Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout01 - Minutes - 4-12-11Agenda Report 111 April 26, 2011 J ��G `� � `iii ) 1 ) i City Council Minutes City Council Study Session April 12, 2011— 4:00 p.m I. ROLL CALL Present: Council Member Hill, Council Member Rosansky, Mayo Pro Tern Gardner, Mayor, Henn, Council Member Selich, Council Member Curry, Council Member Daigle II. CURRENT BUSINESS 1. CLARIFICATION OF ITEMS ON THE:CONSE_NT CALENDAR -_ In response to Mayor Henn's question. regafding Item No. 4 (Central Balboa Pavement Rehabilitation - Phase 1 - Awa4 of Contract No. 4453), Public Works Director Badum clarified that the street will be.replaced with concrete. 2. LOUD AND UNRULY GAT14E.RING ORDINANCE. Police Lieutenant Hartford utilized a'PowerPont presentation that included the elements of the ordinance, definition of a lo/dd'an`&unruly gathering, photo of the red tag posting, list'of`;individuals that.,afe subject` -tio fines, Police Department enforcement ,steps, citation and as`s'ociated red tag fine amounts, and the appeals process. f In response to tiCov'neil,_questions, Police Lieutenant Hartford explained that fines•can —be waiv`d;- rioted71hat -red tags can be removed upon the eviction of the'residentc sta there` -are no appeal fees, discussed Disturbance r'Advisement Cards and how they will be used, clarified that most of the parties that fall,.under this category are during the 4th of July holiday, discussed a similar ordinancd,m Arizona and its effectiveness, and added that it is at the Police Officers' discretion to fine th"renter, owner, and/or attendees. Deputy City Attorney Rtiwen explained that, as long as the owner has the ordinance information in their lease provisions and uses reasonable measures to abate the responsible party, they will not`be held responsible. He also stated that the ordinance can be applied to certain a eas of.fhe City, as long as the City states why it is not subject to the entire City. Mayor Pro Tem Gardner expressed support for the ordinance and explained that is not to stop residents from having parties, it is to stop egregious behaviors. Council Member Rosansky believed that the ordinance should apply to all residents so that it will not attach astigmatism to certain areas, clarified that the violations are not site specific, verified that red tags may be located in two separate places, expressed concern that citations are not being issued, urged staff to re- evaluate the decision to fine property owner's for the first violation, and also directed staff to evaluate the possibility of revoking short -term rental permits upon violation Volume 60 - Page 102 City of Newport Beach City Council Study Session April 12, 2011 of the ordinance. In response to Council questions, Police Lieutenant Hartford explained that party attendees can also be fined if they are engaging in loud and unruly behavior, noted that it is at the discretion of the Police Officer to determine if a citation will be issued, and discussed staffs plan to provide community awareness about the ordinance. Lori Morris applauded the efforts of the Police Department, believed that the ordinance should be enforced throughout the City, and stated that in the past, residents were subject to violence because of lack of enforcement. George Schroeder expressed concern that property; owner's could be fined and believed that the ordinance will deter people from committing egregious acts. Joe Riess thanked the Police Department and'Council for their efforts to improve the quality of life and believed that the ordinance will be a deterrent, that will also make property owner's accountable for their tenants. 11 Sandy Pearson thanked Council for addressing the issues, discussed problems she has had with a rental unit close to her home-;'and urged Council to raise the fines. Jim Mosher expressed opposition- to the ordinance, believed that people will be stigmatized when their homes','- omes =are' A ,6igged, and expressed concern that the fines are too high. A Craig Batley stated that parties, should -be shiit•-down after the issuance of the first violation.noltice and urged Council to direct staff to refine the Ordinance to provide Police'Office> s with a guideline of when to enforce. Council Member Selich indicated that, the ordinance should only apply to areas of the City thatt,are facing the issue. Council Member Daigle agreed that it is not a Citywide issue ai'dds£ated that it- should• be addressed accordingly. Mayor Pro