The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About18 - Public Hearing Notice & CorrespondenceNOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Our Lady Queen of Angels Church Expansion (PA2005 -092) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of the City of Newport Beach will hold a public hearing on an appeal of the Planning Commission's approval of a Use Permit for the expansion of Our Lady Queen of Angels Church. The project site is located at 2046 and 2100 Mar Vista Drive and is zoned Government, Educational and Institutional Facilities (GEIF). Our Lady Queen of Angels Church requests to expand their existing church and school facilities by relocating its church to the adjacent property located at 2100 Mar Vista Drive (presently used by St. Mark Presbyterian Church) and expanding its school within the existing boundaries at 2046 Mar Vista Drive. The expansion includes the construction of a 1,170 -seat sanctuary, additional classrooms, and a 9,450 square foot gymnasium. When combined, the new Our Lady Queen of Angels Church campus will be approximately 12.17 acres in size. The project, as proposed, requires approval of a Use Permit to allow the expansion of the existing church and school facility; to allow the church building to exceed the permitted building height of 35 feet (90 feet proposed for the steeple); to allow the transfer of development intensity from the new church site (2100 Mar Vista Dr.) to the school site (2046 Mar Vista Dr.) so as the square footage for the two properties when combined results in an overall FAR (floor area ratio) of 0.17 consistent with the General Plan; and to allow a total of ten portable classrooms to be located on the school site during the construction period. A traffic study is also required pursuant to the Traffic Phasing Ordinance. NOTICE IS HEREBY FURTHER GIVEN that a Mitigated Negative Declaration was prepared by the City of Newport Beach in connection with the application noted above. The Mitigated Negative Declaration states that, the subject development will not result in a significant effect on the environment. It is the present intention of the City to accept the Mitigated Negative Declaration and supporting documents. This is not to be construed as either approval or denial by the City of the subject application. The City encourages members of the general public to review and comment on this documentation. Copies of the Negative Declaration and supporting documents are available for public review and inspection at the Planning Department, City of Newport Beach, 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California, 92658 -8915, (949) 6443200. NOTICE IS HEREBY FURTHER GIVEN that said public hearing will be held on November 14. 2006, at the hour of 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Newport Beach City Hall, 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California, at which time and place any and all persons interested may appear and be heard thereon. If you challenge this project in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to, the public hearing. For information call (949) 644 -3200. ��U . LaVonne M. Harkless, City Clerk City of Newport Beach NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Our Lady Queen of Angels Church Expansion (PA2005-092) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that Ore City Council of the City of Newport Beach will hold a public hearing on an appeal of the Planning Commission's approval of a Use Permit for the expansion of Our Lady Queen of Angels Church. The project site is located at 2046 and 2100 Mar Vista Delve and is zoned Government Educational and Institutional Facilities (CEIF). Our Lady Queen of Angels Church requests to expand their existing church and school facilities by relocating its church to the adjacent property located at 2100 Mar Vista Drive (presently used by St. Mark Presbyterian Church) and expanding its school within the existing boundaries at 2046 Mar Vista Drive. The expansion includes the oonstrvdion of a 1,170 -seat sanctuary, additional classrooms, and a 9,450 square foot gymnasium. When combined, the new Our Lady Queen of Angels Church campus will be approximately 12.17 acres in size. The project, as proposed, requires approval of a Use Permit to allow the expansion of the existing church and school facility; to allow the church building to exceed the permitted building height of 35 feet (90 feet proposed for the steeple); to allow the transfer of development intensity from the new church site (2100 Mar Vista Dr.) to the school site (2046 Mar Vista Dr.) so as the square footage for the two properties when combined results in an overall FAR (floor area ratio) of 0.17 consistent with the General Plan; and to allow a total of ten portable classrooms to be located on the school she during the construction period. A traffic study is also required pursuant to the Traffic Phasing Ordinance. NOTICE IS HEREBY FURTHER GIVEN that a Mitigated Negative Declaration was prepared by the City of Newport Beach in connection with the application noted above. The Mitigated Negative Declaration states that, the subject development will not result In a significant effect on the environment. It is the present intention of the City to accept the Mitigated Negative Declaration and supporting documents. This is not to be construed as either approval or denial by the City of the subject application. The City encourages members of the general public to review and comment on this documentation. Copies of the Negative Declaration and supporting documents are available for public review and Inspection at the Planning Department. City of Newport Beach, 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, Califomia, 92656 -8915, (949) 644 -3200. NOTICE 13 HEREBY FURTHER GIVEN that said public hearing will be held on November 14. 2006 at the hour of :07 0 P.m. in the Council Chambers of the Newport Beach City Hall, 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California, at which time and place any and all persons interested may appear and be heard thereon. If you challenge this project in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice or in written correspondence delivered to the City at or prior to, the public hearing. For Information call (949) 644 -3200. 62ca? M � LaVonne M. Harkless, City Clerk City of Newport Beach NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Our Lady Queen of Angels Church Expansion (PA 00 -092) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of the City of Newport Beach well hold a public hearing on an appeal of the Planning Commission's approval of a Use Permit for the expansion of Our Lady Queen of Angels Church. The project site is located at 2046 and 2100 Mar Vista Drive and Is zoned Government Educational and Institutional Facilities (GEIF). Our Lady Queen of Angels Church requests to expand their existing church and school facilities by relocating its church to the adjacent property located at 2100 Mar Vista Drive (presently used by SL Mark Presbyterian Church) and expanding is school within the existing boundaries at 2046 Mar Vista Drive. The expansion includes the construction of a 1,170 -seat sanctuary, additional classrooms, and a 9,450 square foot gymnasium. When combined, the new Our Lady Queen of Angels Church campus will be approximately 12.17 acres in size. The project, as proposed, requires approval of a Use Permit to allow the expansion of the existing church and school facility; to allow the church building to exceed the permitted building height of 35 feet (90 feet proposed for the steeple); to allow the transfer of development intensity