The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About17 - Group Homes Appeal - Yellowstone Women's First Step HouseCITY OF NEWPORT BEACH CITY COUNCIL STAFF REPORT Agenda Item No. 17 September 22, 2009 TO: HONORABLE MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL FROM: David R. Hunt, City Attorney Ext. 3131, dhunt(a-) citv.newoort- beach.ca.us SUBJECT: APPEAL OF HEARING OFFICER'S DENIAL OF USE PERMITS AND REASONABLE ACCOMMODATIONS 1621 INDUS (YELLOWSTONE WOMEN'S FIRST STEP HOUSE, INC.) 1561 INDUS (YELLOWSTONE WOMEN'S FIRST STEP HOUSE, INC.) 1571 PEGASUS (YELLOWSTONE WOMEN'S FIRST STEP HOUSE, INC.) 20172 REDLANDS (YELLOWSTONE WOMEN'S FIRST STEP HOUSE, INC.) • (UP 2008 -034) (RA 2009 -04) (PA2008 -105) APPLICANT: Yellowstone Women's First Step House, Inc. APPELLANT: Yellowstone Women's First Step House, Inc. RECOMMENDATION: The applicant/appellant has requested that the City Council continue this item. Based upon past practice in similar situations, staff recommends that this item be continued to the November 24, 2009 meeting date. PUBLIC NOTICE: Public notice was provided in accordance with all applicable laws. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW: This is not a project under CEQA. Appeal of Hearing Officer's Denial of Use Permits and Reasonable Accommodations Yellowstone Women's First Step House, Inc. September 22, 2009 Page 2 Prepared by: ' a David R. Hunt, City Attorney DAVIS•ZFATY September 15, 2009 VIA EMAIL AND FIRST CLASS MAIL Ms. Lelani Brown City of Newport Beach, City CIerk 3300 Newport Boulevard Newport Beach, CA 92658 -8915 LBrownranewportbeachca.gov Re: Yellowstone Women's First Step House - Appeal Hearing Dates Dear Ms. Brown: Please let this letter serve as Yellowstone's formal request that the hearing date for Yellowstone's appeal to the City of Newport Beach, currently scheduled for September 22, 2009, be continued to a later date. Thank you for your courtesy and if you have any questions regarding this correspondence, please feel free to contact me. Very truly yours, DAVIS ZFATY, a professional corporation NICOLE COHRS, ESQ. Cc: Catherine Wolcott, Esq. '181.4 61radmly Street, Swle WI . Laguna Beat h, (A 9 YGS E UJq. { -(,.Pa -111 F.i,\ 94'4. 176. {H%5 nvn«<`d ailutirnC�s.r un; ,vw«.rliacntncr om r. pcl;d 4fifM1armation Phone #: (9401644 -9005 Name:`: CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH" AG12622 AddresS.; 3300 Newport Blvd. Newport Beach, CA 92663 Acct# :296271603 ClierI CITY CLERK_SOFFICE-CITY OF NEWPORT Placed tiy: i Fax #[.,,.__ . ............_.: _...._> Startdate 109 -12 -09 .$to 4ate,09 -12 -09 Tty9i@Pi10rt9 1 RAte COde i &Legal Newport Beach Ta(en1)y; 9962 Susan Channels IfOCtltBtlOn uv- =,-- ym.musvv.,.. umcaan4.ar,va =vim .Size 3 x 100.610 $ifled�SiZel 10.00 TCN Inch Keyword`; Adtype Liner ut." as defined by NBMC "SecCbo 2(f:03Ft S0 °To 'adBiCiin;'Tfie'bpPli'c'2tiC`(s" questing approval of a Reasonable Accommodation for exemption from Chapter 36 of the NBMC and Section 3.36.G30 which requires 100 percent cost recovery r permits related to user serelces. Exemption is also requested from Section 1.91A.050 (C.2) of the NBMC to allow more than two residents pet bedroom i ilh one additional resident. ris activity has been determined to be categorically exempt under the quirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) under Class 1 i xisting Facilities). This class of projects has been determined not to have a militant effect on the environment and is exempt from the provisions of CEQA. I e potential for causing a significant effect on the environment 61(b)(3) of the CEQA Guidelines). It can be seen with certainty no Possibility that this activity will have a significant effect on the and it is not subject to CEQA. d parties may appear and present testimony in regard to these H you challenge these projects in court. you may be limited to those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing r this notice) or in written correspondence delivered to the CRy, at, the public hearing. The staff report may be reviewed at the City erkMOffice, City of Newport Beach, 3300 Newport uourevaw, Newport aeacn, rfifornia, 92663 or at the City of Newport Beach website at ww.rrewporibeachco.gov beginning on the Wednesday prior to the hearing. it more information, call (949) 644 -3232 or (949) 6443002. To be added to permanent notification list of these hearings, e�mall Cliff 0a newportbearbra,gov an it ask to receive these notices. rojerLFNs Ne._PA2008 -105. PA2008.100, PA2008407 and PA2008 -108 ;Hvity, No.: UP2008- 0341RA2009-004. UP2008- 035/RA2009 -005, UP2008 -037/ %2009 -006 and UP2008- 038/RA2009 -007 lye Vitt, City Manager, City of Newport Beach LeCity Brown, City Clerk City of Newport Beach rblished Newport Beach7Costa Mesa Daly Pilot SePtember 12, 2009 Sa952 NOTKEOFPIIKKHEARMG GROUP RESUNT14 USE PERMITS YEEEOWSTOW WOMEN'S FIRST STEP HOUSE, INC. 1561INM MET, 16211NDUS STREET, 1571 PEGASU%STREET, & 20172 REOIANDS WK NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of the City of Newport Beach will conduct a public hearing on September 22, 2009, an or after 7:00 p.m. in the City Council Chambers (Building A) at 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California. The City Council will consider an °;appeal of the Hearing Officer's decision to deny the Use Permit applications of Yellowstone Women's First Step House, Inc. submitted for four separate 'sober living facilities, and to deny the applicant's requests for Reasonable Accommodation at the four locations. The appeal for each application was submitted by the applicant. A brief description of the applications submitted for each location is as follows: L 1561 Indus Street (UP2008 -034 and RA2009 -004). An application requesting approval of a use permit to allow the continued operation of an unlicensed adult alcohol and /or drug abuse sober living facility for 12 resident clients, females only. The application was filed in accordance with Ordinance No- 2008-05- As a Reasonable Accommodation. the applicant is requesting to be exempted from the Residential Use Classification "Residential Care Facilities, General: as defined by Section 26,05.030 (H) of the Newport Beach Municipal Code (NBMC). and to be treated as a "Single Housekeeping Unit," as defined by NBMC Section 20.03.030. in addition, the applicant is requesting approval of a Reasonable Accommodation for exemption from Chapter 3.36 of the NBMC and Section 3.36.03O which requires 100 percent cost recovery lot permits related to user services. Exemption is also requested tram Section 20.91A.050 (C.2) of the NBMC to allow more than two residents per bedroom with one additional resident. 