Tem G"ardn6i',believed •that the ordinance should apply to the entire City. Council Member Ro ansky stated that the ordinance should apply equally to the entire City or not at all, andemphasized the importance of enforcing the ordinance. Council Member Curry believed that more time is needed to evaluate the ordinance, stated that the fines should include a cap, and suggested that Council receive input from; property owners. Mayor Henn encouraged the Police Department to enforce the fines, stated that there should, li; a transitional period for property owners, and noted that the ordinance is`a kargeted tool that will address the issue. City Manager Miff clarified Council changes and received confirmation to include a violation that will revoke short term rental permits and verged that the fine level will remain at the proposed amounts. It was the consensus of Council that the ordinance be brought back for further review and introduction as soon as possible. Volume 60 - Page 103 City of Newport Beach City Council Study Session April 12, 2011 DIRECTION ON ISSUES - SMOKING PARKING PROGRAM, PLASTIC BAGS TAXI. SMOKING IN PARKS IN PARKS, CORONA DEL MAR , BUSINESS LICENSES, WATER Mayor Pro Tem Gardner stated that the Environmental Quality Affairs Committee (EQAC) believed that a ban on smoking in parks and open spaces should be implemented. Council Members Curry and Rosansky expressed support, and Council Members Selich and Hill expressed opposition to a smoking ban in parks and open- spaces. Mayor Henn expressed support for a ban due to fire hazards and suggested that the item be brought back to Council. Jim Mosher believed that there should be a smokingbanIn'the areas depicted in the report due to extreme fire danger. Nancy Skinner expressed support for a ban,, It was the consensus of Council to directstaff to?move forward with tbi'satem. CORONA DEL MAR PARKING PRO RAM Mayor Pro Tem Gardner reported that a parking study was previously prepared, explained how parking issues`imjgct- residents, and`asked for Councirs input. Council Member Hill expressed support \for�the_parking)program and believed that i the issue should be reviewed by the Neighborhood-Revitalization Committee. Karen Tringali: emphasized the importance of issuing parking citations in the area. Dan Purcell_„ stated that the parking program will only benefit commercial businesses andlbelieVed that the metere.will be a hassle. n.3 Coimcil`Member Rosanksy stated, that the problem will not be resolved because employees will 'park further into the residential areas and stated that parking lots and structures are needed:. It was the consensus of Council to refer the item to the Neighborhood Revitalization `Committee. It was the'consuisus of Council to not address the issue. Nancy Skinner believed that the item should be considered by Council because it is important to the ocean and wildlife. Michael Parker suggested that Council increase fines for littering. BUSINESS LICENSES City Manager Kiff reported that the Economic Development Committee (EDC) was working on business license regulations and noted that a handout was included to Volume 60 - Page 104 City of Newport Beach' City Council Study Session April 12, 2011 explain the work in progress. In response to Council Member Hill's question, City Manager Kiff clarified that the consultant can review business license regulations in the. City. Council Member Selich and Mayor Henn added that removing tax entities, special events, and permitting for attendees was also discussed by the EDC. It was consensus of Council that the item be moved forward. WATER TAXI City Manager Kiff noted that the program is a part of the Tidelands Management Committee, indicated that staff is not sure if Council -will provide a subsidy, and asked Council to clarify if the item should be further,revie wed. Council Member Selich stated that Council %left the door open for people who wanted to provide a proposal. Mayor Henn,sugge' , that proposal s he reviewed by the Tidelands Management Committee aril the H1i'bor Commission., Jim Mahoney, Gondola Company of NE service is an on -call service and indicate service is expensive and will need to be su Chandler Bell, Marine Commmitte- _ C1 be considered by the Tideland's\ Ma-ha Committees and emphasized the need for 4. ANIMAL SHELTER,,SERVICES DISC Assistant to,'the Assistant City Manage; and Request; For Proposals (RFPs). PowerPoint presentation_ that included' Beach, stated that his `water taxi a