HomeMy WebLinkAbout10 - Attachment CC1 - Draft ResolutionDRAFT RESOLUTION
With attachments
Exhibit A-
6480 W. Coast Highway
GP2010 -013 and LC2010 -003
Exhibit B-
6904 W. Coast Highway
GP2011 -002 and LC2011 -001
Exhibit C-
6908 -6936 W Coast Highway
GP2010 -002 and LC2010 -002
ATTACHMENT No. CC 1
11
12
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF
NEWPORT BEACH APPROVING AMENDMENTS TO THE
LAND USE ELEMENT OF THE GENERAL PLAN AND
COASTAL LAND USE PLAN TO CHANGE THE LAND USE
DESIGNATION FROM TWO -UNIT RESIDENTIAL TO MIXED -
USE VERTICAL (MU -V) FOR PROPERTIES LOCATED AT
6904, and 6908 -6936 WEST COAST HIGHWAY (PA2010 -182,
AND PA2011 -014); AND FROM TWO -UNIT RESIDENTIAL TO
GENERAL COMMERCIAL (CG 0.5) FOR THE PROPERTY
LOCATED AT 6480 WEST COAST HIGHWAY (PA2010 -190),
ALL LOCATED WITHIN LAND USE STATISTICAL AREA B1
THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH HEREBY FINDS AS FOLLOWS:
SECTION 1. STATEMENT OF FACTS.
1. On July 25, 2006, the Newport Beach City Council adopted Resolution No. 2006 -76
approving a comprehensive update to the Newport Beach General Plan ( "General
Plan Update ").
2. On November 13, 2007, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 2007 -71 approving
Coastal Land Use Plan Amendment No. LC2007 -001 making the Coastal Land Use Plan
consistent with the General Plan Update.
3. On February 5, 2009, the Coastal Commission certified Coastal Land Use Plan
Amendment No. LC2007 -001 with suggested modifications as consistent with Chapter 3
of the Coastal Act (NPB_MAJ_1 -07).
4. On July 14, 2009, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 2010 -053 accepting all
Coastal Commission suggested modifications and re- adopting Coastal Land Use Plan
Amendment No. LC2007 -001 to incorporate all of the suggested modifications within
the Coastal Land Use Plan.
5. On July 14, 2009, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 2010 -054 initiating a
General Plan Amendment to make the Land Use Element of the General Plan
consistent with Coastal Land Use Plan Amendment No. LC2007 -001.
6. Pursuant to Section 65352.3 of the California Government Code, the appropriate tribe
contacts identified by the Native American Heritage Commission were provided notice
of the proposed General Plan Amendment on January 21, 2011. The California
Government Code requires 90 days to allow tribe contacts to respond to the request to
consult unless the tribe contacts mutually agree to a shorter time period. The response
period ended on April 21, 2011, and only a single response was received, but no
requests for consultation were received.
13
City Council Resolution No.
Page 2 of 4
7. A public hearing was held on April 7, 2011, in the City Hall Council Chambers, 3300
Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California. A notice of time, place and purpose of
the meeting was given in accordance with the Newport Beach Municipal Code.
Evidence, both written and oral, was presented to, and considered by, the Planning
Commission at this meeting. At the conclusion of the public hearing, the Planning
Commission voted unanimously (7 ayes, 0 noes) to adopt Planning Commission
Resolution No. 1839 recommending City Council adoption of the recommended
General Plan Amendments, Coastal Land Use Plan Amendments, and amendments to
the Zoning Code.
8. A public hearing was held on May 10, 2011, in the City Hall Council Chambers, 3300
Newport Boulevard, Newport Beach, California. A notice of time, place and purpose of
the meeting was given in accordance with the Newport Beach Municipal Code.
Evidence, both written and oral, was presented to, and considered by, the City Council
at this meeting.
SECTION 2. CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY ACT DETERMINATION.
1. This project exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act ( "CEQA ") pursuant
to Section 15302 — Class 2 (Replacement or Reconstruction) of the CEQA Guidelines,
California Code of Regulations, Title 14, Chapter 3, because it has no potential to have
a significant effect on the environment. Therefore, this activity is not subject to CEQA.
2. The City's action to amend the General Plan, the Coastal Land Use Plan and the
Zoning Code as requested by the property owners is exempt from the California
Environmental Quality Act pursuant to California Code of Regulations §15265.
3. The Planning Commission finds that judicial challenges to the City's CEQA
determinations and approvals of land use projects are costly and time consuming. In
addition, project opponents often seek an award of attorneys' fees in such challenges.
As project applicants are the primary beneficiaries of such approvals, it is appropriate
that such applicants should bear the expense of defending against any such judicial
challenge, and bear the responsibility for any costs, attorneys' fees, and damages
which may be awarded to a successful challenger.
Therefore, to the fullest extent permitted by law, applicant and property owner shall
defend, indemnify, release and hold harmless the City, its City Council, its boards and
commissions, officials, officers, employees, and agents from and against any and all
claims, demands, obligations, damages, actions, causes of action, suits, losses,
judgments, fines, penalties, liabilities, costs and expenses (including without limitation,
attorney's fees, disbursements and court costs) of every kind and nature whatsoever
which may arise from or in any manner relate (directly or indirectly) to the project, the
project's approval based on the City's CEQA determination and /or the City's failure to
comply with the requirements of any federal, state, or local laws, including, but not
limited to, CEQA, General Plan and zoning requirements. This indemnification shall
include, but not be limited to, damages awarded against the City, if any, costs of suit,
attorneys' fees, and other expenses incurred in connection with such claim, action, or
WJ'
City Council Resolution No.
Page 3 of 4
proceeding whether incurred by applicant, City, and/or the parties initiating or bringing
such proceeding.
SECTION 3. FINDINGS.
The proposed amendments of the Land Use Element of the General Plan, the Coastal
Land Use Plan and the Zoning Code are necessary to implement the request of the
property owner's of the three properties involved in the application to change the
designations.
2. The General Plan Amendments No. GP2010 -012, 013 and GP2011 -002, when added
to previous General Plan Amendments within the last 10 years, result in the following
increases in residential units, peak hour A.M. and P.M. trips, and /or non - residential
floor area within Land Use Statistical Area B1:
Table 1: Charter Section 423 Analysis Summary, Statistical Area BI
Allowed Floor
A.M. Peak Hour
P.M. Peak Hour
Increase in
Area
Trips
Trips
Allowed
Dwelling Units
Proposed
4,708 sq. ft.
13.46
17.99
-2
GP2010 -002
Proposed
2,068 sq. R
5.32
7.19
-2
GP2010 -013
Proposed
6,711 sq. ft.
21.80
28.86
3
GP2011 -002
SUBTOTAL
13,487.5 sq. ft.
40.58
54.04
-1
(CG, and MUN
with residential
units)
Prior Amendment
2,550 sq. ft.(80 %)
5.89(80%)
8.04 (80 %)
0
GP2010 -001
TOTAL
16,037.5 sq. ft.
46.47
62.08
-1
A.M. peak hour trip rate is 3 per 1,000 sq. ft
P.M. peak hour trip rate is 4 per 1,000 sq. ft.
Pursuant to the requirements of Charter Section 423 (Measure S) and Council Policy
A -18 (Measure S Guidelines), General Plan Amendment Nos. GP2010 -012, 013 and
GP2011 -002 are classified as a "Minor Amendment' and no vote of the electorate is
required.
3. The existing buildings and uses, and future development of those properties affected
by the proposed amendments will be consistent with the goals and policies of the Land
15
City Council Resolution No.
Page 4 of 4
Use Element of the General Plan and the Coastal Land Use Plan; and will be
consistent with the purpose and intent of the CG 0.5 and MU -V zoning districts of the
Newport Beach Municipal Code.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED:
The City Council of the City of Newport Beach hereby approves General Plan Amendments
and Coastal Land Use Plan Amendments as indicated below and as shown in attached
Exhibits A, B and C.
Exhibit:
Project File Nos.:
Locations:
Activity Nos.:
A
PA2010 -190
6480 West Coast Hwy
GP2010 -013 and LC2010 -003
B
PA2011 -014
6904 West Coast Hwy
GP2011 -002 and LC2011 -001
C
PA2010 -182
6908 -6936 West Coast Hwy
GP2010 -002 and LC2010 -002
Passed and adopted by the City Council of Newport Beach at a regular meeting held on the
May 10, 2011, by the following vote to wit:
AYES, COUNCIL MEMBERS
NOES, COUNCIL MEMBERS
ABSENT COUNCIL MEMBERS
MAYOR
ATTEST:
CITY CLERK
10
CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION
Exhibit A-
6480 W. Coast Highway
GP2010 -013 and
LC2010 -003
(PA2010 -190)
17
12
ARV)
500
:::i Feet
seJOn
GP2010 -013 (PA2010 -190)
General Plan Amendment
6480 West Coast Highway NE ,rr
GP2010- 013.mxd March/2011
Z
il
20
v
NsFr A
2P
O
y
A
PSR CANAL y m
pip 1
1? t O� °? 5 PJ CEDAR STREET
4 �
9
p=
4�
[y NF�o pe'
SST 20� RrN O =s yt Pp5
OpP HF.S O v0 2J4 °�O
p �P
N Existing
O pv,
Two Residential
C vU �p
PS °AF T s,'Q 'fie
p Re � sr4s Proposed Land Use:
Commercial ReeT'kR
Os
° 9y Pp p4.
o
�ss 0p
A yAp
6� C
ti
5
o�
oy
QP ti
6
tip
2�
e
45 stgs
HOR
F
C
5
0 250 500
Feet
LC2010 -003 (PA2010 -190) e
Coastal Land Use Plan Amendment
6480 West Coast Highway
LC2010- 003mxd March /2011 ^-r
22
CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION
Exhibit B-
6904 W. Coast Highway
GP2011 -002 and
LC2011 -001
(PA2011 -014)
23
24
i
--`�� OS(RV) � Py
/
s�
—
l y
2°
P � �
US _
2
4
O Say CANALST • @ • e
SP °O9ST [F� pQP
SPp y y1
2
OQO S �p 23.
2 F9y.Rp p0 vU0
RF
O OR h
5 4
?2 SU
Sa F(4 °yP
?S
y
Rr
c RFS a'i
P pR
pOF h UO2
9A.F Uy,O J
RpryT PS C
1
apt Cpa P2
O SYy OP
U lyY� py
yt �y
?P SyOR
F
JGO OR
ppy¢5
Q
0 250 500 y °`
Feet
GP2011 -002 (PA2011 -014) e
General Plan Amendment
6904 West Coast Highway
GP2011- 002.mxd March /2011
M
OSAp�
m
��Q�II�u�ulluWulDlul Ilp .�
III pIIIIIIIVIVIIVII /I / IIIIIIIIII�I
IVW I I
GG�ST s`NSF ��
SpRF 9A
O _
2
9A H/G -
0
A - •
2
pP �A
20 AP U
9
P2
205 Oq U0
vrP � IFS "F�x
T qty pRJ S 2P yA
� P� rypRfs vVO ,A
� O 2
A R
sT �P2 �e
A
5
2
RT
Ole t �A
v yA y.F9sH CO v� yAr
SRpRFS yA��
G
x 9 Ao2 Hry oR
0 9Y <
0
Pp
y G
2P FST
GO
J
N
�� 2s
0 250 500
Feet
LC2011 -001 (PA2011 -014) e
Coastal Land Use Plan Amendment
6904 West Coast Highway N,,.
LC2011- 001.mxd March/2011
22
CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION
Exhibit C-
6908 -6936 W Coast Highway
GP2010 -002 and
LC2010 -002
(PA2010 -182)
29
30
OS(RV)
Two Unit Residential (RT)
Proposed Land Use:
oysFro
\ R
Oq io
O
y1
O
'aN,i.ROy Up
t
0 00 5
P 9FThh'Y ev~ CANALST
O�
4
O O
o P sFgs y1 u
e ho s
so RFO cee ya
R 2GF it
O OpP O`er
JO
S~
pP
V
Vie= N A
e y ogrsy
1
x� ="p oRFSo
P ti
yF
RANT h- �
0 09 11611, p2 2J
r2
_ O
y1
OS
00 �Y 4
sF P
5 RsyoR ono
F
oe °R
�G
h '
zS
0 250 500 �P
Feet o�
GP2010 -002 (PA2010 -182) e
General Plan Amendment
6908 -6936 West Coast Highway
GP2010- 002.mxd March/2011 N
ST
S2
00119r
\�sH,
51
250
LC2010 -002. mxd Marchl2011
OS
y'G
qY
500
= Feet
`GFST
5�
-0,
CANAL
�4
m�
�FAa
0
v� ar s
oe� hosFs
oa
001151T
LC2010 -002 (PA2010 -182)
Coastal Land Use Plan Amendment
6908 -6936 West Coast Highway
y�Gh
�2
� '9Y
�F
sr
� N
F>
N
y"�
S4
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 9:24 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: froghouse
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: nova bleckley
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 7:49 PM
To: "cwunsworth(a )road runner.com" , "strataland(a )earthlink.net" , "eaton7270 earthlink.net" ,
"rhawkinsCabearthlink.net" , "bhillgren(a)highrhodes.com" , "ameri(Q)_rbf.com"
Subject: froghouse
I have worked at the Froghouse and let me say that it was the most memorable part of growing up in Newport Beach.