from the new church site (2100 Mar Vista Dr.) to the school site (2046 Mar Vista Dr.) so as the square footage for the two properties when combined results in an overall FAR (floor area ratio) of 0.17 consistent with the General Plan; and to allow a total of ten portable classrooms to be located on the school site during the construction period. A traffic study is also required pursuant to the Traffic Phasing Ordinance. NOTICE IS HEREBY FURTHER GIVEN that a Mitigated Negative Declaration was prepared by the City of Newport Beach In connection with the application noted above. The Mitigated Negative Declaration states that, the subject development will not result in a significant effect on the environment. It is the present intention of the City to accept the Mitigated Negative Declaration and supporting documents. This is not to be construed as either approval or denial by the City of the subject application. The City encourages members of the general public to review and comment on this documentation. Copies of the Negative Declaration and supporting documents are available for public review and inspection at the Planning Department. qty of Newport Beach, 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, Califcmia, 9265&6915, (949) 644 -3200. NOTICE IS HEREBY FURTHER GIVEN that said public hearing will be held on November 14. 2006, at the hour of 7: 0 P.M. In the Council Chambers of the Newport Beach City Hall, 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California, at which time and place any and all persons Interested may appear and be heard thereon. If you challenge this project in court, you may be limited to raising only Corse issues you or someone else rased at the public hearing described in this notice or in written correspondence delivered to the City at, or prior to, the public hearing. For information call (949) 6443200. Qvy Udr.c 0. da&-y LaVonne M. Harkless. City Clerk City of Newport Beach NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING Our Lady Queen of Angels Church Expansion (PA2005.092) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of the City of Newport Beach will told a public hearing on an appeal of the Planning Commission's approval of a Use Permit for the expansion of Our Lady Queen of Angels Church. The project site is located at 2046 and 2100 Mar Vista Drive and is zoned GovemmeM, Educational and Institutional Fatties (GEIF). Our Lady Queen of Angels Church requests to expand their existing church and school facilities by relocating its church to the adjacent property located at 2100 Mar Vista Drive (presently used by St. Mark Presbyterian Church) and expanding its school within the existing boundaries at 2046 Mar Vista Drive. The expansion includes the construction of a 1,170�sea1 sanctuary. additional classrooms, and a 9,450 square fool gymnasium. When combined, the new Our Lady Queen of Angels Church campus will be approximately 12.17 acres In size. The project, as proposed, requires approval of a Use Permit to allow the expansion of the existing church and school facility, to allow the church bulkfrng to exceed the permitted building height of 35 feet (90 feet proposed for the steeple); to allow the transfer of development Intensity from the new church site (2100 Mar Vista Dr.) to the school site (2046 Mar Vista Dr.) so as the square footage for the two properties wdhen combined results in an overall FAR (floor area ratio) of 0.17 consistent with the General Plan; and to allow a total of ten portable classrooms to be located on the school site during the construction period. A traffic study is also required pursuant to the Traffic Phasing Ordinance. NOTICE IS HEREBY FURTHER GIVEN that a Mitigated Negative Declaration was prepared by the City of Newport Beach in connection with the application noted above. The Mitigated Negative Declaration states that the subject development will not result In a significant effect on the environment It Is the present intention of the City to accept the Mitigated Negative Declaration and supporting documents. This is not to be construed as either approval or denial by the City of the subject application. The City encourages members of the general public to review and comment on this documentation. Copies of the Negative Declaration and supporting documents are available for public review and inspection at the Planning Deparbnent City of Newport Beach, 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach. California, 92658 -8915, (949) 644 -3200. NOTICE IS HEREBY FURTHER GIVEN that said public hearing will be held on November 14. 2008, at the hour of 7.00 P.M. In the Council Chambers of the Newport Beach City Hall, 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California, at which time and place any and all persons interested may appear and be heard thereon. If you challenge this project in court you may be limited to raising only tense issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice or in mitten correspondence delivered to the (Sty at or prior to, the public hearing. For information call (949) 6443200. LaVonne M. Harldess, City Clerk City of Newport Beach Office of the City Clerk CITY HALL 3300 Newport Blvd. Newport Beach, CA 92663 -3884 IMPORTANT PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE yam ud a Free Printin 9 Use 960'". 10 �w wwb6". om E�?= 2046 and _ x..._ ....1 DATE OF ETIN6:— ..........._ 440 012 07 440 012 08 440 012 09 Fred Weisman Eileen Cirillo I Maryam Samini 2207 Aralia St 2201 Aralia St 2137 Aralia St Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 440 01210 440 01211 440 012 12 Patrick & Lisa Senske George & Mary Mix Jr. Jake Easton III 2131 Aralia St 2127 Araba St 2121 Aralia St : Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 1 Newport Beach CA 92660 440 01213 440 01214 440 012 15 McInnis IRVINE COMPANY Lu Ella May Bennett 2115 Aralia St i 2107 Aralia St 2101 Aralia St Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 I 440 012 16 440 01217 i 440 012 18 Thomas & Kristin Casey Eric Little Leonard Burke 2100 Aralia St 2108 Aralia St 2114 Aralia St Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 440 01219 440 012 20 440 092 04 Garrett Robert & Mary Kinney SCHOOL NEWPORT HARBOR j 2120 Aralia St 2126 Aralia St PO Box 1368 Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92659 { 440 092 79 440101 01 i 440 101 02 CITY OF NE T BEACH Residential Js Caro" Melstrom PO Box 4525 Macarthur Blvd #A 9562 Drumbeat Dr New Beach CA 92658 Newport Beach CA 92660 Huntington Beach CA 92646 440' 10103 44010104 44010105 GRACELAND APARTMENTS ASHBY ENTERPRISES George Woods Jr. 9562 Drumbeat Dr PO Box 17809 115 Apolena Ave Huntington Beach CA 92646 Irvine CA 92623 Newport Beach CA 92662 i 440101.06 440101 10 440102 01 A & B Miller BERGEN EASTBLUFF PROP LLC Jkc 1935 Windward Ln 23045 Stoneridge 17 Teramo Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 Mission Vlejo CA 92692 Newport Coast CA 92657 440 102 02 440102 03 440102 04 Larry Petersen DOMINGO VILLAS INC Robert Chui 20951 Brookhurst St 757 Domingo Dr 1000 Avondale Rd Huntington Beach CA 92646 Newport Beach CA 92660 San Marino CA 91108 440102 05 440102 09 44010210 T James Durkin RMC OF TRACY LLC IRVINE CO OF VA PO Box 4308 2804 Lafayette Rd ! PO Box 4708 Fullerton CA 92834 Newport Beach CA 92663 3 Irvine CA 92616 Aa3A119oA1NO66ips t 009ts 3WqdWKq§6& ®091b9�R�� .4n wadWi1166NMMYwnn aP1dej e6eyPs V le eBeARK4.4wo"Muq jam rree rrr mg �e rmting+� vvvvw.r 1 1J4 .Av .._ _TEMPL E 516pTP . . _ . �� 44010211 44010212 Beach Manhattan 1001 Dove St #225 Project 22 Newport Beach CA 92660 N rt Beach CA i ... .......... .. ... .. ... 