regularly scheduled water taxi believed that water taxis should it and`- -_ Neighborhood Revitalization Houston discussed the program, process, Police Lieutenant Koudelka utilized .a iotos, mandates, shelter services, current as, and how the Orange County Humane Scc ety fitsjhe needs,of the City In response to Council 'questions, Assistant to the Assistant City Manager Houston explained the difference in =the current rate versus the bid price of the Dover Shores `'Pet Care Center, discussed how the euthanasia rate will change, and noted that the item can be brought back to Council on April 26, 2011. Debbie Gonzalez „Orange County Humane Society Manager, explained the adoption rates, discussed.' how animals are evaluated, noted that animals are not euthanizeddueyto lack of space, talked about the volunteer programs, stated that they have 13;•employees, provided the hours of operation, noted that most of the euthanasia occur to feral cats, added that all of the operating expenses are contract fees, and discussed certifications. Council Member Rosansky encouraged Council to visit the Orange County Humane Society prior to the contract coming before Council for consideration. Caroline Samus stated that the current shelter is below standard, believed that the Orange County Humane Society is a step up from the current shelter, encouraged the City to work towards opening a shelter in the City, and believed that there are community organizations that will work to raise money for a shelter. Volume 60 - Page 105 City of Newport Beach City Council Study Session April 12, 2011 City Manager Kiff commended staff for working hard on the issue. Ill. PUBLIC COMMENTS Jim Mosher thanked the City for upgrading the Study Session agenda. IV. ADJOURNMENT - 6:08 p.m. The agenda for the Regular Meeting was posted on April 7, 2011; at 3:40 p.m. on the City Hall Bulletin Board located outside of the City, ' of Newport Beach Administration Building. ti It "6ciordin Secretary J City Clerk ol Volume 60 - Page 106 Eke XL City Council Minutes City Council Regular Meeting April 12, 2011 — 7:00 p.m. I. STUDY SESSION - 4:00 p.m. II. CLOSED SESSION - 6:07 p.m. A. Conference with Legal Counsel - Existing W gation`7Government Code 6 54956.9(a)): Three matters: 1. Porto v CNB, USDC Case No. SACV11 -00180 JVS f, 2. Interinsurance Exchange iof.AAA -b CNB, OCSC Case Np: 30 -2011- 00458025 3. Padgett v CNB, OCSC Case No. 30- 2009,- 002991291 B. Conference with Legal Cou'nse'l-.- Anticipated. Litigation - Initiation of Potential initiation of htigationCagainst Puna McLlwain aka Punahele Aikala McLlwain and Steve'McLlwain of 443 Harlior Drive" . C. Public Employee Performance Evaluation (Government Code 6 54957(b)(1)): The City .Council will meet in closed session to consider the appointment, employment,' evaluation of performance, discipline, or dismissal of two public employees. ti; • „' — _ 'titles: City Manager and City Clerk`” III. RECESS <, IV. RECONVENE AT 7:00 P!M. FOR REGULAR MEETING V. ROLL CALL Present: Council Membe 'Hill , Council Member Rosansky, Mayor Pro Tem Gardner, Mayor Henn, Coun ];Member Selich, Council Member Curry, Council Member Daigle r" VI. CLOSED SESSION REPORT City Attorney Hunt reported that there was no reportable action, except for the matters relating to Porto u CNB and Interinsurance Exchange of AAA u CNB, in which Council voted 7 -0 to authorize the defense of both matters. VII. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE - Council Member Daigle Volume 60 - Page 107 City of Newport Beach City Council Minutes April 12, 2011 VIII. INVOCATION - Mayor Henn IX. PRESENTATIONS Newport Beach Fire Department Centennial Celebration 1911 -2011 - Fire Chief Morgan and Fire Captain Brian McDonough discussed the history of the Newport Beach Fire Department and presented the City Council and Civil Service Board with centennial badges. Proclamation Designating April as DMVIDonate Life California Month - Eric Piper, donor transplant recipient, discussed the importance of the DMV donor program. Mayor Henn read the proclamation and presented it to Mr. Piper and Lisa Pedral of One Legacy. .�i Proclamation Designating April 10 -16, 2011 as National Library Week - Mayor Henn read the proclamation and presented it to Library Services D,irectorCowell. X. NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC Xl. CITY COUNCIL__ANNOUN REPORT (NON- DISCUSSION ITEM) Council Member Hill announced that he attended-,'the Police Appreciation Breakfast on March 30, the Fire Department Centennial Kickofff baApril 9, and read to children at Mariners Library this morning. 