2. 1621 Indus Street (UP 2008 -035 and RA2009 -005). An application requesting approval of a use permit to allow the continued operation of an unlicensed adult alcohol and(or drug abuse sober living facility tar 17 resident clients. females only. The application was filed in accordance with Ordinance No- 2008-05- As a Reasonable Accommodation, the applicant is requesting to Facilities, General,- as defined by Section 20.05.030 (H) of the Newport Beach Municipal Code (NBMC), and to be treated as a "Single Housekeeping Unit." as defined by NBMC Section 20.03.030. In addition, the applicant is requesting approval of a Reasonable Accpilmodalion for exemption from Chapter 3.36 of the NBMC and Section 3.36.030 which requires 100 percent cost recovery for permits related to user services. Exemption is also requested tram Section 20.91A.050 (C.2) of the NBMC to allow more than two residents per bedroom with one additional resident. 3. 1571 Pegasus Street (UP 2008 -036 and RA2009�006). An application requesting approval of a use permit to allow the continued operation of an unlicensed adult alcohol and /or drug abuse sober living facility for 18 resident clients, females only. The application was filed in accordance with Ordinance No. 2008 -05. As a Reasonable Accommodation, the applicant is requesting to be exempted from the Residential Use Classification "Residential Cara, Facilities, General," as defined by Section 20.05.030 (H) of the Newport Elm& Municipal Code (NBMC), and to be treated as a "Single Housekeeping Unit," as defined by NBMC Section 20.03.030. In addition, the applicant is requesting approval of a Reasonable Accommodation for exemption from Chapter 3.36 of the NBMC and Section 3.36.030 which requires 100 percent cost recovery for permits related to user services. Exemption is also requested from Section 20.91A.050 (C.2) of the NBMC to allow more than two residents per bedroom with one additional resident. 4. 20172 Redlands Drive (UP 2008 -037 and RA2009 -007). An application requesting approval of a use permit to allow the continued operation of an unlicensed adult alcohol and /or ding abuse sober living facility for 18 resident clients. males only. The application was filed in accordance with Ordinance No. 2008 -05. As a Reasonable Accommodation. the applicant: is requesting to be exempted from the Residential Use Classification "Residential Care Facilities. General," as defined by Section 2005.030 (H) of the Newport Beach Municipal Code (NBMC), and to be treated as a "Single Housekeeping — ad proof pg. 1 . . Office of the City Clerk CITY HALL 3300 Newport Blvd. Newport Beach, CA 92663 -3884 IMPORTANT PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE 1J3eAveryr® Template 51600 119 364 10 JAMES JOHN ISAACS III 1541 ORCHARD DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 364 13 LILLIAN V MARTIN 1571 ORCHARD DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 364 19 PAUL IPERRY 1511 ORCHARD DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119- 362 -07 Stephen Thames 3569 Meder Road Shingle Springs, CA 95682 119 352 02 David Ho 0 PO BOX 6465 IRVINE, CA92616 i !reed Paper expose Pop -Up EdgeTM 119 36411 119 364 12 DAVID KERREK JOHN C ENGLISH 1551 ORCHARD DR 1561 ORCHARD DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 364 14 119 364 15 ANTHONY KANIER CHURCHILL 1591 ORCHARD DR 1801 PARK COURT PL #B SANTA ANA, CA 92707 SANTA ANA, CA 92701 Rick Dayton - SAH PAC Davis -Zfaty Prof. Law Corp. 2900 Silver Lane 580 Broadway Street #301 Newport Beach, CA 92660 Laguna Beach, CA 92651 119 35103 WILSON REED ROBINSON 20091 KLINE DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 352 03 MATTHEW L BIESER 20141 KLINE DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 352 01 GRAZIANO & DEN PESTARINO 2809 LA SALLE AVE COSTA MESA, CA 92626 119 352 06 ROSA BALOGH 20181 KLINE DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 Yellowstone Group Homes PA2008 -105 to PA2008 -108 Owner Mailing Labels Created: September 9, 2009 Etiquettes faciles h peter i A Repliez h la hachure afin de ; www.avery com ; UtiliseZ le gabarit AVERY® 51600 j chaarrgnement revdler le rebord Pop -Up *e ` 1- 800-GO -AVERY i Use Avery- Template 5160w j :Feed Paper — expose Pop-Bp Edge- 11935101 ERIC ROSENTHAL 1661 INDUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 351 18 HENRY D O'SHEA 1672 PEGASUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 351 21 LOUISE CHARLOTTE LEE 1671 ORCHARD DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 352 07 BEATRICE BOCSI 1681 PEGASUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 352 10 PAUL M EDLER 20142 RIVERSIDE DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 36101 JAMES C HARVEY 1651 INDUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 36104 ANNA MARIE THAMES 28 IMA LOA CT NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92663 119 36107 WILLIAM D WALKER 1571 INDUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 361 10 BRIAN PATRICK SULLIVAN 1592 INDUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 361 13 DANIELLE J SEARS 1591 PEGASUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 Etiquettes faciles h peler Utilisez le gabarit AVERY® 51600 119 35102 KATHLEEN A LOOMAN 1671 INDUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 351 19 GARY DEVINE 1662 PEGASUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 352 04 MICHAEL S CHRISTY 20151 KLINE DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 352 08 KATHLEEN M ANDREWS 1671 PEGASUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 352 11 ANGUS E RICHARDSON 20122 RIVERSIDE DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 36102 YURETTA LORMAN 0 PO BOX 2421 COSTA MESA, CA 92628 119 36105 ROBERT B HANLEY 1601 INDUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 36108 ANNA THAMES 154 E BAY ST COSTA MESA, CA 92627 119 36111 MALCOLM F THOMPSON 1602 INDUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 361 14 ANNA MARIE THAMES 1571 PEGASUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 ' Se de Replier a la hachure afln de jchargement rftkler le rebord Pop•Upr" 119 351 17 VINCENT D COOK 1692 PEGASUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 351 20 WILLIAM H BOSSERT 1661 ORCHARD DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 352 05 ROBERT LEO DUBE' 20161 KLINE OR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 