I have lived in Newport Shores for 20 years and it would not be the same without that business.
157
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 7:38 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: FrogHouse
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: zundholzer(a )aol.com
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 4:54 PM
To: emcdaniel(a),sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth(a)roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(v7earth link. net, rhawkins(a)earthlink.net, bhiligren(a)highrhodes.com, anneri(@rbf.com
Subject: FrogHouse
Please save the Frog House, it is considered at least in my family a landmark that needs not be disturbed.
Please understand that I also value the upgrade of Newport Beach for the future, but please instead consider a
facelift for the building. i would hate not to share this part of my wife and I youthful history with our children.
Thank you for your consideration in the matter
sincerely
Thomas and Tracey McGee
1158
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 7:38 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: My reason for traveling to NEwport Beach
- - - -- Forwarded Message -----
>From: Daniel <danielgbenson @gmail.com>
>Sent: Mar 30, 2011 3:32 PM
>To: emcdaniel @sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth @roadrunner.com, strataland @earthlink.net, eaton727 @earthlink.net,
rhawkins @earthlink.net, bhillgren @highrhodes.com, ameri @rbf.com
> Subject: My reason for traveling to NEwport Beach
>It is alarming that an institution that should be marked for inclusion as a historical site is being so severely threatened. I
make regular pilgrimage to The Frog House from northern California. I have been doing this for decades, as do many
others. But really... Newport Beach without The Frog House? Why bother.
>I am very distressed to discover that The Frog House is still struggling to win this fight to exist. I first shopped at The
Frog House in the early 70's, and though I do not live in the area now, I still make regular visits to The Frog House when I
have a need for supplies. To tell you the truth, it is one of the last reasons I have to visit Newport Beach - or Orange
County, for that matter. But I do because The Frog House is such a huge part of my personal history. Of course, there are
many more like me. Please do not let this beacon of what so much of Newport Beach stands for be taken away. If the city
must get involved, why not figure a way to cash -in on its iconic success. Newport Beach without The Frog House?
Preposterous.
> Daniel Benson
2s9
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 7:38 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Please save The Frog House
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Amanda McCann
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 2:22 PM
To:
Subject: Please save The Frog House
Hello,
I am writing to request you take into consideration the importance of The Frog House on the community. I have
lived in Newport for the past 22 of my 29 years of life and cannot remember a time without it. It truly is a landmark
and has positively represented our city for many years, and I would be so very sad to see this wonderful local
business go. Please allow the zoning change and let The Frog House live on for future generations to enjoy as
much as I have.
Thank you so much for your time and consideration.
Warmest Regards,
Amanda McCann
Newport Beach resident
100
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 7:37 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: The Frog House
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Arne Beckman
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 2:12 PM
To: cwunsworth(c roadrunner.com, strataland(a )earthIink.net, eaton7270)earthlink.net, rhawkins(aDearthlink.net,
bhillgren(a)highrhodes.com, amerie_rbf.com, emcdaniel(d)_sunwestbank.com
Subject: The Frog House
Dear City of Newport Beach,
As a former resident of Newport and Costa Mesa I would ask that the Frog House surf shop be allowed to stay
and flourish. Many of us who grew up in the area got our first surfboards from there. Even after moving to Dana
Point I would still drive to the Frog House for my boards and other supplies.
Even my grandparents (the late Dr Arnold O and Mabel Beckman) would shop for my brother and I there!
Please approve the zoning request and amendment to allow the greatest surf shop on the west coast to continue
on.
Sincerely,
Arnold W Beckman
1358 Terrace Dr
Bullhead City, AZ 86442
Phone: 928 -444 -8106
101
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 7:37 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Please save the Frog House!
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Sarah Kincaid
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 1:35 PM
To: Earl McDaniel , Charles Unsworth , Micheal Toerge , Barry Eaton , Robert Hawkins , Bradly Hillgren , Fred
Ameri
Subject: Please save the Frog House!
Dear Commissioner,
I know you have difficult decisions to make. I respectfully ask that you decide to save the Frog House. I grew up
nearby, and still visit Newport often. The Frog House is a big draw to the area. Please save this wonderful place.
Sincerely,
Sarah Kincaid
Sarah Kincaid
Administrator
A+ Environmental Solutions, LLC
Web: w .envir- solutions.com
Email: Sarahralenvir- solutions.com
6898 Soquel Avenue.
Santa Cruz, CA 95062
Phone: 831- 476 -9200
Fax: 831- 475 -5322
1('02
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 2:07 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: Frog House
From: Rudy Huebner rmailto:rudy@rudyland.netl
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 20111:54 PM
To: emcdaniel @sunwestbank.com; cwunsworth @roadrunner.com; strataland@earthlink.net; eaton727 @earthlink.net;
rhawkins0earth link. net; bhillaren(o)hiahrhodes.com; ameri&bf.com
Subject: Frog House
Hello,
I am writing you in regards to the current situation concerning the Frog House. My name is Rudy; I live in Hawaii, but grew
up in Huntington Beach. The Frog House, and especially TK and his crew, are truly unique in that they have created a
haven of authenticity and camaraderie that is unlike anything I have found anywhere else. The Frog House has such a
colorful history and is home to several generations of surfers; to lose this would be tragic. In my personal experience,
when I began my journey as a surfer, TK sold me my first board and wetsuit. I soon found myself at the Frog House
regularly, surfing out front with TK, Mikey and the boys, and talking story in the shop afterwards. The Frog House is more
than just a surf shop; it's a gathering place where all are made welcome, from seasoned pros to humble beginners.
Myself, and countless others, are so loyal to the Frog House that we simply won't shop anywhere else.
Allowing the Frog House to continue its operations is a great asset to the community, not only for locals, but for all the
summer tourists who surf their first waves on Frog House rental boards. To deprive the community of all the Frog House
has to offer would be a devastating loss; it's one of the last true, core surf shops around that hasn't been homogenized.
The Frog House is a very special place, run by surfers, for surfers. From an outsiders perspective, our culture may seem
hard to understand, but that doesn't make it any less sacred. Because of this, the Frog House can't be treated as just
another standard retail location; it plays a critical role in local surf history and culture, and should be preserved for future
generations. City of Newport, please let the Frog House stay.
Aloha,
R
Rudy Huebner
Graphic Design + Web Development + Photography
949/751 -8799
http: / /rudyland.net
l o3
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 1:05 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: Save the Froghouse
From: Matt Kelley Finailto :mkelley @trusteecorps.coml
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:15 AM
To: cwunsworth @roadrunner.com; strata land @earthlink.net; eaton727 @earthlink.net; rhawkins (dearthlink.net;
bhillgren(a)hiohrhodes.com; ameri(d)rbf.com
Subject: Save the Froghouse
I support the Froghouse's request for a zoning change and an amendment to the General plan to allow the Froghouse to
continue to do business and serve the city of Newport Beach as it has for many years. I am a resident of Newport Beach,
And enjoy regularly shopping at their business and the events that they host, in addition to the proud culture that they
promote. The Froghouse is an integral part of the culture and atmosphere which draws myself, as well as my friends and
family, over and over again. Please approve this minor zoning request and amendment to allow a Newport Beach
mainstay to continue to serve the city's residents and visitors. Thank you for your time and consideration.
I'll be in attendance at their hearing and look forward to seeing a positive outcome to this formality.
Matthew Kelley
Trustee Corps
17100 Gillette Avenue
Irvine, CA 92614
Office: 949.252.8300 ext -155
Fax: 949.252.8330
Cell: 949.310.9736
Offices in California Nevada Arizona
Trustee Corps (Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae Processing Office)
2112 Business Center Drive
2nd Floor — Suite 201
Irvine, CA 92612
Fannie Mae Retained Counsel in CA, NV & AZ Freddie Mac Designated Counsel in CA, NV & AZ
Default services in CA, NV, AK, AZ, ID, MT, OR, HI, TX & WA
1-04
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 1:05 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: The Frog House
Attachments: Clear Day Bkgrd.JPG
From: Joan Burton rmailto :iburtonCalmocnetwork.coml
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:32 AM
To: emcdanielCalsunwestbank.com; cwunsworth @roadrunner.com; strata land @earth link. net; eaton727Co1earthlink.net,,
rhawkinsCaearthlink.net; bhillgren@highrhodes.com; ameri(arbf.com
Subject: The Frog House
Please do not close The Frog House! It's an institution in Newport Boach and very important resource for the surfers in
Orange county. I don't even surf but I grew up with all the local surfers and this is a part of surfing history. Please
rethink this. Thank you.
Joan Burton
Account Manager
MPC Boaters Directory
1- 800- 76YACHT ext 346
1- 949 - 873 -1002 ext 346
105
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 1:05 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: DONT CLOSE THE FROG HOUSE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
From: 13 rmailto:hewitt78 @yahoo.coml
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 11:03 AM
To: rhawkins @earthlink. net
Subject: DONT CLOSE THE FROG HOUSE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I am a community leader and I would like to show my support for the place that is more than a business, but a
community pillar. I was a young boy when the frog house staff really helped me to get into surfing with the
right equipment and support of a life long hobby.
Thanks for your consideration,
Jeremiah "JJ" Hewitt
C.W.A. Local 9510 Acting Vice President for Verizon Unit
Sons of the American Legion Post 291
V.C.H.O.A. President and Board Member
M.B.A. Technology Management
B.S. Information Technology
D
1
Error! Filename not specified.Error! Filename not specified.
0
❑x
This e-mail message may contain privileged and/or confidential information, and is intended to be received only
by persons entitled to receive such information. If you have received this e -mail in error, please notify the
100
sender immediately. Please delete it and all attachments from any servers, hard drives or any other media. Other
use of this e -mail by you is strictly prohibited.
1O7
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 1:05 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: Don't Let the City Shut the Froghouse Down
- - - -- Original Message - - --
From: Cecelia_Ward @Toyota.com [ mailto:Cecelia_Ward @Toyota.com]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 11:11 AM
Subject: Don't Let the City Shut the Froghouse Down
This petition is to let the Newport Beach, Froghouse stay on
PCH ..... Please,
Cecelia Ward
Huntington Beach
is
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 1:04 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: Let the Frog House Stay
From: Fullerbovsmom @aol.com rmailto:Fullerboysmom @aol.coml
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 201112:38 PM
To: emcdaniel @sunwestbank.com; cwunsworth @roadrunner.com; strataland@earthlink.net; eaton727@earthlink.net;
rhawkins @earth link. net; bhillgren @hiohrhodes.com; ameri @rbf.com
Subject: Let the Frog House Stay
Please make a zoning change and a General Plan Amendment to allow Frog House to stay! It is a Newport Icon
that everyone would hate to see go!
log
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 1:03 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW:
From: Suzanne Smith rmailto:suannie @ sbcglobal.netl
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 201112:24 PM
To: strata land@earthlink.net; cwunsworth@ road runner.com; eaton727@earth link. net; rhawkins@earthlink.net;
bhillgrenCabhiahrhodes.com; ameriCcbrbf.com; emcdaniel(&sunwestbank.com
Subject:
Dear Newport Beach Commissioners,
Please, please approve the Frog House request for a zoning change and general plan amendment. It is an
iconic Newport Beach shop.
Furthermore, they are the BEST neighbors! How do I know? For six - and -a -half years my husband and I (and
then 3 of our 5 children) lived in the little red house adjacent to the Frog House. Even with the parking lot, the
customers coming and going, etc. The employees and customers of the Frog House were always better
neighbors than the vast majority of the neighbors we had across the street and next door. TK took great care
in making sure that trash was picked up in his parking lot, and the area immediately around his building kept
clean and tidy. Again, better than many of the neighbors that seemed to circulate in and out of that
neighborhood.
Also, while living there, there were several occasions when cars careened out of control on PCH and ended up
nearly in our living room. Had that house been situated any closer to PCH, I'm sure we would have had more
than one unwelcome late night visitor (along with a great deal of damage to our psyches and the physical
structure of the house). I can't imagine converting that parking lot into a residence after having lived through
those few "close shaves ".
Please approve the zoning change and general plan amendment.
Thank you for your time and service.
Sincerely,
Suzanne Smith
170
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:19 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Save the Froghouse.
