RECLASSIFIED
Building Inspector II
Building Inspector,
1 Position
$5,699
[Step 4]
Senior Step 4]
RECLASSIFIED
Senior Civil
Principal Engineer,
2 Positions
$7,908 x 2 =
Engineer [Step 8]
Plan Check [Step 5]
$15,816
RECLASSIFIED
Office Assistant
Building Department
1 Position
$8,922
[Step 8]
Specialist [Step 41
RECLASSIFIED
P/T Office Assistant
Office Assistant
1 Position
$1,760
[Step 6]
[Step 3]
& Student Aide
= 2 positions
ANNUAL TOTAL: $346,091
CONCLUSION:
Contracting out for additional plan check and inspection services does not appear to be a
viable solution in addressing the Department's additional demands caused by increased
annexation activity and new Code demands. Staff feels this reorganization proposal will
allow the Building Department to provide its current level of customer service.
Approval of Reorganization of the Building Department
December 11, 2007
Page 7 of 7
Prepared and submitted by:
Jay Elbettar, P.E., C.B.O.
Building Director
Attachments: Current Building Department organization chart
Proposed Building Department organization chart
JE/mg
Counci1120071staff rep 12 -11 -2007 staff reorganization.doc
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
CITY COUNCIL STAFF REPORT
Agenda Item No.19
Date: December 11, 2007
TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
FROM: Building Department
Jay Elbettar, 644 -3282, ielbettar(a)-city.newport- beach.ca.us
SUBJECT: Approval of the Reorganization of the Building Department and Budget
Amendment
ISSUE:
With the annexation of West Santa Ana Heights and the adoption of a new family of codes,
how will the Building Department continue to maintain its current service level of timely
plan reviews and inspections?
RECOMMENDATION:
1. Approve the proposed reorganization plan including three new and five
reclassified positions for the Building Department.
2. Approve a budget amendment to appropriate $173,046 from the General
Fund balance to the Building Department's salary and benefits account
numbers 2910 -7000, 2920 -7000, and 2930 -7000.
DISCUSSION:
The attached proposed reorganization is necessary to address the challenges the Building
Department will be facing beginning January 2008. The adoption of new codes by the
State of California differ in philosophy and approach from the codes we had in place for the
past 80 plus years, and the annexation of West Santa Ana Heights will increase the
department workload. Both of these factors will impact the service delivery and timeliness
of plan review and inspection. Since the annexation of Newport Coast in 2001, the
Building Department has been increasingly assuming responsibility for issuing permits for
site improvements, additions and alterations to properties in areas turned over from the
County to the City after construction is completed. The Building Department has not
added any staff in response to this increased demand.
Proposed Changes to the Inspection Division
The Building Inspections Division is divided into two teams, a residential team and a
commercial team. Each team is headed by a principal inspector. Currently there is one
Approval of Reorganization of the Building Department
December 11 2007
Page 2 of 7
vacant building inspector II position in the residential team that is filled by a contract
inspector. The proposal recommended is to reclassify this position to a senior building
inspector position and to add a new senior building inspector position to the residential
team.
The proposed changes are necessary due to the new codes requiring higher level of
knowledge and more involved inspections of construction projects. Material specifications
and installation standards are no longer readily available in the code and inspectors must
have higher levels of technical knowledge of industry standards to evaluate and approve
construction. The plans will be more detailed to ensure and document performance
standards, which will require more inspection time and higher levels of knowledge and
experience.
Currently we are experiencing heavy commercial construction activity, while residential
construction is becoming more complex with larger homes built with basements and
several multi - family dwellings on the horizon. The Building Department did not adjust
staffing levels when the City annexed Newport Coast, East Santa Ana Heights, and Bay
Knolls. There have been many commercial and residential improvement projects in East
Santa Ana Heights and Bay Knolls since the annexation. The Newport Coast work load
has increased incrementally as more of the County's planning areas have been turned
over to the City's authority by the County. As a result we are handling more inspections for
much larger portions of that area. In Newport Coast, we have conducted 10,716
inspections for 3,418 permits. We expect Orange County to turn over eight more tracts to
the City within the next six months. In East Santa Ana Heights we have conducted 4,905
inspections for 1,184 permits, in addition to several code enforcement issues that involved
Building Department staff time to resolve. East Santa Ana Heights' inspection volume
should remain at similar levels, but Newport Coast inspection numbers should continue to
increase as more of the area's permitting jurisdiction is turned over to Newport Beach.