352 09 FRANK H MASTERSON 20152 RIVERSIDE DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 352 12 GEORGE L ROBERTSON 20112 RIVERSIDE DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 36103 PETER H WEISMANN 1631 INDUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 36106 CHARLOTTE C Z HOGAN 507 ALTA VISTA DR SANTA CRUZ, CA 95060 119 36109 TRAVIS & JENNIFER HAINING 1572 INDUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 361 12 JONATHAN DAVIS 1601 PEGASUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 361 15 WAYNE E ROGALLA 1561 PEGASUSST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 www.averycom 1- 800-GO -AVERY Use Avery- Template 516W- j Feed Paper expose Pop-Up Edge- 11936116 11936117 11936118 ' CHESTER P GROSKREUTZ PETER ALLEN KEMMERLY JOSEPH SANDOR 1551 PEGASUS ST 1531 PEGASUS ST 1521 PEGASUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 361 19 119 361 25 11936201 JACK MOTLEY FV SANTA ANA LLC PATRICIA RUTH SANDERS 1501 PEGASUS ST 21 ROADRUNNER CT 20111 RIVERSIDE DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 COTO DE CAZA, CA 92679 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 362 02 119 362 03 119 362 04 DAVID M PLISCO PACIFIC LEGACY REAL ESTAT WELLS FARGO BK NA 20121 RIVERSIDE DR 17853 SANTIAGO BLVD 3476 STATEVIEW BLVD SANTA ANA, CA 92707 VILLA PARK, CA 92861 FORT MILL, SC 29715 119 362 05 119 362 06 119 362 07 DUFFY MICHAEL GOOD STEPHEN THAMES 1651 PEGASUS ST 1631 PEGASUS ST 28 IMA LOA CT SANTA ANA, CA 92707 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92663 119 362 08 119 362 09 119 362 10 ANNIE N PIERMONT MICHAEL G FEDORCHEK PETER P ANDREWS 20162 REDLANDS DR 20152 REDLANDS DR 20132 REDLANDS DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 362 11 119 363 01 119 363 02 RITA M BOSLEY EDWARD PATRICK KEHOE SOHRAB HASHEM 1632 INDUS ST 1642 PEGASUS ST 1632 PEGASUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 363 03 119 363 04 119 363 05 JACK GRUBISICH THOMAS JOHN QUEBBEMANN R WESLEY BEAVERS 1622 PEGASUS ST 1621 ORCHARD DR 1631 ORCHARD DR SANTA ANA, CA 92707 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 363 06 119 364 01 119 364 02 YI HAN WEI PETER L WARREN STEPHEN E ABRAHAM 1641 ORCHARD DR 0 PO BOX 5474 1592 PEGASUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92662 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 119 364 03 119 364 04 119 364 05 LUZ APELES MICHAEL A MCDONOUGH BRIAN WECKLICH 1572 PEGASUS ST 1562 PEGASUS ST 0 PO BOX 1803 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 COSTA MESA, CA 92628 119 364 06 119 364 07 119 364 08 COU ELNATHAN BATOON ARMEN & MARIA GEKCHYAN 1532 PEGASUS ST 1522 PEGASUS ST 1502 PEGASUS ST SANTA ANA, CA 92707 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 SANTA ANA, CA 92707 Etiquettes faciles 6 peler A Repliez A la hachure afin de i vaww.averycom UtiliseZ le gabarit AVERY® StfiO® 1 chargement r6veler le rebord Pop -Up- 1- 800 -GO -AVERY ` ij W07'AJaAe'MMM 119 36410 RESIDENT j 1541 ORCHARD DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 364 13 RESIDENT 1571 ORCHARD DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 36419 RESIDENT 1511 ORCHARD DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 352 02 RESIDENT 20121 KLINE DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92707 i eP ulfe GURPe4 el 9 sepdea I Jeled @ sajpq SQUenbq" J...... _.... __ _.._.___.._♦ �. .._._ ..._ .. 119 364 11 119 36412 RESIDENT RESIDENT 1551 ORCHARD DR 1561 ORCHARD DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 364 14 RESIDENT 1591 ORCHARD DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 351 03 RESIDENT 20091 KLINE DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92707 119 352 03 RESIDENT 20141 KLINE DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92707 119 364 15 RESIDENT 1601 ORCHARD DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 352 01 RESIDENT 20111 KLINE DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92707 119 352 06 RESIDENT 20181 KLINE DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92707 Yellowstone Group Homes PA2008 -105 to PA2008 -108 Occupant/Resident Mailing Labels Created: September 9, 2009 'vu0965 .96pa do -dod asodxe jaded pool 00915 aieldwal oAmAv ash 1 ®A?13AF/ Q I 04 Bull 6uolB PUBS ♦ I slaqul &Aaad AM 119 35101 119 35102 119 3511 7 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1661 INDUS ST 1671 INDUS ST 1692 PEGASUS ST NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 351 18 119 351 19 .... 114 351 20 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1672 PEGASUS ST 1662 PEGASUS ST 1661 ORCHARD DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 35121 119 352 04 119 352 05 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1671 ORCHARD DR 20151 KLINE DR 20161 KLINE DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 352 07 119 352 08 119 352 09 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1681 PEGASUS ST 1671 PEGASUS ST 20152 RIVERSIDE DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 352 10 119 352 11 119 352 12 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 20142 RIVERSIDE DR 20122 RIVERSIDE DR 20112 RIVERSIDE DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 36101 119 36102 119 36103 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1651 INDUS ST 1641 INDUS ST 1631 INDUS ST NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 36104 119 36105 119 36106 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1621 INDUS ST 1601 INDUS ST 1591 INDUS ST NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 361 07 119 36108 119 36109 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1571 INDUS ST 1561 INDUS ST 1572 INDUS ST NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 361 10 119 361 11 119 361 12 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1592 INDUS ST 1602 INDUS ST 1601 PEGASUS ST NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 36113 119 361 14 119 361 15 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1591 PEGASUS ST 1571 PEGASUS ST 1561 PEGASUS ST NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 Mdquettes faciles b peter ; Repliez 6 l hachure afin de ; www.avery.com Utilisez le gabarit AVERY@ 51600 Sens de cha Bement rbv6ier le rebord Pop-Up TM j 1- 800-GO -AVERY i wv�a�anemmnn .i aP aye emipeq el 7 z80dell ' ♦ ' .i jeled @ salve; sauenbl$ 11936116 11936117 11936118 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1551 PEGASUS ST 1531 PEGASUS ST 1521 PEGASUS ST NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 