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Debbie Maxwell
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 9:14 AM
To: rhawkins(a)earthlink.com
Subject: Save the Froghouse
I support the Froghouse's request for a zoning change and an amendment to the General plan to allow the
Froghouse to continue to do business and serve ...the city of Newport Beach as it has for many many years.
While I am a resident of Huntington Beach, I visit Newport Beach quite often and visit the Peninsula /Northwest
section of Newport Beach, where Froghouse conducts business, The Froghouse is an integral part of the culture
and atmosphere which draws myself, as well as my friends and family, over and over again. The owner TK Brimer
is a man of integrity. He is generous to a fault. He has done may things to make our community a better place to
live. TK and all the employees of the Froghouse are always helpful, friendly and cheerful when you go into their
store. Froghouse is and icon in the surf community and in Newport Beachs history. Please approve this minor
zoning request and amendment to allow a Newport Beach mainstay to continue to serve the city's residents and
visitors.
Debbie Maxwell
9652 Sailfish Drive
Huntington Beach, CA 92646
714 - 336 -8507r
1-71
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:19 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Save the Froghouse
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Matt Kelley
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 9:15 AM
To: "cwunsworth(a )road runner.com" , "strataland(a )earthlink.net" , "eaton7270 earthlink.net" ,
"rhawkinsCc earthlink.net" , "bhillgrenC@highrhodes.com" , "ameri(a)rbf.com"
Subject: Save the Froghouse
z72
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:07 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: LET THE FROG HOUSE STAY
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Capt Steve
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 2:48 AM
To: emcdaniel(a')sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth()roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(a)earth link. net, rhawkins(a )earthlink.net, bhillgren(a)highrhodes.com, ameri(@,rbf.com
Cc: tkfrog(aaol.com
Subject: LET THE FROG HOUSE STAY
City of Newport Beach
Let the FROG HOUSE Stay!!!
Surfing is an intricate component to the City of Newport Beach. It's what skiing is to the city of
Mammoth.
Surfing is part of Newport's heart & soul.
The art of riding waves is more than a simple recreational activity; it's a healthy way of life. Surfing
also provides the city with millions of dollars of revenue.
The Frog House has been around since the early years of surfing in Southern California, and longer than
almost any surf shop in the country !!!
The Frog House is more than a landmark to the City of Newport Beach, it's an inspiration to "keep the
stoke," and enjoy life. Generations of surfers (young & old) have bought their very first surfboard there,
and I am proud to say I am one of these surfers. When people drive past the Frog House on PCH, they
forget about their troubles and daily stress; they remember good times and fond memories.
The Frog House is more than a surf shop. It's a spiritual place where families and friends return to year
after year to soak up the history of surfing. For several decades, TK Brimer and his colorful cast of
employees have encouraged kids to `stay off drugs' and just go surfing. If it weren't for TK, I would not
1�3
be the person I am today. He inspired me to travel the world and be a good ambassador towards
protecting our oceans.
Depriving future generations from one of the world's last remaining "Real Surf Shops" would be a crime
and just plain bad business for the city.
Let the Frog House stay. Do not cut out the heart of Newport Beach ! ! !
Sincere Regards,
Captain Steve Voris
captainalohaA live.com
174
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:07 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Fog House Zoning issues
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Steve Short
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 12:06 AM
To: cwunsworth(c roadrunner.com, strataland(a )earthIink.net, eaton727(a )earthlink.net, rhawkins(gDearthlink.net,
bhilIgren(aDhighrhodes.com, amerie_rbf.com, emcdaniel(a)sunwestbank.com
Subject: Fog House Zoning issues
Hello Newport Planning Commissioners,
I would sure appreciate you giving the Frog House a break on the zoning issues that are being discussed in April.
I have been a long time customer of the Frog House and they have always treated me well ... and now my son
shops there too.
We would hate to see them closed down or relocated due to the zoning laws so request that you find some way to
give them a break.
Thanks, Steve Short
ij 5
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:07 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: The Frog House
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: David Ayers
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 8:51 AM
To: rhawkins(a earthlink.net, bhillaren(a )hiohrhodes.com, ameri (0)rbf.com
Subject: The Frog House
Dear Sir,
I am writing to ask you to please do the right thing with the legendary Frog House. Anyone that ever lived or
surfed in Newport Beach has certainly heard of or come across this landmark and icon of surfing. I am sure you
are hearing a lot of people pleading for your help and giving plenty of reasons why and probably telling you a
number of stories. I just simply want to ask you to help save the Frog House and keep the historic charm of
Newport Beach alive. I understand it has to do with residential zoning laws but sometimes laws don't make sense
and certainly some common sense should be applied to this situation.
Thank you for your time,
David Ayers
170
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:06 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Please consider letting Froghouse Stay
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Mary DeScenza
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 10:37 PM
To: cwunsworth(a )roadrunner.com, emcdaniel(a.sunwestbank.com, strataland(a.earth link. net
,
eaton727(a)earth link. net, rhawkins(a)earthlink.net, bhillgrenCcDhighrhodes.com, ameri(@rbf.com
Subject: Please consider letting Froghouse Stay
1 support the Froghouse's request for a zoning change and an amendment to the General plan to allow the Froghouse to continue to do business and
serve the city of Newport Beach as it has for many many years. While I am a resident of Okinawa, Japan, I always try visit Newport beach
whenever I can back to the states and visit the Peninsula/Northwest section of Newport Beach, where Froghouse conducts business. The Froghouse
is an integral part of the culture and atmosphere which draws myself, as well as my friends and family, over and over again. Please approve this
minor zoning request and amendment to allow a Newport Beach mainstay to continue to serve the city's residents and visitors.
Thanks,
Mary Mohler
PS. Even on the other side of the world, 1 still see Froghouse's presence, I have seen multiple bumper stickers here, so the appeal of this surf shop
isn't just for the local crowd, but also maintains a fan base all over the world
177
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:06 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Save the Frog House
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Mike Stebinger
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 10:12 PM
To: emcdaniel(a.sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth(a)roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(v)earth link. net, rhawkins(cDearthlink.net, bhillgren(a highrhodes.com, ameri(@rbf.com
Subject: Save the Frog House
Save the Frog House! This is a icon and i hope to be able to have my 1 year old son his first wet suite there like
so many of us have over the years.
Mike
mi ke(a)long boardsicecream. com
714 -594 -5051
172
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:06 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Let the frog house stay
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Brandon Hoshiko
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 9:45 PM
To: rhawkins @earthlink.net
Subject: Let the frog house stay
Dear Hon. Eaton:
Please allow the Frog House to stay. It is an iconic landmark of Newport Beach & the surfining community at
large. We need the Frog House.
Brandon Hoshiko
I sent this message from a mobile device. I beg your pardon if I appear curt or have overlooked typos.
1�"
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:05 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Frog house
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Courtney Fletcher
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 9:30 PM
To: emcdaniel(a.sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth(a)roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(a)earth link. net, rhawkins(a)earthlink.net, bhiligren(a)highrhodes.com, ameri(@,rbf.com
Subject: Frog house
Dear members of the Newport planning commission,
Please keep the frog house where it is. It's an amazing place that brings the community together and is treasured by all those
who have had the opportunity to take a visit. Thank you for your time, I hope you will consider how much this place means
to us when making your decision.
Courtney Fletcher
10
120
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:05 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Kindly Consider the The Frog House
- - - -- Forwarded Message -----
>From: Dandy O'Shea <aliciamarble @mac.com>
>Sent: Mar 29, 2011 9:28 PM
>To: emcdaniel@sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth @roadrunner.com, strataland @earthlink.net, eaton727 @earth link. net,
rhawkins @earthlink.net, bhillgren @highrhodes.com, ameri @rbf.com
> Subject: Kindly Consider the The Frog House
>Dearest Commissioners,
> Please take careful and kind consideration while reviewing all matters regarding our local treasure, The Frog House. It is
part of the landscape of West Newport, a welcome sign to visitors and home to locals. For years, it is a trusted resource
where the always terrific TK and his great staff have provided us the wonderful tools to enjoy what is really makes our
town so special - the ocean. Please consider that this shop is well loved and patronized. The Frog House is well
maintained, managed and provides a valued service. There is something else about Newport that makes it special, there
is no other place in the world like it. The Frog House is unique, The Frog House is Newport! I appreciate any time spent to
take careful and loving consideration for a place that is sewn into the fabric of Newport, changing it will be pulling at the
fabric of our wonderful local vibe. Please feel free to contact me should you like to discuss this The Frog House and the
connection it has to our city.
>Kind regards,
> Dandy O'Shea
>2 Spanish Bay Drive
> Newport Beach, CA 92660
>949- 644 -9990
11
2 �1
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:05 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Please Save the Frog House
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Sean Frink
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 9:07 PM
To: emcdaniel(a.sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth(aroadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(@earth link. net, rhawkins(c earthlink.net, bhiIIgren(a)highrhodes.com, ameri(@,rbf.com
Subject: Please Save the Frog House
Gentlemen:
As someone who was born Hoag Hospital in 1964, attended Mariners Elementary, Horace Ensign Junior High
School, and NHHS, whose family still lives there, and who spent virtually every waking moment during the
summer and school breaks down in Newport Shores, I think that I know it when I say that the Frog House is a
Newport Beach institution deserving of exceptional consideration by your commission. Seriously, what remains of
the old Newport from the 60's and early 70's, the "Big Wednesday" era golden age of surf companies? Gone is
Russell Surfboards. Gone is the old Newport Surf and Sport. What old school surf companies remain?
Please save the Frog House.
It is truly a deserving of our respect and, in this case, some exceptional treatment by you.
Regards,
Sean Frink
Sean Frink
Partner I Carlsmith Ball LLP
P.O. BOX 5241 SAIPAN, MP 96950 (USA)
CARLSMITH BUILDING, ISA DRIVE; CAPITOL HILL, SAIPAN, MP 96950 (USA)
DIRECT: (670) 322 -3455 FAX: (670) 322 -3368 WEB: w .carlsmith.com EMAIL: sfrinkecarlsmith.com
Uniquely Positioned to Represent Clients throughout the Pacific
Honolulu - Hilo - Kona - Maui - Guam - Saipan - Los Angeles
IMPORTANT /CONFIDENTIAL: This message may contain confidential and privileged information. If it has been sent to you in error, please reply to
inform the sender of the error and then delete this message.
12
122
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:05 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: save the froghouse
- - - -- Forwarded Message -----
>From: Steve Byrne <stevebyrnemarketing @gmail.com>
>Sent: Mar 30, 2011 7:25 AM
>To: strataland @earthlink.net, eaton727 @earthlink.net, rhawkins @earthlink.net, bhillgren @highrhodes.com,
ameri @rbf.com
> Subject: save the froghouse
>I'm a newport beach citizen. Kindly do what is needed to prevent the
>froghouse from moving.
>Thankyou
>The Newport planning commission is he ... aring the frog house request
>for zoning change and the general plan amendment on April 7 at 6:30pm.
>I ask you to forward this message to all members of save the frog
>house asking anyone who would take the time to email a favorable
>request to any one or all 7 of the commissioners that will be voting
>on our fate. Here is a list of their names and emails. Thank you for
>your help .
> Steve Byrne
>714.348.4363 Mobile
13
183
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:04 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Please save the Froghouse
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: CRAIG MOSS
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 7:22 AM
To: cwunsworth(a )roadrunner.com, strataland(a.earthI ink. net, eaton727(a )earthlink.net, rhawki ns(o),earthlin k. net,
bhillgren(aDhighrhodes.com, amerie_rbf.com
Subject: Please save the Froghouse
I'm writing you to express my support for allowing the Froghouse to remain at their current property. They are an integral part of West Newport
and should be allowed to continue providing service to both residents and visitors of Newport Beach. Over 12,000 people have put `like" on the
Facebook page, expressing support as well. I hope that you would please take that into account when making your decision at it has been a symbol
of Newport Beach and the community.
Thank you for your time and consideration
Sincerely,
Craig Moss
14
124
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:04 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: SAVE THE FROG HOUSE
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: SurfbumNate
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 7:12 AM
To: emcdaniel(a)..sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth()roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(v7earth link. net, rhawkins(a )earthlink.net, bhiligren(a)highrhodes.com, ameri(@,rbf.com
Subject: SAVE THE FROG HOUSE
Please save the Frog House. Don't allow a ridiculous technicality to take away one of the last historic landmark
surf shops along the SoCal coast. I love the Frog House, I've been going there since the early 80's, I bought my
wife her first long board there, and we both wish the Frog House to remain where it is forever. Thanks so much.
Nathan Kapel
is
125
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:04 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Frog House -- Keep It Put Where It Is!