440121 05 44012506 Kevin 8 Cherie Sharp Lawrence Brannon 601 Vista Bonita 677 Vista Bonita Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 440125 08 44012509 Sandra Kessler Wayne Lim 681 Vista Bonita 683 Vista Bonita Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 44012511 44012512 HESS PARTNERSHIP Donald Mersch 2348 Roscomare Rd 689 Vista Bonita Los Angeles CA 90077 Newport Beach CA 92660 440126 09 44012610 Jeremy Lang Mark & Anat Lyon 1956 San Bruno 3 Sharon Ln Newport Beach CA 92660 Coto De Caza CA 92679 44012612 442 251 01 Mary Jane Rumbley 1950 San Bruno Project 9 3 Newport Beach CA 92660 Ne Beach CA 933 220 01 - 933 220 02 Hossein Tabrizi Penelope Rae Wilton 835 Amigos Way #1 835 Amigos Way #2 Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 933 220 04 933 220 05 Patricia Krone Kevin Sullivan 835 Amigos Way #4 835 Amigos Way 95 Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 933 220 07 933 220 08 Manuel Mendoza Linda Cs4i PO Box 25384 835 Amigos Way 98 Anaheim CA 92825 Newport Beach CA 92660 933 22010 933 22011 Michael Coppin Lucinda Hardman 835 Amigos Way #10 835 Amigos Way #11 Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 'ff r ifCr`m 960TI 440121 04 BLUFFS HOMEOWNERS PO Box 8167 Newport Beach CA 92658 440125 07 Robert Walsh 679 Vista Bonita Newport Beach CA 92660 l.l'. I. 44012510 Nicholas Hartog 685 Vista Bonita Newport Beach CA 92660 44012513 Diane Geffen 691 Vista Bonita Newport Beach CA 92660 44012611 Connie Kelly 1952 San Bruno Newport Beach CA 92660 442 351 OS Projea 23 N rt Beach CA 933 22003 Eric Slice . j 220 Nate Newport Beach CA 92660 933 22006 Robert Wentz 3820 Cadillac Ave #B Costa Mesa CA 92626 933 220 09 Tracy Nguyen 835 Amigos Way #7 Newport Beach CA 92660 933 22012 George Kanelas 835 Amigos Way #12 Newport Beach CA 92660 ��,,�Q u IRtI aPtdereberj�5@'i I dD jam rive rnnun "ntIn -Use se ve.._.— .LATE 5960TH ' 933 22013 Gregory Steinmann ' 835 Amigos Way #13 tNewport Beach CA 92660 i y 933 22016 Morton 29211 Alfied St Laguna Niguel CA 92677 934 830 01 Beverly Cleveland 1 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 933 22014 Lawrence Vescera 835 Amigos Way #14 Newport Beach CA 92660 . 933 22017 !' Gordon Newell 3674 Barham Blvd #1.310 Los Angeles CA 90068 934 830 02 Christopher & Deborah Santoro 2 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 934 83004 934 830 05 n Melanie Groper " Warren Heeg Jr. 1K 4 Sea Island Dr 5 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660, Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 07 93483008 Gaughan Ronald Grant 17291 Irvine Blvd #41 8 Sea Island Dr Tustin CA 92780 Newport Beach CA 92660 934 83010 934 83011 Sandra Stanger Peter 7arquinio 10 Sea Island Dr 11 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 934 83013 934 83014 Wilber Shaffer Michael Bret Leeper 226 Via San Remo 14 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92663 Newport Beach CA 92660 934 83016 John Varga 16 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 934 83019 Nancy Gill 19 Sea island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 934 83022 Isabel Fontao 22 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 934 83017 James & Janice Gandy 17 Sea island Dr #17 Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 20 Megan Barth 20 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 23 Julie Perry 23 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 IRFAdANI^" AVERY® 5160® AVERYO ss6on 933 22015 William Doremus 835 Amigos Way #15 Newport Beach CA 92660 933 220 18 �� pidei a6eyops®ja 96eun6gW*44li +I Martha Haley 3721 Inlet Isle Dr Corona Del Mar CA 92625 ' 934 830 03 p Noleen Kutash ytC. 3 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 - 934 830 06 Marcia Long Yosemite National Park Ca 95389 934 830 09 Alan Lamble 9 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 934 83012 jJohn & Carla Blom 12 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 15 William Cool 719 Poinsettia Ave Corona Del Mar CA 92625 934 83018 Marilu Brown PO Box 2451 Newport Beach CA 92659 934 830 21 n Craig Hendrickson (. 6436 Lake Washington Blvd NE Kirkland WA 98033 934 830 24 Matthew Stewart 15 Villeneuve Newport Coast CA 92657 �� pidei a6eyops®ja 96eun6gW*44li +I jam rree rnming Use A��J" §q%oGrinting eAvemy TEPMRAIPLATIES96orm 934 830 25 Ray & Shama Biggerstaft III 25 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 28 Joseph Elias 28 Sea Island Dr Newport Reach CA 92660 934 830 31 John Affeldt 31 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 34 LIONHEAD CORP 12735 San Vicente Blvd i Los Angeles CA 90049 934 830 37 James Charalambous 37 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 93483040 Robert Bevaoqua 40 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 43 Kathy Shen-Shane 43 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 46 Darrell & Lynn Pash 1207 Goldenrod Ave Corona Del Mar CA 92625 934 830 49 Vito Nicasslo 49 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 52 -George Keeling 52 Sea Island Or Newport Beach CA 92660 www.avery.com 60 %WAVE@- A =59(60TI 1_800= G0.AVEP! i 934 830 26 934 830 27 Rowan Melbon Shane Shafer 26 Sea Island Dr tC 24001 Oak Vale Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 Valencia CA 91355 9348309 934 830 30 Ruth Ble2 ignani NATHAN LA MOURE CORP 29 Sea Island Dr 41 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 32 934 830 33 John & Linda Schueler MGL PROPERTIES LLC 32 Sea Island Dr 1200 Quail St #140 Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 93483035 934 830 36 , Nancy Gardner Mary Cartell I� 35 Sea Island Dr ju sea island Or 1 Newport Beach CA 92660 1 1 Newport Beach CA 92660 93483038 934 830 39 Leslie Kramer Alexander Callglud 38 Sea Island Dr 39 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 411 934 WU 42 D Lamoure Nathan D Sanders Gorelick PO Box 50 42 Sea Island Dr Lake Arrowhead CA 92352 Newport Beach CA 92660 93483044 934 830 45 Eileen Ney William McCook 4929 Wilshire Blvd 45 Sea Island Dr Los Angeles CA 90010 Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 47 934 830 48 Aida Dagort Paul Miller 910 Island Dr#113 2 Fawn Run Rancho Mirage CA 92270 Pittsford NY 14534 93483060 934 830 51 Debra Chandler Eden Ryl 27271 Las Ramblas 51 Sea Island Dr Mission Velo CA 92691 Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 53 93483054 Michelle Loveall Gina Gold 121 S Palm Dr #404 54 Sea Island Dr Beverly Hills CA 90212 Newport Beach CA 92660 uW*VLW*AVAm ep!dej a5e4-39s q is aftiriftIIIIINdNWdMI 'jam; not PLItTE 596 ing 0.M 934 830 55 Stephanie Huerta 55 Sea Island Or Newport Beads CA 92660 is 934 830 58 Stanley Ordway 58 Sea Island Or Newport Beads CA 92660 i 934 830 61 Juliette Hamilton 1 61 Sea Island Or Newport Beach CA 92660 I 934 83064 Eric Bezkomwayny 2505 W Pch #202 I Newport Beady CA 92663 934 830 67 Eric Bergman 67 Sea Island Or Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 70 Kristin Erin Olson 70 Sea Island Dr j Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 73 Jefrrey Gill 73 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 76 Todd Godfrey I 76 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 I' 934 830 79 Lorene Gonia 79 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 82 Richard Mead 82 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 009`yNO�Y' =.MPNM www.averywm VERY corn AVERY® 5960* 1$1w,, .. 934 83056 934 830 57 Ronald Martel Kenneth Rogers 56 Sea Island Dr R ! 