361 19 119 36125 119 362 01 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1501 PEGASUS ST 20162 SANTA ANA AVE 20111 RIVERSIDE DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 362 02 119 362 03 119 362 04 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 20121 RIVERSIDE DR 20141 RIVERSIDE DR 20151 RIVERSIDE DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 362 05 119 362 06 119 362 07 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1651 PEGASUS ST 1631 PEGASUS ST 20172 REDLANDS DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 362 08 119 362 09 119 362 10 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 20162 REDLANDS DR 20152 REDLANDS DR 20132 REDLANDS DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 362 11 119 363 01 119 363 02 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1632 INDUS ST 1642 PEGASUS ST 1632 PEGASUS ST NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 363 03 119 363 04 119 363 05 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1622 PEGASUS 5T 1621 ORCHARD DR 1631 ORCHARD DR NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 363 06 119 364 01 119 364 02 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1641 ORCHARD DR 1602 PEGASUS ST 1592 PEGASUS ST NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 364 03 119 364 04 119 364 05 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1572 PEGASUS ST 1562 PEGASUS ST 1552 PEGASUS ST NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 119 364 06 119 364 07 119 364 08 RESIDENT RESIDENT RESIDENT 1532 PEGASUS ST 1522 PEGASUS ST 1502 PEGASUS ST NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 NEWPORT BEACH, CA 92660 Y w.096S v 96P3 dn-dod asodxa jaded Paad f ®0965 aleldwal �4aAV as0 ®AZ13Af/ Q of Gull 6mle Pugs i slagel ®land Ase3 NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING GROUP RESIDENTIAL USE PERMITS YELLOWSTONE WOMEN'S FIRST STEP HOUSE, INC. 1561 INDUS STREET, 1621 INDUS STREET, 1571 PEGASUS STREET, & 20172 REDLANDS DRIVE NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of the City of Newport Beach will conduct a public hearing on September 22, 2009, on or after 7:00 p.m. in the City Council Chambers (Building A) at 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California. The City Council will consider an appeal of the Hearing Officer's decision to deny the Use Permit applications of Yellowstone Women's First Step House, Inc. submitted for four separate sober living facilities, and to deny the applicant's requests for Reasonable Accommodation at the four locations. The appeal for each application was submitted by the applicant. A brief description of the applications submitted for each location is as follows: 1. 1561 Indus Street (UP2008 -034 and RA2009 -004). An application requesting approval of a use permit to allow the continued operation of an unlicensed adult alcohol and /or drug abuse sober living facility for 12 resident clients, females only. The application was filed in accordance with Ordinance No. 2008 -05. As a Reasonable Accommodation, the applicant is requesting to be exempted from the Residential Use Classification "Residential Care Facilities, General," as defined by Section 20.05.030 (H) of the Newport Beach Municipal Code (NBMC), and to be treated as a "Single Housekeeping Unit," as defined by NBMC Section 20.03.030. In addition, the applicant is requesting approval of a Reasonable Accommodation for exemption from Chapter 3.36 of the NBMC and Section 3.36.030 which requires 100 percent cost recovery for permits related to user services. Exemption is also requested from Section 20.91A.050 (C.2) of the NBMC to allow more than two residents per bedroom with one additional resident. 2. 1621 Indus Street (UP 2008 -035 and RA2009 -005). An application requesting approval of a use permit to allow the continued operation of an unlicensed adult alcohol and/or drug abuse sober living facility for 17 resident clients, females only. The application was filed in accordance with Ordinance No. 2008 -05. As a Reasonable Accommodation, the applicant is requesting to be exempted from the Residential Use Classification "Residential Care Facilities, General," as defined by Section 20.05.030 (H) of the Newport Beach Municipal Code (NBMC), and to be treated as a "Single Housekeeping Unit," as defined by NBMC Section 20.03.030. In addition, the applicant is requesting approval of a Reasonable Accommodation for exemption from Chapter 3.36 of the NBMC and Section 3.36.030 which requires 100 percent cost recovery for permits related to user services. Exemption is also requested from Section 20,91A.050 (C.2) of the NBMC to allow more than two residents per bedroom with one additional resident. 3. 1571 Pegasus Street (UP 2008 -036 and RA2009 -006). An application requesting approval of a use permit to allow the continued operation of an unlicensed adult alcohol and /or drug abuse sober living facility for 18 resident clients, females only. The application was filed in accordance with Ordinance No. 2008 -05. As a Reasonable Accommodation, the applicant is requesting to be exempted from the Residential Use Classification "Residential Care Facilities, General," as defined by Section 20.05.030 (H) of the Newport Beach Municipal Code (NBMC), and to be treated as a "Single Housekeeping Unit," as defined by NBMC Section 20.03.030. In addition, the applicant is requesting approval of a Reasonable Accommodation for exemption from Chapter 3.36 of the NBMC and Section 3.36.030 which requires 100 percent cost recovery for permits related to user services. Exemption is also requested from Section 20.91A.050 (C.2) of the NBMC to allow more than two residents per bedroom with one additional resident. 4. 