The January 1, 2008, annexation of the west side of Santa Ana Heights has the potential
for more code enforcement issues that will involve the Building Department.
The Building Department rotates the senior inspectors, who possess more technical
knowledge, to conduct commercial and more: complex residential inspections for the
purposes of cross training and to provide flexibility to adjust to needs at any given time.
Currently, the residential team has only one senior position while the commercial unit has
two. Reclassifying one building inspector II to a senior position and adding a senior
position to the residential unit will balance the two teams, allow the department to meet the
increased work load due to the three annexed areas, and handle.the anticipated increased
inspection time due to the complexity of the new codes.
The Plan Check and Permit Services Division is responsible for the project plan review and
approval leading to permit issuance. Currently it is divided into two teams, plan check and
permit counter. The plan check team includes six in -house plan check engineers and five
outside consultants. Four outside plan check consultants perform overflow plan review
when the work load exceeds in -house staff capacity, and one consultant performs grading
Approval of Reorganization of the Building Department
December 11, 2007
Page 3of7
and geotechnical reviews of complex projects. The plan check engineer positions are
flexibly staffed from the associate to the senior level because previous recruitments failed
to yield experienced candidates at the senior level. The Human Resources Director
recommended this approach to enable the department to fill the positions at the lower
classification and gives employees career advancement opportunities enabling us to retain
these valuable employees that are difficult to recruit.
Three changes are proposed to the Plan Check Division as follows:
A. Add two new flexiblv- staffed Plan Check. Engineer position.
This proposal is to add two in -house plan check engineer positions to reduce the
reliance on the outside consultants and provide a full time engineer available at the permit
counter for public assistance.
Compared to other communities, projects in Newport Beach are more complex in nature.
Residential projects may involve basements, shoring, dewatering, fire alarm and sprinkler
systems, sea walls and boat dock construction. All these are elements the Building
Department reviews and inspects. Because of this complexity and our outdated fees,
some consultants who have been working with the Building Department are either refusing
to take on more work or have specifically asked to end their relationship with the City. The
Building Department in the past year has tried four new consultants, which is not efficient
for our customers and the department due to transition and training demands. In addition,
the use of outside consultants does not provide optimal customer service in which the
customer and plan reviewer interaction is limited. We frequently receive complaints
related to outside consultants' service and requests for in -house plan review.
Currently the plan check engineers have a rotating counter schedule. The engineers
respond to the counter as needed; the engineer serving his/her counter hours will report to
the counter when called by a permit technician. Having an engineer available at the
Permit Counter is a very important customer service practice, allowing the engineers to
answer code questions, complete plan revisions; approve less complex projects and
explain policy and procedures to walk in customers without appointment. This need will
grow even more important with the new codes.
The rotating schedule for counter hours takes away from valuable plan check time, creates
frequent disruptions for the engineers and can create increased. wait times for the
customers as they have to wait for the engineer response. The customers may not be
able to see the same engineer on repeat visits to the permit counter which can lead to
confusion and the appearance of inconsistency.
We propose to create a full time plan check engineer position dedicated to service the
permit counter on a full time basis. In addition to providing the counter services mentioned
above, a full time counter engineer will be able to provide screening for plan check
submittals, will allow customers to. see the same engineer on repeat visits and to receive
consistent information and code interpretation.
Approval of Reorganization of the Building Department
December 11, 2007
Page 4 of 7
We have in the past considered adding more staff to eliminate the need for outside
consultants and to provide a more effective counter service. However, space limitations
have precluded us from this consideration. Despite our reservations, we do not feel that
using outside consultants is the most effective solution and adding additional plan check
staff is necessary. We will explore alternatives to solving the space issues, including but
not limited to the consideration of off -site office space. Once we have appropriately
addressed the space limitations we can fill the two plan check engineer positions.