- - - -- Forwarded Message -----
>From: Rod Rodgers <rodndtube @gmail.com>
>Sent: Mar 30, 2011 6:44 AM
>To: emcdaniel @sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth @roadrunner.com, strataland @earthlink.net, eaton727 @earthlink.net,
rhawkins @earthlink.net, bhillgren @highrhodes.com, ameri @rbf.com
> Subject: Frog House -- Keep It Put Where It Is!
>Honorable Newport Planning Commissioners,
>I would sure appreciate you giving the Frog House a break on the zoning
>issues that are being discussed in April.
>The Frog House is a cultural and historical icon, provides a valuable
>service and is a long -time established small business.
>Please make whatever zoning changes are needed in a manner that ensures
>the continued Frog House business where it is and in a manner that does
>not penalize or put into jeopardy the continued success of this small
>business.
>Thanks,
>Rod Rodgers _\m/
>http://rodndtube.com/
>hftp://mypaipoboards.org/
16
120
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:03 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Frog House
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Sharon Brimer
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 6:42 AM
To: rhawkins(a.earth link. net
Subject: Frog House
Dear Mr. Hawkins,
I am writing in support of the request for zoning change and the general plan amendment that would allow the
Frog House to stay in business at its present location.
Sharon D. Brimer
Customer, Frog House
C:949- 233 -0107
v
287
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:03 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Save the Frog House
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Mark Crane
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 6:37 AM
To: emcdaniel(a.sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth(a)roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(v7earth link. net, rhawkins(a )earthlink.net, bhiligren(a)highrhodes.com, anneri(@rbf.com
Cc: 'JEFFREY S BRACEY' , Dane Brimer
Subject: Save the Frog House
is
122
Burns, Marlene
From:
Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent:
Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:02 AM
To:
Burns, Marlene
Subject:
Fw: Please allow the Froghouse to continue in the current location.
Attachments:
Mark Freeman.vcf
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Mark Freeman
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 6:02 AM
To: cwunsworth).roadrunner.com, strata landna.earthI ink. net, eaton727(a)earthlink.net, rhawkins(?) earthlink.net,
bhillgren()Dhighrhodes.com, ameri()Drbf.com
Subject: Please allow the Froghouse to continue in the current location
Dear Newport Planning Commission members,
I'm writing you to express my support for allowing the Froghouse to remain at their current
property.
They are an integral part of West Newport and should be allowed to continue providing service
to both residents and visitors of Newport Beach. 12,375 people out there put "like" on the
Facebook page, expressing support as well. Please take that into account, as you make your
decision.
Thanks for your consideration!
Regards,
Mark Freeman
19
189
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:02 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: the frog house zoning
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: alan fogel
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 5:44 AM
To: rhawkinsia'�.earth link. net
Subject: the frog house zoning
Hi Mr Hawkins,
I've been shopping at the Frog House for over 30 years and I would hate to see them close. Please find a way to let them
stay at their present location. They are an important part of the Newport Beach surf culture and a huge asset to the
community.
Thank you,
Alan Fogel
20
i9 D
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:02 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Thank you for your consideration
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Catherine Ballard
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 8:48 AM
To: rhawkins(a )earth link. net
Subject: Thank you for your consideration
I will keep this brief, as I'm sure you will receive many emails. By the time you meet on April 7th to consider the
zoning changes for the Frog House on PCH, I hope that you understand how much this landmark business
means to many of us in the community.
I grew up in Buena Park and my husband in Norwalk, but we all knew the Frog House. My students here at USC
know the Frog House. Even people who don't surf are familiar with this legendary store. It truly is a landmark, one
that I have known all my life, and I love shopping there. The staff and the atmosphere really represent some of
what I love so much about our beach community.
I also hope that by April 7th you will have learned about what an amazing person the Frog House owner is. TK
Brimer is one of the most amazing people I have had the privilege to come to know. He has a great heart for the
community and it's youth. He spends much of his time and money promoting organizations and events that
benefit the underprivileged youth throughout Orange County.
I know that you carry the burden of making these decisions on behalf of, and in consideration of, the entire
community and I appreciate the weight of your deliberations. Thank you for taking the time to read this and I hope
that you will consider the change in zoning that will allow the Frog House to stay. I really can't imagine what it
would be like to drive down PCH every day and not see the Frog House.
Cathy Ballard
Associate Director
Department of Political Science
USC Dana and David Dornsife College of Letters, Arts and Sciences
3518 Trousdale Parkway
VKC 327, MC 0044
Los Angeles, CA 90089
Phone: 213/740 -6998
Fax: 213/740 -8893
Email: cballard (a)colleae.usc.edu
"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed its the only thing
that ever has."
Margaret Mead
21
191
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:02 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Frog House Re- Zoning
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Sales - The Boat Broker & RV
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 8:06 AM
To: emcdaniel(a).sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth()roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(a)earth link. net, rhawkins(o )earthlink.net, bhiligren(a)highrhodes.com, ameri(@,rbf.com
Subject: Frog House Re- Zoning
Please do not allow the Frog House to be zoned out of it's current location. We might be all the way out here in
Lake Havasu City, AZ, but we frequently surf on the weekends and the Frog House is one of last remaining "Real"
surf shops in that area, and we'd really, REALLY hate to see it go away, as we're sure the general populace
would agree. Please make the right choice in your upcoming vote, for the people, and for the historic value of the
Frog House itself.
Thank you for your consideration.
Your friendly "The Boat Brokers & RV" sales team.
The Boat Brokers & RV
"Your Havasu Connection!"
1680 Industrial Blvd
Lake Havasu City, AZ 86403
m a i Ito: sa les(cilth eboatbroker. co m
800.488.0258 Toll Free
928.453.8833 Local
928.453.1930 Fax
http://www.theboatbroker.com
22
?92
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:02 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: No Subject
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: LarrvKnut(o.aol.com
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 7:51 AM
To: rhawkins(a.earth link. net
Subject: No Subject
I have lived in the area since 1969 and love the charm of old Newport Beach. I have frequented the Froghouse
for years and now bring my granddaughter there. Please consider voting to keep them going.
Larry Knutsen
23
1J° 3
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Wednesday, March 30, 2011 10:01 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Please save the Froghouse
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: LOUIS DULIEN
Sent: Mar 30, 2011 4:13 AM
To: emcdaniel(a.sunwestbank.com, eaton727(a),earthlink.net, cwunsworth(aDroadrunner.com,
rhawkins(a)earth link. net, bhillgren(o)highrhodes.com, ameri(aDrbf.com
Subject: Please save the Froghouse
I grew up across the street from the Froghouse. I rode my bike to school on the boardwalk to Newport El. My
brother and I had our first job at the Froghouse. We both went on to careers in the surf industry. I thank the
Froghouse for introducing me to that industry. Please don't take away the chance for others to experience what
I have through that shop. It's much more than a surf shop. It's a piece of Newport Beach history.
Thank you for taking the time to read this.
Lou Dulien
24
294
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 9:57 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Froghouse
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Austin Morrell
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 8:27 PM
To: emcdaniel(a.sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth(a)roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(v7earth link. net, rhawkins(a)earthlink.net, bhiligren(a)highrhodes.com, anneri(@rbf.com
Subject: Froghouse
Please let the Froghouse stay!
: 9Jr
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 9:56 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Froghouse
- - - -- Forwarded Message -----
>From: Scott Lastovica <slastovica @gmail.com>
>Sent: Mar 29, 2011 7:26 PM
>To: emcdaniel @sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth @roadrunner.com, strataland @earthlink.net, eaton727 @earthlink.net,
rhawkins @earthlink.net, bhillgren @highrhodes.com, ameri @rbf.com
> Subject: Froghouse
>Dear Sir,
>I'm writing to do my part and vote to let the Froghouse stay at it's
>current location in Newport. This is a landmark with a TON of surfing
>history and the guys who work there are the best! This place is one
>of the only original surf shops left. Let's not take this away from
>those of us who love the Froghouse so much.
>Thank you,
> Scott Lastovica
>Avid Surfer and Balboa Island Resident
?90
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 9:56 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Request for Zoning Change and General Plan Amendment
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Steve Albertelli
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 6:49 PM
To: emcdaniel(a.sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth(a)roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(v7earth link. net, rhawkins(a earthlink.net, bhiligren(a highrhodes.com, ameri(@rbf.com
Subject: Request for Zoning Change and General Plan Amendment
As a former resident of and frequent visitor to the City of Newport Beach, I respectfully request that the city
council and planning commission grant the zoning change and general plan amendment requested by the Frog
House surf shop. The Frog House is an integral part of the Newport Beach community. Several times each year
I return to Newport Beach from my current home in Oregon, and each time I return I visit the Frog House. It is
one of the only surf shops that I recommend to out -of -town visitors. Surely the good will and additional income to
other city businesses generated by visitors to the Frog House is of great worth to the city.
Thank you for your consideration.
Steve Albertelli
Eagle Point, Oregon
197
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 9:56 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Let the frog house stay
- - - -- Forwarded Message -----
>From: brandonhoshiko @gmail.com
>Sent: Mar 29, 2011 6:54 PM
>To: rhawkins @earthlink.net
> Subject: Let the frog house stay
>Dear Hon. Eaton:
>Please allow the Frog House to stay. It is an iconic landmark of Newport Beach & the surfining community at large. We
need the Frog House.
>Brandon Hoshiko
>- - - --
>I sent this message from a mobile device. I beg your pardon if I appear curt or have overlooked typos.
4
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 9:55 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Froghouse
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Kindon Olsen
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 7:44 PM
To: emcdaniel(a)..sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth(a)roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(v7earth link. net, rhawkins(a)earthlink.net, bhiligren(a)highrhodes.com, anneri(@rbf.com
Subject: Froghouse
Council members:
I support the Froghouse's request for a zoning change and an amendment to the General plan to allow the
Froghouse to continue to do business and serve the city of Newport Beach as it has for many many years. While
I am a resident of Irvine, I visit Newport beach daily and visit the Peninsula /Northwest section of Newport Beach,
where Froghouse conducts business, at least once a week. The Froghouse is an integral part of the culture and
atmosphere which draws myself, as well as my friends and family, over and over again. Please approve this
minor zoning request and amendment to allow a Newport Beach mainstay to continue to serve the city's residents
and visitors.
Thank you,
Kindon Olsen
?Aq
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 9:55 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Help the Frog House, Please!
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: LaSaRod(a)comcast.net
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 8:06 PM
To: amerita'�rbf.com, bhiloren(a )hiahrhodes.com, rhawkins(a)earthlink.net, eaton727(a),earthlin k. net,
strataland(a)earthlink.net, cwunsworth(a)roadrunner.com
Subject: Help the Frog House, Please!
With the utmost respect, I ask you to please consider rezoning the Frog House so that it may
stay open.
I live in Beaverton, Oregon, but have fond memories of the Frog House since my childhood
beginning over 30 years ago. My uncle owns the shop, so I grew up visiting the Frog House.
Just last week I visited again with my own children. My oldest son donned a wet suit for the
first time and tried to surf!
I imagine that his property would be prime real estate considering the proximity to the beach.
The Frog House means so much more than that. It is a place for Newport and Huntington's
youth to connect and pass time in a positive way.
Many years ago I saw just how important the Frog House is to a community much larger than
you probably think. I was hiking the Inca Trail to Maccu Picchu in Peru and met someone from
Newport Beach. I told him that my uncle owned a surf shop there, the Frog House. He looked
at me and said, "Your uncle is TK Brimer ?"
Since then I have met numerous people here in Oregon who have visited the store and
shopped in Newport Beach. The Frog House remains a memorable place for them and surely
thousands I have never met.
Please do what you can to keep my uncle's store open!
Respectfully,
LaSandra (Brimer) Rodriguez
660 SW 126th Ave
Beaverton, OR 97005
503 - 816 -4687
200
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 9:54 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: "SAVE THE FROGHOUSE" with some details
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: ROBERT LOMBARD
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 8:17 PM
To: emcdaniel(a)sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth()roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlink. net
,
rhawkins(@earthlink.net
Cc: bhiligren(a)hiahrohodes.com, amerciCcDrbf.com
Subject: "SAVE THE FROGHOUSE" with some details
Tuesday
March 29th
9:09 PM
Good evening Mr. Daniel, Mr. Unsworth, Mr. Toerge, Mr. Eaton, Mr. Hawkins, Mr. Hillgren, and Mr. Ameri
Writing to give you a bit of backstory regarding my experience with "The Frog House Surf Shop.
I started surfing at the age of 62 and TK and the crew have been supportive and encouraging for someone of my
age starting out. NO OTHER SURF SHOPS in the Newport or Huntington Beach area other then 5th Street Surf,
which folded due to the economy reached out with advice etc. NOT just trying to sell me something.