20172 Redlands Drive (UP 2008 -037 and RA2009 -007). An application requesting approval of a use permit to allow the continued operation of an unlicensed adult alcohol and /or drug abuse sober living facility for 18 resident clients, males only. The application was filed in accordance with Ordinance No. 2008 -05. As a Reasonable Accommodation, the applicant is requesting to be exempted from the Residential Use Classification "Residential Care Facilities, General;' as defined by Section 20.05.030 (H) of the Newport Beach Municipal Code (NBMC), and to be treated as a "Single Housekeeping Unit," as defined by NBMC Section 20.03.030. In addition, the applicant is requesting approval of a Reasonable Accommodation for exemption from Chapter 3.36 of the NBMC and Section 3.36.030 which requires 100 percent cost recovery for permits related to user services. Exemption Is also requested from Section 20.91A.050 (C.2) of the NBMC to allow more than two residents per bedroom with one additional resident. This activity has been determined to be categorically exempt under the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) under Class 1 (Existing Facilities). This class of projects has been determined not to have a significant effect on the environment and is exempt from the provisions of CEQA. This activity is also covered by the general rule that CEQA applies only to projects that have the potential for causing a significant effect on the environment (Section 15061(b)(3) of the CEQA Guidelines). It can be seen with certainty that there is no possibility that this activity will have a significant effect on the environment and it is not subject to CEQA. All interested parties may appear and present testimony in regard to these applications. If you challenge these projects in court, you may be limited to raising only those issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing (described in this notice) or in written correspondence delivered to the City, at, or prior to, the public hearing. The staff report may be reviewed at the City Clerk's Office, City of Newport Beach, 3300 Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach; California, 92663 or at the City of Newport Beach website at www.newoortbeachca.00v beginning on the Wednesday prior to the hearing. For more information, call (949) 644 -3232 or (949) 644 -3002. To be added to a permanent notification list of these hearings, e-mail dkiff(t1newoortbeachca.gov and ask to receive these notices. Project File No.: PA2008 -105, PA2008 -106, PA2008- Activity No.: UP2008- 034/RA2009 -004, UP2008- 107 and PA2008 -108 035/RA2009 -005, UP2008- 0371RA2009 -006 and U P2008- 038/RA2009 -007 Dave Kiff, City Manager, City of Newport Beach A j Leilani 5r6wn, City Clerk City of Newport Beach CJ • APR-27 -2009 MM UN:3f M UAV1J IOM" arc r"A I" ma 319 3010 �. w Y I'd 962S9i96i6 auolsmollaA 3. ' N us- useAOT OF arm 009 APR-27 -2 WN 08:37 AR DAV[S RAYM arc FAX K 9Q8 378 3875 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Project N0. PA: 2006106 ApO kedon Na: t1Y PO t N& 20084M NereadAppe6rrC YenoweloneYMmItFod Slop HOwa.Inr. Dr. Amn Marlo Tharnn Phmk (842) 678.8000 8fti Addreas: 1821 Indus, Newport Beach, C.e6forrllo 02707 Dale of HaMInB Offloere deddoa: Apra 14, 2000 Nsse of Appkwd: Yallowswie Wotan% PYd Step "mew Inc. (D w*dmofappOcallimfliedwO Nom O6foerl Application for a Cmd msl Uw Pmmit pavan to Ordnance No. 2WOM nquedbrp apprwd d Use PwM No. 2006-006 N Now 1821 Indw to ocr&AM openMp ae an 18 bed a" -coat"faotrly. Reason for Appeal TM Acme apsdas such bat ft ragiisd fauft to 0mt s Codaarai US& Pwrtik can be made. Tharafoa, the City of Newport beach bpnoWfy dented bra nqueet, wbh Pre i". .1 — 1-1 77,111111111111 Dawn''""°pwor, Dray `•,raiwwrncaie..odaanmoa7vnhoru r'd sszssrssrs •uo %smotirti P. 07 u APR -27 -2009 MN 0837 M DAVIS RAYBURN apc 0 M tai. MI Jib SUM r. uo CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH APPLICATION TO APPEAL OECHMN OF THE HEARMS OFFICER PnoJeat Mo. PA: 2006-105 AppNtedw No.: Rses Aoeorn. 2008-05 Mom of AppNbft Yellowstone Women's First Step House. Ina Dr. Arcs Mart Themes Phore: (90) 676 -9000 80 Addnss: 1621 ktdus, Newport (leech, Califon 92707 Date of Hearing Ohs decision April 14.2009 (on appliceft for CarrdEiorW Use PemMU Mama of Applicant Yellowstone Women's First Step House, Ina (Desaipfbn d applioatlon Sled mirth Hearin0 OM M Appkallon for a RessorMW Accommodation pursuarnt to Ordnance No. 2009 -05 requesting that 1821 Indus be permitted an exemption from the occupancy restrictions of Section 20.91A.060 of the Newport Beach Municipal Code whid restrkts ooarpency to two residents per bedroom plus cure additional resident. Reasons for Appeal The City of Newport Beach denied the applicant's Condbonal the Permit appRCatiort, therefore. the City's deehbn regarding the oaxrpancy w nption was mviered mooL Although the City rower specMcaty ruled on this paMouler reasonable s000mmodeHon reWwk Yellowstone hereby appeals because the 1621 Indus hone opsratn such that the required Wings to anent the requested reasonable accommodation can be made. ? April 27. 2008 SIOMA a of Ap"Nerrt Cage FO(R! OFFICE USE ONLY: Rvwhed by Fee salved ontaf Glaoarryrrir WA 620090 WWry"WS WpafTwoomy YfsaNt Ron OonWnLoeaok{2!7rmeW, Apaal or lkal w alkali Oadr WAM RS 044492b 1'd 962S9*96i6 au014sM0TreA • • APR -27 -2009 HON 12:53 PM DAVIS RAYRIRM sae FAX NO. 949 4(u 38(5 Y. Ul /Ut CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH APPUCATM TO APPEAL bECWIOM OF THE HEARIMG OFFICER Projsd Na. PA: 2008 -106 Application No.: Reas. Accom. 2000-5 Mama of Appellant: YeQowstons Women's First Slop House, Inc. Or. Arun Maria Thames Phone (949) 675MW We Address: 1621 IrKluts, Newport Beach, CalOomis 92707 Dais of Head" Officers decision: April 14, 2009 Name of Applicant: YNlowstone Women s First Step House, by. (Aeacription of application flied with Hearing OfRow) Application for a Reasoneble AccommodOw pursuant to Ordinance No. 2008.05 requesting Utat 1621 Indus be treated as a Single Housekeeping Unit as de*W in Section 20.03.030 of the Newport Beach Municipal Coda. Reasons for Appeal The home operates such that the required findings to grant the requested reaaoneble accommodation can be made. Therefore, the City of Newport Beach impropetty denied the request, with prejudice. April 27, 2009 Signature of Appellant Oats FOR OFFICE USE ONLY: L��L' 2 jj�A� --6- - 4�L'7101 Received 3y j Fee received Date C7OdnerMnh anti 8ean9atiwean7�dar SndnowTenwdory 4eeirol f WCoM &oW0W :flow, AppeM d MWrq CPNW#0embn.dees a vwd 02-0449 lb 1,d 96299 ►9646 auo'4SMQjiaA 0 Rm-CI-mo nut uf-ss fin URVIb KHTMM &OC rmh mu. uqa Jro xro r. vc 6'd 96299*96*6 OUO%SMOTIOA Ci 'S ;�xO�:�i� 1�.