The new codes will require more facilitation and training by our staff to the design
community. By adding two in -house plan check engineers, we will be able to plan check
more projects in- house, providing direct interaction with the customers, and lessen the
impact of the consultants' turnover.
B. To reclassify two Plan Check Engineer positions to two Principal Plan
Check Engineer positions.
This division has two vacant engineer positions, presenting the opportunity for this
proposed change. As stated earlier, the new codes have changed drastically compared to
the present codes, and will require more facilitation and training by our staff to the design
community, more exercise of independent judgment by staff and a higher level of
knowledge and expertise. The designers will need to consult with staff to agree on which
approach is to be followed in his/her project design early in the process. As such, the
need to conduct preliminary reviews and early dialogue will increase. The Principal
Engineer positions will provide code interpretations and assist the Deputy Building Official
with the preliminary reviews.
The Plan Check and Permit Services Division will be divided into two teams, with each
principal engineer responsible for one team. The counter operation, over the counter plan
check and technical service, customer support and the trade permits approval will be
supervised by one position, who will also oversee the counter to insure technical customer
interaction is available, and that appropriate screening of plans for completeness at the
submittal stage for plan review is conducted. The other principal engineer will oversee the
plan check team including the consultants.
This proposal will create an efficient organization in which the two principal engineers will
supervise the. two teams under the direction of the Deputy Building Official. This will
eliminate a current span of control issue, with the Deputy Building Official having to
supervise 18 staff members and outside consultants, as well as resolve most code issues.
C. Reclassify an Office Assistant position to a newly created Building
Department.Specialist position.
The Building Department clerical staff is currently pooled under the Administration
Division. This proposal is to reclassify one office assistant position to a newly established
position analogous to the Public Works Specialist position. The position will be moved
from the Administration Division to the Plan Check and Permit Services Division.
Approval of Reorganization of the Building Department
December 11, 2007
Page 5 of 7
The clerical staff performs many technical tasks that exceed clerical duties due to its
technical nature, importance, and required level of responsibility. The following is a list of
these tasks:
Processes permit applications after permit final.
2. Produces monthly statistical reports on construction activities within
the City of Newport Beach and produces reports for the Census
Bureau and the Dodge National Construction Activity Statistics.
These reports were previously produced by a permit technician and
reassigned to reduce the work load at the permit counter.
Processes an average annual volume of 150 requests for building
code modifications and requests for use of alternate construction
materials and methods. It is anticipated that this number will
quadruple with the adoption of the new codes. The position will
facilitate the processing by insuring the proper justifications and
equivalencies are provided and the correct code provision is cited.
4. Run computer programs and produce the Building Department's
monthly construction activity and construction valuation reports. Also
compile the data and produce mid -year and annual reports.
These reports were previously produced by a permit technician and
reassigned to reduce the work load at the permit counter.
5. Design, create and maintain the Building Department web page:
Produce a quarterly, "Strong Motion Instrumentation and Seismic
Hazard Mapping Fee" report. This report is sent to the State of
California with a check for the collected seismic fees.
This report was previously produced by a permit technician and
reassigned to reduce the work load at the permit counter.
7. Make floodplam determinations and provide information to calling
customers whether a property is located within a special flood hazard
area using Federal Flood Insurance Rate Maps.
Proposed Changes to the Administration Division
The Building Department's clerical services are pooled in the Administrative Division. The
division's clerical staff includes one Administrative Assistant, one Department Assistant,
one Office Assistant, one part time Office Assistant and Student Aides, who perform less
complex clerical tasks, led by the Administrative Assistant. With the proposed
reorganization, the office assistant position will be moved to the Plan Check and Permit
Services Division and reclassified as previously discussed. The proposed change is to
replace the. part time office assistant position and two student aides with one full time office
assistant position. The student aides have proven to be invaluable help to the department
for the past 14 years; however the difficulty we now face in their recruitment and retention
Approval of Reorganization of the Building Department
December 11, 2007
Page 6 of 7
is unproductive to the Building and Human Resources Departments. The Building
Department has hired 21 student aides since 2004.
COST CONSIDERATIONS:
The following table represents the Building Department annual budget adjustment that is
needed to implement this reorganization, by position. The attached budget amendment
represents the adjustment needed for the reminder of this FY 200712008. The Building
Department is a fee - for - service operation.