With that being said a shop like "The Frog House" should continue serving their customers and all should be
grateful a small local surf shop has been able to retain their business in these trying times.
PLEASE allow them to stay..... Researching this store it appears they are more of an institution then just a retail
business.
SAVE THE FROG HOUSE.
A supporter and customer,
Robert "The Old Surfer "Lombard
By the way I am now 65 years of age and still catching waves and "The Frog House" is my local shop.
ROBERT LOMBARD
310.248.3685
creative image Management and Casting, Ltd.
http://www.creativeima2em2mt.com
Email sent from Home Base Computer
201
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 9:53 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: comment
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Dean Koutzoukis
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 8:25 PM
To: rhawkins(a.earth link. net
Subject: comment
Mr Hawkins
I urge you to give the Frog House a zoning variance or whatever is needed to allow the iconic Socal surfshop to
remain in its present location. I have personally spent thousands of dollars there and your fine city has reaped
the tax revenue from those dollars. If the Frog House goes so do my tax dollars.
Thank you
Dean Koutzoukis
Yorba Linda CA
202
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 9:53 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: please respect The Froghouse and let it remain where it is
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: michefish(a.aol.com
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 8:37 PM
To: emcdaniel(a.sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth()roadrunner.com, strataland(cDearthlink.net,
eaton727(v7earth link. net, rhawkins(a earthlink.net, bhiligren(a highrhodes.com, ameri(@rbf.com
Subject: please respect The Froghouse and let it remain where it is
Hello, members of the City Council.
I live right by The Froghouse - in fact, I can see it from my house. In the time that I've lived here, I have heard
only good things about our corner surf shop, and I've become friends with some of staff that have worked there for
quite some time. The Froghouse is an honest surf shop where I'd recommend my brother or my friends to get a
board. Places like The Froghouse are why I like living in this part of Newport Beach - we have a neighborhood
here, nearly free of chain businesses. In a county rampant with HOA's, strip malls, and severely planned urban
space, it's refreshing to see independent businesses like this one, especially so close to where I live, inhabit a
space where there is some creative freedom. Plus, The Froghouse has so much surfing history.
From an urban planning perspective, I'm sure how the lot it's on would make for halfway decent residential
space. (That also goes for homes in a similar spot along PCH.) I encourage you to reconsider and allow The
Froghouse to stay right where it is at PCH and Grant.
Thank you so much for your time.
Michelle Giron
engineer and Newport Shore resident
203
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 9:52 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Frog House
- - - -- Forwarded Message -----
>From: ropc @sbcglobal.net
>Sent: Mar 29, 2011 8:31 PM
>To: rhawkins @earthlink.net
> Subject: Frog House
>Pls save the Frog House! We are neighbors and appreciate their kindness and their expertise! We bought my hubby's
board and suit from them. Nice to have such great people representing NB
>Sent via BlackBerry by AT &T
io
204
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 9:52 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Let the Frog House stay!
- - - -- Forwarded Message -----
>From: aberg38 @hotmail.com
>Sent: Mar 29, 2011 6:19 PM
>To: rhawkins @earthlink.net
> Subject: Let the Frog House stay!
>I've been going to this locally owned surf shop for years, as have many others. It would be a massive stain on the City of
Newport if you do not let them stay. Surf Culture is a major part of Newport, whether you like it or not. Please think about
the history that you can save.
>Sent on the Sprint@ Now Network from my BlackBerry@
11
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 7:20 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Please read for April 7 agenda
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Mike Feher
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 6:13 PM
To: emcdaniel(a.sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth(a)roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(v7earth link. net, rhawkins(a earthlink.net, bhiligren(a)highrhodes.com, anneri(@rbf.com
Subject: Please read for April 7 agenda
Esteemed Members of the Newport Planning Committee,
I am writing to ask that you please consider the zoning change that affects TK's Froghouse Surfshop. The
Froghouse is a representation of Newport Beach surf culture. When I tell people about the great city of Newport,
it's one of the things I mention. People who don't live in Newport often mention the Froghouse in conjunction with
Newport Beach. They go hand in hand. I have been shopping at the Froghouse since I was a child and always
assumed I would take my kids there to buy their first surfboards. It's a part of Newport history, and hopefully will
stand as a monument to Newport surf culture. Please consider allowing the Froghouse to remain in business and
grant their rezoning request. Thank you.
Sincerely,
Michael Feher
Newport Beach Resident
12
200
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 7:20 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: For your Consideration
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Christine Feher
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 6:12 PM
To: emcdaniel(a.sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth(a)roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(v7earth link. net, rhawkins(a)earthlink.net, bhiligren(a)highrhodes.com, anneri(@rbf.com
Subject: For your Consideration
Esteemed Members of the Newport Planning Committee,
I am writing to ask that you please consider the zoning change that affects TK's Froghouse Surfshop. The
Froghouse is a representation of Newport Beach surf culture. When I tell people about the great city of Newport,
it's one of the things I mention. People who don't live in Newport often mention the Froghouse in conjunction with
Newport Beach. They go hand in hand. I have been shopping at the Froghouse since I was a child and always
assumed I would take my kids there to buy their first surfboards. It's a part of Newport history, and hopefully will
stand as a monument to Newport surf culture. Please consider allowing the Froghouse to remain in business and
grant their rezoning request. Thank you.
Sincerely,
Christine Feher
Newport Beach Resident
13
2L-)7
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 7:17 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: city officials
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: offroadbob@aol.com
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 5:39 PM
To: ameri(a),rbf.com, bhilloren(a hiohrhodes.com, (a e
rhawkinsarthlink.net, eaton727(a )earthlink.net,
strataland(a)earthlink.net, cwunsworth(a)roadrunner.com, emcdaniel(@sunwestbank.com
Subject: city officials
let the froghouse stay
14
202
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 7:17 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: To my elected officials..........
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Bryan McLaughlin
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 5:29 PM
To: cwunsworth(a )roadrunner.com, strataland(a.earthI ink. net, eaton7270 earthlink.net, rhawkinsto')earthlink.net,
bhillgren(a)highrhodes.com, amerie_rbf.com
Subject: To my elected officials..........
I'm taking a second to write this email to keep a local city landmark alive instead of changing zoning laws to add
another condo to Newport Beach. As a lifelong resident and avid surfer, TK's Froghouse has been a place to go
and enjoy the company of others that love surfing. The new zoning laws seem to want to build another more then
likely same looking and ugly house /condo, rather than allowing a local hotspot to stay in your city. Remember you
all are elected officials and this could also be a political suicide, by making a horrible choice. Lots of very high
profile companies such as Hurley, TK Burgers, Wahoos Fish Tacos, to name a few, are on Froghouse's side. So
with that said keep in mind when they need to expand or relocate, remember what city they wont pick as a choice.
Other business right next door to the Froghouse don't seem to be affected example: Big Belly Deli and Spaghetti
Binder, why Froghouse ? ? ? ?? Thanks for reading this and hope you make an informed and logical decision in
regards to the rezoning laws.
Bryan
15
209
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 7:17 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: To my elected officials..........
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Bryan McLaughlin
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 5:29 PM
To: cwunsworth(a )roadrunner.com, strataland(a.earthI ink. net, eaton7270 earthlink.net, rhawkinsto')earthlink.net,
bhillgren(a)highrhodes.com, amerie_rbf.com
Subject: To my elected officials..........
I'm taking a second to write this email to keep a local city landmark alive instead of changing zoning laws to add
another condo to Newport Beach. As a lifelong resident and avid surfer, TK's Froghouse has been a place to go
and enjoy the company of others that love surfing. The new zoning laws seem to want to build another more then
likely same looking and ugly house /condo, rather than allowing a local hotspot to stay in your city. Remember you
all are elected officials and this could also be a political suicide, by making a horrible choice. Lots of very high
profile companies such as Hurley, TK Burgers, Wahoos Fish Tacos, to name a few, are on Froghouse's side. So
with that said keep in mind when they need to expand or relocate, remember what city they wont pick as a choice.
Other business right next door to the Froghouse don't seem to be affected example: Big Belly Deli and Spaghetti
Binder, why Froghouse ? ? ? ?? Thanks for reading this and hope you make an informed and logical decision in
regards to the rezoning laws.
Bryan
16
210
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 7:16 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: To my elected officials..........
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Bryan McLaughlin
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 5:29 PM
To: cwunsworth(a )roadrunner.com, strataland(a.earthI ink. net, eaton7270 earthlink.net, rhawkinsto')earthlink.net,
bhillgren(a)highrhodes.com, amerie_rbf.com
Subject: To my elected officials..........
I'm taking a second to write this email to keep a local city landmark alive instead of changing zoning laws to add
another condo to Newport Beach. As a lifelong resident and avid surfer, TK's Froghouse has been a place to go
and enjoy the company of others that love surfing. The new zoning laws seem to want to build another more then
likely same looking and ugly house /condo, rather than allowing a local hotspot to stay in your city. Remember you
all are elected officials and this could also be a political suicide, by making a horrible choice. Lots of very high
profile companies such as Hurley, TK Burgers, Wahoos Fish Tacos, to name a few, are on Froghouse's side. So
with that said keep in mind when they need to expand or relocate, remember what city they wont pick as a choice.
Other business right next door to the Froghouse don't seem to be affected example: Big Belly Deli and Spaghetti
Binder, why Froghouse ? ? ? ?? Thanks for reading this and hope you make an informed and logical decision in
regards to the rezoning laws.
Bryan
v
211
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 7:16 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Please Do What You Can To Save The Frog House
- - - -- Forwarded Message -----
>From: Daiquiri Scherer <daiquirischerer @gmail.com>
>Sent: Mar 29, 2011 5:12 PM
>To: rhawkins @earthlink.net
> Subject: Please Do What You Can To Save The Frog House
>Dear Commissioner Hawkins,
>I am writing you to urge you to please make the zoning change to allow
>the historical Frog House to stay. My in -laws live in Newport
>Shores.l want my children to have the wonderful experience of a
>mom -in -pop store trying to provide their customers with personal and
>fhendly service that cares. Growing up in Huntington Beach, I would
>always look out for the Frog House sign and persuade my father into
>taking us in to buy surf stickers. My brothers would buy their surf
>accessories at the Frog House because the staff were experienced and
>honest. Our culture today is full of big business deciding what we
>should like and buy. It makes me lose faith in humanity to think that
>the Frog House could lose their shop due to zoning. If they were big
>business, they would most likely be able to pay for these changes.
> Please help our society reflect that even if you are a small company,
>you can achieve success, by working hard and providing your customers
>with honest business.
>I urge you to please do everything you can for the Frog House.
>Sincerely,
> Daiquiri Scherer
>a mother
18
212
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 7:15 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Save the Frog House
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Kathryn Grant
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 5:08 PM
To: emcdaniel(a)..sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth()roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(a)earth link. net, rhawkins(a)earthlink.net, bhiligren(a)highrhodes.com, anneri(@rbf.com
Subject: Save the Frog House
Hi,
I am a resident of Costa Mesa, a child of the NMUSD school system, and a happy customer of the Frog House.
I am writing that you please do not let the Frog House be converted or torn down.
REALLY ?? What harm will it do to let it stay? PLEASE please do not let this Newport Beach staple die and be
gone ..
Thanks gentlemen for your time
Kasey
How can you get better if you stop learning?
19
213
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 7:15 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Let the Frog House stay please
- - - -- Forwarded Message -----
>From: Lindsey Jensen <lindsey.jensen169 @myci.csuci.edu>
>Sent: Mar 29, 2011 5:02 PM
>To: cwunsworth @roadrunner.com, emcdaniel @sunwestbank.com, strataland @earthlink.net, eaton727 @earthlink.net,
rhawkins @earthlink.net, bhillgren @highrhodes.com, ameri @rbf.com
> Subject: Let the Frog House stay please
>To whom it may concern,
>I'm a huge supporter of the Frog House and it would be a huge shame if
>it is put out of business. Most people probably won't care about it
>since it's just another surf shop, but that's the thing, it's not just
>another. You walk into some of the shops and no one says hi to you.
>BUT at the Frog House there are always the most friendly people and TK
>is such a great owner. That place is legendary status, it's apart of
>peoples lives, it's apart of their history and people only have
>positive things to say about it. I know I'm just another annoying
>college surfer and student sending you an email but please, it will
>mean so much to everyone if the Frog House stays.
>Thanks for your time!