�3Ir ";Hti;il7fFc1'1REnt r;4;t 0 tfx MU. 84H ift btilb r. w CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Appkaliom No-- Use Pettit No. 2006094 Nixon at Appellant Yellowstone Wornwl's Flat Step House, Inc. Dr. Ama Mara Thanes Plane: (949) SM9000 Sits Addreme 1501 Indus, Newport Basch, California 92707 Dais of NewhV 0MCW11 daeNion: Apr# 14.2009 Name of Applicant: Yellowstone Women's FW MW Houss, Inc. (Dentr4o n of app" iaatlarr filled whir Nearing Of6ceir) Application for a Conditional Use Permit pursuant to Ordnance No. 2008.05 requestirg apprcval of Use Permit No. 21106-094 to allow 1581 Indus to oorrtin a opera" as a 12 bed adull softer living fadfdy RGGSM for Appeal The home operates such that the regtirod flndirgs to grant a Conditional Use P'armR Call be made. Therefore. the City of Newport Beach Imprope" dented the nqusat, V Mh prejudice. aignahm of Appe@ark FOR OFRCE USE ONLY: April 27.2009 Date V Fee revived Dele a +oea.rwr.YlObmrya•o0onoroa�9s..eennss .nOm V1, R- FiacaierLowsoA+zrma2mApewa �o orsarr. no, .ao.om ow w as a ri ZI'd 86ZS949646 eu01sr.0110A 9 APR-27-2009 MR 08:36 All DAVIS RAYUM ape 0 htD nu a4a jib JUrs r. u4 CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH APPLICATION TO APPEAL DECISION 4R THE HEARING OFFICER Projsst No. PA: 2008 -105 AppHeaOn Na: Rees. Accom. 2009.04 Naas of Appellant Yellowstone Women's Fin! Stop House. Inc. Dr. Anne Merle Thomas Pbose (948) 578 -9000 Yin Address 1381 l n** Newport Beach. Caltiamis 92707 Dabs of Hsarhrg OfRca's BaWain - April 14, 2009 (on ap A, l on for Conditional Use Permlk) Nave of Applicant Yetbastone Women's Fret Stop House. Inc. ( + of opprosfbn filed wM bear g o"ift1 Application for a Reasonable Accommodation pursuant to Ordnance No. 2o0e -05 requesting that 1581 Indus be permilled an wwnVW ftom the occupancy restrictions of Sadion 20.91A.050 of the Nswpsrt Beads Municipal Cads which restricts occupancy to two reaidernts w bedroom plus ens additional resident. Romans for Appeal The City of Newport Beach denied the applicants Conditional Use Pei appiot9on. thwWars, the C Ws decision regarding the occupancy exemption was .wWo moot Although the City now speciflmgY ruled on this psrthalar reasonable accommodsUon request, Yellowstone hereby appeals because the 1581 Indus home operalss such that the required tindinpe to grant the requested reasonable accommodation con be mode. rlyz 172 Agri 27.2009 Siigg alstre of AAppeYarr Den FOR OFFICE UBEEONLY. QII�A� Q. -�r- 41u lm Reoalv.d by I Foe ta. h— Dab c:gow�wiu rq smnpaeernr¢ ow s.sroar«*ww.r �n.c tarn C.Mntou110a1A t77ee7P71AppW r Nwue oraers o.artoeaemc N�`bM osa+a is ti'd seassrssrs euozseotte,h In -V -eM nun un:J0 Hn v6rlb HHrtruan W E rnA w m aro aoro r. va CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH APPLICATION TO APPEAL VISION OF THE HEARM G "VM Projieet No. PA: 20011-105 Appkaflon Nm: Reas. Aorom. 2009*4 Name of Appellant: Yellowstone Woman's Fret Seep House, Inc. Dr. Anne Marie Thomas Phone: (949) 678 4000 Sm Addraaa: 1681 Indus, Newport Bank Caftmia 92707 Dab of Hearing OlflWa daahbn: April 14, 2009 Name of Applkatlt Yellavni one Women's First Seep House. Inc. (DescrIpSw of appNeaeton filed wflh Haso ft Officer) Application for a Reasonable A000mmodation pursuant to Ordinance No. 2006 -05 requesting that 1551 Indus be treated as a Single Housekeeping Unit as defined in Section 20.111090 of the Newport Beads Municipal Code, Reasons for Appeal The home operates such that the required encb to grand the requested 19820nable accommodation can be made Therefore. the City of Nawpod Beads impmperli denied the request, wilh prejudice. April 27, 2009 84natam of Appellant Dad FOR OFFICE USE ONLY: r~wGcm><ff s.ewnr.*a�n m Frwwrw.our.Wnrce:rnAppsm ,..,V cao.r.o�. ! n.w»eaa';KzAr 01 -d 96299*96*6 eu0%S00traA • • wK-Lf -LlRly tR1K Ult :Jl H8 URY15 KHl'M apc m Mu. AV J►tl JUf9 r. lU S'd 96299b96i6 auo,45moiiaA APR -27 -2009 MOO 08:37 AM DAVIS RAYN M apc I'M NU. 818 378 387b CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH APPMATfOM TO APPEAL QECf9IOM OF THE WAMIG OFFICER Frokwt No. PA: 2006 -107 Appileallon No. Use Pem& No. 2008 -M Nerve of Appellant YeRuwstone Womw s First Soap Ham, Im Dr. Anna Maria Thames Phone: (916) 878.9000 site Address: 1571 Pegasus. Newport Beach. California 92707 gala of ffearin0 0Mc;Wa deoWoer April 14, 2008 Name of Appikartt: Yeliowftne Women's Frst Step Harwe, Ina (OntflpMon of appli 14A M11 WIM Mew" O" Applicallon for a Cortd banal Use PWmk punRWlt to Ordnance No. 2008-05 requestltp approval of Use Permit No. 2008038 to allow 1571 Pegasus to oordimm operating as an 18 trod adult sober K*tg faatky. Reasons for Appeal The home operates such that the required to grant a CondNonel Use Panic can be made. Thenefon, the City of Newport Beach Improperly denied the request, wlth prow)oe. April 27.2009 blgrowie of AppeNaat Data FOR OFFICE USE ONLY d Q. -V Rewhmod by Fee moeivad - 6; fs C:IDoamwMt and SM 41%0bWW4A M AppWar Mm" 00ftm Dtak*Ldv= ftv%W 02#OD iib 9-d 962S9496*6 0u0%SM0tIaA P. 11 F1rK-ef -C" nun IRS:s( Mrl ONVIb KFITM t7h ape PICA lu M d!ti SM CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH AWPUCAT" TO APPM4EC SM OF THE HEARING OFFICER Projaet No, PA: 200&107 APPkWm No.: Ross. Aceom. 2008-06 Name of AppeNant Yellowstone Woman's First Stop House, kh Dr. Anne Mario Thames Phwa: M48) 076-OM MM Addm w 1571 Pegasus, Newport Basch, Cai4omia 9¢707 Cats of Heartrg omoses dedsioro April u, 2009 (on sWieatlon for CondlVanol Use Permit) None of APpNasn<: Yellowstone Women's First seep House, Inc. (Csseripllon of q* wtlon find vM Haring officer) Application for a Reasonable Aaommodd6on prxsuant to Ordinance No. 2MB-05 rowestirhg that 1571 Pogasus be permitted an exemption from the occupancy restrictions of Section 20.91A.0S0 of the Newpwt Bosch Murhtcipd Code which restricts occupancy to two residents per bedroom plus ads additional rool lark Reasons for Appeal The City of Newport Beach derwed the oppficord's Condit fond Use Permit Voloatlon. ttaretore, the City's decision regardiry the occupancy exemption wars rendered nhodht Although the City new specVk* ruled on this Paflcular reasonable aeeomhnodillm request. Yellowstons hereby appeals because the 1571 Pegasus hone operates such that the mq.*ed firhdnga to grant the mquasted reasonable acoomnadeft can be made. i/% April 27. 2009 OW46M of APPailsnt Cate G{Daq.Mne htl aU 7f.earo0ornrhl,00rlBMYpMT�„p�ry InrrnM Red \C0d tOLeoohtl2"D8wAAppMd Haft Ohrwh 06date4 ac Nodud WA44elb L -d 96299096b6 auo %smotteA • APR -27 -2009 NON 08:37 All OAUIS RAYBM a" L III IIJ. aqy 310 MID r. to CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH APPIMAMIMN TO APPEAL DECISION OF TM HEARNG 9MGM Project No. PA: 200&107 Appl'" I'm n No.: Rees. Accom. 