'He'. also announced that the Chamber of Commerce Scholarship Awards Breakfast will be+held__on,April 26 (wivw`newportbeach.com for more information). Council Member Rosansky, stated that he�Mayor Henn, ahl °Council Member Hill attended Coastline Community College's groundbreaking .this morning'for their new campus on 15th Street and Monrovia Avenue in West Newport.% Mayor Pro Tem Gardner announced that the Corona del Mar Residents Association (CdMRA) and the Business mproy_ement District (BID) will hold its annual meeting on April 20 at Sherman,Gaidens (ww'w:c&nmra.org for more information). dember Daigle \announced that she attended the opening day ceremony for the Beach Little League and stated that the Newport -Mesa Interfaith Council will be Mother's Day e'vent at the ^First Presbyterian Church in Orange on May 1 at 4:00 P.M. Council Member Curry announced that he attended the opening reception for the Alexander Calder Exbibit`at.the Orange County Museum of Art. Council Member Selieli- announced that he will be reading to children for National Library Week on Wednesday at 10:30 a.m, at the Central Library. Mayor Henn announced that he attended the Art Exhibition at the Central Library on April 9. He also announced that he attended the Newport- Ensenada Launch Party on April 10 and encouraged everyone to attend at least one of the upcoming events. XII. CONSENT CALENDAR A. READING OF MINUTES /ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS Volume 60 - Page 108 City of Newport Beach City Council Minutes April 12, 2011 1. MINUTES FOR THE STUDY SESSION AND REGULAR MEETINGS OF MARCH 22, 2011. [100 -2011] Waive reading of subject minutes, approve as written, and order filed. 2. READING OF ORDINANCES AND RESOLUTIONS. Waive reading in full of all ordinances and resolutions under consideration, and direct City Clerk to read by title only. C. CONTRACTS AND AGREEMENTS 4. CENTRAL BALBOA PAVEMENT REHABILITATION - PHASE 1 - AWARD OF CONTRACT NO. 4453. [381100 -2031] a) Approve the project drawings and specifications; b) award Contract No. 4453 to Nobest Inc. ( Nobest) for the total bid price of $448,000, art uthorize the Mayor and the City Clerk to execute the contract; c) establish an amount of $112,000 (25 %) to cover the cost of unforeseen work "and anticipated additional concrete street pavement not included in the,6riginal contract; and`d) approve Budget Amendment No. IIBA -041 tran�sferrmg�$55,520 from 7531 - 02002038 (San Miguel Street Improvements) to 7531 /22002041 (Central Balboa Pavement Rehabilitation) and $2,300 fidm 7511- C2002038 (San Miguel Street Improvements to 7511- C2002041 (Central Balboa Pavement Rehabilitation). 6. APPROVAL OF EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT FOR CITY MANAGER (C -4359)- [381100­264),_,a) Approve the .Employment Agreement with David Kiff effective yApiil -.12,.` 2011 (pity Manager Employment Agreement"); and adopt Resoluti n ,No.,2011 -29 approving and authorizing the Mayor to execute the City Manager Employment Agreement. 7. APPRUYAh'OF EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT FOR CITY CLERK (C- 4100). [381100 -2011] a) Approve the Employment Agreement with Leilam BroR,n effective April 12, 2015 ( "City Clerk Employment Agreement "); and adopi-iResolution No. 2011 -30 approving and authorizing the Mayor to execute'`the City -Clerk Employment Agreement. D. ,MISQELLANEOUS,'- 8. PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA FOR APRIL 7, 2011. [100 -2011] Receive grid file written report. 9r"'. BUDGEt; AMENDMENT TO APPROPRIATE EXPENDITURES AND REVENUES FOR OASIS SENIOR CENTER CONTRACT CLASSES. 1100- 20I1IJ Approve Budget Amendment No. 11BA -038 to increase Revenue Account.4410.5474 by $133,155 and Expenditure Account 4410 -8080 by 10. REPLACEMENT OF MOBILE DATA COMPUTERS (MDC) IN POLICE PATROL VEHICLE FLEET. [100 -20111 a) Approve a total expenditure of $193,850.35 to replace the MDCs currently assigned to the Police Department's patrol vehicle fleet; b) approve the sole - source purchase of the replacement MDCs from Datalux Corporation; and c) approve Budget Amendment No. 11BA -040 appropriating $193,850.35 from the Police Department's Internal Service Fund unappropriated fund balance to the Police Vehicle Equipment Account, 6150 -9300. This expenditure includes the Volume 60 - Page 109 City of Newport Beach City Council Minutes April 12, 2011 equipment ($177,444), all sales taxes ($15,326.35), and shipping and delivery costs ($1,080). 