944 La Muada St Newport Beach CA 92660 Laguna Beach CA 92651 .._ ...... .......1 934 830 59 934 830 60 Mark James Platte Larry Diskin 1806 Kumakani PI BO Sea Island Dr Honolulu HI 96821 Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 62 i 934 830 63 Jeffrey Goodman B M Moskowitz 62 Sea Island Dr 18325 Chariton Ln Newport Beach CA 92660 i Northridge CA 91326 1 I. 934 83065 i 934 830 66 John Murphy I James Paulus 65 Sea Island Dr 66 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 f , 934 830 68 934 83069 Joanne Jacobs Timothy Wilson 68 Sea Island Dr #68 69 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 71 93483072 Raymond Acosta Roberta Kem 82 El Morro Vlg 72 Sea Island Dr Laguna Beach CA 92651 Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 74 934 830 75 Ross & Sandra Halstead Willy DeBoer 74 Sea Island Dr 75 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 . __......._..._............ Newport Beach CA 92660 934 83077 934 830 78 Andrea Young George Kotzeff 77 Sea Island Dr 78 Sea Island Dr Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 934 830 80 934 830 81 Carolyn Bollman Wilber Shaffer . 80 Sea Island Dr 226 Via San Remo Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92663 934 830 83 939 230 01 Fletcher Howard Herzog 83 Sea Island Dr 1 Northampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 ;a BeLy�j U�ro S apldej aBeysg9 @ a- jam A rintfng 5960TM .939 230 02 Alfred Schnell 3 Northampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 05 William 8 J M Purves 9 Northampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 08 W C Graves 1921 Port Bristol Cir Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 11 Robert 8 Marie Marble 23 Northampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 939 23014 Larry 8 Laura Ainsworth 29 Northampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 17 Harrell Kloke 37 Northampton Ct #117 Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 20 Jones 41'Northampton Ct gewport Beach CA 92660 939 230 23 Wolistein 47 Northampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 26 View Land & Busn Sea 3419 Via Lido #405 Newport Beach CA 92663 939 230 29 James Hoote 320 23rd St S #1528 Arrington VA 22202 =0\3 wviwaverycom , AVERVOSI &D -. �r 1- 8pp�frQyt�1<{� com ........_.1=800- GO -AVF -. ® AVERY® 596or 939 230 03 939 23004 Kareem Habeeb Patricia Reilly 5 Northampton Ct 7 Northampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 _.. ; New Beach CA Q2660 939 230 06 939 230 071 Ronald Chez ,p ! Richard Wendt Il. 11 Northampton CI 15 Northampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 09 939 23010 Gail Scherer Roger Miller 4 1528 Galloway or 1121 Granville Dr Barrington IL 60010 Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 12 939 239 13 Lucy Al Shu Tzen Chou BUDOO ASSOCIATES LLC 25 Northampton Ct 6005 Lake Geneva Or Newport Beach CA 92660 Reno NV 89511 939 23015 939 230 16 Sidney Wasserman Henrietta Gospns 31 Northampton Ct 33 Northampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 i Newport Beach CA 92660 939 23018 939 23019 MisB Kessler Myron Bander 35 Northampton Ct #118 39 Northampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 21 939 230 22 Laszlo Kaveggia Thoma%Volden 43 Northampton Ct 45 Northampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 i Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 24 939 230 25 James McGrew Sutherland 49 Northampton Ct 53 Northampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 i, 939 230 27 939 230 28 Alban Ann Stem W J & A M Wilson 49 Southampton Ct :.47 Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 30 939 230 31 Harlan Erickson ! Kimberley Parker 3300 Irvine Ave #270 41 Southampton Ct #131 Newport Beach CA 92660 Newport Beach CA 92660 esn rUTA� !HilPIMOrdrP � aptdej aBerues a ie a6e�i��nnNH� •• jam V, nn, Use r Ave.. LATE.5960— 939 230 32 Richard Ayres 39 Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 35 Thomas Thorkelson 33 Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 93923038 Clifford Meyer L 27 Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 41 Robert Ctler 19 Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 93923044 Donna Hall 15 Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 47 Francisco Santos 7 Southampton Ct #147 Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 50 Edward D10do I Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 ZI www.avery.com 1-800-GO-AVE'.. 93923033 Paul Liener 35 Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 36 Paul Johnson 31 Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 93923039 Mad Palash 25 Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 A 939 230 42 Mark Anderson 21 Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 93923045 Linda Kaye Martin 11 Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 48 Leigh Umnarco 5 Southampton Ct Newport ach CA 92660 Our Lady Queen of Angeles Church i Attn: Father Kerry Beaulieu 12046 Mar Vista Drive i Newport Beach, CA 92660 Roman Catholic Diocese of Orange Roman Catholic D* e of Orange Attn: Joe Novoa Attn: Joe N a 2811 East Villa Real Drive ..;2811 illa Real Drive Orange, CA 92863 ge, CA 92863 Our Lady Queen of es Church Barnard Ventures, Lj.0 Attn: Father A Scott B, PrrfBeaufieu tin. 2046 Bi Itreet .4�ista Drive 5100 Ne4p-ort Beach, CA 92660 NOrt beach, CA 92660 ,Roman Catholic Di e of Orange St Mark Pre'sbyte urch Attn:: Joe Nov Attn: John er Ull Illa Real Drive t 10 ista Drive Or ,CA 92863 rt Beach, C CA 92660 AMV-09-WIl, ON @AUW rttlllll AVER0 $-1600 AVERY0 50601; 93923034 Randolph & Paula Goodman W Howell Rd BqIhosda4dD.20817 - 939 230 37 Larry Tucker 29 Southampton Ct Newport Bdach CA.92660 939 230 40 Michael Mudd 23 Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 . 939 230 43 Dorothy Made Smith 17 Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 46 j George Mural 9 Southampton Ct Newport Beach CA 92660 939 230 49 Linda Favreau 3 Southampton Ct #149 i Newport Belch CA 92660 Barnard Ventures, LLC !Attn: Scott Barnard 5100 Birch Street Newport beach, CA 92660 :St. Mark Presbyterian Church 'Attn: John Benner 2100 Mar Vista Drive Newport Beach, CA 92660 Barnard Ventures, LLC Attn: ScotLBAntarcr Wr�uch Street Newport beach, CA 92660 8t. Mark erlan Church Mar Vi:Zve ewport Beach, CA 92660 6V%§~V asn a jam raw rnrrmg -Use AvW TEMPLATE 51600 Mary Kay and Steve Dugan 851 Domingo Unit 1 Newport Beach, CA 92660 i LS ®A AV AMA"9.00g-L gORS VIdW31�+owesn wm tiane Mnnen Buquud Owl Ulef CITY OF NEWf Rff" 2WSEP20 M045 Application No. Name of Appellant OFFICE OF f THE CITY CLERK � or person filing: UNT`k 6f Address: Date of Planning Commission decision: �S-?PE - 20 Regarding application of-. 6b &f,",f o c S(C Ikucclti iforV (Description of application filed with Planning Commission) (FA-2, x -CszZ �� {. �caZGu� 1 0,-\, ax, -,C% Ace/L� Reasons for Appeal: «U�s yC( Appellant Date '5) �,,L 301 a Ll FOR OFFICE USE ONLY p Date Appeal filed and Administrative Fee received: / f o1.C7 LO (a 20 Hearing Date. An appeal shall be scheduled for a hearing before the City Council within thirty (30) days of the filing of the appeal unless both applicant and appellant or reviewing body consent to a later date (NBMC Sec. 20.95.060) cc: Appellant Planning (fumish one set of mailing labels for mailing) File APPEALS: Municipal Code Sec. 20.95.050(B) Appeal Fee: $340 pursuant to Resolution No. 2006 -4 adopted on 1- 10-06. (Deposit funds with Cashier in Account #2700 -5000) 2 w: l( cey�cas2 a L7 W VIAL v` Wt l,lLU S �„�. 'C fM RAC-u,, ��e 1� �Mq� U �� F� �vn uv� [�, (fit t`�oS �► � qtr 0�, cv-1.341L �Cw cjam 1�Cl �7 p ��4 So agat (T G�� ^ y �`^� (AU Mj fCU,, CYzKc F CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH 'PLANNING DEPARTMENT P.O.BOX 1768, NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92658 1 1 (949) 644-3200 FEE RECEIPT Date: Check No.: %, Received by. a4 Received from Job Address Zoning Plan Check ....................... ........................................ 