2000-06 Nana of Appslisnt Yellowstone Woman's First Step House. Ina Or, Anna Marie Thames Pbeew. (946) 87680W Oft Address: 1571 Pegasus, Newport Beech, COIor nia 82707 Dab of Steering 011loWs declaim-, April 14,2W9 Nana of AppRctnt: YoNewatone V*mw's First Step House, Ino. Mewiptlon of appHU4on tied wNh He" Offlosrj Application for a Reasonable Aocwnrnodatbn pursuant to O►dinanos No. 200605 requestkq that 1571 Pegasus be treated as a B(rrgla Housekeeping Unit as defined in Section 20.03.030 of the Newport Beach MurWpel Code. Reasons for Appeal The home oparaI such that the rogthirsd findings to grant the reMmiad reasonable accontunodalion curb be made. Therefore. the City of Newport Beach imprepe* denied the req jI with prejudk:s. .. G10 owrarI a F%MOaddet0U10W2r70m"AWWd IMO 0nekaD8d00w.tr0atftvWd02A4Mtb e'd 96zS9b961,6 auOISM0110A 9 M APR -21-Am MN ue:31 An URVls RAYtlIBUI .po rAd MU. M dIG MM r. iv ['d 96299*96*6 auo ,4smoltoA 0 APR -71 -Mil MAI ua:sl fie URV14 KRYMM ape • rrtn nu, oqe aio auto 1. \J CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH Project No. PA: 200&108 Appllcafion No.: Use Perm No. 2006-037 Name of /Appellant Yetlowatorrt Women's First Step House. qra Dr. Anna Marle Thames Ph": ("9) 070 -9aoo Site Adsraw 20172 Redlands Drive, Newport Neon. California 1127W Dad oMeartr Offlara deoleton: April 14.2M9 Name of Applic arht: Yollowalone Womm% First step Howe, Um (D aerlption of appNoation filed with Nearft Cldcerl AppticaVon for a Conditional Use Permit pursumd to Ordba No. 2008-08 requss" approval of Use Pemrii No. 20084)37 to allow 20172 Redlands to continue opereffno at a 17 bed aduR sober Wing tecWly. Reasons for Appeal The home operates such that the required fndingis to gram a Condblonal Use Permit can be made. Thereiae, the City of Newport Beach improperly denied the request. with prejudios. April 27.200 SignsWre of Appaliant 00% 7k SOMEONE c:boaenMn.rosseinpasaeomyvaor awwgar�oarr ukamt a�ca�srcoreannroesprsRer a rwwnr arrow% oxWmdwa RwAKd *144 -QY V Z'd 96ZS9i96i6 euolsolol[eA 0 APR -27 -2008 IM 08:37 An IIAVIs Rftymm ape 0 MA M v4v ifb aafo r. to CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH APELVA_MN 19 AM& DWABI 1 QE TIE HgMh Q OFFICER PmejW No. PA: 2006 -108 AppUcdlon Ne.: Ram Aaoom. 2008-07 Nouns of App.Nant: YMowatae 1 bony$ Flrsf SfJBP House. Inc. Dr. Antis Mo rle Thanes Mons (949) 676-9000 SW Addros: 20172 Redlands Drive, Newport Beach, Calfonia 92707 Dale of Hearing Officer's decldon: April 14, 2008 (on application for Canditional Use Permit) Hama of Appgaant Yelowatorrs Women's First Siep House, Inc. (Daorlom of application iNd vim Hearing 0111cer) Application for s Reasonable Aoconv, otion pweuoud to Ordinanm No. 200606 roqueating that 20172 Redlands be pemlitlad an exemption iron the aoouperncy mstrictbrta of Section 20.91A.030 of the Newport Beech Munk" Code nwllroh restricts ocalpancy to two resWenb Per bedroom pka am oddWonal maiden!. Romans for AMvd The City of Newport Beach denied the am *=Ws Cord tlotW Use Permk application, thavolore, the City's dscieion regarding the ocapmncy exemption vrae rofxlerad moat Abou9h the Cily now specifically ruled on this particuimr raasonabM —xi, modefion rogues!, Yellowstone hereby appeals b*cK= the 20172 Redlands home aperalo such Chat the equirod Nndinge to Word the requested reasonable axananodalk n can be made. April 27, 2009 Signature of AppNlant Dale FOR OFFICE UK ONLY: Grkaanme end $*ftW* ffA4W - a-- NTwlpowy IdWM FW Cmdmr.QA M 77708WAAppaw of "=vi oMoah oaWiMdM RevbaO 0= gn e'd 982S9496i6 suo %smollaA W W PYK- Z(-ZUUB MM U9,41 M11 URVIb KHYt1M &PC rna sal. ma *to aoro r. rr CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH AMMAM14 M APPEAL MSM OF DR WkA INN OFFICER Project No. PA: 4008-109 Appvwfioa Not.: Rees. A000m. 200907 Nana of A"ofie t; Yellowstone Women's Foil Step House, Ina. Or. Arms Maria Thwnss Prone: (949) 978MM Ski Addrmv 20172 Rsdands Ddve Newport Beads, Caffornk 92707 Date of Hearing OMfars dseision: Apd 14.2009 Name of Appiktanf: Yellowstone Woman's Frst Step Mows, Ina (Description of application filed Vrilh Hearing Olfker) Application for a Reasonable Accommodation pursuant to Orftance No 20MO equal ng that 20172 Redlands be treated as a Single Housekeeping Unit as defied in Section 20.03.030 lithe Newport Beach Mwkipst Code. Rowans for Appeal The home operates such that the required firdfflp to grant the ropit I raasonaW accommodetlon can be roads. Therefore, the city of Newport Beach inhpmperly denied Me request with prejudice. April 27.2909 Sigralture of Appellant Dee FOR OFFICE USE ONLY: Rea d by Fee rsesh Date G �s � T «wd+c ro�soahz»naa><rao..'d rran�r 0ewn o.aaer.eoo *'d 962e9r96r6 su0lcroOrtrA V1' Ili Authori,ted to Publish Adveruscmrnts of all kinds including public notices by Dmrm of the Superior Court of Orange County. California \umhcr ,N 62 14 September 29, 1961, and A -24831 June 11, 1963. RECEIVED PROOF OF PUBLICAMW 17 AM I91 28 STATE OF CALIFORNIA) ppCR s0 ) . COUNTY OF ORANGE ) I am a Citizen of the United States and a resident of the County aforesaid: I am over the age of eighteen years, and not a party to or interested in the below entitled matter. I am a principal clerk of the NEWPORT BEACH - COSTA MESA DAILY PILOT, a newspaper of general circulation, printed and published in the City of Costa Mesa, County of Orange, State of California, and that attached Notice is a true and complete copy as was printed and published on the following dates: September 12, 2009 I declare, under penalty of perjury, that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on September 15, 2009 at Costa Mesa, California. SigneMre $l YELLOWSTONE WKNI'S FIRST STEP HOUSE, INC. 1%1 INDUS STREET. IE2I FM STREET, 1571 PEGASUS STREET, b 20172 REDLANDS UK NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City Council of the City of Newport Beach will conduct a public healing on Sytan kow 22, 2009, w er aha 7x00 paw. in the City Council Chambers (Building A) at 3300 Newport Boulevard. Newport Beach. California. The City Council will consider, an appeal of the Hearing Officer's decision to deny the Use Permit applications of Yellowstone Women's First Step House. Inc. submitled for lour separate sober living facilities. and to deny the applicant's requests for Reasonable Accommodation at the tout locations. The appeal for each application was submitted by the applicant A brief description of the applications submitted for each location is as follows. 1. 