20
214
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 7:14 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: The Frog House
- - - -- Forwarded Message -----
>From: Modern Innovation <eric @themoderninnovation.com>
>Sent: Mar 29, 2011 5:00 PM
>To: emcdaniel @sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth @roadrunner.com, strataland @earthlink.net, eaton727 @earthlink.net,
rhawkins @earthlink.net, bhillgren @highrhodes.com, ameri @rbf.com
> Subject: The Frog House
>Dear Sirs,
>I am writing to you on behalf of The Frog House surf shop on PCH. When you go to vote, please know that this shop
means a lot to many people. In fact, it is one of the last true surf shops in California. I know we have the likes of Jack's
and Huntington Surf and Sport in our area, but they are not true surf shops. They are more like department stores with
surfboards and they have terrible service. The Frog House is very specific to surf and their service and knowledge is
unparalleled. They have been a family type store for many many years and they have a very loyal and supportive
customer base. It would be sad to force out such a unique place that, to me and many others, is like a historical
monument here in Newport. Please give them the consideration they deserve.
>SAVE THE FROG HOUSE!
>Thank you,
>Eric Vallely
21
�ZJr
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 7:14 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Froghouse
- - - -- Forwarded Message -----
>From: Los Lavaz <info @loslavaz.com>
>Sent: Mar 29, 20114:39 PM
>To: emcdaniel @sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth @roadrunner.com, strataland @earthlink.net, eaton727 @earthlink.net,
rhawkins @earthlink.net, bhillgren @highrhodes.com, ameri @rbf.com
> Subject: Froghouse
> Please don't take away one of our last surf monuments left in Huntington Beach and Newport Beach. The Frog house is
a classic Store , Facility, which is like a family cornerstone to my family, friends, and there families. If anything ever
happened to the Store it would greatly effect and Piss off a numerous amount of people. Even if the Froghouse decided to
close down on there own we'd be Pist. But, Clearly thats not the case here. So, Please SAVE the Froghouse.
>Sincerely,
>THAN K YOU,
>Vulcho Bonev
>Cell: (714)478 -2462
>INFO @LOSLAVAZ.COM
>W W W. LOSLAVAZ. COM
22
210
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 7:14 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Froghouse
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Dena
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 5:51 PM
To: rhawkins(a)earthlink.net
Subject: Froghouse
Dear Mr. Hawkins;
The Froghouse is an institution. It is irreplaceable and irresponsible to not let it stay in
business. My family & I have been shopping this family operated store for decades.
Small location, locally owned and great proprietors make this a must have for Newport.
My family is 3rd generations of NB, with my mom graduating from Harbor, she is 70 years
old. Us 'old" timers remember the good places long gone, do not let this business die an
ugly death at the hands of government.
Please vote to keep the Froghouse.
Thank you! - Dena
23
�2�
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 7:14 PM
To: Charlie Bowman
Cc: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Re:
- - - -- Original Message---- -
From: Charlie Bowman
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 5:17 PM
To: rhawkinsna earthlink.net
Subject
SAVE THE FROGHOUSE!!!!
24
212
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, March 29, 2011 7:13 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Newport Beach Institutions
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Brandon Seger
Sent: Mar 29, 2011 5:34 PM
To: emcdaniel(a)..sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth()roadrunner.com, strataland(a).earthlin k. net,
eaton727(v7earth link. net, rhawkins(a earthlink.net, bhillgren(a highrhodes.com, anneri(@rbf.com
Subject: Newport Beach Institutions
Greetings,
The Newport Beach that I grew up in is slowly disappearing. I'm not sure whose bright idea it was to get rid of the
Reuben E. Lee and replace it with nothing but pushing out the Frog House would be a similar mistake. When you
have your big meeting with all of the important civic leaders present, please make the case to do what's
necessary to keep the Frog House around.
Thank you,
Brandon Seger
25
�z9
Correspondence
Item No. 3d
Burns, Marlene West Newport Amendments
PA2 -182
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Sunday, April 03, 20114:37 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Vote to keep the Frog House where it is!
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Dan & Elizabeth Songster
Sent: Apr 3, 2011 8:33 AM
To: rhawkinsCa.earth link. net
Subject: Vote to keep the Frog House where it is!
Mr. Robert Hawkins
PA2010 -190
PA2011 -014
This is to request that you favorably respond to the Frog House Surf Shop request for zoning
change and the general plan amendment on April 7pm. Please leave the Frog House where it
is, this is too important to mess with.
I repeat: On the April 7th vote I very strongly urge you to rezone in favor of the Frog
House staying in place at its current address.
Our Frog House is one of the most famous surf shops in the world is located at the north end
of Newport Beach, CA right on Pacific Coast Highway. The Frog House is a surf shop in the
purest sense of the word and has been operating at this location since 1963 It is also one of
the last of a breed of surfshop that still stocks surfboards made by people who surf, and these
board are sold in the Frog House by people who surf. To someone looking for a surfboard,
whether they are a beginner or expert, that means a lot. It is not a strip mall shop, or a place
with pretty girls behind the counter, it is truly a surf❑ --shop!
When I graduated high school in 1968 1 visited the Frog House hoping I might get a summer
job-[ did! But I got more than just a few dollars to make it until the fall when college opened up,
I made friends and over the years more friends -much like family.
It was a fun experience then and still is. Everytime I visit and watch the people behind the
counter as well as those walking in I see people who appreciate each other. TK Brimer treats
both their employees and customers with respect and honesty and the people know it. A
business with a history like that should be praised for the way it has served the community of
Newport Beach as well as how they have molded people who were kids when they started
working there and now have kids who have worked there, and now they have grandchildren! It
is a family.
Everyone I know of who hears about the possible loss of the Frog House is at first disbelieving,
then they are outraged. TK and the Frog House may not have political connections but they do
have the support of the community, a very wide spread and passionate community.
At a time when everyone is downsizing and jobs are still being lost why would a city choose to
close down a viable money making business that gives back to the community, in fact is a vital
part of the community?
i
220
Do the Right Thing: Allow the Frog House to stay where it is on Pacific Coast Highway.
An institution that has served generations of surfers (and visitors) and wants to
continue serving out laughter, good surfboards, and inspiration and yes, (I never
thought I would say this) guidance for the youth of the area.
Daniel Songster
23522 Cavanaugh Road
El Toto, CA 92630
949/768 -0431
221
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Sunday, April 03, 20114:36 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Froghouse
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Josh Klinge
Sent: Apr 3, 2011 12:29 PM
To: cwunsworth(a )roadrunner.com, strataland(a.earthI ink. net, eaton727(a )earthlink.net, rhawkins(o)earthlink.net,
bhilIgren(aDhighrhodes.com, amerie_rbf.com
Subject: Froghouse
222
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Saturday, April 02, 2011 11:22 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: The Froghouse
From: Anna Prober [mailto:annaprober @cox.netl
Sent: Friday, April 01, 20119:56 PM
To: cwunsworth @roadrunner.com; strataland @earthlink.net; eaton727 @earthl ink. net; rhawkins @earthlink.net;
bhillpren @hiahrhodes.com; ameri @rbf.com
Subject: The Froghouse
Begin forwarded message:
From: Anna Prober <annaprober(acox.net>
Date: April 1, 2011 9:48:54 PM PDT
To: cam pbell(a-)_city. newport-beach.ca. us, Igarcia(a)_city.newport- beach.ca.us
Cc: palford _city.newpor- beach.ca.us
Subject: The Froghouse
Esteemed City Planning Commission Staff and Members,
I am writing to save the Froghouse. Plain and simple. I grew up a few houses away from there, and
for me it is one of the last jewels Newport has to offer that has not been engulfed in the
development so many other beach cities have seen. Tom and Linda, the owners, are long time
family friends as well. I grew up alongside their children and as a child I was surrounded by the
love their home exuded.
The Froghouse is simply an extension of true home values that are being lost by many cities and
businesses today.
Tom has given SO much to the community, its youth, and surfing in general.
The work he has done and the investment he has made into our community is impossible to put into
words.
It saddens me to imagine the loss of not just a store front... but of the values Tom and his staff
express to everyone that walks in, every life he touches.
A feeling of coming home.
Heads I pay, tails it's free. (It's what Tom told all of us when buying surfwax as kids)
Please don't take this as lightly as a coin toss, but do keep in mind the gravity of once something is
lost, a place we've all called "home" it can never be brought back.
223
Please, SAVE THE FROGHOUSE! ! ! !
Warm Regards,
Anna O'Bourke- Prober
224
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Saturday, April 02, 2011 11:22 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: Let the Frog House stay
- - - -- Original Message - - - --
From: Phil Barren [mailto:pbannan426 @mac.com]
Sent: Friday, April 01, 2011 10:41 PM
To: emcdaniel @sunwestbank.com; cwunsworth @roadrunner.com;
strataland @earthlink.net; eaton727 @earthlink.net; rhawkins @earthlink.net;
bhillgren @highrhodes.com; ameri @rbf.com
Subject: Let the Frog House stay
We need the Frog House.
It is Newport's only REAL surf shop. The local community depends on
the Frog House. Please let it stay.
Thankyou
= III I -FII.I
225
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Saturday, April 02, 2011 11:21 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: Please Keep Newport Real
From: brett Landry rmailto:brettlandry@omail.coml
Sent: Saturday, April 02, 2011 12:44 AM
To: cwunsworth @roadrunner.com; strataland @earthlink.net; eaton727 @earthl ink. net; rhawkins@earthlink.net;
bhilloren @hiahrhodes.com; ameri @rbf.com
Subject: Please Keep Newport Real
The Frog House surf shop is not just a business. It's a place where kids and families and anyone who enters
discovers the beauty and excitement that comes from surfing. It is one of the last unique establishments in a
growing sea of sameness in California and I hope that Newport will see that it adds true value to the city. Please
vote for it to stay.
Cheers,
Brett
220
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Saturday, April 02, 2011 11:14 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: Support the Froghouse's request for zoning!
Attachments: Candice Bernstein.vcf
From: Candice "Candy" Bernstein rmailto:tourcandy(a)gmail.coml
Sent: Saturday, April 02, 20117:42 AM
To: cwunsworth @roadrunner.com; strataland @earthlink.net; eaton727 @earthlink.net; rhawkins @earthlink.net;
bhiligren @highrhodes.com; ameri@rbf.com; emcdaniel @sunwestbank.com
Subject: Support the Froghouse's request for zoning!
To whom it may concern:
Please accept my letter as direct support for a truly historic and special place that has been loved and a part of all
Newport Beach locals' souls. We will always remember The Frog House from our childhoods and have passed the history
to our children as we share our famous surf shop with them. I support the Froghouse's request for a zoning change and
an amendment to the General plan to allow the Froghouse to continue to do business and serve ...the city of Newport
Beach as it has for many many years. The Froghouse is an integral part of the culture and atmosphere which draws me,
as well as my friends and family, over and over again. Please approve this minor zoning request and amendment to
allow a Newport Beach mainstay to continue to serve the city's residents and visitors and preserve our rich surfing
culture and please save The Froghousel
Warmest regards and please don't take this away from us,
Candy Stomp Bernstein
227
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Saturday, April 02, 2011 11:14 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: frog house
From: steve goss rmailto :gossoerformance@gmail.coml
Sent: Saturday, April 02, 20118:33 AM
To: emcdaniel @sunwestbank.com; cwunsworth @roadrunner.com; strataland@earthlink.net; eaton727@earthlink.net;
rhawkins(a)earthlink.net; bhillgren(abhighrhodes.com; amer0rbf.com
Subject: frog house
Hello I would love to request the Frog House be allowed to stay .I grew up in that shop and so did many other
locals .I still shop there weekly We do not have many at all home town locals surf shops just big corporate non
personal surf shops !Frog house is like buying products from friends and family!Please let them stay .Thank
You Steve Goss
222
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Saturday, April 02, 2011 3:39 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: The Froghouse
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: Anna Prober
Sent: Apr 1, 2011 9:56 PM
To: cwunsworth(cilroadrunner.com, strata landna earthIink.net, eaton7270)earthlink.net, rhawkinsC(Dearthlink.net,
bhillgren(dhighrhodes.com, ameri(cDrbf.com
Subject: The Froghouse
Begin forwarded message:
From: Anna Prober <annaprober(cD-cox.net>
Date: April 1, 2011 9:48:54 PM PDT
To: cam pbell 65�citv.newport- beach.ca.us, igarciaCcDcitv.newport- beach.ca.us
Cc: palford(a)city.newpor- beach.ca.us
Subject: The Froghouse
Esteemed City Planning Commission Staff and Members,
I am writing to save the Froghouse. Plain and simple. I grew up a few houses away
from there, and for me it is one of the last jewels Newport has to offer that has not
been engulfed in the development so many other beach cities have seen. Tom and
Linda, the owners, are long time family friends as well. I grew up alongside their
children and as a child I was surrounded by the love their home exuded.
The Froghouse is simply an extension of true home values that are being lost by
many cities and businesses today.
Tom has given SO much to the community, its youth, and surfing in general.
The work he has done and the investment he has made into our community is
impossible to put into words.