2700-5003 $ Overtime Plan Check ....................................................... ..... 2700-5003 Park Dedication Fee ................................ Planning Activity Deposit ........................................................ 029--$ $ Ji6b- Planning Activity Fees wV) 5000 ................................................... I ......... . .............................. Records Management Fee (# of sheets—) .................1........... — $ Sale of Maps & Publications (Planning) ........... ......................2700 -5812 $ -Sale of GIS maps ................................................................... 0630-5810 Other(Specify) ............................................. .......... .............. — $ Fee Receipt No. F:IUSERSIPLNtShare(ATMPLTSIFEERCPT.doe P TOTAL SEP?%020 r ..Sep 21 06 12:14p Doremus The Doremus Family Trust Post Office Box 69149 West Hollywood, California, 90069.0149 Telephone 323 650-4501 Facsimile 3223 650 -1065 Email pddoremus@gmail.com IF AX TRANSMITTAL 1=0RM message: 323 650 -1085 p.1 }DECEIVED 7M6 SEP 21 PM 2: 33 GFR E OF THE CITY CLERK CITY OF NIINIPORT BEACH To: W. Cathy Malkemus From: The Doremus Family Trust Date Sent: September 21, 2006 CC: Y6a Granada homeowners Association Phone: 949 6443309 Fax 949 644 -3039 Number of Pales Two ,(2) u A inease forward the covitewts of this faeam&il.eto Ms. MaLleew+.irs awd or the City CLeriz's o f fi.ceto be docu.vu.ewted as the trace awd accurate wordLwe as tke - peasovis for Appeals filed Uesterda8 bd the villa c.,ra"ola Hvwceowmrs AssocLatiow Lw refere"e to tine proposed expav+siow of our f..adte auueew of AweeLs Church awd SchooL (I>A- 2005 -092) Lvwwr.ed't.ateL0 upow real -pt. IwcL"Eve of this cover paee there are Two (2) pages. Thawle, Oou.. Paul D. Dorevx.us, Trustee The norewn.us f=avu,Uu Trust The information contained herein is confidential and intended only for the person(s) to whom it is addressed. If you receive this information f correspondence and you are not the person for whom it was intended, or the legal agent of the person for whom it was intended andfor for the purpose it was Intended, disclosure of this information may be a violation of the law and you are instructed to return this Correspondence to the undersigned. Know that retention of any had copies is punishable by law. No claim of ownership is made to third party materials cited herein. You are hereby on notice, that divulging, forwarding or oticerwise sharing any portion of this communication with a third party not specifically named in the "Addressed To" section may subject the addressee(s) andfor its agents, to charges of libel, slander, and breach of confidentiality. This communication is copyright and may not be reproduced, sold or circulated without the authors prior written consent Sao 21 06 12:14p Doremus 323 650 -1085 p.2 APPLICATION TO APPEAL DECISION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION Original Applicant: Our Lady Queen of Angels Church (PA- 2005-092) Appeal Applicant's Information Filed: September 20, 2006 Villa Granada Homeowners Association Reasons for Appeal: Appellant Applicant requests a minimum of One Hundred and Twenty (120) days to be heard by the City Council regarding this matter, as to consider conducting new Studies (Traffic & otherwise) as well as to fully review all documentation pertaining to the proposed project and permits granted (PA- 2005 -092). Appellant also requests that OLQA immediately cease and desist any and all attempts to install any `New' classrooms which are either of a temporary and or permanent nature. Appellant firmly believes that the new findings will validate our serious concern(s) as to any and all increase of students to the Our Lady Queen of Angels Church / School as well as the proposed enlarged seating capacity of One Thousand, One Hundred and Seventy (1170) parishioners in a Church which conducts Six (6) services per weekend - with the very real potential of approximately Seven Thousand (7000) attendees per weekend. Our Lady Queen of Angel's proposal equates to an increase of Two Thousand (2000) people per weekend, not to mention the hundreds of additional vehicles that will bring said attendees into the direct vicinity of the Church and onto our already overcrowded residential streets. Appeal Applicant intends to consider the possibility of conducting a new `Traffic Study', one which will focus on the germane intersections of Eastbluff / Mar Vista / Domingo and Amigos Street(s) - the streets that actually surround the OLQA Church and OLQA School - instead of relying on the currant study (funded by OLQA) which wrongly focused on the intersection of Jamboree and Eastbluff ONLY. Appellant firmly believes that the new, forthcoming information will shed new light on the very complicated equation of the ongoing and dangerous traffic jams and congestion as well as validate our concerns as to the currently proposed and approved expansion of both the size, height and seating capacity of the new church, and the proposed and approved increased capacity of One Hundred and Eighty (180) students of the Church's school and their direct and numerous adverse effects they would have on the adjacent neighboring communities. "RE QED AFTER AGENDA Page 1 of 5 i PRNTED; ' I Brown, Leilani From: Harkless, LaVonne Sent: Monday, November 13, 2006 1:54 PM To: Brown, Leilani Subject: FW: URGENT November 14, City Council Hearing Pleae Forward to City Council Members Please Print this for Tuesday's meeting. Thanks. From: Ung, Rosalinh Sent: Monday, November 13, 2006 1:28 PM To: Harkless, LaVonne Subject: FW: URGENT November 14, City Council Hearing Pleae Forward to City Council Members Please forward. Thanks. From: PD Doremus [mallto:pddoremus @gmail.rom] Sent: Monday, November 13, 2006 12:54 PM To: Ung, Rosalinh; KingandKrone @aol.com; rebeccagouin @yahoo.com Subject: URGENT November 14, City Council Hearing Pleae Forward to City Council Members November 13, 2006 Honorable City Council Members City of Newport Beach 3300 Newport Boulevard Newport Beach, CA 92658 -8915 RE: Application to appeal decision of the Planning Commission Our Lady Queen of Angels proposed expansion (PA02005 -092) Dear Council Members: I am the applicant in the above entitled application, filed on September 20, 2006, to appeal the decision of the Planning Commission. The purpose of this letter is to advise the Council Members of the following: 1. I am currently out of the country on a previously arranged trip and cannot attend the hearing presently scheduled for Tuesday, November 14, 2006. 2. In my application to appeal this matter I made it specifically clear that I would be unavailable the entire month of November and requested that the hearing be set for a minimum of 120 days from the filing of my application for the reasons contained within and those included in my application. 3. For reasons unknown to me the hearing has been scheduled for a time when I, the applicant, cannot attend, which I believe to be prejudicial to me. As the petitioning party I believe I have the right to attend and participate in any hearing regarding my application and feel that my rights have been ignored. 