11. AUTHORIZATION TO UPGRADE OFFICE ASSISTANT POSITION TO DEPARTMENT ASSISTANT POSITION WITHIN THE OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY. [100 -2011] Continue the item until budget discussions come before the City Council. Rosansky to approve the Consent Calendar, except for the Items removed (3 and 5) and rioting the continuance of Item 11. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: Ayes: Council Member Hill, Council Member Rosansky, Mayor Pro Tem Gardner, Mayor Henn, Council Member Selich, Council Member Curry, Council Member Daigle � , N XIII. ITEMS REMOVED FROM THE CONSENTXALENDAR 1 3. RESOLUTION SUPPORTING AN ORANGE COUNTY TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY (OCTA) MEASURE M2 ENVIRONMENTAL CLEANUP, TIER 1, GRANT PROGRAM. [100 -2011] Jim Mosher expressed concerri;;thatr the grant application has not been written and is not attached to the staff repcirt. CityZManager Kiff -in dicated that the grant is fairly basic and one that Council has traditionally supported. Mayor Pro Tem Gardner added that the resolutionlistipulates whai- tlie_grant will be used for. to adopt RI6olution No. 2011 -28 authorizing and supporting the submission of grant applications -for the "OCTA Measure �M2, Environmental Cleanup, Tier 1, grant program. The motion ea `iea,'n the following roll call vote: 4r Ayes: Council Member``H'ill, Council Member Rosansky, Mayor Pro Tem Gardner, Mayor Henn. Council Member Selich, Council Member Curry, Council Member Daigle 5. FOURTH AMENDMENT TO PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH NIANCHOR, QEA, L.P. FOR AGENCY COORDINATION AND CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT SERVICES FOR THE RHINE CHANNEL DREDGING,P,ROJECT (C- 4304). [381100 -2011] Mayor Henn" requested that it be made clear that, in the event the General Fund does expend money for the project, it would be in the form of a loan to the Tidelands Fund so the City can track the expenditure as a tidelands expenditure. He noted that this would be similar to the tracking system that occurs for other dredging expenditures. Motion by Mayor Henn, seconded by Council Member Daigle to a) approve the Fourth Amendment to the Professional Services Agreement with Anchor, QEA, L.P. for agency coordination and construction management services for the Rhine Volume 60 - Page 110 City of Newport Beach City Council Minutes April 12, 2011 F4 a M Channel Project; and b) if the State Lands Commission does not object to this proposed expenditure, approve Budget Amendment No. 11BA -39a appropriating $624,964 from un- appropriated Tidelands Fund to 7231- C4402004 OR if the State Lands Commission does object to this proposed expenditure, approve Budget Amendment No. 11BA -39b appropriating $624,964 from un- appropriated General Fund (010 -3605) to 7014- C4402004. In the event of an objection, City staff will work with the State Lands Commission to address their concerns and seek approval of the proposed expenditure and authorization to reimburse the General Fund from the Tidelands Fund, The motion carried by the following roll call vote: 1' ,r Ayes: Council Member Hill, Council Member Rosansky;?,Mayor Pro Tem Gardner, Mayor Henn, Council Member Selich, Council Member- Curry, Council Member Daigle !a ' PUBLIC COMMENTS Wendy Brooks suggested developing a contest<'that runeconcurrent with the' grand opening of the new City Hall in order to generate a Citiy public image slogan. Jim Mosher discussed the Statement of Economic Intl some consultants are exempt from filing Form 700s. most consultants would not be required,to,file a Form impacts to the City or make decisions. In response to Curtis Westland's question, Mayor :Henn regarding the proposed loud and unruly 'gathering g ordiri Session today, but it will' = becoming back to'the-City Council (Form 700) and questioned why Attorney Hunt emphasized that )ecause they do not have specific indicated that the discussions a ice was discussed at the Study for consideration. Mayor Pro Tem- .Gardnen;reported -that -the Bicycle Safety Committee is requesting ideas on whetherAliere -are any streets that could'be closed to vehicular traffic, but not to bicycle or pedestrian traffic. She'indicated that the committee meets the first Monday of the month or individuals can email ideas to her: Counoil.Member Daigle discussed the collaborative effort that takes