It saddens me to imagine the loss of not just a store front... but of the values Tom
and his staff express to everyone that walks in, every life he touches.
A feeling of coming home.
Heads I pay, tails it's free. (It's what Tom told all of us when buying surfwax as kids)
Please don't take this as lightly as a coin toss, but do keep in mind the gravity of
once something is lost, a place we've all called "home" it can never be brought back.
Please, SAVE THE FROGHOUSE!!!!
io
2:�9
Warm Regards,
Anna O'Bourke- Prober
11
230
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Saturday, April 02, 2011 3:38 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Let the Frog House stay
- - - -- Forwarded Message -----
>From: Phil Barman <pbannan426 @mac.com>
>Sent: Apr 1, 2011 10:41 PM
>To: emcdaniel@sunwestbank.com, cwunsworth @roadrunner.com, strataland @earthlink.net, eaton727 @earth link. net,
rhawkins @earthlink.net, bhillgren @highrhodes.com, ameri @rbf.com
> Subject: Let the Frog House stay
>We need the Frog House.
>It is Newport's only REAL surf shop. The local community depends on
>the Frog House. Please let it stay.
>Thankyou
0:011 -P ITI . a
12
2S2
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Saturday, April 02, 2011 3:37 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: The Froghouse
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: John Matteson
Sent: Apr 1, 2011 11:22 PM
To: "cwunsworth(a )road runner.com" , "strataland(a )earthlink.net" , "eaton7270 earthlink.net" ,
"rhawkinsCabearthlink.net" , 'bhillgrenC@highrhodes.com" , "ameri(a)_rbf.com"
Subject: The Froghouse
Please let the froghouse stay. I have many memories as a kid of that place and it truly is a landmark to many.
Thank you for your consideration.
John Matteson
killawava.com
13
232
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Saturday, April 02, 2011 3:37 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: Fw: Please Keep Newport Real
- - - -- Forwarded Message---- -
From: brett landry
Sent: Apr 2, 2011 12:43 AM
To: "cwunsworth(a )road runner.com" , "strataland(a )earthlink.net" , "eaton7270 earthlink.net" ,
"rhawkinsCc earthlink.net" , "bhiIIgrenC@highrhodes.com" , "ameri(a)rbf.com"
Subject: Please Keep Newport Real
The Frog House surf shop is not just a business. It's a place where kids and families and anyone who enters
discovers the beauty and excitement that comes from suiting. It is one of the last unique establishments in a
growing sea of sameness in California and I hope that Newport will see that it adds true value to the city. Please
vote for it to stay.
Cheers,
Brett
14
233
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Friday, April 01, 2011 10:27 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: Save The Frog House!!!
From: vitaminblue @aol.com rmailto:vitaminblue @aol.coml
Sent: Thursday, March 31, 2011 5:10 PM
To: rhawkins @earthlink. net
Subject: Save The Frog House!!!
Robert Hawkins,
Please vote to Save The Frog House!!!, the surf shop has been a part of surfing history for many, many years.
Thank You,
Frank D. Ornelas
15
2S4
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Friday, April 01, 2011 10:27 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: Save The Frog House
- - - -- Original Message - - - --
From: david carter [mailto:dcwjahvatnd @yahoo.com]
Sent: Thursday, March 31, 2011 6:53 PM
To: emcdaniel @sunwestbank.com; cwunsworth @roadrunner.com;
strataland @earthlink.net; eaton727 @earthlink.net; rhawkins @earthlink.net;
bhillgren @highrhodes.com; ameri @rbf.com
Subject: Save The Frog House
A New port Beach institution that Needs to remain for the Kids to Have for
their Surf Gear! Proper Zoning the Property For this Newport Beach
Institution Should not even be a Question in an economy that needs Merchants
in Newport Beach Tourist industry that has Hotels near by in HB and Channel
Inn in Newport.
Thank you for Voting in consideration of the Frog house
David M Carter
16
235
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Friday, April 01, 2011 10:27 AM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: Please save the FROGHOUSE
From: Tim West rmai Ito: harborcleantim @ vahoo.coml
Sent: Thursday, March 31, 20119:59 PM
To: harborcleantim@vahoo.com
Cc: cwunsworth @roadrunner.com; cwunsworth @roadrunner.com; strataland @earthl ink. net; strata land @earthlink.net,,
eaton727 @earthlink.net; eaton727 @earthlink.net; rhawkinsCalearthlink.net; rhawkins @earthlink.net,,
bhilloren@hiohrhodes.com; bhilloren@hiohrhodes.com; ameri @rbf.com; ameri@rbf.com
Subject: Please save the FROGHOUSE
The Froghouse is a family owned business that goes out of its way to give back to our community. The FROGHOUSE is a
Newport Beach ICON, it stands for Welcome to Newport Beach. There are so few family owned businesses. The
Froghouse is a Newport Beach Landmark. Once again please do not take away our past our memories and our stories to
our children ( this is were I bought my first new surfboard for only $75.00 )
I'm a resident of 42 years
Thank you Tim West & Family
v
23 o
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Monday, April 04, 2011 1:18 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: Frog House
- - - -- Original Message - - --
From: Hurley, Bob (Hurley) [mailto:Bob_Hurley @hurley.com]
Sent: Monday, April 04, 2011 11:00 AM
To: emcdaniel @sunwestbank.com; cwunsworth @roadrunner.com;
strataland@earthlink.net; eaton727 @earthlink.net; rhawkins@earthlink.net;
bhillgren @highrhodes.com; ameri @rbf.com
Cc: Tk
Subject: Frog House
Esteemed Commissioners....
I am writing to you regarding the Frog House in Newport Beach. For fifteen
years, I have lived in the neighborhood across the street from the
Froghouse. My wife and I own three properties in the neighborhood .... 6708,
6706 W. Oceanfront and 6707 Seashore. We have nothing but great things to
say about how important this establishment is to our community, on multiple
levels.
Our company, based in Costa Mesa, is called Hurley. We are a subsidiary of
Nike Inc. We are approximately a Three Hundred million dollar a year surf
Company. We are also owners in "A" Restaurant in Newport ....... As surfing
has become important to the modern world ........ surfing the
internet "... "stoked "....... the Frog House continues to be an iconic Newport
Beach Landmark. The city of Huntington Beach is called "Surf City USA ", and
has reaped many commercial and community benefits from being "surf friendly"
Having a unique asset like the Frog House in Newport ....... enhances Newport
Beach's reputation as an important Beach Community. The local restaurants
and other businesses also benefit greatly ... let alone the fabulous kids in
the neighborhood ...... we would hate them going to Huntington to buy their
surf gear.
237
I urge you to please vote to keep the Frog House in Newport!
Respectfully,
Bob Hurley
Chairman and Founder Hurley LLC
Subsidiary Nike Inc.
Concerned taxpayer:)
Burns, Marlene
From: Robert C. Hawkins [rhawkins @earthlink.net]
Sent: Monday, April 04, 2011 1:18 PM
To: Burns, Marlene
Subject: FW: Zoning Decision
From: Dean Taylor Finailto:rinduck @ yahoo.coml
Sent: Monday, April 04, 2011 1:00 PM
To: rhawkins(aea rthlin k. net
Subject: Zoning Decision
Mr. Hawkins -
I am writing today as a concerned citizen who has spent quite a bit of my life either visiting or living in, Newport Beach. The purpose of
this message is to convey my support for one of the truly legacy businesses in Newport Beach, The Frog House. The Frog House has
long been a fixture in West Newport and is recognizable to all those who pass by it each day. I would imagine it is also a fond memory
for those who visit Newport Beach each summer.
I understand that the Frog House has been caught in a zoning issue that jeopardizes its ability to continue supporting the local
community, if at all to exist. It would be a real travesty to allow this to happen. Many surfers, locals, beach visitors and other customers
would be somewhat harmed by forcing the The Frog House to close in this location and for what purpose?
While I fondly recall the days where the roadsides thru West Newport and into Huntington were dirt/sand parking areas and believe that
more infrastructure is not necessarily good for the city, I do understand that changes need to be made. What I do not support is change
for the sake of change. There are many businesses in the West Newport area that do not appear to be affected by this zoning law. I'm
not sure why this is, but it does appear that the analysis supporting the zoning law was not done in a complete manner. Even so, there
needs to be some rationalization that would acknowledge that long -time existing businesses, such as the Frog House, would be
"grandfathered in ". In time, it may be appropriate to enforce such a zoning law if the original businesses either moved to other locations
or went out of business.
I am strongly behind modifying the zoning restrictions to allow The Frog House to continue in their present location unhindered. The
city will not be impacted and the residents are clearly beneficiaries from this decision. It's the right thing to do.
Sincerely,
Dean Taylor
949.230.9108
239
Burns, Marlene
From: rhawkins @earthlink.net
Sent: Monday, April 04, 2011 10:13 PM
To: Burns, Marlene; rhawkins @earthlink.net
Subject: Frog House to plead its case before Planning Commission
This story was sent to you by: Robert C. Hawkins
Frog House to plead its case before Planning Commission
Staff recommends approving application, but questions the building's looks.
By Mike Reicher, mike.reicher @latimes.com
April 4 2011, 8:58 PM PDT
The Frog House surf shop will take another leap toward preservation Thursday when the Newport Beach Planning
Commission reviews its application to remain a business.
The complete article can be viewed at:
http: / /dailypi lot.trb.com/ news /education /tn -dpt- 0405 -frog house-20110404,0,6661 663. story
Visit Daily Pilot at http: / /dailypilot.trb.com
240
Frog House to plead its case before Planning Commission - Daily Pilot Page 1 of 1
dailypilot. com/news /education/tn -dpt- 0405 - froghouse- 20110404,0,6661663. story
Daily Pilot
Frog House to plead its case before Planning Commission
Staff recommends approving application, but questions the building's looks.
By Mike Reicher, tnike.reicher @latimes.com
8:58 PM PDT, April 4, 2011
The Frog House surf shop will take another leap toward
preservation Thursday when the Newport Beach
Planning Commission reviews its application to remain a
business.
Owner TK Brimer and representatives of other
properties on West Coast Highway will present their
case about why the city shouldn't require their land to be
used for residential purposes.
A city law intended to displace some drug recovery
homes from residential neighborhoods also affects the
50- year -old shop, an animal shelter and a party planning
store.
advertisement
City planning staff members recommended approving their application, but had some reservations.
The staff report reads: "Although the Frog House has a strong following that supports its continued
economic success, aesthetically, the property detracts from the overall district."
Brimer said he was concerned that city officials may decide that his eclectic building doesn't fit in with
their vision for Newport Beach.
"Not all of Newport needs to look like Newport Coast," he said. "Our store, it harkens back to an earlier
beach scene."
While a Facebook page supporting the Frog House has more than 3,500 members, Brimer said he
expects about 25 to show up for Thursday's meeting.
Later, the application will go to the City Council and then the California Coastal Commission for
review.
2.4-1
http: / /www. dailypilot .com /news /education/tn -dpt- 0405 - froghouse- 20110404,0,5340724,p... 04/05/2011
242
Additional Correspondence
Received May 3, 2011
243
244
May 3, 2011
BY HAND DELIVERY
Honorable Nancy Gardner
Newport Beach City Council
3300 Newport Boulevard
Newport Beach, California 92663
AUTHOR'S EXTENSION 2108
AUTHOR'S E MAIL AOORESS:
paul@IaMrientl com
h1(p: r; wuv w.l a wf riantl, com
File No. I I -0 I 7-029
RECEIVED BY
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
MAY 0 3 2011
@M OF NEWPORT BEACH
RE: The National Cat protection Society, a California nonprofit corporation;
6904 West Coast Highway, Newport Beach, California 92663;
Land Use Modifications: Mixed -Use Vertical
Dear Councilmember Gardner:
I. Background
Our firm represents The National Cat Protection Society, a California nonprofit corporation
(the "Society ").
The Society owns and occupies a commercial building located at 6904 West Coast Highway,
Newport Beach, California 92663 (the "Property ").
Enclosed for your information is a series of pictures of the Property.
The Society has cared for and protected homeless cats at the Property for over eighteen (18) years
without incident, noise, or community disruption of any kind. The Society (and its commercial
operation) has truly been a model citizen.
We believe that until recently the Property was assigned a commercial zone dating back to the
1950's — over 50 years ago.
When the new Zoning Code became effective on November 25, 2010, the old mixed use zone
(including commercial) for the Property (SP -4) was replaced with a new residential zone (R -2, Two -
Unit Residential).