11/13/2006 Page 2 of 5 4. For the record I have the %t to have a hearing scheduled with9thirty (30) days as stated on the application filing form. And I believe I made my position quite clear in filing the application that in the event the hearing would be scheduled during the month of November that I would exercise my right to insist on a hearing within thirty (30) days. 5. Despite my attempts to advise Our Lady Queen of Angles of said petition I have yet to hear from them or any of their representatives and therefore, in the interest of fairness ask that the hearing, scheduled for November 15, 2006, be rescheduled to insure the participation of all interested parties. Further, insofar as Our Lady Queen of Angels has been mulling this proposal around since 2000 I don't see how a one or two month continuance would cause them any unnecessary inconvenience. However, should the Council continue with the hearing, despite my objections, I will take this opportunity to briefly outline my objections regarding the proposed expansion plans of Our Lady Queen of Angels. There are several aggravating facts that I believe the Planning Commission failed to seriously consider in reviewing the proposed expansion plans for Our Lady Queen of Angels. They are as follows: First and foremost, while Our Lady Queen of Angel's purports that the new sanctuary seating capacity will be marginally smaller in size than the two (2) combined churches (St. Mark's and Our Lady Queen of Angels) the fact remains that St. Mark's only had one (1) service a week, wherein Our Lady Queen of Angels has a total of six (6) services a week. Therefore, the five (5) additional services that Our Lady Queen of Angels conducts every weekend combined with the additional of the soon to be former St. Mark's increases the proposed capacity by an estimated seating capacity of One Thousand, One Hundred and Seventy (1170) parishioners in a Church which conducts Six (6) services per weekend — with the potential of approximately Seven Thousand (7000) attendees per weekend. Our Lady Queen of Angel's proposal equates to an increase of Two Thousand (2000) people per weekend, not to mention the hundreds of additional vehicles that will bring said attendees into the direct vicinity of the Church and onto our already overcrowded residential streets. And even by the conservative traffic study presented by Our Lady Queen of Angel's statistics, which I disagree with, will bring an additional seven hundred (700) plus cars per weekend into the neighborhood, a number that I argue will be more in the vicinity of seven hundred and fifty (750) cars, which is unacceptable. And while statements from the church itself suggest that there would not be any ' significant impact on the traffic' all evidence suggests otherwise. The numbers simply don't add up. We are not talking math, this is simple arithmetic. The addition of another five to seven hundred plus cars a weekend is a substantial impact on those who live in the neighborhood. Furthermore, our Lady Queen of Angles suggestions that posting " parking dot fell" signs and or "parking attendants" is laughable since many of Our Lady Queen of Angels parishioners have and continue to reckless disregard to both the neighborhood by double parking, parking in No Parking Zones, jaywalking and by blocking intersection of Mar Vista and Domingo by dropping off and picking up family members and friends, suggests to me that they will disregard any such notices stating "lot full" and or any attendants that I don't sincerely believe that Our Lady Queen of Angels has any intention of spending funds on since they never have before. This equation does not even address the many special events held on site, inclusive of but not limited to weddings, funerals or other such events that Our Lady Queen of Angels promises to limit to no more than one thousand (1000) people and respective vehicles. More specifically, directing the Councils attention to an article published in 1990 addressing the traffic and proposed traffic study in and around Our Lady Queen of Angels wherein Councilman John C. Cox Jr. stated " that funding a study would be a 'waste of money' when the council is already aware of the traffic problems" further exacerbated by Councilman Clarence J. Turner who stated that, " he was previously unaware of how clogged the traffic is around the school between 7:30 and 8:05 each morning ". Turner said "solutions must be found to reduce the congestion before the Newport a ch 11/13/2006 Page 3 of 5 coast is devalop which�eVected to_cause...fs_juin in enrolont at the high school". For the record, nothing whatsoever has been done to reduce the 'congestion' expect the closure of Bison and restricting access to public streets (Mar Vista and Alba) which has only exacerbated the situation and put additional stress onto Eastbluff. Further, the 'new and improved drop off plan' instituted last year hardly addresses the problem, only moved it to the other side of the street, and in doing so eliminated bike lanes creating even more of a potential hazard to students, residents alike. Equally egregious is the fact that despite the steady development of the city, especially the home developments (inclusive of but not limited to Newport Coast) the fact that no high school as been constructed since 1960 constitutes, at the very least, negligence on the part of the Planning Commission in allowing hundreds, maybe thousands of four and five bedroom homes to be built without the foresight of furnishing the necessary schools to facilitate the ever increasing student body, which presently is increasing by one hundred (100) students per year it will only get increase expedientially. 2. While representatives from Our Lady Queen of Angels have, in fact, represented that they have' reached out to their neighbors' during the Planning Commission hearing it appears to me that all evidence suggests the contrary especially considering that Our Lady Queen of Angels proposal calls to relocate the two (2) main driveways that will serve as the major thoroughfares for both the sanctuary and school on Domingo, a residential street, suggests to me that neither the church nor its architects have demonstrated little, if any, respect for the neighborhood or those who reside within, by bringing traffic farther into the neighborhood rather than away from it. Upon fiuther review the Council will note that there are one driveways, and or entrances or exits on either Eastbluff and or Mar Vista, directing all the traffic to Domingo, farther into the neighborhood that Our Lady Queen of Angels purports to have claimed to "reach out too ". Furthermore, upon closer inspection you will can see for yourselves that the two (2) proposed driveways are located at the farther possible point on the property from the major intersection, Jamboree and Eastbluff, and will have an enormous negative impact on the hundreds of homeowners and residents who reside on Domingo and or Amigos Way. Furthermore, insofar as the two (2) proposed driveways serve as both ingress and egress I believe this will only exacerbate the unresolved traffic issues that compromise the quality of lives of those who live in the neighborhood, and given the similar situation at Corona del Mar Plaza wherein only one (1) driveway serves as the primary and only ingress and egress to the shopping complex and Public Library, should serve as a reminder of such poor planning. 