1561 Indus Street (UP2008 034 and RA2009 004) An application requesting approval of a use permit to allow the continued operation of an unlicensed adult alcohol and /or drug abuse sober living facility for 12 resident clients. females only. The application was filed in accordance with Ordinance No 200805 As a Reasonable Accommodation. the applicant is rsquestrrQ to be exempted from the Residential Use Classification 'Reudenhal care Facilities. General.' as defined by Section 20 05,03D /H) of the Newport Beach Municipal Coda (NBMC), and to be treated as a "Single Housekeeping Unit,' as defined by NBMC Section 20.03.030. In addition, the applicant is requeslmT approval of a Reasonable Accommodation for exemption from Chapter 3.36 of the NBMC and Section 3.36.030 which requires 100 percent cost recovery for periods related to user services. Exemption is also requested from Section 20.91A.050 (C.2) of the NBMC to show more than two residents per bedroom with One additional resident. 2 1621 Indus Street (UP 2008 -035 and RA2009 005) An application requesting approval of a use permit to allow the continued operation of an unlicensed adult alcohol and /or drug abuse sober living facility for 17 resident clients, females only. The application was filed in accordance with Ordinance No, 200805. As a Reasonable Accommodation, the applicant is requesting to be exempted from the ResidenWl Use Classification 'Res.dent.al Care Facilities. General.' as defined by Section 20 05 030 (H) of the Newport Beach Municipal Code (NBMC), and to be treated as a 'Singh Housekeeping Unit.' as defined by NBMC Section 20.03.030. In addition . the applicant is requesting approval of a Reasonable Accommodate bon for exemption hom Chapter 336 of the NBMC and Section 3.36030 which requires 100 percent cost recovery for permits related to user services Exemption is also requested from Section 20.91A050 (C 2) of the NBMC to allow more than two residents Par bedroom with one additional rev0ent. 3. 1571 Pegasus Street (UP 2008036 and RA2D09 006). An application requesting approval of a use permit to allow the continued operation of an unlicensed adult alcohol and /or drug abuse sober living facility for 18 resident clients. females Only The application was bled in accordance with Ordinance No 200805. As a Reasonable Accommodation. the applicant Is requesting to be exempted from the Residential Use Classt"tuln 'Resieential Care Facilities. General.- as defined by Section 2005.030 (H). of the Newport Beach Municipal Code (NBMC), and to be treated as a 'Singh Housekeeping Unit.' as defined by NBMC Section 20.03.030. In addition, the applicant is requesting approval of a Reasonable Accommodate tion for exemption from Chapter 3.36 of the NBMC and Section 3.36.030 which requires 100 percent cost recovery for permits related to user services. Exemption is also requested from Section 20.91A.050 (C2) of the NBMC to allow more than two residents per bedroom with one additional resident a. 20172 Redlands Drove (UP 2008037 and RA2009 007). An application requesting approval of a use permit to allow the continued operation of an unlicensed adult alcohol and /or drug abuse sober living facility for 18 resident clients, males only The application was filed in accordance with Ordmante No 200805. As a Reasonable Accommodation, the applicant is requesting to be exempted from the Residential Use Classification 'Residential Care Facilities. General,' as defined by Section 20.05.030 (H) of the Newport Beall Municipal Code (NBMC), and to be treated as a 'Single Housekeeping Unit.' as defined by NBMC Section 20.03030 In addition. the applicant is requesting approval of a Reasonable Accommoda. lion for exemption from Chapter 7.36 of the NBMC and Section 336.030 which requires 100 percent cost recovery for permits related to user mry ,ces Exemption is also requested hom Section 20.91A.050 (C 2) of the NBMC to allow more than two residents per bedroom witn one additional resident. This activity has been determined to be categorically exempt under thel requirements of the California Envn Onmmial Quality Act (CEOA) under Class 1 (Existing Facilities). This dais of projects has been determined not to have a significant effect nn the environment and is exempt from the provisions of CEQA. This activity is also covered by the general rule that CEQA applies only to projects that have the potential for causing a ugmficant l effect on the environment (Section 15061(0)(3) of Ina CEQA Guidelines). It can be Men with certainty that there is no possibility that this activity will have a significant effect on the environment and it is not subject to All interested parties may appear and present testimony in regard to them applications. If you challenge them projects in court, you may be limited to raising only them issues you or someone else raised at the public hearing (ascribed in this notice) or in written correspondence delivered to the City, at, or prior to. the public hearing. The staff report may be reviewed At the City Clerk s Office. City of Newport Beach. 3300 Newport Bouleva Newport Beach. California. 92663 or at the City of Newport Reach website at winrW.ea=:IA adAcs.pv beginning on the Wednesday prior to the hearing. for more mfOrmaUOn. call (949) 6443232 or (949) 6443002 To be added to a permaneeontt notification list of these hearings. email halal File .x PA2006 105. and PA2008 106 receive PA2008- -107 and cPA2GOB -108 Aeffs,1ry ere.: UP2008 034;RA2009 004, UP2008035,'RA2OO9.DOS. UP2008 037 /RA2pp9 006 and UP2008 038 /RA2O09 007 Dave Koff. City Manager. City of Newport Beach Eeilant Brown, City Clerk VIA HAND DELIVERY • No poom RECEIVED 16: 70 M 27 M 3 00(61- a1 w* - Ctl� k�(� of�►rk DAVIS•ZFATY pFF!CE OF C(i`l OF h�N°ORT B�� N April 27, 2009 Newport Beach City Council City Clerk's Office 3300 Newport Boulevard Newport Beach, California 92663 Re: Yellowstone Women's First Step House, Inc. Applications to Appeal Decision of Hearing Officer Use Permit Applications; 2008 -034; 2008 -035; 2008 -036; and 2008 -037 Reasonable Accommodation Requests: 2009 -04; 2009 -05; 2009 -06; 2009 -07 To Whom It May Concern: This firm is general counsel for Yellowstone Women's First Step House, Inc. Enclosed are the Applications to Appeal Decision of the Hearing Officer regarding Yellowstone's Use Permit Applications and requests for Reasonable Accommodation for the following properties: 1561 Indus, 1621 Indus, 1571 Pegasus, and 20172 Redlands. We understand that there will be a hearing on the enclosed appeals within sixty days. Please inform this firm of the scheduled hearing date and time when decided. Thank you for your courtesy and if you have any questions regarding this correspondence, please feel free to contact us. Very truly yours, DAVIS ZFATY a professional corporation NICOLE COHRS Enclosures :)80 Broadway Street, Suite 301 -1 aguna Beach, CA 92651 - 949.376.. >828 Fax 949.176.'i87ri infoodzauornevl.com wwv..dzattorne<s.com