245
LAW OFFICES OF
WATKINS, BLAKELY L&
P. ARNSEN BLAKELY'
TORGERSON LLP
JOSEPH MANCINI
NOEL K. TORGERSON'
PAUL K. WATKINS•
SUITE 810
535 ANTON BOULEVARD
'A PRORESSIONAL CORPORATION
COSTA MESA, CALIFORNIA 92626-7047,
TELEPHONE (', 14) 556 -0800
FACSIMILE (714) 641 -4012
May 3, 2011
BY HAND DELIVERY
Honorable Nancy Gardner
Newport Beach City Council
3300 Newport Boulevard
Newport Beach, California 92663
AUTHOR'S EXTENSION 2108
AUTHOR'S E MAIL AOORESS:
paul@IaMrientl com
h1(p: r; wuv w.l a wf riantl, com
File No. I I -0 I 7-029
RECEIVED BY
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
MAY 0 3 2011
@M OF NEWPORT BEACH
RE: The National Cat protection Society, a California nonprofit corporation;
6904 West Coast Highway, Newport Beach, California 92663;
Land Use Modifications: Mixed -Use Vertical
Dear Councilmember Gardner:
I. Background
Our firm represents The National Cat Protection Society, a California nonprofit corporation
(the "Society ").
The Society owns and occupies a commercial building located at 6904 West Coast Highway,
Newport Beach, California 92663 (the "Property ").
Enclosed for your information is a series of pictures of the Property.
The Society has cared for and protected homeless cats at the Property for over eighteen (18) years
without incident, noise, or community disruption of any kind. The Society (and its commercial
operation) has truly been a model citizen.
We believe that until recently the Property was assigned a commercial zone dating back to the
1950's — over 50 years ago.
When the new Zoning Code became effective on November 25, 2010, the old mixed use zone
(including commercial) for the Property (SP -4) was replaced with a new residential zone (R -2, Two -
Unit Residential).
245
Counciltnember Nancy Gardner
Nexpori Beach City Council
Ma1,3, 2011
Page 2
REeEIV &D RY
PLANNING DEPARIIWENT
MAY ®3 N110
CPYY OF NEWPORT MACH:
It is our understanding that under the General Plan, the zoning for the Property and several others
fronting PCH was changed to an R -2 zone with the thought that when the properties were
redeveloped in the future, the highest and best use would be residential. Then, in light of the
Council's decision to abate all non - conforming uses in 2008, the Property was designated for
abatement. (Please see the enclosed letter dated January 14, 2011 from James Campbell, Acting
Planning Director, Planning Department, City of Newport Beach.) As indicated in the letter, the
Society was instructed to abate the non - residential use of the Property by November 25 of this year, a
short seven months from now.
On January 26, 2011, the Society filed an Application for a General Plan Amendment to restore a
commercial zone for the Property.
On April 7, 2011 and after significant discussion and public testimony, the Planning Commission
unanimously adopted the following Resolution:
"Motion made by Commissioner Toerge and seconded by Commissioner Hawkins, to
adopt a resolution recommending the City Council approve amendments to the Land
Use Element of the General Plan, Coastal Land Use Plan and the Zoning Code to
change the land use designations from Two -Unit Residential to Mixed -Use Vertical
(MY -V) for properties located at 6904, and 6908 -6936 West Coast Highway
(PA2010 -182, and PA2011 -014); and to Commercial General (CG) for the property
located at 6480 West Coast Highway(PA2010 -190) with thefollowing modifications:
Addition of the following Finding to the Resolution: 'The subject property at
6904 West Coast Highway is occupied by a veterinary and animal boarding
care facility which was established by benefit of Use Permit No. 353 in 1957
(Animal Hospital) and its subsequent amendments in 1973 and 1994
(establishing the current National Cat Protection Society use as a cat care
and boarding facility), are legal nonconforming uses and any future changes
are subject to the provisions of the Nonconforming Uses and Structures
Chapter of the City of Newport Beach Municipal Code (currently codified as
Chapter 20.38).'
In addition, the changes amending the Resolution and Exhibits reflecting the
motion made."
As a final item of background information, I am enclosing a letter dated March 17, 2011 from the
Newport Beach Chamber of Commerce supporting the reinstatement of the commercial zone for the
Society's property.
240
Councilmember Arancy Gardner
Netivport Beach City Council
Ala 1) 3, 2011
Page 3
11. What is the Society Requesting?
PLANNIMO DEPARTMENT
MAY 03 2011,
CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH
The Society requests that the Council support the PlanningComtnission's Resolution recommending
the MU -V land use modifications including the Commission's finding as follows:
"The subject property at 6904 West Coast Highway is occupied by a veterinary and
animal boarding care facility which was established by benefit of Use Permit No. 353
in 1957 (Animal Hospital) and its subsequent amendments in 1973 and 1994
(establishing the current National Cat Protection Society use as a cat care and
boarding facility), are legal nonconforming uses and any future changes are subject
to the provisions of the Nonconforming Uses and Structures Chapter of the City of
Newport Beach Municipal Code (currently codified as Chapter 20.38). "
It is important that the Council add the Planning Commission's above finding to the Council's
Resolution due to the fact that (while "Animal Grooming" and "Animal Retail Sales" are
"Permitted" uses under the MU -V Zoning District), "Veterinary Services" are "Not Allowed" in the
MU -V Zoning District and the Society IS performing basic veterinary services on the Property.
[Section 20.22.020, Table 2 -8 Allowed Uses and Permit Requirements for Mixed -Use Zoning
Districts, page 2 -34.)
Finally and as you know, Section 20.22.010A (MU -V (Mixed -Use Vertical) Zoning District)
describes the permitted uses of this zoning classification as follows:
"20.22.010 — Purposes of Mixed -Use Zoning Districts
A. MU -V (.Mixed -Use Vertical) Zoning District. This zoning district is intended to
provide for areas appropriate for the development of mixed -use structures that
vertically integrate residential dwelling units above the ground floorwith retail uses
including office, restaurant, retail, and similar nonresidential uses located on the
ground floor or above."
The Society does not presently use the Property for residential purposes, but the MU -V (Mixed -Use
Vertical) zone modification would appear to offer the Society more flexibility (combining usage for
both commercial and residential purposes) in the use of the Property (including a continuationof the
current commercial use), and the Society therefore supports the Planning Commission Resolution
with the additional finding, and we urge the Council to adopt the Planning Commission's
recommendation to Council.
Thank you for considering the Society's position on this matter.
24:7
Councilmember Nancy Gardner RECENED ny
Newport Beach City Council PLANNING GEPAMWENT
May 3, 1011
Page 4
Ay e
g 2U ,
Sincerely,
Paul K. Watkins for
Watkins, Blakely & Torgerson, LLP
Enclosures
PKW:jbag
cc: Ms. Denise Johnston
Mr. Richard Tanzer
N:\PKW\Clients\Ta er Nad Cat Protection Soc \Ltr to Councilmemben 05031 I doc
CITY OF NEWPORT 6EACH
242
r
NATIONAL
CAT PROTECTION
SOCIETY
6904
1
�7
IIII` III����
.E
a- C" I
� aftm�-- -- -
I
It
a I
AMA -,;
ENTER
i
r
R
i
_
r
ENTER
W
m
0
ro. • . -1 m NO-1 iD �, m o -i o �. o °. N O O � Z O) Z •-
m 7D JO CD m s ° p O� n s � m� m °� m m mom m CITY0
ID a m m Fd�wq E.mac3m Z-°a m30 °' gNO c :° y
CD CD n� m p 3 � m� vm 0� rn °° 3 a`° 0 o � w � ; ro
0.0 C tO (O m 4 3 m�� 7 ri j 0 (DD m 0 m `. d C, �$� yam° N
m m O W 0 Q n 7 0 m 7 N> S, �' O N-a (D pNj A O u 8JY3A �a
CL CD 3 mm m o3D° wo °- O gy - toRo m
3 7 CD m O m N w m q j m N fD V j j .0 _@ m
`Dp m 0 mg fpm =° ammo n�
a 3 '.i cp CD m� fD f� m o° CO C) -- 0 p p CD
CD Cl 0
m �p O. S O S S, N- m A O m° ~ 7 CD W H
% m <� m �' CD -. N� (7 O aD A p
L CD °_ s < m CID 0 a ° °° < m YD' c "-m rnn h wZ y
o �Et w q--0 O (O m 0 j G) CL c W� °of z
to m n '. CD A ° a
m
c No °�?my mm""u' vmcgo -. o n7t
a N D o N c Q r m m x 'a = a 6:3 c y
CL m ro a- (D m o �' y 3 S} b a o Leo (/L��
.3r U m N' ' m x 0 0 CL C ` j m �m C v m Y
N N m O C a m
CD o _ m .» mv, F m
�. a"••` p O m iii m = m S Q
CL 0 a N < Z 7 M 7 p_ m m ® �
oN v° wb 38�� ��� my a�S_ °a rqa c) m
/D O j �` m m N c Q �. O ca . T
b �' m N O� '< .m.. a T U S m m V
'Op W 7 7 .� :n m N CD 3 CD m
m 0
(� O 0 _ Al
CD .0 � a c ��c v (D m?m a w
0 _ s Cr .� ® a s –70 , x cr z � j O C (D N
V~ m c CD ' a= W 3 o� m °� s n
=y' N a CD a C DF O m N y y m 4: m U m Z c>
N _
CD [7 -� -.. 1 .� N
S ? � C mo m„ 7 q ~ m C 3 Iti •�1 _ C7 n CD
m m N 6. SA =8 =ryp 03. v�'C m mp a w 7 fll W �J
7 m S a O C7 7j —1
cr m n o D3'jw
n Z \
0
_ � o
t
/7
O\
02
\(
}§
\�
k§
\\
\
«
0
§
N
(
\/
}
�\
/
:
>I g
�
■
a s $
\�
A �
�
\r
\� CD
kCP
Ai
&
§
t
_
�
M \
» q
g
�
co
�
§
-00r
k %� §(k
_r- % %a
7 §EQ2
� CL Mr
=r ƒEE0
ƒEEik
'13 -0
g,��
/gf /kk
, & Z)
CD =r
A.39* 08
so =r
% /AEI g
CD to
a7�,�K
/cr IM
go
aJ2222
}L k
e /ks &
¥
(
/
Emma
6904 Cd9St Hwy W
Zoning Districts
R-1 . Swgk -Uuk R O.nlW
-- R4 -T60LK RautleimM
- RM - Re &tlerdiai MulUpleUnq
CC - Com axial Corridor
_ CG- Camieaeial General
- CN - CumnmMial P.Meational N
CN - NelehbW wod Cmmadel
_ CV - t•Onlllerdal VuirSm, Mg
f .Mbmd the
...... Os - Opal Spam
PC - Flamed CanenulUly
r PF - PUblk Fadlilie
- F - Public ImUtutlom
PR - Perks 8M Re .4m,
1 Owl
1 �
• o
1+
H
tl
N
0
Y
Y
d
Y
YN
M
tl
,O
�o
N
0
J
J
H
r••1
0
r
H
I 79
O rR
0 9
m
v
a
0
0
0
100
VMS
NEWPORT BEACH
CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
Building on a Century of Service
March 17, 2011
Earl McDaniel, Chair
Planning Commission
City of Newport Beach
3300 Newport Boulevard
Newport Beach, California 92663
RECEIVED BY
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
MAY 0 3 2011
CRY OF NEWPORT BEACH
RE: The National Cat Protection Society, a California nonprofit corporation;
6904 West Pack Coast Highway, Newport Beach, California 92663
Dear Chairman McDaniel:
The Newport Beach Chamber of Commerce ( "NBCC ") is an association which
represents over 700 business owners and operators in Newport Beach.
The National Cat Protection Society (the "Society") has been caring for and protecting
homeless cats at 6904 West Pacific Coast Highway (the "Property") for over 18 years.
When the new Zoning Code became effective on November 25, 2010, the old
commercial zoning (SP-4) was replaced with new residential zoning (R -2, Two -Unit
Residential).
It is my understanding that under the General Plan, the Society's Property and several
others along PCH were changed to R -2 with the thought that when the properties were
redeveloped in the future, the highest and best use would be residential. Then, in light
of the Council's decision in 2008 to abate all non - conforming uses, the Society's
Property became a target for abatement.
The Society (and its commercial operation) has been a model citizen in West Newport
Beach since 1993. It has c ?red for and and protected homeless.cats without incident,
noise, or community disruption of any kind.
We believe that the Societys proposed General Plan Amendment to revise the zoning
from R -2 (Two -Unit Residential) to CG (General Commercial) (which would reinstate the
commercial zone in place for at least the past 38 years) is well taken.
The Newport Beach Chamber of Commerce supports this General Plan Amendment
for the Society's Property.
Sincerely,
Richard R, Luehrs,
President
1470 IAMsoikn ROAD, NEWPORT BEACH, CALIFORNU 92660 • PH: (949) 729 -4400 • FAx: (949) 729 -4417 • Wm www.NFw?0115rfM