3. In reviewing the voluminous report, prepared and paid for and submitted by Our Lady Queen of Angels, I believe there are several misrepresentations by Our Lady Queen of Angels that I feel compelled to address, they are as follows: First and foremost, notwithstanding the fact that the report attempts to argue that the low attendance of certain 'morning services' as mitigating issues to argue any potential traffic issues, the fact that Our Lady Queen of Angels has substantiated its request to expand both its sanctuary and school to accommodate the' growing needs of the church and its school or words to that effect, there is every reason to believe that expect to fill both to full capacity. Secondly, I don't feel that the traffic study presented by the Church is unrealistic in suggesting that by doubling the size of the schools enrollment will only add an estimated seventeen (17) cars on school days especially considering that there is no evidence of a bussing system and or car pooling program to make a concerted effort on the churches part to eliminate any excess traffic. Thirdly, no one on the Planning Commission even questioned the fact that the proposed gymnasium will remain open till 9:00 P.M. seven nights a week and or the extra traffic that brings into the equation. Fourthly, contrary to the sutmnary's claims that there will be' no aesthetic impact' by more than doubling the height of the proposed roof from twenty (20) feet to fifty -five (55) feet I suggest that the 'aesthetic impact' will be quite significant, since that and the proposed ninety (90) foot steeple both exceed the thirty -five (35) foot height restriction that the City has set as both excessive and particular insulting to the neighborhood. 11/13/2006 Page 4 of 5 4. Lastly, and most troubling is the aggravating fact is that both the Planning Commission and just about everyone else, including Our Lady Queen of Angels, seems to be ignoring the virtual ' elephant in the room' so to speak, Corona del Mar and the traffic issues that that, in and of itself, presents to the equation. Notwithstanding the fact that it has been over forty (40) years since a high school has been built, the student body enrollment is increasing exponentially, by at least one hundred (100) students a year, which seems to be of little, or no concern to the Planning Commission or Traffic Commission. Neither Corona del Mar High School itself nor the neighboring streets were designed to accommodate the overcrowding enrollment and or traffic burden especially considering that when the high school was built a majority of the student body traveled to and from via school buses. By closing off access to Bison and other such residential streets the City has only exacerbated an already out of control situation. In closing, I would ask that the Council give serious consideration to the oversights of the Planning Commissions decision wherein it did not in fact act in the City's best interests in properly investigating the proposed expansion. The Summary report prepared on behalf of Our Lady Queen of Angels is littered with gross misrepresentations from the true and actual numbers of parishioners to the traffic situation, I believe that that in and of itself speaks volumes of the Churches lack of veracity. The proposed expansion is far too large for a neighborhood and or streets that were never designed, nor have ever been redesigned to handle the number of vehicles that the Church, its school and C.D.M. high school bring into our neighborhood. For the Church and or its appointed representatives to misrepresent that the traffic will not be impacted is particularly insulting to those of us who reside here. Therefore, I am respectfully requesting that the hearing be postponed and or Our Lady Queen of Angels proposed expansion plans be denied for their less than forthright manner in misrepresenting the true and actual ramifications that the oversized proportions will have on the neighborhood and its residents. Respectfully, Paul Drake Doremus 835 Amigos Way Villa Fifteen Newport Beach, CA PDD:kbd The information contained herein is confidential and intended only for the person(s) to whom it is addressed. If you receive this information / correspondence and you are not the person for whom it was intended, or the legal agent of the person for whom it was intended and/or for the purpose it was intended, disclosure of this information may be a violation of the law and you are instructed to return this correspondence to the undersigned. Know that retention of any hard copies is punishable by law. No claim of ownership is made to third party materials cited herein. You are hereby on notice, that divulging, forwarding or otherwise sharing any portion of this communication with a third party not specifically named in the "Addressed To" section may 11/13/2006 Page 5 of 5 subject the addressee(s) and/or its Wts, to charges of libel, slander, and bl*h of confidentiality. This communication is copyright and may not be reproduced, sold or circulated without the author's prior written consent. 11/13/2006 Authorized to Publish Advertisements of all kindsltdmg public notices by Decree of the Superior Court of Orange County, California. Number A -6214, September 29, 1961, and A -24831 June 11, 1963. PROOF OF PUBLICATION STATE OF CALIFORNIA) ) ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) am a Citizen of the United States and a resident of the County aforesaid; I am over the age of eighteen years, and not a party to or interested in the below entitled matter. I am a principal clerk of the NEWPORT BEACH - COSTA MESA DAILY PILOT, a newspaper of general circulation, printed and published in the City of Costa Mesa, County of Orange, State of California, and that attached Notice is a true and complete copy as was printed and published on the following dates: November 4, 2006 I declare, under penalty of perjury, that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on November 6, 2006 at Costa Mesa, California. e Signature • RECEIVED 2�'S 10 13 AM I1. 07 __ Fi" OF r, TV rI EF, (90 feet proposed to. the steeple); to allow the transfer of develop NONE OF PUBLIC PEARING newtchuchnyffeo(210C Oer Ludy O. en Mar Vista Dr.) to the of Angels Church school site (2046 Mar Expansion Vista Dr.) so as the (PA2005 -092) square footage for the NOTICE 15 HEREBY two properties when GIVEN that the City combined results in an Council of the City of overall FAR (floor area Newport Beach will hold ratio) of 0.17 consistent a public hearing on an with the General Plan; appeal of the Planning and to allow a total of Commission's approval ten portable classrooms of a Use Permit for the to be located on the expansion of Our Lady school site during the Queen of Angels Church. construction period. A The project site is local- traffic study is also re- ed at 2046 and 2100 quired pursuant to the Mar Vista Drive and is Traffic Phasing Ordi- zoned Government, Edu- nance. cational and Institution. NOTICE IS HEREBY al Facilities (GEIF). FURTHER GIVEN that a Our Lady Queen of Mitigated Negative Dec. Angels Church requests laration was prepared to expand their existing by the City of Newport church and school facili- Beach in connection ties by relocating its with the application church to the adjacent noted above. The Miti- property located at 2100 gated Negative Declara- Mar Vista Drive (pres- tion states that, the ently used by St. Mark subject development will Presbyterian Church) not result in a signifi- and expanding its cant effect on the envi- school within the exist- ronment. It is the pres- ing boundaries at 2046 ent intention of the City Mar Vista Drive. The to accept the Mitigated expansion includes the Negative Declaration construction of a 1,170- and supporting doc. seat sanctuary, addi- uments. This is not to tional classrooms, and a be construed as either 9,450 square foot gym- approval or denial by nasium. When cam- the City of the subject bined, the new Our Lady application. The City en- Queen' of Angels Church courages members of campus will be approx- the general public to imately 12.17 acres in - -- size. The project, as Proposed. requires ap- proval of a Use Permit to allow the expansion of the existing church and school acility; to allow the church building to exceed the Permitted building height of 35 feet O review and comment on this documentation. Copies of the Negative