place between the City, the Federral Aviation Administration (FAA), and John Wayne Airport (JWA). She noted that the airport,is,aware of the problems above Crystal Cove, they investigated claims relative to Jasmine Cree`k.'and other; .areas, and assured everyone that the City will continue to monitor every issue. Council Member Curry discussed the Finance Committee meeting in which they will be recommending that the City change its auditor, reviewed revenue trends, and reviewed the Facilities Finance Plan (FFP). Mayor Henn highlighted the first meeting of the Tidelands Management Committee and reported that the committee will meet regularly on the third Wednesday of the month at 4:00 p.m. at OASIS Senior Center, and that applications are due for the citizen advisory panel of the Tidelands Management Committee on April 18 at 5:00 p.m. He stated that the panel will probably consist of seven members and the first steps will be to determine the visions for the tidelands, define priorities and the work plan, and receive a presentation from Volume 60 - Page 111 City of Newport Beach City Council Minutes April 12, 2011 XVI. the Harbor Commission about the visioning work they have been doing. Regarding the Neighborhood Revitalization Committee, he reported that the citizen advisory panel will be formed for each neighborhood study area and that applications for this citizen advisory panel are due on May 9. He reported that applications are available on the City's website. 12. RESOLUTION NO. .2011 -31: CHANGING THE MEMBERSHIP AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE AVIATION COMMITTEE. [100 -20111 City Manager Kiff stated that the handout relative to the G did not indicate in some areas that appointments will be'n confirmed by the City Council. He requested that the,attacl those amendments: !� e` Jim Mosher questioned the committee member ` terms and Members should serve on the committee: He stated ttee's membership by the Mayor and It be approved with last Aviation Committee meeting and .,only Council Member 'NI attendance from the Council membership. He; questioned Council aviation issues and requested that minutes betaken at the meetings. three Council attended the rigle was in ommitment to Council Member Daigle took issue with Mr. Mosher's statements, stating that Council Member Selich attends most of the meetings and former Council Member Webb attended every meeting,when he was on Council. She added that the City also has a strong advocate in Council Member, Hill. She'e&phasized that Council is fully engaged and supportive of airport, efforts'' - _. Council Member Hill added that_he attended Aviation Committee meetings even before he wasro ' Council and that ;tbi last meeting. was the only meeting he ever missed - Motion _ by,Co -uncil' Member Daia'le; seconded by Council Member Curry to adopt Resolution,No. ?'201 -1.31 relating to, the membership and responsibilities of the t ViaLlukl-UUMLUILLUU: ,The motion carried by the following roll call vote: '. Ayes: Council Member HkCouncil Member Rosansky, Mayor Pro Tem Gardner, Mayor Herm, Council Member Sehch, Council Member Curry, Council Member Daigle �? 13. RESOLUTION NO. 2011 -32: AMENDING THE SPECIAL EVENTS ADVISORY COMMITTEE'S" TRUCTURE AND DUTIES. [100 -20111 City Manager Kiff reported that the proposed resolution reflects the new process for reviewing spe ial events. Motion by Council Member Curry, seconded by Council Member Rosanskv to adopt Resolution No. 2011 -32 amending the structure and duties of the Special Events Advisory Committee. Council Member Hill requested that the attachment to the resolution be amended to reflect "Chairperson" throughout. Volume 60 - Page 112 City of Newport Beach City Council Minutes April 12, 2011 Jim Mosher believed that the membership should be composed of citizens who are not affiliated with any special events. The motion carried by the following roll call vote: Ayes: Council Member Hill, Council Member Rosansky, Mayor Pro Tern Gardner, Mayor Henn, Council Member Selich, Council Member Curry, Council Member Daigle XVII. MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION - None XVIII. ADJOURNMENT - Adjourned at 8:08 p.m in memory of Kenneth "Ken" Carr The agenda for the Regular Meeting was posted on April-7y-2011, at 3:40 p.m. on the City Hall Bulletin Board located outside of :the City -of Newport Beach Administration Building. i 1 \ 4 I Recording S6 ,retary - _ \ ,ice'' • ;.. .T Mayor City' "Clerk Volume 60 - Page 113