Annual Cost of Staffinq Reorganization
CONCLUSION:
Contracting out for additional plan check and inspection services does not appear to be a
viable solution in addressing the Department's additional demands caused by increased
annexation activity and new Code demands. Staff feels this reorganization proposal will
allow the Building Department to provide its current level of customer service.
Job Tltle
Current
Proposed,
Total Cost
NEW
Senior Inspector
1 Position
$92,682
[Step 4]
NEW
Civil Engineer, Plan
2 Positions
$910,606 x 2 =
Check [Step 4]
$221,212
RECLASSIFIED
Building Inspector II
Building Inspector,
1 Position
$5,699
[Step 4]
Senior Step 4]
RECLASSIFIED
Senior Civil
Principal Engineer,
2 Positions
$7,908 x 2 =
Engineer [Step 8]
Plan Check [Step 5]
$15,816
RECLASSIFIED
Office Assistant
Building Department
1 Position
$8,922
[Step 8]
Specialist [Step 4]
RECLASSIFIED
P/T Office Assistant
Office Assistant
1 Position
$1,760
[Step 6]
[Step 3]
& Student Aide
= 2 positions
ANNUAL TOTAL: $346,091
CONCLUSION:
Contracting out for additional plan check and inspection services does not appear to be a
viable solution in addressing the Department's additional demands caused by increased
annexation activity and new Code demands. Staff feels this reorganization proposal will
allow the Building Department to provide its current level of customer service.
Approval of Reorganization of the Building Department
December 11, 2007
Page 7 of 7
Prepared and submitted by:
1 �,
,��n'ir tor
..Director
Attachments: Current Building Department organization chart
Proposed Building Department organization chart
JFJmg
Councl=07%staff rep 12 -11 -2007 staff reorganization.doc
� a�WPOa
r
o �
F
C'tGlveEH�'
Building Department
35 positions — 29 permanent full time
6 part time
Administration (949) 644 -3275
Building counter (949) 644-3288
Fax # (949) 644$250
Inspections
Chief Building
InspeCtOr
Steve Hook
X3266
CURRENT
Building Director
Jay Elbettar
x3282
Plan Check & Permit Services
Deputy Bulltlina
Official
Faisal Jurdl
x3277
Administration*
'Clerical services for all
divisions are pooled by
administration.
Principal Inspector
Prtncipal inspector
Plan Check
Permh Cpunter
Administrative
Commercial
Residential
Enalneers
Supervisor
Assistant
SpR etlalsM
John Surekle
Ray Baltera
Vousef Sarm
Susan Mccourt
Monika Goodwin
Lanny Mge
x3282
X3281
x3278
x3289
x3276
x3293
Suzanne Kuslk
WW
X3286
Senior Building
AB Haji
Permit chnicians
Department Assistant
Senior Building
Inane
x3292
$W tleM Aitle
Inspectors
Mike Dexter
Eric Skadn
Can elancey
Debi Schank
x3284
Leslie TrenSeltl
x3287
x3270
291
Open
Duarte
X3260
Vacant
29C
Office Assistant
X3279
Sanchez
Susan Yamada
Paul Sobek
287
x3280
X3268
Bulltlina inspectors 11
Vacant
23281
Techniclan
Pn -Office Assistant
Howard Hart
Subtrade Plans
Harris
274
Raymund Reyes
(Contract) x3284
miner
Dan Macey
t Aid"
Student Aitlas
Mal Fleener
x3269
achado
Dennis Chew
x3271
Phyu Aung
Residential Building
Edward Harz
Records inspector
x3273
Jax32
�n 1"
Outside Plan Check Consultants
can
26
Ghosn Associates (949) 647-0496
SPS plan Check Services (714) 904 -6822
Jim tiitennark
X3272
VCA Group (714) 978 -9780
TCB (714) 836-4447
Geotach Consultant
Bagehi Engina0ng (949) 262 -8292
October 2007
sh.cmpt PenonncIka imaanc
��wPO4,T
Building Department
r- n
V
C'ee IF00.N�P 36 positions — 33 permanent full time
3 part time
Administration (949) 644 -3275
Building counter (949) 644 -3288
Fax # (949) 644 -3250
Inspections
Chief Building
Inspector
(1)
PROPOSED
Building Director
(1)
Plan Check & Permit Services
Deputy Bulldina
Official
(1)
Proposed positions: EM
V = Vacant
"Flexibly staffed positions,
Associate to Senior Engineer
Administration*
divisions are pooled by
administration.