Declaration and sup- porting documents are available for public re- view and inspection at the Planning Depart- ment, City of Newport Beach, 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California, 92658 -8915, (949) 644- 3200. NOTICE IS HEREBY FURTHER GIVEN that said Public hearing will be held on Novomfaor 14, 2006, at the hour Of 1:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers of the Newport Beach City' Hall, 3300 Newport Boule- vard, Newport Beach, California. at which time and place any and all persons interested may appear and be heard th2reun. If you challenge this project in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues YOU or someone else raised at the public hearing described in this notice or in written cor- respondence delivered to the City at, or prior to, the public hearing. For information call (949) 644 -3200. LaVonne M. Harkless, City Clerk City of Newport Beach Published Newport 3each /Costa Mesa Daily 'ilot Nov. 4, 2006 Sa604 O OLQOA Project Approval Appeal Hearing Vtila Granada CommuftAssociation Homeowners Easlbluff Apartment Owners Association Amigoa Properties LP November 14,2006 01111y1o6— -#Ie 2 0 Scope of Project vs.Community • Future Growth. • Traffic & parking problems already exist & acknowledged by City Staff. • Problem ignored in OLQOA Neg. Dec, & Traffic Study. • City lacks adequate data/analysts to warrant pemdl approval at this time. • City has opportunity to act on entities it has control over to mitigate current & future impacts. s D Significant Impact • Any growth by the Church or Public School - Is 1 or 27 vehides significant? • Project Neg Dec fails to address threshold of proper significance. • City resources used to manage existing traffic indicates significant problem requiring mitigation. • Can't assess significance without adequate traffic study. 40 Flawed Traffic Study • Current. study does not consider impact of public & public school an local ftftic. • combined Use N city stream is CIVe =cam. • Inadequate study of vehicular traffic an Mar VistatDomingo. • Sadly is responsibility of agency approving use permit, rot the private party. • Use of obscure traffic models rather than actual Waft count. • Removal & reinstatement of bike lane not analyzed. s O Mitigation Measures with Significant Impact • Minimal measures proposed by Neg Dec are Inadequate & non- krrictlonnt. • 2nutlpatlwn nreewseaakd me mml adtrews baflk. • More functional mitigation measures needed: • Removeeweag public parkegm MarM mend Domingwdu"peek boumtvi mwafictlay. • flmrnerMZa➢ �dwMaAertrallhmawM�aMMeri *�aWl.wapes6l Review & review parkeg mr wgessl*"m SOW ftp ff end pick up pademe acme AMrPM s O Neg Dec vs. Public Records • The Neg Dec does not acknowledge traffic andfor parking problems. • City Staff & Public observe problems. • Records show acknowledgement • Hearings • City Expenses • Need for Parking Management Plans; School Drop Off Schedules 70 In Conclusion • City should postpone approval of the use permit wrtil the completion of an EIR to Include a comprehensive battle study. • Take advantage of the existing opportunity to improve the existing traffic and parking conditions. • Taking this time now will insure that the City has fully explored the problem and made improvements that will b9rr01lit this community and support continued growth. RESOLUTION NO. 2006-99 RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH DENYING THE APPEAL AND UPHOLDING AND AFFIRMING THE DECISION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S APPROVAL OF USE PERMIT NO. 2005 -020 AND TRAFFIC STUDY NO. 2006 -002 FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2046 AND 2100 MAR VISTA DRIVE (PA2005 -092) WHEREAS, an application was filed by Our Lady Queen of Angels (OLQA) Church for properties identified as 2046 and 2100 Mar Vista Drive located on the south side of Mar Vista Drive, west of Eastbluff Drive and Jamboree Road. The application requests the approval of a Use Permit to allow the expansion of the existing church and school facilities; to allow a proposed church building to exceed the permitted building height of 35 feet (90 feet proposed for the steeple); to allow the transfer of development intensity between the two sites in accordance with Section 20.63.080 of the Municipal Code; and to allow ten (10) portable classrooms to be located on the school site during the construction period. Traffic Study approval pursuant to the Traffic Phasing Ordinance (TPO) is also requested. The expansion includes the construction of a 1,170 -seat santuary, ten (10) additional classrooms, and a 9,450 square foot gymnasium; and WHEREAS, on August 17, 2006, the Planning Commission held a noticed public hearing in the City Hall Council Chambers, 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California at which time the project applications, the Mitigated Negative Declaration and comments received thereon were considered. The Planning Commission considered the environmental document and associated technical reports during the consideration of the project. Notice of time, place and purpose of the public hearing was given in accordance with law and testimony was presented to, and considered by, the Planning Commission at the hearing, and WHEREAS, at the September 7, 2006 hearing, the Planning Commission, with a vote of 6 ayes (one absent). adopted the Mitigated Negative Declaration and approved Use Permit No. 2005 -020 and Traffic Study No. 2006 -002; and WHEREAS, on September.20, 2006, an appeal was duly filed by Paul Doremus, representing Villa Granada Homeowners Association in accordance with Code Section 20.95.040; and. WHEREAS, on November 14, 2006, the City Council held a noticed. public hearing in the City Hall Council Chambers, 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California at which time the appeal was considered. The appeal presented no new information that would call into question the validity of the environmental analysis in the record. Page 2 of 2 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the City Council of the City of Newport Beach hereby denies the appeal and upholds and affirms the Planning Commission's approval of Use Permit No. 2005 -020 and Traffic Study No. 2006 -002, set forth in the Planning Commission Resolution No. 1696 with amended Condition No. 3 to state as follow: 3. The maximum school enrollment capacity shall be 600 students, Kindergarten through 8t' grade. This resolution shall take effect immediately upon adoption. Passed and adopted by the City Council of Newport Beach at a regular meeting held on the November 14, 2006 by the following vote to wit: 0 CITY CLERK AYES, COUNCIL MEMBERS Curry_, Selic_h, Rosanskv Daigle, Nichols, Mayor Webb NOES, COUNCIL MEMBERS None ABSTAIN, COUNCIL MEMBERS Ridgeway ABSENT COUNCIL MEUBERS N MAYOR • • STATE OF CALIFORNIA } COUNTY OF ORANGE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH } I, LaVonne M. Harkless, City Clerk of the City of Newport Beach, California, do hereby certify that the whole number of members of the City Council is seven; that the foregoing resolution, being Resolution No. 2006 -99 was duly and regularly introduced before and adopted by the City Council of said City at a regular meeting of said Council, duly and regularly held on the 14th day of November 2006, and that the same was so passed and adopted by the following vote, to wit: Ayes: Curry, Selich, Rosansky, Daigle, Nichols, Mayor Webb Noes: None Absent: None Abstain: Ridgeway IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto subscribed my name .and affixed the official seal of said City this 15th day of November 2006. City Clerk Newport Beach, California