Principal Inspector
Principal Inspector
:i1 LA§SEFEBtl:j
::3iEC4:)C$811aEEi ::;
Administrative Records
Commercial
Residential
:: :PHhcIi39Endrdaer::
: Prfitc1i1a1:Eiidhi8ei!::
Assistant Specialist
(1)
(1)
d:`P.IanEGtiecki ; iEi;i[
iiECUStotileF$gri4aeEiE
(1) (1)
Senior 8uildina s
c
�;�Ei?IiiR C1R41EEi
Department Assistant SWdeM Abe
Sadler Building
Plan Check
Inspectors
Engineer, Senior"
(M € i ii ill;
6)
RECf esBi lEr
(1)
..........
Ft
l ci+�ssiairo€
)::Seh)dr�o1'
1918 :
Plan
Plan Cheek
.. ..:
senior Bulldina
hPo'.'�
R@TSt, -.....
Enaineer. Senior'
Permit Counte
Inspectors
(1)
Supervisor
Plan Check
Engineer. Senior"
'ss:ansoectok.! ? ?i
(1)
Permit Technicians
(1)
Residential Buldlna
Plan Check
Engineer. Senlor"
Permit Technicians
(1)
Permit (,e)hnkians
Recants Inspector
(1)
... .
(1)
Bulldina Inspectors n
(1)
Building Inspectors II
(1)
Bulldina Inspectors II
(1)
ShnreA➢eP[ PenonnehpWoftd aganiutian tl�art
Outskle Plan Check Consultants
Ghosn Associates (949) 547 -9495
SPS Plan Check Services (714) 904 -8822
VCA Group (714) 978 -9789
TCB (714) 8354447
Geotech Consultant
Bagahi Engineering (949) 252.8292
Student Aidea
(1)
Sutdrade Mans
Examiner
(1)
City of Newport Beach NO. BA- 08BA -030
BUDGET AMENDMENT
2007 -08 AMOUNT: $173,046.00
EFFECT ON BUDGETARY FUND BALANCE:
Increase Revenue Estimates Increase in Budgetary Fund Balance
�X Increase Expenditure Appropriations AND �X Decrease in Budgetary Fund Balance
Transfer Budget Appropriations No effect on Budgetary Fund Balance
SOURCE:
from existing budget appropriations
from additional estimated revenues
qX from unappropriated fund balance
EXPLANATION:
This budget amendment is requested to provide for the following:
To increase expenditure appropriations for approval of the proposed reorganization of the Building Department.
One half of the annual cost of the reorganization will be appropriated because the reorganization will occur in the
middle of the fiscal year.
ACCOUNTING ENTRY:
BUDGETARY FUND BALANCE
Fund Account Description
010 3605 General Fund - Fund Balance
REVENUE ESTIMATES (3601)
Fund /Division Account
EXPENDITURE APPROPRIATIONS (3603)
Description
Division Number
Account Number
Signed:
Signed:
Signed:
Financial Approval: Administrative Services Director
Administrative Approval: City Manager
ity Council Approval: City Clerk
Amount
Debit Credit
$173,046.00
$880.00
$49,191.00
$122,975.00
* Automatic System EntfyC.
ate
Date
Date
Description
Division
Number
2910
Building - Administration
Account
Number
7000
Salaries - Misc
Division
Number
2920
Building - Inspections
Account
Number
7000
Salaries - Misc
.Division
Number
2930
Building - Plan Check / Permits
Account
Number
7000
Salaries - Misc
Division Number
Account Number
Signed:
Signed:
Signed:
Financial Approval: Administrative Services Director
Administrative Approval: City Manager
ity Council Approval: City Clerk
Amount
Debit Credit
$173,046.00
$880.00
$49,191.00
$122,975.00
* Automatic System EntfyC.
ate
Date
Date